É impressionante como uma moça tão jovem tem essa incrível introspecção musical do mesmo nível dos grandes mestres e mestras do vilão erudito .Sem falar da sua grande beleza e simpatia .Bravo, um viva à grande diva do violão erudito Ana Vidovic .
She has a NATURAL AND GOD GIVEN DEEP UNDERSTANDING of performing... not just playing the guitar but of CREATING an EXPERIENCE for the listener... 9:44 wait, not just the listener but the viewer... wait, no not just the viewer but the male drooler and female jealous of her looks! She always looks gorgeous too! She's the whole deal wrapped up in one!
se esse masterclass foi na centro cultural em SP, eu estava lá. Sou guitarrista de Thrash Metal... hehehe mas me interesso muito pela música erudita. Fui apenas como observador e pude aprender muito com o feedback dela para os caras aí. Ela é simplesmente apaixonante. Linda, talentosa, extremamente atenciosa com todos que fizeram perguntas e uma incrível professora. O violão dela tem um som impressionante, nunca pensei que um violão pudesse ter um alcance tão grande quanto o dela... mesmo nas dinâmicas mais baixas. Quando tiver um concerto dela aqui eu vou com certeza!
I think the first guitarist is a excellent player with great potential.....technically proficient under pressure which is a really good foundation to build from. He just needs to develop his feel....Ana breaks this down to technical elements (dynamics/ articulation etc which is technically correct ....but the 'missing spark' goes beyond the guitar and even music. He needs to goes out and fall in love, smell the roses, dance in the forest, grow spiritually as a person and bring this back into the music!
Colly Flour Yes. Also he just looks so shy. It must have been terrifying for him to present to such an amazing artist. It can be so hard to take criticism, let alone in front of an audience & ultimately on youtube. Years ago I knew a banjo player who also taught, & she had some buttons printed for her students (as a joke): "I did it better in practice."
+Denise Di Salvo so what you want him to do? snap out of it? some people are shy and cannot be helped, he is a good player and did better than many people criticizing him would. Also, it is bullshit about go and find your spirituality and all that soul crap. People are different, and this what he presents while he plays. Ana is around the same age, and portrays more "feeling", it has nothing to do with her having more spirituality and all that crap, is all about TALENT, there is a reason why she is so admired and has everything in one person, looks, personality, confidence, proficiency, technique, the perfect package, nerves of steel in public, no amount of practice can give your that, and you gotta work with what you have. No amount of bullshit spirituality seeking, meditation and wisdom will give this guy, what she obtained by having the right genes, mind, muscles, brain, etc
Denise Di Salvo English is not my first language, but I could write better if I wanted to. My comment is mostly directed to the first comment. I have been playing guitar for 14 years, so I have knowledge and experience on this subject. There are no such things as soul or spirituality. They are nothing but made-up terms to explain talent and certain personality/character traits. For example, many Asian women players get criticized for having no soul or feelings, mostly because they are introverted while inside they could be full of them. There is a reason why this girl is so admired and successful in the classical guitar world. Do you think all this guy needs to do is practice, find his "spirituality" and suddenly he will be as proficient as her? She is extremely talented, and no amount of training will get you to her level. She has the whole package. She has looks, confidence, nerves of steel, technique, talent, charisma, and so many other attributes, that play a huge role in guitar playing. Naturally, many will refuse to accept this realization, because it leaves them hopeless. They rather believe in HOPE than be cognizant of an unpleasant truth that negates that hope, even if such hope never materializes.
+Denise Di Salvo Plus one here, well said. Seriously, if I had to play for Ana Vidovic, I would be totally bricking it! Plus, she covered a bunch of stuff. When I was playing seriously and taking lessons, I tried to take one thing from each lesson. However, in the master class setting, you want to take in as much as you can. It' can be really overwhelming.
