Will China Collapse? Palki Sharma Explains

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 16 май 2024
  • Watch The Full Episode Here: • Palki Sharma Returns T...
    Check out BeerBiceps SkillHouse's Podcasting 101 Course - bbsh.io/podcasting-101
    Follow BeerBiceps SkillHouse's Social Media Handles:
    RUclips : / @beerbicepsskillhouse
    Instagram : / beerbiceps_skillhouse
    Website : bbsh.in/trsclips-launch-cpyt
    For any other queries EMAIL: support@beerbicepsskillhouse.com
    In case of any payment-related issues, kindly write to support@tagmango.com
    Check out my Mind Performance app: Level SuperMind
    Android - lvl.fit/androiddownload
    Ios - lvl.fit/iosdownload
    Join the Level Community Here:
    linktr.ee/levelsupermindcommu...
    ✅ Subscribe To Our Other RUclips Channels:-
    BeerBiceps (English Channel):
    / beerbicepsofficial
    Ranveer Allahbadia (Hindi Channel):
    / ranveerallahbadia
    TRS Clips हिंदी (Hindi Podcast Highlights):
    / @theranveershowhindi
    Best Of TRS :
    / @bestoftrs
    Best Of TRS Hindi :
    / @bestoftrshindi
    RAAAZ By BigBrainCo :
    / @raaazofficial
    RAAAZ Clips :
    / @raaazclips
    BigBrain Plus :
    / @bigbrain_plus
    Link to our blog: beerbiceps.com/
    Today, on The Ranveer Show, we welcome Palki Sharma Upadhyay. She is a journalist, Managing Editor, at Firstpost, and an award-winning Indian news anchor. She is someone who is extremely passionate about foreign affairs and aims to provide insightful analysis on the same. On this episode, she will delve into the current Geopolitics situation and will share her insightful views on it.
    In this podcast, we spoke about her work and her immense viewership, her learnings from the books she read, insights on the current geopolitical situation, the importance of Soft power in the world of Geopolitics, her experience in Israel during the war, women viewership of Geopolitics, about her oxford university speech and much more.
    This episode will reflect the real person behind Palki Sharma. We talked about every aspect of Geopolitics that, in my opinion, everyone should watch. I hope you will enjoy this episode and let us know your thoughts in the comments.
    #palkisharma #geopolitics
    --
    INSTAGRAM : @beerbiceps
    / beerbiceps
    FACEBOOK : @beerbiceps
    / beerbiceps
    TWITTER : @beerbicepsguy
    / beerbicepsguy
    WHATSAPP: BeerBiceps
    whatsapp.com/channel/0029VaA5...
    LINKEDIN : @beerbiceps
    / beerbiceps
    TELEGRAM: @beerbicepsguy
    t.me/beerbicepsguy
    SNAPCHAT: @beerbicepsguy
    ----------------------------------------------
    About :
    TRS Clips is a collection of SHORT CLIPS from The Ranveer Show podcast. Enjoy our latest knowledge-fueled videos from the BeerBiceps team. Every conversation on #TheRanveerShow is intellectual, deep & progressive. We cover everyone from entrepreneurs to Bollywood film stars to even athletes.
    Today, The Ranveer Show or TRS - Happiness Through Curiosity. A show where we host the world's greatest success stories and try digging out their secrets to success. Every conversation is an EXTREME learning experience for the viewer.

Комментарии • 593

  • @Sirrajj
    @Sirrajj 15 дней назад +44

    Seems like she's hoping for China's downfall so india could take advantage, but no country Prospers like that, we have not the half skilled workers, infrastructure or that many world level of educational institutions, our export capacity is very far from them so we should rather focus on our own development

    • @arijitnaskar8151
      @arijitnaskar8151 13 дней назад

      China will buy u one day don't worry..

    • @objectsmedia4523
      @objectsmedia4523 11 дней назад

      Korea and Japan are prime example of manufacturing hub. Both Korea and Japan became top economy by West, west builds a country and they skips to the next one. China was smart at that they used everything making China the only hub , but now Chinese goods are getting expensive... Time for the west to leave.

    • @zeetvisascam3443
      @zeetvisascam3443 8 дней назад +3

      Let them dream man

    • @Grace-gh3mw
      @Grace-gh3mw 7 дней назад +1

      No, china grew in a corrupt way so it will fall. And I don’t know why we have that much inferiority complex. We never see the progress we are making.

    • @zeetvisascam3443
      @zeetvisascam3443 7 дней назад +1

      @@Grace-gh3mw haha if you putting that way then named me any country is not corrupted!!?

  • @nmew6926
    @nmew6926 13 дней назад +31

    Palki and many Indians think that manufacturing industry is only about Iphone, Tesla assembly lines and Chips manufacturing. Has Palki visited the CANTON Fair. There were tens thousand different items on display. How many of them can India produce in a competitive way. Can India manufacture and export an item as simple as an umbrella at a competitive price.

    • @rajatsingh1375
      @rajatsingh1375 11 дней назад +3

      Certainly India can
      Soon we will dummy

    • @morningstararun6278
      @morningstararun6278 7 дней назад +1

      ​@@rajatsingh1375 Maybe an umbrella, but nothing more than that.

  • @kumarrohit7294
    @kumarrohit7294 22 дня назад +165

    Pandemic has been censored from her speech, now this comment may be censored as well

  • @Uawaw
    @Uawaw 10 дней назад +4

    Since last 5 years she has been saying china will collapse this year 😂😂😂😂

  • @Scythe6140
    @Scythe6140 22 дня назад +40

    pandemic is not a cuss word, so why is it censored?

    • @SparkNewsCorp
      @SparkNewsCorp 21 день назад +10

      RUclips will demonetize the video otherwise.

    • @Scythe6140
      @Scythe6140 21 день назад +21

      @@SparkNewsCorp wow it's so strange that we get censored for stating the actual truth. Freedom of expression I see 🙂

    • @jimkuan8493
      @jimkuan8493 21 день назад

      Because people know that was a Virus War waged between US and China. And India is the helpless bystander that relies on the West for protection.

