Origin of Judaism - A Brief History | 5 MINUTES

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 2 окт 2024
  • Judaism is the world’s oldest monotheistic religion, dating back nearly 4,000 years.
    This video covers the brief history of Judaism, from it's beginnings to the present day.
    Judaism, at its core, is a monotheistic religion with Jewish roots. The first known organized religious group came about in the second millennium BC.
    About 5 Minutes:
    5 Minutes' mission is to produce Well-researched, Engaging, Simple and Concise History educational material for free.
    RESOURCES:
    -National Geographic
    www.nationalge...
    -History.com
    www.history.co...
    -Encyclopedia Britannica
    www.britannica...
    -WorldHistory.org
    www.worldhisto...
    -Wikipedia
    en.wikipedia.o...
    -BBC
    www.bbc.co.uk/...
    -Crash Course
    • Christianity from Juda...
    Image and Footage Credits:
    -Wikimedia Commons (Arpingstone/ INS Pirat/ the Providence Lithograph Company/ Rembrandt/ James Tissot/ HOWI/ Eickenberg/ Michel Wolgemut, Wilhelm Pleydenwurff/ Dr Jorgen/ photographer Becklectic/ Triggerhippie4/ Remitamine/ Tm/ Alonso de Mendoza/ Magnus Manske/ Guise/ Lecen/ Themadchopper/ McLeod/ Eloquence/ Poeticbent/ Jonund/ New York Ward, Lock/ Fæ/ Blaisio Ugolino/ Makinal/ Tuxyso/ Bert Kaufmann/ comakut/ FastilyClone/ Aethralis/ Mattes/ Sodabottle/ Cropbot/ CarlosVdeHabsburgo/ Mathiasrex/ Mykola Ivasiuk/ Triggerhippie4/ Remitamine/ KlausSchwab/Andrew J.Kurbiko/ Steerpike/ Eduardo Aguiar Pacheco/ Tagishsimon/ Shawarsh/ FMSky/ Jacek Halicki/ Adam Cuerden)
    -Pixabay (GDJ)
    -Pinterest (Sloane Simpson/ Mike Kinde)
    • The Future Of Energy S...
    images.app.goo...
    images.app.goo...
    • History of the Jews - ...
    images.app.goo...
    images.app.goo...
    images.app.goo...
    images.app.goo...
    images.app.goo...
    • History of the Jews - ...
    images.app.goo...
    upload.wikimed...
    images.app.goo...
    images.app.goo...
    images.app.goo...
    images.app.goo...
    pixabay.com/ph...
    Music:
    The Road To Mecca by Vlada Balas
    Sound Effects:
    freesound.org/...
    freesound.org/...
    freesound.org/...
    freesound.org/...
    freesound.org/...
    freesound.org/...
    freesound.org/... freesound.org/...
    freesound.org/...
    freesound.org/...
    • Video
    __
    Want to find 5 Minutes elsewhere on the internet?
    Facebook - / 5-minutes-10. .
    Twitter - / 5minute87989295

Комментарии • 956

  • @5minutes762
    @5minutes762  2 года назад +40

    IMPORTANT MESSAGE: URGENT REQUEST FOR SUPPORT FOR THE CHANNEL FANS BEFORE HAVING TO PUT AN END TO THE PROJECT!
    We have been striving to work on this channel (5 Minutes), producing high quality content that is also concise in as little as Minutes. We thought that this could be interesting to learn curated information in a very short period of time, especially given the quick pace of today's world.
    However, unfortunately, after 1 year of consistent and patient work and regular posting of at least 1 video every 2 weeks, we have been disappointed to see that the channel has not really taken off on RUclips. With Less than 1,000 subs and as little as 300 views per video, we see no other choice but having to halt and put an end to this project we really loved and enjoyed!
    We involved different RUclips experts to help us propagate the knowledge offered by this channel but the results have been modest. We understood that such low traction so far may be due to changes done by RUclips on its ranking algorithms to compete with platforms such as TikTok in entertainment videos (dance, music, fun, cooking, sports...).
    Although this is a hypothesis and is definitely not verified, we are unable to pursue this project for more than this past year given that it didn't really achieve its number 1 goal, which was reaching as much people as possible around the world and disseminating knowledge in a compelling way.
    We will still be publishing our last 3-4 videos over the next couple months.
    We are writing this to ask for your support in case there is anything you can do, such as sharing, liking, posting on other platforms, or contributing to our Patreon page (www.patreon.com/5_minutes).
    If not, then no worries, we thank you very much for liking our content and for following it!
    All the best!

    • @Chosenone978
      @Chosenone978 Год назад

      Everything you said is a lie

    • @jasonwalsh5277
      @jasonwalsh5277 Год назад +2

      This is the first time I've watched your channel and I loved it. That's a bummer it's not taking off, but I'll watch and like your videos and hopefully it will take off eventually. I think I'm going to send my dad this one because he has no idea about any of this

    • @LordJesusChristisGodandSaviour
      @LordJesusChristisGodandSaviour Год назад +1

      God, the Lord Jesus Christ loves you! Restore your relationship with God by repenting of your sins and putting your faith in Jesus Christ, "... that Christ died for our sins according to the Scriptures, and that He was buried, and that He was raised on the third day according to the Scriptures..." (1 Corinthians 15:3-4)

    • @urstruly00
      @urstruly00 Год назад

      Too many mistakes. The old testament was not a Jewish text. It was a Hebrew text ancient Hebrew. Jews are from Judah, the son of Jacob. Moses, Noah, Adam, Abraham, Isaac Elijah none are Jews. Semitism came from the son of Noah, Shem not Jews. Jews We’re not a thing for many many many generations later. Israel and Judah or separate do not the same thing. Where is. Jacob Israel, favorite child, Joseph true Israel from His beloved, Rachel? Jews are not gods, chosen people doesn’t say Jews in Deuteronomy. Choose her from Leah, which Jake up was tricked into marrying. Please read the text you made many mistakes

    • @imrefacsar
      @imrefacsar Год назад

      ruclips.net/video/fQP273qIe2Y/видео.html

  • @HadiPirhosseinlou
    @HadiPirhosseinlou 9 месяцев назад +36

    Technically, Judaism is not the first monotheistic religion. At least a thousand years before that, Zoroaster invented monotheism, and many of the beliefs of Abrahamic religions were taken from Zoroaster's religion.

    • @maypap13
      @maypap13 8 месяцев назад +11

      Zoroastrianism, as founded by Zoroaster, likely emerged in the 6th or 7th century BCE, while the roots of Judaism trace back further, possibly to the 12th century BCE or earlier.

    • @gabeastard8572
      @gabeastard8572 2 месяца назад +1

      There was 200 year age gap as for as I know between Judaism and Zoroastrianism

    • @LarryKahal
      @LarryKahal 2 месяца назад

      Thanks, I was going to make the same comment

    • @samreya143
      @samreya143 Месяц назад +6

      And long before that he have Buddhist and Hindus.... searching divinity through self meditation and Yoga. No harms to others. Pretty sure Abrahamic God will cede to exists when people get more knowledge and wisdom

    • @silentwitness536
      @silentwitness536 Месяц назад

      ​@@maypap13 According to self aggrandizing Rabbis lol

  • @chrismathis4162
    @chrismathis4162 Год назад +637

    Nothing will make you an atheist quicker than doing a comparative study of the history of religions.

    • @dizzdizz7464
      @dizzdizz7464 Год назад +19

      True

    • @deluge848
      @deluge848 Год назад +23

      And all the non believers Insanity leads to.....???

    • @dizzdizz7464
      @dizzdizz7464 Год назад +36

      @@deluge848 leads to what?

    • @yschles
      @yschles Год назад +60

      True. I know that Christianity and Muslims essentially created their religion of the back of Judaism and some other religions at the time. But what did Judaism get its religion from? That’s what I’m trying to find out

    • @ijansk
      @ijansk Год назад +70

      ​@@yschles Sumerian mythology.

  • @wattjock
    @wattjock 10 месяцев назад +70

    Abraham was not a "Jew"; Abraham was a Hebrew.
    The term "Jew" comes from the Descendants of the house of Judah.
    This is a very important distinction.

    • @ZoharBak
      @ZoharBak 9 месяцев назад +5

      Same thing different word they are interchangeable

    • @wattjock
      @wattjock 9 месяцев назад +6

      @@ZoharBak ~ no, not at all.

    • @almamolina5935
      @almamolina5935 9 месяцев назад +3

      Actually Abraham was aramean

    • @wattjock
      @wattjock 9 месяцев назад +6

      @@almamolina5935 ~ both the Bible and the Torah clearly state he was Hebrew.
      Now, if they were known as Aramaen prior to being known as Hebrew, you will have to show me where.

    • @dianamyuri5877
      @dianamyuri5877 9 месяцев назад

      You know what’s Hebrew?

  • @itseveryday8600
    @itseveryday8600 9 месяцев назад +113

    1:37 So the Iranians actually helped Jewish people by letting them return to Judah, which lead to building of the 2nd temple.
    3:40 And Musilm & Jews lived relatively peacefully during 9 ~ 13 century.
    Also, under Ottoman empire Musilm & Jews lived relatively peacefully, between 16th to 19th century.
    So it seems that Britain messed things up really badly, for tthe 20th century.

