Sir, we Indians 🇮🇳 follow you to understand the reality. We are a few who don't not really want to hear only good things about our country or bad about others but are interested in reality because we care about our future. May we leave behind a better world for generations to come. We support your impartial journalism and sincerely hope that it would remain so. 💛
Bad people are everywhere. Some countries accept like you others plainly shy away from accepting the facts. For a person or a country to improve, one must accept that things are wrong. I respect you a lot
Dear Syed, Army has not allowed political parties to develop a mature and evolved democracy. You are truthful, courageous and visionary journalist. God bless you good health, security, all successes and long life.
...but sir, why don't the Pakstani people go out on the street & demand that pakfauj goes back to the barracks & that pakfauj gives space to true democracy? It seems that Pakstani just complain but never actually take action.
@@nnbg8000 Revolting against the deep state doesn't just simply happen. Pakistanis have always come out on street like you said, there's probably 10 protests happening in the country right now. But where do you protest against the Establishment? Even making posts on social media gets you arrested.
@@karachiseascouts I understand but isn't this what the people in Myanmar are doing? You think if lakhs/crores of people go out on the street, peacefully, & demand democracy in Pakstan, you won't be able to achieve your goal? Of course you will. It won't happen after 1 protest. Only the people of Pakstan can fight for it. You will have to start small. Perhaps a street corner protest, peacefully. In today's world, there will be enough people who will be willing to support you on-line.
@@nnbg8000 I've seen you ask this question in some other comments as well. Therefore, I'd like to answer it to the best of my knowledge. The arguments I'll discuss are directly from this video. 1) Polarization: as people, the proletariat, are fed constant news for a prolonged time, their critical thinking devolves completely. As time passes, they firmly adhere to the rhetoric - the concept of a villain and a hero. Even if the people, who are brainwashed, see an informative video like this one, they don't dare understand the arguments and rather become defensive. 2) All other institutes, except the all-powerful, have been rendered incompetent to handle the current problems. As there are no options except the omnipotent, no one has a choice but to adhere. Otherwise, the state will fall apart - attacked by foreign groups or violence from within. 3) Fear: this factor dominates. First of all, only a few fully understand the entire structure, and even these intelligent people don't speak of it. That is because the backlash of doing so is too costly. People like this content creator are among these intelligent people. However, instead of staying apathetic, he, this content creator, has decided to speak about what he observed. You might not realise this, but he's taking on a daunting task which might lead to severe repercussions. I can further dwell on each point or give multiple other arguments, but that's not my point. I hope these three arguments entertained your query. Regards, Someone on the internet. Disclaimer: these arguments don't reflect my personal views.
The surprising thing is that on Pakistani channels where usefull, intellectual, economic issues base content is uploaded, most of the viewers and comments are from Indians. On the other hand, if you watch Indian songs, entertainment, and comedy shows, you will find a large number of Pakistani viewers. This shows what our priorities as a nation are and how other nations have moved ahead of us.
Watch coke Studio Pakistan you find majority of comments from indians. Since muzammil criticizes Pakistan you find majority indians since they are obsessed with Pakistan. On the other hands people like arundati roy are called propagandist in India.
@ASIM BASHIR YES U HAV STATED VERY CORRECTLY I AM IN TOTAL AGREEMENT WITH UR VIEW. THE AVERAGE PAKISTANI'S IDEA OF INDIA STARTS IN PUNJAB TRAVELS TO DELHI,AGRA,KASHMIR, THEN A BIG JUMP TO BOMBAY WITH GOA THROWN IN BETWEEN. WHAT THEY DONT KNOW IS INDIA IS SO VAST N DIVERSE THAT VERY FEW PEOPLE TALK OF THE SOUTH WHERE THE REAL ACTION IS, N ALSO MAHARASHTRA N GUJRAT, WHICH IS POWERING INDIA IN IT'S ECONOMIC GALLOP. THE SOUTH IS THE HUB FOR IT INDUSTRY WITH CITIES LIKE BANGALORE, HYDERABAD, CHENNAI, N TIER 2 CITIES LIKE THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, MANGALORE, MYSORE, COIMBATORE, WHICH ALSO CONTRIBUTE TO THE IT, ITES INDUSTRY. CORE MANUFACTURING ALSO HAS TAKEN OFF IN BIG BIG WAY SINCE 2014 SINCE MODI TOOK OVER AS PM. INDIA IS SPENDING HUGE AMOUNTS HAS BEEN INVESTED IN ROAD INFRASTRUCTURE, GREEN ENERGY, ALSO MORE THAN 100 START UP'S EACH VALUED AT A BILLION EACH N MANY MORE COMING IN THE ECO SYSTEM, OF START UPS. THE COMING DECADE WILL ALSO SEE THAT INDIA BECOMES A MANUFACTURING HUB BACKED BY IT. TO GREAT LEVELS. AND MOST OF THIS ACTION IS HAPPENING IN THE SOUTH, GUJRAT N MAHARASHTRA. GOOD TO C PEOPLE LIKE U WHO UNDERSTAND WHERE THE PROBLEM IS BUT DONT GET AN OPPORTUNITY TO RECTIFY IT BECAUSE OF EXTREME NEPOTISM N CORRUPTION IN PAKISTAN.
@@s.v.srinivasan6041 story cut short there will never be any comparison between mighty INDIA and Pakistan....Kashmir is the only cash cow for the corrupt Pak Estb to keep them in the business..
As an Indian, This topic is not very relevant for me, but always love to watch your videos, the way you support your arguments with books, authors, philosophers is very interesting and shows your overall understanding. your way of communication is very simple and elegant.
Dear Syed Journalists like you, Arzoo, Shakil, and intellectual like Prof. Pervez Hoodbhai and Prof. Ahmed are great hope. Only way is creating awareness among youths for change and better nation.
Extremely rare to see such a neutral , clear and balanced perspective from a Pakistani! Wonder if Pakistanis actually revere this man's deep knowledge! Incredibly knowledgeable and mature assessment of the topic! Hope he is not picked up by the Pakistani establishment and software updated by the You-know-Who!
