People are devoted to their faith while being respectful to others, very refreshing to watch. Definitely not what the mainstream media portrays Iran as
You are not well right? If they chose to. you can be tortured, killed or simply executed. Becoming non-religious has the death penalty in the eyes of iranian government. They use rape and shooting ( specially girls) in the eye as a policy. In iran 70% of iranians hate islam .... the islamic clergy will be lynched when they get the chance. There are not street reporting.... it is all set in scene with people watching. The government is very flexible to get what they want lol their children are walking half nude in canada, us and uk . do these look natural to you? if in your country people were being interviewed would it look like this? Everybody ignores them..... look at something similar in turkey and you'll se the huge difference. Btw there is no such thing as mainstream media.... it is your media ...whatever the f you watch lol
@@KoroushRP where are the religious people? what % Btw in Iran you can't be secular....... go google what secular is. This is the biggest sin of all in the eyes of your leader ( ali the beggar)
same think brits think about Shakespeare..... they have read maybe 5 pages lol Use less drugs dude. Lucky you have someone here who knows half his work by heart..... he liked old men . big part of his work is about his lgbtqra+-STD+kmp lol But yes they are amongst maybe 10 best poets who wrote in persian ....not wanting to get into some weirdo's starting abou no he was afghan no tajik no whatever lol if any his name is the ROMAN lol
@@farsalami8605 let's talk about his name first. His simple and correct name is Jalaladdin Mohammad-e-Balkhi. in the Islamic history books his name is attested as "Muhammed Ibn Muhammed ibn Hosayn-e-Hosayni Khatibi-e-Bakri-e-Balkhi". During his own lifetime, he was known by titles such as "Jalaladdin"(the glory of religion), "Khodāvandegār"(The master, The lord) and "Khodāvandegār Molānā"(our master, The lord). Later on, he was given various titles such as "Molavi"(my master), "Molānā"(our master), "Molavi-e-Rumi"(my master The Roman. But by this time Molavi had turned into a special name for him alone and people would only think of him when the word Molavi was said, not the literal meaning). His pen name in some poems is "Khamush"(The silent). The reason why he's known as Rumi to non Muslim world is that he settled in the sultanate of Rum ruled by a branch of Seljuks. The translations of his works by Europeans gave him the name "Rumi" so that's what many know him as. Not his real name which is said above( most of Iranians call him Molānā though) well, It is a topic of much debate when it comes down to his relation with that Oldman you mentioned( his name is Shams-e-Tabrizi). The admirers of Rumi believe that his relation with Shams was very special and very abnormal because Shams( himself a man who had dedicated himself to god and got very close to the supreme being) caused Jalaladdin to truly come as close as he could to god and with aid of Shams he was able to experience the god in Metaphysical levels. They argue that it is stupid to think it was sexual relation between them while Jalaladdin's poems are all about the love of god and losing yourself in the way of god.
@@farsalami8605 Molānā spoke Persian as his mother tongue. A language that is the mother tongue of Persians and effectively makes him Persian. He was born in Balkh. A land which had been settled by Iranic peoples (Aryans of the Avesta) THOUSANDS of years even before him. Trying to identify him as belonging to modern day Iran or Afghanistan or whatever is just simply dumb. There were none of these back then. There was only Iran in its ancient form( called Ērānshahr by the Sasanians) and that Ērānshahr wasn't just today's Iran. It was all the Iranic peoples wether Persian, Parthian, Daylamite or etc. Therefore I simply consider him a man belonging to the whole iranic world that Modern Iran, Afghanistan and Tajikistan are equally a part of no matter what.
@@artinrahideh1229 what did i say and what have you a problem with? lol I actually only say undisputed facts... now youtube wants to ban me hahahaha in this case i don't care to infect a simple talk with all kind of people wanting to claim molana/ mevlana whatever. as he himself says. گفتم: ز کجایی تو؟ تسخر زد و گفت: ای جان نیمیم ز ترکستان نیمیم ز فرغانه نیمیم ز آب و گِل نیمیم ز جان و دل نیمیم لبِ دریا نیمی همه دُردانه گفتم که: رفیقی کن با من که منم خویشت گفتا که: بنشناسم من خویش ز بیگانه من بی‌دل و دستارم در خانهٔ خمّارم یک سینه سخن دارم هین شرح دهم یا نه؟ Should we really even waste time arguing what we should call him ...?!!
no iranian would say allah... even the religious few. Are you from the jihadi army? Your name seems so. Somehow many of you use this kind of names lol Hala bebinam mamanet raft poshteboon babam montazeresh bood lol Did you understand this? looool
@khalidarsalanbaibars2722 depends of what you call atheist. But i would say in cities most people don't identify as muslim or religious anymore. some regions are more conservative like the baloochs. But going so far to say this vast majority believe in nothing supernatural at all would go too far. But islamic religion has been executed lol in the last decades. Iranians know things about islam which others don't or don't care about. I think that there are still many who think there must be something but definitely not mohammad or quran. The older people may not care about religion in many cases, but still i find there is still some sorts of superstition. It is a reasonably complicated country lol
@@farsalami8605 to be honest i dont blame u after seeing the version of islam iranians have creates and their crazy rituals of humilating and harming themselvs and other strange believes
@khalidarsalanbaibars2722 Honestly not sure about atheism stats but faith in Islam has declined long time. Our history and civilization is ancient and our sense of spirituality, philosophy, art is far older before Islam from the Arabian peninsula. So some boldly declare atheist, some just spiritual but never pray, some converted to other religion, most like in the video don't take religion serious but we still stay culturally muslim. Let us be humans first.
Iran's religious history is very fascinating! The faith of the Prophet Zarathustra (peace be upon him) has a very close connection to all the Abrahamic religions. There were three Zoroastrians who came to greet the baby Jesus (peace be upon him). One of the most closest companions of Prophet Muhammad ﷺ was a Persian named Salman Farsi and the Grandson of Prophet Muhammad ﷺ Imam Hussain married the daughter of the Persian Zoroastrian King. Not to mention the great Zoroastrian King Cyrus who defeated the pagan king of Babylon and freed the Israelites. Iran has a Shrine dedicated to the Israelite Prophet Daniel (peace be upon him). The Prophet Abraham (peace be upon him) was originally from Iraq, a close neighbour of Iran and a land that was and is heavily influenced by Iran. It is very likely that Abraham, Zarathustra, Moses, Jesus and Muhammad (peace be upon them) all worshipped the same One True God.
Proud to be a muslim. I fell my allah all time and my allah help me all time. When i was in deportation for 2 years i all time pray to Allah. some time i though about suicide but Islam stop me and i realise the meaning that allah say that allah take exam those person which person he loves more. Like prophet got lots of exam.Alhamdulillah now i am so happy and my believe are more strong. Islam is one true religion ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
@@saintnevensky5512 i know what is true brother. I am a Muslim and i believe my religion by mu Heart and soul. But i respect all the religion i respect christianity. And as a Muslim i love prophet jesses.
@@tarinkhondakar1923 I prayed to Jesus and he healed me. I had twitching all over the body, I came to russia this year to study theology. I was not born Christian.
As a British Iranian born and raised in London and a practicing Muslim. I'm quite shocked by how apathetic some of these opinions are. I recommend they watch videos of interviews with Muslim converts. Islam from the point of view of western christian converts is quite fascinating. I wonder If these kids were raised here in the UK and suffered everything we suffered just to maintain their Deen, such as being forced to defend their faith from childhood in school, being probed about exactly why we do everything we do as Muslims, needing to be able to answer the hard questions when interrogated by Non-Muslims throughout our lives up into adulthood, perhaps then they wouldn't take their Deen for granted?
The problems isnt about islam, younger generation slightly shifting to more less conservative and secular society after anti hijab protests, anti government and anti islamic morality police protests, this is the years after those protests. Iranian heritage nationalism rising and younger generations barely take islam seriously anymore. Especially after the death of Mahsa Amini becoming the catalyst of "apathetism" Iran originally was secular nation before becoming islamic republic after revolutionary, when liberalism doesnt work, people change to conservatism. And now when conservatism doesnt work, people are attempting to shift back to liberalism again Now if theres someone to be considered that are more apathetic would be yourself.
Oh please tell Iranians who live under an autocracy more about your strife and struggles of being a Muslim in one of the most progressive nations on the planet. In fact, don't, go live in Iran and swap spots with someone that wants to leave. Be a true "Muslim"
🇷🇺☦🤝☪️🇵🇸🇮🇷Then you're not a true Persian. True Persians are God fearing Shia Muslims who are proud at their holy Ayatollahs and the Islamic Republic - the only true friends of Palestinians, who are on the front lines fighting against the evil Zionist entity! Long live the beloved Islamic Republic and their hard strict Shariah laws!!
@@EasternRomeOrthodoxy I am a Shiite, but the story is not what you think. The Iranian government distorts the Shiism for political reasons, and makes Shiites outside Iran loyal and slaves to it, and exposes them to danger.
@@EasternRomeOrthodoxy proud of islamic republic? So you are saying that as an iranian girl I should be proud of a regime that kills girls because they don't wear hijab?
There are people who think. Very great answers and critical . no doubt these people have great and ancient history . Very critical thinkers and answers seem real . progressive people
I’m Iranian, both of my parents are Iranian. I was born and raised in America and I think it’s so interesting to see other people’s views on religion. My dad was always pretty lax with religion and even allowed me to go to Christian church with my friends.
Spirituality is not the same as religion in Iran. Islam has significantly faded in Iran specially among the younger generation in recent years (an example is my own family where everyone has become atheists).
your family is not all iran people you hang out with those people that the reason this is your idea , my family also is religious thats another example that there are still many religious people
@@AA-jt6ec when i say that Islam has faded I don't mean that noone religious is left, but that many who were once religious are not anymore (including my family). I do agree I might be biased as I base my opinion on people I come in contact with, but their number is not 3-4 people. My extended family alone is like 40 people and they have their own families and friends they're in contact with (making a population of 150-200 people). I can see the religion (not spirituality) fading. I live in a relatively religious city and attended school where many were religious. I know 8 of my acquaintances from high school alone who used to wear chador and now don't even wear hijab. I walk in the street and can see how people dress has changed. All surveys done outside the country show a big shift in Iranians' religious beliefs. Of course they can't be generalized to all the population but they still show a lot.
Its the exact opposite for me, i was religious growing up, my family werent and only started to pray more recently, cover themself more recently. And i changed to becoming irreligious.
Almost all Iranians believe in God but the majority of those especially the youth under 35 they do do not have any faith in any religion but as their culture they respect Zoroastrianism.
@@ابنالعراق-ك4ه4ه Mind your own business, We do not need Iraqis opinion about our interests in religion or culture, We are not Arabs ! put your effort on improving your own culture if you have any.
Very interesting video, good questions answered by intelligent people, it tells you a lot about Iran. In my opinion t is good to be a moral person, with or without religion, but those who impose religious morals (and rules) on people are the real source of evil. Those people are often motivated by power and economic benefits, not only in Iran.
In Iran, no one imposes religious rules on people. This claim is ridiculous. No one can impose religious rules on others. In Iran, religious rules are propagated and the propagation of non-religious ideas is prohibited. But people are free.For example, women are free to choose their clothing, but you are not allowed to advertise not wearing the hijab. If you encourage others to be naked, you will be dealt with.
@@aiakbari1726 you're either very ignorant about what's happening in the country, or being paid by the Islamic Republic as part of their propaganda machine! Just take a look at the latest Hijab bill to understand how ridiculous your comment is!
yes it tells you that this was setup, intelligence guys were watching ( mostly the reporter is one we call the ...interrogator/journalists... go too far and you'll be raped in jail ( yeah they dont care they like boys more lol ). Yes they let you say something less than ideal once in a while....so retards think oh see ..it isn't that bad hahahahaha
@@Adam-326 he is a filth. they shoot girls in the eye ( girls ...young girls .... they gass school kids .... rape is seen as an punishment for young girls once it was because then they are whores and can't go to heaven... now it is just fun ) This filth gets blood money to come on youtube. In iran you need to spend money to break the filters to get on youtube lol This video is all setup... you can't walk around in iran with a camera and talk to people...in 10 minutes you'll be in jail....you might stay there for 10 years
Interesting...like any other societies , Iranian society has peaple with a lot of differences and similarities...but overall peaple here are committed to morals and have the love of imams❤ Have a nice day everybody
Their hearts are in the right place, but I believe due to the western soft war against faith some have stepped further from Islam. The enemies knew that they can’t defeat a nation with strong beliefs so they targeted that. You can tell from the way they talk they are respectful people and by sitting down and clarifying and answering some of their doubts or corrects some of the misinformation they can be guided to the path of Haq (truth). This is why our beloved Rahbar said “our Jabha (battlefield) today is Jihad Tabeen (Jihad of Clarification)”. I think this is highly important. Inshallah we see this youth learn more and become true Soldiers of Imam Al-Zaman(aj). All the love from the Hussaini Zainabi Nation of Bahrain. 🤍🇧🇭🇮🇷
No this is not the case with Persian People they hate Arabs with the core of their heart so they don't want to follow real Islam , actually they developed a New version of Islam Mostly they Worship Shrines and ask things from Shrines. They think real Islam would change their identity.