    • @ashwin.unlead
      @ashwin.unlead 16 дней назад +4

      @@Scythe6140 YT censors so many normal words here

    • @user-cc5wz3te1w
      @user-cc5wz3te1w 13 дней назад +1

      china power

  • @arshad1647
    @arshad1647 17 дней назад +34

    We indians can only talk talk talk ill on china, while china is going some much ahead of us

    • @vaibhavrathi8624
      @vaibhavrathi8624 11 дней назад +1

      yeah, true

    • @user-kz5cw2gj3w
      @user-kz5cw2gj3w 9 дней назад

      How did the China miracle happen? They tore up all the old social contracts, belief systems and ways of doing business. Killed off the opium addicts. The went forward without looking back to their past identity. I don't see, I admit I am an outsider, India doing that, your country has one eye on the past while the other tries to focus on the future.

    • @Grace-gh3mw
      @Grace-gh3mw 7 дней назад

      Then you don’t know anything because India is really rising and china is really falling and it will be evident by 2050 but yes we do need good leadership like this one.

    • @Grace-gh3mw
      @Grace-gh3mw 7 дней назад

      We have so much inferiority complex I don’t know why.

    • @Purplepebbles.
      @Purplepebbles. 5 дней назад

      Yes it's the truth

  • @jliang70
    @jliang70 21 день назад +13

    So Palki's understanding of Deng Xiaoping's policy is only half glassful type, I mean like most of the western media or politicians think Deng if he is alive today he would not have responded to US trade war or tech war or any war, he would be just floating around and do nothing against the like of Trump or Biden. That is just one of the greatest mistake anyone could make of Deng. What Xi is doing right now is not different to what Deng would have done, you can see how tough Deng was when it came to China's negotiation with Britain, he wasn't giving away much to the British, his tough stand with the British was if you don't agree what he said then he will send in the PLA to retake HK through force. I think if you really want to understand China and also India you need to look at some of the study completed by Wen Tiejun, he actually understand the problem in India as well as China. Palki talk about China's problem but she does not understand the cause of the problem, for example problem with Evergrande, the real problem for Evergrande is actually Xi, Xi actually want to squeeze this bubble created by companies like Evergrande by reducing their ability to borrow money from Chinese banks, Xi never want the big four banks and the government to keep this sort of speculative real estate company keep making that real estate bubbles bigger and bigger, he is more in the mind of building an economy based on real productivity rather than real estate speculation building on massive borrowing. Xi himself did not pick a fight with the US, it was the US that started the trade war with China, Xi basically responded to the threat he was facing from the US, Xi did a great job in responding to trade war and also tech war, his policy largely expanded the supply chain in China, and the development in China's semiconductor industry is at a rapid pace considering one of Xi early goal in this sector was to secure China can be self reliant with matured semiconductor industry contrasting this to where India and also US is right now. It won't be a surprise in a decade that China will supply the chips for cheap. India thinks it is the leader of the global south but in the global south China is the country that has far greater influence and can do more for these countries than India. We can look at the aspect of trade and infrastructure building. In one way you can say the new infrastructures bring a new loan or higher level of debt but without it how does a country in Africa moving its produces and mineral out of the country and selling them on the world market

    • @Latika-ln1ee
      @Latika-ln1ee 20 дней назад

      If common people of the US do not like Trump they can vote him out..... but does common Ch*nese people have the power to throw out Xi from power within a month???......... This is exactly what she is telling.... The leaders either ding or xi are scared that that if they are thrown out by ordinary people then communists collapse and then china will fall, becos there is no another party.....

  • @vikeng21
    @vikeng21 21 день назад +27

    Talk talk talk that is the only thing these people do and see where China has progressed way ahead of them.

    • @L20241
      @L20241 20 дней назад +1

      These ppl? Shaddaplah

  • @Latika-ln1ee
    @Latika-ln1ee 19 дней назад +14

    Just a few decades back Chinese economy was 23rd rank in the world and Japanese economy was 2nd and everyone thought that Japan would overtaken the us..... Today chinese economy is 2nd and everyone thinks that china will overtake the us..... 😅😅😅😂😂😂

    • @tiaoyi-bx5yi
      @tiaoyi-bx5yi 18 дней назад +21

      The biggest difference is that Japan is a US military colony, and India is also a US military colony, but China is not.

    • @Gulfnas1
      @Gulfnas1 17 дней назад +5

      You can't put Japan and China together!!

    • @Latika-ln1ee
      @Latika-ln1ee 17 дней назад

      Yes, of course!!!.... We can't put Japan and China together.... Japan has US to back it + Japan has good relations with most of the world including US colony India and the West.... But China is all alone.... the moment China gets to the situation like Japan, the first countries to kick it will be the US, followed by US colonies in West and Asia, then the Muslim world will kick and finally the biggest kick will from from its so called brothers.... But most importantly, Japan and China are very different, if Japanese people are angry with their government they have options but China you know either its the angry people or the government which will win.... In case the angry people win then it will be disintegration with Chinese characteristics.....

    • @anilkumargupta8555
      @anilkumargupta8555 15 дней назад +6

      @@tiaoyi-bx5yi "India is also a US military colony"??? What are you smoking?

    • @tiaoyi-bx5yi
      @tiaoyi-bx5yi 15 дней назад +6

      @@anilkumargupta8555 The US military often enters India for exercises. And no sovereign country will allow the US military to enter. Can you deny that India is a military colony of the US military?

  • @catinbootsnow4267
    @catinbootsnow4267 17 дней назад +39

    When was the last time Palki Sharma visited China and talked with the ordinary people there - workers, farmers, students, teachers, officials and businessmen alike?

    • @kamandalamjalam1541
      @kamandalamjalam1541 17 дней назад +16

      She knows everything. Past, Present and the Future. She lived in every country and she talked with all cultures, all leaders, all students and every body on the earth.

    • @naturalselection1203
      @naturalselection1203 16 дней назад

      Nolki kurma is a western puppet.

    • @ashwin.unlead
      @ashwin.unlead 16 дней назад +9

      don't get triggered friend

    • @akashjatua8519
      @akashjatua8519 15 дней назад +2

      She just didn't have your number handy.. else she would have told you !!

    • @mhlsunil
      @mhlsunil 13 дней назад

      ​@@akashjatua8519 true 👍

  • @primal1233
    @primal1233 20 дней назад +33

    Palki is very honest. Every reporter and journalist should be like her

    • @gourighosh4167
      @gourighosh4167 20 дней назад +4

      For nieve !🤣😁😅

    • @bkaladhar7087
      @bkaladhar7087 18 дней назад

      US, India imposed illegal sanctions on China and blame Xi Jinping for that.