Same as piano, like Martine Krause said：On stage, you have to play 10 times louder and faster. Some people couldn't understand, why we need to play so loud? even in studio, music is all about perform, you need to communicate with your audience, if you can't reach the last row, they don't know what you are trying to "say", we always practice so loud, so much of deep tone, but all we get are complaint, especially in Singapore, i think most of the Singaporean don't even know the art and beautiful of music, they just pretend. Back to this, regardless what instrument that you learn, music are universe, we all taking about the same language, like Ana said, the sound projecting, deeper tone, more contrast and dynamic colour, articulation, all are essential music elements.
Small world :-) do you know this guitarist? Mr. Lam Vien? and still flying your RC planes at baylands mr. Bic ???? ruclips.net/video/mx7GRqhvvUM/видео.html
MrTrucTran Not flying any more for a long time. Most of my planes are in different states of wreckage. Mr. Truc, do I know you? I don't know Lam Vien. He plays well.
That's interesting, but doubling sounds will only raise the volume very modestly because the ear hears sound logrithmically, not linearly. Even so, I think the dynamic range would have been limited. I think the guitar is a good analogue for the harpsichord in that respect
Its's true, many people play Baroque music at the same level of volume, it shouldn't happen, Baroque music is so expressive, and before Renaissance we have lot of lyrical vocal music, there is no way we play Baroque music like a machine, expressiveless
I think the first guitarist has a lot of hidden potential, but he completely lacks good ideas. It is so heavy and backwards. He has along way to go to gain artistic control, but Ana's input changed it for the better. Yet, he went back to his unfortunate tendencies right afterwards.
Contrast the beautiful sound and power of her Jim Redgate guitar with his guitar which sounds as if it was made out of a discarded egg carton. He could do with a better guitar methinks.
+ergastule Ha, yep! My advice to people who ask what guitar to buy is "Whatever you like as long as it feels right... and costs at least $1000, ;o) I never used to think that way until I got an Augustino Loprinzi. Within a couple of weeks it completely changed the way I play. A good instrument responds to even the most subtle changes in expression and attack. You don't have to push it to play louder. You can go from dolce to ponticelo by moving your hand just a few centimeters up the or down the strings and slightly varying the angle that you fingers address the uppers. I don't think that a good instrument can make a poor player good, but a bad instrument can severely limit and even discourage a player with potential. All that being said, I have had my instrument played by people who are of superior talent than me and been dumbfounded at how much more sound they can extract from the same instrument.
He needs better right hand angles. Essential full sound, more gallantly, even arrogant by contrast. Problem is he's not developed enough yet, he needs to essential whole of what she's showing him. He's got a sweet guitara though.
Ana Vidovic is already one of the all time greats. Even the short excerpts she plays to demonstrate her ideas to the students are exquisite.
É impressionante como uma moça tão jovem tem essa incrível introspecção musical do mesmo nível dos grandes mestres e mestras do vilão erudito .Sem falar da sua grande beleza e simpatia .Bravo, um viva à grande diva do violão erudito Ana Vidovic .
Before Ana the song was a cadaver...after her the song turn into life. Great master teacher woman
Amazing teacher .
Impossível não se apaixonar por ela! Quanta técnica e quanta elegância.
Ela é uma linda talentosa maravilhosa e uma doçura de pessoa.
I saw Ana at a master class in Calgary. She is fantastic teacher and performer.
She has a NATURAL AND GOD GIVEN DEEP UNDERSTANDING of performing... not just playing the guitar but of CREATING an EXPERIENCE for the listener... 9:44 wait, not just the listener but the viewer... wait, no not just the viewer but the male drooler and female jealous of her looks! She always looks gorgeous too! She's the whole deal wrapped up in one!