25 % to 30% people are better knowledge about the current affairs and the present system there ; but they cant speak as their system is so ; the mullah and establishment will hound them.
Lots of love and respect from India. Some people would say Indians watch your channel cause you are criticizing Pakistan but I wouldn't say it's so. Lot of us watch to understand an impartial view of what is really happening beyond the politics. What kind of structural and systemic issues exist in Pakistan which has led it to where it is today. Maybe we can even learn something to better our own systems & institutions to avoid such a fate ourselves. Keep doing what you're doing, can't believe you're so young and so well read and have the courage to speak truth to power especially in times of tyranny.
Dear Syed - I have recently discovered your channel. You are one of those rare Pakistanis like Prof. Hoodbhoy who not only know the real history but also are trying to teach it to other people who have been fed lies by Pakistani establishment. You are like a breath of fresh air. Pakistan and South Asian area need people like you. I really hope you can get into a political leadership role. I am a big fan now and will continue to follow your good work
Dr. Hoodbhoy's forte is Science and not politics. That is why his views at times are biased. Syde Muzammil and Taimur Rahaman are much better when they speak on Politics and World affairs.
@@KU77AR Aftab Iqbal is a fuddu.....His opinions are largely biased n he spreads lies n false propoganda to his viewers....Even many people from Indian punjab follow him blindly just because there are Punjabi comedians in his show n they kinda relate with them b'coz of their language
Muzammil sir your videos revived my interest in sociology and philosophy. After coming across your channel I've read two books recommended by you. The way you question the society while quoting philosophers inspired me to another level. Love from India.
Much appreciate your courage to speak fearlessly. The world has very few journalists like you. Sometimes I worry for your safety given the limitations to journalism. We have very few journalists like you in the Indian-subcontinent.
Happy to see young people like you from an Islamic country who are seemed to be truth-seekers and progressive thinkers ,above all the confinements of narrow religious lanes. People like you are very rare to find.With Love & Respect, - Rensoy Philip, Kerala State, South India.
@@contrarian322 yeah I noticed that too. He likes to quote western philosophers, maybe just to impress people. I commented on one of his blogs pointing out that these guys came late in the game. There is rich Islamic tradition of logical reasoning. Anyway he puts it out there. Will cut him some slack there.
Couple of weeks ago, I was sitting with one of my senior colleague who also happens to be from the subject of political science and an Associate Professor, who was sharing some of issues which are being discussed in Professor Parvez Sahib's You tube that is "The black hole", Which I had already subscribed. Professor sahib (my colleague) suddenly started talking about you and said there is a young man from Pakistan who is much clear about the politics and anything which revolves around human existence, virtually be its anything and claimed there is hardly any parallel to him (he meant you) in India or per se Indian subcontinent. And i felt confused honestly at that moment. The matter came and went away, I hardly bothered. Professor sahib feel really inclined towards Pakistan and it's culture and i thought thats why he is singing your wax lyricals. I felt highly skeptical about his remark. Today again I was sitting with him (my colleague) and suddenly he played one of your previous you tube on his Android device and i listened to that whilst sitting in his chamber only. You would not believe it I was awestruck and putting everything aside, I drew whole of my attention to what we're you saying in that video. I could safely say that my skepticism was literally meaningless. I came back home listened few more of your you tubes and now this one, it's really some thing out of this world experience. I would say it's not just the people in Pakistan but everywhere else should have or atleast try to be aware as you are being. Thanks and regards Support from Ludhiana, India.
When it comes to Pakistan he is a great analyst but he don't have any grasp about Indian politics. We have many Indic minds here. Pakistan needs a revolution right now, but India not need any. I respect him but this is the reality. So don't compare these two countries. Our problems are different.
Well projected the deepest issue of our beloved state PAKISTAN. May Allah protect the Muslim Ummah from all negativities and united for sake of betterment of the general public.
This video reminds me of how 1984 is becoming reality day by day...every three or four years, the establishment creates a big brother and a Goldstein to engage the common people...but the power always remains within the establishment...this is happening not only in Pakistan and every country..
@@asad-kc8zf @ yes curruption hai india mai but decorator nhe ..... Curruption wala janwar hai india mai but establishment wala nhe ..... Right wing nationalist Elected govt he centre mai but unko awam laaye hai wo awam ke vote sa khadi he ...aaga koi leftist ya centre wali govt bhe hogi ....
@@naveedch316 @ India mai right wing nationalist Elected party tau hai yes wo decorator nhe he bass kaam wesa he hai hope next election congress ko vote de humare log .... center govt mai phir sa congress aa jaye
Today after watching this video, I truly believe you are not only the honest but must be the bravest person in whole Pakistan.. we Indians have watched multiple videos of different Pakistanis who dare to speak against the govt but you are the first one who openly speaking about the Deep State/ establishment… road ahead can be turbulent but keep up the good work .. will share and ask others to subscribe
Rational and impartial analysis .Real Journalists,You are our saviours . Knowledge of truth is half the battle won. we Indians should not be delusional about our great growth story .We need to improve on lots of things .
You are probably one of few people in Pakistan who can name army directly Your analysis are very much balanced without blaming anyone directly or abusing any agency or giving revolutionary lectures to provoke public so I guess you will be safe. Once the cause is analysed then only the problems can be solved, if Pakistan starts today from the scratch ending madarsa education and bring every child to normal school followed by crushing radicalism after 20yrs results will be visible Love from India
Good to listen you after a break and you came up with the real root cause of country's overall system failure. Even despite, if Quaid e Azam can come back to become the PM, I am sure he will not be able to complete his tenure and will be declared ghaddaar by establishment. As long as this establishment structure is intact, there will never be a hope. Ashir azeem spoke on this topic as well in a detailed series of establishment in his RUclips channel.
Mr jinaah was declared traitor as very early stage. That's why he left alone to die during his visit. Jinaah sister Fatima was also declared traitor by establishment.
Appreciate your independent thoughts brother........please, continue making these kind of videos on multiple domains.......Best wishes from India🇮🇳🇮🇳!!!
