To receive your holiday gift click here: drive.google.c... The framing link mentioned in the video will be under the "Printing Instructions" in the link above.
Bonjour cher Ian, un grand merci pour ce beau cadeau et pour toutes vos vidéos et conseils que j'apprécie énormément. À mon tour de vous souhaiter de très belles fêtes et à la nouvelle année. Cristina
Hi and thank you so much Ian. I appreciate your videos more than I can say. It’s awesome how much effort and enthusiasm you put into teaching. We all profit from it so much. Thanks again and have a wonderful Christmas Time. Cheers from Germany.
Hi Ian, thank you so much for your immense generosity throughout the year with all you have given us and for being so kind as to give us these amazing pencil drawings to print off. They are all really beautiful and very much appreciated. I do hope that you and your family enjoy a very Happy and Peaceful Christmas and yes, your personal most creative year yet in 2023. Looking forward to seeing you then. Best wishes from Ireland.
Thank you so much. This is a very touching and generous gift… Your videos have helped me enormously in developing my painting practice and understanding how to think more analytically as I paint. You share your knowledge with us with such great generosity, video by video, with clarity, simplicity and vision. This gesture is so much a part of who you are as a teacher. Only you! Thank you. I shall treasure them.❤
Thank you for the sincere comment, Penny. I am delighted that you are finding them so helpful in your painting practice. You are so welcome. Happy Holidays to you and your loved ones
Thank you for your generosity and dedication. Your way of teaching has haloed me get back into drawing, painting and I am enjoying it immensely. I wish you and your family a healthy, peaceful and creative new year. All the best!
Thank you so much Ian for this gift. How special and thoughtful. You are an amazing teacher and I learn so much from your tutorials. May 2023 be the most fulfilling and creative year for all of us. Wishing you a Merry Christmas and happy, healthy New Year.
Dear Jan, Thank you for your gift! It has been a leasure to follow your lessons for over two years. These are always instructional and inspirational. Thank you for your talent, energy and willlingness to share your skills and knowledge with the aspiring artists. Wishing you the very best for the 2023 and hope to continue be part of the circle of artists that follow you and learn from you. Keep the creatinve energy and juices flowing!
Thank you, Ian, for the "Best of wishes" in our creative pursuits! Same to. you and yours! You and your instructional videos have been a great inspiration and blessing! A Christmas Blessing...
Thank you and I wish you and your family a Merry Christmas and a fantastic New Year 2023! I love the channel, very informative and you are so selflessl in sharing your wonderful knowledge with all of us!
Hi Ian and thank you so much for your gift. I have learned so much from you and follow you with pleasure. Merry Christmas and a happy new year to you and your family. See you next year. Hi from Dorte from Denmark
Thank you Ian, for both your time and effort you put into your video's and also your gift. Both are very much appreciated. I wish you and yours a happy Christmas and New year. All the best from Ireland.
Thank you and I wish you a Christmas. I follow your work and try to profit when my main business was trading in free diamonds, but your work is just as valuable as it is. Thank you for the second time
Hi Ian, thank you so much for your kindness, it is so much appreciated, I have enjoyed your videos and learned so much from them, thank you. Wishing you and your family a peaceful and happy Christmas and the very best of health and happiness for 2023. Anne from Ireland
Thank you so much Ian for all those fantastic videos last year. I learned a lot from your videos to see the big picture in stead of loosing myself in minor details. Have a wonderful christmas time and a happy new year for you and your family. Greetings from Belgium.
Hello and thanks so much Ian! Your videos have helped me tremendously in my journey over the past months, and I look forward to what's to come in the new year! Best wishes to you and your family for the Christmas season and the new year!
Good morning from coastal North Carolina. Your instruction on composition has helped me tremendously. My medium is watercolor and I’m basically self-taught with much help from you and a few other RUclips artists I follow. Deeply appreciate your gentle guidance on how to capture the light with values. My best to you; sending love, light, and well-being.
Hi there Ian, again I thank you! That is my short reactie when I have seen one of the video's you share with us. My english is not so good so thats why I keep it allways short. But now I want to thank you for all that you learn all of us and for your good wishes . For me you are a great teacher, explaning it all so intens and clearly. I hope you and your familie have a very healty , loving and creative year also. PS. Today it is my birthday so your gift feels also as an birthdayspresent. So: Thank you Ian.
Oh thank You so very much sir! I love the style of yours, and I´m returning time after time to get the most out of the lessons You have made fo us all!! A very merry xmas for You and yours from Denmark!
Thank you very much for this thoughtful gift Ian. I enjoy watching your videos but have time constraints because of ill health. I wish you and your loved ones a Happy Christmas and peaceful 2023.
