I feel like the indie brands have been bringing so much to the industry! Part of me hates waiting for my order, but another part of me loves tracking my purchase, and finally digging in when it arrives! The main stream brands just don’t give me the same thrill anymore!
I was so wrong about your ranking! Killer Purr and Pastel Pup were so much farther up on your list than I thought they would be! The Whalesong palette is one of the most unique palette color stories I've ever seen.
Pastel pup. Because you mentioned the staining of the Whalesong palette. Really like to see your ranking of palettes. Be fun to see more ranking videos. My Pastel Pup arrived from the restock, excited to play with it tomorrow. 😻💙💙
Just a quick note that Harmonia and Wolfling are switched in your palette: harmonia is a the teal one, and wolfling is the shimmer. Wow, it's amazing how differently I would have ranked mine, but I love all of them so so much!
I am ready for menagerie to release singles of the shades in pastel pup. I ordered some singles from them in February and I def see why Annette,you,Beauty Bean and Bad to Brow love Menagerie their mattes are awesome and shimmers beautiful too I think I love mattes just a little more
I have Whalesong, Violet Ink and the 4 new tri-foils. None of the other palettes speak to me. Pastel Pup is cute, but I love Creepy Cute so I don’t think I need it. Love these ranking videos.
I wanted the Dragon Child palette so badly. In all honesty, I only wanted it for the packaging and name of it. I love Dragons! I know it’s a silly reason to buy something, which is why I never ordered it. I was looking for a good sale price but it was sold out and then discontinued. I don’t think I would be able to do this. I love all my palettes and would feel bad 🤣
I think the reason why a lot of pastel palettes include white, grey and black is probably because pastels remind us of the 1960’s. In the 60s they often applied black or grey lines in their crease and the white may be a matte inner corner. Just a guess, because those contrast colors look off putting when placed with pastel shades. 🤷♀️
Whalesong is my favorite. I have all except pastel pup which I may get during a Black Friday sale. I don’t like some of the shimmers in the feral palette and the killer purr, but the whalesong has the best quality in my opinion.
I only have 3 palettes, Dragon Child, Feral & Whale Song. And i love them all equally, i wouldnt be able to rank them. Thats why ive never done a single ranking video🙈 I just want everyone on top😂😂
I get to buy 4 palettes in 12 months. I have Killer Purr and Whale Song on my list when they restock. After Devinah's Butterfly collection, that leaves me 1 through Nov. Now I want Pastel Pup because I have nothing like it.
Ohh Im kinda surprised at your ranking! I only have 2 menagerie cosmetics palettes (ferral and courtship) but I love them both! This was fun to watch and hear your thoughts!
I have the feral palette but the only other colour story that lights my fire is the pink discontinued one. I’m not a big green fan, but the huechera? Green shimmer is truly captivating. 💚
I havent tried any menagerie products, nothing has captured my heart yet :D but im trying to be really selective with my purchases. My low buy is still going well btw :D im in month 6 already! And i even decluttered a bit more during self isolation times (do work fulltime as well tho, just in home office). Hope you are well, thanks for the video!
Nadine A. Their mattes are unbeatable. If you’re on a budget, they’re so worth the price. Now, I’m not a shimmer girl, but I will tell you I’ve had multiple shimmers arrive broken in a palette, or I’ll just be holding the palette vertically and they’ll just crumble to the floor. It’s the craziest thing! And it’s not easy getting them replaced. Even though I don’t wear them, I still want a complete palette. If you just got a palette, they’ll replace- once yo’ expectations sent pictures. But if it’s an older palette, they won’t send you a new one.
Thank you for the information I was interested in the Whale song palette but now that I know it stains your skin for days I will be passing on that! Thanks for your review!
You're not alone, I'm also not thrilled with menagerie's change of formula. It's still really good, but I love soft, kickupy shadows most. They really went and took my favorite formula away from me 😔
Lucky in the Dragon Child palette makes a beautiful highlight for me. Their shimmers in the DragonChild palette also look like liquid gold on the eyes with a glitter glue.
Amy Loves Makeup probably. I’m so ready for this to all be over, yet I’m also terrified that we’re gonna try to open up the country too soon and we’ll wind up right back in quarantine.
I just got my Pastel Pup and Whalesong yesterday, and both had shades that were completely shattered and all over the place 😭 Even though the box has “Do not drop” printed RIGHT ON IT, it seems like the Delivery person drop -kicked it into a brick wall.
