The American lady did not states the facts, USA dismantled Unions in 1990's and the pay is $12 per hour as the minimum federal wage for USA. It is the capital system that is not good for the worker.
Business environment is extremely Fluid. Sustainable competitive advantage one has maybe eroded away in few months especially in technology. I would say the Definition of Capitalism now not only encompasses $$$ but Technology (Data Science, AI, automation - a New Concept of Capitalism.
As one chinese worker put it best in the film "I have no choice." People should be given a tolerable amount of work for a liveable wage and an opportunity to improve their life. Factory work in itself is soul numbing. Hopefully human civilization will evolve beyond it.
This is such a great documentary. I did not aware of this before and somehow I just watched this last week. I liked a lot and I made my own review video in my channel. thanks
If American way of business model and management work, GM wouldn't had closed down and the Chinese wouldn't have the opportunity to get in. The owner already said, he would close down the business if they unionize. 100% of nothing or....?
@Obi2, The American way of business has been doing on good way. Sure, sometimes can happen some problems, and this is why we have to do anything fit with law. At the end of 70's to beginning 80's in China, according to premier Deng Xiaoping' s "No care white or black, if you can get rich you are a Glory", and "Self-interest, Self-market" s theories: the smugglers bring as huge quantities of fake watches from Hong Kong smuggle to south China, and this kind of business have created these smugglers became the billionaires quickly, also they no need pay any tax and employees. But it caused all China states watches factories were bankruptcy, and more than 600,000 watches' related workers were laid off. this has caused the working class peoples being poor, stressed, depression, and suicide.
@Cjango Freeman How come? How come one thing is related to another? I am not a Trump supporter, but tell me why he will close down is $500M Business because Trump is raising Tariffs on some of the Chinese imports?
@Cjango Freeman I think you have to understand that China is not comparing option A or B and deciding to go with B. China is expanding anywhere! They will invest in Mexico, in US, Canada, etc. Trust me. This investor won't shut-down his $500M factory in Ohio because of the increment of tarifs. I can guarantee you that.
@@nadominhoca They will close it down as soon as they find a way to move their investment somewhere else that has better profit margins. That is how it works. The workers may have some legitimate grievances, but they should take their political organizing efforts to their government instead of their employer.
16:10 the anchor just laughs at the caller who is being completely sincere and bringing up the blatant truths they are ignoring - the union employees were threatened and/or fired. It's eerie.
Why not be fired if you cannot do what the Chinese shift dd achieve, did grandly f@kd by communists? Enjoy capitalism still? 23tril of debt keep rising. That's why wages increased you guys yourself brought this mess cause you keep complaining and complaining sto winning allready. Shut up and show what sacrifice you can offer inside the company
Till the time law were enacted to protect US workers, the US factory owners in the olden days treated their workers much worse. Just the the novel "the Jungle" by Upton Sinclair.
I watched the documentary and it’s so shameful how the mentality of “ we deserve more because we’re Americans “ forces employers to close businesses. Unions are the cancer of the work place. In the documentary one guy makes a comment that he doesn’t want Chinese tv shows play in the break room because “this is America “
yerovi86 first off all the living standard in the US is much higher than in China. In the US you can’t even afford enough food from the wages they pay in China. With an minimum wage off 7.25 dollar you live under the poverty line. I live in The Netherlands and for the last hundred years we have unions for every kind off work you can think off. The employers have there own unions. The unions off the employees and the unions off the employers are negotiating every couple off years the wages and the employment conditions together with benefits. The government is functioning as an mediator. Workers are a lot better off then in the US. We are a rich country with a lot off trade and plenty enough work. Unlike the US we did not dwell in the past. So when manufacturing jobs disappeared and the coal mines closed the government schooled the workers that lost there job and actively looked for alternative work. We never expected it will come back and we never ask for it. We are very down to earth and right away thought, it is what it is let’s move on. It is not the unions or that workers wants to much. It is an attitude problem. Holding on to the past and not wanting to change. A lot off Americans want to go back to the fifties and sixties. Does days are gone.
@@Bruintjebeer6 Those days could come back if we closed our borders, kicked out the foreigners whi displace us and became completely self contained and self sufficient, which we actually could do.
GM ....why do Americans need more than one car to a family? We see 2 car garages are now passé. Any upper class family can have up to 4 car garages. The ultra rich have multiple cars in multiple locations to go with their multiple homes. I think good honest working and middle class perhaps have doubts about this kind of extravagancy. If GM folded, a good person could find other work. The coal miners who lost jobs in mines are now being trained as bee keepers. Yep! When America becomes humble in a sincerely honest way, we can be inventive as hell. But we can't ever survive eating nuts & bolts and rubber tires. ☮️
Don’t take the moral high ground by saying that fuyao should let the workers unionize and pay more for their benefits unless you are the one paying. It is cutthroat competition. Fuyao was struggling to make ends meet. Use laws and regulations for working standards. Union most of the time represents low efficiency. I am a worker and used to belong to a union. They function like a mob. you pay protection fee and you get unjustified benefits paid by your employer. Worse than socialism.