THANK YOU FOR THIS MARVELOUS GIFT!! i ll hang them as a quadriptique for sure .!🤗Iove your work, calm and elegant videos✨️very inspirant.Hope 2023 will be a very creative year, we need it 💫seasonal greetings to you all.🙏👋Do in Paris🗼😉
Thank you for the gift! 🎄 I wish you exactly what I wish for myself: lots of inspiration and peace of mind for the NewYear! Be happy, healthy and( why not?) wealthy! 😀Merry Christmas! Adriana
Thank you Ian! Wishing you and Anne and your family a wonderful Christmas & New Year! YOU are an inspiration & reminder for daily practice & simplifying/clarifying paintings and life! Thank you the gift of your drawings… as always, beautiful, sensitive and true! Thank you for all you do! Thank you for being you! Enjoy the coming days & coming year. May life be gentle, inspiring and beautiful. xoxo Jayne Bourke, Avondale PA
Thank you so much! Very kind. Thanks too for your videos - they are so helpful! 👏🙏 Wishing you and your family a very happy Christmas and a wonderful new year! Warm greetings from Australia, Dianne 🌟🌲💐🤗💕
Thank you so very much Ian! You provide and demonstrate so much priceless knowledge which I find great inspiration in. Happiest, Healthiest Holidays Wishes for you and yours. ❤🧡💚
Thank you! What a wonderful gift. I also appreciate all the gifts you give through out the year, Thank you, Thank you!! I wish for you and your wife a very wonderful Christmas and a very healthy happy creative New Year! Best Wishes from Florida!
Wishing you and all you love Bene Cose (All Good Things) for the holidays 2022, for New Year 2023, and all years forward. Each of your videos is an art journey in a fuller understanding of fundamental technique in absorbable bytes. Brilliant. Your book, "Mastering Composition" is a favorite in my library. Thank you for all you do - and thank you for this sweet gift.
Thank you very much Mr. Roberts for your Christmas present. I find your videos very interesting and informative. I wish you a Merry Christmas and a wonderful New Year!
Thank you Ian. I've always enjoyed your pre-paint sketching technique and it's one of the most valuable lessons I've gained from your excellent videos. I hope you have a great Christmas and that we have an even better 2023 as we move away(?) from Covid.
Hi Ian, what a wonderful suprise! Thank you so much. And thank you for all you've given me this year. You have definitly helped me grow as an artist. Wishing you and yours a very happy holiday and the best for 2023. Laura Johnston
Hi Ian, thank you so much for your generous gift. Thank you for 2022 and for sharing your knowledge so generously. Wishing you and family all the very best for Christmas and new year 2023.
Ian, somehow it seems that it should be we, who give you the Christmas gift. After all, you have given of yourself in your art videos. Anyway, I wish you, your family, and everybody on this RUclips channel a very Merry Christmas. May 2023 be as fulfilling. God Bless Everyone.
Thank you Ian, those are beautiful sketches!! Happy Holidays to you as well. I have learned many good techniques and theories from you. I look for many more in 2023!
Oh Ian, thank you so much! These are beautiful! You are so sweet, and I just love learning so much from you! I wish you and your family a very Merry Happy Christmas and a happy, healthy new year! 🎄🎅🌠
What a wonderful gesture! Thank you… I wish I could reciprocate in some way. You give us so much of yourself with each and every post. Merry Christmas 🎄 from South Africa
Dear Mr. Roberts! I would like to take this opportunity to thank you for the great support and the super instructive videos. I always get excited about a new video and I always look at each video with enthusiasm. Thank you very very much for that 💕🎨🎨 I wish you and your family a Merry Christmas and a fantastic New Year 2023 🍀🍾🎁🎨 Best regards from Salzburg, Robert
A very happy holiday to you, Ann and family! Thank you for sharing so much with "your followers" this last year. It has been a solid place to build from. May 2023 bring much joy into your home.
Thank you Mr Roberts. I really like how you simplify things by thinking in terms of shapes. Even though I'm digital painting, not with real brush, but I find your approach really inspirtional. Merry Christmas and thank your for the gift 🙂
Thanks again for your special generosity and thoughtful wishes! I have a perfect spot for your collection!! Merry Christmas and all the best to you through 2023. I greatly appreciate your videos. Cheers!
What a beautiful gesture - thank you! I'm looking forward to the 2023 inspirational videos as I'm a little short of that at present! Wishing you and yours a very Merry Christmas and a Prosperous New Year!