Que talento construído ao longo da sua jornada, parabéns, uma inspiração para quem ama música e violão(guitarra)👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Not only an incredible musician but an excellent teacher
se esse masterclass foi na centro cultural em SP, eu estava lá. Sou guitarrista de Thrash Metal... hehehe mas me interesso muito pela música erudita. Fui apenas como observador e pude aprender muito com o feedback dela para os caras aí. Ela é simplesmente apaixonante. Linda, talentosa, extremamente atenciosa com todos que fizeram perguntas e uma incrível professora. O violão dela tem um som impressionante, nunca pensei que um violão pudesse ter um alcance tão grande quanto o dela... mesmo nas dinâmicas mais baixas. Quando tiver um concerto dela aqui eu vou com certeza!
Wow ana really understands dynamics and feel ..so important in all styles from classical to metal she's a great teacher
Ana is the finest player I've ever seen. For her age she's incredible .
Só uma professora hein... FANTÁSTICO ter aula com essa DEUSA das cordas!
I am happy to have discovered this gem!
buenisimo. me encanto como enseña. como tocan la guitarra. felicidades. Dios los bendiga
.
ANA VIDOVIC VOSE ESELEBRIDADI SSO LOCO PELA SUAS MUSICAS
Fantástico!! E adorei a tradução, deu uma ajudinha apesar de entender ingles kkkk
To Tony Nugent;
The first piece is Domenico SCARLATTI: Sonata in A major, K208
Sorry, K322 Scarlatti had at least two Sonatas in A Major.
Que maravilla de mujer!
Enchanting
I think the first guitarist is a excellent player with great potential.....technically proficient under pressure which is a really good foundation to build from. He just needs to develop his feel....Ana breaks this down to technical elements (dynamics/ articulation etc which is technically correct ....but the 'missing spark' goes beyond the guitar and even music. He needs to goes out and fall in love, smell the roses, dance in the forest, grow spiritually as a person and bring this back into the music!
Colly Flour Yes. Also he just looks so shy. It must have been terrifying for him to present to such an amazing artist. It can be so hard to take criticism, let alone in front of an audience & ultimately on youtube. Years ago I knew a banjo player who also taught, & she had some buttons printed for her students (as a joke): "I did it better in practice."
+Denise Di Salvo so what you want him to do? snap out of it? some people are shy and cannot be helped, he is a good player and did better than many people criticizing him would. Also, it is bullshit about go and find your spirituality and all that soul crap. People are different, and this what he presents while he plays. Ana is around the same age, and portrays more "feeling", it has nothing to do with her having more spirituality and all that crap, is all about TALENT, there is a reason why she is so admired and has everything in one person, looks, personality, confidence, proficiency, technique, the perfect package, nerves of steel in public, no amount of practice can give your that, and you gotta work with what you have. No amount of bullshit spirituality seeking, meditation and wisdom will give this guy, what she obtained by having the right genes, mind, muscles, brain, etc
Denise Di Salvo English is not my first language, but I could write better if I wanted to. My comment is mostly directed to the first comment. I have been playing guitar for 14 years, so I have knowledge and experience on this subject. There are no such things as soul or spirituality. They are nothing but made-up terms to explain talent and certain personality/character traits. For example, many Asian women players get criticized for having no soul or feelings, mostly because they are introverted while inside they could be full of them. There is a reason why this girl is so admired and successful in the classical guitar world. Do you think all this guy needs to do is practice, find his "spirituality" and suddenly he will be as proficient as her? She is extremely talented, and no amount of training will get you to her level. She has the whole package. She has looks, confidence, nerves of steel, technique, talent, charisma, and so many other attributes, that play a huge role in guitar playing. Naturally, many will refuse to accept this realization, because it leaves them hopeless. They rather believe in HOPE than be cognizant of an unpleasant truth that negates that hope, even if such hope never materializes.
+Denise Di Salvo Plus one here, well said. Seriously, if I had to play for Ana Vidovic, I would be totally bricking it!
Plus, she covered a bunch of stuff. When I was playing seriously and taking lessons, I tried to take one thing from each lesson. However, in the master class setting, you want to take in as much as you can. It' can be really overwhelming.
Obviously latin lover has no idea about basic year 9 level psychology.....'nature vs nurture' .... Look it up and educate yourself.