@@방구머겅 I said use laws and regulations. Safety has been there for ages. Don't present such simple and meaningless questions. No sensible people would be against safety and basic human rights.
@@방구머겅 Is that first time you saw grumpy employees? Run a business yourself. You will probably see more. People get hurt everywhere. I choked badly today while eating.
Yes, they can be creative at finding food in dumpsters, finding a place to sleep, etc. Without low skill jobs many people will be unemployable, regardless of training.
@@trinat347 cause the Chinese did better you mean? You never learn your lesson and try to hide behind laws at the same time where your economy falling apart! This is really delusional comments like yours I mean. Do something for your country like the Chinese do. That's the lesson you didn't understand.
GM had 2400 workers with a average pay of $25 a hour 5 days a week for 50 weeks ( if you count the other days for vacation as non paid) is around $120,000,000 a year on payroll. The average company of this size pays around $1,106 on cleaning supplies and toilet paper / soap a month so that's $13,272 GM also provided them Health Care coverage the average coverage plan over the course of a year the company would pay $2,000 so that's $4,800,000 Thats $124,813,272 just to have employees ... you would still have to pay any suppliers/ vendors, electricity, water, trash, sewer... so just to hire that many employees and give them Health Care coverage and somewhere to shit and wash their hands , three weeks off a year and pay them for 8 hour shift..
That's why GM is bankrupt, They hire too many worker and The worker are paying too expensive compare to their productivity. No wonder most of usa manufacture are moving to china and vietnam
@@Fauzanarief-n7i it's is what you get and what you're giving from a business perspective. If everything I've stated above as a businessman I'm giving to the employee then I should have an employee that is willing to bust their tail and be highly productive instead of figuring out a way to unionize just to be lazy
Maybe the Chinese assembly line workers should organize into unions so that they don't have to work the "996" schedule anymore. 9AM to 9PM, 6 days a week. THERE IS MORE TO LIFE THAN WORK. Labor unions fought this battle at the end of the 19th century. Workers should not have to work slave hours. Workers need dignity, too.
@poewhite oh they are not gonna miss you also, believe me that. I am Greek, but I enjoyed where the Chinese shift was the most productive. Fkd by the so bad communists socialists? 😅 Enjoy it.
@@lriddle21 yeah Ironie, since tiny little Greece didn't get any preparations or what's being looted out of Greece or the ppl got killed and we didn't menage to get for the families had victims not even a penny and the good so called politicians in 1953 wrote of the debt of Germany. We where forced to bring in German and French cars so these was a matter of time but the irony is more you want to talk about Greeks debt problem but more besides don't want to talk about yours 23trillion debt problem
I watch the full movie, there is a guy name ROB, he was welcome chinese, treat chinese best food, teach them play guns where china forbided, but after 2.5year he still be fired.
Check this 11:30. What is he saying? “General Motors could not longer support that factory” … I guess the truth was: GM dropped the factory-like a hot potato as soon as they could make enough profits, regardless of the workers … I find it zynistic in that context to use the word “support”.
Thought provoking. That s the curel reality of global competition. Terms u dismiss are good enough for others half a world away. The real answer IS to move on, do something they can't do. But that s hard too. Who says life s easy though? No one owes anyone a living.
how is the "Chinese way" and worse than the "American way"? American companies simply moved the factories to China precisely to be able to do the same things. With some factories coming back, three things are clear: 1) wages are lower, benefits less, 2) more automation (fewer employees) and 3) longer/more work. So, where is the difference? America has always been complicit in this trend -- American CEOs and boards decided to move factories to China. American politicians passed the laws and set policies to encourage globalization and free trade so such factories in China could supply consumption in the US. China/Chinese did not put a gun to our heads! And the average American is not even voting to protect themselves -- low turnout or voting for the establishment (ie corporate) democrat or republican. no wonder things are the way they are!
An "American" was hired to be CEO of Fuyao, and didn't "work out" so an "ethnic Chinese-American" was chosen.🤣 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Laughing so hard.... I'm crying...
I really like a sentence in this film,” Americans are overconfident.” Honestly, who is not a SLAVE of life? If you are not, may be you are a billionaire:）Don’t forget that better workers gain better pay, especially in this high-competitive and technology-driven world. Of course “better” means efficiency, productivity and high-quality.
