Nah, the public caning only last 2 minutes. Why ? Because sharia caning is not the same as civil caning. The cane size and technique are not the same. While 1 civil caning will heavily damage the butt , bleeding and take month for it to heal before another 1, sharia caning not damaging at all. This law work because there's still higher shame awareness in the society
@@desmondsee1890 Introducing cane to their butt. Butt, meet Cane, He is happy to see you... Interesting fact, in Indonesia, there's one province that use Sharia law, Aceh. Non-Muslim are given choice of punishment by Sharia Law or Jail, the data show, they usually choose canning. Because jail, took time from their life, while healing from canning usually take less time.
No worries, Malaysia will be high income economy in 2 years. Worries about your first..Singapore still canes people, you calling Singapore backward too? Or am I wrong?
The muslim being interviewed stated that they support public caning and some even wanted to implement such punishment nation wide. Malaysian modernisation in the 70s to 80s come to a waste.
Kalau ada masa nak minum dkt kedai, apa salahnya buka internet baca perkara yg berkait dengan berita tu lebih teliti, sbb kebanyakan islamophobic dia takkan mampu jawap soalan simple tentang Islam , apakah lagi berkenaan undang2 Islam, disebabkan baca berita sahaja , kalau Betül modern Jangan baca headline, dengar sekerat2
What a shallow comment, you speak as if the authorities are going to impose syariah law to all tourists coming to Malaysia. Non-Muslim are not subject to Syariah law you dingus.
The syariah law only applies to certain states as Malaysia is a federal state. Certain states with a significant non-muslim population don't have such a punishment. Unfortunately, this happened in conservative state so they had to execute the punishment.
@@virenkumar6058 I prefer this way, if it truly make ppl scare to commit a crime, it will really help a lot. Malaysia current crime rate is getting hard, there a lot kidnapping, robbery, rapist, and murdered happen after covid lockdown
Only applies to poor people soon it will be world news the pm will have to add this in his world speech lectures other than the Gaza Palestinian speechs
Wow is Malaysia is going back to 1400 years cave century unfortunately while others countries are advancing into the technology world from Vietnam, Thailand, Myanmar, Laos, Indonesia, and Philippine ...
It's just an instance in a minor state. Malaysia as a whole is less of a shithole country compared to most of those you mentioned, objectively speaking.
@@RUclipsChannel-fu5yw Well if Islam is that great muslim won't be killing muslim for leaving the faith ...you are so damn right we are fearing of Islam of their violence ...who give you the right to cane this man in front of the people to install fear to muslim and who are giving fear to the muslim itself ...
@@RUclipsChannel-fu5yw Have you ever question why do you think they are doing this to the muslim ...why do you think in the Arab world muslim are leaving Islam in closet and can you really understand Arabic in order to understand the Quran and are you getting your knowledge from the Iman..and not from your own brain to understand the arabic teaching ...Use your brain rather than following blindly ..
*Am confused about this khalwat like what if a man khalwat with another man that has no blood relationship let say they staying in same hotel room is it allowed or not ?*
@AntiZionisLaknatullah I know that but I meant is if let say a man stay in hotel room with another man to save hotel cost and they just both friends visiting Malaysia and both Muslim so is it allowed or not or they need to stay in separate room since they both have no blood relationship thats why am not sure about this close proximity and take note both are straight man they just want to save hotel charges so need to know whether its allowed or not ?
@@PVillapah But can a man stay with another man in hotel room so they can save on hotel charges when they go for holiday but of course they sleep on separate bed
Victimless "crime". Nobody is hurt, nobody is a victim. Yet treated like a criminal and caned publicly. They can never stop forcing their beliefs on others
Cuba fikir, lu sebagai ibu dan bapa tengok anak lu kena sebat depan orang ramai apa rasa lu. Lagi apa rasa orang yang kena sebat itu. Mungkin dia fikir lagi kejam lepas itu,bila dia bebas nanti. So, bagi saya zaman beribu tahun dulu bolih guna undang 2 macam itu. Sekarang zaman morden, ada cara kita bolih menghukum. Emak bapa yang kena rotan itu sudah tentu ada perasan cemburu.
Religion is protected from criticism, thats why we have this.Nothing will change in our lifetime.Just accept it. Imagine if PAS one days gains full power.
They probably never will. A good possible reason that they're doing it to the man in the video is to sent a clear and stern warning to those who may engage in such illegal acts. But the reality is that, a lot of people will get away with it even with how strict Islam is.
Why sickening? It just shows how ignorant you are. If a male stranger was in a room with your teenage daughter, would you let it be? Voters in Kelantan and Terengganu have been voting for PAS in fair democratic elections. Why do you think you know better? Have you visited these places before. FYI, Kelantan is home to the largest sitting Buddha statue and the 2nd largest reclining Buddha statue in SE Asia.