A warning for any non-native Farsi speakers/people who don’t speak Farsi: the English subtitles are misleading. They are exaggerated. The Arabic subtitles are more accurate, so if possible use those, but if not then just take the English translation with a grain of salt. And yes, I speak all three.
Azan, especially at Noon is a world class gift from Islamic tradition, so precious and timeless. And Moazen Ardabiliy is the best Azan I’ve ever hear. It deserves to be recorded as a timeless universal cultural heritage.
Azan is tune of death. Every morning in Iran , innocent prisoners execute by the sound of Azan. Those prisoners arrested because they shouted for justice. They shouted for shelter, food and freedom . We Iranian hate Azan.
Yes and everyone of them who says they don't like the Islamic government will go to jail. IRAN is becoming a big prison for anyone who thinks differently. They passed a law a few days ago that will put a woman in jail for up to 20 years if they don't wear hijab according to the government rules after so many warnings. Something that are allowed in most nob Shia countries. Iran is becoming another Afghanistan soon
@@48sufi not true, you go to jail if you destroy public property whilst demonstrating. Why don't you do the same interview in other middle eastern countries including Israel and see the governments response. None of the people in this video were prosecuted
@@48sufi In fact there have been strict laws for hejab in iran for four decades, but they are not implemented For example in the video you can clearly see women without islamic veils Only damage to government property and rioting are crimes and this is normal
Iranian culture and personal lifestyle is very religious orientated. The majority of Iranians indirectly believe in Islam,as they hold the belief of there being one God
Iranians are very perceptive as to where the world is going. They seem to identify materialism as the most popular aspiration much like the rest of the world.
Zarathushtra is a point of finding the truth for us. For example: I do not like Islam and I believe that Islam cannot be the religion of God. Because when the Muslims attacked Iran, they burned the works related to Zoroaster and other Iranian sources. If Muhammad was the prophet of God, he should have done something to prevent this crime against humanity. Because of this crime of Islam and Muslims, today we do not know a part of the history and science of our ancestors and this is a great loss for the world.
@@almodatheryasser6471 and some of them said no but the subtitles said yes. The thing is not all people have the balls to say what they believe in such matters.
If you talk to Iranians behind the camera, most of them say this famous sentence that "Iranians became Muslims by the force of the sword of the desert Arabs." Before Islam, Iranians were the first monotheists in the world and believed in God. Please read about the religion of Zoroastrianism, which is the first monotheistic religion and is much older than Christianity, Judaism, and Islam.
If you did not know... The "Jews" from Ezion-geber in the south-east of today's Egypt were captured by the Babylonians about 600 BCE and released by Kourosh/Cyrus-the-Great about 60 years later. Cyrus then moved the released people to Hebron in today's West Bank, a short distance away from Jerusalem. Only then the Torah ("five books of Moses") was written! Torah is the foundation book for the Jews, Christians and Mus1ims (qur-arn repeatedly refers to it). So, the Jews would have picked up monotheism while held captive in Babylon. In various archaeological finds it is evident that, prior to the Babylonian captivity, the Jewish heaven comprised of more persons than just the supreme God. For example, this God even had a wife!
They were forced to convert but still they carried the legacy of Islam and spread Islam accros the South Asia.. In short you are saying Iranian were stupid??
im behind the camera and iranian and say you are lieng iranian at that time were unhappy with their king and liked to become muslim you can not force anyone to believe something specially iranian cause as you see out language didnt change although they force to do it but people all believed in islam cause they loved prophet and islam not arab culture
With a natural process, our nation could have been something similar to Turkey in terms of religious beliefs, but due to the pressures of the religious government, this process has been accelerated and the society is strongly distancing itself from religion. However, it has been said even in our classical literature that the purpose of religion is spirituality, the manifestation of morality and justice, and reaching God, and those who are only stuck in the appearance of religion were called the قشری
Peaple giving you headache in this comment section because it wasn't what they wanted to see😂😂😂 And talking for millions of peaple because that's what they wished it to be....
Every soul has a moral obligation to strive for ultimate truth, and its a continuous journey, offcourse at age of 16 your view of this realm is different as one is just at the beginning of this journey as you move further and encounter harsh realities of life if you are keen observer your purpose of life changes. Being great admirer of science especially Astronomy, quantum physics, living things around me I am convinced that ultimate truth that there is some higher power which is unseen but it is there because thus universe is so intelligently designed how come it is possible that design is there but without designer if designer is there we have been created and we are concioince beings then there must be purpose of our creation, and creator has put this inherent tendency in every soul so someone is looking for it in the skies, some in idols, some in sciece but everyone is searching for it as I said it is a journey of individual soul which he or she has to do alone without any external pressure so in my iopinion it must be allowed the way nature itself has planned it. I ❤ Shia Islam because I found Hussain ibn e Ali in it
Salam 'alaykoum warahmatAllah. From your Shia Muslim brother in Indonesia 🇮🇩🇮🇷. Alhamdulillah, all praise be to Allah SWT alone. I'm so grateful for Allah SWT has guided me to the path of the true Islam (Shia Islam) at the age of 19 years old this year (2023). When God Almighty perfected the religion of Islam at the Ghadeer Khoum. The path that the Last Messenger and Prophet of God Muhammad RasoulAllah shalAllahu 'alayhi wa aalehi tell us to hold onto at the Ghadeer Khoum ( Quran al-Kareem and Ahlul Bayt صلوات الله عليهم جميعاً ).
متاسفانه شما به جای اینکه یک تصویر دقیق رو از جامعه حال ایران نشون بدید فارغ از هر سیاستی ، شما دارید بیشتر با ضربان حاکمیت جلو میرید و حتی در ویدیو های قبلی ما افراد بی حجاب رو نمی‌دیدیم . نمیدونم میخواید چی رو ثابت کنید اما در مناطق مذهبی بیشتر میرید تا اون چیزی که میخواید رو نشون بدید . لطفاً رسانه آزاد باشید ، نه دریچه‌ای از نگاه خودتون و حاکمیت .
ضربان حاکمیت چیه عزیز ما هم ایرانی هستیم و هیچ ارگان حکومتی هم عضو نیستیم و هم خودم هم خانوادمون عقایدمون مشابه همین افراد داخل ویدیو هست و تا هفتاد درصد مسلمان هستیم،نمیدونم شما چرا همه جا اصرار دارید که بگید همه بی دینن یا همه باید بی دین بشن ..شما به عقاید خودتون باشید ماهم به عقاید خودمون داخل این ویدیو هم افراد بی دین هم بودن و مسلمان هم بودند
@@AA-jt6ec خانم شما انگار تو جامعه و نسل جوان نیستین نه؟ بنده تو شهر قم زندگی میکنم قشنگ همه دارن بالا تا پایین اسلام رو فوش میدنن و مسخره، و جالبتر و شکه کننده تر اینکه با آگاهی هم اسلام رو رد میکنن
Oui l'identité de chaque être humain sur cette planète a des sources multiples qui n'ont rien à voir avec la religion . Et l'identité de chacun est très personnelle . Elle doit être respectée sans jugement . Pourquoi les oiseaux du ciel auraient plus de libertés que les êtres humains ? Le matérialisme n'est pas mauvais en soi : la corruption , l'intolérance , la violence sont pires que tout. Chaque être humain a un talent, des qualités : il a le droit de les exploiter librement. Pour moi, la richesse n'est pas un but ,ni la mode ,ni le luxe mais la fortune ,la vie luxueuse des autres si elles sont honnêtes ne me gênent pas du tout. Et la mode est un choix personnel que je respecte. Si on croit en Dieu alors : LA PAIX EST UN DON DE DIEU 🕊 ET ON DOIT LA PROTÉGER .
The Shia sect has made Islam (in general) weaker in Iran. Please don’t hate me but understand. I have cousins from both Sunni and Shia sides. The heavy importance of 12 infallible imams has led people away from Sunnah. After losing interest from Shia (like getting disgusted from self beating (yes it happens) or cursing/bad mouth about Sahabas, Shia not only lose interest in Shiasm but in Islam as a whole. Fun fact: Iran and its surrounding regions were once Sunni before Safavid Empire 😢
You know why Iranian become Shiia ?! Because Arabs were extreme and violent and uncivilized only reaction of Iranian was join the opposition of Khalifa in order to show their objection.
Hahahahahaha Have you forgotten that Sunni doctrine produced Al-Qaeda, ISIS, and global terrorism?!! Have you forgotten that Sunni terrorism blows up innocent people and that the last terrorist attack occurred in Iran about two months ago and caused the death of 100 people and the injury of 300 people?!! Do you think that ISIS and Al-Qaeda will make Sunnis proud of their religion?!! On the contrary, many Sunni peoples resort to atheism or non-religiousness, and some resort to Shiite Islam in large numbers, and millions of people have converted to Shiite Islam in Africa alone.
Hahahahahaha Have you forgotten that Sunni doctrine produced Al-Qaeda, ISIS, and global terrorism?!! Have you forgotten that Sunni terrorism blows up innocent people and that the last terrorist attack occurred in Iran about two months ago and caused the death of 100 people and the injury of 300 people?!! Do you think that ISIS and Al-Qaeda will make Sunnis proud of their religion?!! On the contrary, many Sunni peoples resort to atheism or non-religiousness, and some resort to Shiite Islam in large numbers, and millions of people have converted to Shiite Islam in Africa alone.
Hahahahahaha Have you forgotten that Sunni doctrine produced Al-Qaeda, ISIS, and global terrorism?!! Have you forgotten that Sunni terrorism blows up innocent people and that the last terrorist attack occurred in Iran about two months ago and caused the death of 100 people and the injury of 300 people?!! Do you think that ISIS and Al-Qaeda will make Sunnis proud of their religion?!! On the contrary, many Sunni peoples resort to atheism or non-religiousness, and some resort to Shiite Islam in large numbers, and millions of people have converted to Shiite Islam in Africa alone.
Hahahahahaha Have you forgotten that Sunni doctrine produced Al-Qaeda, ISIS, and global terrorism?!! Have you forgotten that Sunni terrorism blows up innocent people and that the last terrorist attack occurred in Iran about two months ago and caused the death of 100 people and the injury of 300 people?!!
Interesting question. I’ve seen quite a few Iranians say that most of the citizens have become disillusioned with Islam and generally don’t care for it or any other religion. How true is that, from your experience?
@@Adam-326 if that’s the case then yes. She says in Persian word by word “I belong to the religion-less Iranian majority” it’s a play of words on how they used to call non Muslim Iranian as “minorities”. And now The majority is non Muslim lol
@@Hermesborugerdian Fascinating. I’m planning on learning Farsi in the future, so it’s cool to see how Iranians think. Also, you’ve got a cool taste in music haha, די מגניב!
اسلام تنها ار چهل سال نیست تو ایران اسلام درتاریخ ما جاداره من افتخار میکنم که مسلمونم و واقعا از خدا میخوام این کسایی که چشمشون رو وحقیقت بستن رو باز کنه امیدوارم همه در سایه خداوند یگانه باشید
@@deadbeat5165 considering india's racial diversity, i dont meant "caucasian" as in white, european descent im referring to indo aryans people in general
شعب ايران مظلوم يعيش في فترة نفور من الدين بسبب سياسات الحكومة الشيعية. طبيعي غالبية الشعب يكره الدين و بسبب الاعلام المعادي للعرب بدأ الشعب بكراهية الدين الذي جاء عن طريق العرب. ما لا يعرفه اغلب الايرانيين لن اكثر فترة ذهبية عاشتها ايران هي الفترة المذهب السني في اول خمس قرون من دخول الاسلام و بعد استيلاد الصفويين علي ايران اصبح الدين في انحدار الي يومنا هذا ..
