@@kabztunesyes!! My thoughts exactly!! I mentioned in another comment that a cover should be a spin on the song that is unique to the artist performing it. The POP goes punk albums come to mind for this (they might not be the best covers, but they get the idea of a different take on whatever song). For example, if a dubstep artist were to cover a song, it would be stupid if he got s band together to play the same instrumental parts that the original does. I'd expect to hear a dubstep version of the song! Otherwise, it's less of a cover, and more like performing the music (like how a modern orchestra doesn't COVER a piece by Mozart, they PERFORM it).
Why is it that no matter what I do, My Chemical Romance is haunting me? All I did was look up New Year's Day, and went to their Wikipedia page and I freaked out when I saw that they did a cover for Sleep. All I wanted to do was immerse myself into new bands that was NOT My Chemical Romance. Since I have had a problem (but is is really a problem?) for a few months now of having a habit of listening to MCR ONLY and I seem to never tire of listening to the same songs over and over again. I'M BROKEN...PLEASE HELP ME.
xTwisted xAngel they are my fave band ever because of not only their music... but the lyrics, the purpose, and who they are as people. They are so amazing. You should definitely listen to them
Honestly I'd recommend you get YOUR ears checked if you cant tell what good music is ;) No such thing as bad music, just people with different tastes in music.
The best covers happen when the band makes the song their own, and can put their own passion behind the music instead of being afraid to depart from the original style. This is a great cover! I wish the rest of the album was this kick-ass.
This is the only cover off the tributes album I actually like. The difference between the original version and this version of the song (in my opinion) is that the original was more based on sadness, while I get more of an angry vibe from this version. I like it
This has got to be the best cover, imo. I didn't think I would like any of the covers, but seriously they were all awesome. Of course it can never top MCR but I don't think any cover can top any original and I'm not just talking about MCR.. But overall I loved it. Makes me cry but I love it.
The screams towards the end brought me right back to the release day of "The Black Parade," all the way back in 3rd October, 2006 when I was 15, listening to the CD for the first time... a really great cover~
Yeah that was realllllyy bad. It was just so disrespectful to do that to that song especially considering it’s about cancer. And this is coming from someone who loves twenty one pilots and saw them rice on the trench tour already. That’s the one time when I got incredibly pissed at them.
@@mychemicalromancewillpierc5241the whole album is about cancer and they did it for the tribute album. I really don't understand it bothering anyone. It was a good cover 🤷🏾♂️
@@joeypez9432 i just don't like it because it's not my style, nothing against TØP's other stuff, it just doesn't click for me. I'm sure others don't like it because of how much it changes, but they can have that opinion
Yeah I get that not everyone will like a cover. To each their own. I just didnt understand it being disrespectful. They were asked to do the cover as a tribute and they did what any good band does with a cover. They made it their own. Oddly enough my least favorite cover on the album is by my favorite band on the album - creeper. I liked that the tribute album didn't enlist all super huge bands for this tribute, but more for lack of a better term "up and coming" type bands. I discovered a few bands through this album that I absolutely love now including creeper, new years day, ghost town and others. I dont think I would have found some of these bands without MCRs music 💜
Joey Pez it’s disrespectful because they turned a beautiful song into a dubstep remix track. They didn’t even sing the full song. Just “lips are chapped and faded-faded” it got annoying.
Kemist 781 I think it's a decent cover but I'm not a huge TOP fan. Production-wise, it's a little better than Sleep, but in terms of overall quality/ aesthetic, I like the Sleep cover a lot more.
W-what... what was this? I'm stuned right now... Damn, it was... just perfect! Her voice is so gorgeous and powerful at the same time, also the whole song felt stronger and darker here. Even though MCR is my favourite band, I dare to say that if this doesn't tops the original it gets on par with it, AT LEAST.
This cover is what got me in to New Year's Day in the first place. From someone who has been an MCR fan for fifteen years now, I must say...great band, great cover.
this one and Cancer are the good ones off of the album (just my opinion, I know a lot of people hate Cancer but I personally loved it along with this one)
this is honestly the best cover from the album, because they kept true to the original song while adding in their own sound and influence, plus it sounds friccin amazing.
This is one of my fave covers off the whole album, that include Cancer and Mama but this is my favorite. Ashley's voice is so amazing and it fits so well. I'm in love holy shit😍😍
Despite how much hate this album got from die-hard MCR fans, _(I'm not saying they're bad, just the backlash for this album was RIDICULOUS!)_, this is seriously a good cover. It gives it a more epic and more intense feeling, in my opinion, the original song is amazing, I like it. But this just gives me a whole new feeling that inspires me to draw more (I'm a digital artist).