  • @angakaanx8967
    @angakaanx8967 17 дней назад +28

    She is 100% anti-china of India more than Indian army😂👍

    • @thetanobonano
      @thetanobonano 8 дней назад +1

      She’s Indiana, what do you expect?

  • @ay9523
    @ay9523 20 дней назад +74

    This lady single handedly destroying chinese propaganda 👍

    • @EMaestro-PLR
      @EMaestro-PLR 13 дней назад

      Are you sure? I have watched her from the days of Wion. She is an anti-Chinese propagandist who only focuses on bad mouthing china to distract attention. if China is bad, imagine India given the human right, hunger , rape issues. How well is India run compared to China? The result speaks for itself. Please spend time improving your own country rather than demonizing others. That will not improve your country's problem.s

    • @GTFO_0
      @GTFO_0 13 дней назад +19

      😂😂yeah yeah lmao whatever makes you happy

    • @prabhakararaoaravapalli9050
      @prabhakararaoaravapalli9050 13 дней назад +2

      Kudos to Palki ❤🎉

    • @zeetvisascam3443
      @zeetvisascam3443 8 дней назад +3

      India another win after 1962

    • @warnasamika
      @warnasamika 8 дней назад +1

      @@zeetvisascam3443😂😂😂 good one

  • @junaidt192
    @junaidt192 19 дней назад +8

    She is the biggest obstacle now of we Indians and the Chinese getting along well and mutually benefiting each other through trade and cultural exchanges..fear mongers like her always catch the imagination of people who need an enemy country to feel better about their own country... countries in the west have no issues with each other and we in the east are still stuck with the mess of having eternal conflict with each other..

    • @EMaestro-PLR
      @EMaestro-PLR 13 дней назад +2

      India needs more people like you, who are objective and not bias. Instead of learning from one another she prefers to badmouth the other party as though by doing that India's problem will be solved. Either is nationalistic but stupid or she is working for the CIA.

    • @hemantbavle920
      @hemantbavle920 11 дней назад

      You are very badly informed. War monger? It's China who has always started the problem.
      She is a realist. Western countries have enough problems..their media doesn't show it that's it.

  • @kolviczd6885
    @kolviczd6885 16 дней назад +6

    "If you want something done go to China, if you want something said go to US and partners".

  • @ananthan8951
    @ananthan8951 20 дней назад +70

    If the Chinese are super confident of their present and future, why do they flock to others' comment boxes to brag?

    • @peaceloverespect
      @peaceloverespect 19 дней назад +8

      It's simple, because there are too many Chinese people, there are always people who are interested in various relationships, and they don't like to avoid problems to cater to themselves or deceive themselves.
      In fact, I am not only paying attention to India, I am also paying attention to Pakistan, Nepal, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, and the Maldives.
      love from china(cn bot) jai hind!🤗

    • @catinbootsnow4267
      @catinbootsnow4267 17 дней назад +4

      For fun. 😊

    • @kamandalamjalam1541
      @kamandalamjalam1541 17 дней назад +8

      @manwan9370 Are you serious? Which country are you living on the Earth?? China's GDP is 6 times that of India. So when and how China admitted India is No.1? India's two main exporting industries are IT and Pharma. If China does not export API needed for Pharma, India's entire Pharma industry will be collapsed. If USA reduces the H1-Bs, most IT companies will loose big revenues. There are no other major export from India.

    • @jacksmith-mu3ee
      @jacksmith-mu3ee 16 дней назад +9

      😂India best achievements so far
      India's Hunger index
      2013: 63rd rank
      2022: 107th rank
      India's Happiness index.
      2013: 111th rank
      2022: 136th rank
      India's press freedom rank
      2013:79th
      2022: 150the the fourth pillar of worlds largest
      democracy is no more
      India's unemployment rate
      2013:4.9%
      2023:7.5%
      Unemployment rate never increase in growing
      economy.. india is growing only on paper and by
      loan
      India's Debt
      before 2014: ₹55 lakh crore
      2023: ₹155 lakh crore
      India's GDP from 2004 to 2014:
      $709 billion to 2.04 trilion (almost triple)
      India's GDP from 2014to 2024:
      $2.04 trillion to 3.6 trilion (expected)...not even
      double

    • @ashwin.unlead
      @ashwin.unlead 16 дней назад +1

      @@jacksmith-mu3ee GT FO no one asked to compare the 2 countries here

  • @countryboy9695
    @countryboy9695 21 день назад +30

    She is suffering from china phobia. India is far behind from china and china phobia won’t help to bridge the gap.

    • @riseshine7517
      @riseshine7517 21 день назад +2

      That's y it is better to avoid bat soup during meal in order to come out from India phobia😂

    • @hzhu12
      @hzhu12 13 дней назад +1

      like far far far behind lol

    • @vikramchauhan5283
      @vikramchauhan5283 5 дней назад

      Just like China has Taiwan phobia, dalai lama phobia

  • @bkb23plus
    @bkb23plus 22 дня назад +43

    Why beeping🤔 pandemic??

    • @gireeshkumar511
      @gireeshkumar511 20 дней назад

      RUclips remove the video, China has influence on RUclips

    • @thirunarayanan8326
      @thirunarayanan8326 20 дней назад +2

      wuhan pandermic

    • @vaibavrajasekar2412
      @vaibavrajasekar2412 19 дней назад +6

      RUclips demonetises creators when they say the word pandemic

    • @bkb23plus
      @bkb23plus 19 дней назад

      @@vaibavrajasekar2412 oh I see

    • @ayushgarg6069
      @ayushgarg6069 18 дней назад +2

      ​@@vaibavrajasekar2412 But why ?? Is sm owned by China now ??😢

  • @haroonarif9369
    @haroonarif9369 21 день назад +24

    Its clear ahe doesnt know a thing about politics she needs a promter

  • @boyzcook
    @boyzcook 21 день назад +22

    Focus on own Country's topics. Don't drive out Indian people to outside topic which won't help us in development of our country. Keep focusing on our own Country's development.

    • @Latika-ln1ee
      @Latika-ln1ee 20 дней назад +6

      Have you heard of the story of the rabbit and the tortoise.... In the end the tortoise wins..... only the final result matters, class tests don't matter..... The communists are stupid, you suffered so much.... Decades of hardworking, propoganda, loyalty to party, struggling.... But in the end everyone is making fun of you but your neighbour has become a major regional power...... there is so much freedom to choose any party and any leader.... If your most people don't want to be communists then do you have choise????.... No !!!!