    • @christinequinn5355
      @christinequinn5355 9 месяцев назад

      They did indeed, for MANY nations and peoples. I am from Ireland and can nearly guarantee that Britain AND France will never admit to the utter madness they created when they created the "state of Israel".
      The HOLOCAUST and the endless POGROMS were a EUROPEAN manifestation of hatred and antisemitism.
      Europe created a cultural and geographical disaster by transporting hundreds of thousands of EUROPEAN Jews directly into the Middle East, thereby disposessing hundreds of thousands of Palestinians from their native land.
      The United States, with 5 MILLION Jews, is now just as complicit as Britain and France in the present day GENOCIDE we are seeing in Gaza.

    • @captainbeidou
      @captainbeidou 8 месяцев назад

      Britain always shoves their butt into everything and turn it into sh*t!!

    • @fasted8468
      @fasted8468 8 месяцев назад +15

      Not only that but Christians and Muslims lived peacefully together as well. In 1947 the population of Palestine was approximately 10% Christian, 85% Muslim, 5% Jewish.
      Ironically, even the 75,000 Christians were removed, with full support of Christian nations, for Jewish settlers.
      It may be the only time in history where a religion removed its own followers for others, and ignored th irony of it all.
      Israel is about 1.9% Christian now, the least Christian nation in the free world.

    • @alisyr5128
      @alisyr5128 8 месяцев назад +11

      Quran and Muslim tradition have mixed attitude towards the jews , prophet Mohammed erased three Jewish tribes from Madina , committing horrible acts upon them , also Quran calls them names 😳

    • @emad3241
      @emad3241 8 месяцев назад +8

      @@alisyr5128the muslims had treaties with tens of jewish tribes, the massacres of 3 jewish tribes were purely political
      For example, banu qurayza started a war aimed at ending islam and taking control of arabia, they were defeated and massacred

  • @AD-dp3ug
    @AD-dp3ug 9 месяцев назад +4

    Judaism is not the oldest monotheistic religion, Zoroastrianism is. Enough propaganda! Most of the stories of the Old Testament were versions of the Babylonian stories.

  • @jasonleon1976
    @jasonleon1976 Год назад +60

    I am not religious (so have no bias) But I'm fascinated with history, specifically early civilization and religion in its infancy. I am not surprised why the world is in a shit state.

    • @instalyf8777
      @instalyf8777 Год назад +2

      Hinduism is not a religion. It is immortal. Its a way of life. Worshipping every being in this earth. The sun the moom the universe. Hinduism started earlier than this earth was born.

    • @urstruly00
      @urstruly00 Год назад

      @@instalyf8777nope

    • @urstruly00
      @urstruly00 Год назад +8

      This guy makes many mistakes it’s not a Jewish book it’s a Hebrew book. Jews were not a thing until many many many generations later the son of Jacob Israel is the father of the Jews. Abraham, Moses, Noah, Isaac Jacob Elijah none of these people were ever a Jews. There is no say star of David in the whole Bible. The star is a star of Remphan. They don’t know Much of the Torah, which is the old testament, the Babylonian Talmud they worship Satan again see star of Remphan. If you actually like this stuff I can share.

    • @urstruly00
      @urstruly00 Год назад

      a Semite Comes from Noah sunshine, which has nothing to do with Jews really. You don’t know anything

    • @noneofyourbusinessna740
      @noneofyourbusinessna740 11 месяцев назад

      Yes please share the truth in a world of lies ruled y satan the devil revelation 12 verse 9

  • @andrewparker1478
    @andrewparker1478 11 месяцев назад +16

    I love how Jesus is on the list of influential Jews

    • @LokendraSingh-ug3xq
      @LokendraSingh-ug3xq 10 месяцев назад

      underrated comment

    • @xNevlosx
      @xNevlosx 9 месяцев назад +2

      I just wish people knew more about the people who had him crucified.

    • @federicafarrisfortune561
      @federicafarrisfortune561 9 месяцев назад

      ​@@xNevlosxThey were arrogance personified,namely Sadducees and Pharisees.Notice similarities with today's Jews,arrogant.

    • @dr.jamesolack8504
      @dr.jamesolack8504 8 месяцев назад +2

      @@xNevlosx
      Why do you wish this??
      Just curious….

    • @Droobie03
      @Droobie03 3 дня назад

      @@xNevlosx The Romans? We already know a lot about them.

  • @doitall36
    @doitall36 11 месяцев назад +69

    Interesting how this video opened up saying Judaism was 4000 years old then contradicted itself quickly afterwards by saying that it was less than 2800 years old

    • @jamesbaker223
      @jamesbaker223 11 месяцев назад +6

      Can you provide the time stamps for me, I'm having trouble following your comment?

    • @garrymcfadden4105
      @garrymcfadden4105 10 месяцев назад +3

      @@jamesbaker223it said it began in 8bc

    • @jamesbaker223
      @jamesbaker223 10 месяцев назад

      So he speaks of the break from worship of many Gods 2800 BC to worship of one God Yahweh in 800 BC right?@@garrymcfadden4105

    • @MrRecrute
      @MrRecrute 10 месяцев назад +2

      @@garrymcfadden4105, that’s certainly extending the period of Judaism beyond even that which is written in the Hebrew Scriptures particularly as there is no archaeological evidence to support the claim.

    • @korneliusmcdonald7270
      @korneliusmcdonald7270 10 месяцев назад +5

      That's how you know it's a hidden agenda if lies he spewing

  • @collegemathematics6698
    @collegemathematics6698 11 месяцев назад +61

    I'm not Jewish but I admire the Jewish people.

    • @dr.jamesolack8504
      @dr.jamesolack8504 8 месяцев назад +6

      I’m an atheist and couldn’t care less.

    • @byrondickens
      @byrondickens 7 месяцев назад

      @@dr.jamesolack8504 So what are you even doing here, Sparky? There's plenty of channels where other atheists are crying about how they don't believe in God because some giant invisible sky daddy (who only atheists believe in anyways) didn't come down out of the clouds and change their diapers for them. One of those would surely be more to your liking.
      Other people, atheists included, might actually be interested in where different people and their ideas came from.

    • @jasonrose6288
      @jasonrose6288 5 месяцев назад +4

      ​@@dr.jamesolack8504You're more a narcissist, I think.

    • @Coollegalass
      @Coollegalass 5 месяцев назад +3

      @@jasonrose6288well said

    • @ThorBash
      @ThorBash 4 месяца назад +3

      @@dr.jamesolack8504well you cared enough to comment. Obviously his comment bothered you, as yours did to me.

  • @raycaster4398
    @raycaster4398 10 месяцев назад +20

    FYI: Zoroastrianism, older than Judaism, was the first monotheistic religion.
    Each of the major Abrahamic religions (Judaism, Catholicism, Christianity, Islam, Mormonism) were born of violence and war. In actuality, each of their ancient or old proprietary foundational tribalist books (the Jewish Bible, the New Testament, the Quran, the Book of Mormon) represent political manifestos to form a moral fabric and trust for trade, and claims for real estate, back in the days when life was nasty, brutal and short and nights were long, dark and scary.
    It's time to cast off the mythological stories, magical thinking, obsessive ritual, organized superstition, institutionalized intolerance and tribalist revanchism.

    • @hiruzenmonofuke7344
      @hiruzenmonofuke7344 10 месяцев назад +3

      The oldest recorded monotheistic tradition is actually Egyptian and probably came into being before zoroastrianism

    • @hiruzenmonofuke7344
      @hiruzenmonofuke7344 10 месяцев назад +6

      Also zoroastrianism wasn't really completely monotheistic like say Judaism .

    • @moniqueengleman873
      @moniqueengleman873 10 месяцев назад +2

      I agree with you. So much blood spilled in the name of God

    • @blusheep2
      @blusheep2 10 месяцев назад +2

      Most of what we understand about Zoroastriansim was written down 1000 years after Zoraster is said to have lived. We really don't know much about what the original religion looked like.

    • @hiruzenmonofuke7344
      @hiruzenmonofuke7344 10 месяцев назад +2

      @@blusheep2 atleast how zoroaster intended it to be

  • @Omegajunior2658
    @Omegajunior2658 2 месяца назад +6

    I may be Christian (Roman Catholic) but I am always interested in Judaism. I like Judaism. I am always being very respectful towards Judaism as well.
    By the way this video is very interesting.
    Good morning from Ireland 🇮🇪

    • @strikerpepsi2941
      @strikerpepsi2941 29 дней назад

      You are a jew actually because jesus himself is jewish

  • @Musebandiscool
    @Musebandiscool 11 месяцев назад +5

    The oldest monotheistic religion is Zoroastrianism.

