Asalamoalaikum everyone. Here are the SUBTITLES that I have transcribed for non-Urdu/Hindi speakers. 0:00:08.800,0:00:11.600: The question: Do you feel that Islam
0:00:11.685,0:00:13.740 : treats men and women as equals?
0:00:14.180,0:00:19.100 : And, must a woman always act as per her husband's wishes?
0:00:19.100,0:00:22.920 : And, can she not even leave her home without her husband's approval?
0:00:23.540,0:00:26.200 : Do Islam's rules not imply that
0:00:26.200,0:00:29.180 : women are not as intelligent as men?
0:00:29.760,0:00:32.540 : And neither can be trusted?
0:00:32.540,0:00:36.980 : Based on how society perceived women in the 7th century.
0:00:37.140,0:00:42.940 : What changes should be implemented in the Shariah so that this situation is improved?
0:00:44.260,0:00:46.375 : In terms of everything that just has been stated,
0:00:46.375,0:00:47.965 : this is not found anywhere in Islam.
0:00:48.420,0:00:52.400 : Men and women are absolutely equal in terms of their makeup.
0:00:53.000,0:00:55.880 : Humans come from both men and women,
0:00:55.880,0:00:58.260 : Both have a very extraordinary rank,
0:00:58.260,0:01:01.500 : Both are equal as far as being a human is concerned.
0:01:01.700,0:01:06.240 : There is no difference between them in the moral sense.
0:01:06.740,0:01:10.640 : There can be no societal restriction placed on them either.
0:01:10.640,0:01:14.960 : A man can do as he pleases, just as a woman can do as she pleases.
0:01:14.960,0:01:19.040 : He can earn whatever education that he pleases, and she can earn whatever education that she pleases.
0:01:19.080,0:01:22.780 : They can fill whatever role in society that they please.
0:01:22.980,0:01:24.820 : There is absolutely no restriction.
0:01:25.320,0:01:27.840 : However: as far as the home is concerned,
0:01:28.100,0:01:29.980 : the home is an establishment.
0:01:30.400,0:01:32.060 : When this establishment is made,
0:01:32.120,0:01:34.180 : then the relationships that exist there
0:01:34.360,0:01:37.740 : have been given a difference in ranking.
0:01:37.835,0:01:40.815 : For instance, a mother and her son are not equal.
0:01:40.815,0:01:43.055 : The mother is at a higher rank.
0:01:43.420,0:01:45.780 : Similarly, a father and his daughter are not equal.
0:01:45.840,0:01:48.080 : The father is at a higher rank.
0:01:48.220,0:01:50.580 : In the same way, there is the relationship of a brother and sister.
0:01:50.660,0:01:53.320 : In terms of the relationship between the husband and wife,
0:01:53.500,0:01:56.900 : the husband has been made the head of the home.
0:01:57.080,0:02:01.260 : He has various responsibilities upon him (i.e. protection, provision).