    • @boyzcook
      @boyzcook 20 дней назад +6

      @@Latika-ln1ee First, I’d like to point out that your reply doesn't directly address my original comment. My main point was about focusing on our own country's development rather than being distracted by external topics. However, let me respond to your arguments.
      The story of the rabbit and the tortoise is often used to emphasize persistence, but in the real world, speed and adaptability are crucial. In practice, being slow often means being left behind.
      You mentioned that Chinese communists are "stupid" and that the Chinese people are suffering. Have you ever visited China or studied its development in-depth? It's important to understand a country beyond what we hear from potentially biased sources.
      India faces significant challenges, and sometimes the government diverts attention by creating negative propaganda about neighboring countries, including China. This can lead to misconceptions and a lack of focus on our own issues. You seem to have fallen into this trap.
      Regarding your point about freedom in India: while we do have the freedom to choose our leaders, this freedom is undermined if it doesn’t translate into tangible improvements in living conditions. Many parts of India still struggle with inadequate infrastructure, education, sanitation, and safety. It’s like having the freedom to choose any plate when there's no food to serve on it.
      As for China, you claim they lack choice and democracy. Yet, the Chinese government focuses on collective goals and development, which has lifted millions out of poverty and turned the country into a major global player. When the system is effectively driving development, constant changes in leadership, the freedom of choosing political parties and leaders may not be necessary.
      I hope this gives you a broader perspective. Let's focus on India’s growth and development rather than getting sidetracked by external issues.

    • @Latika-ln1ee
      @Latika-ln1ee 19 дней назад

      @@boyzcook till 1970 ind*an economy was larger than ch*na .... You can check in Google..... Ch*na opened up its market decades before ind*a.... But that's the mistake.... Ch*nese companies were not strong when China opened up, so Chinese companies had to copy to survive.... But when india opened up many years after china, indian companies were regional leaders and ind*an companies like Tata and Mahendra bought many western companies, and started to expand abroad.... See the motor bike market in africa, where indian motor bike companies have eaten the market of Chinese companies..... Ind*an companies no copying, they are regional giants and they are growing very fast abroad.... now india is further opening up but china is closing down, the base of Chinese companies is not strong, it depends on copying others.... 15 years back the gdp growth rate of India was 4% and China's was 12%, seven years back India's was 6% and China's was 6%, now India's is 7.6% and China's is 5%, it is projected that in next 5 years India's will be 8.5% but China's will be 4%.....

    • @Latika-ln1ee
      @Latika-ln1ee 19 дней назад

      @@boyzcook please let seek truth from facts!!!!.... This is a famous quote of Deng Xiaoping.... In 1970, India's economy was bigger than China.... Cheak out Google if you don't believe me.... Then why is Chinese economy bigger 2day????..... Story of rabbit and tortoise..... China opened up its economy before Chinese companies were strong, so western countries captured the whole chinese market, chinese companies has no choise but copy western countries to survive and export, the growth of china was actually the huge profits made by western countries in china.... but that was a huge mistake.... India opened up many years after china, when indian companies were regional powers, companies like Tata and mahindra then started acquiring western companies and expanding abroad.... The gdp rate of china 15 years back was 12% India's was 4%.... 7 years back China's was 6% and India's was also 6%.... Now China's is 5% India's is 7.6%.... projections are that in next 5 years China's is 4% and India's is 8.5% .... This is the fact!!!!......

    • @dilipdk17
      @dilipdk17 16 дней назад +5

      @@boyzcook Appreciate the time and effort you put in.

  • @yashsawalkar8493
    @yashsawalkar8493 20 дней назад +28

    Lol, her understating of China is Laughabale

    • @JhilmilBasu
      @JhilmilBasu 17 дней назад +5

      U explain then

    • @shrikanthkk89-home
      @shrikanthkk89-home 16 дней назад +1

      *laughable - at least use autocorrect
      And please enlighten the people by sharing your understanding of China.

    • @yashsawalkar8493
      @yashsawalkar8493 16 дней назад

      @@shrikanthkk89-home yeah whatever

    • @ashwin.unlead
      @ashwin.unlead 16 дней назад

      @@yashsawalkar8493 you are a clwn at best can't even explain then lectures other people.

    • @JusticeAboveAll-ro3sm
      @JusticeAboveAll-ro3sm 13 дней назад +3

      Yeah! Pappu is the correct guy to describe China, no? After all he did a party level MoU with CCP. You hope he continues the legacy of Nehru vis-a-vis China, no?

  • @edo_Gasper
    @edo_Gasper 16 дней назад +5

    bro, China is just a poor developing country from the third world, they have tons of problems. They will be always developing country. Bharat No.1!!

  • @vikramshetty5590
    @vikramshetty5590 22 дня назад +39

    Admire her honesty 👏

    • @kamandalamjalam1541
      @kamandalamjalam1541 21 день назад

      What honesty? Complete lies and unabated distortion of facts. Phalki claims all the countries that took loans from China are debt-trapped. The fact is most of the African countries are benefitted by the bullet trains, ports, high ways, hospitals and Govt offices built by China. They are not loans. They are partnerships. If any African Govt fails to pay the loans, its China that will loose as China cannot take the railways and trains back to their country.

    • @stephanmbenti2855
      @stephanmbenti2855 15 дней назад +1

      What honesty? The woman clearly hasn’t been to China and talked with the locals so how can she speak with certainty? She doesn’t like China it’s that simple.

    • @kamandalamjalam1541
      @kamandalamjalam1541 15 дней назад +2

      @@stephanmbenti2855 No, she has mystical powers. She can travel in Past and future. In her journey into the past, she saw how British looted India. She was there in 1857 and 1947 as well. She also travelled into the future and came back. You should not question her mystical powers.

    • @stephanmbenti2855
      @stephanmbenti2855 15 дней назад +1

      @@kamandalamjalam1541 you know what, your right I won’t ever again.

    • @EMaestro-PLR
      @EMaestro-PLR 13 дней назад

      @@kamandalamjalam1541 Yes, master. let's call her guru palki from now on..🤣

  • @aeratj5741
    @aeratj5741 21 день назад +15

    a news reader is pretending to b an expert on everything/

    • @JhilmilBasu
      @JhilmilBasu 17 дней назад +1

      And ur commenting pretending to know everything 😅

    • @arijitnaskar8151
      @arijitnaskar8151 13 дней назад +2

      U know it better it seems..please come to the limelight..we need folks like u..who knows the real thing..enlightened . 😂

    • @EMaestro-PLR
      @EMaestro-PLR 13 дней назад

      She claims to be a journalist when she is actually a propagandist. A journalist writes and report news without bias. This lady is using her exposure to cook up her own stories. Probably why she got sacked from wion earlier.