I didn't like Creeper's cover but Will has the same gritty vocals as Gerard did in bullets, I just think people don't like it because it's not like the black parade style at all
That saiyan guy I thought it was Gerard? Because the place they were staying at was supposedly haunted and Gerard had bad night terrors. And it does sound a lot like gee in the original song...
reminder that ash is a giant mcr fangirl like the rest of us which is why she busted out this BOMB fuckin performance
Yeah and this cover is amazing
Listening to this makes me think this is actually a New Years Day song rather than a cover
MCRkilljoy For life AGREE!!
A good sign of a cover done right
Agreed
@@kabztunesyes!! My thoughts exactly!! I mentioned in another comment that a cover should be a spin on the song that is unique to the artist performing it.
The POP goes punk albums come to mind for this (they might not be the best covers, but they get the idea of a different take on whatever song). For example, if a dubstep artist were to cover a song, it would be stupid if he got s band together to play the same instrumental parts that the original does. I'd expect to hear a dubstep version of the song! Otherwise, it's less of a cover, and more like performing the music (like how a modern orchestra doesn't COVER a piece by Mozart, they PERFORM it).
Why is it that no matter what I do, My Chemical Romance is haunting me? All I did was look up New Year's Day, and went to their Wikipedia page and I freaked out when I saw that they did a cover for Sleep. All I wanted to do was immerse myself into new bands that was NOT My Chemical Romance. Since I have had a problem (but is is really a problem?) for a few months now of having a habit of listening to MCR ONLY and I seem to never tire of listening to the same songs over and over again. I'M BROKEN...PLEASE HELP ME.
But, seriously, this cover is beautiful. Thank you so much New Years Day! :)
The Killjoys Take a look at my channel bio for what I listen to, tons of good bands!!
bandlovergirl98 yes mam
I do that with like every band I ever like xD
Palaye Royal is a good band if you like Mcr
3:18-4:03 *EarGasm*
I don't even know this band but this cover is so perfect!
I recommend you listen to them, they're amazing.
xTwisted xAngel they are my fave band ever because of not only their music... but the lyrics, the purpose, and who they are as people. They are so amazing. You should definitely listen to them
eargasm? really?... I'd recommend you get your ears checked.
Honestly I'd recommend you get YOUR ears checked if you cant tell what good music is ;) No such thing as bad music, just people with different tastes in music.
xTwisted xAngel YOU NEED TO LISTEN TO NEW YEARS DAY THEN
Her screams are perf
Ikr
agreed!
I love this bc they put a little NYD vibe in it but still kept the MCR vibe at the same time
Bring Me The Llamas Me too and I love your username XD!!
What is nyd?
Bree the fandom queen New Years Day..
Honestly making it a metalcore song was fucking genius.
Agreed
this is the best cover in the entire album tbh
It's one of the best, I agree, together with Famous Last Words, The End and The Sharpest Lives.
Ayça Yıldırım what about cancer
Kemist 781 i think this is way better than cancer (just an opinion)
Ayça Yıldırım same
Ayça Yıldırım ikr
ASHLEY IS SUCH A PERFASSIONAL SINGER....AND THIS IS THE BEST MCR COVER YET EVER MADE..I'M PROUD OF ASHLEY
Bands Trash professional*
Maaaan →_→ Typo Issues
Bands Trash There is no way that was a typo, as "perfassional" is not a word...
Maddi Is The Raddest Unicorn i know :/ what the heck? I wrote professional in a wrongway that is a typo...
I'm proud of New Year's Day.
The best cover on the album
Yeah it's pretty good.
truuue
ElChismosogro Futbolero easily
State Champs did an amazing job with The Sharpest Lives too
Yeah, by a fucking landscape
this is so fucking good
This is decently one of the better on this album
definately*
The best covers happen when the band makes the song their own, and can put their own passion behind the music instead of being afraid to depart from the original style. This is a great cover! I wish the rest of the album was this kick-ass.
Ghost Town's was good too
No surprise that New Years Day would have the best cover of the whole album. They're the greatest.
I got legit chills listening to this
Same, I feel like crying...a little. *sighs* Fine, I'm such a damn liar, I feel like crying A LOT!
