Is the number omega a mathematical oracle?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 8 сен 2024

Комментарии • 238

  • @AllAnglesMath
    @AllAnglesMath  Месяц назад +3

    Hi everyone,
    I'm here to express my extreme gratitude for the amazing comments. We're clearly blessed with a cool and wholesome community. You all rock!
    I can tell you that my dad was extremely moved by all of your wishes. He asked me to convey this message, straight from him to all of you:
    "
    I want to thank you all for the many birthday wishes. It is an exceptional and unexpected gift.
    Also, my heart warms up when I see your appreciation for the work of my son.
    I would like to complement his motto 'keep learning' with mine: 'keep teaching'.
    Knowledge has this peculiar property that the more of it you give away, the more of it you have left.
    Have a goof life.
    "

  • @kyay10
    @kyay10 Месяц назад +43

    BTW, we won't be able to solve *all* maths problems with Omega because Omega has no information about programs that have access to omega. This is the hierarchy of hyper computation or something like that, and it's really neat. But yes realistically all problems we care about are problems about programs that don't have access to omega

    • @ianweckhorst3200
      @ianweckhorst3200 Месяц назад +2

      Well that is why omega is uncomputable, if it could be computed, we’d have that problem, we also actually know it’s irrational, because if it was rational it would be computable

    • @ahoj7720
      @ahoj7720 23 дня назад

      @@ianweckhorst3200It’s even transcendental, as all algebraic numbers are computable.

  • @omrishavit8843
    @omrishavit8843 Месяц назад +25

    Happy birthday to your Dad from Boston! 75 is a big one, congratulations!

  • @JimFarrand
    @JimFarrand Месяц назад +7

    Happy Birthday, All Angles's Dad!
    I too am a software engineer. I have an 18 month old little boy. I think there are many, ways in which I could succeed as a parent, but if in two decades time, my boy is making RUclips videos (or whatever has replaced them) which challenge me to think and learn in the same way that your boy has done for me today, I will feel super proud of what he has achieved. And if he traces any part of his love of learning and his willingness to challenge himself back to me, then I in turn will trace it back to videos like this one that have helped and inspired me. Thank you so much for helping to create a world filled with the passion and curiosity

    • @AllAnglesMath
      @AllAnglesMath  Месяц назад +1

      Thank you so much for that uplifting comment. Let's keep spreading knowledge!

  • @logician1234
    @logician1234 Месяц назад +40

    Doesn't omega depend on the system being used? So it's not really a constant like pi, unless you specify the system you are working in (some specific lambda calculus, for example)

    • @AllAnglesMath
      @AllAnglesMath  Месяц назад +31

      You're right, the exact value will depend heavily on all the choices we make along the way. I didn't want to get bogged down in the details, so I skipped over it. But well spotted.

    • @Atrix256
      @Atrix256 Месяц назад +1

      I was wondering about this, neat to hear.
      It'd be fun to try and calculate a few trivial bits of omega :)

  • @clementdato6328
    @clementdato6328 Месяц назад +43

    Happy cake day for you dad 🎉

  • @danv8718
    @danv8718 Месяц назад +19

    Happy anniversary from Spain, and thank you for inspiring your son!! We absolutely love his incredible videos.

    • @AllAnglesMath
      @AllAnglesMath  Месяц назад +3

      Muchas gracias!

    • @CesarCI-uy6tp
      @CesarCI-uy6tp Месяц назад +2

      Creía totalmente que sería el único español aquí. Me alegra saber que no.

  • @rainytreecat3992
    @rainytreecat3992 Месяц назад +3

    I think that to compute the number to a certain accuracy would require you to know the answers to all the problems it could solve, so it's less of an oracle and more of a compression algorithm. And an optimal one too, since it's not compressible further!

  • @scalex1882
    @scalex1882 Месяц назад +3

    Thank you sir for making my day! This video was absolutely incredible. Happy birthday to your Dad from Düsseldorf, Germany!

  • @palfers1
    @palfers1 Месяц назад +3

    I just turned 75 too, and I'm also a Dad, so happy birthday to both us Dads!
    I found an interesting pattern for the composites of Euler's quadratic. Perhaps you can find it too.

    • @AllAnglesMath
      @AllAnglesMath  Месяц назад

      Congratulations on your recent birthday!