@@AA-jt6ecA country’s government can be bad and economy can be bad, but that shouldn’t impact someone’s faith in Allah. If you look at the people of Gaza, relatives dying, houses are destroyed, shortages of food and water, yet you would find their faith is very strong. Even the little children would say, “HasbanAllah wa ni’amal wakeel.”
یعنی بعضی جوابات کاملا بدون منطق بود، مثلا اینکه کار خوب کن ولی نماز نخوان، در حالی که باید هم کار خوب کن و هم نماز بخوان. مثلا یکی میگفت هم از مسلمان بودنم خوش هستم و هم نیستم، یعنی اوج بی منطقی (اگه خوش نیستی چرا هنوزم مسلمان موندی؟) جالبتر اینکه بعضی اسلام را آنگونه قبول داشتن که خودشان میخواستند، نه آنگونه که خداوند از آنها خواسته
Watch dr zakir naik, blogging theology, daniel haqiqatjou and btw secular iranians love israel u can see the surveys only the religious iranians like palestinians, if ur a muslim and human dont be distracted by fitnah online
Today, most Iranians, especially the youth, have become familiar with the fruits and results of religion that have been introduced to them, and this video is clearly an expression of those results. Due to the fact that history is considered a science and this science is growing with the advancement of technology, for less than 20 years, surprising facts about the lies of the history of the Islamic religion, which generally come from the historians of the Abbasid regime, have been revealed. In the meantime, especially the young people of Iran will gradually become familiar with these facts and the roots and foundations of this religion of Islam have been completely questioned. In this way, the people of Iran will revise the truth of their beliefs and this is just beginning. This issue promises a great intellectual revolution among Iranians. (It should be noted that all the things mentioned in this video as humanity and good morals actually arise from human conscience, which existed before religion, and even now, there is no need for religion for that human morality.)
not true though, in countries without religion you can see obvious absence of basic morality. Just look at western countries with high promiscuity, or countries like Japan where cheating is norm, or korea where too much emphasis on outward appearance.
As an Iranian, I tell you that your conclusion was wrong. Where did you get such a conclusion from this video? In which part of the video did he mention lies and distortions in religion? You cannot attribute your opinion to this video or the Iranian community. Even this video cannot express the opinion of all Iranian people.
This video was very biased about various issues and the questions were not attractive. Anyway, irreligious people can't talk much in Iran because it has serious consequences for them
@@aln339 If you pay attention, you will see that they talk very little, and in the clip, their way was not focused, and they did not say their words and reasons as much as the others, and they were on the sidelines of the clip.
@@whisperofthestorm6889 the thing is you are claiming Iran like some other countries in the region is a close country and you can not talk about your feelings about religion. People can easily talk about their feelings about religion, and no one will persecute them.
@@aln339 Those who are irreligious in Iran always exercise caution because there is a high possibility that they will be rejected or misrepresented. But the main issue about this clip was how purposefully and biased they talked about the issue of religion, and this issue was very clear in the movie, whether it was asking questions or focusing on the opinion of people who still had religion and ignoring the non-religious person compared to others.
@susanna9831 better to have enough brain and ability to think and respect science, the same science that made covid vaccines and saved lives, not a god that does nothing to save it's followers
@mohi6877 he did not oppose science he merely reminded you that being without an objective morality system makes you a joke and a literall menace to society, look up what Richard Dawkins says about r*pe being arbitrary on RUclips That is the pinaccle of being atheist/agnostic :)
at least you have a solid foundation of your belief, I'm half Iranian westerner I claim being muslim to be proud of my culture & ancestry. I'm personally more agnostic. What I dislike very much is Iranians or any middle easterners in general who are heritage nominal muslims but convert to Western Christianity and subscribe to white supremacism.
😂 you mean how indians are obssesed with looking?some bollywood actors can look iranian it's because they are cherry picked or actually have iranian/afghan blood. Don't want to be mean but not being comfortable with yourselves and denying your own people's appereance does not give you a nice look. I've seen many indians in india on daily basis and less than 1 percent of indians would actually look like iranians and usually those people do have iranic blood themselves.
@sunny-td7qg u must be high or something.. none of these people look like bollywood actors r u kidding me .. their faces and skin and bone structure are very indic regardless
every one knows that turks magically got the suuuper white skin of ancient slanted eyed turks(who weren't mixed up themselves at all😂) but also got completlyyy different faces througout the years they invaded west asia🤔like from mongol face to greek face kinda different😏 go get a life where you don't have to deny your ancesters or steal others cultures to feel validated you troll😂🤡
In general, the northern regions of Iran have whiter skin than the south and the Balochs, etc., but Iran is a colorful land, Iranian Turks are brown and white, etc., and they are diverse, we do not have these discussions in Iran.
As persian people we beleive in Allah , and a higher creator. But many of us reject or question the quran , and mohammad especially. Most of the younger people reject sharia. As persian people we unanimously beleive in one creator , that every religion worships in many ways. Many of us hold the shahnameh higher than the quran , and practice zorashtrian culture while remaining " cultural muslims". This interviews were a good enough representative of iran , however many more irreligious people exist , but probably avoided saying it on camera ( regime ) , however still 30% of persians are muslim. More than half are agnostic. Atheism is not very common , but agnostics are majority.
nah muslims are more than 50 percent, talking in behalf of everyone shows your ignorance , and also ferdowsi, poet of shahname was a shia muslim so its a silly thing to put that up of quran
@@KoroushRP do I need to remind you there are whole Iranian country side cultures with tribal backgrounds, that almost never had respect for Islam. Kurds, Lors and Torkmans are great examples
@@HermesborugerdianSome Kurds are more traditional than religious, however the majority are quite religious Sunnis, most Turkmen are much more conservative than the average Shias. Generally speaking the religious minorities in Iran are like most religious minorities anywhere, more religious than the average.
متاسفانه روی اعتقادات خیلی کم کار شده کتابای مربوط به اصول دین و حقیقت اسلام خیلی کم معرفی شده اون قسمت جذاب عقلانیت دین برای مردم گفته نشده پس برای همین جوانان مشکلات اعتقادی دارن
اتفاقا خیلی زیاد کار شده شما این فشار دینی رو که حکومت به مردم ورود میکنه رو در هیچ کجای دنیا بجز ایران نمیبینی. و بخاطر این زیادی کار شدنش ادم زده میشه ازش
Muslims are not the same. The muslims of eastern countries like Pakistan, Iran and India are more spiritual than religious per se. The Islamic revolution in Iran brought more doctrine and organization in that country. In middle eastern countries like Iraq, Syria and Jordan, the islam practiced there is much more in line with the local arab culture. Islam is truly an arab religion not always compatible with the local culture be it Pakistani, Indian or Iranian in the case of this video.
Wow! You just compared Pakistanis to Iranians in terms of religious beliefes :))) These two are exactly the opposite. Pakistanis are whatever Iranians aren't.
درود. متاسفانه این کلیپ از منطقه تقریباً مذهبی شهر تهیه شده و یک بانو با حجاب اختیاری در این کلیپ نیست. امروز چند درصد از بانوان ایران چادری هستند شاید کمتر از 10درصد ولی اونا را پررنگ جلوه میدهند...به امید رنسانس فکری در ایران و اندکی تفکر و تعقل
رنسانس در ایران نبوده که بخواهیم شبیه اش بشیم، تحولی فکری ایرانیان در منطقه خاورمیانه هم شکل گرفته با قدرتمند شدن در منطقه و اتحاد حول محور مقاومت صرف نظر از قوم و مذهب و نابودی و اخراج اشغالگران صهیونیست و ...
اتفاقا شما اصلا فکر نمیکنید و فکر میکنید همه مثل خودتون هستند . و البته این حرف شما که "هرکی حجاب داره زوریه و بی حجاب اختیاریه فقط "کاملا حرف خودخواهانه ایست و در جهت دیکته کردن عقیده خودتون به بقیه.. چون بسیاری از افراد با علاقه و بخاطر عقیدشون حجاب دارند و البته ده درصد نیستند حداقل 60 درصد ایرانیا مسلمان هستند حتی با حجاب کمتر من افراد اینگونه رو میشناسم که حتی حجاب نداره و حرم میره و نماز هم گاهی میخونه
حالت واقعا خوب نیست ۱۰ درصد ۴ نفر را میبینی ک تو صفحات اجتماعی یه چیز میگن زیاد تو چشم هستند برا همین ایجور فک میکنی،،،،،هیچ نباشه ۷۵ درصد تو شهر حجاب را دوست دارند،،،،هالا روستا ها خو ۱۰۰ درصد شون مذهبی هستند
@@shadabqureshi786according to gamaan, a non profit institute in the Netherlands, Iran is 40% muslim. They did a survey of 50,000 iranians. And after cleaning the survey as per pew research guildines, and after removing responses from iranians outside of iran (the diaspora, who almost all of which are non-believers) they were left with 39,000 responses in the report. This is a huge number for a poll btw, most polls done in other countries for similar stats have about 2000-3000 respondents max. If u look further into thr gamaan study u can see even out of the 40% that identified themselves as muslim, most of them are not very religious (for example much fewer than 40% believe in a heaven and hell, or jhinn). If Ur interested in reading more search GAMAAN, RELIGION STUDY and u can find it published online. The thing u have to note is that doing surveys in iran is notoriously almost impossible over the phone or in person. As these surveys are not anonymous, answering u r not muslim for 99% of the population categorized as muslim by the regime is punishable by death. Also to do an in person or phone survey in iran u must have permission from the regime by law, and u cannot make the survey anonymous (it must be supervised by the regime). So the gamaan study is the best study we have, not only by number of respondents, but also because it was done anonymously so people were not afraid to answer honestly. These figures are not hard to believe because even according to the regime jummah prayer attendance is at an all time low (this is something the regime is very scared about). This is coming from an Iranian diaspora. When I speak with my family in Iran they estimate no more than 60% of the population max wld categorize themselves as muslim. So if we assume that the gamaan study may have slightly undercounted the number, we can take halfway between 40% and 60%, which is 50%. Most of which again are not very religious. People in iran have been leaving islam in droves since the revolution. During the recent protests many thousands were doing quran burnings. Islam is not a religion made for iran, it is one made for 7th century arabs. Putting trust in this religion has brought nothing but hardship to my people. Islam regime propaganda is rampant, so be cautious about it. They have basiji bots all over social media that will make u think we r a very religious country, this is simply not true. Khomeini hijacked a revolution that was already happening and not for islamic reasons. My people will be freed soon, Iranshar!
این عدل که میگن توی اسلام هست منظور عدل خدا در خلقت هست نه این که همه چی عادلانه باشه. وگرنه خود اسلام اول از همه با تقسیم کافر و مسلمون و تفاوت حقوق اساسی عامل بی عدالتی بود.
How it's injustice of Division of Muslim vs Kaffir? God has created you but you stop believing it and deny your creator then such claim will already start dividing
تفاوت عدل و مساوات رو باید درک کنید مساوات یعنی با هر شخصی جدای از اینکه چیکار کرده به چی باور داره و کی هست یکسان برخورد کنی ولی عدل به این معنا نیست عدل یعنی با هرکسی بسته به اینکه چه چیزی باور داره چه کارایی انجام داده رفتار کنی و اگه رفتارش نادرسته مجازات اش کنی و طرد اش کنی فرقشون از زمین تا آسمونه
@@thehonestdude1067 هر چی که هست اینایی که میگفتن از اسلام عدالتش را دوست دارن متوجه نبودن که عدل منظور عدالت خدا در افرینشه نه مساوات به قول شما. در واقع در اسلام مساوات نیست اون عدل هم فقط منظور عدالت در افرینشه که اتفاقا عدالتی هم در افرینش نیست
@@hasinabegum1038 God is only one, From Adam to Abraham, From Noh to Joseph, From Jesus to Moses and Prophet Muhammad all of them preaches one God now God has many names but He is only one, So when you say if someone believe other than Allah if you mean by Hindus that they believe many God's or Christian they believed in 3 God then they are not adhering to truth or closing their eyes from truth... Human are smart how can God be more than one?