Sir- We Indian have a great respect for you. And know the facts of Pakistan administration and the sources of power there through your channel. Sir keep yourself safe in Pakistan. Allah blessed you sir. Srikumar 🇮🇳
@Kuch bhi rakhle i am just complementic him for his bravery. and julian assange and edward snowden are not consipericy theorist they told the truth. why do i know this because i work in cyber security.
Last part about imran khan is mind blowing i was a PTI supporter but i stand with the right whoever said it to public now i have decided not to castvote unless a party lie on my expectations.
Hi Syed, very well said and intriguingly presented, entailing the listeners to ponder upon and dwell upon. Hope that Pakistanis listen to this and realise the blunders that were made by your political elites in the past and still keep counting.
Yeah hope so that Pakistani people listen to people like him, Tarek Fateh ji, Istiaq Ahmad ji, Arzoo Kazmi ji. We wish good luck for Pakistan. We want friendship with Pakistan
👏 good summary! That is the reality! Good to know that now some Pakistanis understand our political system. Although history will keep repeating itself untill we learn our lesson!... I can only hope that time comes soon!
There is no doubt that he is the gem of a person but his viewers are mostly Indians...Pakistanis need to listen to such sane voices so that they can improve their mindsets n can have a positive approach towards nation building rather than hating their neighbours b'coz of some false propoganda n lies spread by their politicians n military establishment.......Pakistan is a highly radicalised society n only people like Muzammil is a ray of hope for Pakistanis in these difficult times
@@kapildaryani5136 establishment's hold over media so strong that they have captured the public in thier insane political drama. Public keeps fighting over thier shitty politicians, who are nothing but a distraction from the evil doings of these laathiwalas.
After so much time spent on news, podcasts, etc. afterall i found someone who can speak freely and tell truth about EST. Thanks man, Allah save and help you against these B's.
Muzzamil bhai, you have hit the nail on the head and there cannot be a better and easier explanation of the game that Pakistani Establishment plays to keep its power. The only way this grip of establishment be broken is when a common man takes to the street and cause a revolution. I am quite skeptical if any such revolution will take place because a common man in Pakistan has deliberately being kept so uneducated and dumb, just brainwashed and radicalized, that they cannot even see what they are being dished. I will also quote that during the freedom struggle against The British there weren’t many freedom fighters amongst the people who now live in Pakistan, so I will say by nature these people are not revolutionary. Why some ethnicity or race is revolutionary whereas some are very docile is a subject for another debate though. I just wish and pray that God gives wisdom to people of Pakistan so that they can understand and then act on what Muzzamil and so many others are trying to convey
Ma Sha Allah, this man @syed Muzammil is absolutely 💯 admirable journalist, may Allah protect you, keep it up Sir, such a amazing content and peak point creative minds, love you muzammil Bhai🥰🥰❤️❤️
Great analysis to deal with heart of the issue through history of pakistan. you are really a man of character who has a great knowledge of world history & also a great preacher of humanity . Thank you and again thank you! God bleedings always be with you!!!
I was eagerly waiting for ur next video since long pertaining to current highly polarized political predicament of a country facing the dire economic crisis, and ur highly opinionated analysis on the civil military engagement which is the reflection of the client-patronage relationship between the british rulers and the native rulers.
What a knowladge seyad u r doing great job by reaching to ppl through tech. Youth of Pakistan sud follow him . Pliz Pakistani youth pliz follow seyad n support him
I wish, I had an elder brother like Syed Muzammil - I'm assuming he is more than 34 years old !!!! Such a polite & charismatic person & knowledgeable !
Great video explaining the real situation of Pakistan. I totally relate with your narrative and I also find debating over politicians useless in the current situation. I remember watching the Bhootnath movie which explained that we should vote for the most honest person but we compromise and vote for the least corrupt out of the available options. As a nation, we always compromise and let go of things which have led us to the current situation of Pakistan. We are morally compromised people and that's why we always choose the morally compromised leaders who are also pseudo leaders with no real power.
@@Im_AbHiJiT UP me srivastav hain to Nepal me kyu nhi ho skte. Nepal ke tarai ke log UP ,Bihar ke logo ki trh hi hain . Baki pahadi log Sikim aur Darjling ke logo ki trh hain
Best video to explain the crisis... Although this video also results in creating hopelessness and feeling of sadness but at parallel, I could only hope that awareness of the problem could one day garner a solution... May that day comes sooner.. Is educating the masses the first step towards the solution?
Bro Your opinion and presentation is very transparent and too good. You are 100% correct. Hope lot of Pakistani's watch your video and do their homework and learn true history 👌
Dear Syed Muazzalim ji, Thanks for explaining dirty Political scenario alongwith dirty immoral, corrupt politicians & same type of Miltestablishment & its role in dirty politics with dirty means. Gandhiji, Badshah Khan ji always laid stress on use of pure & moral means & not corrupt or immoral means to achieve good goals for public. Thanks.
@@amnahaque9058 quite right. Public & Jinnah both responsible for division of subcontinent. Jinnah never suffered jail or atrocities for sake of Muslim public. Nowadays IK is trying to project himself as Gandhiji in Pakistan without suffering Gandhiji like jails just like Jinnah who never suffered atrocities & made no struggle. Intellectuals should educate public in Pakistan.
Thanks for the education you gave us defining "Pakistani Establishment" that I was confused of, earlier (I am an Indian-American and have a lot of knowledge-interest on South Asia). So, that means - no political party nor its leaders can make any change in that poor country unless "Establishment" wishes for it? In that constrains and current financial situation that Pakistan is in, can you predict what may come in near future? I am asking this, as I believe that the powerful "Establishment" doesn't want to die along with the destruction of Pakistan that would surely come sooner if the country is not managed right, now.
