What is Israel’s endgame for Gaza?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 13 окт 2024
- Go to ground.news/ca... to access worldwide perspectives on Israel, Palestine and geopolitical events. Subscribe for 40% off unlimited access.
#Israel is building roads all across #Gaza, which will be fortified with watchtowers and bases, and allow the Israelis to monitor any point in #Gaza without occupying the entire territory.
Support CaspianReport
✔ RUclips membership ► / @caspianreport
✔ Patreon ► / caspianreport
✔ PayPal ► www.paypal.me/...
✔ Merchandise ►teespring.com/...
Crypto endorsement
✔ Bitcoin ► 1MwRNXWWqzbmsHova7FMW11zPftVZVUfbU
✔ Ether ► 0xfE4c310ccb6f52f9D220F25Ce76Dec0493dF9aA0
✔ Bitcoin Cash ► 1BKLti4Wq4EK9fsBnYWC91caK7NZfUhNw9
Join us on Facebook or Twitter
✔ Twitter ► / caspianreport
✔ Facebook ► / caspianreport
✔ My equipment and editing software ► www.amazon.com...
Watch CaspianReport in other languages
✔ Spanish ► / historiageopol%c3%adtica
✔ Russian ► / thecuriouscat
#ad #sponsored
![[4K] Watch SpaceX Catch A Starship Rocket From Space!!! #IFT5](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/pIKI7y3DTXk/mqdefault.jpg)
Go to ground.news/caspian. Subscribe for 40% off unlimited access. Follow Caspian Report’s custom feed with breaking news and blindspots on geopolitical events.
the illusion of you seeing all sides they are owned by the same people anyway hehe they spred nothing but fake news just take the board from Reuters there are there to control the narrative nothing else
What disingenuous bullshit to suggest people can't discern various new articles on their own. May the ground open up and swallow you whole.
I don't see what's Egypt's problem with Israel controlling this strip. It's a fraction of their already shared border to the southeast.
"I genuinely believe in seeing all sides"... proceeds to give us I* propaganda
@@mand4lex "I dont see why Egypt has an issue with a fascist state pushing millions of their kin into poverty, extremism and refugee status within their own land at their own border. It is so baffling to me."
you guys do realize that we are talking about 2 million human living in there right. the graphics looks like they building something for animals. imagine something like this being done anywhere else in the world. the level of dehumanization is baffling !! God !! and they can do all this because they got money to buy US senate and congress!
Zogs got the learnings from there own enemy of ww2 i guess
After seeing what they did and how they celebrated on October 7 of last year, I'm not sure whether calling them animals is unfair to the latter.
if you're unhappy with this solution, what do you think Israel should do instead to maintain it's security?
@nathanz8208 exactly . 👏
@@nathanz8208 If maintaining your "security" means oppressing millions, fighting all your neighbors, and defying the entire world, whose security is really being protected here?
This is basically Attack on Titan
Yes it is.
Wall Maria, rose and sina
Is it? Close but no
and the Rumbling is WW3
Irrelevant but what a disappointing end to a great show.
To say that Hamas "removed the Palestinian authority in 2007" is quite a euphemism.
They were elected. US and Israel didn’t like that they won in a democratic election so they tried to overthrow them
quite the euphemism
October 7th didn't really work out well for them. And I don't understand why Hezbollah/Libanon started poking the bear, as if they wanted to be attacked. It's sad what they put their people through.
Its sad? Don't pretend you care. You don't care. If you cared you would have bothered to learn why they "poked the bear".
Why did they poke the bear then?
One important thing that I think was left out was all the effort Egypt has put in on their side to prevent smuggling into Gaza. They literally evicted thousands of people and bulldozed everything within a multi-kilometer buffer zone that is under control of their military in order to make smuggling harder. Nothing exists there now except for military facilities, the border crossing, piles of rubble, and dirt. A narrow strip of Israeli controlled pavement on the Gaza side of the border is nothing in comparison to what they have done.
Egypt is a military dictatorship that has to strangle its own population that, last time they voted, they democratically elected the Muslim Brotherhood (born from resistance when Egypt was under the British Empire) which is technically the origin of Hamas. It would be a whole other seperate video, and a long one at that.
The Egyptian side of things is often left out. The Egyptians more than anything fear the intermingling of the Iranian backed Hamas and their own insurgency in the Sinai. It's basically the entire reason the civilian population of Gaza has no where to go because the Egyptians feared that Hamas weapons or soldiers would end up joining up with their own rebels.
Yeah it looks like not many of their neighbors want the Palestinians to harbor terrorism
They did it on their own territory though.
@@XandateOfHeavenno, they fear the United States. Since independence who has meddled more in Egypt; Iran or the USA... You know the answer, so does the government of Egypt.
This plan reminds me a lot of the Spanish plan for winning the Cuban Revolution in the 1890s. Basically you cut the length of the territory into multiple chunks, blocked by armed checkpoints, to prevent freedom of movement for insurgents and cut off the organization's ability to siphon support from the local population.
But the Israelis will run into the same problem as the Spanish did: it takes an awful toll on the local population. Less freedom of movement means less commerce, less ability for aid to get through, makes it harder for people to see their friends and family locked in other districts. Now I have no doubt that the Israelis will be better funded than the Spanish were, and likely won't engage in as much brutal conduct as General Weyler did, but they might want to take note that when states engage in "reconcentration" policies, it seldom ends well.
You forget to mention the USA, this time is not backing the insurgents but the colonisers. That has played wonders for Israel for years and it will continue to do so.
The conduct that Israelis have already engaged in is worse than anything done by the colonial powers.