These people paint a very rosy picture of jobs being created by the Chinese in the US but the reality a 100,000 jobs, 200,000, or even 500,000 jobs will not equal the 20 million lost due to the lack strategy when building the relationship with China beginning in the 70's. Because the US wealth was control by the few the results where horrific. The few thought only about there own personal wealth with complete disregard for the wealth of all Americans. China on the other hand has its wealth controlled by the state, the wealthy of China are control by the government who has the it's base interest in the people. America will continue to digress to a slum for most and a condo for others with the wealthy living in their feudal castle estates.
Blah blah about wealth and Chinese trying to create jobs - know where the wealth is going ? Too bad Americaucks do not get it and welcome butchery of peasants nations calling it "war" United States Bombings of Other Countries. America’s “Bombing List” www.globalresearch.ca/united-states-bombings-of-other-countries-americas-bombing-list/5533371
The only one of the three I'd hire in that picture... the Chinese guy, just from the look of them you can tell the other two will be lazy and complain a lot, just saying.
Personally, China should not invest in USA, not then, not now, not in the future. There is simply a huge cultural and work ethics differences. I dont see it succeeding.
X Y Z Chinese workers are being replaced by workers in Vietnam and Africa as well as by robots, automation etc.. Everyone is more or less in the same boat, so to speak, in those types of jobs.
What if "American" factory workers don't care about a cultural show, put on by their factory higher ups, but want to chill with their children, take a hike in nature, or just get a good night's sleep! These big shows don't mean happiness, because while some are forced to sing & dance per CCP regulatory injunctions, other citizens practicing a form of peaceful spiritual meditation (Falun Gong) are beaten, arrested, imprisoned without trial, given a number instead of a name, and finally forced to be operated on for their organs. (They don't survive this, their corpses are burned in hospital boiler rooms. There were 70 to 100 MILLION of these peaceful practicioners before the crackdown in 1999. This is now hush hush. Google it . Oh people, all that glitters IS NOT GOLD.
People from countries all over the world want to live in the USA(legally or not). Why the government of yours does not use the works of those peoples, like the mexicans, ensuring that these people will not be deported without guarantees and that you can get the factories out of China?People from countries all over the world want to live in the USA, because the government of yours does not use the labor force like the Mexicans, ensuring that these people will not be deported without guarantees and that you can get the factories out of China? not depriving it so much, because they no longer invest in the American continent (central and south america) which is better strategically?
China bosses try work in America is different than in China. China bosses should follow the working laws in the us. USA has overtime pay which china does not. America has workers comp, osha safety in working conditions, and other American comply working laws that china does not comply working in US. Many culture clashes. China companies don’t work in America. China companies represent communism, don’t ever work for Chinese owned companies. Chinese companies = communism. American companies = safety work environment, equal pay, ot pay, no culture clashes, no force work. America has pay holidays off, sick days, overtime pay to work on certain holidays, overtime automatic over 40 hours, which Chinese boss from china companies will not comply to. China bosses don’t comply with environment issues, they dispose chemical waste into sewer which is environmental issues. China try to pollute our water, air, and land like they did in their own country. America should ban china owned operations in America.
Well we can't eat nuts and bolts and rubber tires. The land is not only plentiful but fertile, so if ALL factories, especially slaughterhouses meat packing inhumane chicken, & pig factories close down, there could be a peaceful society for good people. Okay, if you are starving, go hunting, but in nature you won't find a forest strew with freshly butchered carcasses all laid out in a row. No, even carnivorous animals are vicious and will kill prey when they are HUNGRY. why not re-think the causes of acute and chronic mental & physical distress ? Any good reason?
From this film producer and the comments from USA, I can see American people are good people, they understand Chinese people are good friends of American. In Chinese language America is ""美国""。""美国""means ""Beautiful Country"". It proves from Day One China thinks American are beautiful country with beautiful people. It proves from Day One Chinese has best impression of United States. 美国~is the only beautiful country in Chinese language. 99% of Chinese including Communist party members think American people have beautiful heart. We only have one earth, we should be a big family and live together harmony. That's the hope of every Chinese people including every Communist party member. We need peace to live. We are family.
1. they FIRED everybody in this movie 2. they fired the whole US management 3. worst wages 4. they called all US employees donkeys and treated them like shit 5. most employees will be replaced by robots soon 6. nice movie LOL
When a factory is facing losses and cannot afford high wages, then the union organizes a strike and asks for a rise in wages. You can think about what the factory management will do, the factory can only choose to close down, what else can they do? Does the factory management go to the bank to lend money to the workers to raise high wages? Why does GM go bankrupt? Is it necessary for Chinese companies to repeat the same mistakes?
Thank you! 9% of the positive comments on this video are all Chinese. They tend to delete the comments that point out China's arrogance. Sorry, no slave labor in US Fuyao...