I agree Sir But Indeed roots of our Establishment are somewhere else Who were interested to divide India ? And create a state in name of religion Which can play a role of buffer zone inbetween Soviet Union and India ? Who were so called hypocratic democracy chamipions of the world but in Pakistan supported dictatorship.? Our Establishment is a tool of great game and We are victim of it Unfortunatly India and our other neighbours are also suffering because of our role in region . We Pakistan are responsible to destablize our region and World . Creation of Pakistan has played its role Congratulations . I as Pakistani Muslim think it is better to join back our mother land India and burried establishment with its guardians for ever. Solution of mistake is to Undo it
@@raghavbatra12345 I have a dream of United India Just imagine how powerfull We were if India Pakistan and Bangladesh were one Country . Lot of Pakistani just Love India .
@@naveedch316 We are Punjabis and we will make a greater Punjab. We have no relation with Hind, neither are we interested in Pakistan or Hind. Im also a Pakistani Punjabi and youre delusional to think Hind is our mother land
Well said!
Seedha hi well said. Banda kahin se counter check karwa leta hai. I guess this is what we can expect of comedians turned journalists.
@@talhawajid5902 ?
Look pakistani muslims fight over one another😂.
Welcome to the jungle mongrels
Imran khan ko lao😂🤣
@@talhawajid5902 konse nashe karte ho bhai , zarurat hai mujhe , quality maal lag raha hai kafi
سید مذمل آپ مستقبل کی آمید ھو ۔۔۔
❤کاش کہ دلوں میں اتر جائیں تیری بات
اس شعور کو پھیلانے میں ہم آپ کے ساتھ کھڑے ہیں۔
Sir, we Indians 🇮🇳 follow you to understand the reality. We are a few who don't not really want to hear only good things about our country or bad about others but are interested in reality because we care about our future. May we leave behind a better world for generations to come. We support your impartial journalism and sincerely hope that it would remain so. 💛
Yes👍
Bilkul Theek🙏
Absolutely right!
Well put!
Bad people are everywhere. Some countries accept like you others plainly shy away from accepting the facts. For a person or a country to improve, one must accept that things are wrong. I respect you a lot
Dear Syed,
Army has not allowed political parties to develop a mature and evolved democracy. You are truthful, courageous and visionary journalist. God bless you good health, security, all successes and long life.
...but sir, why don't the Pakstani people go out on the street & demand that pakfauj goes back to the barracks & that pakfauj gives space to true democracy? It seems that Pakstani just complain but never actually take action.
@@nnbg8000 Revolting against the deep state doesn't just simply happen. Pakistanis have always come out on street like you said, there's probably 10 protests happening in the country right now. But where do you protest against the Establishment? Even making posts on social media gets you arrested.
@@karachiseascouts I understand but isn't this what the people in Myanmar are doing? You think if lakhs/crores of people go out on the street, peacefully, & demand democracy in Pakstan, you won't be able to achieve your goal? Of course you will. It won't happen after 1 protest. Only the people of Pakstan can fight for it. You will have to start small. Perhaps a street corner protest, peacefully. In today's world, there will be enough people who will be willing to support you on-line.
@@nnbg8000 I've seen you ask this question in some other comments as well. Therefore, I'd like to answer it to the best of my knowledge. The arguments I'll discuss are directly from this video.
1) Polarization: as people, the proletariat, are fed constant news for a prolonged time, their critical thinking devolves completely. As time passes, they firmly adhere to the rhetoric - the concept of a villain and a hero. Even if the people, who are brainwashed, see an informative video like this one, they don't dare understand the arguments and rather become defensive.
2) All other institutes, except the all-powerful, have been rendered incompetent to handle the current problems. As there are no options except the omnipotent, no one has a choice but to adhere. Otherwise, the state will fall apart - attacked by foreign groups or violence from within.
3) Fear: this factor dominates. First of all, only a few fully understand the entire structure, and even these intelligent people don't speak of it. That is because the backlash of doing so is too costly. People like this content creator are among these intelligent people. However, instead of staying apathetic, he, this content creator, has decided to speak about what he observed. You might not realise this, but he's taking on a daunting task which might lead to severe repercussions.
I can further dwell on each point or give multiple other arguments, but that's not my point. I hope these three arguments entertained your query.
Regards,
Someone on the internet.
Disclaimer: these arguments don't reflect my personal views.
Well that's last option
The surprising thing is that on Pakistani channels where usefull, intellectual, economic issues base content is uploaded, most of the viewers and comments are from Indians. On the other hand, if you watch Indian songs, entertainment, and comedy shows, you will find a large number of Pakistani viewers. This shows what our priorities as a nation are and how other nations have moved ahead of us.
Exactly and then insan or disappoint ho jata hai
Watch coke Studio Pakistan you find majority of comments from indians.
Since muzammil criticizes Pakistan you find majority indians since they are obsessed with Pakistan.
On the other hands people like arundati roy are called propagandist in India.
Exactly... Because people are slaves of their momentary pleasure.....lack of culture and degradation of society.....
@ASIM BASHIR YES U HAV STATED VERY CORRECTLY I AM IN TOTAL AGREEMENT WITH UR VIEW.
THE AVERAGE PAKISTANI'S IDEA OF INDIA STARTS IN PUNJAB TRAVELS TO DELHI,AGRA,KASHMIR, THEN A BIG JUMP TO BOMBAY WITH GOA THROWN IN BETWEEN.
WHAT THEY DONT KNOW IS INDIA IS SO VAST N DIVERSE THAT VERY FEW PEOPLE TALK OF THE SOUTH WHERE THE REAL ACTION IS, N ALSO MAHARASHTRA N GUJRAT, WHICH IS POWERING INDIA IN IT'S ECONOMIC GALLOP. THE SOUTH IS THE HUB FOR IT INDUSTRY WITH CITIES LIKE BANGALORE, HYDERABAD, CHENNAI, N TIER 2 CITIES LIKE THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, MANGALORE, MYSORE, COIMBATORE, WHICH ALSO CONTRIBUTE TO THE IT, ITES INDUSTRY. CORE MANUFACTURING ALSO HAS TAKEN OFF IN BIG BIG WAY SINCE 2014 SINCE MODI TOOK OVER AS PM. INDIA IS SPENDING HUGE AMOUNTS HAS BEEN INVESTED IN ROAD INFRASTRUCTURE, GREEN ENERGY, ALSO MORE THAN 100 START UP'S EACH VALUED AT A BILLION EACH N MANY MORE COMING IN THE ECO SYSTEM, OF START UPS. THE COMING DECADE WILL ALSO SEE THAT INDIA BECOMES A MANUFACTURING HUB BACKED BY IT. TO GREAT LEVELS.
