Yeah, a problem with many of these map animations is that often you don't get info about what's happening, they don't show the cities, I've even seem map animations without the dates.... so you just end up watching blue and red gaining and losing grounds in some place
Yeah dude this is very informative, the other videos mostly look like someone playing Agar.io. Definitely entertaining but I was always left with tons of questions.
I haven't even finished watching yet and I already love this video and this style. I know using no gains colour usually gets a lot of criticism from the community but I personally think gain colours can sometimes be confusing and annoying. I think the labels are a great addition and I think they really make these few but extremely well produced and researched frames feel like far more. Great video, keep it up. Edit: Just finished watching. Amazing work Yan!
Exceedingly well made video, I really like the addition of the labels - helps contextualize events for someone only vaguely familiar with China/Chinese history (i.e me)
i just want to say i really appreciate your videos. they have done much to help me contextualize these events in a place im geographically unfamiliar with, while being also in my language. thank you for the work you do
If you don't mind, can you make a video about Drug King, Khun Sa, the Lord of the Golden Triangle? I studied Myanmar history in recent, and found kind of awesome. Khun Sa was a warlord in Shan states, Myanmar. And due to his massive opium smuggling operations in the Golden Triangle, where he was the dominant opium warlord from approximately 1976-1996. No one else made map, just yet. If you make this into a real video it would be real cool.
Imagined how hard it is to make one video in this channel make, many detailed and effort as been put into the video. Instead of effortlessly use a random colour consuming each other
Was this Yuan Shikai's finest hours? Or were these victories his furthest of his peak follies to attain popular & legitimate recognitions? Find out in the next three years!
@@RobertIIIdeOutremer The upstart of a Yuan cannot sign these demands when he's dead by then and his squabbling subordinates are in power/claiming their piece of their pies, or attempting to restore the last, & teenage Qing Emperor
Hello, recently I've been watching some of your latest videos, specifically those regarding Tibet and Sichuan. You do seem to have some knowledge regarding Chinese history, or at least you know how to navigate through it, and I'm wondering if you could help me with a bit of an issue I've been facing regarding the Qing and the Republic of China's border disputes, a piece of history which particularly caught my eyes lately. I've already successfully researched about the ones over the Burma-Yunnan boundary, both the undemarcated area in the north, interested by the Pianma Expedition of the British, and the one in the south, with some rich silver mines, that interested governor Long Yun. I'm mainly interested in the dispute over the Pamir region, on the modern Sino-Tajik border. Specifically I'm looking for sources which would help me identify who effectively controlled the region prior to 1895 and also the full extent of the Chinese claim. Besides that, I'm also interested in sources which would help me identify when the British effectively moved into modern Arunchal Pradesh after the McMahon lines. I hope you could redirect me to sources that would help me understand the matter regarding these two issues.
Hello, I'm curious about your fantastic work in showing boundaries of the relatively independent kingdoms(tusi), since I didn't find them in neither in CHGIS nor in the contemporary administrative divisions. Would you mind informing me of the source? I'll be grateful for that.
Can you make a entire HISTORY OF CHINA: EVERY YEAR. You are the most qualified youtuber for this. I mean mith every, even the smallest, revolt, the historic provinces, large cities, emperors, chancelors, the historic accurate coastlines and rivers ect. like super detailed like your videos mostly are. Please
ruclips.net/video/dakBd_2ZMYw/видео.html& watch this if you know chinese it is extremely long and detailed and an underrated channel this is arguably the best entire history of china video I doubt even yan xishan can do better than this but then again it was probably made by a studio or group of people so it isn't a fair comparison
Could it be called a Revolution if it wasn't successful? Wouldn't it be called a rebellion since it was defeated? Also sorry for not saying so imediatly; but really good job on this one! The educational style in my opinion is far better for the mapping community than the more animated style. I actually learned a good deal about the Second Revolution in this video; something other versions couldn't offer.
Well, it was intended to be a repeat of the success of the 1911 Xinhai Revolution, so it's usually called the Second Revolution. I suppose you're correct, though.
@Sugarz the Russian Revolution of 1905, counts as a revolution because things did change; It worked. The czar ending the reforms after a few years would be a counter-revolution. But either way; even if a revolution only works short term its still a revolution. If a 'revolution' doesn't work period' then its a rebellion.
America, Europe and Japan: Not our fault, all internal crisis Also them: China, gib all your lands andf resources of you to us! If you collapse, is even better for us
His plan to install himself as Emperor triggered a rebellion from Yunnan and Guizhou, which had not been suppressed in 1913, which were soon joined by Guangxi, Guangdong, Hunan, Shaanxi, and Sichuan. Yuan Shikai was unable to defeat them and faced possible revolt from his generals, so he was forced to restore the republic. However, even upon his death, Yuan Shikai still ruled most of China. But because he had not had enough time to create a centralised national government and administration, when he died the centralised China he had worked to build fell apart, beginning the warlord era.
You can notice the South still not completely pacified. Most of these men were neither kuomintang aligned, nor wanted a monarchy back. That's why they rebelled during 1916. Then after Yuan's inability to supress this revolt, some of his own generals, 8 I believe, sent him a letter telling him to resign. Then he died a few months later, probably from the stress.