Hi Ian ! I think your gift was the most wonderful you could have given me !! You know how I am always telling you how much I love your pencil drawings and never get tired of watching you drawing them !! Wow ! I felt like jumping up and down for finally getting not just one ...but four of them !! You are ever so kind both in your teaching and in sharing these little gems ! I am ever so grateful and Blessed to be Subscribed to your awesome Channel. I wish You and your lovely wife Anne the best Blessed Christmas full of love and happiness and also for the coming New Year . Thank You so so much Ian ! Warmest regards and Best Wishes....Lorraine 🤗🙏🏻
What a lovely gift! Thank you Ian, for your teaching and generosity. I've learned so much from your wonderful videos. You've shown me a way to think about composition, and it helps a lot! I love your pencil drawings, I'll print and put them up on my inspiration wall. Have a great holiday ❤️😄
Thank you so very much, sir, for all the hard work you put into this channel. I look forward to each and every new post 🤗! Thank you, also, for these fabulous drawings 🤩! They’ll soon be adorning my studio walls 😄. Merry Christmas to you and yours!
Oh my what a lovely gift thank you. Thank you for your monthly video gifts all year as well! The best instruction on RUclips in my opinion. Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year! Wishing you health and may all your needs be supplied. God Bless
Thank you very much Mr. Ian Roberts Very moved by your kindness and generosity. I wish you a very Merry Christmas for you and your family.🌟 See you very soon for the new year 2023 in drawing and color 🎨
Hello and thank you very much for your generosity, Jan, much appreciated. Your lessons mean a lot to me and give much support. Merry Christmas and Happy New Year.
Hi Ian, I have followed you for sometime and deeply appreciate what you share, as I have no access to English speaking teachers, here in Uruguay. Your gifts travel further and are more deeply felt than you will ever know.Thank you, thank you!
Ian, Merry Christmas to you and your wife! I'm now beginning a series from Tomales Bay and the northern part of the Point Reyes peninsula. Great shapes. 🙂
Hi Ralph, I love that neck of the woods. As you say, great shapes. Have a great time with that series. My very best wishes to you for 2023. A year in enthusiastic artistic expression. All the best.
Hello Ian, thank you so much for these prints of your marvellous sketches. I said to myself in your last video that I would pay for one of those (still would, wallet disagrees!). Thank you, have a safe, happy and joyful turn of the year. Regards, SN
Bless your heart! So sweet of you. I really like your drawings. Have a wonderful Christmas and New Year. I'm in the UK and we've recently had a spell of snow, so it's out with the paints to take advantage (although too cold to paint outside). Might you ever consider doing a tutorial on snow painting? It's really interesting to attempt.
Hi Jonquil, I did a video on how to paint white (including snow) this time last year. ruclips.net/video/oe8x2jO3qnM/видео.html. I hope you enjoy it. All the very best and happy holidays
And to you too Ian. I've had your Mastering Composition book for a long time. I keep going back to reread it. It's one book I'll always keep. I just received Authentic Creativity so I have some good holiday reading. Thank you for all your inspirational videos, books and tips. 🥂
Thank you very much for the generosity, for giving away this gift, and more importantly for sharing your information and experience with us. Happy holidays.
Thank you very much! How kind! The videos are already so priceless and now we get a beautifulI gift to! Let us all keep making paintings. The world needs nice things, now more than ever! I wish you and your family all the best. And again, a big thank you for al the effort! Warm greetings tot everyone!
Merry Christmas to you and yours. Thank you 🙏 for your generous gift 🎁 and thank you for sharing your artistic talents 🎉🎉🎉 Here’s to new adventures with our art in 2023 👍
What a lovely soul, thanks, Ian (my son's name is Ian after my great uncle) You have been a big part of my growth as a painter, and I have absolutely trashed your book, I mean it looks well-loved! Only a yrat old but looks five years old. You and Carlson, good stuff. Thank you and wishing you a stellar new year.
Hi Ian thanks for your generous gift and sharing with everyone, wishing everyone a very happy and peaceful Christmas God bless from the Midlands of Ireland, regards Noel
thank you very much for your gift. wish You and Your family Merry Christmas . you are wonderful Teacher who explains each and every thing in detail. and easy to understand. Thanks again for your wonderful videos. That will be continue.
Thank you for such a lovely gift! Your channel is very inspirational and educational! You are truly appreciated! Wishing you and yours a Merry Christmas!
To receive your Christmas gift click here: drive.google.com/drive/folders/1OlKtx3iiTpUfUXS3LutKtNreCcqmDe6U?usp=sharing
Thank you, Ian, for sharing your artistic knowledge and for the beautiful drawings!
Thank you!
Bonjour cher Ian, un grand merci pour ce beau cadeau et pour toutes vos vidéos et conseils que j'apprécie énormément. À mon tour de vous souhaiter de très belles fêtes et à la nouvelle année. Cristina
I am very looking forward to sign up your drawings lessons, Merry Christmas and Happy Happy New Year🙏🙏🙏
You. So much appreciation.
Hi and thank you so much Ian. I appreciate your videos more than I can say. It’s awesome how much effort and enthusiasm you put into teaching. We all profit from it so much. Thanks again and have a wonderful Christmas Time. Cheers from Germany.