AND MOST OF THIS ACTION IS HAPPENING IN THE SOUTH, GUJRAT N MAHARASHTRA. GOOD TO C PEOPLE LIKE U WHO UNDERSTAND WHERE THE PROBLEM IS BUT DONT GET AN OPPORTUNITY TO RECTIFY IT BECAUSE OF EXTREME NEPOTISM N CORRUPTION IN PAKISTAN.
@@s.v.srinivasan6041 story cut short there will never be any comparison between mighty INDIA and Pakistan....Kashmir is the only cash cow for the corrupt Pak Estb to keep them in the business..
Syed Muzzamil thank you for teaching us the truth
Logic,common sense and rationality is the medicine that Pak establishememt needs..good work bhai..love from 🇮🇳 India
Why don't u stop interfering and focus on ur own problems.... FreeKhalistan
@@AbdullahKhawar262 yes why you people s#it on dhruv rathee video
Syed Muzamil Sir, you are the only Pakistani journalist whose video I am eagerly waiting for, stay safe and take care of yourself..✌️
Finally someone explained the difference bw Army and Estabilishment for Pakistanis..Appreciated
Logic, rational thinking, facts, truth ❤❤ Love you from India
Ajeeb sa naam qun rakha h..!?!? Odisha me kahan se ho..??
@@sanusam420 not from odisha.
are these actual indian accounts or establishment is slowly plotting against you 🤔
@@masoudabdulwahid8549 Syed Muzammil is the New face of Establishment... lol 😂
@@masoudabdulwahid8549 Your name Contains Abdul. Follow the path of Dr Abdul Kalam. Read some of his books eg " Wings of fire" etc.
As an Indian, This topic is not very relevant for me, but always love to watch your videos, the way you support your arguments with books, authors, philosophers is very interesting and shows your overall understanding. your way of communication is very simple and elegant.
You will take lndia forward ❤
Dear Syed
Journalists like you, Arzoo, Shakil, and intellectual like Prof. Pervez Hoodbhai and Prof. Ahmed are great hope. Only way is creating awareness among youths for change and better nation.
You are right DG police saheb.
you cannot understand . this is not awareness to the public to change in better way its just negativity against the country .
@@AneesUrRehman-xi3uv If this negativity against the country so what establishment has done are all positive things in 75 years
Extremely rare to see such a neutral , clear and balanced perspective from a Pakistani! Wonder if Pakistanis actually revere this man's deep knowledge! Incredibly knowledgeable and mature assessment of the topic! Hope he is not picked up by the Pakistani establishment and software updated by the You-know-Who!
25 % to 30% people are better knowledge about the current affairs and the present system there ; but they cant speak as their system is so ; the mullah and establishment will hound them.
Who?
جِس معاشرے کے لوگ ظلم و زیادتی کے خلاف کھڑے نہیں ہوتے،
ایک وقت آتا ہے کہ وہی ظلم و زیادتی انہیں کھڑے تو کیا بیٹھنے کے قابل بھی نہیں چھوڑتی...!
Welcome to Islam
Lots of love and respect from India.
Some people would say Indians watch your channel cause you are criticizing Pakistan but I wouldn't say it's so.
Lot of us watch to understand an impartial view of what is really happening beyond the politics. What kind of structural and systemic issues exist in Pakistan which has led it to where it is today. Maybe we can even learn something to better our own systems & institutions to avoid such a fate ourselves.
Keep doing what you're doing, can't believe you're so young and so well read and have the courage to speak truth to power especially in times of tyranny.
Muzammil bhai Mai aap ko 7,8 din sunta hu aur Meri soch me bahut fark Aya hai
Love from 🇮🇳
ExMuslim Zafarheretic ko suno soch badal jayegi
@@Ramraju146 🤣🤣🤣🤣 right
@@AjayKumar-rt1qv 😝🤪😜
Remember our 40 soldier 👍🇮🇳
@@Ramraju146 ja ja kar peshaab pi aur gobar kha
بہت ہی بہترین تجزیہ کیا اپ نے ان چوروں کا قاتلوں کا۔عوام کی خقوق کو کہانے والے بھی یہی سارے فساد کی جڑ یہی فوج اور اس کے جنریل ہیں۔
Bro ur an ocean of knowledge. We r fortunate to have people like u in this generation.
This is the power of in-depth knowledge.Sir you are defending your country with your eloquence,facts and rationality.
Dear Syed - I have recently discovered your channel. You are one of those rare Pakistanis like Prof. Hoodbhoy who not only know the real history but also are trying to teach it to other people who have been fed lies by Pakistani establishment. You are like a breath of fresh air. Pakistan and South Asian area need people like you. I really hope you can get into a political leadership role. I am a big fan now and will continue to follow your good work
True sir if he remains same need a personality with clear vision and speaking, soft and efficiently. Moreover logically
Dr. Hoodbhoy's forte is Science and not politics. That is why his views at times are biased.
Syde Muzammil and Taimur Rahaman are much better when they speak on Politics and World affairs.
@@KU77AR Aftab Iqbal is a fuddu.....His opinions are largely biased n he spreads lies n false propoganda to his viewers....Even many people from Indian punjab follow him blindly just because there are Punjabi comedians in his show n they kinda relate with them b'coz of their language
Please unsubscribe this mf said rubbish about our PM Modi ji
Why you do not want to think this man start from imran and finish on imran.he is living bughze imran
This type of journalism has the power to start the revolution against establishment and 🫡
Muzammil sir your videos revived my interest in sociology and philosophy. After coming across your channel I've read two books recommended by you. The way you question the society while quoting philosophers inspired me to another level. Love from India.