  • @siddharthnayak2361
    @siddharthnayak2361 5 месяцев назад +4

    💛❤️💛❤️💛❤️💛❤️Abrahmic religion like Islam and christianity says their is only "ONE GOD" and everything is GOD made.
    But pagan religions like Hinduism says that "EVERYTHING IS GOD" so no duality ie " AHAM BRAHMASMI"💛❤️💛❤️💛❤️💛❤️💛❤️ie SANATAN DHARMA and it says " we cant distinguish GOD and GOD MADE" so "EVERYTHING IS GOD"
    So conclusion is SANATAN DHARMA OR HINDUISM is far more advanced then abrahmic religion💛❤️💛❤️💛❤️💛❤️

  • @geosenseagroproject987
    @geosenseagroproject987 11 месяцев назад +37

    Hellenistic Judaism refers to the fusion of Jewish and Greek culture and ideas that occurred during the Hellenistic period, which followed the conquests of Alexander the Great in the 4th century BCE and continued for several centuries thereafter. This period had a significant impact on Jewish thought, culture, and religious practice. Here are some key aspects of Hellenistic Judaism:
    1. Cultural Influence: The spread of Greek culture throughout the Eastern Mediterranean, including the lands where Jewish communities lived, led to the adoption of Greek language, customs, and values among some Jews. This cultural influence is often referred to as Hellenization.
    2. Translation of the Hebrew Bible: One of the most notable developments of Hellenistic Judaism was the translation of the Hebrew Bible (the Old Testament) into Greek. This translation, known as the Septuagint, allowed Greek-speaking Jews and non-Jews to access Jewish scripture and played a significant role in the dissemination of Jewish religious ideas.
    3. Philosophical Syncretism: Some Jewish thinkers during this period sought to reconcile Jewish religious beliefs with Greek philosophy. Philo of Alexandria, a prominent philosopher of this era, attempted to blend Jewish theology with Greek philosophy, particularly the teachings of Plato and Stoicism.
    4. Diaspora Communities: As Jewish communities spread throughout the Hellenistic world, they faced the challenge of maintaining their religious and cultural identity amidst the dominant Greek culture. Synagogues became important centers of Jewish life and worship.
    5. Religious Resistance: Not all Jews embraced Hellenistic culture and ideas. Some resisted Hellenization and clung to traditional Jewish practices and beliefs. The Maccabean Revolt (circa 167-160 BCE) is a notable example of such resistance, resulting in the establishment of an independent Jewish state for a period.
    6. Ethical and Moral Philosophy: Hellenistic Judaism also saw the development of ethical and moral philosophy within the Jewish tradition. Jewish thinkers explored questions of ethics, virtue, and the purpose of life in a Hellenistic context.
    Hellenistic Judaism was a complex and dynamic period in Jewish history, marked by a diversity of responses to Greek culture and ideas. While some Jews embraced aspects of Hellenization, others resisted it, and the tension between Jewish tradition and Hellenistic influence continued to shape Jewish thought and identity for centuries to come.

    • @saidmohammed7597
      @saidmohammed7597 7 месяцев назад

      The Greek conquest of Palestine was after the Parsian Cyrus conquest that built the Solomon kingdom which was destroyed by Nebuchadnezzar who took Jews to Babylon. The last conquest was the Roman empire that lasted with the Muslim take over Palestine 631 AD.

    • @crystalcvt
      @crystalcvt 4 месяца назад

      chatGPT ass response

    • @Mok377
      @Mok377 4 месяца назад +2

      Respectfully, your dancing around a lot of context. While some Jews were willingly adopting Greek culture, many were being wrongfully forced to adopt it and not allowed to keep the Torah and its commandments without consequences of imprisonment, torture, execution, confiscation of property, exile, public humiliation, the list goes on. Brit mila, keeping Shabbat, we’re made illegal. We were forced to eat non kosher foods and to commit idolatry to the Greek idols in our own temple which had been defiled by the invading Syrian Greeks. (Syrians who adopted Hellenistic Greek culture and invaded Israel and forced it’s culture on the people of israel). We had to learn Torah in secret. Look into the origins of a dreidel.
      This was a very bad period for the Jews. Not as nice as you make it sound.

  • @brianswelding
    @brianswelding Год назад +19

    Not trying to be "that guy" but isn't Zoroastrianism the world's first monotheistic religion?

    • @johnsonhunglo1993
      @johnsonhunglo1993 Год назад +4

      Vedic religion?

    • @slev6592
      @slev6592 11 месяцев назад +2

      No. Judaism is at least 3300 years old even if you don’t refer to religious scriptures.

    • @rozetalami6289
      @rozetalami6289 10 месяцев назад

      @@slev6592I have read that Zoroastrianism was there before Jimudaism like 4000 BCE but to be honest all this beliefs are engraved into us by books that say that this person or that person when we don’t really know the truth because things in centuries can be transmitted and reconstructed according to the era and the people that influenced history.

    • @slev6592
      @slev6592 10 месяцев назад

      @@rozetalami6289 the thing is that if you look at a site like the altar of Joshua on mt Ebal or some Egyptian texts that mention the Jewish name of God it is clear that Judaism is at least 3300 years old even if you totally disregard the Jewish scriptures. I am not sure that the same can be said about Zoroastrianism.

    • @AverageHandEnjoyer-jp3xu
      @AverageHandEnjoyer-jp3xu 8 месяцев назад +4

      ​@@sandy11711"Monotheistic".
      Hinduism is polytheistic

  • @gemleollc4755
    @gemleollc4755 11 месяцев назад +18

    During WWII, natives of South Pacific islands saw American and Japanese fighter planes flying in the sky as gods. Only when the Americans landed did the natives realize the flying machines were not gods. Think about it.

    • @dr.jamesolack8504
      @dr.jamesolack8504 8 месяцев назад

      Don’t have to think about it. There is no ‘God’. Biggest fabrication of mankind!

  • @gromit8844
    @gromit8844 2 года назад +26

    love these videos! thanks for making them 🙏🙏

  • @BHTQ18
    @BHTQ18 9 месяцев назад +10

    Jews have always been successful and educated people despite the persecution throughout history. There is something unique about their culture that propels them to be that way I am not Jewish but I admire the culture

    • @Kylie.jenner
      @Kylie.jenner 7 месяцев назад +2

      I thought I was the only non-jewish person admiring them in the whole world 😅

  • @doyouknoworjustbelieve6694
    @doyouknoworjustbelieve6694 11 месяцев назад +15


    Judaism is based on Canaanite, Mesopotamian and Ancient Egyptian beliefs and stories. Their monotheism is based on Zoroastrian beliefs mixed with a drive for creating an identity for themselves in a sea of powerful nations. Their God is a Canaanite God they elevated as the creator of the universe.

  • @2-ie2tj
    @2-ie2tj 7 месяцев назад +9

    God is one, He neither begot nor was born

    • @OgbabeHenschel-ow5qi
      @OgbabeHenschel-ow5qi 5 месяцев назад +1

      Allah is the local god of Qurarish tribe and not God

    • @QuranInAllLanguage
      @QuranInAllLanguage 5 месяцев назад +4

      ​@@OgbabeHenschel-ow5qi why you pagans spoke what you don't know about?

    • @souhimrohella
      @souhimrohella 4 месяца назад

      True , allah is one true god

    • @OgbabeHenschel-ow5qi
      @OgbabeHenschel-ow5qi 4 месяца назад +2

      @@souhimrohella one true God calling himself a DECIEVER???🤣
      Quran 3 vs 54 👈

    • @unknownuser6348
      @unknownuser6348 Месяц назад

      ​@@QuranInAllLanguagejustice for Ayesha.

  • @krs48
    @krs48 9 месяцев назад +4

    Judaism is not the world’s oldest monotheistic religion. Zoroastrianism is older. Akhenaten had a monotheistic religion in Egypt. This channel is full of it

    • @maypap13
      @maypap13 8 месяцев назад

      Zoroastrianism, as founded by Zoroaster, likely emerged in the 6th or 7th century BCE, while the roots of Judaism trace back further, possibly to the 12th century BCE or earlier.

    • @maypap13
      @maypap13 8 месяцев назад

      Unless you were there, don't make ridiculous claims.

    • @Ponto-zv9vf
      @Ponto-zv9vf Месяц назад

      How do you know Zoroastrianism is older?

  • @thelonecritic1
    @thelonecritic1 10 месяцев назад +7

    irony : world religions have taught love and tolerance to one another, yet humans hate each other.

    • @DrHayfever
      @DrHayfever 10 месяцев назад

      Well said
      ..

    • @Bosbay6902
      @Bosbay6902 9 месяцев назад

      irony : the muslim protected the jews as stated in the video but now are getting slaughtered by jews

    • @xNevlosx
      @xNevlosx 9 месяцев назад

      Judaism in the Torrah says the equivalent of "love thy neighbor." In the Talmud, it says "even the best of the goyim(non-jews) should be killed"....among other bad things.

    • @mukkah
      @mukkah 9 месяцев назад

      But did it though and do we though? Like, on an average... Maybe. Just curious, honestly.

    • @Ponto-zv9vf
      @Ponto-zv9vf Месяц назад

      What? The bible and the quran are full of conflict and hate.

  • @RM-ct6xv
    @RM-ct6xv 11 месяцев назад +4

    As I understand it , Zoroastrianism was the first monotheistic religion.