Well the economic hardship that will result will not affect Israel at all.
Contrary to your example of Cuba, Gaza is not a colony.
Their conduct has been documented and will be used in court.
@@mathieusimoneau3358 do you even believe what you have written yourself? They are literally colonizing Gaza.
That is a great quote: Without enforcement rules are just polite suggestions.
Absolutely. International law is meaningless if not actually upheld
@@minkinns8438
Like why should israel obey these rules if the other side doesn't.
Chumps don't survive long in the middle east ask armenia.
@@nicbahtin4774armenia is not in the middle east. You seem uneducated and ignorant sadly
Because they claim to be modern country @@nicbahtin4774
@@alen2773what nonsense, Armenia is a middle eastern country, continents are divided by bodies of sea or mountains, above Georgia, Azerbaijan and Armenia is a huge line of mountains cutting Russia from the Caucasus, therefore clearly Armenia is middle eastern, part of the Middle East divided from Europe by a massive line of mountains clearly separating Caucasian lands from Russia and Europe, I can’t believe your so uneducated in geography.
Not only in terms of geography but also in language and culture, the entire Armenian history is filled with mostly middle eastern interactions between Syrians and Mesopotamian and Anatolian people, Armenian culture is purely middle eastern and resembles Syriac culture and Pontic Greek Anatolian culture, and Assyrian culture, I can’t believe your so ignorant to such a point, we in Lebanon have Armenians a lot and they’ll have a good laugh at being called “European” 😂😂😂.
Furthermore Greek and Byzantine culture itself is Middle East based, I’m sure true Greeks would agree, the Byzantines used turbans and middle eastern clothing and customs as shown in the Chora church, the entire Greek history before Charlemagne of the franks was just pure Greek interactions and mixing with the Middle East since Alexander the Great, the Byzantines even then treated Europeans as “barbarians” your an absolute ignorant, Greek Armenian and Assyrian and Syriac cultures and Italian ( especially south Italian ) are similar, alien to European culture and are very middle eastern.
Furthermore the Middle East is not Arab, they came after their brutal conquests of the levant.
( I’m not speaking on politics, I’m speaking here pure history because your claims are preposterous )
Sincerely, from a Lebanese Catholic…
So Netanyahu, Biden and Harris will get Nobel peace price for building a fish tank
Hamas begged for it.
@@testthewest123 disagree, it all started because of British and French mischief to keep middle east divided and eternally at war with their divide and rule policy, which Jews bought into it And US is still continuing.
lol yup
@@testthewest123 Gazan were already living like that before. The only difference is this time the territory is getting smaller and smaller.
@@hamaidmk skill issue
This is basically the Israeli government trying to split the difference between their occupation of Gaza from before 2005, and "disengagement" from 2005 to present. They know occupying Gaza in its entirety is too costly, but its now political suicide for the Israeli government to allow Hamas to come back, so they need to convince voters they've done something. Gaza will essentially suffer the same fate as the West Bank, but probably without settlements.
I would say they can't do this long term, because it makes a permanent peace essentially impossible. The Palestinian government ruling a rump state occupied by Israeli troops means there is no chance for the two sides to develop separately and animosity be forgotten. Hwoever the Israeli military occupied Gaza for decades before 2005. The Arab world also cares less and less about the conflict, as they see Islamists as a greater threat compared to the benefits of scapegoating the Israelis for internal problems.
Israel left Gaza alone for 17 years and they got rockets for 17 years. There’s no other choice from a Statist perspective.
Sums it up pretty well. Politically speaking, Gaza is the more troublesome prospect for peace between the two Palestinian territories due to the fact that it, arguably, had a real tangible chance at autonomous government. A chance that ended with rockets and war. Of course there are no saints in this conflict. Israel had an initial hand in Hamas' rise to power, but many see Gaza as responsible for their own actions (complicated i know given the amount of foreign powers involved and the internal dictatorship).
In contrast, while not simple in the slightest, the west bank has been peacful-ish in recent memory. With pre-existing plans for its own autonomy. Plans that were left by the wayside during Netanyahus goverment but it would still be a less painful pill to swallow compared to Gaza. There is absutolutly no chance that israel would allow an autonomous Gaza given the absolute fiasco and devastation of the last two decades of Gazan independence. Say what you will about israeli interference in Gaza up till now, it was still an attempt to stay outside apart from military interests (stopping weapons transports).
@@BlueSpawn maybe isreal goverment shouldn't have made there life hell in blocked?
@@takeserious2641 The problem is a sort of chicken and egg. Israel fear attacks from Hamas and has a blockade, blockade gives Hamas new recruits, Hamas launches attacks, Israel retaliates and tightens sanctions.
Part of the issue here is that Hamas isn't acting in the interest of the population of Gaza, because they know attacks won't lift the blockade. They're acting in the interest of Iran, which is the only way their strategy makes sense, it's otherwise too self destructive.
@@KorenGreenbergwell if israel still honour the oslo agreement maybe the 7 october attack would not happened either
Lets take bets on how long it takes for Israel to start building settlements in these 'corridors' and 'buffer zones'
1 month. Calling it now
😂 goose, Israel left in 2005.
If palestinians accepted Israel's right to exist they would have gaza and the entire Westbank. They opted for double or nothing. They are getting nothing.
That's a bad idea. I understand the point to the corridors, and they could help Israel economically by giving them access to the sea in more places, but they should never be settled.
@@hmidlashkham5552 I'm guessing they won't, if they do that's incredibly foolish. The whole point of the corridors is to have the fighting away from Israeli civilians settlements.