U right or left wing?.. Just a quez. Nothing more
Youth like you will take lndia forward ❤❤
Most intellectual person in pakistan. We need more people like you in this polarized world. Your country should be so proud of you. Real gem
Much appreciate your courage to speak fearlessly. The world has very few journalists like you. Sometimes I worry for your safety given the limitations to journalism. We have very few journalists like you in the Indian-subcontinent.
kitni rational, logical batein hain… apko salute karta hu bhai g.. kash zyada se zyada Pakistani awam apki videos dekhe
اللہ پاک آپ کی حفاظت فرمائے آمین
Good job done 👍
May Jesus Christ, Sri Ram, Buddha, and Guru Nanak also protect you.
Muzammil sahb ki 1 behtreen koshish Pakistan ki jahil awam ko awareness deny k liye.
Happy to see young people like you from an Islamic country who are seemed to be truth-seekers and progressive thinkers ,above all the confinements of narrow religious lanes. People like you are very rare to find.With Love & Respect,
- Rensoy Philip, Kerala State, South India.
These kind of people have always been there , one just needs to look a bit. Now let’s see if you can find some in your own backyard.😊
You are a hindutva troll. You have no idea why our country is in the situation that is today.
why was it essential to write "south india".. U could simply mention "India"
Stop parting with north indians..
Look at the pictures behind him ..it’s clear where se coming from and rightly so .
@@contrarian322 yeah I noticed that too. He likes to quote western philosophers, maybe just to impress people. I commented on one of his blogs pointing out that these guys came late in the game. There is rich Islamic tradition of logical reasoning. Anyway he puts it out there. Will cut him some slack there.
آپ دوسرے عاشر عظیم ہو۔۔۔ شاباش ۔۔
اللہ تمہاری حفاظت کرے۔ اسی طرح ہم لوگوں کو حقیقت سمجھاتے رہو
Couple of weeks ago, I was sitting with one of my senior colleague who also happens to be from the subject of political science and an Associate Professor, who was sharing some of issues which are being discussed in Professor Parvez Sahib's You tube that is "The black hole", Which I had already subscribed. Professor sahib (my colleague) suddenly started talking about you and said there is a young man from Pakistan who is much clear about the politics and anything which revolves around human existence, virtually be its anything and claimed there is hardly any parallel to him (he meant you) in India or per se Indian subcontinent. And i felt confused honestly at that moment. The matter came and went away, I hardly bothered. Professor sahib feel really inclined towards Pakistan and it's culture and i thought thats why he is singing your wax lyricals. I felt highly skeptical about his remark. Today again I was sitting with him (my colleague) and suddenly he played one of your previous you tube on his Android device and i listened to that whilst sitting in his chamber only. You would not believe it I was awestruck and putting everything aside, I drew whole of my attention to what we're you saying in that video. I could safely say that my skepticism was literally meaningless. I came back home listened few more of your you tubes and now this one, it's really some thing out of this world experience. I would say it's not just the people in Pakistan but everywhere else should have or atleast try to be aware as you are being.
Thanks and regards
Support from Ludhiana, India.
@@charurolvcharurolv9230 same teaching here in DAVV Indore and persuing phd on CPEC
And we happen to teach in same college Jaggi ji😀
When it comes to Pakistan he is a great analyst but he don't have any grasp about Indian politics. We have many Indic minds here. Pakistan needs a revolution right now, but India not need any. I respect him but this is the reality. So don't compare these two countries. Our problems are different.
My best wishes to you and your colleague. Cheers.
@@syedmuzammilofficial7067 thank you so much Sir
The topic is very interesting ...the basic understanding of Pakistan politics and economics...real intellectual talk
Please continue...even if your followers don't increase as much as other so called influencers...keep spreading critical thinking among the masses
Well projected the deepest issue of our beloved state PAKISTAN. May Allah protect the Muslim Ummah from all negativities and united for sake of betterment of the general public.
Finally wait is over ☺️
This video reminds me of how 1984 is becoming reality day by day...every three or four years, the establishment creates a big brother and a Goldstein to engage the common people...but the power always remains within the establishment...this is happening not only in Pakistan and every country..
As a Indian, I was always confused with establishment term. Thanks sir
Bcz iss naam kaa Janwarr India mee nahii hotaa
That is why you not know.
Love from Pakistan
@@naveedch316 Yeh jaanwar her jagaa pey hai , India mey bhee, bus soortain faraq hain!
@@naveedch316 love from India bhai
@@asad-kc8zf @ yes curruption hai india mai but decorator nhe ..... Curruption wala janwar hai india mai but establishment wala nhe ..... Right wing nationalist Elected govt he centre mai but unko awam laaye hai wo awam ke vote sa khadi he ...aaga koi leftist ya centre wali govt bhe hogi ....
@@naveedch316 @ India mai right wing nationalist Elected party tau hai yes wo decorator nhe he bass kaam wesa he hai hope next election congress ko vote de humare log .... center govt mai phir sa congress aa jaye
Today after watching this video, I truly believe you are not only the honest but must be the bravest person in whole Pakistan.. we Indians have watched multiple videos of different Pakistanis who dare to speak against the govt but you are the first one who openly speaking about the Deep State/ establishment… road ahead can be turbulent but keep up the good work .. will share and ask others to subscribe
ھماری عدلیہ اور جنرلز کا پاکستان سے لینا دینا کچھ بھی نہیں۔ بس اربوں روپے بناتے ھیں اور ریٹائرمنٹ کے بعد فیملی سمیت کسی دوسرے ملک چلے جاتے ھیں 😡😡
Yaha bhiiiiiiiiiiiii pahunch gae jnab , bhai ki bate kan kholti he
Ullu ka pathay channel ka name change kr nai to tu b fake ho jy ga
👍👍👍👍
@@Informative_bano tu bhi ruclips.net/video/MWmdAViZrTY/видео.html
@Råndi Draupati 😍 - Çoncúbine of Múslíms tera mohamad toh ayesha ke chut ki puja karta tha 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Rational and impartial analysis .Real Journalists,You are our saviours . Knowledge of truth is half the battle won. we Indians should not be delusional about our great growth story .We need to improve on lots of things .