Mashaallah subhanallah Allah hazrat Muhammad (pbuh) or Ali apse razi ho apko oor aala makam atta karain apki tamam mushkilat haal karain apko oor ilm say nawazay jannat k darwazay apke Liye kholay rahe or Allah nabi or Ali ki madad or mohabbat atta ho apko
Javed ghamadi is just love it allah aap ko sehat aur tandrusti day all time great for me I don't think any other better prayer than this prayer allah qabool farmaey aameen aurangzeb butt from Switzerland daska sialkot siranwali ❤
WE BESEECH God (ﷻ), in the name of His greatness which transcends all limits & His munificence which outruns all measures. To pour upon us the light of guidance & to remove from us the darkness of ignorance & wrong-doing; To make us like those who saw the truth as truth, and chose to follow it & those who saw falsehood as false¬hood, and decided to eschew it; To bestow upon us the felicity which He has promised to His saints and prophets; To initiate us, on our departure from the House of Delusion, into that happiness the height of which cannot be scanned by the understanding, and the extent of which cannot be conjured up by the imagination; To give us, when after deliverance from the horrors of the Doomsday we approach the bliss of Paradise, "that which no eye ever saw, no ear ever heard, and which never occurred to the heart of man; and To invest with peace and bless our Prophet Muhammad, the Chosen One, the best one of all mankind; and his noble descendants and pure companions, who were the keys to guidance, and the lamps lit in the darkness. It is observed that there is a class of secularists who believe in their superiority to others because of their greater intelligence and insight. They have abandoned the religious duties faith imposes on its followers. They laugh at the positive commandments of religion which enjoin the performance of acts of devotion, and the abstinence from forbidden things. They defy the injunctions of the Sacred Law. Not only do they overstep the limits prescribed by it, but some have renounced the Faith altogether, and some by having indulged in diverse speculations, wherein they followed the example of those people who "turn men aside from the path of God, and seek to render it crooked; and some independent scholars slander the Quran of double standards, for instances, Quran 33;59 O Prophet, speak unto thy wives and thy daughters, (((and the wives of the true believers))), that they cast their outer garments over them when they walk abroad; this will be more proper, that they may be known to be matrons of reputation, and may not be affronted by unseemly words or actions. God is gracious and merciful.The independent scholar Javed Ghamidi sinfully asserts that the divine Order of draping is for Prophets PBUH wives only & is not for the other Muslim women, despite, a clear express statement that commands the messenger [pbuh] to tell your wives & your daughters and women of Believers to drape [cover] themselves with outer garment when they go out. ." The heresy of these people has its basis only in an uncritical acceptance - like that of the Jews & Christians - of whatever one hears from others or sees all around. They could not avoid it; for they are the progeny of the secular atmosphere & their enslaved Hindu ancestors had pursued no better ways. In the second place, such heresy results from theoretical inquiries which are the outcome of stumbling - skeptically, misguidedly, and stupidly - upon fanciful notions raised by the People of willful Innovations. The heretics in our times have heard the westerner morally bankrupt civilization with materialistic advancement & the awe-inspiring names of people like Socrates, Hippocrates, Plato, Aristotle, etc. They have been deceived by the exaggerations made by the followers of these philosophers - exaggerations to the effect that the ancient masters possessed extraordinary intellectual powers: that the principles they have discovered are unquestionable: that the mathematical, logical, physical & metaphysical sciences developed by them are the most profound: that their excellent intelligence justifies their bold attempts to discover the Hidden Things by deductive methods; and that with all the subtlety of their intelligence and the originality of their accomplishments they repudiated the authority of religious laws: denied the validity of the positive contents of historical religions, and believed that all such things are only sanctimonious lies and trivialities. When such stuff was dinned into their ears and struck a responsive chord in their hearts, the heretics in our times thought that it would be an honor to join the company of great thinkers for which the renunciation of their faith would prepare them. Emulation of the example of the Secular Westerners learned held out to them the promise of an elevated status far above the general level of common men. They flattered themselves with the idea that it would do them honor not to accept even truth uncritically. But they had actually begun to accept secularism falsehood uncritically. They failed to see that a change from one kind of intellectual bondage to another is only self-deception, a stupidity. What position in this world of God can be baser than that of one who thinks that it is honorable to renounce the truth of the final divine revelation which is accepted on authority, and then relapses into an acceptance of falsehood which is still a matter of blind faith, unaided by independent inquiry? Such a scandalous attitude is never taken by the unsophisticated masses of men; for they have an instinctive aversion to following the example of misguided genius. Surely, their simplicity is nearer to salvation than sterile genius can be. For total blindness is less dangerous than oblique vision Please remember Muslim & secular Muslims are not equal; Secular dread God but joy in their passions, God will not show favor to the passion worshippers. God manifest in his works of creation & providence; the righteous shall be rewarded. Muhammad pbuh, the first Muslim, must exhibit the pure religion of God. Secularists who repent shall be rewarded. Muhammad pbuh cannot deliver the reprobate. God revealed in the growth and decay of Nature. Muhammad pbuh & the infidels shall debate before the Lord
MashaAllah The women asked, ‘O Messenger of Allah, what is deficient in our intelligence and religious commitment?’ He said, ‘Is not the testimony of two women equal to the testimony of one man?’ They said, ‘Yes.’ He said, ‘This is the deficiency in her intelligence. Is it not true that a woman can neither pray nor fast during her menses?’ The women said, ‘Yes.’ He said, ‘This is the deficiency in her religious commitment.’” (Narrated by al-Bukhari, 304)
I think it would be a good idea to add subtitles - I have started them, so others please join in if you can. Update: Okay, I am done the subtitles for this video.