Honestly, I don't see how anyone can't see this plan and not think it as anything less than setting up a hard occupation.
Do u think Israel should allow sovereignty after the Oct 7 attacks? No country in this earth would allow that I guarantee it. If anything maybe it’s UN forces instead of Israel, but they need to be proactive or else Israel will need to step in again.
Occupation of Jewish own land. Right. UK occupies Muslim London.
@@davidcooks2379 clearly you have a laughable understanding of history.
The idea of Zion being Jewish land wasn't even born before 1896. Some Palestinian families spent 11 generations in Palestine.
Oh, and since you most likely don't know what happened in 1896, Theodor Herzl published Judenland
It is. But Hamas went to war, and they ll lose. You know, I know, everyone knows they ll re-arm themselves and attack Israel again, so that is what you get: control and subjugation.
Unfortunately.
@@johnythecookedsteak4819the land of Israel being Jewish is older than the religion of Islam good sir. There’s a ton of evidence to support this.
Remember what happened to the USS Liberty 🗽
Israel has never been our friend they just cling on to larger military and political powers to fund their offensive war effort. People don’t bring up that Jewish terrorist groups where attacking British army personnel in the 40s no one talks about that and after the British empire collapsed than they latched themselves on to America then attacked the USS liberty, the Israeli state is not our friend.
Nooo dont mention that. Thats obviously an accident (jk)
When you remember that friendly fire is a thing
Didn’t Palestine celebrate the 9/11 attack?..
@@ElSauxy02 what????
Starting a war and losing doesn’t make you the victim
Who started this in 1948? Yea, that's right.
@@jamiey1200The arab league did, do your research instead of repeating false statements online, you absolute buffoon. Radical Islamic violence and hatred for jews started long before 1948 anyways, there's a reason there are no jewish communities in any Arab countries.
And winning confers no moral claim. Might is not right.
Absolutely right my brother. Imagine the other way around. They would have no mercy. Israel have been very kind.
@@stevenwotherspoon5205 - Barbarian logic.
Ah so they gather them all under tight control, kinda like in ghettos? Why does that sound familiar?
Sounds very familiar. Indeed...
Kinda like something that happened in ww2
Because you WANT it to sound familiar! Yalla snackbarr! There are 54 muslim states on Earth. Can you tell us ONE, with democracy, Woman Rights, sexual freedom, Freedom of Speech, Press, and a strong Economy(not only fossile Oil), Science, but no War, Torture, Dictatorship, Inflation xxl, Corruption xxl? You cant?
WHAT does this tell us about islam?
They are free, to leave! Your Picture is BS!
Dont remember jews invading Germanny , kidnap & r@pe & murder Germans.. also, these are no gehttos, Weve seen what happen when Israel left in 2005 and left them to built their own autonomy... Not a good idea
A person with basic empathy would call it a concentration camp.
Netanyahu calls it shooting fish in a barrel.
Nah this just West Bank model on Gaza finally…
@@yl_ohmeohmy racism at its finest.
@@fawaaza.7743 hey I went to a fish market you know what I’m sayin? I went to to this fish market and I said “ooooh good morning Hamas!”
@@yl_ohmeohmy😂😂😂so funny
A person who has more heart than brains would call it that.
A person who has more brains than heart would call it a necessary security measure.
If you lose a war you started you lose the ability to dictate the outcome.
@@alesh2275 than i guess isreal is lossing the war
@@alesh2275 i guess isreal is loosing the war
The Treaty of Versailles would like a word. How did that work out for everyone?
@@bassistmike1987 Versailles was comparatively lenient compared to the decade long occupation, systematic dismantling and rebuilding of the German state and full annexation of Prussia after World War 2.
Who do you think "started" this war? It certainly wasn't the people of Gaza.
Germany and Austria had occupation zones after a war where a radicalized population were happy to fight and die to conquer their enemies. This is what happens in war against an expressly genocidal regime
You’re confused; this video is about if Israel *wins*.
Ig the mentioned genocidal regime is not Shitrael, this is the most idiotic comment I've seen in a while. And I regularly read Zionazi comments, so this is high "praise."
@@NahedElrayes they are winning though, so far atleast
@@NahedElrayes When*
Yes Hamas and Islamic Jihad are expressly genocidal regimes (see what happened to the PA in Gaza and the Christian community), and Israel will have to occupy Gaza again for awhile just like the allies and Soviet Union did with Germany.
When your enemy wants nothing more than to destroy you (and acts upon it), does it not make sense to occupy his lands until he can be trusted? This was successfully done to Germany after WWII.
Thank you for helping us understand why these people are the "chosen ones" during ww2, everything makes perfect sense now.
They literally installed former Nazis as technocrats and completely failed at denazification. There was no success in the program, because obviously, the only way to redevelop the country was to get the people who actually live there to participate in its redevelopment.
That's the problem with what Israel wants to do in Gaza. They have no intention of having Palestinians in control of any part of Palestine, in either Gaza or the West Bank because they are not interested in a Palestinian state.
Thank you for highlighting an example of the left news not covering something important. I feel like in the West, it is popular to automatically take the side of the "victim" regardless of the facts. It is important to be educated by views and facts from all sides in order to figure out the closest truth rather than that heard in local Western news and social media alone. Ground news is great for this, Cheers
The world's largest Concentration Camp.
I think you should look up what that word means.
@@JohnTheStunIt's what's happening in Gaza and on a lesser scale in the West Bank.
India will break this record in the future.
@@SeimaBlessings *BRRR* Wrong. Try again.