  • @thfc1961
    @thfc1961 9 месяцев назад +5

    Maimonides, who is seen as the most successful synthesizer of medieval Judaism and the Islamic world, “God has entangled us with this people, the nation of Ishmael, who treat us so prejudicially and who legislate our harm and hatred…. No nation has ever arisen more harmful than they, nor has anyone done more to humiliate us, degrade us, and consolidate hatred against us.” 1172

    • @pakkarim
      @pakkarim 8 месяцев назад

      This will debunk your comment and others like you...
      A short and simple listing of the history relating to the expulsion of the Jews over the past thousand years:
      1080 - Expulsion from France.
      1098 - Expulsion from the Czech Republic.
      1113 - Expulsion from Kievan Rus (Vladimir Monomakh).
      1113 - Massacre of Jews in Kiev.
      1147 - Expulsion from France.
      1171 - Expulsion from Italy.
      1188 - Expulsion from England.
      1198 - Expulsion from England.
      1290 - Expulsion from England.
      1298 - Expulsion from Switzerland (100 Jews executed by hanging).
      1306 - Expulsion from France (3,000 burned alive).
      1360 - Expulsion from Hungary.
      1391 - Expulsion from Spain (30,000 executed, 5,000 burned alive).
      1394 - Expulsion from France.
      1407 - Expulsion from Poland.
      1492 - Expulsion from Spain (law prohibiting Jews from entering the country forever).
      1492 - Expulsion from Sicily.
      1495 - Expulsion from Lithuania and Kiev.
      1496 - Expulsion from Portugal.
      1510 - Expulsion from England.
      1516 - Expulsion from Portugal.
      1516 - A law in Sicily allowed Jews to live only in ghettos.
      1541 - Expulsion from Austria.
      1555 - Expulsion from Portugal.
      1555 - A law was issued in Rome allowing Jews to live in ghettos only.
      1567 - Expulsion from Italy.
      1570 - Expulsion from Germany (Brandenburg).
      1580 - Expulsion from Novgorod (Ivan the Terrible).
      1592 - Expulsion from France.
      1616 - Expulsion from Switzerland.
      1629 - Expulsion from Spain and Portugal (Philip IV).
      1634 - Expulsion from Switzerland.
      1655 - Expulsion from Switzerland.
      1660 - Expulsion from Kyiv.
      1701 - Complete expulsion from Switzerland (Edict of Philip V).
      1806 - Napoleon's ultimatum. Badarja.
      1828 - Expulsion from Kyiv.
      1933 - Expulsion from Germany and genocide.
      On May 14, 1948, the State of Israel was established on Palestinian lands.
      *Jews were expelled from all countries throughout history*
      Compiled by:
      - Ihsan Al-Faqih
      Therefore, we say … whoever sympathizes with the Jews should give them their land.
      ‎#Al-Aqsa_Flood

    • @pakkarim
      @pakkarim 8 месяцев назад

      Only the Muslims of Andalusia in Spain and in the Ottoman Empire gave shelter to the Jews. Israel is the repayment to the kindness of the Muslims.

    • @gabrielleangelica1977
      @gabrielleangelica1977 7 месяцев назад

      Racist. The Jews in his Spain was treated better by Muslims than by Christians.

  • @nalik4905
    @nalik4905 2 года назад +17

    Wow, i see quality improvement here, watching you since the beginning

    • @jurgenjung4302
      @jurgenjung4302 6 месяцев назад

      RUclips: ROBERT SEPHER mit "The Hidden History of Zionism" und "Subversive Origins of Communism" 👍

    • @Ghaghdjs
      @Ghaghdjs 6 месяцев назад +1

      @@jurgenjung4302 no thanks ☺️

  • @nelsonmaraidza8066
    @nelsonmaraidza8066 8 месяцев назад +2

    Send this to someone who thinks palestines had the land first😂

    • @sheldonduff9338
      @sheldonduff9338 6 месяцев назад

      Nelson. You are wrong. This story does not say that Jews were first in this land, or owned it, or controlled it. If you are American, Canadian, or Australian or any nationality with colonialism in its history, even if the Jews were the very first inhabitants, so what. Are these countries giving back all their land to their indigenous people?

  • @erth8096
    @erth8096 Год назад +29

    How can people still believe in religion after knowing about the whole history of their religion 😂

    • @TheShadowgaming01
      @TheShadowgaming01 10 месяцев назад +5

      Yeah it's kinda silly 😂

    • @rozetalami6289
      @rozetalami6289 10 месяцев назад +4

      Yeah right. I think is more a community commodity that gives the people a sense of belonging to a certain group but that of course causes friction with other groups that have other beliefs. But is totally nonsense to me because I always think all this beliefs were not there when humanity itself was created. So is all a well built story to divide humans and create wars. Unfortunately 😢

    • @k9m42
      @k9m42 10 месяцев назад

      How can they not..?

    • @mukkah
      @mukkah 9 месяцев назад +1

      Because people are dumb on average.
      Source: am a dumb person

    • @dr.jamesolack8504
      @dr.jamesolack8504 8 месяцев назад

      @@rozetalami6289
      ‘Humanity’ wasn’t created……it evolved.

  • @mukkah
    @mukkah 9 месяцев назад +3

    LIES!! .... the video was longer than 5 minutes ^_^'
    Really nice, succinct data delivery =D

  • @RH-fc1hc
    @RH-fc1hc Год назад +8

    Zoroastrianism is the oldest known monotheistic religion not Judaism. The start of your video is very misleading.

  • @markenglish9841
    @markenglish9841 3 месяца назад +1

    every day i fight for the jewish people. god bless you israel

  • @SenjiaMurtic
    @SenjiaMurtic 11 месяцев назад +4

    Mentioned was money lending with interest was a forbidden practice in christianity, how did this change over time?

    • @mukkah
      @mukkah 9 месяцев назад +3

      Because Money > Ideology, to some at any rate

  • @abdeallahbennaceur3087
    @abdeallahbennaceur3087 4 месяца назад +2

    The amount of misinformation in this video is crazy

  • @sarahruiz3988
    @sarahruiz3988 3 месяца назад +4

    Zoroastrianism is actually the world's oldest monotheistic religion and the religion that judaism is based on.

    • @Ponto-zv9vf
      @Ponto-zv9vf Месяц назад +1

      Who says to both the oldest and what anything is based on? Iran is a bloody long way for stupid and ignorant people from the Levant to travel on foot, it's likely they had no horses to ride there. And why is Zoroastrianism practically dead? How about Akhenaten, he tried, and failed.

  • @cyb-m
    @cyb-m Год назад +2

    Wrong. Hinduism is the oldest, it is also monotheistic at its core. Stop looking at the world thru the Abrahamic lens, and may be you will get enlightened.

  • @shawnreedKAG17
    @shawnreedKAG17 Год назад +8

    With where I'm at spiritually, I just see people who need help and what I can or can't do to just help

    • @mukkah
      @mukkah 9 месяцев назад +2

      Ye man, really wish we'd believe a little more in ourselves / each other and a lot less on hypothetical, unseen beings we know of from papers written by men 100s / 1000s of years ago. I can see my fellow common folk, and feel their love / hate. Much more tangible than any religion, imo.

    • @dr.jamesolack8504
      @dr.jamesolack8504 8 месяцев назад

      Religion, in general, is a scam.

  • @williamtotherow3367
    @williamtotherow3367 9 месяцев назад +2

    Judaism was not monotheistic at all. They worshiped El, Baal and Yahweh all during the time after they entered the promised land. They constantly returned to the worship of Baal and Asherah after God punished them, sent them angles, prophets and warned them time and time again for 1000 years but they would return to the worship of the Canaanite Gods. The truth, Yahweh was a Canaanite God and the Jews were appointed Yahweh from the council of Gods. That is why the first Temple was destroyed and many plagues and losing wars was delivered by God.

    • @xxlionroarxxxxxxxx4438
      @xxlionroarxxxxxxxx4438 9 месяцев назад

      And you believe this ?😂

    • @williamtotherow3367
      @williamtotherow3367 9 месяцев назад

      @@xxlionroarxxxxxxxx4438 Believe what? Please respond.

    • @williamtotherow3367
      @williamtotherow3367 9 месяцев назад +1

      @@xxlionroarxxxxxxxx4438 Believe What?

    • @williamtotherow3367
      @williamtotherow3367 8 месяцев назад

      @@xxlionroarxxxxxxxx4438 I* don't believe that angels were sent, I don't believe in the exodus, I'm saying what they claim as true is even told wrong.

    • @AnthonyRamsay-tg8xg
      @AnthonyRamsay-tg8xg 4 месяца назад

      Are you knowledgeable about the 12 tribes of Israel?

  • @cloudaura7852
    @cloudaura7852 Год назад +5

    why the division took place and what happened to the two sons ishaak and ismail and why they were expelled by the Romans and why they were blamed for the plague too many questions :D

    • @MySiamesedreams
      @MySiamesedreams Год назад

      There is a theory that many people were eating pork which carries disease more readily than other animals. We know Jews do not eat pork.

    • @rozetalami6289
      @rozetalami6289 10 месяцев назад

      Hahaah sorry I’m not reading at your comment because it makes totally sense. I’m just smiling cause Jews say they are the people of God but never explained why they were so much hated, ok so probably Christians said Jews killed Jesus, ( one theory although I am not sure about Jesus either but anyway) and this is one idea. Another one they say is that Jews have always handled money. They have always been known to be moneylenders so not really loved for this and this makes them greedy and sinners at the eye of God. So, in substance they are not loved by God but they say they are the People of God. I mean a total mess and nonsense

  • @cyprokka
    @cyprokka 8 месяцев назад +1

    Zoroastrianism is the world's oldest monotheistic religion. Not Judaism.

  • @insertname9286
    @insertname9286 11 месяцев назад +3

    i see a pattern here lol

  • @k9m42
    @k9m42 10 месяцев назад +2

    Why are atheists always so angry and bitter…?

  • @shockeemhull1217
    @shockeemhull1217 Год назад +12

    Why does god have a chosen people? I never got that why not just have everyone know who you are so that there is no mistake of who to worship. It just seems unfair of a god to choose a group of his children over another

    • @Idkjustyet
      @Idkjustyet Год назад

      From my understanding it was Noah who cursed Ham & set that up. Nevertheless God allowed it. & the people who were there on earth were all one race, the human race. This was before they got scattered & multipled more .

    • @springe6570
      @springe6570 Год назад +8

      As a jew imma explain this to you really quick, in the torah it was said that god offered his religion to every "nation" of the people of earth, and out of everyone the hebrews which is us are the only ones who agreed to accept and take his religion. We are not the chosen people, we are the one who chose to be the chosen people.