You can have public caning so long as there is freedom of choice with religion. Make no mistake, this is a public display of power. religion is being used to control and wield power. once you implement freedom of religion, watch their power be eroded
Apostasy is a big sin in Islam. Such rules apply in Muslim majority countries! The practice of pennance is common in many religions! Many religions have severe punishments for certain offences. Joan of Arc was burned at the stake! Some religious punishments have changed with the time! Some not! All are decided by those who are in power! 😀💪
This will attract seperatists from Neighboring southern Thailand to join Malaysia due to having this kinda sharia law that “satisfies them”. Becareful by saying, “this should be applied to the whole of Malaysia” brother, it won’t affect your country alone but also transnational issues.
Malays have been living in that area up till Phuket. They woke up one day, found out League of Nations decided those fall under Thailand. Of course, they oppose it.
According to the Malaysian Muslim Lawyers Association, the caning was done according to the Constitution. They say, it only follows the Terengganu Sharia Criminal Enactment, Sec 125! Which allows the punishment in a humanitarian manner! It said, the lashes were light, smaller rotan used with little force and not injuring the guilty person. (Today's Utusan, pg 4).😀🇲🇾
@@peacefulindian318to soft, and then they surprise that the offender repeat the same crime 😮. Thanks to this, Malaysia crime rate are increasing. 🤦🏽♂️
Every religions got your own religious laws, rules and regulations should just stick on your own religious laws, rules and regulations because PREVENTION is better than cure
Malaysia is a federalist system. Hence, each state has their own laws and customs. Though I might not agree with it, we must respect it or not don't be preaching diversity only when it is in your favour.
Friend, perhaps you have missed this point. Islamic affairs are administered by each state government , of which the respective sultans of each state is the head of Islamic affairs under the constitutional monarchy political system . Therefore, each state would implement Islamic Shariah laws differently. The 4 states of Perlis, Kedah, Kelantan and Trengganu are ruled by the democratically elected conservative Islamic politically party, PAS ( Parti Al-islam Se-Malaysia) . Hence, these state governments would implement a more stricter Shariah law that is approved by the state legislative assembly. What then is the federal government ( Putrajaya) 's role? It merely coordinate Islamic affairs ( excluding the Shariah laws) through the government agency , JAKIM . However, the Federal law, including the Penal code, is held supreme over state laws and no state law, other than those allowed, can supercede the provisions of the Federal law .
@kokkintang9983 we are talking the same point. It is just that I m simplifying it. But my point is we should embrace diversity in totality. The people of those state wanted to be govern by a Islamicly conservative government, then let them be. If we disagree, give concrete facts why they are wrong. Like psychological or criminalogical statistics.
@@kokkintang9983Muslims have separate laws regarding marriage, divorce, inheritance, etc. Some states have their own enactments of Islamic law provisions separately for Muslims. The states have the authority to enact such laws. Such laws cannot contradict the provisions in the Federal Constitution. A mother-daughter team have challenged the Kelantan enactments and won. In this caning incident, so far, no one challenge such laws in the Court. Federal government will not interfere in state islamic enactments, unless it's seemed as ultra-vires (done in a bad faith). 😀🇲🇾
@@kokkintang99832) Muslims generally don't oppose religion-based laws bec it's related to their faith. Like the Christians, Muslims are also have a duty to obey their commandments! Millions of Filipino Catholic women are waiting for divorce from their bad husbands, but the Church is slow in approving divorces. Bec, Catholic Church frowns on divorces. It's their belief. Muslims in Malaysia also follow the Federal Criminal laws in the Courts. Sharia laws are applicable in matters of adultery, fornication, and prostitution, Lgbt, etc! (I'm a Muslim).
@@lpfong2538Baseless in Malaysia there are robberies everywhere and everyday. Plus Malaysians are even caught on CCTV inside a play of workshop stealing. And Malaysia is listed as the world's most corrupted county. What moral value BS are you referring to? Shame on you the pot calling the kettle black! Shame on you!
@@lpfong2538 Singapore is not an Islamic country unlike Terengganu which is known as an Islamic state but yet still has pubs & bars and definitely has 'moral decay' just like the one reported here.
Do you think that the malaysian royalty or rich politicians are subject to the same laws ? Do you think religious affairs officials raid their hotels and homes looking for these offensives. This law weights heavily against the poor and the less well connected.
Uh.. I see people who are not Malaysian will misunderstood the location. No, it was NOT DONE INSIDE THE MOSQUE. It was done in a Dewan in Bahasa Melayu or translated to English is Hall. So he was caned infront of the public in a hall that is within the mosque area. Most mosque today have attached offices, classrooms, halls, and many more multipurpose rooms. I bet there will be more people that will be voicing their objection to it. But seriously people, don't be hypocrites. Look at the many people asking the police or government to release the identity of criminals that was censored to protect his/her identity. "Why censored this criminal's face". "Why hide their identity." So on and so forth. So when these criminals and law offenders is publicly punished by the law, suddenly they say it is a form of torture? It is inhumane? it is against human rights? It is degrading? Stop exaggerating and stop with the double standard. A public punishment is a good thing in my opinion. It serves as a warning and a reminder to others who watched it. It can act as a deterrent. AND IT WILL HELP MAINTAIN A FAIRNESS TO ALL WHO ARE PUBLICLY PUNISHED. Because there will be witnesses when the punishment is being carried. The person executing the punishment must do it fairly to all and follow exactly what supposed to be done or he will be held accountable for it. So instead of just leaving it 100% to the court, the public will also be involved in upholding the law. Which is what we all are supposed to do anyway.
