This is almost similar to a Walstad style setup and hence no filter or CO2 has been used. It is meant to develop into a small thriving ecosystem. Heavy planting has been done on purpose and they will act as a natural filter for this Aquajar. Only a pair of shrimp has been housed here since the jar is small. Fishes should never be kept in such small setups. Also this Aquajar will need regular water changes and maintenance to keep the plants and livestock in good health. Fertiliser dosing will also be needed for plant growth.
Do you have any recommendations for a heater for a setup this size? I have a 1 gallon jar in looking to redo but can't trust the temperature in my office
I made something similar but without the soil only sand 😊😊😊and I used a tea pot! Only two shrimp one clam and two very mini Boraras maculata fish! They are very timid and small and they don't attack the shrimps, I use them to prevent some uninvited Aeolosoma hemprichii worm! And one very very tiny snail for cleaning! The teapot is doing very well! Still required regular 3/1 water change every day tho
Before you invest in this kind of thing do a cheap/free experiment that will reveal an important flaw in cylindrical tanks, the way refraction of light actually makes it hard to see it's inhabitants/contents. Use a large plastic jar first. With some life-forms from a nearby body of water. You will see.
Very true. I have a 2g shrimp jar that's cylindrical (dirted in true Walstad fashion), and the curve of the glass most definitely interferes with visual enjoyment. Makes it difficult to monitor the inhabitants, so I have to sit and shift position or turn it a bit to get a good look inside. Eventually I'll replace that jar with a small cube aquarium of similar size, so the sides are flat instead of curved like the jar. I'll repurpose the jar as a terrarium. The curve doesn't seem as disruptive when there's no water in them.
@@aididdat1749 it just pours along the sides and the sheet floats up. You can see the process a bit more clearly in this video ruclips.net/video/Ki1QRhNGgrQ/видео.html
El único problema que puedo decir de esta belleza de mini-acuario plantado es que son demasiadas la cantidad de plantas en ese espacio tan reducido, aunque su combinación crea realmente esa armonía, pero el problema real es que estas no se están quietas y empiezan a crecer y crecer, claro algunos dirán que solo es cuestión de podar y podar, pero bueno, habría que probar como funcionan estos pequeños experimentos.
It is extremely important to have very heavy planting in no filter setups because plants will be taking up the work of natural filtration. And yes frequent pruning would be needed for such setups and can even be an enjoyable activity for folks who love the hobby. I highly recommend the book - Ecology of the Planted aquarium by Diana Walstad.
i see you mention the walstad method but you seem to only use aquasoil and ada supplement. from my understanding the walstad method works very well because you use organic soil and you end up with a balanced ecosystem that need almost no maintenance. its been a while since i read the walstad book but it seems like the organic dirt is a big part of why it works very well.
You are right wrt to organic soil. The organic dirt I have access to here in the city has not yielded good results. In fact it destroyed my earlier setup which could be due to several other factors as well. My best bet right now is to go with aqua soil capped with sand. It has given some good results so far. So lets move forward and find out. It is also an organic soil extract so it should perform.
@@TheUrbanNemophilist its similar where i live but most of my local aquarium stores has tropica substrate which seems to just be normal soil thats safe for aquariums. i have several vases with tropica bottom substrate and aquasoil or sand on top. in my experience you get similar results but with potting soil vases last longer (like 4+years)
Brooooo!! Very cool...Love your builds, exquisite and beautiful. I must say, tho....Are the materials pricey!? If possible, might you provide links or info. on resources for plantings, soils, scape materials etc....for those new to your channel? Very much appreciated, thank you!
Thanks. ADA product pricings are a bit on the higher side but quality is top of the line. All materials are available online as well as in local auascaping stores.
This is awesome! Definitely feels like a good idea for a first attempt. Are there any lights that you can recommend? Amazon has too many options and a lot seem bad quality. Thank you!!
Thanks. The plants I am using are mostly low demand except the hairgrass. If you are using similar low demand plant species you can puck up a lamp with a 5-8 watt fluorescent bulb. Any other clip on aquascaping led light should also work
How you going to deal with those fast growing plants? i did this once but couldnt handle the plants , they grew up so fast so i eventually gave up. besides each time you trim the plant it develops more and more stem so i wonder what is your plan here . Can you help me? :)
sir whenever I add fish food in aquarium, after sometime the food goes to bottom and I can't see it because of the rocks, so will the fish be able to eat this in between stones? My stones are small in size and there are alot of it, I dont think so that the fish can push the tiny stone and eat the food. so what to do? should I removed these stones and replace it with something else? please any suggestion???