    • @lucciangel6260
      @lucciangel6260 Год назад +1

      @@springe6570 why don’t you, or the Jewish people, believe in Christ? Was He not in fulfillment of the prophecies in the Old Testament? Didn’t David, Moses and Abraham prophecize His coming?

    • @lucciangel6260
      @lucciangel6260 Год назад

      @@springe6570 why don’t you, or the Jewish people, believe in Christ? Was He not in fulfillment of the prophecies in the Old Testament? Didn’t David, Moses and Abraham prophecize His coming?

    • @johnramirez3247
      @johnramirez3247 Год назад +9

      They are the chosen people of their god "according to the books they wrote".

  • @fisnikberisha670
    @fisnikberisha670 9 месяцев назад +1

    Zoroastrianism is the world’s oldest monotheistic religion not Judaism!

    • @maypap13
      @maypap13 8 месяцев назад

      Zoroastrianism, as founded by Zoroaster, likely emerged in the 6th or 7th century BCE, while the roots of Judaism trace back further, possibly to the 12th century BCE or earlier.

  • @MW-ec1jx
    @MW-ec1jx Год назад +3

    Zoroastrianism is the oldest monotheistic religion.

  • @augen8819
    @augen8819 7 месяцев назад +1

    Everyone can convert to judaisem ask any synagoge in new york

  • @Mirabella-t4k
    @Mirabella-t4k 11 месяцев назад +6

    Very interesting peace of history.

  • @Jonathangriffin82
    @Jonathangriffin82 Месяц назад +1

    To be fair, Islam might be the worlds oldest religion considering Muslims consider Adam the first Muslim

  • @7kingztrading494
    @7kingztrading494 11 месяцев назад +11

    Uh, right from the start we got problems. The first monotheistic religion was established under the rule of Akhenaten and it wasn't Judaism...it was the worship of Aten. So at this point I'm skeptical about the rest of the information in this video...but let's see.

    • @americanoo109
      @americanoo109 11 месяцев назад +1

      Maybe he meant out of the major world religions? But you are right.

    • @1000OtherFoxes
      @1000OtherFoxes 11 месяцев назад +2

      I mean I'm sure we can trace back to the cavemen and find tribes worship one single entity...

    • @7kingztrading494
      @7kingztrading494 11 месяцев назад +1

      @@1000OtherFoxes you say that as if it would outdate the civilizations of the Nile. You say that as if those caveman were sophisticated enough to come up with such concepts. 🤣🤣🤣 Yeah...try again. And some type of evidence would be great... instead of just a vague statement meant to put doubt in the minds of the unknowing.

    • @1000OtherFoxes
      @1000OtherFoxes 11 месяцев назад

      @@7kingztrading494 With the concept of what? worship and deities?

    • @7kingztrading494
      @7kingztrading494 11 месяцев назад

      @@1000OtherFoxes spirituality

  • @xxlionroarxxxxxxxx4438
    @xxlionroarxxxxxxxx4438 9 месяцев назад +1

    Copied so many stories from Greek, Persian and Indian mythology 😮

  • @activistmalpractice
    @activistmalpractice 10 месяцев назад +4

    Holy shit, a lot of great info in 5 minutes!

    • @mukkah
      @mukkah 9 месяцев назад

      Seriously, aye

    • @dr.jamesolack8504
      @dr.jamesolack8504 8 месяцев назад +1

      A lot of info in 5 minutes. As far as the info being ‘great’……that’s debatable…

  • @Paultricounty
    @Paultricounty 9 месяцев назад +2

    I’m not sure but I don’t think Jesus was practicing Christian Jewry , he was teaching Judaism. I think the term Christian came many years after his death.

  • @MultiSciGeek
    @MultiSciGeek 11 месяцев назад +7

    You can't be serious taking a fictional book as a basis for explaining history. At least back it up with arkeological and third party evidence, as opposed to taking it face value.

    • @rozetalami6289
      @rozetalami6289 10 месяцев назад +1

      I think the same. When they say Bible Torah or Quran or any religious book I never believe it. I mean there is no historical evidence but just mere writings of fictional stories written by someone in a certain historical and political context

    • @blusheep2
      @blusheep2 10 месяцев назад +1

      @@rozetalami6289 That is the stupidest thing I have ever heard. Have you read any of the these books? There are gobs of historically verified truths in the Bible. To just write something off because you don't like the religious content makes you look like an idiot.

    • @byrondickens
      @byrondickens 7 месяцев назад

      Ah, spoken through the true willful ignorance of modern atheism!
      Meanwhile, secular historians and archaeologists are ever finding more and more evidence that people and events described in the corpus of literature that we now know is the Bible at least have their basis in actual history. You don't have to believe any religious claims to admit this but you do have to approach the scholarship honestly and open up your closed mind.
      ruclips.net/video/nDu4K8kroNw/видео.htmlsi=B0PndTgsJsqy5y4A
      ruclips.net/video/58_csxSA25M/видео.htmlsi=hBaOIBcdC7Va0QWS
      ruclips.net/video/6ZHeUGexiO8/видео.htmlsi=DjLR5feUjKVbOh4B

  • @Amirnezam1
    @Amirnezam1 10 месяцев назад +1

    Zoroastrianism is the first and therefore the oldest monotheistic religion. Get your fact straight.

  • @CharliePayne-e8g
    @CharliePayne-e8g 9 месяцев назад +3

    this video is 6 mins but i like it longer anyway

    • @mukkah
      @mukkah 9 месяцев назад

      Something something she said

  • @itzch0colatewaffleyt53
    @itzch0colatewaffleyt53 7 месяцев назад +1

    It is disrepectful to depict pictures of what HaShem looks like.Pls don't

  • @NubianLoveGod
    @NubianLoveGod Год назад +6

    How come they are all white? This is weirdness...

    • @tagbarzeev8283
      @tagbarzeev8283 Год назад +3

      Why don't you look at Mizrahi Jews or Yemenite Jews, there are many Diaspora groups of Jews.

    • @Jewish_Israeli_Zionist
      @Jewish_Israeli_Zionist Год назад

      Two reasons:
      1. The Khazar convertion
      2. Convertion of local European women as a result of lack of Jewish women in the European Jewish communities.

    • @axaeyexus
      @axaeyexus Год назад +1

      ​@@Jewish_Israeli_Zionist The Khazars weren't even close to being large enough to affect Jewish numbers. They look like any population of that area. Assyrians are often blonde and blue eyed. Please, stop.

    • @axaeyexus
      @axaeyexus Год назад

      Could have something to do with white people murdering their kinsmen that looked ethnic. Why are some black folks in America lighter than the black folks in Africa?
      Try using the handful of neurons left in your skull, if there are any. 🙄

    • @tagbarzeev8283
      @tagbarzeev8283 Год назад +1

      @עברי יהודי ישראלי Your correct Jewish men did marry Southern Italian women who converted to Judaism after the destruction of the 2nd temple. If you have watched videos by Henry Abramson or Shaul Stamford they highly dispute the Khazar theory.

  • @rtmusicvideos431
    @rtmusicvideos431 5 месяцев назад +1

    Jews lived as “dhimmis” or second class citizens in Muslim lands for centuries. Jews had to pay a tax called “Jizya” for not converting to Islam, and were subject to many prohibitions under the law and sometimes experienced massacres.
    In both Christian and Muslim countries, Jews were forced into being money-lenders because the Christians and Muslims usually prohibited Jews from having any other profession. I believe the prohibition against money lending in Christianity and Islam is actually based on the prohibition in Judaism, but Jews had no other choice but to be money-lenders.
    There were times of tolerance and intolerance of Jews in both Christian and Muslim lands. When your religion is based on another one, it’s easy to use the predecessor as a scapegoat for any problems in society.

  • @Salem-b9k
    @Salem-b9k 9 месяцев назад +7

    How to explain the similarities between the Old Testament and the ancient Mesopotamian myths?

    • @SuperGamingCraftSGC
      @SuperGamingCraftSGC Месяц назад +1

      You can probably thank the Babylonian captivity for that.
      Jews have probably absorbed some ancient mesopotamian myhts when they were in exile in babylon.

  • @SatClub403
    @SatClub403 11 месяцев назад +2

    What ACTUALLY happened though? Because it's not like the invisible man really came from the sky and gave them real estate.
    What's the real world history?

    • @abdhulmajeed8828
      @abdhulmajeed8828 11 месяцев назад +2

      @satclub...... Real history is not there in the world. Historians were always obeying the rulers and writing history to the willof of those who were in power.

    • @rozetalami6289
      @rozetalami6289 10 месяцев назад

      Love this.. and is totally true. You know books are written by us so people and we create doctrines , beliefs , faiths and anything else to make others believe that what they’re saying is the truth but no one ever has said yes I have seen and meet God. Is just an explanation of what we can’t explain so the creation of earth which is is a total wonder to the human brain to fully understand. I believe in science because at least tries to give a rational explanation of things. And premising that I hate communism and all the totalitarian regimes , communists say that Religion is the Opium for the masses. And that is quite true

    • @danielbershtein4288
      @danielbershtein4288 9 месяцев назад +1

      real history is in the bible, which is a history book and probably the oldest one. people came into a deserted land, settled in, created a religion and a home. simple.

  • @micahistory
    @micahistory 2 года назад +4

    5th to comment, also i'm your 300th subscriber! Just found this channel!

  • @alisonbrowning9620
    @alisonbrowning9620 Месяц назад +1

    Zoroastrianism was the first monothesitic religion

  • @josephwilliammarek9566
    @josephwilliammarek9566 11 месяцев назад +3

    I am interested in the history of the people who became Jews -- before the time of Abram!