The fact that you actually think punishing someone for "Khalwat" aka "Being around someone of opposite sex" is normal speaks volumes of how messed up Malaysia has become. God almighty. Basically the dark ages but with wifi.
I extremely curious - so will this Sharia Law of yours be implemented on non Muslims? And, is the Sharia Law above the country law or will there be only ONE law to follow? And which is the law that all citizens should abide?
@@milesedgeworth132 You obviously don't know what "khalwat" means do you? You are basically a person in the dark ages, with wifi, and smartphones, but doesn't know how to use it, or maybe you believe technology is some sort of sorcery and is a blasphemy to whatever God you believe in. This is why over simplifying and generalizing things can create misinformation and misunderstanding. But I highly doubt you care. You obviously just out to be hateful and spread your lie based hate to others. Read the damn news FULLY on this case AND UNDERSTAND what "khalwat" is first before you make spread hate and lies from your accusations. You are also flaunting your stupidity to the world.
Observe the laws of the country in which you live! In this case, no bonking or any form of sexual contact outside of marriage. Since this is very hard to prove*, they were slapped with the offence of 'khalwat', close proximity with a non-family member of the opposite sex. *The evidentiary requirements are almost impossible due to its strict criteria.
Once u bring religion into govt ,public , policy ,etc then problems starts. Worse if u spend billions on religion? Pm Anwar need to be blamed . He has no foresight , no pragmatism .He himself follows racial , religious policies n as FM allocates billions for religion ! PAS means *People Are Stupid* , People Always Stupid* ,*People Always Slander ** The Federal govt allocates yearly millions , billions to Kelantan , Kedah , Trengganu , Perlis ( Pas controlled states ) for economic development ,n how much goes for religions?
No choice for anwar bro, he has to do all this to win malay support if u cant win malay votes u cant be government. But at least we do see anwar doing real work also. Compared to other candidates he’s the best already.
fellow was a repeated offender. I assumed he was warned with the potential consequences the first time. but heyyy its 2024 and youre still following a tradition dated over a thousand years ago. then again what do i know im no expert🤷🏽♂️
The same goes for innocent women, young boys, and girls in the Middle East. Being married at a young age and died shortly after intercouse, little boys are used for pleasure, and women to produce baby.
@@90taetaeya Whether public or private, caning is still considered barbaric in the western world regardless of the offence type. An offence in one country may not be offence in another country. Still the western countries are not happy with Singapore's capital punishments and canings. Does this mean you are going to change them to look good to them? Same way let all countries practice the punishments in their own way.
Muta'ah marriage are marriage of convenience. A temporary marriage agreement for a certain period. It's not allowed in Malaysia. Some Muslim sects practice it in some countries!
To those Singaporeans who criticize this (mainly Islamophobes), canning is still a legal punishment in Singapore. So much for "Advanced" Singapore right?.
2blueshirt26 The difference is Singapore canning for punishment of crime while Sharia Law canning for mingling with women...Are you still living in a cave society and do not want to advance ...
Since u are clueless, be educated Singapore’s caning is based on serious n dangerous crimes which harm others like armed robberies, rapes, assault with weapons, injuries etc. Not for religious reasons like in the company of opposite sex or even committing adultery. 😆
Canning for “close proximity” for example talking to a lady who is not your relative? Anyway, I guess using ambiguous terms like "close proximity," especially in situations such as interacting with a woman who isn’t a relative, seems intentional. Certain authorities likely prefer such vague language because it allows for broad interpretation, enabling them to justify almost anything. In turn, this can be weaponized to target and persecute those who don’t conform to their specific man-made traditions.
@@salvation88I said in Banda not in other parts of Aceh, since now we have a govt institution to carry it out, but mainly Aceh now is not about religion but about development, punishment are for prevention not intended to carry out. Different than PAS that made its religion national headlines.
Singaporean will love this kind of news..kiasu punya attitude. Anyway, the Ringgit and the MYR is appreciating every week again..our GDP growing more than 5%, Singapore economy not moving ...😂
It's good to have dream, even day dream.. but we are very certain that Malaysia will never make it to 1st world. Too many 3rd world mentality and religions crippling the country growth. The Chinese were having delusion that ringgit will grow and surpass SGD but they are still flocking to Singapore to earn SGD. Indians have no say in the country.. Malays are complacent and still living in stone age time frame. We sincerely wish you good luck. 🤣🤣🤣
Viewers show some respects to our Muslim brothers in that particular state. That is won by the islamic party (PAS), they have their beliefs. Don't be an enemy or bastard, when you give your comments that you.
Respect one another, respect another's man religion or beliefs. The state is won by the Islamic party, that's a reason and backgrounds to that. Hope you are sensitive and tolerance to their beliefs...and not jump into conclusion too rapidly and be a bastard..😢
Syariah Law is only applicable in several states and not the entire Malaysia. However the religious authority can still arrest misbehaving Muslims anywhere in Malaysia. Non-Muslims are not affected. I have been to Terengganu and Kelantan many times and do not see any issues there.
