This original version is the best version of this song. I like when it's only Ka Kui singing it. This song is one of my favourite. It's genius and a grand masterpiece!
ewan4ever , bro , I can sing exactly similar to him in this song with a guitar but playing guitar still in a practice mood . This version have a good guitar solo clearly hear Ka ku is talking to Paul guitar sound . Very good song by so far in Chinese rock !
This is the BEST version, my most favorite of KaKui's early composition. So precious.I am so worry that it disappears on RUclips. because of license problem.
Paul Wong's guitar playing is heartbreakingly beautiful. In the melancholic embrace of his arms, the guitar wept with a soulful lament, its strings trembling as if haunted by unseen specters. Within its wooden confines, a tempest of emotions swirled, at once a gentle dirge and a violent storm of unrest. The haunting melody spilled forth like a forlorn spirit, yearning to escape its earthly confines and traverse the realms of the unknown.
This guitar solo alway hit my hard ! After 15 years of practicing but still can’t master it ! One day I will be able to solo this whole song with the technology we have. Then I will post on RUclips lol
this version was nice bt i can't find this version thru sogou, baidu or even limewire .. could someone plss tell me where to download this versions ? thank you.
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
2023年我都仲聽緊。家駒～你在遠方好嗎😭😭
每日必聽/百聽不厭/只有家駒。這7分鐘太過癮，開車放大聲到極限。
2023.1.17
家駒厲害的地方就是透過他的歌聲，他的歌曲，把聽眾帶進那首歌的情境裡，真的感同身受。第一次聽這個版本，完全可以感受到他的無奈⋯⋯
2017 還是在聽，而且還是每日都聽，感覺到家駒的音樂路是多麼的艱辛，一路堅持著他的理想，如果人死後真的有靈有性，家駒應該感到滿足，他很成功，他的音樂影響了所有人，能讓人上進又能讓人反思，有了你，使我明白什麼叫音樂，使我愛上音樂同時更愛上了你，這樣一愛就是幾十年了，是永恆的愛，每次聽你唱歌我會流淚，捨不得你的離開，你是獨一無二，無人取代！
永遠沒人可以代替你。
Y u k M e i K o n g M e too。
好的音樂, 一兩秒便能帶動你的情緒
@@OldSchoolLadYES!!!!!❤❤❤❤😊
係聽過最好聽，最動聽，最打動人的歌，非家駒的歌莫屬。兼每日都要聽家駒唱的歌，上youtube 睇佢永遠年輕的樣，真的好懷念家駒。家駒的離開，帶給我們（fans）心裏永遠的痛，同無盡的惋惜。
對! 每天都最少上來一次聽聽家駒的聲音，看看他永遠年青的樣子! 真的沒法忘記他
2023 繼續聼 ♥
家駒在嗎.為何每次我來這聽這首7分鐘.再見理想你獨唱版本.時間7分鐘過很快.好像帶我進入空靈世界心靈的感覺.
今生忘了不了的聲音
有好常一段時間，沒有工作的時候，特別是在午夜時分，都是他歌聲陪伴我渡過
好音樂能衝破時間，幾時聽都唔覺老土
家駒是港人的驕傲，你叫我言之無物我仲辛苦，家駒係歌迷心目中永遠是不老男神，他離開我們時只有31歲蒼天点解可以咁殘忍，說到這裡眼淚還是狂野時速
每一次听到这首歌的intro我总是有种想哭的感觉，不知道你们也是一样呢？
Tan Pey Shin 有同感，真的哭了
Tan Pey Shin 真的很伤心 哭了😭😭
T a n P e y S h i n我都是，好想喊。
@@meifei879 真的想哭
+1
真的是無法忘記的聲音,到了這年代還是那麼好聽，可見當時他所做的音樂早已超越~
十1
許祐寧十1
2024 六月28日在聽
深夜3時18分還在聽家駒唱歌。
家駒講過佢地嘅歌5糸羅尼娛樂架糸羅黎欣賞嘅，所以每次聽佢既歌都會留意 旋律同歌詞，再見理想同午夜怨曲都糸我好鐘意嘅歌，佢糸唱緊Beyond既經曆，好有內心世界，家駒你好野，希望你糸天國真正做到自由自我，永遠高唱我歌，祝你愉快💞💓💗🎼🎵🎶🎸🎻😘🤘🤘
呢個版本真係第一次聽，贊!
家駒用自己的靈魂去唱這首歌，風格獨有，那種無奈與哀怨盡於歌聲中流淌着，好傷感啊！ 一絕... ❤️❤️😢😢😢
Ka Kui still alive in my heart.
This original version is the best version of this song. I like when it's only Ka Kui singing it. This song is one of my favourite. It's genius and a grand masterpiece!
ewan4ever , bro , I can sing exactly similar to him in this song with a guitar but playing guitar still in a practice mood . This version have a good guitar solo clearly hear Ka ku is talking to Paul guitar sound . Very good song by so far in Chinese rock !
光聽前奏，就覺家駒想說深埋內心的故事，很沈重又滿懷難伸的理想，一起高呼rock'n roll....家駒的音樂，間奏都讓人意猶未盡。
黃貫中編得很好
永遠的黃家駒
這是靈魂, 這是詩一般的絕美樂章, 淒冷得令人茫然落淚 ...
更增添對家駒的無限思念 ...
非常感激你無私的分享, 多謝哂!