  • @irisvandamme3671
    @irisvandamme3671 Месяц назад +6

    Fijne verjaardag vake! (Best wishes from Belgium)

  • @DidierSampaolo
    @DidierSampaolo Месяц назад +2

    Happy birthday from Marseilles, France, from a fellow software engineer. :))

  • @willclayton5922
    @willclayton5922 Месяц назад +2

    The halting problem is decidable for finite deterministic systems, so it's theoretically possible to calculate omega for some systems. Unfortunately, any problem worth solving with omega would require massive amounts of computational power

  • @carloselfrancos7205
    @carloselfrancos7205 Месяц назад +3

    Happy birthday from France!

  • @isabellawinslow5803
    @isabellawinslow5803 Месяц назад +1

    Happy 75th birthday from the Blue ridge Mountains of North Carolina! May it and the days that follow be wonderful 💕

  • @orpheus2883
    @orpheus2883 Месяц назад +3

    Happiness and many more years of life for your dad!
    From Brazil!

  • @pseudolullus
    @pseudolullus Месяц назад +9

    HBD to your dad from Korea!

  • @aaronspeedy7780
    @aaronspeedy7780 Месяц назад +2

    Happy birthday to your dad from Texas! Congratulations on the big 75!

  • @8-P
    @8-P Месяц назад +3

    This was one of the best videos i have watched in the couple of weeks on RUclips, thank you!

  • @dinhero21
    @dinhero21 Месяц назад +3

    Happy 75th birthday! Thank you for having such a great son! From Brazil!

  • @kro_me
    @kro_me Месяц назад +2

    Happy birthday to your dad!!

  • @lordeji655
    @lordeji655 Месяц назад +1

    Happy birthday from France !! Take care of yourself, hoping everything's going great !

  • @caddr
    @caddr Месяц назад +3

    Happy Birthday from Indonesia

  • @pedrohcf891
    @pedrohcf891 Месяц назад +2

    Happy Birthday to your dad from Brazil!

  • @ShawSumma
    @ShawSumma Месяц назад +3

    Happy birthday mr. Dad, from central Michigan.

  • @user-dk3gv5tm3v
    @user-dk3gv5tm3v Месяц назад +2

    Happy Birthday to your dad from India 🎊
    Today is my mom's birthday too

    • @AllAnglesMath
      @AllAnglesMath  Месяц назад +2

      Thank you, and happy birthday to your mother. Wish her all the best from us!

    • @user-dk3gv5tm3v
      @user-dk3gv5tm3v Месяц назад

      @@AllAnglesMath ❤️

  • @AnshKrishnia
    @AnshKrishnia Месяц назад +2

    Happy birthday to your dad from india🎉

  • @trixelpixel5196
    @trixelpixel5196 Месяц назад +2

    Happy Birthday from Columbus, Ohio, USA! ❤

  • @dansheppard2965
    @dansheppard2965 Месяц назад +3

    Oh Ω, not ω. That's not so surprising, but I'll watch anyway, 😀. Chaitin's work is always worth revisiting!

  • @tophat593
    @tophat593 Месяц назад +2

    Oh, it's my dad's birthday today as well. I think he's 76, I always forget whether it's my mum or dad was born in 48 or 49.
    What a nice coincidence. :) Happy b'day to both our dads.

    • @AllAnglesMath
      @AllAnglesMath  Месяц назад

      Our best wishes to your dad as well!

    • @tophat593
      @tophat593 Месяц назад

      @@AllAnglesMath He was 75 as well. :) Had a big bbq with the grandkids in the evening. Was really good!

  • @quakquak6141
    @quakquak6141 Месяц назад +2

    Happy birthday to your dad from Italy!

  • @xenophobe3691
    @xenophobe3691 Месяц назад +2

    Happy Birthday from South Florida!

  • @amr3162
    @amr3162 Месяц назад +2

    Happy birthday from Egypt 🎉

  • @shardator
    @shardator Месяц назад +2

    Happy birthday to your dad! Mine will be 75 next week!

    • @AllAnglesMath
      @AllAnglesMath  Месяц назад +2

      Thanks, and send your dad our best wishes in turn!

  • @RosimInc7
    @RosimInc7 Месяц назад +1

    Happy birthday to your Dad from Quebec, Canada!

  • @BrianOxleyTexan
    @BrianOxleyTexan Месяц назад +2

    Happy birthday from Houston, TX!

  • @luckythelucklesswolf1419
    @luckythelucklesswolf1419 Месяц назад +2

    happy birthday from Canada!