Politically correct but impractical answer. The kind of equity he talks about has made relationships so fragile in West. Contradicts the essence of Quran and Hadith too.
If both can earn, then why men are responsible for the home's economic stability.For what purpose woman spend her earning other than family.This is a logical question.Men and women can go with equity, islam also talk about equity and justice
He is responsible because women get pregnant and bear the pain of child birth. Then bear the post delivery pain and raise the child. (not sure if women are allowed to earn or not but this is why he mainly spends on her, also because she gives him intimacy.) Also, the man spends on his children because children are mainly called his. They are his direct responsibility.
Pregnancy is just one case the woman face. Couple (both compliment each other. Both has roles. And both will share money with each other, if both are earner. Both should spend on equality basis, if a woman really want equality.
@@Blendvision608 How I understand this according to Islam is the kids belong to the man. The woman not only gives her body to her husband but also bears one of the most painful pains to give birth to his children. When women is giving birth, what is the man doing equal to her in the marriage? This is my understanding. The only time she should be spending money is when she does not give birth to his children. In this union, she is not taking up something so extra ordinary on herself. But if the man asks her to contribute equally he would need to equally contribute to household chores. This is simple case of justice. Men spend on the children because they are his. On the women cause she is literally taking up worst of the pains, the effects of which won't disappear from her body. Even Quran mentions about the pain of the childbirth.
It is not about "both can earn so should both contribute equally". It is what each partner does in a marriage. Both should contribute equally in their efforts. To take money from a woman who gives birth to your children by sacrificing her body and contracting many problems because of it, is complete injustice.
It’s very simple if you read Quran it says something similar That Allah is making a Khalifa ( a Rajul/male/Mard) on Earth and after Making Adam Aly he salat o Salam his wife was made... Mard was made first as Khalifa ( Aurat ko queen bana k nahi bheja giya tha) and the Jin were created before them. And He taught all names to Adam and the Malaika did sajda to Adam. how simple answer you want? Fear Allah we all are answerable to Allah one day (applies only for those who believe in Quran even in Bible) Please finish this argument read Quran think on it and you will find answers Insha’Allah
He did not created adam as khalifah he created all human beings as his khaifah read surah Fatir....Men and women are equal in islam read surah imran verse 195 and Surah hujrat verse 13..... Dont be ignorant....i can give u many reference from quran which says men and women are equal.....read Surah Imran verse 195 Surah nisa verse 128 surah nahl verse 97 surah tauba verse 71 and 72 surah Ghafir verse 40 surah al fatha versr 48 surah Hadid verse 12 and 18 surah layl verse 3 syrah Nisa verse 1 surah ahzaab verse 73 surah Buruj and manyy more....... Surah Najm verse 45 He created pairs male and female...
According to Islamqa website, there are four men responsible for a woman's expenditure in an order. If she is unmarried then her father and if father has died, her brother. If she is married, her husband. If she gets widowed or divorced then her son, father or brother. (please check the order from the authentic site). This is the only solution in a society where women are not allowed to work. Because theese mahrams can simply refuse to take her responsibility after she gets widowed or divorced, my opinion is that women should be made to learn concrete, meaningful skills that they can utilise if such a situation arises where her male relatives refuse to support her or if they support, they do so with making her realise their favour upon her or give her so little that does not fulfil her needs.
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
Ma shaa Allah...u r my mentor...May Allah give u patience and strength to keep up this beautiful service of Islam..