Thank you for the kinds words. Happy holidays! You're very welcome!
Hi Ian, thank you so much for your immense generosity throughout the year with all you have given us and for being so kind as to give us these amazing pencil drawings to print off. They are all really beautiful and very much appreciated. I do hope that you and your family enjoy a very Happy and Peaceful Christmas and yes, your personal most creative year yet in 2023. Looking forward to seeing you then. Best wishes from Ireland.
Same to you Dearbhla, and thank you for the kind note. I am delighted you are finding my videos so helpful. Happy holidays to you and your loved ones.
Thank you so much. This is a very touching and generous gift…
Your videos have helped me enormously in developing my painting practice and understanding how to think more analytically as I paint. You share your knowledge with us with such great generosity, video by video, with clarity, simplicity and vision. This gesture is so much a part of who you are as a teacher.
Only you!
Thank you. I shall treasure them.❤
Thank you for the sincere comment, Penny. I am delighted that you are finding them so helpful in your painting practice. You are so welcome. Happy Holidays to you and your loved ones
Thank you for your generosity and dedication. Your way of teaching has haloed me get back into drawing, painting and I am enjoying it immensely. I wish you and your family a healthy, peaceful and creative new year. All the best!
Happy holidays to you and your loved ones. You're very welcome and thank you for the nice comment Berolina
Thank you so much Ian for this gift. How special and thoughtful. You are an amazing teacher and I learn so much from your tutorials. May 2023 be the most fulfilling and creative year for all of us. Wishing you a Merry Christmas and happy, healthy New Year.
@Gail Check . Thank you and Ditto.
Happy holidays to you and your loved ones. You're very welcome and thank you for the kind words Gail
Dear Jan, Thank you for your gift! It has been a leasure to follow your lessons for over two years. These are always instructional and inspirational. Thank you for your talent, energy and willlingness to share your skills and knowledge with the aspiring artists. Wishing you the very best for the 2023 and hope to continue be part of the circle of artists that follow you and learn from you. Keep the creatinve energy and juices flowing!
You're very welcome. I appreciate your kind words Svetlana. Happy holidays to you and your family
Thank you, Ian, for the "Best of wishes" in our creative pursuits! Same to. you and yours! You and your instructional videos have been a great inspiration and blessing! A Christmas Blessing...
You're very welcome. Glad you find my videos inspirational. Merry Christmas to you Andrea
Thank you and I wish you and your family a Merry Christmas and a fantastic New Year 2023! I love the channel, very informative and you are so selflessl in sharing your wonderful knowledge with all of us!
You're very welcome and thank you. Delighted you like my channel. Merry Christmas to you
Thanks for the share and what you share with us ongoing.
I look forward to each video.
Blessings to you and your family in 2023 as well!
Best, Laura 🎉
Happy holidays to you and your loved ones. You're very welcome
Merry Christmas to you and your loved ones, all the best for 2023 from the Netherlands! Thanks for the gift!!
Happy holidays! You're very welcome!
Awfully nice gesture, Ian. Thank you and Merry Christmas to you and yours.
You're very welcome. Merry Christmas to you Nancy
Hi Ian and thank you so much for your gift. I have learned so much from you and follow you with pleasure. Merry Christmas and a happy new year to you and your family. See you next year. Hi from Dorte from Denmark
You're very welcome. Merry Christmas to you and happy new year Dorte
Thank you Ian. I have learnt many things from you. God bless you and your family, Merry Christmas.
You're very welcome. Merry Christmas to you Philomena
Hi Ian-thank-you so much for the nice gift and for your generous teaching. Have a blessed Christmas.
You're very welcome. Merry Christmas to you
Thank you Ian, for both your time and effort you put into your video's and also your gift. Both are very much appreciated. I wish you and yours a happy Christmas and New year. All the best from Ireland.
You're very welcome. Merry Christmas to you!
Thank you and I wish you a Christmas. I follow your work and try to profit when my main business was trading in free diamonds, but your work is just as valuable as it is. Thank you for the second time
I am glad you like the gift. Happy holidays
Hi Ian, thank you so much for your kindness, it is so much appreciated, I have enjoyed your videos and learned so much from them, thank you. Wishing you and your family a peaceful and happy Christmas and the very best of health and happiness for 2023.
Anne from Ireland
You're very welcome. Happy holidays to you and your family Anne.
best wishes from France ! (and thx for sharing quality videos)
Glad you like them!
Thank you so much for the beautiful gift! I have been so inspired by your videos!!
You're very welcome. Happy holidays to you and your family Hope. Glad you like the videos
Thank you Ian!!✨🎄All the best from Switzerland 🏔️🇨🇭
Same to you! Happy holidays Franziska
Hi Ian, thank you for the Christmas present! Thank you for all of your help in the painting process!!! Merry Christmas!!!