  • @baruchben-david4196
    @baruchben-david4196 Месяц назад +2

    Happy Birthday from Chicago...

  • @cemacmillan
    @cemacmillan Месяц назад +2

    Belated happy birthday to your Dad from France. Good work getting your (now grown) child interested enough in these topics that now they are making videos for the engineers like me who didn't get to learn the spicy bits of the math.

  • @jacoblister
    @jacoblister Месяц назад +3

    Happy birthday from New Zealand

  • @TheTriggor
    @TheTriggor Месяц назад +1

    Happy birthday to your dad from Poland!
    By the way, I believe even if we knew the value of omega, running all possible programs at once could be tricky - at a trillion in, we would still be looking at programs that print random constants

    • @AllAnglesMath
      @AllAnglesMath  Месяц назад

      You're right, the entire idea of omega is mostly theoretical, not very practical.

  • @lexinwonderland5741
    @lexinwonderland5741 Месяц назад +2

    HAPPY BIRTHDAY, MR. ANGLES! from Atlanta, USA

    • @AllAnglesMath
      @AllAnglesMath  Месяц назад

      Thanks! Would be weird if that were really our last name. Like the Paul Simon song: You can call me All 😉

  • @igorstaszkiewicz1226
    @igorstaszkiewicz1226 Месяц назад +4

    Happy (3 * 5^2)-th birthday to your Dad from Poland!🎉

    • @AllAnglesMath
      @AllAnglesMath  Месяц назад

      Yup, that seems to work out to 75. Thanks!

  • @DeclanMBrennan
    @DeclanMBrennan Месяц назад +3

    A big happy birthday to your Dad from another software engineer in the beautiful Wicklow hills of Ireland.

  • @qazw5414
    @qazw5414 Месяц назад +2

    happy birthday for your dad from Turkey 🎉

  • @marekglowacki2607
    @marekglowacki2607 Месяц назад +4

    Best wishes from Poland - Cracow !

  • @David-lp3qy
    @David-lp3qy Месяц назад +2

    Happy birthday padre! Blessings from Colorado!

  • @Yuurei-Ressha9216
    @Yuurei-Ressha9216 Месяц назад +2

    Happy Birthday to your Dad from the panhandle of Florida

    • @aaronspeedy7780
      @aaronspeedy7780 Месяц назад +2

      Woah we are very close. I'm from the panhandle of Texas. Happy birthday to you, All Angle's dad!

    • @AllAnglesMath
      @AllAnglesMath  Месяц назад +2

      My country has no panhandle, but we do have some funky bits flying off in the north.

  • @Iophiel
    @Iophiel Месяц назад +1

    Hey! This is also my mother's birthday

  • @michaellatsky
    @michaellatsky Месяц назад +4

    Happy birthday from South Africa!❤ 2:15

  • @user-lz1yb6qk3f
    @user-lz1yb6qk3f Месяц назад +4

    Happy birthday from Russia🎉
    About hauling problem - had anyone proved that it's the same number for any Turing-complete language? Cuz if it's not true, we could state the opposite problem - choose number between 0 and 1. For said number construct a programming language in a way that it's hauling constant would be this arbitrary number.

  • @Nihil2407
    @Nihil2407 Месяц назад +2

    Happy birthday from Berlin!

  • @maxtrax3258
    @maxtrax3258 Месяц назад +2

    I like the Idee of omega. Happy birthday from Switzerland to your father.

    • @AllAnglesMath
      @AllAnglesMath  Месяц назад

      Thank you! Switzerland is one of our favorite hiking countries.

  • @aintgonnatakeit
    @aintgonnatakeit Месяц назад +2

    happy bday from the southern USA! great video!

  • @Joe-Joe-Circus
    @Joe-Joe-Circus Месяц назад +1

    A key step in our journey to figuring out if a program halts or not is using omega-n, where n is the "length" of our program and then used to take the first n digits of omega.
    A few questions I've been thinking about as a result of this and my thoughts (feel free to chime in):
    Questions -
    Is it possible that omega has less than n digits? I.e. does omega have infinitely many digits?
    Does a random number have to have infinitely many digits?
    Why is omega "random"?
    Thoughts -
    From the video, a key point is that a number is random if (and only if?) it is incompressible. Thus, if a number is not random, we could write a program to write out its digits. If it is random, we could not do that. So, if a number has finitely many digits, we should be able to write a program with finitely many steps to write out the digits of that number. So a random number must have infinitely many digits.
    Secondly, Turing proved through the halting problem that we can't have a program determine whether all programs will halt or not. Thus, we can't compress the probability that a random program halts, and so omega must be random.
    Since omega is random, it must have infinitely many digits, meaning we could always take the first n digits for arbitrary n.
    I'm little shaky on that second jump. Let me know if I'm missing something or can think about it in a different way.
    Great video and happy birthday to dad!