Just an FYI for peeps who have never tried these or just want a few shades from a palette- buy them now! They discontinue shades at lightening speed. Almost every color from the Dragon Palette is gone. All those deep, beautiful burgundy shades are gone. It sucks. Not a shimmer girl, so I won’t speak in those, but there mattes, in my opinion, are unbeatable.
This was so cute, Amy!! 💛💛💛🥰 there are so many menagerie palettes that I want so this was so helpful!!! 💜💜💜💖 thank you so much for this great video!! I can’t wait for my pastel pup to ship 🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩💛
@@AmyLovesMakeup Yes, that is their only major flaw. They also reformulated Mimic to a lighter shades with a brown duochrome. Which you would actually probably like better, but I personally prefer the original version.
I really adore duochromes but depending on where you live getting singles especially from indie brands can be hard. I was wondering if you could maybe do a video about the best palettes with duochromes/unique shades. I really like the colour story of the Morphe 39S but 1. i don't know if i want to support Morphe and 2. I'm not a fan of big palettes let alone giant ones...
I have the Killer Purr on my list but I try to wait to buy until I want multiple items. I thought I would end up getting Pastel Pup but it didn't speak to me like I thought it would. I am looking forward to the reveal of the Metamorphosis palette and hoping that's the one that speaks to me.
I am so pissed at myself for not grabbing Dragon Child when I had the chance! I still haven’t used Pastel Pup ... but it took me a couple of months to finally use Killer Purr and now I love it ... I think Feral would be #1 and then Whalesong - or maybe even Killer Purr now that I think of it ... hm ... I love Courtship but it is limiting ... same with Violet Ink ...
Hi Amy loved the video, can't wait to purchase Menagerie palettes in the future! I've been meaning to ask though if you could do a shopping guide to certain indie brands and kind of like the do's and don'ts, for instance I've had a close eye on Clionadh for a good bit but before I jump the gun I would like some advice from someone who knows indie brands like the back of their hand😂 Would that be possible? And it's more than just that one brand too cuz I've also had my eye on like I said Menagerie and Terra Moons and others!
I would like Menagerie to make a new sale with some Dragon Child palettes for those who missed it, in the form of a preorder so that they do not produce more than necessary. I know it won't happen but I secretly hope so... ;) My favorite palette from them at this time is the Whalesong palette but I haven't received my Pastel Pup palette yet so, we'll see. :)
I made a palette from them that’s basically killer purr and whalesong combined with more vibrant shimmers and a few more browns that weren’t in K.P. and I’m a bit disappointed. All my browns just blend out orange.
I own feral and a bunch of singles from menagerie and I love them. I also ordered the trifoils as well. I thought you would pick whalesong! Surprise! 🤣
You surprised me with Killer before Feral!! I was sure the more neutral palette would be 4th or lower. Are you a purist in that you would never change up the original shade layout?
Hey Amy just a question they will be doing a restock on Jan 29th and I’m finally getting pastel pup so you have a code with them?? They are discontinuing the purple 6?pan palette would u suggest picking it up or have a better purple monochromatic palette suggestion?
i always thought Menagerie was a strange name to choose if the brand was donating to animal welfare, since a menagerie is a collection of caged/captured animals usually for display... honestly that's the only reason i haven't bought anything, feels a little off...
@@AmyLovesMakeup not according to WD Definition of menagerie 1a : a place where animals are kept and trained especially for exhibition b : a collection of wild or foreign animals kept especially for exhibition and yeah, i know it can also mean a varied collection, but still, i personally get more negative vibes than benign, but that's just me of course :)
Ok I’m pausing to guess... except I’m having serious deja vu, and I feel like you already said that you like pastel pup the most, mostly because whale song stains your eyes so much. Am I crazy? Or maybe you said that in another video? Anyways that’s my guess 😂
I think my ranking would be WAY different.. hmm might have to do this at some point
I’d love to see you so this. Super curious what your number one would be 😏
Annette's Makeup Corner Yes! I’d love to see your ranking!
Annettes number 1 would be her colab 🤞🤞🤞🤞🤞🤞🤞🤞🤞🤞🤞🤞🤞🤞
Hmm, I’m trying to make a guess! I think the violet ink or maybe whale song for number 1?Would love to see you do this one too!
Yes please do a video on this.
I feel like the indie brands have been bringing so much to the industry! Part of me hates waiting for my order, but another part of me loves tracking my purchase, and finally digging in when it arrives! The main stream brands just don’t give me the same thrill anymore!