This is the only cover off the tributes album I actually like. The difference between the original version and this version of the song (in my opinion) is that the original was more based on sadness, while I get more of an angry vibe from this version. I like it
Agreed
This has got to be the best cover, imo. I didn't think I would like any of the covers, but seriously they were all awesome. Of course it can never top MCR but I don't think any cover can top any original and I'm not just talking about MCR.. But overall I loved it. Makes me cry but I love it.
Dancing in the Moonlight by Toploader.
When your friend asks you if this is a new Sleeping With Sirens song, and then you want to go stab them directly in the face
I wear black, and that's all you need to know. I don't know why but I laughed so hard at this 😂
I wear black, and that's all you need to know. YES XD
I come back to this a year later.
t h e s t a t e m e n t s t i l l
s t a n d s
Kellin Quinn low-key sounds like DoodleBob
AyeAyeRon I snorted so hard I gave myself whiplash
Ash Costello is a goddess!
i just think it's beautiful that a bunch of bands took their time to make this album
The screams towards the end brought me right back to the release day of "The Black Parade," all the way back in 3rd October, 2006 when I was 15, listening to the CD for the first time... a really great cover~
best.
cover.
on.
the.
album.
YES
Ashley's voice is a one of a kind ♡
So much better than twenty one pilots cover. Why aren't we all talking about this one. I loved this cover when it came out and I still love it
Yeah that was realllllyy bad. It was just so disrespectful to do that to that song especially considering it’s about cancer. And this is coming from someone who loves twenty one pilots and saw them rice on the trench tour already. That’s the one time when I got incredibly pissed at them.
@@mychemicalromancewillpierc5241the whole album is about cancer and they did it for the tribute album. I really don't understand it bothering anyone. It was a good cover 🤷🏾♂️
@@joeypez9432 i just don't like it because it's not my style, nothing against TØP's other stuff, it just doesn't click for me. I'm sure others don't like it because of how much it changes, but they can have that opinion
Yeah I get that not everyone will like a cover. To each their own. I just didnt understand it being disrespectful. They were asked to do the cover as a tribute and they did what any good band does with a cover. They made it their own. Oddly enough my least favorite cover on the album is by my favorite band on the album - creeper. I liked that the tribute album didn't enlist all super huge bands for this tribute, but more for lack of a better term "up and coming" type bands. I discovered a few bands through this album that I absolutely love now including creeper, new years day, ghost town and others. I dont think I would have found some of these bands without MCRs music 💜
Joey Pez it’s disrespectful because they turned a beautiful song into a dubstep remix track. They didn’t even sing the full song. Just “lips are chapped and faded-faded” it got annoying.
This is actually the best cover of the whole album
didn't expect anything less from NYD. UGH just sheer perfection
I can't stand the talking in the intro but this is probs the best cover on the album.
apologist. Same
apologist. What about cancer
Kemist 781 I think it's a decent cover but I'm not a huge TOP fan. Production-wise, it's a little better than Sleep, but in terms of overall quality/ aesthetic, I like the Sleep cover a lot more.
I'm not a TOP fan at all, but loved that cover. this one is so good too
I actually prefer CTE cover
It's like I stopped breathing during her screams.
This is my favorite cover on the entire album. Ashley's voice is so amazing in this.
new years day made the best cover on this
W-what... what was this? I'm stuned right now... Damn, it was... just perfect! Her voice is so gorgeous and powerful at the same time, also the whole song felt stronger and darker here.
Even though MCR is my favourite band, I dare to say that if this doesn't tops the original it gets on par with it, AT LEAST.
THIS I CAN AGREE WITH
This cover is what got me in to New Year's Day in the first place. From someone who has been an MCR fan for fifteen years now, I must say...great band, great cover.
This honestly makes me happy
Lol. Do you like Black Butler?
lol
this one and Cancer are the good ones off of the album (just my opinion, I know a lot of people hate Cancer but I personally loved it along with this one)
Freezing Paint agreed
wait, are you supposed to freeze paint? that a thing?
Ron Riggs 😂😂
Freezing Paint I hate
State Champs did an amazing job with The Sharpest Lives too
Yeah, best one, hands down. This is my absolute favorite MCR song, and Ash nailed it. Fantastic.
Well done Ashley! You did amazing in this cover!
I agree
this is honestly the best cover from the album, because they kept true to the original song while adding in their own sound and influence, plus it sounds friccin amazing.
I'm about to cry not only is this an amazing cover but she even included the screaming behind the wall of guitars
On every single track everyone says "This is the best one out of the rest" like stop. They're all great.