    • @beestoe993
      @beestoe993 9 месяцев назад

      The world was made up of many small tribes in that time

    • @jenica6381
      @jenica6381 9 месяцев назад +2

      There’s none. . .they all came from Abraham, Isaac then Jacob who’s name was changed to Israel by God the Creator King.

    • @josephwilliammarek9566
      @josephwilliammarek9566 9 месяцев назад

      Further research has revealed the Jews were part of the larger Canaanite Civilization.

  • @ikiruyamamoto1050
    @ikiruyamamoto1050 9 месяцев назад +2

    I enjoyed the history in the video! But you lost me on the CLAIM that Judaism is NOT a religion but an ethnicity. That utterly fails to account for the different versions of Judaism (e.g. Orthodox, Conservative, and Reform). It also fails to account for conversions, and Jews from different racial groups.

    • @maypap13
      @maypap13 8 месяцев назад +1

      Jews are a people, a family. it is more than a religion and more than an ethnicity.

    • @TheDream-xs1xt
      @TheDream-xs1xt 8 месяцев назад

      @@maypap13 ITS ABOUT LIES THEFT AND MURDER

    • @ECKohns
      @ECKohns 4 месяца назад

      Conversion in Judaism only happens when a person wants it and seeks it out themselves. It’s also a rigorous process. Unlike Christianity and Islam where the goal is to spread that religion and convert the whole world.

  • @johnaweiss
    @johnaweiss 4 месяца назад +3

    I came looking for history, and instead i got the mythical bible.

  • @abundure9257
    @abundure9257 Месяц назад +1

    Zoroastrianism is the oldest monotheistic religion

  • @theresalreneparada1096
    @theresalreneparada1096 8 месяцев назад +4

    Thank you for this information. I am 79 years old . I had a hysterectomy at about age 46 and for the last 2:years I have had big problems with urination urgency, leaking and also feel my vagina had prolapsed. I will definitely have these checked.

  • @sean27972
    @sean27972 9 месяцев назад +1

    all absolute nonsense

  • @SwissMix-cv7ye
    @SwissMix-cv7ye 6 месяцев назад +3

    L Jews

  • @RamZar50
    @RamZar50 11 месяцев назад +6

    How about origins!?
    Abraham was born in Ur in Sumeria (Southern Iraq) around 2000 BCE and trekked his way along the Fertile Crescent to Canaan (Israel & Palestine). Many Old Testament fables are based directly on much older Sumerian texts.

    • @blusheep2
      @blusheep2 10 месяцев назад +1

      That isn't what the scholars say.

    • @RamZar50
      @RamZar50 10 месяцев назад

      @@blusheep2 I didn’t mean the entire Old Testament. The Book of Genesis and the Sumerian tablets.

    • @blusheep2
      @blusheep2 10 месяцев назад

      @@RamZar50 I'm referring to the same thing you say. Most scholars today believe that all the ancient Mesopotamian creation stories stem from an even older oral tradition. The Bible doesn't borrow from the Sumerian kings list anymore then the Sumerian kings list borrows from the Bible. They are both borrowing from an ancient oral tradition. Therefore, scholars see Genesis as a polemic, not a borrowing, of these ancient texts.
      People often think about the similarities of theses stories, of which there are some. They rarely notice the differences. The old stories of Genesis are vastly different then these other stories and the Gilgamesh story which the Bible is said to be derived from actually predates the flood story in the Gilgamesh epic. There are 5 copies of Gilgamesh spread over hundreds of years. Only the last copy has a flood story in it and that copy post-dates the Genesis flood account so it might be that it borrowed from the Bible but even there, the Epic is said by scholars to be connected, linguistically, to the Atrahasis and not the Bible.

  • @urstruly00
    @urstruly00 Год назад +2

    It’s a Hebrew book from Eber maybe but no it’s not a Jewish book

  • @instalyf8777
    @instalyf8777 Год назад +10

    Hinduism is not a religion. It is immortal. Its a way of life. Worshipping every being in this earth. The sun the moom the universe. Hinduism started earlier than this earth was born.

    • @mukkah
      @mukkah 9 месяцев назад

      Wait what?

    • @Onlylettuce92
      @Onlylettuce92 8 месяцев назад +1

      @@mukkahpolytheism and animism

  • @urstruly00
    @urstruly00 Год назад +3

    By 160 the New Testament was created it was made during the Apostles time not long after Jesus. For the Bible to be close and complement, the old testament would’ve been a lot of work only God could have done it. Please read. Isaiah 53

  • @HuzaineHajiDaud
    @HuzaineHajiDaud 8 месяцев назад +1

    Yahweh? Its Hashim's

  • @retiloveyouisraelbo8988
    @retiloveyouisraelbo8988 Год назад +4

    My brother, in the diaspora a lot of Jews came to Mexico, Cuba, Santo Domingo, and Puerto Rico. They where the one who had the money, to pay for costly trip.

  • @glennbarrow8325
    @glennbarrow8325 10 месяцев назад +1

    THE TRUE STORY regarding PALESTINE
    -Palestine is the land of the Prophets.
    -Jews have no rights in Palestine
    -Palestine is for Palestinians
    -Jerusalem is the capital of Palestine
    -There is no country of Israel
    Some of the Prophets who lived in Palestine are:
    Ibrahim (Abraham)
    Lot
    Ishmael
    Ishaq (Isaac)
    Ya'qoob (Jacob)
    Yusuf (Joseph)
    Daud (David)
    Solomon
    Zakariyyah (Zachariah)
    Yahya (John)
    {May the peace and blessing of Allah be upon them)
    Ibrahim(Abraham) has two sons:
    1. Ismael
    2. Isaac
    Isaac's son was Jacob(Ya'qoob) where most of the Prophets came from his lineage such as Yusuf(Joseph),Daud(David),Sulaiman(Solomon),Zakariyyah(Zacarias),Musa(Moses) and Yahya (John).
    The second name of Prophet Ya'qoob(Jacob) is ISRAEL so his clans are called BANU ISRAEL(Son's of Israel). Also, accordingly, ISRAEL means Abdullah (servant of Allah).
    But the tribe of Israel has been known for disobedience and stubbornness where they oppose and kill their own Prophets sent to them except for a small number them, this is how the Quran describes them.
    Among their disobedience are:
    -They disobeyed Prophet Solaiman (Solomon)
    -They disobeyed Prophet Musa (Moses)
    -They disobeyed Prophet Eisa (Jesus)
    -They killed Prophet Yahya (John)
    -They killed Prophet Zacariah (Zacarias).
    THAT'S WHY ALLAH PUNISHED THEM. THEIR PUNISHMENT IS THAT, THEY WOULD HAVE NO LAND IN THIS WORLD EXCEPT THOSE WHO BELIEVE.
    What happened to them for several centuries is that wherever they ended up in the middle east after the time of Prophet Eisa (Jesus), others went to Europe and America.
    In World War II between the years 1941 and 1945 the Holocaust occurred where nearly 6 million Jews died in Europe at the hands of Adolf Hitler of Germany.
    The reason for Adolf Hitler's great anger towards the Jews is about politics and religion where the Jews believe that people who do not belong to them are animals or the lowest creatures, because they believe that they are the chosen people who chosen by Allah, so Hitler did this to them.
    They only got land in Palestine because GREAT BRITAIN took pity on them where it was recommended to the UNITED NATIONS and the UN immediately received it in the year 1947, because the Jews also served for a long time in Great Britain.
    In the following year (1948) the Zionist Jews immediately declared their own country in Palestine which they called ISRAEL where it seemed as if they only arrived in Palestine as refugees until they gradually expanded their land to conquer in the lands of the Palestinians in a violent and forced way, at the same time they gathered all the Jews around the world where before they would have been scattered because of the punishment of Allah.
    This is where the Arab countries intervened and there was a war that has not ended until now between the JEWS and the ARABS.
    Apart from this conflict, the Jews also do not respect the Arabs because they believe that they are the only believers, so they did not believe in Prophet Muhammad SAW and it was easy for them to kill Arab Muslims. Why?
    Prophet Ismael, the brother of Prophet Isaac, is the son of Hajar, the second wife of Prophet Ibrahim, who used to be the maid of Sarah, who was the mother of Prophet Isaac, the first wife of Prophet Ibrahim (according to their history).
    And after the reign of the clans of Isaac in which the last Prophet among them was Prophet Eisa (Jesus), Allah gave this promise to the clan of Prophet Ismael where the last prophet and Messenger would come from his clan. Prophet Muhammad SAW.
    Because the last Prophet did not come from the family of Isaac, the Jews did not believe, believing that Prophet Ismael was inferior compared to their ancestor, Prophet Isaac, the son of Prophet Ibrahim's first wife, besides that, they really are people who disobeys, even to the early Prophets.
    In other words, the ongoing conflict between Jews and Arab Muslims is about religion and history.
    Palestine is a place of Arab Muslims, and the believers in the clans of Israel, it does not include those who disobey, they are not among in the promise of Allah.
    There are three existing religions in Palestine:
    1. Judaism
    2. Christianity
    3. Islam
    WHY ARE THE CHRISTIANS IN PALESTINE NOT INCLUDED IN THE ENEMY OF THE PALESTINIAN MUSLIMS?
    Christians are not like Jews, where Jews are worse but they are the same race, Jews also consider Christians as enemies because they did not really believe in Prophet Eisa (Jesus), they are the ones who accused Mary committing adultery (Zina) and Prophet Eisa (Jesus) was a child of zina (adultery), so a great miracle happened from Allah where Prophet Eisa spoke when he was a baby to refute what the Jews were saying and prove the innocence of his mother.
    WHY DO THEY WANT TO TAKE JERUSALEM WHERE MASJID AL-AQSA IS LOCATED?
    They believe that here is the very temple of Prophet Solaiman that was destroyed and replaced by masjeds, so this is what they want to restore from its original, but if you go back to history and the books you will not find any solid evidence about the temple that they claim.
    Rather, the Masjid Al-aqsa is the one that was built by Prophet Adam and rebuilt by Prophet Solaiman.
    And they have no right to it because they also disobeyed Prophet Solaiman as we mentioned.