I actually learned instead of mindlessly staring at various colours on a map
Yeah, a problem with many of these map animations is that often you don't get info about what's happening, they don't show the cities, I've even seem map animations without the dates.... so you just end up watching blue and red gaining and losing grounds in some place
Yeah dude this is very informative, the other videos mostly look like someone playing Agar.io. Definitely entertaining but I was always left with tons of questions.
You often don't hear about this second revolution. thanks for covering it and amazing job
Jesus Christ I cant even Imagine how much effort it took to make this video
In all honesty, like this format better cause it shows what and where these important events happened.
I haven't even finished watching yet and I already love this video and this style. I know using no gains colour usually gets a lot of criticism from the community but I personally think gain colours can sometimes be confusing and annoying. I think the labels are a great addition and I think they really make these few but extremely well produced and researched frames feel like far more. Great video, keep it up.
Edit: Just finished watching. Amazing work Yan!
Noice
"Holy crap, how are you so buff?"
"Every time China has a civil war, i do one push up."
*"Jesus christ."*
I, I don't know if that's humanly possible!
Did you have a stroke?
"I so one pish push up"
@@dodolulupepe Sorry, typing on a mobile keyboard is hard. But now i fixed it.
@@amazingalex7439YT lol :p
"For every faction in a chinese civil war I do 1 squat"
God almighty...
Exceedingly well made video, I really like the addition of the labels - helps contextualize events for someone only vaguely familiar with China/Chinese history (i.e me)
i just want to say i really appreciate your videos. they have done much to help me contextualize these events in a place im geographically unfamiliar with, while being also in my language. thank you for the work you do
Such a great detail, an excellent piece of work here.
Really Interesting video, and I've always loved just how much attention to detail you pay in mapping historical events.
Oh my God, it’s so amazing, how much information has been collected... it’s admire work!👍👍👍🔥
哇哦，阎锡山你终于更新了！
I just discovered your channel today!! This is so well researched, Thank you for your hard work
If you don't mind, can you make a video about Drug King, Khun Sa, the Lord of the Golden Triangle?
I studied Myanmar history in recent, and found kind of awesome.
Khun Sa was a warlord in Shan states, Myanmar. And due to his massive opium smuggling operations in the Golden Triangle, where he was the dominant opium warlord from approximately 1976-1996.
No one else made map, just yet. If you make this into a real video it would be real cool.
Learn the words that end in _ly, for example, RECENTLY.
After many years, you kept the promise from that comment on Emperor's Tigerstar video hahahahaha, good job
The map is so detailed! Didn't know there are so many things happening in this period as textbooks only mention it slightly!
Thank you for adding text. I learned something new about Chinese history.
Imagined how hard it is to make one video in this channel make, many detailed and effort as been put into the video. Instead of effortlessly use a random colour consuming each other
Excellent as always!
Bro this is the best map channel ever
Was this Yuan Shikai's finest hours? Or were these victories his furthest of his peak follies to attain popular & legitimate recognitions? Find out in the next three years!
His finest hour was 1915,before japanese forced him to sign the 21 demands.
@@RobertIIIdeOutremer The upstart of a Yuan cannot sign these demands when he's dead by then and his squabbling subordinates are in power/claiming their piece of their pies, or attempting to restore the last, & teenage Qing Emperor
POG Yan posted!
Your style is amazing
Great video! It doesn't look "low resolution" at all to me
Impressive work, as usual!
Yan Xishan making detailed mapping videos: UPGRADES, PEOPLE, UPGRADES!!!!
Great video, certainly much Better and more informative than any other
Animated map God has returned
Hello, recently I've been watching some of your latest videos, specifically those regarding Tibet and Sichuan. You do seem to have some knowledge regarding Chinese history, or at least you know how to navigate through it, and I'm wondering if you could help me with a bit of an issue I've been facing regarding the Qing and the Republic of China's border disputes, a piece of history which particularly caught my eyes lately. I've already successfully researched about the ones over the Burma-Yunnan boundary, both the undemarcated area in the north, interested by the Pianma Expedition of the British, and the one in the south, with some rich silver mines, that interested governor Long Yun.
I'm mainly interested in the dispute over the Pamir region, on the modern Sino-Tajik border. Specifically I'm looking for sources which would help me identify who effectively controlled the region prior to 1895 and also the full extent of the Chinese claim.
Besides that, I'm also interested in sources which would help me identify when the British effectively moved into modern Arunchal Pradesh after the McMahon lines.
I hope you could redirect me to sources that would help me understand the matter regarding these two issues.
Great work. Good effects, number of soldiers. 👍👍👍
Amazing job! I learned a lot
Great video, as always
I love this idea of map-informative video.
Hello, I'm curious about your fantastic work in showing boundaries of the relatively independent kingdoms(tusi), since I didn't find them in neither in CHGIS nor in the contemporary administrative divisions. Would you mind informing me of the source? I'll be grateful for that.
Could you, at some point, do videos on the Warring States and Three Kingdoms periods?
Great work!