With 500km of tunnels? Lmao
Most shocking thing the last year was how the world has (not) reacted
There are 54 muslim states on Earth. Can you tell us ONE, with democracy, Woman Rights, sexual freedom, Freedom of Speech, Press, and a strong Economy(not only fossile Oil), Science, but no War, Torture, Dictatorship, Inflation xxl, Corruption xxl? You cant?
WHAT does this tell us about islam?
I still dont understand why the British and other European powers did not simply divide the region into North and South with Jersualem being a neutral zone. The fact they put pockets of territories everywhere was doomed for disaster
The intention was basically the same as India, to have the zones roughly in line with where people lived. But more importantly it's very likely the Israelis would have declared independence and a war would have started with the Arab League no matter the partition plan. If anything starting it with population transfers might have made it worse.
It was but people thinking 7 October is first day of this bs but it’s from post ww2 and Zionist didn’t think is enough and started attack them and steal their lands and the nato (allies) remade new contract that changed the map to small lands then again Zionist did it again and left only 2 lands west and east they didn’t want share it from start but they want all Middle East as their holy land look what they attacking now ? Their plan to take all land from Egypt to Iraq and Syria wait and see their reason of attacking Syria or Iraq they will say “we defending our people” by killing Iraqi children
because they want to have reason to intervene in the middle east. biden once said, "if there was no israel we hat to invent one". the middle east is the richest place on earth and the geography is the most important for trade.
Israel tried in several occasions to split Jerusalem with that exact intention. It was always rejected because Israel demanded that their neighbors recognize their right to exist in exchange which was too much to ask
@@johnhenryiii3070the fact that Israel asking to be recognized as having a right to exists is to big an ask shows where the start of this whole problem comes from.
Just remember who started the war in Gaza and how
Yes Isreal attacked mosque goers in Ramalan month and they responded with oct 7 attack
Question is.. how many isrealies died in oct 7 attack?
Israel. By decades of occupation and war crimes
Just remember who started the German - Herero "war" in 1904. It started with Hereros killing many farmers and it ended with a genocide against their people by the Germans.
So - by your logic - they had it coming I guess?
This didn't start on October 7th.
Why don't you google what the Nakba and operations "Protective Edge", "Cast Lead" and "Guardian of the Walls" were
By that logic Hitler is the good guy in WW2 as UK and France declared war first
I was in Sinai in 1977 Shall Mashek, and 1979 Eilat. I also got to tour in Bethlehem and Dome of the Rock in 1971. It only got more and more divided and dangerous, peace never came, but got worse.
The zionist stole the land and expelled* 700k of the native population in 1948
Many villages get slaughtered and in all 500 villages turn to ruble and planted forest over to hide what one time was there.
This is not something was better at the 70's, they called PLO terrorist back then, becous they wanted to free the land that was stolen from them.
If you are interested to understand the truth read or listen to audiobook of
The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine
By Ilan Pappé
No Islam, know peace.
Know Islam, no peace.
Israel has always taken and never given anything for peace
@@clanpsiright.. So if the Gazans become Christian Israel will let them live like Humans?
@@clanpsi shut the hell up, go take your medication
I've watched your channel for years, absolutely love your content and geo-political analysis. Genuinely believe your channel is an important community service.
I see viewers taking issue with your fishtank description. I'd like to remind viewers that YT would likely censor this video if there were any references made to the reality that certainly maps as a perfect circle over some of the regimes "David" here seems to take inspiration from. You've presented the issue as factually as possible, and that alone deserves applause because it is so difficult to maintain an objective perspective whilst gathering the facts on this topic.
What your detractors are having a hard time seeing is that, no, you are not downplaying anything. This is a perfect moment where the facts can speak for themselves with no additional commentary required.
It's a great time for him to talk about how the Kingdom of Hejaz Arab-ians migrants were given Jordan, the largest part of British Palestine but the Kingdom of Hejaz were outraged when the Brits gave Israel to the Otterman Empire Jews.
@@starchild5793 > the Kingdom of Hejaz Arab-ians migrants were given Jordan
No they weren't. That was something the British planned on, but it never materialized in the wake of WW1.
Likewise, nobody would care about Israel in 2024 if the west had only _planned_ to move the Jews there after WW2. The difference is that Israel actually exists. The theoretical Hejaz kingdom doesn't.
thats the lamest excuse.. so he used that term so he can profit a bit more from the video?
@@Moon___man monetisation potential is a function of visibility on a platform like this; not his fault we live in a capitalist superstructure
For real man, this channel is just great shit
As a nation, what are we to do with 2 million people who want us dead and live just 10 mins drive away from us?
Any ideas? I'm all ears.
All these losers in the comments won't give you one. They're too brainwashed with palestinian propaganda. They want you dead too, just like the arabs do. They think you're evil.
Relocate them to Russia. They have plenty of space, water and other resources. Also they desperately need more people to solve demographic problems. With some crazy amount of cash this plan could work out.
They want you dead because of how you have treated them for the last nearly 80 years.
I have advice but its too late for you now - learn to self reflect over your behaviour and see that there are consequences for your behaviour.
There's a saying "if you are thrown out of 1O9 bars then at sometime you have to realize its not them its you".
I'm glad that most here recognize the atrocities of the Israeli state.
Nah this is war Isreal can’t allow Gaza to keep attacking them.
But you need to understand the atrocities of the other side to really have a balanced view.
@@MisterPerson-fk1txgo back & look at the history of the reserve bank & the enslavement of mankind.