Avoid gravel and stones for substrate. Have a layer of aquasoil capped with a thick layer of sand. You can read the book Ecology of the planted aquarium by Diana Walstad to know more about fish tanks and how they work.
You can build without filter. You will need to test your water for kh gh and ammonia and adjust accordingly. Regular water changes will be needed. Plants help with natural filtration. Cleaning, trimming and maintenance will not be an issue once plants are rooted. Thanks
@@TerrAqua from reading the book using organic potting soil is a must and cant really be replaced with aquasoil. like a walstad vase/bowl/tank is different from a low tech planted vase/bowl/tank that uses aquasoil. you probably get similar results but the walstad method is sorta its own method where you cant change too much and still call it walstad imo. its been a while since reading the book though so i might be a bit wrong.
@TheUrbanNemophilist What do you do for water? Do you use filtered or distilled water in the aquariums? I also live in the city and have never owned a terrarium so 100% beginner :)
Experts say 5 dwarf shrimps per gallon. Invertebrates do not need as much swimming space as fishes. But space is one thing. Shrimp has a very low bioload and hence can thrive in smaller setups compared to fishes.
They can reach 1.5/2 cm so you should give them more than a gallon (about 4 litres), a shrimp tank is recommended to be a minimum of 5 gallon (about 20L) but 10 gallon (about 40L) is better to keep ph levels more easily stable. I keep my shrimp in a 100L tank and I have 30 in there with 4 kuhli loaches (be careful with kuhli loaches, only tank breed kuhli won’t eat shrimplets) and don’t plan to get many more shrimp in there. I’ll probably cap the tank at 40/45 but by the literati I should be able to keep around 200 in a tank my size but I don’t see how they’d like that, unless it had a shit ton of surface area and less height like breeders tanks.
@@TheUrbanNemophilist Walstad's book is EXCELLENT! Since I read that book, I've done all of my setups as dirted tanks with sand caps. Haven't had one fail yet. Truly is a wonderful read.
This is almost similar to a Walstad style setup and hence no filter or CO2 has been used. It is meant to develop into a small thriving ecosystem. Heavy planting has been done on purpose and they will act as a natural filter for this Aquajar. Only a pair of shrimp has been housed here since the jar is small. Fishes should never be kept in such small setups. Also this Aquajar will need regular water changes and maintenance to keep the plants and livestock in good health. Fertiliser dosing will also be needed for plant growth.
Do you have any recommendations for a heater for a setup this size? I have a 1 gallon jar in looking to redo but can't trust the temperature in my office
I made something similar but without the soil only sand 😊😊😊and I used a tea pot! Only two shrimp one clam and two very mini Boraras maculata fish! They are very timid and small and they don't attack the shrimps, I use them to prevent some uninvited Aeolosoma hemprichii worm! And one very very tiny snail for cleaning! The teapot is doing very well! Still required regular 3/1 water change every day tho
This video is so well done, from the music, to the fade-out, just a relaxing vid all the way around. 👊🏼
Thank you
Amazing, at 1st its look boring, but whe it add red leaf ,and the water gettimg clear, the jar looks amazing, soo fresh in my eyes ❤
Before you invest in this kind of thing do a cheap/free experiment that will reveal an important flaw in cylindrical tanks, the way refraction of light actually makes it hard to see it's inhabitants/contents. Use a large plastic jar first. With some life-forms from a nearby body of water. You will see.
Very true. I have a 2g shrimp jar that's cylindrical (dirted in true Walstad fashion), and the curve of the glass most definitely interferes with visual enjoyment. Makes it difficult to monitor the inhabitants, so I have to sit and shift position or turn it a bit to get a good look inside. Eventually I'll replace that jar with a small cube aquarium of similar size, so the sides are flat instead of curved like the jar. I'll repurpose the jar as a terrarium. The curve doesn't seem as disruptive when there's no water in them.
That is absolutely lovely. Beautiful little eco system 😘
Thanks. Glad you liked it.
Luar biasa natural 👍 dan menginspirasi 👍
Thanks
Very relaxing😌. I'm also a creator but your channel is on another level❤
Thanks
The pumice is an interesting choice...light and good for building height, but it will float...here's hoping the sand and aquasoil cooperate with you.
Simply stunning.
Thank you
Neat and simple.. Expecting update videos👍
Please more Shrimp living in luxury Thx 🙏🏿
Very impressed by the method of pouring water with that bubble sheet. How do you pierce it?