I was so wrong about your ranking! Killer Purr and Pastel Pup were so much farther up on your list than I thought they would be! The Whalesong palette is one of the most unique palette color stories I've ever seen.
Pastel pup. Because you mentioned the staining of the Whalesong palette. Really like to see your ranking of palettes. Be fun to see more ranking videos. My Pastel Pup arrived from the restock, excited to play with it tomorrow. 😻💙💙
Just a quick note that Harmonia and Wolfling are switched in your palette: harmonia is a the teal one, and wolfling is the shimmer.
Wow, it's amazing how differently I would have ranked mine, but I love all of them so so much!
Haha yes my palette is all mixed up 😂 I would love to hear how you would rank yours
I think pastel pup wins for me as well! It’s just such a great all around pastel palette, with a great variety of pastel shades.
I am ready for menagerie to release singles of the shades in pastel pup. I ordered some singles from them in February and I def see why Annette,you,Beauty Bean and Bad to Brow love Menagerie their mattes are awesome and shimmers beautiful too I think I love mattes just a little more
I have Whalesong, Violet Ink and the 4 new tri-foils. None of the other palettes speak to me. Pastel Pup is cute, but I love Creepy Cute so I don’t think I need it. Love these ranking videos.
DishingUpTheDodgers When they restock, I’d love to grab the tri-foils! They look amazing!
I wanted the Dragon Child palette so badly. In all honesty, I only wanted it for the packaging and name of it. I love Dragons! I know it’s a silly reason to buy something, which is why I never ordered it. I was looking for a good sale price but it was sold out and then discontinued. I don’t think I would be able to do this. I love all my palettes and would feel bad 🤣
I think the reason why a lot of pastel palettes include white, grey and black is probably because pastels remind us of the 1960’s. In the 60s they often applied black or grey lines in their crease and the white may be a matte inner corner. Just a guess, because those contrast colors look off putting when placed with pastel shades. 🤷♀️
Whalesong is going to be the favorite.
I like the new change to your background. I noticed it a few videos back but forgot to comment.
Thank you 😊
Whalesong is my favorite. I have all except pastel pup which I may get during a Black Friday sale. I don’t like some of the shimmers in the feral palette and the killer purr, but the whalesong has the best quality in my opinion.
I only have 3 palettes, Dragon Child, Feral & Whale Song. And i love them all equally, i wouldnt be able to rank them. Thats why ive never done a single ranking video🙈 I just want everyone on top😂😂
Hahha they are hard to do 😂
I get to buy 4 palettes in 12 months. I have Killer Purr and Whale Song on my list when they restock. After Devinah's Butterfly collection, that leaves me 1 through Nov. Now I want Pastel Pup because I have nothing like it.
I for sure thought Whalesong would be your #1!
I'm torn between Pastel Pup and Killer Purr as my favorite, their shimmers are chunky but once I learned how to apply them I think their my favorite
Ohh Im kinda surprised at your ranking! I only have 2 menagerie cosmetics palettes (ferral and courtship) but I love them both! This was fun to watch and hear your thoughts!
Whale song for #1
I just think I'm going to give Killer Purr a miss when I place a order next, I just don't want neutral anything
I have the feral palette but the only other colour story that lights my fire is the pink discontinued one. I’m not a big green fan, but the huechera? Green shimmer is truly captivating. 💚
I mixed up my Feral and Dragon Child and like the color stories so much better now. The pans are magnetics, so you could maybe consider rearranging.
I havent tried any menagerie products, nothing has captured my heart yet :D but im trying to be really selective with my purchases. My low buy is still going well btw :D im in month 6 already! And i even decluttered a bit more during self isolation times (do work fulltime as well tho, just in home office). Hope you are well, thanks for the video!
I’m happy your low buy is still going well for you!! 😊
Good for you!!! Inspiring!!
Nadine A. Their mattes are unbeatable. If you’re on a budget, they’re so worth the price. Now, I’m not a shimmer girl, but I will tell you I’ve had multiple shimmers arrive broken in a palette, or I’ll just be holding the palette vertically and they’ll just crumble to the floor. It’s the craziest thing! And it’s not easy getting them replaced. Even though I don’t wear them, I still want a complete palette. If you just got a palette, they’ll replace- once yo’ expectations sent pictures. But if it’s an older palette, they won’t send you a new one.
Thank you for the information I was interested in the Whale song palette but now that I know it stains your skin for days I will be passing on that! Thanks for your review!
I think Pastel Pup is your favorite!