Asalamoalaikum everyone. Here are the SUBTITLES that I have transcribed for non-Urdu/Hindi speakers.
0:00:08.800,0:00:11.600: The question: Do you feel that Islam
0:00:11.685,0:00:13.740
: treats men and women as equals?
0:00:14.180,0:00:19.100
: And, must a woman always act as per her husband's wishes?
0:00:19.100,0:00:22.920
: And, can she not even leave her home without her husband's approval?
0:00:23.540,0:00:26.200
: Do Islam's rules not imply that
0:00:26.200,0:00:29.180
: women are not as intelligent as men?
0:00:29.760,0:00:32.540
: And neither can be trusted?
0:00:32.540,0:00:36.980
: Based on how society perceived women in the 7th century.
0:00:37.140,0:00:42.940
: What changes should be implemented in the Shariah so that this situation is improved?
0:00:44.260,0:00:46.375
: In terms of everything that just has been stated,
0:00:46.375,0:00:47.965
: this is not found anywhere in Islam.
0:00:48.420,0:00:52.400
: Men and women are absolutely equal in terms of their makeup.
0:00:53.000,0:00:55.880
: Humans come from both men and women,
0:00:55.880,0:00:58.260
: Both have a very extraordinary rank,
0:00:58.260,0:01:01.500
: Both are equal as far as being a human is concerned.
0:01:01.700,0:01:06.240
: There is no difference between them in the moral sense.
0:01:06.740,0:01:10.640
: There can be no societal restriction placed on them either.
0:01:10.640,0:01:14.960
: A man can do as he pleases, just as a woman can do as she pleases.
0:01:14.960,0:01:19.040
: He can earn whatever education that he pleases, and she can earn whatever education that she pleases.
0:01:19.080,0:01:22.780
: They can fill whatever role in society that they please.
0:01:22.980,0:01:24.820
: There is absolutely no restriction.
0:01:25.320,0:01:27.840
: However: as far as the home is concerned,
0:01:28.100,0:01:29.980
: the home is an establishment.
0:01:30.400,0:01:32.060
: When this establishment is made,
0:01:32.120,0:01:34.180
: then the relationships that exist there
0:01:34.360,0:01:37.740
: have been given a difference in ranking.
0:01:37.835,0:01:40.815
: For instance, a mother and her son are not equal.
0:01:40.815,0:01:43.055
: The mother is at a higher rank.
0:01:43.420,0:01:45.780
: Similarly, a father and his daughter are not equal.
0:01:45.840,0:01:48.080
: The father is at a higher rank.
0:01:48.220,0:01:50.580
: In the same way, there is the relationship of a brother and sister.
0:01:50.660,0:01:53.320
: In terms of the relationship between the husband and wife,
0:01:53.500,0:01:56.900
: the husband has been made the head of the home.
0:01:57.080,0:02:01.260
: He has various responsibilities upon him (i.e. protection, provision).
0:02:01.555,0:02:04.705
: A woman can work,
0:02:04.705,0:02:06.900
: she can do as she pleases; there isn't a restriction upon her.
0:02:07.020,0:02:10.615
: However, she is not responsible for fulfilling the responsibilities of the home.
0:02:10.620,0:02:14.380
: In the Islamic Shariah, this responsibility has been given to the man.
0:02:14.380,0:02:16.260
: For this reason,
0:02:16.260,0:02:21.100
: the woman has been asked to maintain an attitude of support,
0:02:21.100,0:02:23.120
: and not one of rebellion.
0:02:23.200,0:02:25.480
: These are the teachings of the religion.
0:02:25.560,0:02:27.900
: Ideas such as, they cannot leave the home
0:02:27.940,0:02:29.900
: or they cannot work
0:02:30.220,0:02:32.800
: have not been stated anywhere.
0:02:32.800,0:02:35.115
: This has not been mentioned anywhere.
0:02:35.120,0:02:39.360
: We have been taught to live with them in harmony and respect.