You're very welcome. Merry Christmas to you Kerry
Thank you Ian!!! Merry Christmas! I really appreciate it ❤️
You're very welcome. Merry Christmas to you Jackie
You're an excellent teacher. I have a friend just learning to paint and i pointed her to your channel. Merry Christmas
Thanks so much. I hope she enjoys my videos. Merry Christmas to you
Thank you so much, Merry Christmas to you too, and all the best to you and family in 2023!
You're very welcome. Merry Christmas to you Seva
This is so nice of you. I’m on my way in to my work at the hospital shortly, and this is a lovely lift. Merry Christmas!
I am delighted you like the gift. Merry Christmas to you and your loved ones Carolyn
Thanks Ian ! such a beautiful gift. Very generous of you.
I am delighted you like the gift. Happy Holidays to you and your loved ones
Thank you very much, Merry Christmas Ian!🎉
You're very welcome. Merry Christmas to you Donna
Thank you so much Ian for all those fantastic videos last year. I learned a lot from your videos to see the big picture in stead of loosing myself in minor details. Have a wonderful christmas time and a happy new year for you and your family. Greetings from Belgium.
You're very welcome. Happy holidays to you and your family Tim
Not a stupid giveaway like all the other youtubers do shows you Ian is such a nice guy and he actually cares and i god damn love him
Thank you. Glad you like the gift
Hello and thanks so much Ian! Your videos have helped me tremendously in my journey over the past months, and I look forward to what's to come in the new year! Best wishes to you and your family for the Christmas season and the new year!
You're very welcome. Happy holidays to you and your family Giselle. See you in the new year.
Thank you so much! Merry Christmas to you and your family!
You're very welcome. Merry Christmas to you Lyne
Thank you and a very happy Christmas to you and your family.
You're very welcome. Merry Christmas to you Lesley
Good morning from coastal North Carolina. Your instruction on composition has helped me tremendously. My medium is watercolor and I’m basically self-taught with much help from you and a few other RUclips artists I follow. Deeply appreciate your gentle guidance on how to capture the light with values. My best to you; sending love, light, and well-being.
You're welcome Susan. Thank you for the kind words and I am delighted you are finding my videos so helpful. Happy holidays to you and your loved ones
Thank you! Merry Christmas to you and your family
You're very welcome. Merry Christmas to you
Hi there Ian, again I thank you! That is my short reactie when I have seen one of the video's you share with us. My english is not so good so thats why I keep it allways short. But now I want to thank you for all that you learn all of us and for your good wishes . For me you are a great teacher, explaning it all so intens and clearly. I hope you and your familie have a very healty , loving and creative year also. PS. Today it is my birthday so your gift feels also as an birthdayspresent. So: Thank you Ian.
That is very kind of you to say. I am delighted you are enjoying the videos, and a very happy birthday. All the best to you
Thank you for all those inspiring videos this year !!
I wish you a merry Christmas and a healthy, creative and happy 2023!!!, margreet 🎨✍🏻
Thank you so much. I am glad you enjoyed the videos. On to 2023. Happy holidays
Oh thank You so very much sir! I love the style of yours, and I´m returning time after time to get the most out of the lessons You have made fo us all!! A very merry xmas for You and yours from Denmark!
You're very welcome. Happy holidays to you and your family Johnny
Thank you very much for this thoughtful gift Ian. I enjoy watching your videos but have time constraints because of ill health. I wish you and your loved ones a Happy Christmas and peaceful 2023.
I am delighted you like the gift Bee. Happy Holidays to you and your loved ones
THANK YOU FOR THIS MARVELOUS GIFT!! i ll hang them as a quadriptique for sure .!🤗Iove your work, calm and elegant videos✨️very inspirant.Hope 2023 will be a very creative year, we need it 💫seasonal greetings to you all.🙏👋Do in Paris🗼😉
I am delighted you like the gift. Happy Holidays to you and your loved ones Dorothee!
Thank you so much! 💖
Merry Christmas! 🎄 & Happy New Year! 📯
🎀🕯🔔✨🎄✨🔔🕯🎀
You're very welcome. Happy holidays to you!
Thank you for the gift! 🎄 I wish you exactly what I wish for myself: lots of inspiration and peace of mind for the NewYear! Be happy, healthy and( why not?) wealthy! 😀Merry Christmas! Adriana
Thanks so much. All the very best and happy holidays
Thank you Ian! Wishing you and Anne and your family a wonderful Christmas & New Year! YOU are an inspiration & reminder for daily practice & simplifying/clarifying paintings and life!
Thank you the gift of your drawings… as always, beautiful, sensitive and true! Thank you for all you do! Thank you for being you!