@@YanQi. the backwardness of shariah law and it’s insulting attitude to normal people is the problem here. It’s all about power and humiliation. Nothing spiritual about that.
It's insulting that Asian people wants to be like Arabs, honestly its downright hilarious. Never thought religion has this so much power in the government because I thought shouldn't religion be individual thing or a group project.
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
So will the same punishment be extended to Malaysian celebrities and VIPs if they are guilty of khalwat?
Even more like berzina,etc
Respect their countries rules.
@@SabBliss Think they have immunity
If they are found guilty under the respective states that enforced sharia law at the moment and only applies to Muslims.
@@bobafett5757must revoke this immunity. All are equal except their iman
Shameful authorities. Uncalled for
And so they self righteously claimed that their middle east arabic desert religion is the most merciful, compassionate, forgiving, loving, etc??
Jesus Christ was also born in the Middle East! 😂
They should invite najib and rosmah to watch as they have been acquitted now
Not invite lim guan eng for tunnel case and anwar sodomy case?
so called religion of peace
The real beauty of tue religion of peace. You can marry up to 4 but you can not be close proximity to others❤❤❤
Nah, the public caning only last 2 minutes. Why ? Because sharia caning is not the same as civil caning. The cane size and technique are not the same. While 1 civil caning will heavily damage the butt , bleeding and take month for it to heal before another 1, sharia caning not damaging at all. This law work because there's still higher shame awareness in the society
Thanks for this.
How u know.
What's canning? Put them in cans? They're not tuna you know
@@desmondsee1890😂😂😂
@@desmondsee1890 Introducing cane to their butt. Butt, meet Cane, He is happy to see you...
Interesting fact, in Indonesia, there's one province that use Sharia law, Aceh.
Non-Muslim are given choice of punishment by Sharia Law or Jail, the data show, they usually choose canning.
Because jail, took time from their life, while healing from canning usually take less time.
MALAYSIA CAN NOW LOOK FORWARD TO ANOTHER HUGE DIP IN FOREIGN INVESTMENTS
...THANK YOU PAS FOR CAUSING THIS BIG PROBLEM ...
this shariah punisment for Muslim only.. dont worry ok.
One step forward, and two steps backwards. Very sad.
One step forward, 100 steps backward.
This kind of country CAN PROGRESS?
TO FIRST WORLD LEVEL?
60 over yrs have passed since LKY told them, you CAN'T run this country properly!😆
Lee already said in 1980s that a *Malay Malaysia* will fail .
What exactly about technology that has been stopped when the man in the video is being canned publicly? Tell me oh Kengleeten.
No worries, Malaysia will be high income economy in 2 years. Worries about your first..Singapore still canes people, you calling Singapore backward too? Or am I wrong?
Thank GOD I Follow Jesus ✝️ & I live in a nation of over 75% Budhdhist without any fear !
its not the law of the country. its the state govt which happens to be led by the opposition., they hv already been told that it is unconstitutional
@mayfoo02 OK !
The muslim being interviewed stated that they support public caning and some even wanted to implement such punishment nation wide. Malaysian modernisation in the 70s to 80s come to a waste.
Awak ni islamophobic ke?
Kalau ada masa nak minum dkt kedai, apa salahnya buka internet baca perkara yg berkait dengan berita tu lebih teliti, sbb kebanyakan islamophobic dia takkan mampu jawap soalan simple tentang Islam , apakah lagi berkenaan undang2 Islam, disebabkan baca berita sahaja , kalau Betül modern Jangan baca headline, dengar sekerat2
@@RUclipsChannel-fu5yw Who is Islamophobic and you cant even leave Islam for fearing prosecution for death penalty ...
@@RUclipsChannel-fu5yw You defend a belief you do not have the ability to understand ..You are a sheep follower ...
Canning is still use in Singapore, so does that mean Singapore is also backwards Wong?
Taliban law
Dum2 tries to be an expert.
@@UserAme99taliban does the same too bozo
@@UserAme99cuz it is ttrue, it is taliban laws and its barbaric
Muslim destroying asian culture ,
They should have stayed in barren desert😂
Its simply islamic law.
Terengganu is 100% under administration of Parti Islam se-Malaysia ( Malaysian Islamic Party)
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Keep away from tregganu tourists..u are in dubai law
Singaporean be aware when visiting malaysia.
Simple, Singapore not allowed to come at first place. If they want to visit, they can just go to other countries😒
What a shallow comment, you speak as if the authorities are going to impose syariah law to all tourists coming to Malaysia. Non-Muslim are not subject to Syariah law you dingus.
The syariah law only applies to certain states as Malaysia is a federal state. Certain states with a significant non-muslim population don't have such a punishment. Unfortunately, this happened in conservative state so they had to execute the punishment.