@@branstasko1 If you are a boss, do you want your employees to help you make money or get into trouble? Don't live in your own world, "What do I need to do, that is realistic"
Forklift Operator lost everything and was living at her sister's basement. Managed to get a job at Fuyao. A few months later managed to move to a small apartment and start moving on with her life. A couple of months later joined the unions thugs asking for more money and benefits. A month later lost her job. Well done!!!
also, the Chinese are coming from a very different starting place -- severe poverty. Many Chinese working today were once dirt poor or are aware of others Chinese that are still in poverty. That makes them more willing (not happy) to work harder and longer for less. But, this goes back to globalization -- free trade, etc. We did not compete well against the Japanese in the 80s, we are not against the Chinese the last couple of decades. Developed societies are more concerned with decent living than wages/career. Chinese are more concerned with putting food on the table.
Perhaps explain why the President's family makes all their clothing and other products ( including MEGA HATS) in China, Indonesia, Bangladesh? The union should offer to buy the company and compete for product sales globally. Wages would then depend on profit!
What hell do you know about working mentality of American or non Asian. You need money to pay rent everything run on money. You know what Chinese should just work with no pay then tell me how you feel. American pull out and use 1970 act to bring back jobs in America we need them not them since they have different mentality
The American lady did not states the facts, USA dismantled Unions in 1990's and the pay is $12 per hour as the minimum federal wage for USA. It is the capital system that is not good for the worker.
iland300
The Chinese factory owner is
a member of the CCP … Chinese
Communist Party …. So much
for the Proletariat … in China
and in the USA.
Chinese businessman:
Now let me remind you of the real Capitalism in the old days.
China doesnt practice real capitalism
gaguy1967 China practices 20th century Capitalism
Business environment is extremely Fluid. Sustainable competitive advantage one has maybe eroded away in few months especially in technology. I would say the Definition of Capitalism now not only encompasses $$$ but Technology (Data Science, AI, automation - a New Concept of Capitalism.
Like UK used to be ?
那也是为什么中国能快速追赶美国，而美国却日渐衰落
As one chinese worker put it best in the film "I have no choice." People should be given a tolerable amount of work for a liveable wage and an opportunity to improve their life. Factory work in itself is soul numbing. Hopefully human civilization will evolve beyond it.
True , I’ve been there
Folks in Shanghai work on hyper mode for a rather lousy wage. that's what made developing economies into developed economies
This is such a great documentary. I did not aware of this before and somehow I just watched this last week. I liked a lot and I made my own review video in my channel. thanks
Koreans are similar to Chinese? As in slavery work mindset?
If American way of business model and management work, GM wouldn't had closed down and the Chinese wouldn't have the opportunity to get in. The owner already said, he would close down the business if they unionize. 100% of nothing or....?
@Obi2, The American way of business has been doing on good way. Sure, sometimes can happen some problems, and this is why we have to do anything fit with law.
At the end of 70's to beginning 80's in China, according to premier Deng Xiaoping' s "No care white or black, if you can get rich you are a Glory", and "Self-interest, Self-market" s theories: the smugglers bring as huge quantities of fake watches from Hong Kong smuggle to south China, and this kind of business have created these smugglers became the billionaires quickly, also they no need pay any tax and employees. But it caused all China states watches factories were bankruptcy, and more than 600,000 watches' related workers were laid off. this has caused the working class peoples being poor, stressed, depression, and suicide.
@Cjango Freeman How come? How come one thing is related to another? I am not a Trump supporter, but tell me why he will close down is $500M Business because Trump is raising Tariffs on some of the Chinese imports?
@Cjango Freeman I think you have to understand that China is not comparing option A or B and deciding to go with B. China is expanding anywhere! They will invest in Mexico, in US, Canada, etc. Trust me. This investor won't shut-down his $500M factory in Ohio because of the increment of tarifs. I can guarantee you that.
@Cjango Freeman Trump is the last thing from a warhawk.
@@nadominhoca They will close it down as soon as they find a way to move their investment somewhere else that has better profit margins. That is how it works.
The workers may have some legitimate grievances, but they should take their political organizing efforts to their government instead of their employer.
16:10 the anchor just laughs at the caller who is being completely sincere and bringing up the blatant truths they are ignoring - the union employees were threatened and/or fired. It's eerie.
Why not be fired if you cannot do what the Chinese shift dd achieve, did grandly f@kd by communists? Enjoy capitalism still? 23tril of debt keep rising. That's why wages increased you guys yourself brought this mess cause you keep complaining and complaining sto winning allready. Shut up and show what sacrifice you can offer inside the company
@@savkot6051 unlike the Chinese , Americans value the lives & labor of their fellow citizens
that's life in China
Till the time law were enacted to protect US workers, the US factory owners in the olden days treated their workers much worse. Just the the novel "the Jungle" by Upton Sinclair.
Until a US factory created shift work and the 40-hour work week.