Enjoy the coming days & coming year. May life be gentle, inspiring and beautiful.
xoxo Jayne Bourke, Avondale PA
You're welcome. Thank you for the kind words. Happy holidays to you and your loved ones
Thank you, what beautiful drawings! I always love your pencil work, and thank you for your wonderful RUclips videos. Have a wonderful Christmas sir!
You're very welcome Jon. Merry christmas!
Thanks Ian for your excellent tutorials! Hope you have a wonderful holidays! 🎉🎉🎉
Happy holidays to you and your loved ones. You're very welcome Malie
🙏 🙏🙏 merry Christmas for you and health and please continue with your RUclips videos. All the best for 2023!
Merry Christmas to you Wolfgang, and a happy new year
Thank you very much. Hope you and your family have a bessed Christmas and may God be with you throughout 2023. I enjoy your video's!
Same to you Elizabeth. All the best
Thank you so much! Very kind. Thanks too for your videos - they are so helpful! 👏🙏 Wishing you and your family a very happy Christmas and a wonderful new year! Warm greetings from Australia, Dianne 🌟🌲💐🤗💕
You're welcome. Thank you for the kind words. Happy holidays to you and your loved ones
Thank you for being such a wonderful giver! I really enjoy your videos and look forward to 2023. Merry Christmas and Happy New Year!
Thanks so much. All the very best and happy holidays
Thank you so very much Ian! You provide and demonstrate so much priceless knowledge which I find great inspiration in. Happiest, Healthiest Holidays Wishes for you and yours. ❤🧡💚
Thanks so much. All the very best and happy holidays
Many thanks Ian, and all the best to you for 2023. Watching your videos is inspiration for me. I'm looking forward to watching them all. Cheers
Happy new year! Delighted you found it inspirational
Thank you! What a wonderful gift. I also appreciate all the gifts you give through out the year, Thank you, Thank you!! I wish for you and your wife a very wonderful Christmas and a very healthy happy creative New Year! Best Wishes from Florida!
Happy new year from me and Anne, Patty. Thank you
Wishing you and all you love Bene Cose (All Good Things) for the holidays 2022, for New Year 2023, and all years forward. Each of your videos is an art journey in a fuller understanding of fundamental technique in absorbable bytes. Brilliant. Your book, "Mastering Composition" is a favorite in my library. Thank you for all you do - and thank you for this sweet gift.
That makes me so happy to hear that you are enjoying my book. I am delighted you like the gift. Happy Holidays to you and your loved ones Phyllis
Thanks Ian - Can't tell you how helpful and inspirational you have been - Happy Christmas from NZ
You're very welcome. That is kind of you to say. Merry Christmas to you Mat.
Thank you very much Mr. Roberts for your Christmas present. I find your videos very interesting and informative. I wish you a Merry Christmas and a wonderful New Year!
You're welcome. Thank you for the kind words. Happy holidays to you and your loved ones
Thank you❣️And happy holidays to you and your family as well. Your work and contribution to artist development is exceptional.
Thanks so much. All the very best and happy holidays
Thank you Ian. I've always enjoyed your pre-paint sketching technique and it's one of the most valuable lessons I've gained from your excellent videos. I hope you have a great Christmas and that we have an even better 2023 as we move away(?) from Covid.
You're welcome. Thank you for the kind words. Happy holidays to you and your loved ones
Hi Ian, what a wonderful suprise! Thank you so much. And thank you for all you've given me this year. You have definitly helped me grow as an artist.
Wishing you and yours a very happy holiday and the best for 2023. Laura Johnston
Thanks so much. All the very best and happy holidays
Hi Ian, thank you so much for your generous gift. Thank you for 2022 and for sharing your knowledge so generously. Wishing you and family all the very best for Christmas and new year 2023.
Happy holidays Milly! Thank you and all the best
Ian, somehow it seems that it should be we, who give you the Christmas gift. After all, you have given of yourself in your art videos. Anyway, I wish you, your family, and everybody on this RUclips channel a very Merry Christmas. May 2023 be as fulfilling. God Bless Everyone.
Thank you for the kind words George. Happy holidays to you and your loved ones and all the very best
Thank you Ian, those are beautiful sketches!! Happy Holidays to you as well. I have learned many good techniques and theories from you. I look for many more in 2023!
Thanks so much. All the very best and happy holidays
Oh Ian, thank you so much! These are beautiful! You are so sweet, and I just love learning so much from you! I wish you and your family a very Merry Happy Christmas and a happy, healthy new year! 🎄🎅🌠
Thanks so much. All the very best and happy holidays
What a wonderful gesture! Thank you… I wish I could reciprocate in some way. You give us so much of yourself with each and every post. Merry Christmas 🎄 from South Africa
Happy holidays to you and your loved ones Franco
Dear Mr. Roberts! I would like to take this opportunity to thank you for the great support and the super instructive videos. I always get excited about a new video and I always look at each video with enthusiasm. Thank you very very much for that 💕🎨🎨 I wish you and your family a Merry Christmas and a fantastic New Year 2023 🍀🍾🎁🎨 Best regards from Salzburg, Robert
You are very welcome and thank you for the kind words. Happy holidays to you and your loved ones Robert
@@IanRobertsMasteringComposition thank YOU very very much dear Ian 🎄🍀🎨
A very happy holiday to you, Ann and family! Thank you for sharing so much with "your followers" this last year. It has been a solid place to build from. May 2023 bring much joy into your home.