My vote is for the whalesong....you’re a grunge girl at heart 😍🙈
Lol, and that’s why I never try to guess - 50/50 shot, and I guessed wrong 🤣🤣🤣
😂😂😂
Katie Marie so did I!!!
You're not alone, I'm also not thrilled with menagerie's change of formula. It's still really good, but I love soft, kickupy shadows most. They really went and took my favorite formula away from me 😔
Well I’m glad I’m not crazy 🙈
I'm so sad about that! Maybe they'll bring it back for the butterfly palette?
6:54 I think Whalesong lol. I have Whalesong and Violet Ink. I'm not crazy about pastels on me personally but yea lol.
Oooooh I love the green nail polish!!!! Ever thought of reviewing indie nail polish?
Lucky in the Dragon Child palette makes a beautiful highlight for me. Their shimmers in the DragonChild palette also look like liquid gold on the eyes with a glitter glue.
Awww, I am still waiting for the PastelPup to ship. I did the preorder April 7th. Can't wait for it to get here!💚💙🧡
I hope it gets to you soon!
I really want to eventually get my hands on Pastel Pup, but it’s always out of stock.
I believe it’s taking longer to restock because of shipping delays and the effect of Covid 19 ):
Amy Loves Makeup probably. I’m so ready for this to all be over, yet I’m also terrified that we’re gonna try to open up the country too soon and we’ll wind up right back in quarantine.
Restock coming this Saturday June 27th
I just got my Pastel Pup and Whalesong yesterday, and both had shades that were completely shattered and all over the place 😭
Even though the box has “Do not drop” printed RIGHT ON IT, it seems like the Delivery person drop -kicked it into a brick wall.
Oh man I hate when that happens ):
Rewatching for the restock!!!!
Thank you for this comment!!! I just realized the restock is today. I thought it was the third 😂
Just an FYI for peeps who have never tried these or just want a few shades from a palette- buy them now! They discontinue shades at lightening speed. Almost every color from the Dragon Palette is gone. All those deep, beautiful burgundy shades are gone. It sucks. Not a shimmer girl, so I won’t speak in those, but there mattes, in my opinion, are unbeatable.
Menagerie Cosmetics is currently sold out of all their palettes. I wanted a cpl & can't get any just now. 💜
Purple Peggy not sold out gone. Just can’t ship with Corona shutting down so much. Keep checking. Once they can ship again, you’ll see them available.
This was so cute, Amy!! 💛💛💛🥰 there are so many menagerie palettes that I want so this was so helpful!!! 💜💜💜💖 thank you so much for this great video!! I can’t wait for my pastel pup to ship 🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩💛
I’m glad you enjoyed it and I hope you get your palette soon! 😊
Pastel Pup is the favorite.
Yep! I got it right hahaha
I just got my first Menagerie palette (I built my own) and am super excited to try them out!
Paused it to say Pastel pup is the top pick. Simply because it’s new
Amy, they reformulated their pearl shade. I don't like it as much cause it's now a more white color (instead of beige) and I like the beige a lot!
I noticed that in the photo on their website it looks very white. I really wish they would stop changing palettes after the fact 🙈🙈
@@AmyLovesMakeup Yes, that is their only major flaw. They also reformulated Mimic to a lighter shades with a brown duochrome. Which you would actually probably like better, but I personally prefer the original version.
Definitely Whalesong. I mean, it’s certainly my favorite! 😂
They’re all different and special for different reasons. Not too much of overlap.
I agree 😊
I really adore duochromes but depending on where you live getting singles especially from indie brands can be hard. I was wondering if you could maybe do a video about the best palettes with duochromes/unique shades. I really like the colour story of the Morphe 39S but 1. i don't know if i want to support Morphe and 2. I'm not a fan of big palettes let alone giant ones...
Thats an interesting idea!
Dragon Child is my favorite!
Can't wait to try Menagerie! Do they have good sales on black Friday? Does anyone remember?
I think maybe they did 30% off or something like thatv
Great video! Love all your rankings!! 🌸🌸🌸
Thank you 😊
I think Whalesong is your fave
I have the Killer Purr on my list but I try to wait to buy until I want multiple items. I thought I would end up getting Pastel Pup but it didn't speak to me like I thought it would. I am looking forward to the reveal of the Metamorphosis palette and hoping that's the one that speaks to me.
Rank the juvia's place palettes😍😍
I want to do those next! Figured this one would be a bit quicker 😂
@@AmyLovesMakeup Omg😍Can't wait to watchhh
I totally thought you'd pick the whale song palette as number one! I want to try their palettes so bad.