You have a Socialist mentality.
I watched the documentary and it’s so shameful how the mentality of “ we deserve more because we’re Americans “ forces employers to close businesses. Unions are the cancer of the work place. In the documentary one guy makes a comment that he doesn’t want Chinese tv shows play in the break room because “this is America “
yerovi86 first off all the living standard in the US is much higher than in China. In the US you can’t even afford enough food from the wages they pay in China.
With an minimum wage off 7.25 dollar you live under the poverty line.
I live in The Netherlands and for the last hundred years we have unions for every kind off work you can think off.
The employers have there own unions. The unions off the employees and the unions off the employers are negotiating every couple off years the wages and the employment conditions together with benefits. The government is functioning as an mediator. Workers are a lot better off then in the US. We are a rich country with a lot off trade and plenty enough work. Unlike the US we did not dwell in the past. So when manufacturing jobs disappeared and the coal mines closed the government schooled the workers that lost there job and actively looked for alternative work. We never expected it will come back and we never ask for it. We are very down to earth and right away thought, it is what it is let’s move on.
It is not the unions or that workers wants to much. It is an attitude problem. Holding on to the past and not wanting to change. A lot off Americans want to go back to the fifties and sixties. Does days are gone.
@@Bruintjebeer6 Those days could come back if we closed our borders, kicked out the foreigners whi displace us and became completely self contained and self sufficient, which we actually could do.
There are currently 11 million job vacancies in America for unskilled workers. Americans would rather stay home than do those kinds of jobs.
很多讨论进入了一个误区，尤其是说这是一个文化冲突。其实应该是一个有关“关公战秦琼”的争论。几千年来中国人的这种“刻苦勤劳”是被“饥饿”逼的，几千年来一直为“吃饱”而奋斗，而我们这一代勉勉强强进入到为了“吃好”的阶段。所以，对我们来说，工作比其它的更重要，包括长时间的工作，次一点的工作环境，低工资都是次要的。尽管现在我们已经摆脱了饥饿，但“刻苦勤劳”的mindset还是根深蒂固的，尽管如此，也不会持续太久了。美国工人“懒散”的今天，就是我们下一代工人的明天。很难想象我们的下一代还会像我们这一代这么的拼就象我们这一代觉得我们父母的那一代不可思议一样。他们会向资方提出各种要求的，当矛盾凸显时，工会自然就是他们的代言人了。这给企业的提示是，当你找一个养尊处优的人当保姆时，要考虑再三，这个人是不是当保姆的料，尽管你给他的工资高点儿。给政府的启示是，这个矛盾早晚都会出现，怎么提前制定更好的政策和技术（譬如，人工智能和自动化）来平衡劳资方面的矛盾，而不是工会过度的所求来阻挠企业的运营，从而又回到“大锅饭”的年代。
也不是吧。。。。就是企业习惯了低成本的东西了，这种低成本只存在于农民工进城的过程中，也就是中国没有工业化，靠着毛时代的平等的遗泽，可以以低于劳动力再生产的成本压榨。。一旦完成工业化，你就必须按照工业化的工人阶级的劳动力再生产的成本进行内循环了。。。本身吃苦耐劳不是好事。尤其是这种产品。。。收入太低，生产的东西太多，没人消费，就经济危机了。完成工业化以后，生产的价格和支付给社会的收入总量得是一样的。卖钱多，发钱少，最后东西就卖不出去了。理想状态下，全行业公司利润应该是不超过3%的。微粒刚刚好。
Maos Great Leap Forward , that explains why everyone still hungry in that country!
GM ....why do Americans need more than one car to a family? We see 2 car garages are now passé. Any upper class family can have up to 4 car garages. The ultra rich have multiple cars in multiple locations to go with their multiple homes. I think good honest working and middle class perhaps have doubts about this kind of extravagancy. If GM folded, a good person could find other work. The coal miners who lost jobs in mines are now being trained as bee keepers. Yep!
When America becomes humble in a sincerely honest way, we can be inventive as hell. But we can't ever survive eating nuts & bolts and rubber tires.
☮️
Fuyao should have made the Windows in Mexico, a free trade partner, and truck them into the states.
Why? Are you just evil? Lol
Don’t take the moral high ground by saying that fuyao should let the workers unionize and pay more for their benefits unless you are the one paying. It is cutthroat competition. Fuyao was struggling to make ends meet. Use laws and regulations for working standards. Union most of the time represents low efficiency. I am a worker and used to belong to a union. They function like a mob. you pay protection fee and you get unjustified benefits paid by your employer. Worse than socialism.
Even work in a danger ? thats insane
방구머겅 factories are always dangerous
@@방구머겅 I said use laws and regulations. Safety has been there for ages. Don't present such simple and meaningless questions. No sensible people would be against safety and basic human rights.