    • @aashishgautam7484
      @aashishgautam7484 13 дней назад

      😂

  • @nitishpanday4566
    @nitishpanday4566 21 день назад +15

    Holy shit, the Chinese pandemic word has been censored from her speech by the host

    • @hokroeger
      @hokroeger 21 день назад +4

      It's not a Chinese word.

    • @jimkuan8493
      @jimkuan8493 21 день назад

      Because people know that was a Virus War waged between US and China. And India is the helpless bystander that relies on the West for protection.

  • @CarsandBikes
    @CarsandBikes 19 дней назад +2

    I was born in Taipei. Living in an affluent area of Silicon Valley, CA. I split time between here and Shenzhen area, which I have a home as well. I really like the new infrastructure that was created in a very short amount of time. So yes, I like a nice clean place with good infrastructure from from Silicon Valley and China.

  • @drona8563
    @drona8563 22 дня назад +10

    Why was the word 'pandemic' censored?

    • @boomerang8909
      @boomerang8909 21 день назад +1

      Good catch, because anyone who tried to read her lips saw "pacific".

    • @jimkuan8493
      @jimkuan8493 21 день назад

      Because people know that was a Virus War waged between US and China. And India is the helpless bystander that relies on the West for protection.

  • @pushkarkhanal4340
    @pushkarkhanal4340 21 день назад +23

    How much anti-china you can be?
    Palki Sharma Upadhaya: Yes! 😂😂😂

    • @debasismohanty1952
      @debasismohanty1952 21 день назад +6

      She is a journalist not a geo political expert

    • @pushkarkhanal4340
      @pushkarkhanal4340 21 день назад +11

      @@debasismohanty1952 exactly! you spoke my mind. She is not a geo political expert. She is a china hawk. A journalist anguished in a Sinophobic bent. My dear friend, 🙂It's a no-brainer

    • @debasismohanty1952
      @debasismohanty1952 21 день назад +5

      @@pushkarkhanal4340 if ranveer want to talk about geo politics he should invite geo political experts not journalists

    • @gireeshkumar511
      @gireeshkumar511 20 дней назад +2

      She is not KhanGress Chemcha to support China😂😂

    • @GareebInsaan2020
      @GareebInsaan2020 20 дней назад +3

      ​@@pushkarkhanal4340Beggaristani 🇵🇰🤣

  • @gauravmishra5859
    @gauravmishra5859 14 дней назад

    Informative

  • @GareebInsaan2020
    @GareebInsaan2020 20 дней назад +18

    Whenever Palki is talking, China 🇨🇳 starts running scared 🤣

    • @weingkham4033
      @weingkham4033 19 дней назад +2

      China don't care about india....it is only indian who only talk about china....china competition is usa

  • @TheLakshmiKarthik
    @TheLakshmiKarthik 21 день назад +11

    Why can't one say "PANDEMIC" without big-brother's permission ?

    • @jimkuan8493
      @jimkuan8493 21 день назад

      Because people know that was a Viru War waged between US and China. And India is the helpless bystander that relies on the West for protection.

  • @llawliet7194
    @llawliet7194 20 дней назад +4

    RESPECT MA'AM ❤❤❤

  • @lachen7
    @lachen7 15 дней назад +2

    Palki was truly lost with that first question. Could never recover. A conceptual and philosophical question answered with a non answer. Not a single concept was seen in her "answer".

  • @adityadas8251
    @adityadas8251 21 день назад +14

    How come so many Chinese bots are spamming in comment section, isn't there ban on RUclips?

    • @vorlon81
      @vorlon81 20 дней назад +7

      Maybe learn something about the world , it is bigger than india.

    • @GareebInsaan2020
      @GareebInsaan2020 20 дней назад +5

      ​@@vorlon81Chinese bot triggered 🤣

    • @naturalselection1203
      @naturalselection1203 16 дней назад +1

      ​@@GareebInsaan2020Indian bot got no answer

    • @EMaestro-PLR
      @EMaestro-PLR 13 дней назад +2

      I thought all bots are created by indian software engineers?

    • @GareebInsaan2020
      @GareebInsaan2020 12 дней назад +1

      @@naturalselection1203 Beggaristani 🇵🇰 spotted 🤣

  • @Aggraganya
    @Aggraganya 18 дней назад +1

    Why is "pandemic" censored?

  • @vorlon81
    @vorlon81 20 дней назад +21

    Isnt She still at the Airport waiting for Elon Musk?

  • @higherbeingX
    @higherbeingX 21 день назад +3

    WTF..Why was the Pandemic word muted?

    • @jimkuan8493
      @jimkuan8493 21 день назад

      Because people know that was a Virus War waged between US and China. And India is the helpless bystander that relies on the West for protection.

  • @sirg7573
    @sirg7573 21 день назад +5

    Why did you beep "Pandemic"?

  • @ajaydeori8211
    @ajaydeori8211 16 дней назад +2

    Bhai india china gdp k upar bhi ek video banao😂😂😂

  • @tankarajsunuwar975
    @tankarajsunuwar975 22 дня назад +1

    Oooo..my god palki!😂
    Too mirchi.

  • @nmew6926
    @nmew6926 21 день назад +36

    India claimed to be a $3,75 Trillion economy.
    When China was a $3,75 Trillion economy, that was in 2007. At that time, all Chinese household have toilets and connected to sewage system. In 2007, all Chinese households have running water. All Chinese in 2007 don't live in slums. In 2007, China high speed rail was already a reality. By 2007, China had sent men in space several times already. In 2007 China was confident they can organize something great for the 2008 Olympics.
    Sorry Palki India today has none of these attributes. Modi and the BJP government are cooking their books to fool the Indian people for votes.

    • @yashas829
      @yashas829 21 день назад +1

      Bro 🫡

    • @sayandebnath2939
      @sayandebnath2939 21 день назад +4

      And what about the 7 years between 2007 and 2014 ? What did the then in power government do ? What developments did happen during that time. India as it was in 2007 has took a massive leap forward. We are far more confident, powerful, we have the ability to control world politics, our decision is valued. There are problems and there will be problems , no govt can eradicate each and every problems , even the chinese govt has abolished certain communities of their rights.