You're welcome. Happy holidays to you and your loved ones. All the very best.
I have enjoyed all your tutorials! Thank you! Wishing you and your family the best Christmas ever and an awesome new 2023!
Thank you! You too!
Thank you Mr Roberts. I really like how you simplify things by thinking in terms of shapes.
Even though I'm digital painting, not with real brush, but I find your approach really inspirtional.
Merry Christmas and thank your for the gift 🙂
You're welcome. Thank you for the kind words. Happy holidays to you and your loved ones
Thanks again for your special generosity and thoughtful wishes! I have a perfect spot for your collection!! Merry Christmas and all the best to you through 2023. I greatly appreciate your videos. Cheers!
You're welcome. Happy holidays to you and your loved ones
How lovely! Thanks so much for your generosity and the drawings. Looking forwrad to continuing to learn from you in 2023. Have a wonderful Christmas!
You're welcome. Happy holidays to you and your loved ones
What a beautiful gesture - thank you! I'm looking forward to the 2023 inspirational videos as I'm a little short of that at present! Wishing you and yours a very Merry Christmas and a Prosperous New Year!
You're very welcome. Merry Christmas to you Maria. Thank you for the kind comment
Hi Ian ! I think your gift was the most wonderful you could have given me !! You know how I am always telling you how much I love your pencil drawings and never get tired of watching you drawing them !! Wow ! I felt like jumping up and down for finally getting not just one ...but four of them !! You are ever so kind both in your teaching and in sharing these little gems ! I am ever so grateful and Blessed to be Subscribed to your awesome Channel. I wish You and your lovely wife Anne the best Blessed Christmas full of love and happiness and also for the coming New Year . Thank You so so much Ian ! Warmest regards and Best Wishes....Lorraine 🤗🙏🏻
You're welcome. Thank you for the kind words. Happy holidays to you and your loved ones
Thank you so much Ian for the lovely Christmas gift. All the best to you for the New Year and a very happy wonderful Christmas.
Thanks so much. All the very best and happy holidays
Thank you, Ian. Wishing you, Anne and all your family a healthy, joyous Christmas and New Year.
Thanks so much. All the very best and happy holidays
What a lovely gift! Thank you Ian, for your teaching and generosity. I've learned so much from your wonderful videos. You've shown me a way to think about composition, and it helps a lot! I love your pencil drawings, I'll print and put them up on my inspiration wall. Have a great holiday ❤️😄
You're welcome. Thank you for the kind words. Happy holidays to you and your loved ones
Thank you so very much, sir, for all the hard work you put into this channel. I look forward to each and every new post 🤗! Thank you, also, for these fabulous drawings 🤩! They’ll soon be adorning my studio walls 😄. Merry Christmas to you and yours!
You're welcome. Thank you for the kind words. Happy holidays to you and your loved ones
Oh my what a lovely gift thank you. Thank you for your monthly video gifts all year as well! The best instruction on RUclips in my opinion. Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year! Wishing you health and may all your needs be supplied. God Bless
You're welcome. Thank you for the kind words. Happy holidays to you and your loved ones
Thank you very much Mr. Ian Roberts
Very moved by your kindness and generosity.
I wish you a very Merry Christmas for you and your family.🌟
See you very soon for the new year 2023 in drawing and color 🎨
Thanks so much. All the very best and happy holidays
Hello and thank you very much for your generosity, Jan, much appreciated. Your lessons mean a lot to me and give much support. Merry Christmas and Happy New Year.
Thanks so much. All the very best and happy holidays
Hi Ian, I have followed you for sometime and deeply appreciate what you share, as I have no access to English speaking teachers, here in Uruguay. Your gifts travel further and are more deeply felt than you will ever know.Thank you, thank you!
Thank you for the kind comment Sharon. That makes me very happy to hear. You're so welcome and all the best.
Thank you Ian! I wish you a happy Christmas celebration and a very good new year 2023. 😊
You as well Fernando
Ian, Merry Christmas to you and your wife! I'm now beginning a series from Tomales Bay and the northern part of the Point Reyes peninsula. Great shapes. 🙂
Hi Ralph, I love that neck of the woods. As you say, great shapes. Have a great time with that series. My very best wishes to you for 2023. A year in enthusiastic artistic expression. All the best.