The Shia way brought them away from the real islam, unfortunately. Please try to understand the islam do not focus to much about shia nd Ali..... They specially the regime and society very bad marketing for islam, because how they do and believe is to be honest not islam.
It's Not About Shia or Sunni There is A Lot Of Shia Country Such as Yemen, Azerbaijan, Iraq Some Iranians Don't Like Islam Because Of Crimes of Omer , Osman and Abu baker in the Iran
Ask the same question in one of the other muslim countries, and 99% will answer alhamdulilah that he/her are Muslim. The people from ahle sunna don't have this kind of antipathy against there religion.
these types of questions should not be asked in iran as most ppl will not be able to actually freely express their opinions since they will be sent to jail or even executed so its quite biased.
They are openly saying what they want, there doesn't seem to be much distress about expressing their opinions. Try the same in many other countries in that region 😊
dont spread lies its not true, they are just talking about their religion , in many videos in iran a lot of people dont have hijab which is law of iran and they dont get sent to jail also many people insult leader of iran and nothing happens to them only if you are a famous guy that may happen to you
@@irani544 im also in iran and say you are lieng , it is not such law in iran that you have to be mulim ,only there is law of hijab about these things which if you are not a famous person mostly is not making any trouble for you these days
@@AA-jt6ec what the hell? Literally two people last year were hanged for what is called سب النبی. For instance if you say Muhammad was a pedophile and it gets enough attention and some basterd is too much of a basterd to report you for it you can easily get hanged. Bahaiis and convert Christians(not Armenians and Assyrians) are activelly persecuted. Are you kidding me? I don't care if you live in Iran or not. You can live in Iran and listen to Miley cyrus or Nickie Minage everyday and have no idea what's going on in your country. I'm guessing you're one of those people. Have fun living in your world of ignorance. I envy you people.
Muhammad claims that Jesus is a prophet before him! In order for a prophet to be identified, the previous prophets must prophesy him, and the person made the prophecies come true!And Jesus did it! But Muhammad's prophecy did not happen! So Muhammad is not a prophet and Islam is not God's religion and Allah is not God either!So only the Catholic Church tells you about the true God!
I don’t blame people for their apathetic view in religion. It is mainly the failures of Islamic scholars who couldn’t convey the true charm of islam to people. These people hadn’t seen the darkness and discrimnation when there’s not enough resources and people are not afraid of judgement day. If they had seen the Cruelty of desperate humans who aren’t afraid of laws, they would have appreciated islam more. You can see integrity and compassion of religious people amidst the darkness of desperation. Youths there don’t lack anything, they don’t feel insecure due to strict laws, yet they crave for limitless freedom... How laughable...
They seem spiritually liberal though outwardly looking fanatical. Once they followed the beautiful religion of Zarasthustra/Zoroaster before a foreign religion no matter how good was forced upon them. Essence of Zoroastrianism: Good thoughts, Good Words and Good Deeds. How beautiful! Now they know absolutely nothing about it! How sad!
2 minutes in And this Feels like a state Sponsored propagnada video. Which this whole channel probably is cause i didn't see any Relevant content about the protests.
@@sakinafatima Hum log yahan aksariyat mey nai is leye deen sey qareeb han, Ahlulbayt sey qareeb ha, Wahan wo log humesha aksariyat mey han ise leye wo mazhab par itna fakhar nai kartay, Ajj key irani khud ko Irani honay par fakhar kartay han na keh mazhabi honay par.. Rehbar e Muzam ko jis nigah sey hum dekhtay han wo log nai dekhtay wo aun ko aik hakim key tor par dekhtay han na keh mazhabi rehnuma key tor par
due to so many things in Iran we cant just get the real things out of most of people because there is always government there is always laws there is always so many things in Islamic countries which doesn't give the rights to people to tell what's their real opinion on things religion as Iranian i don't see people by the eye of religion because religion is a regional thing we don't know we are just small humans on a planets with too many stories if a god exist I don't think he would tell us to worship him and always telling him he is mighty and he is powerful because he already knows who he is I think we should care more about the our people and our future because I saw to many people used religions as a weapon in their hands to get power over others if a religion is real there should not be any force evolve in it to make the others accept that's the one who control past will control future we should take care of our children that's the governments guys religions extremists and other people doesn't corrupt them and at the end my opinion on religion i don't really believe in religions and prophets because im a human i have feeling i have common sense if someone have its own religion and doesn't bother me why it should be a problem for me but i saw many times mostly in Abrahamic religion that's there is no stop to bothering others because north west African didn't did anything to Muslims but they attacked them to spread religion same as Spanish people the people some of the Jews from start of history did made a lots of things harder for other people in lands or Arabia by having control over water and many many things happened by the churches in dark times in America and Europe
asking about iranian people’s beliefs and specifically about islam is ridiculous. the punishment for apostasy in iran is death. no one can say the truth
![تاریخ آذربایجان [آذری‌ها ترک بودند یا فارس؟]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/xK2VC1DY39w/mqdefault.jpg)
People are devoted to their faith while being respectful to others, very refreshing to watch. Definitely not what the mainstream media portrays Iran as
Exactly wallah!! God bless the iranian people❤
@@umeedecthere are lots of Iranian secular and religous muslims. Stop being butthurt
You are not well right? If they chose to. you can be tortured, killed or simply executed. Becoming non-religious has the death penalty in the eyes of iranian government. They use rape and shooting ( specially girls) in the eye as a policy.
In iran 70% of iranians hate islam .... the islamic clergy will be lynched when they get the chance.
There are not street reporting.... it is all set in scene with people watching.
The government is very flexible to get what they want lol their children are walking half nude in canada, us and uk .
do these look natural to you? if in your country people were being interviewed would it look like this? Everybody ignores them..... look at something similar in turkey and you'll se the huge difference.
Btw there is no such thing as mainstream media.... it is your media ...whatever the f you watch lol
@@KoroushRP where are the religious people? what %
Btw in Iran you can't be secular....... go google what secular is. This is the biggest sin of all in the eyes of your leader ( ali the beggar)
@@farsalami8605probably 20-30% are very religous, 20% agnostic and athiest, the rest in between
They are a very warm, sweet and cultured people.
Thanks, we are not Muslim and weren't at all , this channel conformation bias is out of my mind
It would be interesting to know what modern Iranians think about Rumi's works
Like they all read about it😂
same think brits think about Shakespeare..... they have read maybe 5 pages lol Use less drugs dude.
Lucky you have someone here who knows half his work by heart..... he liked old men . big part of his work is about his lgbtqra+-STD+kmp lol But yes they are amongst maybe 10 best poets who wrote in persian ....not wanting to get into some weirdo's starting abou no he was afghan no tajik no whatever lol if any his name is the ROMAN lol
@@farsalami8605 let's talk about his name first. His simple and correct name is Jalaladdin Mohammad-e-Balkhi. in the Islamic history books his name is attested as "Muhammed Ibn Muhammed ibn Hosayn-e-Hosayni Khatibi-e-Bakri-e-Balkhi". During his own lifetime, he was known by titles such as "Jalaladdin"(the glory of religion), "Khodāvandegār"(The master, The lord) and "Khodāvandegār Molānā"(our master, The lord). Later on, he was given various titles such as "Molavi"(my master), "Molānā"(our master), "Molavi-e-Rumi"(my master The Roman. But by this time Molavi had turned into a special name for him alone and people would only think of him when the word Molavi was said, not the literal meaning). His pen name in some poems is "Khamush"(The silent). The reason why he's known as Rumi to non Muslim world is that he settled in the sultanate of Rum ruled by a branch of Seljuks. The translations of his works by Europeans gave him the name "Rumi" so that's what many know him as. Not his real name which is said above( most of Iranians call him Molānā though)
well, It is a topic of much debate when it comes down to his relation with that Oldman you mentioned( his name is Shams-e-Tabrizi). The admirers of Rumi believe that his relation with Shams was very special and very abnormal because Shams( himself a man who had dedicated himself to god and got very close to the supreme being) caused Jalaladdin to truly come as close as he could to god and with aid of Shams he was able to experience the god in Metaphysical levels. They argue that it is stupid to think it was sexual relation between them while Jalaladdin's poems are all about the love of god and losing yourself in the way of god.
@@farsalami8605 Molānā spoke Persian as his mother tongue. A language that is the mother tongue of Persians and effectively makes him Persian. He was born in Balkh. A land which had been settled by Iranic peoples (Aryans of the Avesta) THOUSANDS of years even before him. Trying to identify him as belonging to modern day Iran or Afghanistan or whatever is just simply dumb. There were none of these back then. There was only Iran in its ancient form( called Ērānshahr by the Sasanians) and that Ērānshahr wasn't just today's Iran. It was all the Iranic peoples wether Persian, Parthian, Daylamite or etc.
Therefore I simply consider him a man belonging to the whole iranic world that Modern Iran, Afghanistan and Tajikistan are equally a part of no matter what.
@@artinrahideh1229 what did i say and what have you a problem with? lol
I actually only say undisputed facts... now youtube wants to ban me hahahaha
in this case i don't care to infect a simple talk with all kind of people wanting to claim molana/ mevlana whatever.
as he himself says.
گفتم: ز کجایی تو؟ تسخر زد و گفت: ای جان
نیمیم ز ترکستان نیمیم ز فرغانه
نیمیم ز آب و گِل نیمیم ز جان و دل
نیمیم لبِ دریا نیمی همه دُردانه
گفتم که: رفیقی کن با من که منم خویشت
گفتا که: بنشناسم من خویش ز بیگانه
من بی‌دل و دستارم در خانهٔ خمّارم
یک سینه سخن دارم هین شرح دهم یا نه؟
Should we really even waste time arguing what we should call him ...?!!
im iranian and muslim, like these people maybe my faith has became faded a little but i still believe in allah❣
no iranian would say allah... even the religious few. Are you from the jihadi army? Your name seems so. Somehow many of you use this kind of names lol Hala bebinam mamanet raft poshteboon babam montazeresh bood lol
Did you understand this? looool
@khalidarsalanbaibars2722 depends of what you call atheist. But i would say in cities most people don't identify as muslim or religious anymore. some regions are more conservative like the baloochs. But going so far to say this vast majority believe in nothing supernatural at all would go too far. But islamic religion has been executed lol in the last decades. Iranians know things about islam which others don't or don't care about. I think that there are still many who think there must be something but definitely not mohammad or quran. The older people may not care about religion in many cases, but still i find there is still some sorts of superstition.
It is a reasonably complicated country lol
@@farsalami8605 to be honest i dont blame u after seeing the version of islam iranians have creates and their crazy rituals of humilating and harming themselvs and other strange believes
Faded in what sense?
@khalidarsalanbaibars2722 Honestly not sure about atheism stats but faith in Islam has declined long time. Our history and civilization is ancient and our sense of spirituality, philosophy, art is far older before Islam from the Arabian peninsula. So some boldly declare atheist, some just spiritual but never pray, some converted to other religion, most like in the video don't take religion serious but we still stay culturally muslim. Let us be humans first.
Iran's religious history is very fascinating! The faith of the Prophet Zarathustra (peace be upon him) has a very close connection to all the Abrahamic religions. There were three Zoroastrians who came to greet the baby Jesus (peace be upon him). One of the most closest companions of Prophet Muhammad ﷺ was a Persian named Salman Farsi and the Grandson of Prophet Muhammad ﷺ Imam Hussain married the daughter of the Persian Zoroastrian King. Not to mention the great Zoroastrian King Cyrus who defeated the pagan king of Babylon and freed the Israelites. Iran has a Shrine dedicated to the Israelite Prophet Daniel (peace be upon him).
The Prophet Abraham (peace be upon him) was originally from Iraq, a close neighbour of Iran and a land that was and is heavily influenced by Iran. It is very likely that Abraham, Zarathustra, Moses, Jesus and Muhammad (peace be upon them) all worshipped the same One True God.
And it is very likely all of Abrahamic religion are copy paste of Mazdayasna
فکر کردم اینو خودم پست کردم
چقدر تفکراتمون شبیه همه برادر
Abrahamic religions copied Zoroastrians'
Zoroastrians believed in one GOD before the others I think. Anyway there is only one GOD and no One True GOD no matter what zealots say.