  • @kingofnumbers7660
    @kingofnumbers7660 Месяц назад +2

    Happy birthday to your dad!

  • @ivanjorromedina4010
    @ivanjorromedina4010 Месяц назад +1

    Happy birthday to your dad from the east of Spain!

  • @marcocorico1
    @marcocorico1 Месяц назад +3

    Hi, nice explanation video !
    I'm currently working on a video on the exact same subject and I have some remarks, especially on the part "how the oracle works":
    The Omega that you describe in your video is not defined on a prefix computing model which mean that it is possible that your Omega can be greater than 1 for example if the 2 programs of length 1 (the ones encoded by 0 and 1) both halts they will both add a wheight of 0.5 which will make the total already equals to 1. And by your defenition that would mean that even if there are only thoses two programs which halts the probability of any programs to halts will be 1 (Omegas can be seen as a probability but not in a direct way) .
    At 17:48 you said that you work only on the shorts programs which means that you can only compute a lower bound of that omega because there are programs on size greater than n that can have an impact of the first bits. To do so you have to not work only on the programs of size n but all programs of your computing model. Since there is an infinity of programs you can't do the trick of "I do one step of each programs and I start again" because that would mean that you can only performs at most one step of each program, to get over this you can use what we call a "Dovetailling" which works like the bijection between N and N^2.
    I know i am being really pedantic about theses little details but as I said, this is a nice explanation video that probably make the whole concept understandable for a person that don't know about it already and all of thoses details can take a while to explain and might hurt your audience retention so keep it that way 😄

    • @AllAnglesMath
      @AllAnglesMath  Месяц назад

      Thanks for the interesting feedback. As soon as your video is ready, feel free to post a link here. Looking forward to learning more!

  • @diribigal
    @diribigal Месяц назад +2

    Happy birthday from Baltimore!

  • @amarasa2567
    @amarasa2567 Месяц назад +1

    Happy birthday to your dad from France :)

  • @willbradley1734
    @willbradley1734 Месяц назад +2

    happy birthday to your dad from minnesota 🎉

  • @benrogers5416
    @benrogers5416 Месяц назад +1

    Happy Birthday to your Dad from Tennessee

  • @taylormanning2709
    @taylormanning2709 Месяц назад +3

    Happy birthday to a lucky father, from the Sonoran Desert

  • @rylieweaver1516
    @rylieweaver1516 Месяц назад +2

    Best wishes to your dad from Tennessee! (And California)

  • @cartatowegs5080
    @cartatowegs5080 Месяц назад +1

    Happy birthday from Duluth Minnesota!

  • @garrettbates2639
    @garrettbates2639 Месяц назад +1

    Happy Birthday from New Mexico.

  • @twixerclawford
    @twixerclawford Месяц назад +1

    Just to clarify: the reason why we can't know omega is not because you can't write it down, but rather that it is impossible to *prove* that that number is indeed omega. Similar to how it's impossible to prove the continuum hypothesis, or gödel's incompleteness theorem

    • @sataincsushipower
      @sataincsushipower Месяц назад

      No - if we could write it down (compute it with finite means) then there would be a halting function. We might not be able to prove that it is actually the halting function, but it would work all the same.
      Since the existence of the halting function leads to contradicition this number cannot be computed.

    • @oliverray58
      @oliverray58 Месяц назад

      @@sataincsushipowerCOUNT THE CONTRADICTION AS A HALF. THE CONTRADICTORY ONE IS ONLY ONE PROGRAM OUT OF QUADRILLIONS AND QUADRILLIONS SO IT WON'T AFFECT THE ESTIMATE FOR OMEGA BY THAT MUCH IF YOU DON'T COUNT IT. I AM EXCITED TO SEE IF YOU MATH NERDS CRACK IT ONE DAY!