Ret c: no, this is the best one for sure
Then listen to the cover of Creeper. :D
oh my god her screams are awesome
this is such a good cover, they did the original proud.
0:00 - 4:49 my favorite part
Mrs valo666 me too
Same ♡
I didn't even know these covers existed until now.
Now THIS is how you do a cover! 🎶 Kudos to you, New Years Day!
Ash Costello- vocals
Nikki Misery- lead guitar
Jeremy Valentyne- rhythm guitar
Brandon Wolfe- bass
Daniel Trixx- drums
By *FAR* the best cover on the album
I am in tears over here this is fucking beautiful!!!💜💜💜 Ash killed it
Wow, she's got a powerful voice
I love this! Am I the only one that likes the whole album so far?
I had no idea they covered this but it sounds amazing.
easily the best cover on this album
3:50 that squeal sounded so good!!!😂🤟
Those screams tho
Why does Ashley sound kinda like Kellin lol...
Ophelia C. Omg.. true
Ophelia C. disrespect
She sounds nothing like him!
You're right hahaha
Lol lol lol tru
I love this song and mcr and NYD killed it great cover!
This is one of my fave covers off the whole album, that include Cancer and Mama but this is my favorite. Ashley's voice is so amazing and it fits so well. I'm in love holy shit😍😍
Best cover of the tribute album. Ash has such a nice voice 💕😍
Not a fan of the beginning but was converted by the power behind that ending. Best cover on this record by a long shot
NYD makes this song their own while paying respects to MCR, which makes this a great cover, and the best on the album imo
Despite how much hate this album got from die-hard MCR fans, _(I'm not saying they're bad, just the backlash for this album was RIDICULOUS!)_, this is seriously a good cover. It gives it a more epic and more intense feeling, in my opinion, the original song is amazing, I like it. But this just gives me a whole new feeling that inspires me to draw more (I'm a digital artist).
This song just cured my cancer that i got from Creeper - This is How I Disappear.
I didn't like Creeper's cover but Will has the same gritty vocals as Gerard did in bullets, I just think people don't like it because it's not like the black parade style at all
Do you mean cancer from TOP? :D
Holy shit I never knew creeper covered mcr
Aw man
I love creeper but holy shit that cover was ass
This is a really awesome cover of sleep at first I was a bit doubtful that it would be good
My favourite one of the entire album❤
This was the best cover
Aaaannnnddd now they're playing Download with My Chem. Holy fucking shit, they've made it.
my favorite band :new years day 4 ever♥♥♥♥
you know it’s a good cover when it sounds like the band’s original song
One of the best covers on a disappointment.
If only they used Gerard's recordings for the talking parts.
Woop Woop Nah. These were way better 🤷
(Late response) it was Frank Iero that did the recordings
That saiyan guy I thought it was Gerard? Because the place they were staying at was supposedly haunted and Gerard had bad night terrors. And it does sound a lot like gee in the original song...
i thought it was mikey?
ive always assumed it was ray. the whole band stayed at the haunted place and it sounds like ray to me
WHY AM I JUST FINDING OUT THAT NEW YEARS DAY COVERED SLEEP
Genuinely a great cover!
Absolutely killed this cover!
the screams are so fucking good on this what the hell
This is so good so now I have the need to listen to mcr again goddamnit
Best Cover in the album
I love them so much I'm proud of New Years Day
the best cover, hell yeahhhh!!
My fav cover on this album
This is the best cover on this album 🙂
this is such a badass cover
I love this one, they killed it, so good!
The beginning was really rough but almost everything after that was fucking great.
this cover is epic wow
i love this cover so much!
The E5 high scream
Ash’s voice is so fucking good!!!!😍😆😆
Iconic, the moment 🔥
Amo este cover ❤
this along with Dead!, and WTTBP are so my favorites on the tribute album😍😍😍
is the best cover on the album, good job
Love this
Best cover of this song
Ya hacía falta escuchar una voz femenina. Una de las mejores interpretaciones que he escuchado... Sin duda la descargaré :)
Best cover. Other covers sounded like rushed concepts.
best cover I've heard. Thanks Ash ❤️🇲🇾
yay i was alive during mcr's existence
Guys You F#$king Rocked It
i need this on spotifyyyyy
This is amazing
I'm impressed! Very good cover.
Yeah this is defentaly the best cover, Ash suits this song so well
THIS IS THE BEST ONE I LVE IT