Thanks Keith for a excellent series ,I watched all 22 of them ,I can fully understand what you have achieved here they are the basis for a good loco, with some modifications and tweaking you can polish the brass as they say ,I have just purchased a Kingscale 61xx and I have similar work to to to that thanks again , All the best Graham
G'day Keith I will state the obvious ......its bloody terrific and all the work you put in really paid off! It's Chinese but when you consider that the Chinese were building and maintaining those huge QJ's it's no wonder! John
@@keithappleton OK... but what they [should have] learned from your series is the difference between "sort of OK" and "exceptional" ! ! Further, it [your approach] can be applied to any product to make it exceptional. Oh well... Maybe it's just as well if they are asleep at the wheel.
Sad to see this series come to a close, but Im CHUFFED that the loco runs so sweetly. Cant wait to see you nipping round a railway with it! I hope one day to own my own miniature steam locomotive (when I can afford one that is XD) So these videos are a god send, and also as a trainee fireman I find the steam up video most useful as I learn the ropes. Cheers Keith!! -Nathan
Thankyou Keith, for a very informative series of videos and I look forward to obtaining all the necessary parts from Blackgate Engineering and put time aside to modify my own 14xx to a standard likely not as good as yours but hopefully a lot better than it is right now. Maybe you could ask blackgates to make a package of the necessary parts you used to make ordering easier. Kind Regards Peter Australia
Thank You Keith for a great series. She is a beautiful engine. It was enjoyable to watch you test and talk about and carryout the modifications. By The Way, how is the heat over there?
Keith, you would be more then welcome to run your engine at the model engineers track here in Southampton, when you are next down in the south. On the first Saturday of each month. Thanks
That's very kind, thank you. I occasionally visit a friend of mine who lives in Portsmouth, so it is a possibility I could call in ..... camera in hand }:-)))
I notice you are using CMD Rolling roads :) What are these 14xx's like to oil up since everything is between the frames? Are they are good starter engine?
The 14xx is easy enough to lubricate with an extension pipe on the oil can. Please watch the entire series and judge for yourself whether or not you should buy one . . . . .
Fascinating Keth Im not a fan of the GWR ( LNER Man her) but I have to say Ive always found the 14XX class interesting. This one seems to be very free steaming I await the Vido of it running under load with anticipation
Me neither, I like GNR and LMS engines best. But ever since I saw the 14XX loco that was featured in the old film "The Titfield Thunderbolt" I like this particular class of GWR engine {:-)))
I think I tend to lean a bit toward LNWR, but really I like engines from most the railways. Along with the 14XX, another one of my favourites from the GWR is the broad gauge Rover class single. With the green and red Victorian livery they look quite nice indeed.
When I see your and other steam locomotive I've get a song on my mind called.. the train from bloemfontein.. beautiful locomotive to.. and is it a 0-4-2 locomotive??
Hang on. Previously you said your track was 7 1/2". Unless you've added a third rail to give you a dual gauge railway, how are you going to run it? Ps. In my yoof I used to lay full size railways for all the local steel works plus some for British Rail, NCB and some quarries.
Bonjour Keith, You say it is a great locomotive but you rebuilt it almost completely...This is not exactly what I would have said. Even if the original price is low, a final user should take care the work done by a specualist, and the work of a specialist has a significant and justified cost. Never mind, this is your work and it is perfect, as usual would I say. And I am impressed to see you mini injectors work at almost 100 PSI (> 6 bars). Amicalement, Raphaël
Your summary of the engine echoes my thoughts on a lot of Chinese products. Often very good machining, but somehow they seem to loose interest when it comes to assembly and finish. I have a Chinese milling machine, same problems, now I have fixed them its a great machine. I suppose it is the final assembly and careful felting that takes time and costs money. For the price you get a lot of metal.
It's almost as if the manufacturers did not realize that people who buy replica steam engines actually wanted to steam them! I bet the people back in China, if they watched this series, will change their minds.
I wonder if that Chinese mamufactor has watched this and realise they need to fix there production line to avoid all the issues and include the modifications that you have done.
I'm hoping that their great engineering starts to be reflective in the build quality. I assume they're a new manufacturer who're just having a bit of a shaky start is all. Though I hope the reason Blackgates had it was for some advice from a third party to correct some of the issues, and that they'll get something out of these videos too.
Thanks Keith for a excellent series ,I watched all 22 of them ,I can fully understand what you have achieved here they are the basis for a good loco, with some modifications and tweaking you can polish the brass as they say ,I have just purchased a Kingscale 61xx and I have similar work to to to that thanks again , All the best Graham
Beautiful little jewel. Running so smooth. I hope the manufacturer is taking notes.
Reaching the end of your work on this engine is a bit like finishing the last book in a good trilogy. Well done !
It sounds so plucky and merry under steam. I really can't wait to see it on a track. Thanks for showing us this test, Keith!
What a wonderful job you have done on the loco I’m very Im very impressed thanks tim
Many thanks!
It's always sad to see a series come to an end but I'm looking forward to what you start next !
She turned out quite a sweet engine, nice work Keith!
Almost sad to see this one end Keith.
*quick, someone get him a basket case locomotive to start on ;) *
Such an absolutely gorgeous little engine! Runs beautifully, thanks to your careful craftsmanship and tinkering of course.
Gorgeous little locomotive. Runs like a Swiss watch.
G'day Keith I will state the obvious ......its bloody terrific and all the work you put in really paid off! It's Chinese but when you consider that the Chinese were building and maintaining those huge QJ's it's no wonder! John
Woohoo runs like a beauty!! Well done Squire!!
Another beautiful model, well done
Just want to say what an excellent job youve done on this loco
Did the manufacturer ever thank you? This series is priceless to them ! ! !