@@virenkumar6058 I prefer this way, if it truly make ppl scare to commit a crime, it will really help a lot. Malaysia current crime rate is getting hard, there a lot kidnapping, robbery, rapist, and murdered happen after covid lockdown
Only applies to poor people soon it will be world news the pm will have to add this in his world speech lectures other than the Gaza Palestinian speechs
Wow is Malaysia is going back to 1400 years cave century unfortunately while others countries are advancing into the technology world from Vietnam, Thailand, Myanmar, Laos, Indonesia, and Philippine ...
Backward law. Adohai
It's just an instance in a minor state. Malaysia as a whole is less of a shithole country compared to most of those you mentioned, objectively speaking.
İslamophobia ke tu?
@@RUclipsChannel-fu5yw Well if Islam is that great muslim won't be killing muslim for leaving the faith ...you are so damn right we are fearing of Islam of their violence ...who give you the right to cane this man in front of the people to install fear to muslim and who are giving fear to the muslim itself ...
@@RUclipsChannel-fu5yw Have you ever question why do you think they are doing this to the muslim ...why do you think in the Arab world muslim are leaving Islam in closet and can you really understand Arabic in order to understand the Quran and are you getting your knowledge from the Iman..and not from your own brain to understand the arabic teaching ...Use your brain rather than following blindly ..
*Am confused about this khalwat like what if a man khalwat with another man that has no blood relationship let say they staying in same hotel room is it allowed or not ?*
Kenali Islam, maka anda akan tahu tentang undang-undang Islam yang sangat menjaga agama,maruah dan berlaku adil..
@AntiZionisLaknatullah I know that but I meant is if let say a man stay in hotel room with another man to save hotel cost and they just both friends visiting Malaysia and both Muslim so is it allowed or not or they need to stay in separate room since they both have no blood relationship thats why am not sure about this close proximity and take note both are straight man they just want to save hotel charges so need to know whether its allowed or not ?
Then you are eligible to become Malaysian PM
@@PVillapah But can a man stay with another man in hotel room so they can save on hotel charges when they go for holiday but of course they sleep on separate bed
@@PVillapah Think I am qualified
what an embarassment
They walk the talk for their own religion.
Victimless "crime". Nobody is hurt, nobody is a victim. Yet treated like a criminal and caned publicly. They can never stop forcing their beliefs on others
Cuba fikir, lu sebagai ibu dan bapa tengok anak lu kena sebat depan orang ramai apa rasa lu. Lagi apa rasa orang yang kena sebat itu. Mungkin dia fikir lagi kejam lepas itu,bila dia bebas nanti. So, bagi saya zaman beribu tahun dulu bolih guna undang 2 macam itu. Sekarang zaman morden, ada cara kita bolih menghukum. Emak bapa yang kena rotan itu sudah tentu ada perasan cemburu.
Who are u to judge?
Malaysia Boleh!!
Religion of peace
In your view, a religion that promotes peace shouldn't also be promoting weapons for war, too right?
Piss❤
Religion is protected from criticism, thats why we have this.Nothing will change in our lifetime.Just accept it.
Imagine if PAS one days gains full power.
They are protected out of fear of knowing the truth where millions will leave without fear of prosecution
Only for those caught for khalwat?
There's tens of thousands for hidden khalwat!.
How to catch them? LOL
They probably never will. A good possible reason that they're doing it to the man in the video is to sent a clear and stern warning to those who may engage in such illegal acts. But the reality is that, a lot of people will get away with it even with how strict Islam is.
Funny thing even this state citizens also running away from their state 😁
Sickening such Muslim state law.
Jadi? Apa kaitan Islamic law dengan
Non Muslim ?
@@RUclipsChannel-fu5yw GISB. Biggest child abuse scandal. By muslim.
Why sickening? It just shows how ignorant you are. If a male stranger was in a room with your teenage daughter, would you let it be? Voters in Kelantan and Terengganu have been voting for PAS in fair democratic elections. Why do you think you know better? Have you visited these places before. FYI, Kelantan is home to the largest sitting Buddha statue and the 2nd largest reclining Buddha statue in SE Asia.
Bolehland bolehlaw
Hello, 7 months old bots. Bolehlaw, bots.
To Bodohland land ?
You can have public caning so long as there is freedom of choice with religion. Make no mistake, this is a public display of power. religion is being used to control and wield power. once you implement freedom of religion, watch their power be eroded
No，Indonesia has freedom of choice but aceh still have this and extended to non Muslim
Apostasy is a big sin in Islam. Such rules apply in Muslim majority countries!
The practice of pennance is common in many religions! Many religions have severe punishments for certain offences. Joan of Arc was burned at the stake! Some religious punishments have changed with the time! Some not! All are decided by those who are in power! 😀💪
This will attract seperatists from Neighboring southern Thailand to join Malaysia due to having this kinda sharia law that “satisfies them”. Becareful by saying, “this should be applied to the whole of Malaysia” brother, it won’t affect your country alone but also transnational issues.
@@rochefort.04 @rochefort.04 wkwkwkwk kenapa anda ini emosi kayak anak kecil 🤭
Maybe you don’t know the history of Yala Pattani. 😂 The Malay Peninsula is from Temasek up till above Phuket.