@@edward6297 is that so? the workers in Netflix video said diff tho?
@@방구머겅 Is that first time you saw grumpy employees? Run a business yourself. You will probably see more. People get hurt everywhere. I choked badly today while eating.
Focus on 5g factory, less worker, more product means price became low. People more time in creativity.
Yes, they can be creative at finding food in dumpsters, finding a place to sleep, etc. Without low skill jobs many people will be unemployable, regardless of training.
This movie makes Andrew Yang that much more relevant.
I just felt disgusted watching the documentary, i live in Ohio . Im proud to be apart of the UAW
@Will Buy It all the way around but also the Chinese . I said what i said
Everyone wants more, a higher wage, a decent job and 35 hours per week. give them all or nothing, that's why factory moves out of the USA.
Let's hope you still have a job few years from now.
thats why you were poor
@@trinat347 cause the Chinese did better you mean? You never learn your lesson and try to hide behind laws at the same time where your economy falling apart! This is really delusional comments like yours I mean. Do something for your country like the Chinese do. That's the lesson you didn't understand.
Where can we find this movie? How many minutes is the movie? Can we download it ?
110minutes
Mike Lindner it’s on Netflix
Netflix.
GM had 2400 workers with a average pay of $25 a hour 5 days a week for 50 weeks ( if you count the other days for vacation as non paid) is around $120,000,000 a year on payroll.
The average company of this size pays around $1,106 on cleaning supplies and toilet paper / soap a month so that's $13,272
GM also provided them Health Care coverage the average coverage plan over the course of a year the company would pay $2,000 so that's $4,800,000
Thats $124,813,272 just to have employees ... you would still have to pay any suppliers/ vendors, electricity, water, trash, sewer... so just to hire that many employees and give them Health Care coverage and somewhere to shit and wash their hands , three weeks off a year and pay them for 8 hour shift..
That's why GM is bankrupt, They hire too many worker and The worker are paying too expensive compare to their productivity. No wonder most of usa manufacture are moving to china and vietnam
@@Fauzanarief-n7i it's is what you get and what you're giving from a business perspective. If everything I've stated above as a businessman I'm giving to the employee then I should have an employee that is willing to bust their tail and be highly productive instead of figuring out a way to unionize just to be lazy
@@KingGh0st_o we'll they could hire a robot to improve productivity without overwork
Battle between slaves vs workers. That's my takeaway from this film.
this is developing economy worker ethics vs a rotting welare economy
Maybe the Chinese assembly line workers should organize into unions so that they don't have to work the "996" schedule anymore. 9AM to 9PM, 6 days a week. THERE IS MORE TO LIFE THAN WORK. Labor unions fought this battle at the end of the 19th century. Workers should not have to work slave hours. Workers need dignity, too.
Also note the Chinese pay their workers in pennies and they have a huge wage gap where their workers are basically living in poverty
It's okay to leave OHIO once in a while to see the world...
@poewhite oh they are not gonna miss you also, believe me that. I am Greek, but I enjoyed where the Chinese shift was the most productive. Fkd by the so bad communists socialists? 😅 Enjoy it.
@@savkot6051 a Greek talking about economics hahaha talk about irony.
@@lriddle21 yeah Ironie, since tiny little Greece didn't get any preparations or what's being looted out of Greece or the ppl got killed and we didn't menage to get for the families had victims not even a penny and the good so called politicians in 1953 wrote of the debt of Germany. We where forced to bring in German and French cars so these was a matter of time but the irony is more you want to talk about Greeks debt problem but more besides don't want to talk about yours 23trillion debt problem
@@lriddle21 the irony is more that you hate communism and you don't get the lesson learned by them.
I watch the full movie, there is a guy name ROB, he was welcome chinese, treat chinese best food, teach them play guns where china forbided, but after 2.5year he still be fired.
Yeah evil china boss.
Check this 11:30. What is he saying? “General Motors could not longer support that factory” … I guess the truth was: GM dropped the factory-like a hot potato as soon as they could make enough profits, regardless of the workers … I find it zynistic in that context to use the word “support”.
Thought provoking. That s the curel reality of global competition. Terms u dismiss are good enough for others half a world away. The real answer IS to move on, do something they can't do. But that s hard too. Who says life s easy though? No one owes anyone a living.
chf gbp to the point. And a good point.
No but what they owe is a functioning and safe environment
Also a livable wage , ppl are destroying the working class
This lady interviewing the American lady really bothered me. Rude and condescending. Totally biased as well. Not surprising.