No, not a word ...... but I did buy it from the manufacturer at a discounted price }:-)))
@@keithappleton OK... but what they [should have] learned from your series is the difference between "sort of OK" and "exceptional" ! ! Further, it [your approach] can be applied to any product to make it exceptional. Oh well... Maybe it's just as well if they are asleep at the wheel.
That really is a good looking engine Keith. Congratulations. Money in the bank so to speak.
Thanks for the video Keith, Nice looking engine.
This is an excellent series Keith, thank you very much.
an excellent work of craft . . . better than a work of art!
Smooth runner. Can't wait to see it on the tracks.
Very nice engine now, Keith. It's been an interesting series. Looking foreward to seeing her on the track. :)
Thank you Keith another good series.
Sad to see this series come to a close, but Im CHUFFED that the loco runs so sweetly. Cant wait to see you nipping round a railway with it! I hope one day to own my own miniature steam locomotive (when I can afford one that is XD) So these videos are a god send, and also as a trainee fireman I find the steam up video most useful as I learn the ropes. Cheers Keith!!
-Nathan
the color looks a lot better now that it's outside, it's not as dark as the real one but it's still a lovely green
Thankyou Keith, for a very informative series of videos and I look forward to obtaining all the necessary parts from Blackgate Engineering and put time aside to modify my own 14xx to a standard likely not as good as yours but hopefully a lot better than it is right now. Maybe you could ask blackgates to make a package of the necessary parts you used to make ordering easier. Kind Regards Peter Australia
Glad you found the series useful - I already sent a list of the parts that I used to Blackgates Engineering ......
Grand!
Thank You Keith for a great series. She is a beautiful engine. It was enjoyable to watch you test and talk about and carryout the modifications. By The Way, how is the heat over there?
The heat is pleasant - it makes a change from wet & miserable }:-)))
Keith, you would be more then welcome to run your engine at the model engineers track here in Southampton, when you are next down in the south. On the first Saturday of each month. Thanks
That's very kind, thank you. I occasionally visit a friend of mine who lives in Portsmouth, so it is a possibility I could call in ..... camera in hand }:-)))
Well done, What are the common Gauge's of track in UK? I just checked one of our local tracks and they are 3 ½”, 4 ¾” and 7 ¼” tracks.
3 1/2, 5 and 7 1/4 inch gauges in the UK usually . . .
I notice you are using CMD Rolling roads :) What are these 14xx's like to oil up since everything is between the frames? Are they are good starter engine?
The 14xx is easy enough to lubricate with an extension pipe on the oil can. Please watch the entire series and judge for yourself whether or not you should buy one . . . . .
Fascinating Keth Im not a fan of the GWR ( LNER Man her) but I have to say Ive always found the 14XX class interesting. This one seems to be very free steaming I await the Vido of it running under load with anticipation
Me neither, I like GNR and LMS engines best. But ever since I saw the 14XX loco that was featured in the old film "The Titfield Thunderbolt" I like this particular class of GWR engine {:-)))
I think I tend to lean a bit toward LNWR, but really I like engines from most the railways. Along with the 14XX, another one of my favourites from the GWR is the broad gauge Rover class single.
With the green and red Victorian livery they look quite nice indeed.
When I see your and other steam locomotive I've get a song on my mind called.. the train from bloemfontein.. beautiful locomotive to.. and is it a 0-4-2 locomotive??
Keith, do you know what spring rates you have on your 14XX ?
No Idea, I used the ones that it was originally fitted with on the Driving wheels and used a pair from Blackgates Engineering on the trailing wheels.
Is it possible to use compressed air or steam through the blower instead of a fan to draw the fire.
yes ....
Is there going to be a video of you running it?
did you not watch the part of this video where I mention it ???
At least it runs smoothly without oscillation.
Hang on. Previously you said your track was 7 1/2". Unless you've added a third rail to give you a dual gauge railway, how are you going to run it?
Ps. In my yoof I used to lay full size railways for all the local steel works plus some for British Rail, NCB and some quarries.
But will it reach 88 miles per hour? (/Back to the Future III) :P
What sort of price range do these Chinese built locos cost?
Please look on Google.
Bonjour Keith,
You say it is a great locomotive but you rebuilt it almost completely...This is not exactly what I would have said. Even if the original price is low, a final user should take care the work done by a specualist, and the work of a specialist has a significant and justified cost. Never mind, this is your work and it is perfect, as usual would I say. And I am impressed to see you mini injectors work at almost 100 PSI (> 6 bars).
Amicalement, Raphaël
Your summary of the engine echoes my thoughts on a lot of Chinese products. Often very good machining, but somehow they seem to loose interest when it comes to assembly and finish. I have a Chinese milling machine, same problems, now I have fixed them its a great machine. I suppose it is the final assembly and careful felting that takes time and costs money. For the price you get a lot of metal.
It's almost as if the manufacturers did not realize that people who buy replica steam engines actually wanted to steam them! I bet the people back in China, if they watched this series, will change their minds.
Now all you shaken all the bugs out of this 14xx she runs better then a swiss made watch
Is oliver
I wonder if that Chinese mamufactor has watched this and realise they need to fix there production line to avoid all the issues and include the modifications that you have done.
I'm hoping that their great engineering starts to be reflective in the build quality. I assume they're a new manufacturer who're just having a bit of a shaky start is all. Though I hope the reason Blackgates had it was for some advice from a third party to correct some of the issues, and that they'll get something out of these videos too.
They are not a new manufacturer - far from it , they just couldn't figure out how to make an injector work . . .
Fancy selling it?
not at the moment }:-)))
Don’t blame you! How much is it worth second hand roughly?