It would be very interesting if you can make seperate episodes of history of current Chinese provinces.
Anyway, good video as always!
？what
what？
I love this formate even more than the "advancing maps" because it give explanations what happened where. China is so biiiiig ...
Can you make a entire HISTORY OF CHINA: EVERY YEAR. You are the most qualified youtuber for this. I mean mith every, even the smallest, revolt, the historic provinces, large cities, emperors, chancelors, the historic accurate coastlines and rivers ect. like super detailed like your videos mostly are. Please
Or let him work on projects he can reasonably finish?
ruclips.net/video/dakBd_2ZMYw/видео.html& watch this if you know chinese it is extremely long and detailed and an underrated channel this is arguably the best entire history of china video I doubt even yan xishan can do better than this but then again it was probably made by a studio or group of people so it isn't a fair comparison
@@oneworldornone347 TWO HOURS? I must see this one! Thanks for the link!
This is a video I would like to eventually make. But if I ever do make it, it certainly won't be soon.
@@yanxishan6575 Take your time we are waiting for ya.
Could it be called a Revolution if it wasn't successful? Wouldn't it be called a rebellion since it was defeated?
Also sorry for not saying so imediatly; but really good job on this one! The educational style in my opinion is far better for the mapping community than the more animated style. I actually learned a good deal about the Second Revolution in this video; something other versions couldn't offer.
Well, it was intended to be a repeat of the success of the 1911 Xinhai Revolution, so it's usually called the Second Revolution. I suppose you're correct, though.
@Sugarz that's not true
@Sugarz again, missing the point
@Sugarz the Russian Revolution of 1905, counts as a revolution because things did change; It worked. The czar ending the reforms after a few years would be a counter-revolution. But either way; even if a revolution only works short term its still a revolution. If a 'revolution' doesn't work period' then its a rebellion.
@Sugarz No, I would not call the second revolution a revolution. I would call it a rebellion.
Bai Lang Gang Gang
I have a suggestion. Maybe you could do the Seven States Rebellion from the second century BC? Btw every single one of your videos is awesome
All those names are super hard to follow! But this is a very nice and interesting video.
Great Job!
The location in Shanghai is Jiangwan, not Jiangwen
France: finally, a worthy opponent! Our battle will be legendary!
This is very nice!! 와 미쳤다ㅏㅏ
Anyone have any good books in English on the Chinese Civil War era?
Do you have a good resource to read about the early warlord period?
America, Europe and Japan: Not our fault, all internal crisis
Also them: China, gib all your lands andf resources of you to us! If you collapse, is even better for us
How the hell did Yuan Shikai manage to lose control after all this?
For one he fell over dead shortly after
He never lost control; instead, there was no one after he died in 1916 who could keep control like him.
His plan to install himself as Emperor triggered a rebellion from Yunnan and Guizhou, which had not been suppressed in 1913, which were soon joined by Guangxi, Guangdong, Hunan, Shaanxi, and Sichuan. Yuan Shikai was unable to defeat them and faced possible revolt from his generals, so he was forced to restore the republic. However, even upon his death, Yuan Shikai still ruled most of China. But because he had not had enough time to create a centralised national government and administration, when he died the centralised China he had worked to build fell apart, beginning the warlord era.
@@yanxishan6575 I see. Makes sense.
You can notice the South still not completely pacified. Most of these men were neither kuomintang aligned, nor wanted a monarchy back. That's why they rebelled during 1916. Then after Yuan's inability to supress this revolt, some of his own generals, 8 I believe, sent him a letter telling him to resign. Then he died a few months later, probably from the stress.
However, Mr. Sun failed again.
Nice work, greetings from Russia
how is this even real
beautiful thank you
You are from tawan?
Chinese and Russian civil wars were really brutal, but they could overcome it.
Epic Thumbnail
How embarrassing
@@yanxishan6575 lol
Interesting video.
Hello there
Thanks
Ahhh, so that explains why the Republic of China changed its flag... (from Yuan Shikai's 5 stripe flag to modern Taiwan flag)
I wish it could be made animated too
The most complicated war
Cool vdo!
3:16 Cool it's Chiang Kai-shek
Chiang Kai-Shek was not cool
@@procyon6370 I know
I don't know about Chinese Modern and Contemporary History.
Nice
壮哉吾诸夏文明。
Macao should be white
Macau is very small,much smaller than Hong Kong.I don't think we can see it in this map
@@RobertIIIdeOutremer I did actually draw it on the map, but the blurriness that resulted from uploading it to youtube prevents one from seeing it.
suicidal admit
Christ
didnt watch it yet but good video
Traditionally, Chinese people always need to worship a dictator.
Yuan Shikai surely is a good emperor
He was just born in wrong time
Lol all hail emperor Yuan Shikai
🇨🇳 only real china
Subjective
🇲🇳 is true china
@@LucidFL ragers, real China is under Z rule
Obviously 🇨🇳 is the real china
Um no, real China is under Z rule . z is supreme and is real China because China is under Z rule
first
Nope, Eros was first.
amogus
sus
Sus
No
fun fact：
The 1913 Second Revolution ---- when Chinese people don't like the 1912 voting result