    • @glennbarrow8325
      @glennbarrow8325 10 месяцев назад

      Have you read the Qur'an?? Let me give you a glimpse of it..
      🌹1.Don't insult (Q49:11)
      🌹2.Speak kindly (Q2:83)
      🌹3.Speak gently (Q17:28)
      🌹4.Don't backbite (Q49:12)
      🌹5.Speak the Truth (Q3:17)
      🌹6.Keep your oaths (Q5:89)
      🌹7.Do not be arrogant (Q7:13)
      🌹8.Restrain your anger (Q3:134)
      🌹9.Think good of others (Q24:12)
      🌹10.Don't be rude to parents (Q17:23)
      🌹11.Don't make fun of others (Q49:11)
      🌹12.Turn away from ill speech (Q23:3)
      🌹13.Walk in a humble manner (Q25:63)
      🌹14.Keep your trusts & promises (Q23:8)
      🌹15.Don't claim yourself to be pure (Q53:32)
      🌹16.Do not even approach adultery (Q17:32)
      🌹17.Don't call others with bad names (Q49:11)
      🌹18.Remember Allah and be thankful (Q2:152)
      🌹19.Speak nicely, even to the ignorant (Q25:63)
      🌹20.Don't ask for repayment for favours (Q76:9)
      🌹21.If enemy wants peace, then accept it (Q8:61)
      🌹22.Salute the Prophet (saw), do salawats (Q33:56)
      🌹23.Call ˹all˺ people to the pilgrimage (hajj) (Q22:27)
      🌹24.Give charity /spend (in the way of Allah) (Q2:254)
      🌹25.Don’t criticize small donation/charity of others (9:79)
      🌹26.Be mindful of Allah and be with the truthful (Q9:119)
      🌹27.Do not consume one another’s wealth unjustly (Q2:188)
      🌹28.Stand firm for justice even if it is against yourselves(Q4:135)
      🌹29.Don't remind others of the favours you done to them (Q2:264)
      🌹30.Return a greeting in a better manner or at least the same (Q4:86)
      🌹31.Do not be excessive, extravagant, don't spend wastefully (Q17:26)
      🌹32 Life of this world is no more than the delusion of enjoyment (Q3:185)
      🌹33.Performing prayers (salat/namaz) is a duty on the believers (Q4:103)
      🌹34.Turn away from trash talk like gossip, slandering people etc.(Q28:55)
      🌹35.Fasting is prescribed for you-as it was for those before you (Q2:183)
      🌹36.Don't Bribe authorities in order to devour a portion of others’ property(Q2:188)
      🌹37.Establish prayer (salat/namaz) and donate from what was provided (Q8:3)
      🌹38.Establish prayer (salat/namaz) and donate from what was provided (Q14:31)
      🌹39.Establish prayer (salat/namaz), pay alms-tax, and bow down with those who bow down (Q2:43)
      🌹🕋40.Know that this worldly life is no more than play, amusement, luxury, mutual boasting, and competition in wealth and children.(Q57:20)🕋🌹
      ✍Explanation:
      💚Please note these are not the complete ayats, but I took keywords from each ayat. If you would like to read the full ayat, then check the reference.
      💬For example take a look the first statement:
      🌹Don't insult (Q49:11), when you google Quran 49:11, then you will see the complete surah’s English translation and you will see following:
      ☝️🕋O believers! Do not let some ˹men˺ ridicule others, they may be better than them, nor let ˹some˺ women ridicule other women, they may be better than them. Do not defame one another, nor call each other by offensive nicknames. How evil it is to act rebelliously after having faith! And whoever does not repent, it is they who are the ˹true˺ wrongdoers.☝️🕋
      🤲🌻ALWAYS REMEMBER🌻🤲:
      ✍Allah is the most merciful and forgiving, no matter how much you have been sinning, run towards Allah , turn to Allah and repent , ask for forgiveness. Some references from the Quran:
      🌺🌺🌺🕋Quran 39:53🕋🌺🌺🌺
      Say, ˹O Prophet, that Allah says,˺ “O My servants who have exceeded the limits against their souls! Do not lose hope in Allah’s mercy, for Allah certainly forgives all sins. He is indeed the All-Forgiving, Most Merciful.
      🌺🌺🌺🕋Quran 25:70🕋🌺🌺🌺
      As for those who repent, believe, and do good deeds, they are the ones whose evil deeds Allah will change into good deeds. For Allah is All-Forgiving, Most Merciful.

    • @blusheep2
      @blusheep2 10 месяцев назад +1

      This was an interesting read. Most just deny that Israel was ever in the land or try to avoid that they were by saying the current Jews aren't real Jews and/or the real Jews converted to Islam long ago. This theory that says the reason its not their land is because God took it away from them after rejecting their prophets is at least interesting.
      I reject it though because the Bible doesn't paint a picture of the Jews separate from their land in the last days. I think it could be true that God removed his protection of them after rejecting their Messiah, but the Bible is clear that they will return in the end and have their temple back. When that will happen, it doesn't say. Therefore, it would be hard to make a case for your theory because this could be the time God is drawing His people back to the promised land. If so, the judgment would be against the Muslims at this time, not the other way around.
      It now is a competition between what the Quran says about the Jews and their promised land and what the Bible says. You would have to convince me that the Quran is from God, which I don't believe it is.

    • @danielbershtein4288
      @danielbershtein4288 9 месяцев назад

      Israel will forever be the Jewish state, and you will keep suffering from this fact :)

    • @jeffrynirenstein5989
      @jeffrynirenstein5989 Месяц назад

      ​@@blusheep2greater answer

  • @VeerMaratha
    @VeerMaratha Год назад +2

    Jewish came from Yadav lineage.
    That's why we call them Yehudi.

  • @demoscratos4577
    @demoscratos4577 5 месяцев назад +1

    so Persia helped the Jews? So Muslims actually got along better with jews than jews did with European Catholics and christians ? so then why all the animosity against Iran and muslim Arabs ? seems like it europeans who fucked things up

    • @crystalcvt
      @crystalcvt 4 месяца назад

      it was. there was Jewish and Muslim coexistence in the Levant for centuries before the colony of Israel was created. Judaism was even the majority religion in cities such as Tiberius. Jaffa and Safed were both between 20-50% Jewish and the Ottomans encouraged Jews to come to the Levant to free persecution from Christians since Jews were seen as people of the book. the hatred comes from the fact that Palestinians (many of whom are Christian, by the way) don't like Israel because it displaced them or murdered them. this gets intentionally misrepresented as antisemitism, which is historically inaccurate.

    • @Coen-e1w
      @Coen-e1w 20 часов назад

      Islam was not even founded when The Persians helped the Jews. So why do you call them muslims?

    • @demoscratos4577
      @demoscratos4577 18 часов назад

      @@Coen-e1w touché

  • @Chosenone978
    @Chosenone978 Год назад +3

    All lie

    • @DTczsk1999
      @DTczsk1999 11 месяцев назад +2

      🤡🤣🫵

  • @andyontheinternet5777
    @andyontheinternet5777 8 месяцев назад +1

    I've seen this comment a few times here. Zoroastrianism IS NOT MONOTHEISTIC. It has the devil and god as equal deities. Therefore, It's a dualistic faith. I agree that unorganized monotheism predated Judaism, but Zoroastrianism was not the first monotheistic faith.

  • @RoyalTurd
    @RoyalTurd 10 месяцев назад +3

    Great video! Very succinct

  • @SmileToday-CryTomorrow
    @SmileToday-CryTomorrow Год назад +2

    The term Roman, is that where Roman Catholics was referring today?

  • @mrweeed5066
    @mrweeed5066 2 года назад +15

    Only reason Judaism survived this long is cause of reveleance of its text with christianity and islam. If only there was no christianity and islam, an complete new religion or strict following of paganism it would have died or maybe jews are just very persistant to their text to this day which is also remarkable. I'm a muslim and I love reading about history and wars from old times especially about roman empire, crazy times!!

    • @Yolaf_
      @Yolaf_ Год назад +14

      That’s incredibly disrespectful. I disagree with you entirely

    • @Idkjustyet
      @Idkjustyet Год назад +2

      They’re still here because they are Gods fleshly people.

    • @RighteousRevolution
      @RighteousRevolution Год назад +5

      Judaism, Christianity and Islam owes its ideological beginnings in Kemet (Egypt). All the commandments are copied from the laws of Maat. That is the source and the actual history of the Abraham's religions. This history is steeped in fantasy and lacks any true critical historical reference.

    • @RighteousRevolution
      @RighteousRevolution Год назад +3

      ​@KonfidentKayy Gpd's people are those who di His will. It has nothing to do with a historically unproven people.