@@dustintacohands11071sr43l is a money grabbing state. The rich J3ws of USA burrow money off the bank(owned by them) to create weapons at the factory that’s (owned by them) they then send it to the war state to further make them more money. E.g Ukr4in3 drives up its national debt & burrows guns off USA. Ukr41n3 then hands farmable land to bl4ckr0ck. With the cycle being complete. They make money by burrowing, they make money by furthering military industrial complex, they make money by stealing land & bargained deals during war times. Basic pattern recognition & one can deduct what is really going on behind the scenes.
How can “they” make money at every sector. From the burrowing. To the manufacturing. To the foreign state repayments etc. Zelenksy is j3w so he dgaf about selling off Ukr41n3 land.
Remember there are still more than 100 Israeli hostages inside of Gaza
No one cares about them
Not even isrean't goverment cares about it
Remember there are more than 10,000 Palestinian hostages in Israeli prisons
Correction: 100 "israelis" prisoners. Ziotards
@@tmnimoment Random civilians you grab off the street don't really count as prisoners.
0:50 “without necessarily occupying the entire territory” IDK man that looks an awful lot like an occupation to me.
To paraphrase a Tel Avivian I met in the 2010s, “seventy years ago, we were the ones facedown on the ground, and the boots looked a little different.”
I assure you bro, this Israeli now changed his wrong notions - 'paliestinins' are the ONLY perpetrators in this war
@@davidblair9877 What he means is the Israelis don't want to have soldiers on every street in Gaza. They want to have the benefits (to them) of an occupation without having to commit the manpower to patrolling and running the entire territory. He's not framing it as an ethical question, but a strategic one.
@@XandateOfHeavenyup
Arab occupation
we live in the worst possible timeline
Why?
@@Hexavielego well because you guys exist
@@Hexavielegocommunists are putting their people in concentration camps and they don't say a peep, but if a Jew does it...
As israeli - agree... i wish that world could unite against the forces of evil.
bro is calling for a destruction of an ENTIRE STATE and don't understand he is the root of the problem - check yourself in the mirror little bro
This suspiciously look like the world's biggest gulag
in GULAG no one get free food from the UN
@@belakovdoj in the gulag the UN food trucks don't get bombed with the excuse of it being hijacked by hamas
In a gulag the prisoners don’t get to build tunnels and rockets
@@ヨママ yeah agree they should just put thier heads down and accept their new system , those silly Palestinians how dare they resist such actions by our greatest ally
Did they have 700km Of underground tunnels with terror and hostages in gulags?
The solution is to implement a new political administration in Gaza that actually cares about about improving the lifes of Palestinians.
LIke the puppet government in the West Bank? Hebron is the laboratory for the apartheid utopia.
That's going to be tricky after Hamas was elected and promptly stopped holding elections.
What does a real life prison camp look like? This is the blueprint. Taking the Warsaw Ghetto and American Reservations to the next level
You know nothing
@@trygd100 haha said the arrogant with no brain or arguments...
It's very unfortunate. Very unfortunate that people in the region seem unable to separate government from religious zealots hellbent on destroying a nation and western civilization because their "god" told them to do so.
As someone whos lived on the rez, its scarily accurate.
When money was tight, he'd get his lunch money from the local wishing well.
the animation looks like some kind of board game i think Israel has given up on any notion’s of peaceful resolution.
i have zero sympathy for gazans. they brought it on themselves when they cheered the deaths of a thousand
God bless israel ❤
Hummas making demands on Israel about what they want for Gaza, that's rich.
Because They Won And Kicked Out The idf From Gaza. This Plan Is Just Another Cope...
They don’t want peace, they got no peace.
True. Israel wants war.
no peace untill palestine is free
You’re right. Hamas wanted war and that’s what they got. It’s sadly unsurprising, isn’t it?
@@drakehyman may the innocents get peace after all the pain
@@dodo-og2ss yes, on both sides. Amen.
Palestinians waking up to the meaning of FAFO.
They had 17 years to get their shit together. Instead of civilian infrastructure they built military infrastructure. Gazans can not be trusted to be anything more than Iranian pawns.
You are a brute
Israel waking up to discover they are the Nazis
Y'all purple haired folks that object to this probably didn't get the memo on why we are doing this in the first place
They're doing thia because they can, all with support of smooth brained sheeple such as you!
Now, What did Hamas actually achieved?
What Isreal achieved anyway?
They died and got a free trip to Jahannam?
@@Destroyer4700 weird way to refer what will happened to the jews
@@Destroyer4700Thats what will happened to You guys
@@MyBigweirdtankcorrection: for "IDF" occupation soldiers and their supporters
Nobody can argue Gaza isn't the world's largest open-air prison. 🤬
It is not
@@trygd100it is. And they kind of asked for it since they still want to fight even after a year of losing. What do you do with a neighbor willing to sacrifice 10 of their own to get one of you?
what is North Korea then? What is Xinjiang? ONLY YOU CANT ARGUE, because u are ignorant and biased
israel gave gaza freedom and look what they did with it.
LMAO, love it how you leftists and jihadis ignore North Korea
What people don’t understand is Palestine has been declaring war ever since. They were always the first ones who attack and have been defeated for multiple times. So what do you think the victors will do? Instead of conceding, Palestinians continues to conduct attacks against someone who defeated all of its neighbors in a matter of days.
Bullshit. Palestinians are occupied, it is the occupier that declares war on the occupied non-stop.
Because they never left Palastinian Alone, the colonisation never ended.
lol, what's next? are you going to claim israelis never used terrorism ( Hagannah, Irgun, Stern Gang)?