0:02:39.360,0:02:40.660
: The Quran says to
0:02:40.660,0:02:50.980
: Go about your affairs as per your times, as per your society and as per the ways of good people.
0:02:51.460,0:02:54.800
: Obviously, there will be a bit of difference in terms of culture.
0:02:54.940,0:02:59.160
: There will be a bit of difference in terms of tribal life.
0:02:59.420,0:03:01.660
: Moral standards are constantly being changed.
0:03:01.660,0:03:03.520
: Therefore, today's moral standards are different (from before),
0:03:03.520,0:03:09.580
: And God has taught us that as moral standards change with the times,
0:03:09.580,0:03:11.700
: we should also improve our behaviour.
0:03:11.720,0:03:17.680
: The principle to understand is that the husband has the responsibility of being the head of the home.
0:03:18.160,0:03:21.900
: In the scenario in which there isn't a man present in the home
0:03:22.160,0:03:24.300
: and there is only a mother to assume the responsibilities of the home
0:03:24.300,0:03:26.480
: then the mother will be of higher rank than her sons.
0:03:26.780,0:03:31.000
: For this reason, a difference does not exist on the basis of gender.
0:03:31.300,0:03:34.780
: Rather, the difference exists on the basis of relationships.
0:03:34.780,0:03:40.960
: The principle in Islam is that all of humanity is equal in the moral sense
0:03:40.960,0:03:42.720
: However, the relationships are not equal.
0:03:42.820,0:03:46.860
: A teacher isn't merely his student's friend, but moreso his father figure.
0:03:47.620,0:03:50.935
: The title of a father possesses significant value in itself.
0:03:50.935,0:03:53.625
: The title of a mother is even greater in value than of the father.
0:03:53.760,0:03:58.000
: As far as relationships are concerned, we do not believe that everyone is equal.
0:03:58.340,0:04:04.900
: In our view, the beauty of humanity exists in these differences between relationships.
0:04:04.900,0:04:09.000
: And this is what exists in Islamic law.
0:04:09.140,0:04:12.720
: It is found in God's book and has been stated by God's messenger.
0:04:13.080,0:04:17.920
: As for the things that people claim, they are not found in the Quran nor in the hadiths. Nowhere.
Masha’Allah may Allah give ajar for this, thanks you so much. 😊
@@ImSadiaNadeem JazakAllah for your kind words!
Mashaallah subhanallah Allah hazrat Muhammad (pbuh) or Ali apse razi ho apko oor aala makam atta karain apki tamam mushkilat haal karain apko oor ilm say nawazay jannat k darwazay apke Liye kholay rahe or Allah nabi or Ali ki madad or mohabbat atta ho apko
Javed ghamadi is just love it allah aap ko sehat aur tandrusti day all time great for me I don't think any other better prayer than this prayer allah qabool farmaey aameen aurangzeb butt from Switzerland daska sialkot siranwali ❤
I really appreciate from the bottom of my ❤️ thank you sir
Well explained. Stay blessed.
To the point answer. Best explanation. May you live long life sir
JazakAllah istaz👍❤
I always look for your explainations !