Well said my friend
Proud to be a muslim. I fell my allah all time and my allah help me all time. When i was in deportation for 2 years i all time pray to Allah. some time i though about suicide but Islam stop me and i realise the meaning that allah say that allah take exam those person which person he loves more. Like prophet got lots of exam.Alhamdulillah now i am so happy and my believe are more strong. Islam is one true religion ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
No, we follow the ONLY truth
☦️❤️❤️
I invite you too
@@saintnevensky5512 i know what is true brother. I am a Muslim and i believe my religion by mu Heart and soul. But i respect all the religion i respect christianity. And as a Muslim i love prophet jesses.
@@tarinkhondakar1923 I prayed to Jesus and he healed me. I had twitching all over the body, I came to russia this year to study theology.
I was not born Christian.
So you was muslim@@saintnevensky5512
@@saintnevensky5512soo what
As a British Iranian born and raised in London and a practicing Muslim. I'm quite shocked by how apathetic some of these opinions are. I recommend they watch videos of interviews with Muslim converts. Islam from the point of view of western christian converts is quite fascinating. I wonder If these kids were raised here in the UK and suffered everything we suffered just to maintain their Deen, such as being forced to defend their faith from childhood in school, being probed about exactly why we do everything we do as Muslims, needing to be able to answer the hard questions when interrogated by Non-Muslims throughout our lives up into adulthood, perhaps then they wouldn't take their Deen for granted?
The problems isnt about islam, younger generation slightly shifting to more less conservative and secular society after anti hijab protests, anti government and anti islamic morality police protests, this is the years after those protests. Iranian heritage nationalism rising and younger generations barely take islam seriously anymore. Especially after the death of Mahsa Amini becoming the catalyst of "apathetism"
Iran originally was secular nation before becoming islamic republic after revolutionary, when liberalism doesnt work, people change to conservatism. And now when conservatism doesnt work, people are attempting to shift back to liberalism again
Now if theres someone to be considered that are more apathetic would be yourself.
Get out of UK.
their own government dictatorship is the exact reason why they are becoming more apathetic to islam
Oh please tell Iranians who live under an autocracy more about your strife and struggles of being a Muslim in one of the most progressive nations on the planet. In fact, don't, go live in Iran and swap spots with someone that wants to leave. Be a true "Muslim"
Shut up english. You are 100% a spy from mi6.
Thanks alot for this video ❤
Amazing vídeo guys. Cheers from Brazil
As a Persian I believe religion is needed for a morally upright society so that it doesnt degenerate, but too much religion and forcing it isnt good.
🇷🇺☦🤝☪️🇵🇸🇮🇷Then you're not a true Persian. True Persians are God fearing Shia Muslims who are proud at their holy Ayatollahs and the Islamic Republic - the only true friends of Palestinians, who are on the front lines fighting against the evil Zionist entity! Long live the beloved Islamic Republic and their hard strict Shariah laws!!
@@EasternRomeOrthodoxy
I am a Shiite, but the story is not what you think. The Iranian government distorts the Shiism for political reasons, and makes Shiites outside Iran loyal and slaves to it, and exposes them to danger.
@@EasternRomeOrthodoxy proud of islamic republic? So you are saying that as an iranian girl I should be proud of a regime that kills girls because they don't wear hijab?
Then why are the best countries least religious? Iceland is least religious. East Asia and China is a million times better than India etc
Agreed
The girl at 15:03 is so pretty and her voice and way of speaking is also beautiful!
There are people who think. Very great answers and critical . no doubt these people have great and ancient history . Very critical thinkers and answers seem real . progressive people
I’m Iranian, both of my parents are Iranian. I was born and raised in America and I think it’s so interesting to see other people’s views on religion. My dad was always pretty lax with religion and even allowed me to go to Christian church with my friends.
Most people in Iran are afraid to say that they don’t believe, because being non-Muslim is punishable by law in Iran
its not like this, mostly love Islam so much. Those who are away from Islam is bcz of western propaganda. My Islam was, is and will always be great 😊❤
@@myounas4456Are u an Iranian?
Right ❤
@@jawabesikhwa4830no he is not that's he can't speak Persian & talking rubbish in English
@@abhiksarkar3829 How do u know she isn't an Iranian? The first person is also speaking in English does it means he is also not iranian?
I think you will get a very different set of responses if you carried these interviews out in Mashad or Qom...
I wish there were more such people in this world...
Spirituality is not the same as religion in Iran. Islam has significantly faded in Iran specially among the younger generation in recent years (an example is my own family where everyone has become atheists).
your family is not all iran people you hang out with those people that the reason this is your idea , my family also is religious thats another example that there are still many religious people
@@AA-jt6ec when i say that Islam has faded I don't mean that noone religious is left, but that many who were once religious are not anymore (including my family).
I do agree I might be biased as I base my opinion on people I come in contact with, but their number is not 3-4 people. My extended family alone is like 40 people and they have their own families and friends they're in contact with (making a population of 150-200 people). I can see the religion (not spirituality) fading. I live in a relatively religious city and attended school where many were religious. I know 8 of my acquaintances from high school alone who used to wear chador and now don't even wear hijab. I walk in the street and can see how people dress has changed. All surveys done outside the country show a big shift in Iranians' religious beliefs. Of course they can't be generalized to all the population but they still show a lot.
Its the exact opposite for me, i was religious growing up, my family werent and only started to pray more recently, cover themself more recently. And i changed to becoming irreligious.
If I really have to leave Islam then I will choose Christianity over atheism.
@@khanbro6455would you be a Unitarian?
Love and respect to ksa 🇸🇦🇦🇪🇲🇦🇧🇭🇰🇼
Almost all Iranians believe in God but the majority of those especially the youth under 35 they do do not have any faith in any religion but as their culture they respect Zoroastrianism.
Speaking in the language of the common people and the majority as if you know what is in the hearts of Iranians indicates your ignorance
@@ابنالعراق-ك4ه4ه Mind your own business, We do not need Iraqis opinion about our interests in religion or culture, We are not Arabs ! put your effort on improving your own culture if you have any.
how do you calculate these stats lol, its false still many people believe in islam and religioun
You didnt watch the video at all. Even the ones who said they don't believe ALL said in one way or anoyher that the Quran is truth.
@@ابنالعراق-ك4ه4ه You are true Muslim and I can tell that just by reading your bullshits
The captions are difficult to read
Is it the font or color or duration?
The color of the font
🙏
Very interesting video, good questions answered by intelligent people, it tells you a lot about Iran. In my opinion t is good to be a moral person, with or without religion, but those who impose religious morals (and rules) on people are the real source of evil. Those people are often motivated by power and economic benefits, not only in Iran.
In Iran, no one imposes religious rules on people. This claim is ridiculous. No one can impose religious rules on others. In Iran, religious rules are propagated and the propagation of non-religious ideas is prohibited. But people are free.For example, women are free to choose their clothing, but you are not allowed to advertise not wearing the hijab. If you encourage others to be naked, you will be dealt with.
@@aiakbari1726 That just sounds like the imposition of religious rules on other people, with extra steps.
@@aiakbari1726 you're either very ignorant about what's happening in the country, or being paid by the Islamic Republic as part of their propaganda machine! Just take a look at the latest Hijab bill to understand how ridiculous your comment is!
yes it tells you that this was setup, intelligence guys were watching ( mostly the reporter is one we call the ...interrogator/journalists... go too far and you'll be raped in jail ( yeah they dont care they like boys more lol ). Yes they let you say something less than ideal once in a while....so retards think oh see ..it isn't that bad hahahahaha
@@Adam-326 he is a filth. they shoot girls in the eye ( girls ...young girls .... they gass school kids .... rape is seen as an punishment for young girls once it was because then they are whores and can't go to heaven... now it is just fun )
This filth gets blood money to come on youtube. In iran you need to spend money to break the filters to get on youtube lol
This video is all setup... you can't walk around in iran with a camera and talk to people...in 10 minutes you'll be in jail....you might stay there for 10 years
Interesting...like any other societies , Iranian society has peaple with a lot of differences and similarities...but overall peaple here are committed to morals and have the love of imams❤
Have a nice day everybody
Their hearts are in the right place, but I believe due to the western soft war against faith some have stepped further from Islam. The enemies knew that they can’t defeat a nation with strong beliefs so they targeted that.
You can tell from the way they talk they are respectful people and by sitting down and clarifying and answering some of their doubts or corrects some of the misinformation they can be guided to the path of Haq (truth). This is why our beloved Rahbar said “our Jabha (battlefield) today is Jihad Tabeen (Jihad of Clarification)”. I think this is highly important.
Inshallah we see this youth learn more and become true Soldiers of Imam Al-Zaman(aj).
All the love from the Hussaini Zainabi Nation of Bahrain. 🤍🇧🇭🇮🇷
I agree.
It's the evil western sanctions that have made Iranians slightly hopeless of Islam when in reality it's the west causing problems
No this is not the case with Persian People they hate Arabs with the core of their heart so they don't want to follow real Islam , actually they developed a New version of Islam Mostly they Worship Shrines and ask things from Shrines. They think real Islam would change their identity.
A warning for any non-native Farsi speakers/people who don’t speak Farsi: the English subtitles are misleading. They are exaggerated. The Arabic subtitles are more accurate, so if possible use those, but if not then just take the English translation with a grain of salt. And yes, I speak all three.
Azan, especially at Noon is a world class gift from Islamic tradition, so precious and timeless. And Moazen Ardabiliy is the best Azan I’ve ever hear. It deserves to be recorded as a timeless universal cultural heritage.
Unfortunately you cannot hear it in Iran.
Azan is tune of death. Every morning in Iran , innocent prisoners execute by the sound of Azan. Those prisoners arrested because they shouted for justice. They shouted for shelter, food and freedom . We Iranian hate Azan.
Don’t be silly
چرت نگو در ایران آ زاد این صداها جمع خواهد شد
@@elestrylbut why...??
Also the ritual of washing hands and face before prayer (Wozo) is an interesting refreshing Islamic tradition. @@skybarhi8340
nice
قشنگ مردم رو گلچین کردی و مصاحبه کردیا🤣
حداقل یکیشونو برای اینکه بقیه شک نکنن درست میاوردی
Ex Muslim atheist from Sri Lanka
Hi to Ex Muslim from Ex Muslim.😅
@@securityoffers hi to you people from ex
Human
@@securityoffers hello
Thats y ur country striggles to the core bca no brain
@@ahteshamahmed4316Dear human is a species you can't change it overnight like religion. Religion is just a name.
I’m iranian and 100% atheistic
I’m iranian and 100% agnostic
Im tehrani and im Christian
im iranian and muslim
Alhamdulilah Muslim!!!!!
I am muslim always because Allah said in Quran proud to be muslim.
I'm an Iranian and I'm ex-muslim. I don't believe in any religion but I am Zoroastrian in my heart
@72_hoor_dallah HE IS HINDU FROM INDIA NOT IRAN JUST FOR LIKE 😂😂😂
95% ARE SHIA MUSLIM
@72_hoor_dallah DO YOU KNOW WHO I AM ??
@72_hoor_dallahbro didnt watch the video
@@HASHASHIN786 crushed india? More like one province(punjab)
@@shahanshahpolonium READ HISTORY OF INDO PERSIAN AND NADAR SHAH INVATION OF MUGHAL INDIA ❤🩹
Make video on do you like Islamic Govt vs Non Islamic
Yes and everyone of them who says they don't like the Islamic government will go to jail. IRAN is becoming a big prison for anyone who thinks differently. They passed a law a few days ago that will put a woman in jail for up to 20 years if they don't wear hijab according to the government rules after so many warnings. Something that are allowed in most nob Shia countries. Iran is becoming another Afghanistan soon
@@48sufi not true, you go to jail if you destroy public property whilst demonstrating. Why don't you do the same interview in other middle eastern countries including Israel and see the governments response. None of the people in this video were prosecuted
as a persian muslim all i want is a secular govt who values freedom
@@shadowgod1797values nationalism and secular laws* not freedumbs
@@48sufi In fact there have been strict laws for hejab in iran for four decades, but they are not implemented
For example in the video you can clearly see women without islamic veils
Only damage to government property and rioting are crimes and this is normal
Iranian culture and personal lifestyle is very religious orientated. The majority of Iranians indirectly believe in Islam,as they hold the belief of there being one God
Islam is not rafidhi heresy
Iranians are very perceptive as to where the world is going. They seem to identify materialism as the most popular aspiration much like the rest of the world.
especially persian girls.