But msia border is till Hatyai
Malays have been living in that area up till Phuket. They woke up one day, found out League of Nations decided those fall under Thailand. Of course, they oppose it.
Malaysia is more developed and better than Thailand our per-capital is double of Thailand.
Most cases of khalwat occurred in the Northern States. Embarrassing.
Many sneaked over to Sungai Golok to look for chickens. Everyone know but act blur as if nothing happen
it occured everywhere.
Tulah semenanjung
Nothing positive about caning and it also contradicts the Constitution.
😑 anything shariah says is positive!
Yet, the Constitution is not respected. One would think that the Constitution is the supreme law of the land.
According to the Malaysian Muslim Lawyers Association, the caning was done according to the Constitution. They say, it only follows the Terengganu Sharia Criminal Enactment, Sec 125! Which allows the punishment in a humanitarian manner!
It said, the lashes were light, smaller rotan used with little force and not injuring the guilty person.
(Today's Utusan, pg 4).😀🇲🇾
@@peacefulindian318to soft, and then they surprise that the offender repeat the same crime 😮. Thanks to this, Malaysia crime rate are increasing. 🤦🏽♂️
Every religions got your own religious laws, rules and regulations should just stick on your own religious laws, rules and regulations because PREVENTION is better than cure
Lovethat Malaysia is famous ❤❤❤
What next? Will stealing be a felony or infringement?
Malaysia is a federalist system. Hence, each state has their own laws and customs. Though I might not agree with it, we must respect it or not don't be preaching diversity only when it is in your favour.
Friend, perhaps you have missed this point. Islamic affairs are administered by each state government , of which the respective sultans of each state is the head of Islamic affairs under the constitutional monarchy political system . Therefore, each state would implement Islamic Shariah laws differently. The 4 states of Perlis, Kedah, Kelantan and Trengganu are ruled by the democratically elected conservative Islamic politically party, PAS ( Parti Al-islam Se-Malaysia) . Hence, these state governments would implement a more stricter Shariah law that is approved by the state legislative assembly. What then is the federal government ( Putrajaya) 's role? It merely coordinate Islamic affairs ( excluding the Shariah laws) through the government agency , JAKIM . However, the Federal law, including the Penal code, is held supreme over state laws and no state law, other than those allowed, can supercede the provisions of the Federal law .
@kokkintang9983 we are talking the same point. It is just that I m simplifying it.
But my point is we should embrace diversity in totality. The people of those state wanted to be govern by a Islamicly conservative government, then let them be. If we disagree, give concrete facts why they are wrong. Like psychological or criminalogical statistics.
@@kokkintang9983Muslims have separate laws regarding marriage, divorce, inheritance, etc. Some states have their own enactments of Islamic law provisions separately for Muslims. The states have the authority to enact such laws. Such laws cannot contradict the provisions in the Federal Constitution.
A mother-daughter team have challenged the Kelantan enactments and won.
In this caning incident, so far, no one challenge such laws in the Court.
Federal government will not interfere in state islamic enactments, unless it's seemed as ultra-vires (done in a bad faith). 😀🇲🇾
@@kokkintang99832) Muslims generally don't oppose religion-based laws bec it's related to their faith. Like the Christians, Muslims are also have a duty to obey their commandments! Millions of Filipino Catholic women are waiting for divorce from their bad husbands, but the Church is slow in approving divorces. Bec, Catholic Church frowns on divorces. It's their belief.
Muslims in Malaysia also follow the Federal Criminal laws in the Courts. Sharia laws are applicable in matters of adultery, fornication, and prostitution, Lgbt, etc!
(I'm a Muslim).
Now people can compare civil canning vs syariah canning.
Malaysia moving backwards is good news for singapore😂
Its not good cos we cannot move already
How is it good news considering Singapore is a stone's throw away and can't sail away to other locations?
Singapore still use canning as legal punishment, so does that mean Singapore is backwards?
Don't come to Malaysia for petrol 😑
Singapore rely on Malaysia for water….😂😅….. cant even produced its own water for local consumptions..😅 ooopsy daisy
Religion of peace ✌️
**piss.
It is just a small cane, used for children during 1950 😂😂
Manusia hidup harus mematuhi aturan tapi kebanyakan dari mereka ga pernah mentaati aturan 😏
Sensible life affirming and protecting rules are important. But this is nonsense.
@@davidrivett7603 ahh masa tua itu harus dihargai dengan menghadirkan diri berdoa pada Tuhan untuk diampuni segala dosa dilakukan di atas dunianya .
@@salvation88Aturan Arab hahaha. B o. D o
Sooooo righteous.
2:41 "...we implement it in the whole of Malaysia" - Malaysia Boleh 😂
7th century culture is the best🎉🎉🎉
Why filming not permitted???
Singapore wants to boost their connectivity with Terengganu and Kelantan. Education & tourism too...😅
This is the state and religion. At least they don't have so many pubs and moral decay like Singapore.
@@lpfong2538Baseless in Malaysia there are robberies everywhere and everyday. Plus Malaysians are even caught on CCTV inside a play of workshop stealing. And Malaysia is listed as the world's most corrupted county. What moral value BS are you referring to? Shame on you the pot calling the kettle black! Shame on you!