@@Ice-qx8yt never left alone? it was arabs who started in 1948...and its them who always start it again after previous conflict stops...same as with Oct7 germans did WW1 and after WW2 they were occupied for 40 years...its time to re-educate those terrorists and their brainwashed people and maybe they will strive for prosperity and not extermination of israeli jews
Correct!
The Abraham's Barbaric & Looney Trio
Suggesting that Israel will re-establish communities in Gaza is disingenuous at best. There is no serious discussion in Israel about actually doing this.
Bro your animations are amazing. And you have a great narrating voice. 5 stars. Such excellent quality.
It is what I thought they would. Splitting the strip into many parts allows them to treat each group differently as well.
This existed already pre 2005. It was called the five finger method
@@Jayhannes It exists in the West bank where there are checkpoints between the cities and villages. Some of these places get constant crackdown like Jenin but others do not.
divide and conquer
WHAT AND WHY ARE THEY FIGHTING FOR IN AFRICA ???
Modern Day 'Uh Parr Tide' in 2024, with US backing.
This reminds me of how germany was divided into many zones after WWII, history doesn't repeat, but it rhymes.
I hope Gaza doesn't get divided into more than 3 zones, is too densely populated, I understand the need for security, but I think that more than 3 would be compressing the area too much
There will be no security for the genpcidal apartheid regime of Shitrael. Don't compare the natives who have been subject to genocide, ethnic cleansing, mass murder, apartheid, torture and land theft to Nazis. The Nazis here are the ones who have in ideology based on race supremacy and lebensraum. And their overextended reich sooner or later will fall.
If they thought it was a open air prison before man are they gonna find out the actual meaning of it.
Israel has learned that there won't be any real truce or ceasefire as long as hamas remains. So it is natural that they will want to ensure that history doesn't repeat.
As an Israeli I'm against presented corridors (and against the occupation).
In 2005, Israel withdraw from the entire Gaza strip, leaving the territory for the palestinine people. What happens then? Hamas a brutal terror organization was elected, and Israelis suffer from daily rocket and missiles fired on them. and then October 7 massacred happens killing more than thousand of insistent Israelis.
I ask you, what does Israel can do to protect herself from ongoing daily missiles fired from Gaza strip, covering more than 2/3 of Israel territory. How can Israel can protect herself from those trying to eliminate her?
You're right, what is Israel supposed to do? Naive/spiteful minds will tell you to make more and more unilateral concessions, more self-restraint. But the other side has shown that they will likely only use that as an opportunity for more and bigger attacks. What will they expect you to do then?
Israel needs to recognize the Palestinian state with full sovreignity and I guess there will be no more rockets fired from Gaza or any other front ;)
It's simple, make peace with them accept you just can't win this way,stop considering them as degraded human beings recognise Palestine state
@@karims4168*cough cough oslo accords*
@@pieegee8532 wtf? I think u have no clue about the Oslo accords, Israel did not recognize a full Palestinian state they just agreed to recognize the PLO, Israel never left the west bank since and kept expanding and stealing Palestinian land and building illegal settlements
Why'd Hamas attack Israel? 💀
you are totally clueless, aren't you? you're right exactly where they want/need citizens of western countries to be. this war is religious 1000%. the land of palestine is supposed to be open for all of the 3 abrahamic religions, this is why it was bouncing between the 3 for the past 3000, give or take, the jews think they're promised almost all of the arab peninsula. the muslims know how important this land is for the end of times, mecca is the holiest of places for muslims but it isn't the only, the mosque and the dome are too. i don't know about the christians, in my pov, they're really lost. now, we can that jews have more or less 2 main factions the zi*oni*sts and the hardcore. the hardcore factions believes its not the right time to make their 'right of land' for their people, they're waiting on their savior/leader aka the antichrist in the muslim religion. and ghe first faction is using a mix of religion and economical influence and everything you can imagine to make their vision come true. now on the other hands muslims are defending not just for palestinian citizens right but for all of the muslims in a way, that's why all of the islamic nations stand behibd them, at least the people, governments have no say in this as no gov dares go against the giants rule. this answer is already long enough, it might not provide a clear answer but it does provide more context and clarity
I fucking wonder
Because israel has been attacking palestine for decades...
@@dinamosflams read
@@autodigitvlogs write
Looks like an open air prison
Free Gaza from Hamas
it already was one since it's inception...
Look at we did to Germany after World War 2. This is nothing new.
That’s what they have chosen when they decided to elect a terrorist government 🤷♂️
Not being allowed into a neighbouring country doesn't mean you're "imprisoned" in your own
Nothing like another video that speculates without a single source in the video or description. Love your work, keep spreading your divisive guess work on this conflict.
For all that oppose israel, what should the solution be when ceasefire is not negotiable???
The teenage boy was accused of breaking his arm simply to get out of the test.
What will be the role of Google and Elon Musk in this matters ? Especially when its about surveillance ...
God forgive us for these unending transgressions against your children. All are condemnable and all should be condemned. We are grateful for your unending grace.
shervan talking about this like its an interesting experiment instead of modern day nazi occupier practices is just disappointing
he is talking about it from historical perspective.
If you want to talk about humanitarian aspects you shouldn't omit Hamas' terror against civilians
🤡
He's being neutral which is mote professional😊
this is caspian report, what'd you expect? Azerbaijan is the biggest supplier of gas to them in the region.
I particularly liked neutral language of this video in a topic that is highly polarised. Thanks
Very balanced reporting, thank you for your hard work.
Before making another typical Apartheid Comment, just know that underdogs aren't always the good guys
Definitely! If Hamas wanted peace, they would have left Israel alone and cracked down on terrorism, once they gained power and Gaza independence in 2005.