    • @bocro5699
      @bocro5699 21 день назад

      It‘s so sad.If inflation(5%/yr) is taken into account,India was a $1,20 Trillion economy,not $3,75🥲

    • @kamandalamjalam1541
      @kamandalamjalam1541 17 дней назад

      @@sayandebnath2939 Do you seriously believe that India has ability to control the World Politics? India's decisions are not valued anywhere except in Pakistan. Most people in developed nations, UK, USA, France, Germany, Aus, NZ, Canada do not even know the name of the Prime Minister of India. How come India can control them?

  • @deerajkv6858
    @deerajkv6858 21 день назад +1

    What understanding it is 😂😂😂

  • @geopoliticsfan
    @geopoliticsfan 22 дня назад +25

    I would like to make a request to Ranveer. that many Indian RUclipsrs have been to China, invite him to your podcast and ask him about China, he can tell you better about China.
    I recommend one indian RUclipsr. Pratikjain vlog

    • @locusstandi8329
      @locusstandi8329 22 дня назад +20

      LOL since when did Travel Vloggers become Geopolitical Analysts? And Palki has been to China in her professional capacity a number of times. She has spoken about on other podcasts.

    • @beautyofnepal8531
      @beautyofnepal8531 21 день назад

      Honestly she knows nothing , her news cutting n information is all from western propaganda channel .

    • @beautyofnepal8531
      @beautyofnepal8531 21 день назад +5

      How many chinese words does palki know ?

    • @user-yw4rx6kb3r
      @user-yw4rx6kb3r 21 день назад +2

      ​@@locusstandi8329 you do know she spends her time bashing china right? She a good source of information about china. Also, it seems she knows a lot about Chinese psychology.

    • @102679nc
      @102679nc 21 день назад

      Vloggers are not authority , they make money from their vlogs , they have bias too and they have to go back to china. Ask an Chinese American if they want to go back to china permanently answer is no.

  • @ricotheman8139
    @ricotheman8139 16 дней назад +6

    I start to liking Palki, she is such a China expert, oops, I meant China bashing expert😂😂. Every time she talks about China, I find it very entertaining, just like watching my 5 years old nephew talks about how he can fight a fire breathing dragon 😂😂😂

  • @saurabhdhingraa
    @saurabhdhingraa 11 дней назад

    in love with her voice.

  • @RichardBrett899
    @RichardBrett899 11 дней назад +1

    If Palki can really read into the thought of Xi Jinping, India would not be the way it is.

  • @braindeadcitizen4838
    @braindeadcitizen4838 7 дней назад

    Palki is the voice of India. She is here to tell all Chinese what Indians think of China.

  • @GameChanger-cr4hx
    @GameChanger-cr4hx 21 день назад +17

    Modi has arrested anyone opposing him ... these two clowns are still recovering from their colonial past.

    • @a.k.1960
      @a.k.1960 21 день назад

      There is no opposition left in China to arrest. All are already in jail or dead. Xi jinping the king.

    • @ananthan8951
      @ananthan8951 20 дней назад

      You are speaking of the Chinese leadership. Here we have a judiciary which is only too active.

  • @user-ue6ho9xo5f
    @user-ue6ho9xo5f 16 дней назад

    She is amazing ❤

  • @khagendradmagar
    @khagendradmagar 22 дня назад +11

    Ask about Modi too.

  • @Malodaiofficial
    @Malodaiofficial 9 дней назад

    Her ex boyfriend was Chinese, I feel her pain & frustration.

  • @directxxxx71
    @directxxxx71 20 дней назад +1

    我是來聽印度自媒體對中國中央新聞聯播主持人白姬的訪問😂😂😂

  • @TheTraveler2222
    @TheTraveler2222 21 день назад +7

    interviewing Palki Sharma about China???....lol 😂😂😂😂, you might as well ask Peter Zeihan!

  • @snitchdo3758
    @snitchdo3758 11 дней назад +1

    From this i knew She is just a student in international geopolitics 😂😂😂
    She has absolute knowledge deficiency

  • @elamaransivasamy5610
    @elamaransivasamy5610 20 дней назад

    🙏🏽

  • @user-hj4wp2lu9i
    @user-hj4wp2lu9i 4 дня назад

    看他们一本正经的讨论真是一种顶级享受🤣🤣

  • @frustratedperson2289
    @frustratedperson2289 10 дней назад +1

    Bro know his audience

  • @kumarp3515
    @kumarp3515 21 день назад +11

    Who else can speak about dark side of China other than Palki !!

    • @hokroeger
      @hokroeger 21 день назад +5

      She is MIke Pompeo's disciple: "We lied, we cheated, we stole"

    • @prajwal1341
      @prajwal1341 19 дней назад +1

      @@hokroeger wumao spotted

    • @kamandalamjalam1541
      @kamandalamjalam1541 17 дней назад +1

      As if there is no dark side in India...LOL..

    • @naturalselection1203
      @naturalselection1203 16 дней назад

      ​@@prajwal1341sangi sucked

    • @EMaestro-PLR
      @EMaestro-PLR 13 дней назад

      @@prajwal1341 Snake spotted.🤣

  • @polaris1985
    @polaris1985 21 день назад +10

    Women who has never been to China is suddenly an expert in this issue.

    • @strawmanfallacy8666
      @strawmanfallacy8666 13 дней назад +3

      She is a bigger expert than an armchair activist like you.

  • @peaceloverespect
    @peaceloverespect 21 день назад +30

    I am Chinese and I strongly disagree with what Palki Sharma said. When I was younger, I was an angry youth. I was not satisfied with the present, liked criticism, and longed for the United States and Japan.
    As I learn more and more, I realize that I am naive and cannot represent more Chinese people.
    Many people like to criticize China's system and do not understand the actual situation. China is not a dictatorship, but an authoritarian system. You do not understand the difference, nor do you understand the advantages, disadvantages and differences of various systems in the world, as well as the national conditions of each country.
    In terms of results, China has achieved the greatest degree of independence and eliminated the extreme poverty of hundreds of millions of people. I clearly know how the lives of my grandparents, my parents, and my family have changed since then.
    I do not deny that there are still various problems in China today, but there is no utopia. It is easy and cheap to criticize and find problems.If you really regard China as an opponent, you should understand your opponent. Just like I have received a lot of Western education, especially American Subject.