@@lpfong2538 Singapore is not an Islamic country unlike Terengganu which is known as an Islamic state but yet still has pubs & bars and definitely has 'moral decay' just like the one reported here.
@@lpfong2538 Without pubs most will sneak across into Gungai Golok to seek chickens and to have fun. Sama sama lah
Monotheist religions: The Ten Commandments
Chinese: 仁、义、礼、智、信 （五常）
What is 仁?
What is 义?
What is 礼?
What is 智?
What is 信?
The gap is huge.
Yet, looking at China with insolent tourist. Seems the number is more better
It's funny reading in these comments section how non-Muslims with zero knowledge suddenly became experts on the Sharia.
Cuz moslems and sharia lacks common sense
They know what sharia will do to them.😊
Do you think that the malaysian royalty or rich politicians are subject to the same laws ? Do you think religious affairs officials raid their hotels and homes looking for these offensives. This law weights heavily against the poor and the less well connected.
@@VanaeCavaeThis law weighs heavily against the poor? Bro, you're tripping dog. 😂
@@VanaeCavaeThe law is for all Muslims. But, the enforcements are for...... (fill in the blank). 😀🇲🇾
Uh.. I see people who are not Malaysian will misunderstood the location. No, it was NOT DONE INSIDE THE MOSQUE. It was done in a Dewan in Bahasa Melayu or translated to English is Hall. So he was caned infront of the public in a hall that is within the mosque area. Most mosque today have attached offices, classrooms, halls, and many more multipurpose rooms.
I bet there will be more people that will be voicing their objection to it. But seriously people, don't be hypocrites. Look at the many people asking the police or government to release the identity of criminals that was censored to protect his/her identity. "Why censored this criminal's face". "Why hide their identity." So on and so forth. So when these criminals and law offenders is publicly punished by the law, suddenly they say it is a form of torture? It is inhumane? it is against human rights? It is degrading? Stop exaggerating and stop with the double standard.
A public punishment is a good thing in my opinion. It serves as a warning and a reminder to others who watched it. It can act as a deterrent. AND IT WILL HELP MAINTAIN A FAIRNESS TO ALL WHO ARE PUBLICLY PUNISHED. Because there will be witnesses when the punishment is being carried. The person executing the punishment must do it fairly to all and follow exactly what supposed to be done or he will be held accountable for it. So instead of just leaving it 100% to the court, the public will also be involved in upholding the law. Which is what we all are supposed to do anyway.
The fact that you actually think punishing someone for "Khalwat" aka "Being around someone of opposite sex" is normal speaks volumes of how messed up Malaysia has become. God almighty. Basically the dark ages but with wifi.
@@milesedgeworth132yeah, to keep asian Muslim. Still being asian ,
I extremely curious - so will this Sharia Law of yours be implemented on non Muslims?
And, is the Sharia Law above the country law or will there be only ONE law to follow? And which is the law that all citizens should abide?
@@CIKcki Sila type di google
@@milesedgeworth132 You obviously don't know what "khalwat" means do you? You are basically a person in the dark ages, with wifi, and smartphones, but doesn't know how to use it, or maybe you believe technology is some sort of sorcery and is a blasphemy to whatever God you believe in. This is why over simplifying and generalizing things can create misinformation and misunderstanding. But I highly doubt you care. You obviously just out to be hateful and spread your lie based hate to others.
Read the damn news FULLY on this case AND UNDERSTAND what "khalwat" is first before you make spread hate and lies from your accusations. You are also flaunting your stupidity to the world.
Why not if our loved ones are protected n spare the agony
Did what wrong? Close proximity?
Extra marital affair on continuous basis. This is the mediated rule instead of 40 full strokes or stoned. I appreciate if you respect the local law.
Khalwat means close proximity in a private place, not in public
Non Muslim please don't give any stupid and baseless comments as it does not involve you.
Observe the laws of the country in which you live! In this case, no bonking or any form of sexual contact outside of marriage. Since this is very hard to prove*, they were slapped with the offence of 'khalwat', close proximity with a non-family member of the opposite sex.
*The evidentiary requirements are almost impossible due to its strict criteria.
Shariah Laws only apply to Muslims so if they are happy with the laws they will keep voting for PAS.
now you are Blessed with RAIN !!
moving more n more backwards everyday.
Lets leave these muslim issues on muslims to muslims. No comments is required from the non muslims community.
Malaysia Boleh Leh😂😅👌👍
Kenah lipat saudara!😮
Once u bring religion into govt ,public , policy ,etc then problems starts.
Worse if u spend billions on religion?
Pm Anwar need to be blamed . He has no foresight , no pragmatism .He himself follows racial , religious policies n as FM allocates billions for religion !
PAS means *People Are Stupid* , People Always Stupid* ,*People Always Slander **
The Federal govt allocates yearly millions , billions to Kelantan , Kedah , Trengganu , Perlis ( Pas controlled states ) for economic development ,n how much goes for religions?