Great guitarist ....
muito bom... obrigado>
Very good!
Gênia
Ótimo!
Same as piano, like Martine Krause said：On stage, you have to play 10 times louder and faster. Some people couldn't understand, why we need to play so loud? even in studio, music is all about perform, you need to communicate with your audience, if you can't reach the last row, they don't know what you are trying to "say", we always practice so loud, so much of deep tone, but all we get are complaint, especially in Singapore, i think most of the Singaporean don't even know the art and beautiful of music, they just pretend. Back to this, regardless what instrument that you learn, music are universe, we all taking about the same language, like Ana said, the sound projecting, deeper tone, more contrast and dynamic colour, articulation, all are essential music elements.
What's the first player playing?
❤️
a interrupção da tradução atrapalhou o masterclass, até parece q não deixava a Vidovic se expressar... mas ainda sim vale a pena assistir
His wrist tends to bend a lot. This may cause wrist pain in the long run. This happened to me. I wonder if that also affects him?
Small world :-) do you know this guitarist? Mr. Lam Vien? and still flying your RC planes at baylands mr. Bic ???? ruclips.net/video/mx7GRqhvvUM/видео.html
MrTrucTran
Not flying any more for a long time. Most of my planes are in different states of wreckage.
Mr. Truc, do I know you?
I don't know Lam Vien. He plays well.
Swine sometimes come here and post comments about the pearls they cannot see.
Anywhere I can get the sheets from?
tiemblan los alumnos...
Dynamics in harpsichord music? I'm sure harpsichordists expressive devices they use in place of crescendos
That's interesting, but doubling sounds will only raise the volume very modestly because the ear hears sound logrithmically, not linearly. Even so, I think the dynamic range would have been limited. I think the guitar is a good analogue for the harpsichord in that respect
Its's true, many people play Baroque music at the same level of volume, it shouldn't happen, Baroque music is so expressive, and before Renaissance we have lot of lyrical vocal music, there is no way we play Baroque music like a machine, expressiveless
tis my dream to have a lesson from her, sigh...........
oooh ghostie.......
not heard of him.
Andre York
If they said they were good guitarists i'd say 'yes sir' and beat a hasty retreat.
atrapalha um tradutor daquele jeito ali.
I think the first guitarist has a lot of hidden potential, but he completely lacks good ideas. It is so heavy and backwards. He has along way to go to gain artistic control, but Ana's input changed it for the better. Yet, he went back to his unfortunate tendencies right afterwards.
+ragnarkisten you want him to change in a couple of minutes? lmao
милашка
Ana Vidovic deu aula de como ser macho
Contrast the beautiful sound and power of her Jim Redgate guitar with his guitar which sounds as if it was made out of a discarded egg carton. He could do with a better guitar methinks.
+ergastule Ha, yep! My advice to people who ask what guitar to buy is "Whatever you like as long as it feels right... and costs at least $1000, ;o)
I never used to think that way until I got an Augustino Loprinzi. Within a couple of weeks it completely changed the way I play. A good instrument responds to even the most subtle changes in expression and attack. You don't have to push it to play louder. You can go from dolce to ponticelo by moving your hand just a few centimeters up the or down the strings and slightly varying the angle that you fingers address the uppers.
I don't think that a good instrument can make a poor player good, but a bad instrument can severely limit and even discourage a player with potential.
All that being said, I have had my instrument played by people who are of superior talent than me and been dumbfounded at how much more sound they can extract from the same instrument.
He needs better right hand angles. Essential full sound, more gallantly, even arrogant by contrast. Problem is he's not developed enough yet, he needs to essential whole of what she's showing him. He's got a sweet guitara though.
is so unpleasant for Ana to speak while the translator tries to interrupt her with a different language, and the student as well!
use a mic....
Faz o que ela tá falando, caramba!!
O andamento é uma pouco mais rápido e as cordas devem ser atacadas com mais rigor!!
Она хорошо?
Tube Oswald она милаш