    • @pings007
      @pings007 21 день назад +8

      How can you defend Chinese occupation of Tibet, Hongkong and erasing their identity? How can tolerate tormenting people of other smaller nations?

    • @uniquerai
      @uniquerai 21 день назад +11

      @@pings007what about kashmir,nagaland,sikkim ,hydrabad😂😂

    • @peaceloverespect
      @peaceloverespect 21 день назад +11

      @@pings007 Just as I know how the West evaluates China, but do you know the history and discussion of China? You don't recognize that Tibet is Chinese, but why does your government recognize it?
      Don't try to argue with me if your level is too low.

    • @ajaykumarsingh702
      @ajaykumarsingh702 21 день назад

      ​​@@pings007
      Tibet and hongkong were and are Chinese territory to begin with.
      Africans don't live there.
      The Mongoloid race has been living there for thousands of years.

    • @MCR0709
      @MCR0709 21 день назад +2

      Chinese people want to be first in every sector so they prepare themselves a lot. Until they are prepared, the game has already been finished and the Chinese cannot showcase their expertise. New games start already in every sector so they went into silence mode to prepare for new games again. Because they have a phobia of defeat. 😂😂😂

  • @papi5377
    @papi5377 20 дней назад +3

    Indie dawno są skolonizowane przez Chiny.
    I słusznie.
    Matka Teresa leci z Watykanu do indi

    • @mohican6158
      @mohican6158 18 дней назад

      Brother , im glad there is someone who knows of the vatican

  • @stevencher9968
    @stevencher9968 20 дней назад +11

    She's a joke. Not only she's not a geopolitical analyst, neither is she a journalist (journalism is about the spirit of reporting the truth). All her comments are based on her bias assumptions about China. The CPC has 90% of the people support, that's according to Harvard university Ash center survey and other recognized institutions and she's painting the other extreme without substantiating.She talk about history when she doesn't know about how China's dispute on territorial issues with other countries came about. l'm not from China but from my understanding, China has every legitimate claim be it border dispute with india based on the unrecognized McMahon line,Diaoyu islands against Japan and SCS based on the Cairo and Portsdam declaration. About Taiwan, no country and nobody has the right to interfere, any external interference can mean declaration of war by separatism against the sovereignty of another country.

  • @99sacrifice
    @99sacrifice 21 день назад +4

    China spends on their security that is a good thing rather than spending outside country, they dont have riot like in India. Non of the big countries have good realionship with small neighbors. India doesn’t have it as well. Very biased opinion.

  • @Suindiakaro
    @Suindiakaro 4 дня назад

    He was too scared to say “equivalent of India’s Modi” 🤣🤣

  • @lifefun1987
    @lifefun1987 11 дней назад

    115 billion export. 20 billion import. 95 billion trade surplus.
    thank u india

  • @harshulmakkar4052
    @harshulmakkar4052 20 дней назад

    Why on earth the “pandemic” word is censored?

  • @deepakteja8231
    @deepakteja8231 5 дней назад

    I don’t think Palki has mentioned anything about economy! The question was about the leadership and his behavior! That is what Palki has shared! And she also said it’s her! Not from the vast political analysis!! Probably Ranveer should have asked in more different way, then probably it would be different! But most of the comments I read is comparing india and china! China is number one producer for the entire world for whatever any country needs! There is no second thought about that! Things you don’t imagine, china manufactures! That itself it tells you how far they are!

  • @dieanramlal8591
    @dieanramlal8591 21 день назад

    ❤❤❤

  • @arjikagupta8501
    @arjikagupta8501 5 дней назад

    In china there is no vini de poo cartoon bcz xi ji xing look like 😅😅😅

  • @iampawanmishraji
    @iampawanmishraji 12 дней назад +1

    Xi is not china Putin

  • @ShubhamSinghBelhari
    @ShubhamSinghBelhari 7 дней назад

    why beep on pandemic word?

  • @temjenimchen7925
    @temjenimchen7925 18 дней назад +1

    (A person who don't know how it works but confidently replies are called heroes to fools and stupid to wise.) Xi Jinping is Party's General Secretary not Chairman lol.

  • @Suhailvtlr
    @Suhailvtlr 21 день назад +2

    China now more powerful under him..China now send machinery America and india Also..then who win now America and china?

  • @shakthidharanp.v8030
    @shakthidharanp.v8030 21 день назад

    We want some body talk about how bring our world Swiss Bank money to our country

    • @a.k.1960
      @a.k.1960 21 день назад

      It is already there. Go and check your account.

  • @kapiljain7325
    @kapiljain7325 6 дней назад

    Palki sharma should take the litmus test, she can visit china rural and stay there for a month ...check the facilities talk to local people etc. And repeat the same in india

  • @tgyel6490
    @tgyel6490 21 день назад +3

    sometimes i wonder when news reporter becomes geopolitical comentator?

  • @TheSethuks1
    @TheSethuks1 9 дней назад

    last century?

  • @devatheshmirra8176
    @devatheshmirra8176 5 дней назад

    She is intelligently intimidating

  • @rkojhavlogs
    @rkojhavlogs 11 дней назад

    Why Pendemic word beeped ?

  • @abtahiabrarjawad1234
    @abtahiabrarjawad1234 9 дней назад

    Palki just showing how Indian wants everyone to think about china, deep down she also knows India doesn't stand a chance against china

  • @user-xl1wr9wm4f
    @user-xl1wr9wm4f 20 дней назад +6

    Anyone who has not worked with Xi & the Chinese party does not have the right to offer opinions, which are not based on facts & evidence.
    Secondly, anyone who is not an expert on chinese culture, growth & development should avoid making statements in the media.
    What a shame that some Indian media & journalists disregard the ethics of journalism & mass media.

  • @SantoshSharma-kq2xt
    @SantoshSharma-kq2xt 11 дней назад

    I don’t think that china is collapsing very soon, china can have a bad phases but collapse will not be so quick! If china collapse India will have some disruptions as well!

  • @MCR0709
    @MCR0709 21 день назад

    Palki Sharma next EAM of India, at least assistant EAM of Mr. JS.