No choice for anwar bro, he has to do all this to win malay support if u cant win malay votes u cant be government. But at least we do see anwar doing real work also. Compared to other candidates he’s the best already.
fellow was a repeated offender. I assumed he was warned with the potential consequences the first time. but heyyy its 2024 and youre still following a tradition dated over a thousand years ago. then again what do i know im no expert🤷🏽♂️
And not a single word for innocent Palestinian tortured to death
The same goes for innocent women, young boys, and girls in the Middle East. Being married at a young age and died shortly after intercouse, little boys are used for pleasure, and women to produce baby.
Singapore also has caning as a punishment. So you are barbaric too
No public caning. And it is for legit criminal offences. Not for “sitting too near a female” or “being gay” or “attempting lesbian sex”.
@@90taetaeya Whether public or private, caning is still considered barbaric in the western world regardless of the offence type. An offence in one country may not be offence in another country. Still the western countries are not happy with Singapore's capital punishments and canings. Does this mean you are going to change them to look good to them? Same way let all countries practice the punishments in their own way.
Boleh. Good
primodial
where is the huge debate. this is islamic law. CNA will need to recognise this.
LOL
To be frank, Singaporeans should just keep silent.
What is mutah marriage in islam which is halal?
Does it vary country to country?
Muta'ah marriage are marriage of convenience.
A temporary marriage agreement for a certain period.
It's not allowed in Malaysia. Some Muslim sects practice it in some countries!
@peacefulindian318
So an agreed mutual sexual service for a fee is halal in islam?
@@peacefulindian318
Haha my replies are rejected by this dark sided utube
@@peacefulindian318
So mutah marriage is a mutual sexual agreement btw 2 parties for a fee?
🧐
To those Singaporeans who criticize this (mainly Islamophobes), canning is still a legal punishment in Singapore. So much for "Advanced" Singapore right?.
2blueshirt26 The difference is Singapore canning for punishment of crime while Sharia Law canning for mingling with women...Are you still living in a cave society and do not want to advance ...
Since u are clueless, be educated Singapore’s caning is based on serious n dangerous crimes which harm others like armed robberies, rapes, assault with weapons, injuries etc.
Not for religious reasons like in the company of opposite sex or even committing adultery. 😆
Your backward society cannot mingling with women and you name yourself advancing
Canning for “close proximity” for example talking to a lady who is not your relative? Anyway, I guess using ambiguous terms like "close proximity," especially in situations such as interacting with a woman who isn’t a relative, seems intentional. Certain authorities likely prefer such vague language because it allows for broad interpretation, enabling them to justify almost anything. In turn, this can be weaponized to target and persecute those who don’t conform to their specific man-made traditions.
@@tobyc8668 if it is man-made, why does it go against the desires of a man?
Good 👍 from aceh
Banda Aceh no longer does this because 37/38 provinces of Indonesia is secular
Thanks Aceh.
@@rochefort.04 fact or hoax can you counter it ?
@@salvation88I said in Banda not in other parts of Aceh, since now we have a govt institution to carry it out, but mainly Aceh now is not about religion but about development, punishment are for prevention not intended to carry out. Different than PAS that made its religion national headlines.
aceh is a shithole
Singaporean will love this kind of news..kiasu punya attitude. Anyway, the Ringgit and the MYR is appreciating every week again..our GDP growing more than 5%, Singapore economy not moving ...😂
It's good to have dream, even day dream.. but we are very certain that Malaysia will never make it to 1st world. Too many 3rd world mentality and religions crippling the country growth. The Chinese were having delusion that ringgit will grow and surpass SGD but they are still flocking to Singapore to earn SGD. Indians have no say in the country.. Malays are complacent and still living in stone age time frame. We sincerely wish you good luck. 🤣🤣🤣
RUU355
Viewers show some respects to our Muslim brothers in that particular state. That is won by the islamic party (PAS), they have their beliefs. Don't be an enemy or bastard, when you give your comments that you.
Respect one another, respect another's man religion or beliefs. The state is won by the Islamic party, that's a reason and backgrounds to that. Hope you are sensitive and tolerance to their beliefs...and not jump into conclusion too rapidly and be a bastard..😢
😅😅😅
I totally support malaysia syariah law after all they are a muslim country and all race should respect that.
Syariah Law is only applicable in several states and not the entire Malaysia. However the religious authority can still arrest misbehaving Muslims anywhere in Malaysia. Non-Muslims are not affected. I have been to Terengganu and Kelantan many times and do not see any issues there.
@@YanQi. the backwardness of shariah law and it’s insulting attitude to normal people is the problem here. It’s all about power and humiliation. Nothing spiritual about that.
@@davidrivett7603 So you don't believe murderers and rpsts deserve to be humiliated?
@@davidrivett7603I think, the "humiliation" is the punishment!
Unless, he says, "Apa malu......."
(fill in the blanks). 😂
It's insulting that Asian people wants to be like Arabs, honestly its downright hilarious. Never thought religion has this so much power in the government because I thought shouldn't religion be individual thing or a group project.
we nid tis
Shariah law prevailed 😊
😂😂😂 the public taught it was a show.
khalwat is not human act so what is wrong with syariah law human right is not depending human but animal