I am curious about how Iranians feel about Zoroastrianism.
Identity
Its a cultural identity for most of us Persians, even if muslim
Zarathushtra is a point of finding the truth for us. For example:
I do not like Islam and I believe that Islam cannot be the religion of God. Because when the Muslims attacked Iran, they burned the works related to Zoroaster and other Iranian sources. If Muhammad was the prophet of God, he should have done something to prevent this crime against humanity. Because of this crime of Islam and Muslims, today we do not know a part of the history and science of our ancestors and this is a great loss for the world.
@@aminniku6898 mohamed was dead then
RESPECT
Imagine asking people in Iran wether they're muslim or not and expecting them to say no😂
Well some of them said no so ...
@@almodatheryasser6471 and some of them said no but the subtitles said yes. The thing is not all people have the balls to say what they believe in such matters.
@@irani544 Bale means yes. Most of them said yes.
@@blackflag6976 Naaaahhhh
You joking man right?😃
As a tehrani my self, im Christian ha.
Is RUclips banned in Iran?
Yes
IRGC and mullahs are restricting every international media in Iran in order to prevent people from accessing free flow of information
@@OshinAttari vpn bro for safety
@@JamesAlisdont call me bro i laugh at you
Yes but everyone can access by using VPN
با احترام ،اصلا ترجمه انگلیسی قابل اعتماد و درست و کامل نیست.
قبول دارم
کانال تحت حمایت ارتش سایبری یا موسسات آخوندیه
ویدیو رو کامل ندیدم ولی واقعا کارشون خوبه بعضی وقتا نیازی نیست که همه واژه هارو ترجمه کردو نوشت
معنی جمله رو کامل میرسونن و چیزی رو جا ننداختن
حق میگی حاجی
If you talk to Iranians behind the camera, most of them say this famous sentence that "Iranians became Muslims by the force of the sword of the desert Arabs." Before Islam, Iranians were the first monotheists in the world and believed in God. Please read about the religion of Zoroastrianism, which is the first monotheistic religion and is much older than Christianity, Judaism, and Islam.
But still it's suddenly happening
Like they don't know that in 1500s ?
So why at that time they changed their religion
If you did not know...
The "Jews" from Ezion-geber in the south-east of today's Egypt were captured by the Babylonians about 600 BCE and released by Kourosh/Cyrus-the-Great about 60 years later.
Cyrus then moved the released people to Hebron in today's West Bank, a short distance away from Jerusalem.
Only then the Torah ("five books of Moses") was written! Torah is the foundation book for the Jews, Christians and Mus1ims (qur-arn repeatedly refers to it).
So, the Jews would have picked up monotheism while held captive in Babylon.
In various archaeological finds it is evident that, prior to the Babylonian captivity, the Jewish heaven comprised of more persons than just the supreme God. For example, this God even had a wife!
It didn't happen by force. Iran became majority Muslim only 300 years after the conquest
They were forced to convert but still they carried the legacy of Islam and spread Islam accros the South Asia.. In short you are saying Iranian were stupid??
im behind the camera and iranian and say you are lieng iranian at that time were unhappy with their king and liked to become muslim you can not force anyone to believe something specially iranian cause as you see out language didnt change although they force to do it but people all believed in islam cause they loved prophet and islam not arab culture
With a natural process, our nation could have been something similar to Turkey in terms of religious beliefs, but due to the pressures of the religious government, this process has been accelerated and the society is strongly distancing itself from religion. However, it has been said even in our classical literature that the purpose of religion is spirituality, the manifestation of morality and justice, and reaching God, and those who are only stuck in the appearance of religion were called the قشری
Peaple giving you headache in this comment section because it wasn't what they wanted to see😂😂😂
And talking for millions of peaple because that's what they wished it to be....
especially haters of my Islam!!!!!
OMG Iranians are different from other Muslim countries.😮 They look friendly and open minded ❤
Know Iran from independent media. Also this channel sponsored by regime. Iranian are kind and peaceful but get poisoned by IRGC and mullahs
Yes they're not Arabs
@@SheehanRamdeyal Arabs are open minded too 😊❤
We are not Arabs and we are civilized since 7000 years ago , we are a peaceful nation
Ex-muslim, Zoroastrian from Iran
Every soul has a moral obligation to strive for ultimate truth, and its a continuous journey, offcourse at age of 16 your view of this realm is different as one is just at the beginning of this journey as you move further and encounter harsh realities of life if you are keen observer your purpose of life changes. Being great admirer of science especially Astronomy, quantum physics, living things around me I am convinced that ultimate truth that there is some higher power which is unseen but it is there because thus universe is so intelligently designed how come it is possible that design is there but without designer if designer is there we have been created and we are concioince beings then there must be purpose of our creation, and creator has put this inherent tendency in every soul so someone is looking for it in the skies, some in idols, some in sciece but everyone is searching for it as I said it is a journey of individual soul which he or she has to do alone without any external pressure so in my iopinion it must be allowed the way nature itself has planned it.
I ❤ Shia Islam because I found Hussain ibn e Ali in it
Salam 'alaykoum warahmatAllah. From your Shia Muslim brother in Indonesia 🇮🇩🇮🇷. Alhamdulillah, all praise be to Allah SWT alone. I'm so grateful for Allah SWT has guided me to the path of the true Islam (Shia Islam) at the age of 19 years old this year (2023).
When God Almighty perfected the religion of Islam at the Ghadeer Khoum. The path that the Last Messenger and Prophet of God Muhammad RasoulAllah shalAllahu 'alayhi wa aalehi tell us to hold onto at the Ghadeer Khoum ( Quran al-Kareem and Ahlul Bayt صلوات الله عليهم جميعاً ).
متاسفانه شما به جای اینکه یک تصویر دقیق رو از جامعه حال ایران نشون بدید فارغ از هر سیاستی ، شما دارید بیشتر با ضربان حاکمیت جلو میرید و حتی در ویدیو های قبلی ما افراد بی حجاب رو نمی‌دیدیم . نمیدونم میخواید چی رو ثابت کنید اما در مناطق مذهبی بیشتر میرید تا اون چیزی که میخواید رو نشون بدید . لطفاً رسانه آزاد باشید ، نه دریچه‌ای از نگاه خودتون و حاکمیت .
ضربان حاکمیت چیه عزیز ما هم ایرانی هستیم و هیچ ارگان حکومتی هم عضو نیستیم و هم خودم هم خانوادمون عقایدمون مشابه همین افراد داخل ویدیو هست و تا هفتاد درصد مسلمان هستیم،نمیدونم شما چرا همه جا اصرار دارید که بگید همه بی دینن یا همه باید بی دین بشن ..شما به عقاید خودتون باشید ماهم به عقاید خودمون داخل این ویدیو هم افراد بی دین هم بودن و مسلمان هم بودند
@@AA-jt6ec خانم شما انگار تو جامعه و نسل جوان نیستین نه؟ بنده تو شهر قم زندگی میکنم قشنگ همه دارن بالا تا پایین اسلام رو فوش میدنن و مسخره، و جالبتر و شکه کننده تر اینکه با آگاهی هم اسلام رو رد میکنن
Exactly
@@AA-jt6ec
Selected replies. dishonest interview.
Right ❤
Oui l'identité de chaque être humain sur cette planète a des sources multiples qui n'ont rien à voir avec la religion . Et l'identité de chacun est très personnelle . Elle doit être respectée sans jugement . Pourquoi les oiseaux du ciel auraient plus de libertés que les êtres humains ? Le matérialisme n'est pas mauvais en soi : la corruption , l'intolérance , la violence sont pires que tout. Chaque être humain a un talent, des qualités : il a le droit de les exploiter librement. Pour moi, la richesse n'est pas un but ,ni la mode ,ni le luxe mais la fortune ,la vie luxueuse des autres si elles sont honnêtes ne me gênent pas du tout. Et la mode est un choix personnel que je respecte.
Si on croit en Dieu alors : LA PAIX EST UN DON DE DIEU 🕊 ET ON DOIT LA PROTÉGER .
The Shia sect has made Islam (in general) weaker in Iran. Please don’t hate me but understand. I have cousins from both Sunni and Shia sides. The heavy importance of 12 infallible imams has led people away from Sunnah. After losing interest from Shia (like getting disgusted from self beating (yes it happens) or cursing/bad mouth about Sahabas, Shia not only lose interest in Shiasm but in Islam as a whole. Fun fact: Iran and its surrounding regions were once Sunni before Safavid Empire 😢
You know why Iranian become Shiia ?! Because Arabs were extreme and violent and uncivilized only reaction of Iranian was join the opposition of Khalifa in order to show their objection.
Hahahahahaha Have you forgotten that Sunni doctrine produced Al-Qaeda, ISIS, and global terrorism?!! Have you forgotten that Sunni terrorism blows up innocent people and that the last terrorist attack occurred in Iran about two months ago and caused the death of 100 people and the injury of 300 people?!! Do you think that ISIS and Al-Qaeda will make Sunnis proud of their religion?!! On the contrary, many Sunni peoples resort to atheism or non-religiousness, and some resort to Shiite Islam in large numbers, and millions of people have converted to Shiite Islam in Africa alone.
Hahahahahaha Have you forgotten that Sunni doctrine produced Al-Qaeda, ISIS, and global terrorism?!! Have you forgotten that Sunni terrorism blows up innocent people and that the last terrorist attack occurred in Iran about two months ago and caused the death of 100 people and the injury of 300 people?!! Do you think that ISIS and Al-Qaeda will make Sunnis proud of their religion?!! On the contrary, many Sunni peoples resort to atheism or non-religiousness, and some resort to Shiite Islam in large numbers, and millions of people have converted to Shiite Islam in Africa alone.
Hahahahahaha Have you forgotten that Sunni doctrine produced Al-Qaeda, ISIS, and global terrorism?!! Have you forgotten that Sunni terrorism blows up innocent people and that the last terrorist attack occurred in Iran about two months ago and caused the death of 100 people and the injury of 300 people?!! Do you think that ISIS and Al-Qaeda will make Sunnis proud of their religion?!! On the contrary, many Sunni peoples resort to atheism or non-religiousness, and some resort to Shiite Islam in large numbers, and millions of people have converted to Shiite Islam in Africa alone.
Hahahahahaha Have you forgotten that Sunni doctrine produced Al-Qaeda, ISIS, and global terrorism?!! Have you forgotten that Sunni terrorism blows up innocent people and that the last terrorist attack occurred in Iran about two months ago and caused the death of 100 people and the injury of 300 people?!!
Interesting question. I’ve seen quite a few Iranians say that most of the citizens have become disillusioned with Islam and generally don’t care for it or any other religion. How true is that, from your experience?
0:24 she literally said majority of Iranians don’t believe in religion 😂
@@HermesborugerdianAh, so she did. I guess the Arabic subtitles captured that better than the English ones did. 😂
@@Adam-326 if that’s the case then yes. She says in Persian word by word “I belong to the religion-less Iranian majority” it’s a play of words on how they used to call non Muslim Iranian as “minorities”. And now
The majority is non Muslim lol
@@Hermesborugerdian Fascinating. I’m planning on learning Farsi in the future, so it’s cool to see how Iranians think. Also, you’ve got a cool taste in music haha, די מגניב!
My playlists are public?? I had no idea 😂
Wow interesting video. It seems much of today's youth around the world doesn't like to follow hardcore religious practices
این کانال مشخصه به جایی وصله
As an Iranian, I am an atheist
@@Human_boy_91 i was atheist but I did find my faith and I'm proud of myself for this
Im zoroastrian but i prefer secular muslims to athiests
@@Human_boy_91 lol cry about it 🍼
@@Human_boy_91 you better to change your extreme belief
I'm agnostic atheist and I'm a Persian ( Iranian) too
اسلام تنها ار چهل سال نیست تو ایران اسلام درتاریخ ما جاداره من افتخار میکنم که مسلمونم
و واقعا از خدا میخوام این کسایی که چشمشون رو وحقیقت بستن رو باز کنه امیدوارم همه در سایه خداوند یگانه باشید
برو یه فکر به حال آب و نونت کن که قراره اسلام حالا حالا ها به مقام انسانیت برسونه تو یه نفر رو
Not really religious in the east = Extremely religious in the west. The standards are diff in each region.