GE asked Fuyao to open a factory in the US
how is the "Chinese way" and worse than the "American way"? American companies simply moved the factories to China precisely to be able to do the same things. With some factories coming back, three things are clear: 1) wages are lower, benefits less, 2) more automation (fewer employees) and 3) longer/more work. So, where is the difference? America has always been complicit in this trend -- American CEOs and boards decided to move factories to China. American politicians passed the laws and set policies to encourage globalization and free trade so such factories in China could supply consumption in the US. China/Chinese did not put a gun to our heads! And the average American is not even voting to protect themselves -- low turnout or voting for the establishment (ie corporate) democrat or republican. no wonder things are the way they are!
the affluent society is over !
An "American" was hired to be CEO of Fuyao, and didn't "work out" so an "ethnic Chinese-American" was chosen.🤣
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Laughing so hard.... I'm crying...
So why doesn't the union buy the factory or build one and compete?
Norma Rae !!! UNION !!! CHINA grow a conscience. Why is it wrong for a working man to make a profit?
I really like a sentence in this film,” Americans are overconfident.” Honestly, who is not a SLAVE of life? If you are not, may be you are a billionaire:）Don’t forget that better workers gain better pay, especially in this high-competitive and technology-driven world. Of course “better” means efficiency, productivity and high-quality.
A slave of Life…you need to live a little
These people paint a very rosy picture of jobs being created by the Chinese in the US but the reality a 100,000 jobs, 200,000, or even 500,000 jobs will not equal the 20 million lost due to the lack strategy when building the relationship with China beginning in the 70's. Because the US wealth was control by the few the results where horrific. The few thought only about there own personal wealth with complete disregard for the wealth of all Americans. China on the other hand has its wealth controlled by the state, the wealthy of China are control by the government who has the it's base interest in the people. America will continue to digress to a slum for most and a condo for others with the wealthy living in their feudal castle estates.
Blah blah about wealth and Chinese trying to create jobs - know where the wealth is going ? Too bad Americaucks do not get it and welcome butchery of peasants nations calling it "war"
United States Bombings of Other Countries. America’s “Bombing List”
www.globalresearch.ca/united-states-bombings-of-other-countries-americas-bombing-list/5533371
The only one of the three I'd hire in that picture... the Chinese guy, just from the look of them you can tell the other two will be lazy and complain a lot, just saying.
우리집 보일라 소리에 맞춰 음향소란에 목숨건 김말이가 보일라꺼지게하면 보일라
웅변소리와 똑같은 성악소리로 보일라 음향냄 기계도 산거 같음
Personally, China should not invest in USA, not then, not now, not in the future. There is simply a huge cultural and work ethics differences. I dont see it succeeding.
X Y Z
Chinese workers are being replaced
by workers in Vietnam and Africa
as well as by robots, automation
etc.. Everyone is more or less in
the same boat, so to speak, in
those types of jobs.
GE asked Fuyao to open a factory in USA
2 bucks more for forgoing for union , compensations and labor rights
That is bullshit. Would never work for china owned companies.
What if "American" factory workers don't care about a cultural show, put on by their factory higher ups, but want to chill with their children, take a hike in nature, or just get a good night's sleep!
These big shows don't mean happiness, because while some are forced to sing & dance per CCP regulatory injunctions, other citizens practicing a form of peaceful spiritual meditation (Falun Gong) are beaten, arrested, imprisoned without trial, given a number instead of a name, and finally forced to be operated on for their organs. (They don't survive this, their corpses are burned in hospital boiler rooms.
There were 70 to 100 MILLION of these peaceful practicioners before the crackdown in 1999. This is now hush hush.
Google it .
Oh people, all that glitters IS NOT GOLD.
가게는 누가 적발하고 길거리는 신고하고 야 집안에 누가 들어오냐 집안에서는 마음대로
There’s a reason GM shriveled up & Chinese companies bloom
People from countries all over the world want to live in the USA(legally or not). Why the government of yours does not use the works of those peoples, like the mexicans, ensuring that these people will not be deported without guarantees and that you can get the factories out of China?People from countries all over the world want to live in the USA, because the government of yours does not use the labor force like the Mexicans, ensuring that these people will not be deported without guarantees and that you can get the factories out of China? not depriving it so much, because they no longer invest in the American continent (central and south america) which is better strategically?
오스트레일리아 광고에 열심히 나오고 공공차량에 다운증후군 임신떄 보라고
China bosses try work in America is different than in China. China bosses should follow the working laws in the us. USA has overtime pay which china does not. America has workers comp, osha safety in working conditions, and other American comply working laws that china does not comply working in US. Many culture clashes. China companies don’t work in America. China companies represent communism, don’t ever work for Chinese owned companies. Chinese companies = communism. American companies = safety work environment, equal pay, ot pay, no culture clashes, no force work. America has pay holidays off, sick days, overtime pay to work on certain holidays, overtime automatic over 40 hours, which Chinese boss from china companies will not comply to. China bosses don’t comply with environment issues, they dispose chemical waste into sewer which is environmental issues. China try to pollute our water, air, and land like they did in their own country. America should ban china owned operations in America.