You are probably one of few people in Pakistan who can name army directly
Your analysis are very much balanced without blaming anyone directly or abusing any agency or giving revolutionary lectures to provoke public so I guess you will be safe.
Once the cause is analysed then only the problems can be solved, if Pakistan starts today from the scratch ending madarsa education and bring every child to normal school followed by crushing radicalism after 20yrs results will be visible
Love from India
Good to listen you after a break and you came up with the real root cause of country's overall system failure. Even despite, if Quaid e Azam can come back to become the PM, I am sure he will not be able to complete his tenure and will be declared ghaddaar by establishment. As long as this establishment structure is intact, there will never be a hope. Ashir azeem spoke on this topic as well in a detailed series of establishment in his RUclips channel.
Mr jinaah was declared traitor as very early stage. That's why he left alone to die during his visit.
Jinaah sister Fatima was also declared traitor by establishment.
Appreciate your independent thoughts brother........please, continue making these kind of videos on multiple domains.......Best wishes from India🇮🇳🇮🇳!!!
Lekin kb tk
Exactly 💯 you're saying absolutely correct.
Right. The "establishment" is a system, with a set of self-sustaining & self-serving feedback loops.
@syedmuzammil Aap ny is new Generation k liue Buhat Barra kaam kia hai. ALLAH PAAK aap ki jifazat farmay aur mazeed izzat atta farmay Ameen.
Marvellous!!!
Muzammil only yo could've made a video on such sensitive topic and explain it matchlessly.
May you go to higher places. Ameen!
Sometimes it's hard to believe that Pakistan has such brilliant minds please keep going ...from India
Something it's hard to believe India have internet. Stfu asswipe apna kaam karna jakar apne maslay dekh
Sir- We Indian have a great respect for you. And know the facts of Pakistan administration and the sources of power there through your channel. Sir keep yourself safe in Pakistan. Allah blessed you sir. Srikumar 🇮🇳
Allah pak apko apne hifz o aman mei rkhy. ameen.
You are a true bold and wise man.
hello syed Muzammil bhi jan.
I genuinely believe that you are extremely brave like along side Julian assange and Edwards Snowden.
@Kuch bhi rakhle i am just complementic him for his bravery.
and julian assange and edward snowden
are not consipericy theorist they told the truth. why do i know this because i work in cyber security.
Bhai your understanding of Pakistan's politics is crystal clear. You don't seems to be a Pakistani. So much truthful.
MashaAllah muzammil bhai the wait is over finally new video is uploaded thanks Allah bless you bhai
Last part about imran khan is mind blowing i was a PTI supporter but i stand with the right whoever said it to public now i have decided not to castvote unless a party lie on my expectations.
Hi Syed, very well said and intriguingly presented, entailing the listeners to ponder upon and dwell upon.
Hope that Pakistanis listen to this and realise the blunders that were made by your political elites in the past and still keep counting.
Yeah hope so that Pakistani people listen to people like him, Tarek Fateh ji, Istiaq Ahmad ji, Arzoo Kazmi ji. We wish good luck for Pakistan. We want friendship with Pakistan
You are handsime , intelligent,brave and truth guy .. Allah bless you 🙏
👏 good summary! That is the reality!
Good to know that now some Pakistanis understand our political system. Although history will keep repeating itself untill we learn our lesson!...
I can only hope that time comes soon!
There is no doubt that he is the gem of a person but his viewers are mostly Indians...Pakistanis need to listen to such sane voices so that they can improve their mindsets n can have a positive approach towards nation building rather than hating their neighbours b'coz of some false propoganda n lies spread by their politicians n military establishment.......Pakistan is a highly radicalised society n only people like Muzammil is a ray of hope for Pakistanis in these difficult times
@@kapildaryani5136 establishment's hold over media so strong that they have captured the public in thier insane political drama. Public keeps fighting over thier shitty politicians, who are nothing but a distraction from the evil doings of these laathiwalas.
After so much time spent on news, podcasts, etc. afterall i found someone who can speak freely and tell truth about EST. Thanks man, Allah save and help you against these B's.
Wish you a very Happy Holi ....long time no see?....as usual very Nice video Muzammil... love and respect from 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
You're the best , honest & realistic journalist. My salute to you from India🇮🇳
Hat's off to you sir
What a explanation 👏👏👏
❤️🇮🇳
Thank you sir you have changed our mind told what is true or false
You are well educated person
I'm already free of such non-issues but thank you "Sir" for this realistic depiction.
Too good…most sensible man….great guy….agree with you on all tpoics
Muzzamil bhai, you have hit the nail on the head and there cannot be a better and easier explanation of the game that Pakistani Establishment plays to keep its power. The only way this grip of establishment be broken is when a common man takes to the street and cause a revolution. I am quite skeptical if any such revolution will take place because a common man in Pakistan has deliberately being kept so uneducated and dumb, just brainwashed and radicalized, that they cannot even see what they are being dished. I will also quote that during the freedom struggle against The British there weren’t many freedom fighters amongst the people who now live in Pakistan, so I will say by nature these people are not revolutionary. Why some ethnicity or race is revolutionary whereas some are very docile is a subject for another debate though. I just wish and pray that God gives wisdom to people of Pakistan so that they can understand and then act on what Muzzamil and so many others are trying to convey
I am seriously shocked and happy to have someone like you!
Awais, I'bad, Pakistan
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Ma Sha Allah, this man @syed Muzammil is absolutely 💯 admirable journalist, may Allah protect you, keep it up Sir, such a amazing content and peak point creative minds, love you muzammil Bhai🥰🥰❤️❤️
YOU ARE ONE RATIONAL AND INTELLIGENT YOUNG MAN FROM PAKISTAN.
Great analysis to deal with heart of the issue through history of pakistan. you are really a man of character who has a great knowledge of world history & also a great preacher of humanity .
Thank you and again thank you!
God bleedings always be with you!!!
I was eagerly waiting for ur next video since long pertaining to current highly polarized political predicament of a country facing the dire economic crisis, and ur highly opinionated analysis on the civil military engagement which is the reflection of the client-patronage relationship between the british rulers and the native rulers.