Spirit of Zoroaster remains and shows here, nice to see that.
🇬🇷🇮🇷☦️🇷🇺
So this is persian people, they are look like northen indian
Sorry, i don't mean this to be racist
tbf the most "caucasian" looking northern indians and some pakistani in general does looks like average persian
@@dondog3123 people in this video look nothing like caucasians .. you look like average indian or bengalis even you are south asian looking
@@deadbeat5165 considering india's racial diversity, i dont meant "caucasian" as in white, european descent
im referring to indo aryans people in general
Where are you from?
شعب ايران مظلوم يعيش في فترة نفور من الدين بسبب سياسات الحكومة الشيعية. طبيعي غالبية الشعب يكره الدين و بسبب الاعلام المعادي للعرب بدأ الشعب بكراهية الدين الذي جاء عن طريق العرب. ما لا يعرفه اغلب الايرانيين لن اكثر فترة ذهبية عاشتها ايران هي الفترة المذهب السني في اول خمس قرون من دخول الاسلام و بعد استيلاد الصفويين علي ايران اصبح الدين في انحدار الي يومنا هذا ..
Of course most of them say yes in front of the camera , but I guarantee you most will say they are not Muslim.
Go to sleep, my friend
Yes true they are Shia not Muslims.
@@wail_bel maybe you should wake up instead of sending people to sleep!
Oh yes waking up to western propaganda @@English_to_Persian
@@wail_bel thank you IRGC agent for your guidance
It is very sad that many youngsters are not practicing Islam. Parents are also to blame. This would happen if you prefer your culture more than Islam.
yes i think 2 things happend about these parent didnt teach these stuff correctly and also government opression and bad economy
@@AA-jt6ecA country’s government can be bad and economy can be bad, but that shouldn’t impact someone’s faith in Allah. If you look at the people of Gaza, relatives dying, houses are destroyed, shortages of food and water, yet you would find their faith is very strong. Even the little children would say, “HasbanAllah wa ni’amal wakeel.”
This is a pretty dumb interview. And biased. Most people, even our parents generation aren't muslims. Lol
@@harisfareed4599 disagree this is very accurate mine and our parent are muslim, may allah guide you and stop being so enemy with islam
@@AA-jt6ec lol delusional supporter of IRGC and Islamic republic
They are not Shia nor sunni they practice a self established religion, they mostly worship graves or shrines. From fire Worship to shrines worship.
Its not Europe or USA where majority people say Noooo 😂😂😂❤
یعنی بعضی جوابات کاملا بدون منطق بود،
مثلا اینکه کار خوب کن ولی نماز نخوان، در حالی که باید هم کار خوب کن و هم نماز بخوان.
مثلا یکی میگفت هم از مسلمان بودنم خوش هستم و هم نیستم، یعنی اوج بی منطقی (اگه خوش نیستی چرا هنوزم مسلمان موندی؟)
جالبتر اینکه بعضی اسلام را آنگونه قبول داشتن که خودشان میخواستند، نه آنگونه که خداوند از آنها خواسته
Down with brutal Islamic regime in Iran
I think you should blur their faces, especially the ones that said no. In Iran we do not really have the freedom to say no to religion.
My faith in religion is fading away day by day ....
Are you a Muslim??
Astagfirullah don't get brainwashed by them they're brainwashed by Shah and Zionists go watch Dr zakir Naik, blogging theology, Yusuf Estes etc
why??? Read Quran with translation and ask help for strengthn of faith from Allah Swt!!!!😊❤
Watch dr zakir naik, blogging theology, daniel haqiqatjou and btw secular iranians love israel u can see the surveys only the religious iranians like palestinians, if ur a muslim and human dont be distracted by fitnah online
Today, most Iranians, especially the youth, have become familiar with the fruits and results of religion that have been introduced to them, and this video is clearly an expression of those results.
Due to the fact that history is considered a science and this science is growing with the advancement of technology, for less than 20 years, surprising facts about the lies of the history of the Islamic religion, which generally come from the historians of the Abbasid regime, have been revealed. In the meantime, especially the young people of Iran will gradually become familiar with these facts and the roots and foundations of this religion of Islam have been completely questioned. In this way, the people of Iran will revise the truth of their beliefs and this is just beginning.
This issue promises a great intellectual revolution among Iranians.
(It should be noted that all the things mentioned in this video as humanity and good morals actually arise from human conscience, which existed before religion, and even now, there is no need for religion for that human morality.)
not true though, in countries without religion you can see obvious absence of basic morality.
Just look at western countries with high promiscuity, or countries like Japan where cheating is norm, or korea where too much emphasis on outward appearance.
Name me some of those lies you mentioned.
I need to know
@@AksarallahCzechia is better then Poland. Kazakhstan is better then Afghanistan and Turkey is better then Iran
@@78alJ0vle ask your mother to read the Quran, it has 0 contradictions and never been changed and memorized by millions.
As an Iranian, I tell you that your conclusion was wrong. Where did you get such a conclusion from this video? In which part of the video did he mention lies and distortions in religion? You cannot attribute your opinion to this video or the Iranian community. Even this video cannot express the opinion of all Iranian people.
of course u cant like iran's relegion i understand why iranian are not relegious because Shia dosent make sence
nah. thats not true
can u explain ur point of view
@@kks.z29
That’s not true
thats not true ,shia is absolute right this is just because of actions of government and opression the real islam is perfect
@@kks.z29that is true !.
فقط از ۳ نفر سوال کرد که ایرانی هستی یا مسلمان.
از جواب ها خوشش نیآمد 😂😂😂😂😂
This video was very biased about various issues and the questions were not attractive. Anyway, irreligious people can't talk much in Iran because it has serious consequences for them
Exacly
Not true, some people literally said they don't believe in anything, and they were not prosecuted.
@@aln339 If you pay attention, you will see that they talk very little, and in the clip, their way was not focused, and they did not say their words and reasons as much as the others, and they were on the sidelines of the clip.
@@whisperofthestorm6889 the thing is you are claiming Iran like some other countries in the region is a close country and you can not talk about your feelings about religion. People can easily talk about their feelings about religion, and no one will persecute them.
@@aln339 Those who are irreligious in Iran always exercise caution because there is a high possibility that they will be rejected or misrepresented. But the main issue about this clip was how purposefully and biased they talked about the issue of religion, and this issue was very clear in the movie, whether it was asking questions or focusing on the opinion of people who still had religion and ignoring the non-religious person compared to others.
iranian here, not muslim, agnostic, specially with the kind of god that ibrahamic religions represent!
Cute
Better to have one God, then bow down to hundreds of useless stone idols, which look like elephants, witches and monkeys.
@susanna9831 better to have enough brain and ability to think and respect science, the same science that made covid vaccines and saved lives, not a god that does nothing to save it's followers
@mohi6877 he did not oppose science he merely reminded you that being without an objective morality system makes you a joke and a literall menace to society, look up what Richard Dawkins says about r*pe being arbitrary on RUclips
That is the pinaccle of being atheist/agnostic :)
at least you have a solid foundation of your belief, I'm half Iranian westerner I claim being muslim to be proud of my culture & ancestry. I'm personally more agnostic. What I dislike very much is Iranians or any middle easterners in general who are heritage nominal muslims but convert to Western Christianity and subscribe to white supremacism.
iranians look exactly like indians im suprised
😂 you mean how indians are obssesed with looking?some bollywood actors can look iranian it's because they are cherry picked or actually have iranian/afghan blood. Don't want to be mean but not being comfortable with yourselves and denying your own people's appereance does not give you a nice look. I've seen many indians in india on daily basis and less than 1 percent of indians would actually look like iranians and usually those people do have iranic blood themselves.
@sunny-td7qg u must be high or something.. none of these people look like bollywood actors r u kidding me .. their faces and skin and bone structure are very indic regardless
Because Indians are descendants of ancient indo-aryans.
you could say most northern indians and pakistanis in general tend to look a lot like persians
@@dondog3123 persians look south asian more than middle eastern
رفتی هرچی ارزشی گیر اوردی ازشون سوال میپرسی
😂😂😂❤
این کانال خودش ارزشیه😂
درست صحبت کن و مردم رو دودسته نکن بسیاری مردم مذهبی هستند در ایران ، باتوهین صحبت کردن راجع به عقاید دیگران فقط بی عقلی خودتو نشون میده
Do Turks living in Iran have this much brown skin?Iranians and Indians look very similar greetings from Azerbaijan 🇦🇿😊
Yes I'm turk but I'm brown
@@blackdimond75 u r not turk you r indian Persians 😂
every one knows that turks magically got the suuuper white skin of ancient slanted eyed turks(who weren't mixed up themselves at all😂) but also got completlyyy different faces througout the years they invaded west asia🤔like from mongol face to greek face kinda different😏 go get a life where you don't have to deny your ancesters or steal others cultures to feel validated you troll😂🤡
Are u Muslim
In general, the northern regions of Iran have whiter skin than the south and the Balochs, etc., but Iran is a colorful land, Iranian Turks are brown and white, etc., and they are diverse, we do not have these discussions in Iran.
As persian people we beleive in Allah , and a higher creator. But many of us reject or question the quran , and mohammad especially. Most of the younger people reject sharia. As persian people we unanimously beleive in one creator , that every religion worships in many ways. Many of us hold the shahnameh higher than the quran , and practice zorashtrian culture while remaining " cultural muslims". This interviews were a good enough representative of iran , however many more irreligious people exist , but probably avoided saying it on camera ( regime ) , however still 30% of persians are muslim. More than half are agnostic. Atheism is not very common , but agnostics are majority.
This is because they are Shiites
nah muslims are more than 50 percent, talking in behalf of everyone shows your ignorance , and also ferdowsi, poet of shahname was a shia muslim so its a silly thing to put that up of quran
از زبان ما دروغ نگو
Javid Shah
Persian power 💪
che rabti dasht
0:24اضافه نگو , اکثریت؟
دقیقا اکثریت
So many gay couples in Iran....
0:24 stop lying in your translations. She stated the known fact that she’s part of the majority of Iranians who don’t believe in religion.
North tehrani liberals arent majority of Iran
@@KoroushRP do I need to remind you there are whole Iranian country side cultures with tribal backgrounds, that almost never had respect for Islam. Kurds, Lors and Torkmans are great examples
@@Hermesborugerdian lol what? Those people are even more religous than regular Iranians.
@@KoroushRP Khoda de qinet you clearly know nothing about Iran 😂
@@HermesborugerdianSome Kurds are more traditional than religious, however the majority are quite religious Sunnis, most Turkmen are much more conservative than the average Shias.
Generally speaking the religious minorities in Iran are like most religious minorities anywhere, more religious than the average.
ريدم تو عسلام دين تروريست ها 😅
خیلیشون دروغ میگن که میخونن میترسن
کسخل از کی میترسن مگه جمهوری اسلامی داعش یا طالبانه
متاسفانه روی اعتقادات خیلی کم کار شده کتابای مربوط به اصول دین و حقیقت اسلام خیلی کم معرفی شده اون قسمت جذاب عقلانیت دین برای مردم گفته نشده پس برای همین جوانان مشکلات اعتقادی دارن
ayshe chand salesh bood? loool
اتفاقا خیلی زیاد کار شده شما این فشار دینی رو که حکومت به مردم ورود میکنه رو در هیچ کجای دنیا بجز ایران نمیبینی. و بخاطر این زیادی کار شدنش ادم زده میشه ازش
هم ریدم توی این اسلامتون هم ریدم توی اون یکی اسلامتون که میگین این اون نیست.
Zer nazan
Muslims are not the same. The muslims of eastern countries like Pakistan, Iran and India are more spiritual than religious per se. The Islamic revolution in Iran brought more doctrine and organization in that country. In middle eastern countries like Iraq, Syria and Jordan, the islam practiced there is much more in line with the local arab culture. Islam is truly an arab religion not always compatible with the local culture be it Pakistani, Indian or Iranian in the case of this video.
Doing a revolution is forbidden in Islam .like 1979 which occurred in Iran. As an Iranian So shit to Iran's 1979 revolution
I don't know which Pakistanis you've met, but Pakistanis are way more conservative when it comes to religion than the Iranians.