🍒 NO CHERRY 🥤 NO DEAL 🍒
세금은 게이가족은 다 무직인데 어디서 나서 세금낼까
both culture need be compromised certain steps. very interesting film, it will be just a start in coming years, not only one case. we will see.
After trump trade war the USA trade deficit went up from 500 billion usd up to 880 billion usd.
중국계 필리핀 홍콩계 필리핀 중국계미국인필리핀 오랑우탄과김말이
대단한 게이생모인지 생부인지 대단한 멘탈
Factories are finished in the west.
Well we can't eat nuts and bolts and rubber tires. The land is not only plentiful but fertile, so if ALL factories, especially slaughterhouses meat packing inhumane chicken, & pig factories close down, there could be a peaceful society for good people. Okay, if you are starving, go hunting, but in nature you won't find a forest strew with freshly butchered carcasses all laid out in a row. No, even carnivorous animals are vicious and will kill prey when they are HUNGRY.
why not re-think the causes of acute and chronic mental & physical distress ? Any good reason?
不知道美国人是怎么想的，如果你要求工厂提高时薪，首先你得为工厂获得利润，而可笑的是福耀还没有通过工人获得盈利工人就要求提高待遇，如果我是老板我也会解雇他们，我聘用你是让你为工厂盈利，而不是来找麻烦的，不知道为什么美国人不懂这个道理，也许真的太过于自信了。
我有贴Ohio州2021 最低时薪8.8/hr (可以谷歌）而且是2021 甚至2022 的标准。Fuyao从2018 就发放14/hr. 数据说话更方便。真的是不太懂为什么那些人希望GM的事在当地重演。
From this film producer and the comments from USA, I can see American people are good people, they understand Chinese people are good friends of American. In Chinese language America is ""美国""。""美国""means ""Beautiful Country"". It proves from Day One China thinks American are beautiful country with beautiful people. It proves from Day One Chinese has best impression of United States. 美国~is the only beautiful country in Chinese language. 99% of Chinese including Communist party members think American people have beautiful heart. We only have one earth, we should be a big family and live together harmony. That's the hope of every Chinese people including every Communist party member. We need peace to live. We are family.
When you stop threatening my country with extreme violence I'll believe you
아이들 기 다죽으면 나타나는 게이머미
1. they FIRED everybody in this movie
2. they fired the whole US management
3. worst wages
4. they called all US employees donkeys and treated them like shit
5. most employees will be replaced by robots soon
6. nice movie LOL
When a factory is facing losses and cannot afford high wages, then the union organizes a strike and asks for a rise in wages. You can think about what the factory management will do, the factory can only choose to close down, what else can they do? Does the factory management go to the bank to lend money to the workers to raise high wages? Why does GM go bankrupt? Is it necessary for Chinese companies to repeat the same mistakes?
The factory hired 2000 workers and will hire more.
Thank you! 9% of the positive comments on this video are all Chinese. They tend to delete the comments that point out China's arrogance. Sorry, no slave labor in US Fuyao...
@@branstasko1 If you are a boss, do you want your employees to help you make money or get into trouble? Don't live in your own world, "What do I need to do, that is realistic"
The gap of rich and poor is much higher in China.
보건증도 필요없고 너하고싶어하는 부탄가스먹고 본드먹고 연기는 티가 안나고
Forklift Operator lost everything and was living at her sister's basement. Managed to get a job at Fuyao. A few months later managed to move to a small apartment and start moving on with her life. A couple of months later joined the unions thugs asking for more money and benefits. A month later lost her job. Well done!!!
also, the Chinese are coming from a very different starting place -- severe poverty. Many Chinese working today were once dirt poor or are aware of others Chinese that are still in poverty. That makes them more willing (not happy) to work harder and longer for less. But, this goes back to globalization -- free trade, etc. We did not compete well against the Japanese in the 80s, we are not against the Chinese the last couple of decades. Developed societies are more concerned with decent living than wages/career. Chinese are more concerned with putting food on the table.
A film by the Obamas?
오랑우탄과 김말이
임신했을때 다운증후군 왔다갔다 하게 한거
Perhaps explain why the President's family makes all their clothing and other products ( including MEGA HATS) in China, Indonesia, Bangladesh?
The union should offer to buy the company and compete for product sales globally. Wages would then depend on profit!
보건증없는 가정이사
김말이옆에 게이많타
Iwant do busies with u inuganda
What hell do you know about working mentality of American or non Asian. You need money to pay rent everything run on money. You know what Chinese should just work with no pay then tell me how you feel. American pull out and use 1970 act to bring back jobs in America we need them not them since they have different mentality