    • @mrweeed5066
      @mrweeed5066 Год назад

      @@Idkjustyet not just jews everyone is you dum dum

  • @Laceykat66
    @Laceykat66 7 месяцев назад +1

    Very good though I would say Judisum endured and did not fade into history because, as you said, it was a matter of ethnicity, ancestry, identity & culture, and not geographic location. The standard practice of conquerors was to eliminate the upper classes and remove the middle classes to other lands (The poor were always subject to whomever ruled the land). The Jews carried their culture with them however and were not directly tied to a specific area.
    Good job, as usual. I wish you were around when I was trudging through all of this in college. Please keep it up.

  • @abdhulmajeed8828
    @abdhulmajeed8828 11 месяцев назад +1

    Not gods law or god promised specific land etc. Those claims are narratives of abraham and his predecessors and contents of their relegious texts. Human origin was from africa anfrom there they travelled and migrated in other areas of earth including africas vast land area, asia, europe, north and south america, australia cotinents.

  • @martindurand3806
    @martindurand3806 2 года назад +3

    Great video ! I think the Persians will be next ;)

  • @junemoran4550
    @junemoran4550 11 месяцев назад +2

    So where’s the part that Palestine was a country for centuries…..

    • @honeypie-hk
      @honeypie-hk 11 месяцев назад

      I think pelesthine is only tribes

    • @MelanieCobos-k9x
      @MelanieCobos-k9x 10 месяцев назад

      There was a conflict between Jews and the Romans and they changed the name of the nation to Syria-Palestinia and kicked the Jews out of their own homeland.

    • @rozetalami6289
      @rozetalami6289 10 месяцев назад

      They were living in the same region one south the other north. But Jews were banished don’t know why because Christians blamed them for killing Jesus I think, so the tribes of Philistine remained there. But is supposed that they have been in that area since the 12th century BCE during the start of the Iron Age. That’s what history says at least and not a religious book whatsoever

    • @blusheep2
      @blusheep2 10 месяцев назад

      @@MelanieCobos-k9x Palestine was just a district of Rome's control. The area of the world was called Palestine, like we might call it the Levant. It was never a nation of its own. Just an area of the world.

    • @blusheep2
      @blusheep2 10 месяцев назад

      @@rozetalami6289 Jews were banished from Jerusalem after the revolt Bar Kobva revolt.(Sp?) The Romans were tired of the rebellious nature of the Jews and so began the diaspora. They were later invited to settle elsewhere in the country but they weren't allowed back into Jerusalem. They eventually settled in Tiberias on the Sea of Galilee and Tiberias today is considered the 2nd holiest city in jerusalem. It was here that the Mishnahs were written and the Rambam entombed.
      It has nothing to do with the Christians
      I'm not sure if descendants of the Philistines still exist or are known to exist. Palestinians aren't Philistines. They are Arabs. Many of the lineages go back to the Muslim conquests which invited Arabs to move into the area. Then when Israel first governing the land, they were building up the country and its infrastructure. Many Palestinians from Jordan came in as migrant workers and never left.
      Most of the Palestinians that were removed from Israel were removed after the war because they fought or sided against Israel. Those Muslims that didn't were never asked to leave and there are 1.8 million of them living there now.
      The settlements, I'm still trying to dig up information on. Its hard because the information out there is highly politicized.

  • @Jennabeth19
    @Jennabeth19 Год назад +5

    Im sure you meant “Israel” not “Palestine”

  • @henryhawthorn8849
    @henryhawthorn8849 4 месяца назад +1

    I’ve always wondered what is the REAL history of the origin of the Hebrew people, which included the Kingdom of Israel (or the “lost 10 tribes”) and Judah. Obviously, the Jewish Scriptures can’t be relied upon as a historical source because it mostly contains ancient myths and legends, with some historical facts. There are different theories as to the actual origin of Judaism, and the one that makes more sense to me is that they were the Hyksos, a group of people who ruled Egypt for a period of time, and then they were expelled, and eventually settled in Canaan. Other than that the origin of the Jews remains a mystery because there are scattered archaeological, and historical evidences.

    • @SuperGamingCraftSGC
      @SuperGamingCraftSGC Месяц назад +1

      History and archeology suggests that the israelites have emerged from the canaanites and diverged from them on the basis of religion.
      From what I know, the Hyksos (or some of them/a large chunk of them) were themselves canaanites, so I guess you could be right.
      I personally think it might explain specifically the origins of what later became the tribe of Levi, that is the main tribe of the exodus story (Moses, Aaron, and Myriam, were of the tribe of levi.)
      The rest of the tribes may have never left the land of israel/canaan, and were later joined by the tribe of levi.
      Speaking from an entirely secular point of view.

  • @TonyBMW
    @TonyBMW 2 года назад +3

    Religious text is BS.
    How about historical facts like archeological findings?
    Noah’s ark gtfo

  • @redheatredheat9906
    @redheatredheat9906 Месяц назад

    I think the oldest religion or culture is the Hindu/Sindhu Indian religion/culture or may be South Indian Tamil

  • @samuelwilliams6171
    @samuelwilliams6171 Год назад +4

    Ex Christian and Muslim Alhamdulillah 😇☝️

  • @countryprideproduction8463
    @countryprideproduction8463 4 месяца назад

    Started off with a big lie! None of those people you mentioned were Jew nor were they associated with any religion. The term Jew is relatively new and so too is Judaism.

  • @martinmgidi2790
    @martinmgidi2790 Год назад +4

    Professional lies

    • @DTczsk1999
      @DTczsk1999 11 месяцев назад +1

      🤡🤡🤡

  • @garysantos7053
    @garysantos7053 9 дней назад

    Zoroaster, also known as Zarathustra, was an ancient Iranian prophet and the founder of “Zoroastrianism.”
    He is believed to have lived sometime between the 7th and 6th centuries BCE (501-700 BCE),
    though some scholars suggest he may have lived as early as the second millennium BCE13 (1300-1201 BCE).
    Zoroaster’s teachings challenged the existing religious practices of his time and introduced the concept of a single god (Monotheism), Ahura Mazda, representing truth and light.
    Abraham (Abram) was born in 1960 B.C. and is the father of the Jewish religion. His forefathers were from southern Mesopotamia (in present-day Iraq).
    According to the biblical narrative, their deity, Yahweh, led Abraham on a journey to the land of Canaan, which he promised to his children.

  • @olfaaloulou6779
    @olfaaloulou6779 2 года назад +6

    Judaism is palestine

    • @azizaaman4290
      @azizaaman4290 Год назад +6

      free palestine

    • @abbakovner1861
      @abbakovner1861 Год назад +2

      OH SHIT SHUT UP, there are times when it's okay to say it, but don't fucking target all the videos that have to do with Jews to spam that

    • @azizaaman4290
      @azizaaman4290 Год назад

      @@abbakovner1861 i didn’t i was just doing research and came across this comment. i’m not one of those people who go out of their way to say free palestinians on every jewish persons page

    • @abbakovner1861
      @abbakovner1861 Год назад +8

      @@azizaaman4290 both are wrong, I understand that you are sorry about Palestine (although Israel is the one that is fine), but God, keep your politics away from religion, you "pro Palestinians" all you do is mark any video that has the word "jew" and say "free palestine", that's not helping, it's just spam and it's reportable, go to a political video to say that.

    • @Jewish_Israeli_Zionist
      @Jewish_Israeli_Zionist Год назад

      Lol so why are you Muslims and Christians?! 😂😂😂😂
      This is so stupid, because Judaism means The religion of Judea... so you contradict yourself hahaha

  • @AshaKambang
    @AshaKambang 6 дней назад

    Each group of society or nation has their own culture, ethnicity, language in the world if we look through the lens of politics. According to Bible the call of Abraham is unique and very meaningful to the whole world including to the descendants of Abraham. God has promised to save the world through Jesus which was promised already to Abraham and his descendants.

  • @SalahDambo-gb6cs
    @SalahDambo-gb6cs 9 месяцев назад +1

    I want to know about them. They have the knowledge of the first books. I believe in these people

  • @Khaledkhanzada
    @Khaledkhanzada 5 месяцев назад

    Who are the LOST TRIBE OF BANI ISRAEL ?
    The Afghans
    whose ancestor QAIS ABDUL RASHEED embraced Islam
    All Pathans are from the LOST TRIBE OF BANI ISRAEL either living in Pakistan or Afghanistan
    Afghans/Pathans were Jews before Islam

  • @mariepereira9847
    @mariepereira9847 9 месяцев назад +1

    Genuine Judaism is not to do to others, what one doesn't like.
    Further, one must transcend the self.

  • @makereadyforjesus1224
    @makereadyforjesus1224 Месяц назад

    Except for the history of the Jews, the divine concept on which Judaism and Christianity are based originated on the religion of the blacks of Africa, notably, the ancient Egyptian civilization. The first five books of Moses, written by Moses, is derived from the religion of Blacks. Hebrew is also spoken by a tribe in Ghana. Likely, this is the root of the Hebrew language. Much of the laws of the Bible, including the Psalms and the Proverbs pre-existed in the ancient religion of the blacks of Egypt of which Moses was a student. Have you ever heard of the wise sayings of Ani and the negative confessions? Please find out. As the saying goes, the 144,000 virgins redeemed from the earth followed Christ wherever he goesth and were not defiled. Christ was first stationed amongst the blacks and the same religion he gave them is the same religion he continued with the Jews and later the Christians. At least Moses saw Christ in Egypt, if you doubt, I will pinpoint it AMONG THE BOOKS OF PAUL. Therefore, the origin of the Hebrew religion and subsequently Christianity is black Africans. God has designed his route in such a way that, nobody can claim he belongs to him alone.