Whalesong......I was wrong😢 Beautiful look today, no surprise there!💚💚💚
I am so pissed at myself for not grabbing Dragon Child when I had the chance! I still haven’t used Pastel Pup ... but it took me a couple of months to finally use Killer Purr and now I love it ... I think Feral would be #1 and then Whalesong - or maybe even Killer Purr now that I think of it ... hm ... I love Courtship but it is limiting ... same with Violet Ink ...
I do not wich ones in first place!! I feel like you loved whalesong...but I'm guessinnggg pastel pup?
Nice lip color ;)
Hi Amy loved the video, can't wait to purchase Menagerie palettes in the future! I've been meaning to ask though if you could do a shopping guide to certain indie brands and kind of like the do's and don'ts, for instance I've had a close eye on Clionadh for a good bit but before I jump the gun I would like some advice from someone who knows indie brands like the back of their hand😂 Would that be possible? And it's more than just that one brand too cuz I've also had my eye on like I said Menagerie and Terra Moons and others!
I have a few videos in mind that are guides to buying indie Makeup but not focused on one brand. I will try and make them a priority to do sooner
I would like Menagerie to make a new sale with some Dragon Child palettes for those who missed it, in the form of a preorder so that they do not produce more than necessary. I know it won't happen but I secretly hope so... ;)
My favorite palette from them at this time is the Whalesong palette but I haven't received my Pastel Pup palette yet so, we'll see. :)
Now I want them all!!!!!!GEE thanks Amy😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂😂❤️❤️👍🏽👍🏽
I made a palette from them that’s basically killer purr and whalesong combined with more vibrant shimmers and a few more browns that weren’t in K.P. and I’m a bit disappointed. All my browns just blend out orange.
I’m sorry to hear that ):
Whalesong!
I own feral and a bunch of singles from menagerie and I love them. I also ordered the trifoils as well. I thought you would pick whalesong! Surprise! 🤣
😱 I was so sure whale song was your favorite
🙈🙈
You surprised me with Killer before Feral!! I was sure the more neutral palette would be 4th or lower. Are you a purist in that you would never change up the original shade layout?
Haha yes i have a hard time moving shadows around even when I can 😂😂 I want to do it more though
@@AmyLovesMakeup me too!! It took all my will power this weekend to combine my Sydney Grace and Colourpop singles 😆
I thought you were gonna pick whalesong as your first place 😅 I only have feral and really loving the formula
I love the looks you’ve been doing with feral. I’m inspired to use it more!
Can you compare the purple palette to the Juvia's purple palette 💛
i think whalesong is your favorite
darn i lost lol
I think whalesong is your favorite lol but I will see
*paused* I vote Whalesong lol
I’m guessing pastel pup 🙈
Hey Amy just a question they will be doing a restock on Jan 29th and I’m finally getting pastel pup so you have a code with them?? They are discontinuing the purple 6?pan palette would u suggest picking it up or have a better purple monochromatic palette suggestion?
My farrel pallet crumbled i got to reorder it andnsamr.thing happened to whalsong
Oh no ):
I love dragon child but I had to toss it cuz it started giving me a reaction on my eyes. I guess it was just too old.
Oh no ):
What's that palette behind you, it looks like Blush Tribe packaging art.
Do you mean the Linda Hallberg Spectral Palette?
Yup! Thats the one. Thank you!
Oh! I was wrong! I though whale song would be number one! And I was so smug! Ha ha!!
That’s too funny
i always thought Menagerie was a strange name to choose if the brand was donating to animal welfare, since a menagerie is a collection of caged/captured animals usually for display... honestly that's the only reason i haven't bought anything, feels a little off...
I believe that the point of a menagerie is to keep animals safe from extinction
@@AmyLovesMakeup not according to WD
Definition of menagerie
1a : a place where animals are kept and trained especially for exhibition
b : a collection of wild or foreign animals kept especially for exhibition
and yeah, i know it can also mean a varied collection, but still, i personally get more negative vibes than benign, but that's just me of course :)
I think whale song!
I think you made whale song number one. Let's see if I'm right lol.
👀💙
Lol I was wrong 😂
Ok I’m pausing to guess... except I’m having serious deja vu, and I feel like you already said that you like pastel pup the most, mostly because whale song stains your eyes so much. Am I crazy? Or maybe you said that in another video? Anyways that’s my guess 😂
Yes I said so in my pastel palette battle. You’re good haha
I predict whale song