*west
more people need to see this
@@pebblepod30they had no airport, no harbour no way in or out... So they never had independence
@barryirlandi4217
They did have much more independence, with all Jews removed from Gaza, but they - as I understand- kept using it to be a security risk.
An airport is not what makes independence.
They elected their own Govt (Hamas), and kept using their resources for attacking Israel.
Can you imagine how things would have gone if Hamas would have given up on attacking Israel, stopped rocket attacks and used their resources for peaceful means?
Idk if Netanyahu's strategy is going to be the best for eventually forcing peace (I suspect not, and I suspect he really wants Greater Israel, not peace), but it is still true that the underdog (Hamas & their supporters) are not the good guys.
It would be the biggest and most horrible irony ever if descendants to a people which suffered immense atrocities in concentration camps during WWII, would end up running even larger ones in present day.
Does a ge-no themselves for people to justify there in WW2
Because karma goes in circles, the palestinians were the nazis in prevoius life. They has been many studies on this. Past life regression, you have paletinians kids 3-8 years old that have past life memory of ww2. You can find books on this
You wouldn't say the same if you were an Israeli who always has to look at their shoulder everytime they're near Gaza. Hamas vowed to annihilate Jews. So how are they supposed to defend themselves from that wanton terrorism?
Moron comment. Typical new age false intellectual, compares everything to Nazis
They Never Suffered Anything. It's All A Lie..
Philadelphi corridor is not new. They are just putting it back and adding some of it all across Gaza.
In a way, the prison now has cell blocks
Pfft, obviously Gaza should be part of Egypt, and the West Bank part of Jordan...this is sooo boring.
@@MarkMcAllister-ni9sf I'm speaking to how gaza is often described as an open air prison by certain media outlets
@@MarkMcAllister-ni9sf And Isreal should be sent to Auswits.
Basically Gaza is becoming Bantustan
Just watch how fast they start building new settlements.
Good video, what you're missing is that this is all the same as it USED TO BE before Israel left Gaza, in essence. There was this plan called "the five-finger print" which is how peace was kept (relatively speaking) between 1967-2005 inside Gaza.
Misinformation
They REALLY want to be pariahs on the international stage, don't they? 🤮
For everyone who is critical of Israel, what do you think Israel should do?
ah the one question they would never answer
I already type a lot, but it is deleted by youtube.. the idea that i type should make that area be peaceful.
@@userd588 that's a goal, not a plan.
@@007kingifrit i write a long plan, but it is repeatedly delete by youtube.
@@userd588 thats fair, youtube sucks
None of these policies will lead to a long term peace. These people need to integrate and have grand children together. Loke the confederates and Yankees now share great grand children as an integrated union. That is the only path to peace. The rest of these policies I cannot support. Xenophobia will never lead to peace.
I guess you missed the fact that Zionazism is an ideology based on race supremacy and lebensraum. "The master race" will never mix with the "untermensch". The only solution they want is the final solution.
America had a mostly similar English speaking culture with the same fundamental values. But you cannot mix Muslims with Jews, as the core of Islam mandates the complete destruction of all Jews. In Judaism, there is nothing to accept other nations and they don't convert. The West is ignorant that is is complete unable to see this as a perpetual religious (Jihad) war/struggle.
There is absolutely no possibility for diplomatic peace. In the East, "Western values" like diplomacy, kindness, compassion are viewed as major weaknesses. Eastern leaders cannot allow themselves to be seen weak by their own people.
There will be never peace from the Arab side until they murder all Jews. Then they turn against each other and then strive for world domination (the Caliphate).
And the West is still baffled and believes in "discussion". Until you can dismantle religion, do not expect any constructive progress unfortunately.
People who cry for "the Jews illegally occupy the land" then provide and alternative: where do you want to transport ~10 million Israelis? Also why not a single Arab nation helped with the "poor" Palestinians?
Nothing is black and white, but insanely complicated on several layers.
I don't expect anything than temporary "quiet" rather than peace in the next 2000 years in the region.
Unfortunately, Israel and its surrounding arab states have been at conflict ever since the day Israel even gained independence from the British. Even before that the hostilities existed. Local arab leaders dehumanizing jews because they started migrating to the region from Europe during the Holocaust. The animosity is generational and it may never go away in our lifetimes.
Wisest commont here. Only true integration, becoming one with the other, heals these wounds. MLK Jr. understood that.
Israel has never known peace. They just want to survive.
You displayed all the corridors in the same width but said that the one on the border to Egypt is 100m in width, while the one next to Gaza City is 2000m in width
This is straight out of a sci fi movie, modern colonialism being supported by everyone!
Respected analysis Shirvan.
Your maps are very good.
Result of 7 october , play stupid games win stupid prizes.
hehe man you know it was not started October 7 don't be stupid
Sorry, the settlements that Israel put in Gaza were not illegal. Just because the anti-Semites in the world labeled it that doesn’t mean it’s true. Israel won the territory of Gaza from a defensive war. It was disputed territories. And if it was smart, they would annex the Gaza.
The people of Gazza could leave. The unfortunate problem is none of the arabs wants them. Isn’t is a shame they own people don’t want them.
@@upperstone6738 We don't build on Native Reservations in the West. A border must be drawn and accepted by both sides. No more violence from Hamas however they are funded by Iran so this may go on for a long time
@@vicfontaine5130 that’s not true. If it was true Manhattan would still be owned by the Native Americans!
@@upperstone6738 I'm referring to current day, even building pipelines is tricky.
@@vicfontaine5130 your comparing peaceful group of people like the native Americans to a genocidal terrorist organization that is running the Gazza strip. It’s like comparing apples to oranges.