Thanks. I don’t pierce it. Just pour water over it.
@@TheUrbanNemophilist But how did the water pass through? You removed the plastic then.
@@aididdat1749 it just pours along the sides and the sheet floats up. You can see the process a bit more clearly in this video ruclips.net/video/Ki1QRhNGgrQ/видео.html
El único problema que puedo decir de esta belleza de mini-acuario plantado es que son demasiadas la cantidad de plantas en ese espacio tan reducido, aunque su combinación crea realmente esa armonía, pero el problema real es que estas no se están quietas y empiezan a crecer y crecer, claro algunos dirán que solo es cuestión de podar y podar, pero bueno, habría que probar como funcionan estos pequeños experimentos.
It is extremely important to have very heavy planting in no filter setups because plants will be taking up the work of natural filtration. And yes frequent pruning would be needed for such setups and can even be an enjoyable activity for folks who love the hobby. I highly recommend the book - Ecology of the Planted aquarium by Diana Walstad.
This is beautiful broo
Thanks
i see you mention the walstad method but you seem to only use aquasoil and ada supplement. from my understanding the walstad method works very well because you use organic soil and you end up with a balanced ecosystem that need almost no maintenance. its been a while since i read the walstad book but it seems like the organic dirt is a big part of why it works very well.
You are right wrt to organic soil. The organic dirt I have access to here in the city has not yielded good results. In fact it destroyed my earlier setup which could be due to several other factors as well. My best bet right now is to go with aqua soil capped with sand. It has given some good results so far. So lets move forward and find out. It is also an organic soil extract so it should perform.
@@TheUrbanNemophilist its similar where i live but most of my local aquarium stores has tropica substrate which seems to just be normal soil thats safe for aquariums. i have several vases with tropica bottom substrate and aquasoil or sand on top. in my experience you get similar results but with potting soil vases last longer (like 4+years)
@@TheUrbanNemophilist it looks very nice!
Brooooo!! Very cool...Love your builds, exquisite and beautiful. I must say, tho....Are the materials pricey!? If possible, might you provide links or info. on resources for plantings, soils, scape materials etc....for those new to your channel? Very much appreciated, thank you!
Thanks. ADA product pricings are a bit on the higher side but quality is top of the line. All materials are available online as well as in local auascaping stores.
One more pls💚
coming soon
Tout simplement magnifique 😍
Thanks
This is awesome! Definitely feels like a good idea for a first attempt. Are there any lights that you can recommend? Amazon has too many options and a lot seem bad quality. Thank you!!
Thanks. The plants I am using are mostly low demand except the hairgrass. If you are using similar low demand plant species you can puck up a lamp with a 5-8 watt fluorescent bulb. Any other clip on aquascaping led light should also work
@@TheUrbanNemophilist thank you!! 🙏🏻
Beautiful work.
I'm thinking about a similar setup, can you update how is the jar today?
Thanks. Overgrown
Great work lovley eco system! But how do you maintain the cleanliness?
Thanks. Water changes, glass cleanup and plant trim ups when needed. Small setups can be high maintenance.
Nice scape sir
Thank you
Bro, please post a video for how to make plant propagation box pls
Theres a moss propagation video on the channel. Can use similar setup for terrestrial moisture loving plants.
@@TheUrbanNemophilist bro, i have dobt whether activated charcoal is mandatory
@@Rraja3603 it works upto a point so use it if you have.
How you going to deal with those fast growing plants? i did this once but couldnt handle the plants , they grew up so fast so i eventually gave up. besides each time you trim the plant it develops more and more stem so i wonder what is your plan here . Can you help me? :)
Its good to have more plants because for no filter setups plants will help with filtration. I will have to keep up with trimming as well.
Super bro ❤
Thanks
sir whenever I add fish food in aquarium, after sometime the food goes to bottom and I can't see it because of the rocks, so will the fish be able to eat this in between stones? My stones are small in size and there are alot of it, I dont think so that the fish can push the tiny stone and eat the food. so what to do? should I removed these stones and replace it with something else? please any suggestion???
Avoid gravel and stones for substrate. Have a layer of aquasoil capped with a thick layer of sand. You can read the book Ecology of the planted aquarium by Diana Walstad to know more about fish tanks and how they work.
@@TheUrbanNemophilist thank you so much for quick reply Sir, I definitely try sand and aqua soil in the right way
❤
Beautiful!!! How are animals called?