今天是2019，5月14日想念家駒唯一偶像
2019年5月20日還在聽，家駒的歌曲令人心痛，但依然想聽。
2019/2/25還在聽，懷念家駒，每天都要報到，希望家駒在天堂可做他愛做的事。
我又上來看你了，聽你獨唱再見理想。
最具影响力的音乐人
没有之一
黃家駒世界級的音樂傢自從家駒不再樂坦就是娱乐圈说得没错，家驹提早祝你生日快乐
好多家駒嘅歌我一路聽一路唱都會喊,呢首都唔例外,我而家喊緊!家駒啲歌感染力好大!
2016了！我仍然在聽，有你相伴無憾一生！
2022年4月3日。又來聽你獨唱。再見理想
一億個懷念,家駒
从88年听到这个声音开始至今无法忘怀！
2020年的今天，小弟还在听着Beyond的歌曲。。。这首也不例外！家驹，永在怀念中。
Wong Ka Kui was a great lyricist and melody maker. We sorely miss him. May the best go with him, wherever he is.
20220319 來報到，陶醉一下....😍😍🎧
今日我还在听(家驹)所唱的每首歌曲，家驹家驹(您)永远永远都是我♥中的歌神很想念想念您，很想去看看您💖💖💖
家驹独唱版，多一份忧伤。
我已經找到對這首歌的感覺了，那就是心疼
每次聽都好感觸，都會諗起好耐無見嘅朋友。唔知點解家駒好多歌都唱出我心中所想，一聽就唔想停
2022 🤟🤟家駒 我又LOOP 您尐歌呀黎~
他就像是一杯酒一樣，越沈越香
他曾講過 要將心裏想講 同周圍所感受嘅事物 要大聲咁唱畀大家聽， 所以 佢嘅歌聲係充滿情感㗎， 佢嘅悲傷佢嘅喜悅大家從佢嘅歌聲裏面可以聽得好清楚㗎！
一起高呼rock 'n roll ,一起高呼rock 'n roll,一起高呼rock 'n roll,oh
盡在不言中，永遠音樂同聲音永記心中👍👍👍🤟🤟🤟
2014年仍是會聽而且覺得好好聽
8/6/2019年還會繼續聽下去。
I miss him.
听在耳边，痛在心里。
回想起1993，6月30日。。。很悲伤，悲痛和感伤。
見到又忍唔住㩒入黎😍😍
Finally found this the very original version. Awesome!!! 🤟🏻
2017近2018.....
我依然再听着!
依旧那么好听
無限♥你念你想你
from their ep album 再見理想 (1986)
仍然在聽🤘🤘🤘
2022 . Just found this very original version. Precious one!
yes, me too. He brings out the emotions of this song very well.
Awesome song
怀念家驹~想你了 😭😭😭
想念好聽，今日已經是2O15，12月9日，一天又一天，
今天已是2019年5月22日，一年又一年，26個年頭了，還繼續聽家駒的歌曲。
This is the BEST version, my most favorite of KaKui's early composition. So precious.I am so worry that it disappears on RUclips. because of license problem.
3:40~3:55短短15秒的電吉他尾音+木吉他刷和弦的節拍
.......家駒曾說他要表達的心境，是用音樂而不是文字\]
superb
睡不着总听
This song is as relevant as ever... 2020 has been unkind for humanity. Let's keep chanting Rock n' Roll!
2018还在听💕💕💕
Paul Wong's guitar playing is heartbreakingly beautiful. In the melancholic embrace of his arms, the guitar wept with a soulful lament, its strings trembling as if haunted by unseen specters. Within its wooden confines, a tempest of emotions swirled, at once a gentle dirge and a violent storm of unrest. The haunting melody spilled forth like a forlorn spirit, yearning to escape its earthly confines and traverse the realms of the unknown.
I really miss Wong Ka kui...Thank you for you for this video.Wong Ka Kui is still alive in my heart.❤😢
在见理想。。。。
😢天妒英才😢😢
2016 就是要聽
19/9/2020還是要聽。
Miss you so so so much 😭 😭 😭
My fav song. just described my sad feelings
T-T rip kai kui
再見理想
GREAT~
Amazing... you never know and he's taking it to the next level
THANKS FOR UPLOAD
心中一股冲劲勇闯。。Rock N roll。。2020.12.05.
this version is hard to find
tks vm for sharing
This guitar solo alway hit my hard ! After 15 years of practicing but still can’t master it ! One day I will be able to solo this whole song with the technology we have. Then I will post on RUclips lol
Still waiting your RUclips video
@@PageCarteller still trying bro,
@@beyondreamtime420 good luck
Thanks for this... love it
wow, the version is far better than the other one I have. thx man!
那年夏天6月30日
一起高呼rock ' n roll
rare!
👍👍👍🤘🤘🤘❤❤❤
这是哪个版本？很好听 我喜欢里面的吉他
这是他们的第一张专辑，自资出版那张，86年的
Angie Ng ku
Ka kui
Uncle Lee
May
RHB
Soon
Following Tomorrow
Forever powder
A/C
Unplugged Live
Own Lee
Beyond
BEYOND
Classic Following Music ABC
Ali
BEYOND rock
遺憾80-90年代大部份香港人剩係鍾意聽譚詠倫張國榮張學友呢啲唔識創作一味翻唱日文歌嘅歌手,而對beyond 呢啲咁有深度咁有才華嘅樂隊唔係太欣賞, 搞到家駒同其他beyond成員要出走日本, 後尾乜嘢悲劇大家都清楚
no problemo!
ok
22/11/2019
不知道為什麼，對它這首獨唱特別偏好
good gan dong
this version was nice bt i can't find this version thru sogou, baidu or even limewire .. could someone plss tell me where to download this versions ? thank you.
Found it yet?
❤❤❤❤❤❤😢😢 excellent......thank ....you......very.....much.....2024......september......
17....❤❤❤❤❤❤😢😢
Mingzhi