@@nikolasmacedonites917but indonesians are most proud to be a Muslim than any other country in the world even not Saudi Arabia
Pakistani Culture is deeply infused with Islam, so it's more than just compatible. Don't speak on behalf of others when you know so little.
Wow! You just compared Pakistanis to Iranians in terms of religious beliefes :)))
These two are exactly the opposite. Pakistanis are whatever Iranians aren't.
درود. متاسفانه این کلیپ از منطقه تقریباً مذهبی شهر تهیه شده و یک بانو با حجاب اختیاری در این کلیپ نیست. امروز چند درصد از بانوان ایران چادری هستند شاید کمتر از 10درصد ولی اونا را پررنگ جلوه میدهند...به امید رنسانس فکری در ایران و اندکی تفکر و تعقل
Are u Muslim
رنسانس در ایران نبوده که بخواهیم شبیه اش بشیم، تحولی فکری ایرانیان در منطقه خاورمیانه هم شکل گرفته با قدرتمند شدن در منطقه و اتحاد حول محور مقاومت صرف نظر از قوم و مذهب و نابودی و اخراج اشغالگران صهیونیست و ...
اتفاقا شما اصلا فکر نمیکنید و فکر میکنید همه مثل خودتون هستند . و البته این حرف شما که "هرکی حجاب داره زوریه و بی حجاب اختیاریه فقط "کاملا حرف خودخواهانه ایست و در جهت دیکته کردن عقیده خودتون به بقیه.. چون بسیاری از افراد با علاقه و بخاطر عقیدشون حجاب دارند و البته ده درصد نیستند حداقل 60 درصد ایرانیا مسلمان هستند حتی با حجاب کمتر من افراد اینگونه رو میشناسم که حتی حجاب نداره و حرم میره و نماز هم گاهی میخونه
بی‌دین همه شهرها هست اما آنقدر نیستند. سر و صداشون زیاده
حالت واقعا خوب نیست ۱۰ درصد
۴ نفر را میبینی ک تو صفحات اجتماعی یه چیز میگن زیاد تو چشم هستند برا همین ایجور فک میکنی،،،،،هیچ نباشه ۷۵ درصد تو شهر حجاب را دوست دارند،،،،هالا روستا ها خو ۱۰۰ درصد شون مذهبی هستند
U cannot be religious and still believe in God.
You still can believe in god while not necessarily believes in any "religions"
And the definition would be deism
As a pakistani, i want to say that there are aprox. 50 percent of Iranian are atheist....
@@shadabqureshi786according to gamaan, a non profit institute in the Netherlands, Iran is 40% muslim. They did a survey of 50,000 iranians. And after cleaning the survey as per pew research guildines, and after removing responses from iranians outside of iran (the diaspora, who almost all of which are non-believers) they were left with 39,000 responses in the report. This is a huge number for a poll btw, most polls done in other countries for similar stats have about 2000-3000 respondents max. If u look further into thr gamaan study u can see even out of the 40% that identified themselves as muslim, most of them are not very religious (for example much fewer than 40% believe in a heaven and hell, or jhinn). If Ur interested in reading more search GAMAAN, RELIGION STUDY and u can find it published online. The thing u have to note is that doing surveys in iran is notoriously almost impossible over the phone or in person. As these surveys are not anonymous, answering u r not muslim for 99% of the population categorized as muslim by the regime is punishable by death. Also to do an in person or phone survey in iran u must have permission from the regime by law, and u cannot make the survey anonymous (it must be supervised by the regime). So the gamaan study is the best study we have, not only by number of respondents, but also because it was done anonymously so people were not afraid to answer honestly. These figures are not hard to believe because even according to the regime jummah prayer attendance is at an all time low (this is something the regime is very scared about). This is coming from an Iranian diaspora. When I speak with my family in Iran they estimate no more than 60% of the population max wld categorize themselves as muslim. So if we assume that the gamaan study may have slightly undercounted the number, we can take halfway between 40% and 60%, which is 50%. Most of which again are not very religious. People in iran have been leaving islam in droves since the revolution. During the recent protests many thousands were doing quran burnings. Islam is not a religion made for iran, it is one made for 7th century arabs. Putting trust in this religion has brought nothing but hardship to my people. Islam regime propaganda is rampant, so be cautious about it. They have basiji bots all over social media that will make u think we r a very religious country, this is simply not true. Khomeini hijacked a revolution that was already happening and not for islamic reasons. My people will be freed soon, Iranshar!
They're not atheist they just don't believe in religion because they're brainwashed into liberalism
Atheists and Agnostics are growing rapidly in Iran
Not atheists but agnostic!
این عدل که میگن توی اسلام هست منظور عدل خدا در خلقت هست نه این که همه چی عادلانه باشه. وگرنه خود اسلام اول از همه با تقسیم کافر و مسلمون و تفاوت حقوق اساسی عامل بی عدالتی بود.
How it's injustice of Division of Muslim vs Kaffir?
God has created you but you stop believing it and deny your creator then such claim will already start dividing
تفاوت عدل و مساوات رو باید درک کنید
مساوات یعنی با هر شخصی جدای از اینکه چیکار کرده به چی باور داره و کی هست یکسان برخورد کنی
ولی عدل به این معنا نیست
عدل یعنی با هرکسی بسته به اینکه چه چیزی باور داره چه کارایی انجام داده رفتار کنی
و اگه رفتارش نادرسته مجازات اش کنی و طرد اش کنی
فرقشون از زمین تا آسمونه
@@thehonestdude1067 هر چی که هست اینایی که میگفتن از اسلام عدالتش را دوست دارن متوجه نبودن که عدل منظور عدالت خدا در افرینشه نه مساوات به قول شما.
در واقع در اسلام مساوات نیست اون عدل هم فقط منظور عدالت در افرینشه که اتفاقا عدالتی هم در افرینش نیست
@@Taqi142What if people believe in other god and not in Allah
@@hasinabegum1038
God is only one, From Adam to Abraham, From Noh to Joseph, From Jesus to Moses and Prophet Muhammad all of them preaches one God now God has many names but He is only one, So when you say if someone believe other than Allah if you mean by Hindus that they believe many God's or Christian they believed in 3 God then they are not adhering to truth or closing their eyes from truth... Human are smart how can God be more than one?
حالم از این چنل حکومتی به هم میخوره
all Iranian must be zorasstrian not muslim
@@Navroz-y1g no all
@@Navroz-y1gthat’s rare nowadays
The Shia way brought them away from the real islam, unfortunately. Please try to understand the islam do not focus to much about shia nd Ali..... They specially the regime and society very bad marketing for islam, because how they do and believe is to be honest not islam.
It's Not About Shia or Sunni
There is A Lot Of Shia Country Such as Yemen, Azerbaijan, Iraq
Some Iranians Don't Like Islam Because Of Crimes of Omer , Osman and Abu baker in the Iran
Shia is the true Islam
Ask the same question in one of the other muslim countries, and 99% will answer alhamdulilah that he/her are Muslim. The people from ahle sunna don't have this kind of antipathy against there religion.
@@HAMADA-Xother peoples religion its not your business brother
@@mazdakbamdadan9733 You are wrong. The islam give me the duty as muslim to take care about human and advice them to the right way, and thats Islam
these types of questions should not be asked in iran as most ppl will not be able to actually freely express their opinions since they will be sent to jail or even executed so its quite biased.
They are openly saying what they want, there doesn't seem to be much distress about expressing their opinions. Try the same in many other countries in that region 😊
We are living here my dear. You can't say stuff openly. That guy who said he doesn't believe has balls of steel.@@nikolasmacedonites917
dont spread lies its not true, they are just talking about their religion , in many videos in iran a lot of people dont have hijab which is law of iran and they dont get sent to jail also many people insult leader of iran and nothing happens to them only if you are a famous guy that may happen to you
@@irani544 im also in iran and say you are lieng , it is not such law in iran that you have to be mulim ,only there is law of hijab about these things which if you are not a famous person mostly is not making any trouble for you these days
@@AA-jt6ec what the hell? Literally two people last year were hanged for what is called سب النبی. For instance if you say Muhammad was a pedophile and it gets enough attention and some basterd is too much of a basterd to report you for it you can easily get hanged. Bahaiis and convert Christians(not Armenians and Assyrians) are activelly persecuted. Are you kidding me? I don't care if you live in Iran or not. You can live in Iran and listen to Miley cyrus or Nickie Minage everyday and have no idea what's going on in your country. I'm guessing you're one of those people. Have fun living in your world of ignorance. I envy you people.
Muhammad claims that Jesus is a prophet before him! In order for a prophet to be identified, the previous prophets must prophesy him, and the person made the prophecies come true!And Jesus did it! But Muhammad's prophecy did not happen! So Muhammad is not a prophet and Islam is not God's religion and Allah is not God either!So only the Catholic Church tells you about the true God!
How much do you know about Muhammad's pbuh prophecy. You know nothing.
Muhammad (pbuh) told that he is the last messenger of God, did you see any prophet after him, do you see any abrahmic prophet or religion after him?
Explain more
2:04 غلط میکنی انجام ندی
I don’t blame people for their apathetic view in religion. It is mainly the failures of Islamic scholars who couldn’t convey the true charm of islam to people. These people hadn’t seen the darkness and discrimnation when there’s not enough resources and people are not afraid of judgement day. If they had seen the Cruelty of desperate humans who aren’t afraid of laws, they would have appreciated islam more. You can see integrity and compassion of religious people amidst the darkness of desperation. Youths there don’t lack anything, they don’t feel insecure due to strict laws, yet they crave for limitless freedom... How laughable...
They seem spiritually liberal though outwardly looking fanatical. Once they followed the beautiful religion of Zarasthustra/Zoroaster before a foreign religion no matter how good was forced upon them. Essence of Zoroastrianism: Good thoughts, Good Words and Good Deeds. How beautiful! Now they know absolutely nothing about it! How sad!
2 minutes in And this Feels like a state Sponsored propagnada video. Which this whole channel probably is cause i didn't see any Relevant content about the protests.
Iranians are so lucky to have Rehbar e Moazzam..Why these people didn't mention him...
جانم فدای رھبر
Ap ko nai pta Iran ki halat Pak o India sey bohat mukhtalif ha
@@Taqi142different in what sense?
@@sakinafatima
Hum log yahan aksariyat mey nai is leye deen sey qareeb han, Ahlulbayt sey qareeb ha, Wahan wo log humesha aksariyat mey han ise leye wo mazhab par itna fakhar nai kartay, Ajj key irani khud ko Irani honay par fakhar kartay han na keh mazhabi honay par..
Rehbar e Muzam ko jis nigah sey hum dekhtay han wo log nai dekhtay wo aun ko aik hakim key tor par dekhtay han na keh mazhabi rehnuma key tor par
@Taqi142 but 100 percent log waha k aesay nai hy kuch mazhabi b hy
@@sakinafatima
Jee mey bhi Yehi keh raha hon Inqalab e Iran key waqt agr log 100% mazhabi thay abb 40% to 60% han
bad music
due to so many things in Iran we cant just get the real things out of most of people because there is always government there is always laws there is always so many things in Islamic countries which doesn't give the rights to people to tell what's their real opinion on things religion as Iranian i don't see people by the eye of religion because religion is a regional thing
we don't know we are just small humans on a planets with too many stories if a god exist I don't think he would tell us to worship him and always telling him he is mighty and he is powerful because he already knows who he is I think we should care more about the our people and our future
because I saw to many people used religions as a weapon in their hands to get power over others if a religion is real there should not be any force evolve in it to make the others accept that's the one who control past will control future we should take care of our children that's the governments guys religions extremists and other people doesn't corrupt them
and at the end my opinion on religion i don't really believe in religions and prophets because im a human i have feeling i have common sense if someone have its own religion and doesn't bother me why it should be a problem for me but i saw many times mostly in Abrahamic religion that's there is no stop to bothering others because north west African didn't did anything to Muslims but they attacked them to spread religion same as Spanish people the people some of the Jews from start of history did made a lots of things harder for other people in lands or Arabia by having control over water and many many things happened by the churches in dark times in America and Europe
asking about iranian people’s beliefs and specifically about islam is ridiculous. the punishment for apostasy in iran is death. no one can say the truth
ذدینش بلبله