WE BESEECH God (ﷻ), in the name of His greatness which transcends all limits & His munificence which outruns all measures. To pour upon us the light of guidance & to remove from us the darkness of ignorance & wrong-doing; To make us like those who saw the truth as truth, and chose to follow it & those who saw falsehood as false¬hood, and decided to eschew it; To bestow upon us the felicity which He has promised to His saints and prophets; To initiate us, on our departure from the House of Delusion, into that happiness the height of which cannot be scanned by the understanding, and the extent of which cannot be conjured up by the imagination; To give us, when after deliverance from the horrors of the Doomsday we approach the bliss of Paradise, "that which no eye ever saw, no ear ever heard, and which never occurred to the heart of man; and To invest with peace and bless our Prophet Muhammad, the Chosen One, the best one of all mankind; and his noble descendants and pure companions, who were the keys to guidance, and the lamps lit in the darkness. It is observed that there is a class of secularists who believe in their superiority to others because of their greater intelligence and insight. They have abandoned the religious duties faith imposes on its followers. They laugh at the positive commandments of religion which enjoin the performance of acts of devotion, and the abstinence from forbidden things. They defy the injunctions of the Sacred Law. Not only do they overstep the limits prescribed by it, but some have renounced the Faith altogether, and some by having indulged in diverse speculations, wherein they followed the example of those people who "turn men aside from the path of God, and seek to render it crooked; and some independent scholars slander the Quran of double standards, for instances, Quran 33;59 O Prophet, speak unto thy wives and thy daughters, (((and the wives of the true believers))), that they cast their outer garments over them when they walk abroad; this will be more proper, that they may be known to be matrons of reputation, and may not be affronted by unseemly words or actions. God is gracious and merciful.The independent scholar Javed Ghamidi sinfully asserts that the divine Order of draping is for Prophets PBUH wives only & is not for the other Muslim women, despite, a clear express statement that commands the messenger [pbuh] to tell your wives & your daughters and women of Believers to drape [cover] themselves with outer garment when they go out. ." The heresy of these people has its basis only in an uncritical acceptance - like that of the Jews & Christians - of whatever one hears from others or sees all around. They could not avoid it; for they are the progeny of the secular atmosphere & their enslaved Hindu ancestors had pursued no better ways. In the second place, such heresy results from theoretical inquiries which are the outcome of stumbling - skeptically, misguidedly, and stupidly - upon fanciful notions raised by the People of willful Innovations. The heretics in our times have heard the westerner morally bankrupt civilization with materialistic advancement & the awe-inspiring names of people like Socrates, Hippocrates, Plato, Aristotle, etc. They have been deceived by the exaggerations made by the followers of these philosophers - exaggerations to the effect that the ancient masters possessed extraordinary intellectual powers: that the principles they have discovered are unquestionable: that the mathematical, logical, physical & metaphysical sciences developed by them are the most profound: that their excellent intelligence justifies their bold attempts to discover the Hidden Things by deductive methods; and that with all the subtlety of their intelligence and the originality of their accomplishments they repudiated the authority of religious laws: denied the validity of the positive contents of historical religions, and believed that all such things are only sanctimonious lies and trivialities. When such stuff was dinned into their ears and struck a responsive chord in their hearts, the heretics in our times thought that it would be an honor to join the company of great thinkers for which the renunciation of their faith would prepare them. Emulation of the example of the Secular Westerners learned held out to them the promise of an elevated status far above the general level of common men. They flattered themselves with the idea that it would do them honor not to accept even truth uncritically. But they had actually begun to accept secularism falsehood uncritically. They failed to see that a change from one kind of intellectual bondage to another is only self-deception, a stupidity. What position in this world of God can be baser than that of one who thinks that it is honorable to renounce the truth of the final divine revelation which is accepted on authority, and then relapses into an acceptance of falsehood which is still a matter of blind faith, unaided by independent inquiry? Such a scandalous attitude is never taken by the unsophisticated masses of men; for they have an instinctive aversion to following the example of misguided genius. Surely, their simplicity is nearer to salvation than sterile genius can be. For total blindness is less dangerous than oblique vision Please remember Muslim & secular Muslims are not equal; Secular dread God but joy in their passions, God will not show favor to the passion worshippers. God manifest in his works of creation & providence; the righteous shall be rewarded. Muhammad pbuh, the first Muslim, must exhibit the pure religion of God. Secularists who repent shall be rewarded. Muhammad pbuh cannot deliver the reprobate. God revealed in the growth and decay of Nature. Muhammad pbuh & the infidels shall debate before the Lord
Very nicely explained everything
Beautifully explained!!!!
Excellent and logical answer as always
Great answer
MashaAllah
The women asked, ‘O Messenger of Allah, what is deficient in our intelligence and religious commitment?’ He said, ‘Is not the testimony of two women equal to the testimony of one man?’ They said, ‘Yes.’ He said, ‘This is the deficiency in her intelligence. Is it not true that a woman can neither pray nor fast during her menses?’ The women said, ‘Yes.’ He said, ‘This is the deficiency in her religious commitment.’”