  • @pureatheistic
    @pureatheistic Месяц назад +2

    If you Like this video and topic, you should DEFINETLY go and buy yourself a copy of Gregory Chaitin's book - "Meta Math".
    It is an amazing book for math and computer nerds in general, but covers the story behind the exploration of Omega coming straight from the man himself, and gives insight into his thought process on discovery and knowledge.

  • @IncaTrails
    @IncaTrails 25 дней назад +1

    Happy birthday to you dad - he must be very proud of you!

  • @worndoubloon1175
    @worndoubloon1175 Месяц назад +1

    Happy birthday to your dad from Oregon!

  • @d4v0r_x
    @d4v0r_x Месяц назад +1

    happy birthday dad, from koper, slovenia

  • @asappia
    @asappia Месяц назад +2

    Happy B birthday from Antibes in France

    • @AllAnglesMath
      @AllAnglesMath  Месяц назад

      I have fond memories of walking along the Cap d'Antibes. Thanks for the wishes!

  • @MarcDonis
    @MarcDonis Месяц назад +2

    happy 75th from Luxembourg! 🎉

  • @vkessel
    @vkessel Месяц назад +1

    Happy birthday from Canada!

  • @rubenvanderark4960
    @rubenvanderark4960 Месяц назад +2

    Happy birthday!

  • @fdipanfilo5445
    @fdipanfilo5445 Месяц назад +2

    happy birthday from Cochrane Canada

  • @jonathandawson3091
    @jonathandawson3091 Месяц назад +2

    This is all theoretical though.
    Because between at the boundary of halting programs, there lie the busy beavers. I.e. program of length n that runs the largest possible number of steps before halting.
    The number of steps a busy beaver runs before stopping, BB(n), is finite but absolutely insanely humongous - because in some way, it is the largest numbers that you can ever describe if you were the cleverest person.
    So even if you knew Omega, you would need to wait an almost indescribably long time before the scale tips over, way, way, unimaginably larger than age of the universe or anything we can describe easily.

    • @AllAnglesMath
      @AllAnglesMath  Месяц назад

      Agreed. Omega is purely theoretical in many ways, but still fun to think about.

  • @lygaret
    @lygaret Месяц назад +2

    HB from Boulder, CO, USA! coder dads are important!

  • @petterlarsson7257
    @petterlarsson7257 Месяц назад +2

    happy birthday from sweden

  • @Sawatzel
    @Sawatzel Месяц назад +1

    Happy birthday from Germany ❤

  • @Ataristic
    @Ataristic Месяц назад +2

    Happy birthday from Finland, Angle Dad

  • @waso_laso_sewi
    @waso_laso_sewi Месяц назад +4

    HB to your dad from France ;)

  • @MeshremMath
    @MeshremMath Месяц назад +2

    Happy birthday from the Americas

  • @Ctrl-Z-Renders
    @Ctrl-Z-Renders Месяц назад +2

    Happy b-day from belgium!

  • @jonathanlister5644
    @jonathanlister5644 Месяц назад +1

    Happy birthday to your Dad from Dunoon, Scotland. I will have a wee dram to toast you!

  • @Zantorc
    @Zantorc Месяц назад +1

    Happy birthday from London and a 68 year old retired software engineer.

  • @denisballakh1326
    @denisballakh1326 Месяц назад +2

    Happy birthday from Russia!

  • @lunafoxfire
    @lunafoxfire Месяц назад +2

    Happy birthday from USA!

  • @user-cr3dn9vt6h
    @user-cr3dn9vt6h Месяц назад +1

    Happy birthday from Ukraine. I'm software engineer as well, love math

  • @daxplatiro1668
    @daxplatiro1668 Месяц назад +1

    Happy Birthday from Hawaii!!🥳🥳🥳

  • @NatAttack99
    @NatAttack99 Месяц назад +1

    Happy birthday to your dad from canada :D

  • @jonathandawson3091
    @jonathandawson3091 Месяц назад +5

    There is a better and simpler number than Omega that has the same properties described here in this video.
    1. List all programs. Not just n bits, btw, list all of them.
    2. Construct a binary number whose kth digit is 0 if the kth program in your list halts, otherwise 1.
    It has the same properties as Omega (i.e. it exists, not compressible, not knowable etc.), and you don't need to go through hoops to prove that it solves all the open questions.

    • @AllAnglesMath
      @AllAnglesMath  Месяц назад +1

      Nice one. But if I understand it correctly, your number wouldn't be totally random. Since most programs halt, you could easily win money by betting that each bit is a 0. The weird property of Omega is that it's definable-but-random.