Thanks. Shrimp
Magnifique 👍🌟👌
Thanks
I want to do this myself. Do you mind if I don't add a filter?
How do I clean the aquarium when there are too many plants in it?🌱🌱
You can build without filter. You will need to test your water for kh gh and ammonia and adjust accordingly. Regular water changes will be needed. Plants help with natural filtration. Cleaning, trimming and maintenance will not be an issue once plants are rooted. Thanks
@@TheUrbanNemophilist how do you change the water without dumping everything out and messing up the scene?
@@jessereising2238 siphon by using air tubing pre-filled with water. Shown in this video ruclips.net/video/Ki1QRhNGgrQ/видео.html
@@jessereising2238 siphon by using air tubing pre-filled with water. Shown in this video ruclips.net/video/Ki1QRhNGgrQ/видео.html
@@jessereising2238 A turkey baster also works well to remove water from such a small setup.
Can the shrimps live in that space without filter? With frequent water changes I assume?
Yes
@@TheUrbanNemophilist Τhanks!
What is the brand of the little light stand looks perfect for the size of the jar. Thank you.
Its a Nubios. Details in this video ruclips.net/video/_3-WPc6n-6A/видео.html
@@TheUrbanNemophilist Thank you again! I appreciate it.
Nyc vid…light stand source.?
Its a Nubios. Covered here ruclips.net/video/_3-WPc6n-6A/видео.html
Can this be done with only small stone chips and sand.
You will also need some soil so that plants get nutrients. You could however use epiphytic plants without soil and use liquid ferts.
Nice
Will the plants do well without Co2 🤔like the hair grass
Lets find out. Walstad says hairgrass can be grown using her method. All other plants are low demand
I am reading up about it
It says to use potting soil and no fertilizers, no filters and to avoid using hardscape
@@TerrAqua from reading the book using organic potting soil is a must and cant really be replaced with aquasoil. like a walstad vase/bowl/tank is different from a low tech planted vase/bowl/tank that uses aquasoil. you probably get similar results but the walstad method is sorta its own method where you cant change too much and still call it walstad imo.
its been a while since reading the book though so i might be a bit wrong.
@@oNorw Ok In the Video Aquasoil was used hence I was mentioning it
Do I need everything that you used or only the aquasoil and sand will work and how do you maintain the it?
just aquasoil is also fine
@TheUrbanNemophilist What do you do for water? Do you use filtered or distilled water in the aquariums? I also live in the city and have never owned a terrarium so 100% beginner :)
RO water
I'm completely ignorant about, shrimp doesn't need more space like fishes?
Experts say 5 dwarf shrimps per gallon. Invertebrates do not need as much swimming space as fishes. But space is one thing. Shrimp has a very low bioload and hence can thrive in smaller setups compared to fishes.
They can reach 1.5/2 cm so you should give them more than a gallon (about 4 litres), a shrimp tank is recommended to be a minimum of 5 gallon (about 20L) but 10 gallon (about 40L) is better to keep ph levels more easily stable.
I keep my shrimp in a 100L tank and I have 30 in there with 4 kuhli loaches (be careful with kuhli loaches, only tank breed kuhli won’t eat shrimplets) and don’t plan to get many more shrimp in there.
I’ll probably cap the tank at 40/45 but by the literati I should be able to keep around 200 in a tank my size but I don’t see how they’d like that, unless it had a shit ton of surface area and less height like breeders tanks.
Can you tell me what the lamp is? I would love to make a walstadstyle jar too.. Instead of shrimp.. DAPHNIA CULTURE?
Its a Nubios. More details here ruclips.net/video/_3-WPc6n-6A/видео.html
What about the 3.3L model? What would be best to put in that one? Thanks.
Snails and shrimp
What are the dimensions of that jar??
About 8 inch height and 6 inch diameter
Hey where can I buy the plants and shrimps in Mumbai?
You could check at your local aquascaping stores
Where do you live? How does this tank sustain without co2 injection
Recommended reading- Ecology of the planted aquarium by Diana Walstad
@@TheUrbanNemophilist okay. Will do. Do you live in the tropics or the colder climate?
@@vinodhd10 tropics
@@TheUrbanNemophilist thanks for your response. Will read that book. Are you from India?
@@TheUrbanNemophilist Walstad's book is EXCELLENT! Since I read that book, I've done all of my setups as dirted tanks with sand caps. Haven't had one fail yet. Truly is a wonderful read.
That shrimp will be dead in no time
Almost 3 weeks and doing great. Check out updates on my instagram.