What a knowladge seyad u r doing great job by reaching to ppl through tech. Youth of Pakistan sud follow him . Pliz Pakistani youth pliz follow seyad n support him
Pakistan diyan Mauja hi Mauja
Jithe vekho uthe Faujan hi Faujan 💪
واہ ، کیا بات ہے ۔ کمال کر دیا ۔
زبردست گیم !
Sir you've analyzed the whole saga in a very comprehensive way.! ♥️ 🌺
Love from the Balochistan ♥
I wish, I had an elder brother like Syed Muzammil - I'm assuming he is more than 34 years old !!!! Such a polite & charismatic person & knowledgeable !
Great video explaining the real situation of Pakistan. I totally relate with your narrative and I also find debating over politicians useless in the current situation. I remember watching the Bhootnath movie which explained that we should vote for the most honest person but we compromise and vote for the least corrupt out of the available options. As a nation, we always compromise and let go of things which have led us to the current situation of Pakistan. We are morally compromised people and that's why we always choose the morally compromised leaders who are also pseudo leaders with no real power.
Please somebody share this with Imran Riaz kaaan and let him know this is what you call journalism 💯
Love from Nepal 🇳🇵 sir Happy Holi to you ! You are a great person
Happy holi bhai
Nepal me bhi Shrivastava hsi ??
@@anokhelal-in7do migrate kiya hoga... india me bhi to bahot sare Nepali rehte hai....
@@Im_AbHiJiT UP me srivastav hain to Nepal me kyu nhi ho skte. Nepal ke tarai ke log UP ,Bihar ke logo ki trh hi hain . Baki pahadi log Sikim aur Darjling ke logo ki trh hain
happy HOLI
Syed muzmil is the forever defenders of Status Quo. Their ultimate goal is to gain power. public is not in their equation.
Best video to explain the crisis... Although this video also results in creating hopelessness and feeling of sadness but at parallel, I could only hope that awareness of the problem could one day garner a solution... May that day comes sooner.. Is educating the masses the first step towards the solution?
Well said
Taaaliyan.
Probably the best video ever created on this topic.
Allah apki hifazat farmaye.
You are a gem.
This man playing with fire
Bro
Your opinion and presentation is very transparent and too good. You are 100% correct. Hope lot of Pakistani's watch your video and do their homework and learn true history 👌
We eagerly wait for your video. Pls be regular on channel.
True explanation of a reality
75 years ki web series type story in 30 min 😂😂
😂😂😜
Mei Pakistan se hu but 👍👍👍👍😂😂😂😂
@@Games-nj5cy mei India se hu but 😂😂😂😂😂
but nahin, lekin 😎
اپ کے ہر ویڈیو سے بہت کچھ سیکھنے کو مل جاتا ہے، زندہ رہو سید صاحب
Sayed please be regular on your video . We wait for your video
Bundle of thanks, Muzamil.
For making things clearer than ever.
Worth listening. unfortunately, most of the people in Pakistan are not educated enough to understand what you said.
Syed muzammil show is like "Dawat" of knowledge and wisdom.
Dear Syed Muazzalim ji,
Thanks for explaining dirty Political scenario alongwith dirty immoral, corrupt politicians & same type of Miltestablishment & its role in dirty politics with dirty means. Gandhiji, Badshah Khan ji always laid stress on use of pure & moral means & not corrupt or immoral means to achieve good goals for public. Thanks.
Inn dirty politicians ko log hi vote detay hain. People are to blame too.
@@amnahaque9058 quite right. Public & Jinnah both responsible for division of subcontinent. Jinnah never suffered jail or atrocities for sake of Muslim public. Nowadays IK is trying to project himself as Gandhiji in Pakistan without suffering Gandhiji like jails just like Jinnah who never suffered atrocities & made no struggle. Intellectuals should educate public in Pakistan.
@@AnilSharma-bd1jy check dhruv Rathi recent video
Brother you have just turned my opinions and mentality 180 degrees!!!
I'm from india your way of thinking inspire me a lot and its help in my study also so big thank you
Are bapre.yea to badiya hai biru.keep up
Thank you Muzammil for clearing my mind from this absolute waste of time political system of this so cold Islamic Republic of Pakistan.
Thanks for the education you gave us defining "Pakistani Establishment" that I was confused of, earlier (I am an Indian-American and have a lot of knowledge-interest on South Asia). So, that means - no political party nor its leaders can make any change in that poor country unless "Establishment" wishes for it? In that constrains and current financial situation that Pakistan is in, can you predict what may come in near future? I am asking this, as I believe that the powerful "Establishment" doesn't want to die along with the destruction of Pakistan that would surely come sooner if the country is not managed right, now.
Yes u r right there will be a massive blood revolution needed to solve this
I pray for this man that he keeps on speaking like this and remains fair. May Allah keep him in His Aman.
Is video ko b youthiya jhutlaen ga k Hmra khan asa ni ha🤷♂
Wah zabardast
I agree Sir
But
Indeed roots of our Establishment are somewhere else
Who were interested to divide India ? And create a state in name of religion Which can play a role of buffer zone inbetween Soviet Union and India ?
Who were so called hypocratic democracy chamipions of the world but in Pakistan supported dictatorship.?
Our Establishment is a tool of great game and We are victim of it
Unfortunatly India and our other neighbours are also suffering because of our role in region .
We Pakistan are responsible to destablize our region and World .
Creation of Pakistan has played its role
Congratulations .
I as Pakistani Muslim think it is better to join back our mother land India and burried establishment with its guardians for ever.
Solution of mistake is to Undo it
am being honest , majority of indians dont even want POK anymore. we just want peace and development not expansion and violence
@@raghavbatra12345
I have a dream of United India
Just imagine how powerfull We were if India Pakistan and Bangladesh were one Country .
Lot of Pakistani just Love India .
@@naveedch316 We are Punjabis and we will make a greater Punjab.
We have no relation with Hind, neither are we interested in Pakistan or Hind.
Im also a Pakistani Punjabi and youre delusional to think Hind is our mother land
@@HM-ee8tj punjab is also a part of cultural civilization
Your thinking seems purely mature