If it wasn't an open prison before it will now be it if this really happens
It was always open air pris on under the international law
The wheels of justice turn slowly Israel, the wheels of justice turn slowly.
See I have totally the opposite values here. I think the priority should be whatever solution enforces peace in a practical way, namely, preventing attacks on Israel- which Hamas etc are realistically going to do no matter what Israel does, if they are able to.
Where your highest value seems to be an idealism that has no respect for any practical considerations involved in peace in Gaza. Obviously, there is nothing Israel can realistically or reasonably do that stops the attempt to attack it from Militants, other than suicide or mass exodus to please those that hate them (not going to happen in the real world).
And I'm talking about the " force Gaza peace goal & strategy" - the topic of the video- not the rest of Netanyahu's strategy.
@@pebblepod30 I see so your solution to peace is to keep Israel happy while they:
A. Occupied the land and exiled the natives at inception.
B. Continue to expand settlements illegal even under today’s international laws.
C. Continue to subjugate Palestinians to apartheid.
D. Refuse to give the Palestinians a fair state and allow the refugees back.
E. Carry out group punishment when certain groups naturally resist this injustice.
Yes, we have different values indeed.
@Cheeriot
No, I didn't day any of that did I?
You assumed everything, and all those points are about idealism (which both sides will never agree on anyway), rather than peace in practical, achievable terms.
I was only talking about what is practically necessary to get any peace or any kind, other than total conquest and genocide.
Why not just answer what I asked instead, or give an alternative PRACTICAL REAL WORLD solution for peace?
@Cheeriot
I bet you are not going to stop thinking in black and white terms, and just simply try to think about what I said in practical peace terms.
My experience that people who lement the horrors of war, don't peace either (and yes, Netanyahu might not either, but that's beside my point about practical, real world peace over idealism).
@@pebblepod30 What is practical? It means both sides agree to a compromise and feel they’ve been treated fairly right? Otherwise it’s not practical just forced down the throat of one side.
Israel already exists, no denying, but so do the Palestinians. And, until they’re given a practical solution, they will always despise them, and naturally support groups like Hamas who will get them a shred of their dignity back when the opportunity arises.
I told you what the practical solution is but you refuse to listen and gaslight me instead. Treat the Palestinians like human beings, and don’t let Israel’s money and influence dictate the reality on the ground because it won’t bring peace. Ever.
How is Egypt making a “valid point”considering the context of Israel fighting a defensive war on the Philadelphia corridor? Like how is securing that border not beneficial for Egypt? As their border is compromised if Hamas controls it? Make that make sense?
You forgot to mention that Hamas originally arose from such a situation.
Kid your zog father started with Nakbha
this is right - what do you suggest Israel should do to protect it's population from genocide?
@@ImMrSpieglerprobably stop bombing people who are told to evacuate and go else where, then Israel bombs those places people went....
Stop the occupation and allow Palestinian state would be a good start.
@@Sa-ee3js and their leader got iced from it. And put their people in a even worse situation
This looks like a dystopian nightmare.
So many Palestinian copers in the comment section 😂 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
Atleast we dont laugh at tragedy
@@nabilnufaeil6464 You gave out candy on 10/7
@@alphablobmom5521 palestine got full meal from israel since 1967 until now.
@@nabilnufaeil6464yeah you don't laugh you celebrate like there's no tommorow😂😂😂
Considering the fact that they’ve enacted a full blockade on the north and are currently starving 300K people, I’d say thats the job of these “corridors”
Brown hands have typed this…
Is it just me or is caspian report strangely pro Israel?
Seems pretty impartial to me.
He's azerbaijani jew
Gods chosen what a joke that is
Greater Israel Project. They need land.
Oy vey, that's just a conspiracy theory 🤫
Right like Israel can’t wait to take Gaza back. Nobody wants Gaza not even its leaders. You think Israel is gonna do any rebuilding there?
Similar tactics were used by British in South Africa and were successful.
Humint is still indispensable despite Israel's relative military technological superiority.
An amazing report that collates Geography with News!!
Very sad state of affairs
Wars have consequences. They should make peace like every other losing party in human history.
This is fasinating how high-quality and well put the video is, and all the facts are correct.
But one thing just bothers me. Not a single mention of 7th of october. But many times bringing up presumed plans for new Israeli settlements (acknowledging that it is the hardliners who seriously suggest that).
I was a fan of the channel for long time (since the microphone was not that good) and it always impressed me for almost unbiased report painting a clear picture without any blindspots at least. But for some reason when it comes to the largest terrorist atack since 9/11 it is called "current hostilities" like I'm watching Russia Today and not one of my favorite channels the CaspianReport. When put like that, still professionaly and highly factual, but without the key reason why Israel is doing what it's doing currently, it paints the picure like Israel has just started all of this just for the sake of settlements.
Israel doing all of to make impossible the events that at 7th of October happen again. How it is doing it is a totaly legitimate point and we must debate that.
I believe that nothing stops a bullet like a job and that Israel must invest in Gaza bacause it is in it's own interest and because for many years noone showed any intention to do it for them. And before 7th of October it kind of was the case, Israel suplied Gaza with water, electricity and money practicly free of charge and with no string attached. Now Israel will be a lot more reluctant.
All supported by uncle sam.
Not in my name.
Ethnik 'Klenn Sing' with US backing.
"The Philadelphia Corridor"
Ah yes, aptly named.
"Brotherly Love"" indeed.
If the victor gets to draw the map, a better question would be "What is Hamas's end game for Gaza"