    • @pUQahplA
      @pUQahplA Месяц назад

      @@AllAnglesMath Change the construction slightly then.
      1. write a list of all halting programs in lexicographical order (list H) and do the same for all non-halting programs (list NH)
      2. begin your decimal expansion of the constant starting at "0."
      3. randomly choose between the 2 lists
      4. if you chose list H, concatenate 1 to your number, otherwise concatenate 0.
      You can then map each bit in the number:
      1. note the value of b_n
      2. counting the number of b_n' (0 < n' < n) that match b_n (call this i_n)
      3. then b_n is mapped to the i_n'th entry list H if b_n is 1, otherwise it's mapped to the i_n'th entry of list NH
      This results in a number with the same properties as OP described (trivially tells you whether a program halts or not), but with added randomness.
      Also since there are a countably infinite number of both halting and non-halting programs, saying "most programs halt" is incorrect. You can easily take any haling program and make it non-halting by adding a no-op infinite loop at the start of the program. Since there are a countable infinity of both, you can say (in some sense) that there are the same number of both types since you can always pair a program of one class to a program of the other class.

  • @letscodeitup
    @letscodeitup Месяц назад +1

    Happy Birthday to your dad!

  • @krystofsedlacek
    @krystofsedlacek Месяц назад +1

    Great video, very well explained; the topic choice is perfect and carries a nice philosophical thought at the end, "I compress; therefore, I understand." is my favorite line. Btw I think there is a mistake at 10:36 since a perfect number equals HALF the sum of its divisors, not twice (actually, quite a bummer that it's not twice the sum, as that would make the problem of proving that an odd one doesn't exist pretty easy lol). Also, happy birthday to your dad. Maybe he can wish for the first 2^75 digits of omega as he blows out the candles on the birthday cake.

    • @AllAnglesMath
      @AllAnglesMath  Месяц назад

      You're absolutely right about the perfect numbers. My mistake.

  • @sataincsushipower
    @sataincsushipower Месяц назад +1

    Good video!
    I'm seeing quite a few people questioning the reasoning and results of the last section of the video.
    While I'm certainly no expert I wanted to give some notes on where this video is skipping over details (some I think are a bit crucial). This isn't to discredit the video! I understand that some simplifications must occur so the video is accessible:
    1. If we actually allow all binary sequences to define a program and add 1/2^k whenever that program halts, notice that this number can be as large as n, when considering just the sequences of length n.
    This number therefore isn't a probability. I would urge watchers to think about how you might actually describe the probability over an infinite sequence of options. The answer is to define a measure, which is where the 1/2^k thing comes from.
    2. The only reason the 1/2^k thing works is because the constant is defined with respect to a *prefix-free*, *universal* turing machine. You might think of this as the 'programming language', which leads to the different values of omega, but this language has restrictions, namely that if one program p halts, then any program which has p as a prefix (is just p with some extra characters added on) then this program *cannot* halt.
    With this restriction, and this restriction only, the 1/2^k computation step makes sense, (what would that mean if these values summed more than 1, how would we know a prefix has contributed?)
    3. The way the 'simulate all programs' step is animated wouldnt work, because we would have to execute a countably infinite set of '1st steps' before returning to the 2nd step of the first program. The solution here is to use a diagonal approach, only executing the xth step of the yth program once all previous programs have computed at least the x+1th step. (Search dovetailing on wikipedia and the subsection on infinite sequences if confused)
    I found this set of slides helpful for further reading: Search for 'Computation and Thermodynamics - UCR Math'
    Again to reiterate - I liked the video! But just wanted to add more detail for eager viewers looking to better understand the concept.

    • @AllAnglesMath
      @AllAnglesMath  Месяц назад +1

      Thank you for clarifying! I must admit that I didn't catch all those details myself.

  • @turtlebro8314
    @turtlebro8314 Месяц назад +1

    Happy birthday to papa from England

  • @dan0_0nad76
    @dan0_0nad76 Месяц назад +1

    Happy birthday from Italy

  • @simeondermaats
    @simeondermaats Месяц назад +2

    Happy birthday to your father from Leuven!

  • @cytosolic5303
    @cytosolic5303 Месяц назад +1

    Happy Birthday from Washington State.

  • @hildegillis511
    @hildegillis511 Месяц назад +3

    Proficiat!