  • @shakthidharanp.v8030
    @shakthidharanp.v8030 21 день назад +1

    I want her in government of india she is totally framed woman of correctness

  • @ankitsingh6120
    @ankitsingh6120 11 дней назад

    Haaa Kar lo

  • @Shreds1016
    @Shreds1016 18 дней назад

    She is awesome ❤🥰💪

    • @jacksmith-mu3ee
      @jacksmith-mu3ee 14 дней назад

      😂😂😂😂 good joke

    • @Shreds1016
      @Shreds1016 14 дней назад

      @@jacksmith-mu3ee Someone is jealous.

  • @shankarkerala
    @shankarkerala 21 день назад

    oh ok ok ok

  • @harshailani2042
    @harshailani2042 21 день назад

    Whenever i see him i see carry in him.

  • @vnair2333
    @vnair2333 12 дней назад +2

    why pandemic is beeped????????????????? now it seems something is fishy. i respect you work , but this not the way right way to conduct podcast.

  • @prabhakararaoaravapalli9050
    @prabhakararaoaravapalli9050 13 дней назад

    Palki is a very respectable and professional journalist !
    You may take her permission to call her didi.

  • @Latika-ln1ee
    @Latika-ln1ee 20 дней назад

    Palki madam is already a legend in journalism.... People of four continents know her and she has played a huge role to remould the perception of lawmakers in the US and Aussies towards Ch*na.... a master in the field of Geo-politics she has unmasked the true face of communist and their actual intention against the west....

    • @kamandalamjalam1541
      @kamandalamjalam1541 17 дней назад +2

      Are you mad? Do you exactly know what you are speaking/writing?? US and Aussies lawmakers listening to her?? What non-sense? I am an Indian lived for 30 years in India and living in UK/USA for the last 15 years. Nobody, except her RUclips subscribers know her name. Last time she came to Oxford Union, only some Pakistanis recognised her. She does not have any knowledge on any topic. She fumbles on every question in a 1-2-1 interview. She can only read the pre-prepared script given to her.

    • @Latika-ln1ee
      @Latika-ln1ee 16 дней назад

      @@kamandalamjalam1541 Dude the English that you speak.... I am more than convinced that indeed you are a resident of UK/USA🤣🤣😂😂 for more than one and a half decade😂😂🤣🤣🤣.... by the way let me present to you some tini-mini facts..... She is a renowned indian journalist having worked in Doordarshan, Hindustan Times, CNN-News 18, popular amongst indian diaspora... She also has 672K followers in Instagram and many of whom are reputed US and Aussies.... Its all in the open you can check it out.....

    • @Latika-ln1ee
      @Latika-ln1ee 16 дней назад

      Yes of course, from your English i am utterly convinced that you must be a resident of UK/USA for a decade and a half😂😂🤣🤣🤣..... The person you are mocking is but an award-winning indian journalist having worked with Doordarshan, Hindustan Times, CNN-NEWS 18.... A name common to indian diaspora.... The 672K followers that she has in Instagram has many reputed US and Aussies....👍👍

  • @niraulaj
    @niraulaj 21 день назад +4

    This young podcaster has sold his souls to power house like BJP. Feel sad for him. Wake up young man or be a history

    • @a.k.1960
      @a.k.1960 21 день назад

      Already China is history. No future.

  • @augustzhao1689
    @augustzhao1689 16 дней назад +2

    I don't know how much Chinese history you have read, yes, that is from someone who has never spent any significant time in China, and who does not speak Chinese or read Chinese... Self-claimed leader of Chinese knowledge. The quote you gave from Deng Xiao Ping, was wrong. Because the one who translated that quote was mistaken... all in all, you have no idea what you are talking about!

  • @Bharat108._
    @Bharat108._ 21 день назад +2

    Palki Sharma is Queen 👑

    • @vorlon81
      @vorlon81 20 дней назад +4

      Queen of Lies and Arrogance

    • @Bharat108._
      @Bharat108._ 20 дней назад

      @@vorlon81 cry more

    • @vorlon81
      @vorlon81 20 дней назад +2

      @@Bharat108._ Bhakt spotted 😂

  • @alextube2551
    @alextube2551 21 день назад +3

    talk is cheap, people need to be educated and work hard and slowly build up a country, no matter how much one wants to talk it up, it's a slow process that will take decades.

  • @boonswithbenedictions8468
    @boonswithbenedictions8468 11 дней назад +1

    omenn!! Tatha ashtu !!

  • @wdp7128
    @wdp7128 21 день назад +12

    Palki's take on BRI is incorrect.
    For better interpretation, watch BRI Institute / Sweden, and the analysis by professor Jeffrey Sachs.

    • @a.k.1960
      @a.k.1960 21 день назад

      Ask srilanka.

    • @jliang70
      @jliang70 21 день назад +4

      @@a.k.1960 OK, Sri Lanka, how much of Sri Lanka's debt were owed to China? Can you answer that one ? Should be very easy.

    • @a.k.1960
      @a.k.1960 21 день назад

      @@jliang70 more than half at abnormal interest rate and clauses which have collapsed Sri Lanka and China gobbled up the port. Horrible bully. China has become a big problem for the whole world.

    • @a.k.1960
      @a.k.1960 21 день назад

      @@jliang70 more than 50 percent of srilanka's debt is to China at abnormal interest rates and conditions. Bully China gobbled up Hambantota port.

    • @ananthan8951
      @ananthan8951 20 дней назад

      Sachs is Sino Russian spokesperson.

  • @gourighosh4167
    @gourighosh4167 21 день назад +5

    See, how clever we are ! If you are at the bottom no fear of fall ,may be one or two guys can step over you . But if you are at the hight you may have a fall ! She is living in her imaginary world .

    • @a.k.1960
      @a.k.1960 21 день назад +1

      That is the problem with China. Scared of their own people.

    • @gourighosh4167
      @gourighosh4167 21 день назад

      @@a.k.1960 not own people. CIA spends in billions to destroy any country who does not follow them or take orders. You are naive.

  • @abhimanyurai566
    @abhimanyurai566 17 дней назад +1

    Its either Bro or Mam 😀

  • @thianlangamkamei9497
    @thianlangamkamei9497 20 дней назад +8

    Palki i unsubscribe ur channel because there is lot of biased in ur reporting. U talk only about china that's is only from ur viewpoint, so sad.

    • @GareebInsaan2020
      @GareebInsaan2020 20 дней назад +3

      Your comment here proved again, she's absolutely 💯 right

    • @EMaestro-PLR
      @EMaestro-PLR 13 дней назад

      @@GareebInsaan2020 You have a strange logic. I never understand what an indian means when they start shaking their head.