Thank you so much! Love them and will certainly frame them. Happy Holiday to you and your wonderful artist wife.🥂
Thanks so much. All the very best and happy holidays
Thank you a Merry Christmas and a fantastic New Year 2023 for you and your family!
Same to you, Marc. Thank you
Thank you Ian, for the lovely gift. Best wishes for a wonderful holiday and happy 2023 to you and Ann.
You're very welcome. Happy holidays to you and your loved ones too, Joyce
Hello Ian, thank you so much for these prints of your marvellous sketches. I said to myself in your last video that I would pay for one of those (still would, wallet disagrees!). Thank you, have a safe, happy and joyful turn of the year. Regards, SN
You're welcome. Thank you for the kind words. Happy holidays to you and your loved ones
Bless your heart! So sweet of you. I really like your drawings. Have a wonderful Christmas and New Year. I'm in the UK and we've recently had a spell of snow, so it's out with the paints to take advantage (although too cold to paint outside). Might you ever consider doing a tutorial on snow painting? It's really interesting to attempt.
Hi Jonquil, I did a video on how to paint white (including snow) this time last year. ruclips.net/video/oe8x2jO3qnM/видео.html. I hope you enjoy it. All the very best and happy holidays
Merry Christmas Ian and thank you for the years of excellent instruction and inspiration. All the very best to YOU!!
Thanks so much. All the very best and happy holidays
And to you too Ian. I've had your Mastering Composition book for a long time. I keep going back to reread it. It's one book I'll always keep. I just received Authentic Creativity so I have some good holiday reading. Thank you for all your inspirational videos, books and tips. 🥂
You're welcome. Thank you for the kind words and I am delighted you like the books. Happy holidays to you and your loved ones
Thanks Ian! I have really enjoyed your videos, and learned so much from them. Merry Christmas and Happy New Year to you and your family.
Thanks so much. All the very best and happy holidays
Good morning. Thank you so much for the lovely gift! Wishing you and your loved ones a wonderful holiday season. 💗🙏🏻💗🙏🏻
You're welcome. Happy holidays to you and your loved ones
I am having difficulty in painting clouds.. Please consider making a video on painting clouds...
I made a video on how to paint clouds three years ago: ruclips.net/video/COqh39EyZQg/видео.html. Happy new year
Thank you very much for the generosity, for giving away this gift, and more importantly for sharing your information and experience with us. Happy holidays.
I am delighted you like the gift. Happy Holidays to you and your loved ones Fatima
Five months later … Thank you so much for the Christmas gifts and for your videos. You are a great teacher. Happy Memorial Day!!
ᴍᴇꜱꜱᴀɢᴇ ᴍᴇ ᴏɴ ᴛᴇʟᴇ-ɢʀᴀᴍ ᴡɪᴛʜ ᴛʜᴇ ᴜꜱᴇʀɴᴀᴍᴇ ᴀʙᴏᴠᴇ ᴏɴ ᴛᴇʟᴇ-ɢʀᴀᴍ ᴀᴘᴘ
Thank you very much! How kind! The videos are already so priceless and now we get a beautifulI gift to!
Let us all keep making paintings. The world needs nice things, now more than ever!
I wish you and your family all the best. And again, a big thank you for al the effort!
Warm greetings tot everyone!
You're welcome. Thank you for the inspiration words. Happy holidays to you and your loved ones
Merry Christmas to you and yours. Thank you 🙏 for your generous gift 🎁 and thank you for sharing your artistic talents 🎉🎉🎉 Here’s to new adventures with our art in 2023 👍
You're very welcome. Merry Christmas to you Diana. On to 2023!
What a lovely soul, thanks, Ian (my son's name is Ian after my great uncle) You have been a big part of my growth as a painter, and I have absolutely trashed your book, I mean it looks well-loved! Only a yrat old but looks five years old. You and Carlson, good stuff. Thank you and wishing you a stellar new year.
You're welcome. Thank you for the kind words and I am delighted you found the book so helpful. Happy holidays to you and your loved ones
Excellent, thank you so much Ian! Happy holidays to you and your loved ones! I truly hope it's a spectacular 2023!
You're very welcome. Happy holidays to you and your loved ones David
Hi Ian thanks for your generous gift and sharing with everyone, wishing everyone a very happy and peaceful Christmas God bless from the Midlands of Ireland, regards Noel
You're very welcome. Merry Christmas to you Noel
thank you very much for your gift. wish You and Your family Merry Christmas . you are wonderful Teacher who explains each and every thing in detail. and easy to understand. Thanks again for your wonderful videos. That will be continue.
Happy holidays to you and your loved ones. You're very welcome and thank you for the kind words Gopal
Thank you for such a lovely gift! Your channel is very inspirational and educational! You are truly appreciated! Wishing you and yours a Merry Christmas!
You're welcome. Happy holidays to you and your loved ones