(Narrated by al-Bukhari, 304)
Koi bata sakta hai javed sahab ki kitabh Mizan Barcelona mai mil sakti hai. Kya yeh angrezi mai hai
Ye urdu aur english me ha you can order through Al-mawrid's website easily .
You can find the book online in English (and Urdu I believe) as PDF.
MashaAllah
I think it would be a good idea to add subtitles - I have started them, so others please join in if you can.
Update: Okay, I am done the subtitles for this video.
😂😂😂
❤❤❤❤
Good reply
Great
Politically correct but impractical answer. The kind of equity he talks about has made relationships so fragile in West. Contradicts the essence of Quran and Hadith too.
Go about your affairs as per your times, as per your society and as per the ways of good people.
❤
If both can earn, then why men are responsible for the home's economic stability.For what purpose woman spend her earning other than family.This is a logical question.Men and women can go with equity, islam also talk about equity and justice
He is responsible because women get pregnant and bear the pain of child birth. Then bear the post delivery pain and raise the child. (not sure if women are allowed to earn or not but this is why he mainly spends on her, also because she gives him intimacy.) Also, the man spends on his children because children are mainly called his. They are his direct responsibility.
Pregnancy is just one case the woman face. Couple (both compliment each other. Both has roles. And both will share money with each other, if both are earner. Both should spend on equality basis, if a woman really want equality.
@@Blendvision608 How I understand this according to Islam is the kids belong to the man. The woman not only gives her body to her husband but also bears one of the most painful pains to give birth to his children. When women is giving birth, what is the man doing equal to her in the marriage?
This is my understanding.
The only time she should be spending money is when she does not give birth to his children. In this union, she is not taking up something so extra ordinary on herself. But if the man asks her to contribute equally he would need to equally contribute to household chores.
This is simple case of justice.
Men spend on the children because they are his. On the women cause she is literally taking up worst of the pains, the effects of which won't disappear from her body. Even Quran mentions about the pain of the childbirth.
It is not about "both can earn so should both contribute equally". It is what each partner does in a marriage. Both should contribute equally in their efforts.
To take money from a woman who gives birth to your children by sacrificing her body and contracting many problems because of it, is complete injustice.
Great👍 so many unislamic practices we do
Hum logun ne aaj tak Islam kya samja tha
matlb orat mard kie ijazat k baghair ghar say bahar ja skti hai
It’s very simple if you read Quran it says something similar
That Allah is making a Khalifa ( a Rajul/male/Mard) on Earth and after Making Adam Aly he salat o Salam his wife was made...
Mard was made first as Khalifa ( Aurat ko queen bana k nahi bheja giya tha) and the Jin were created before them.
And He taught all names to Adam and the Malaika did sajda to Adam.
how simple answer you want? Fear Allah we all are answerable to Allah one day
(applies only for those who believe in Quran even in Bible)
Please finish this argument
read Quran think on it and you will find answers Insha’Allah
He did not created adam as khalifah he created all human beings as his khaifah read surah Fatir....Men and women are equal in islam read surah imran verse 195 and Surah hujrat verse 13..... Dont be ignorant....i can give u many reference from quran which says men and women are equal.....read
Surah Imran verse 195
Surah nisa verse 128
surah nahl verse 97
surah tauba verse 71 and 72
surah Ghafir verse 40
surah al fatha versr 48
surah Hadid verse 12 and 18
surah layl verse 3
syrah Nisa verse 1
surah ahzaab verse 73
surah Buruj
and manyy more....... Surah Najm verse 45 He created pairs male and female...
Is a brother responsible for his sister's expenses?
According to Islamqa website, there are four men responsible for a woman's expenditure in an order. If she is unmarried then her father and if father has died, her brother. If she is married, her husband. If she gets widowed or divorced then her son, father or brother. (please check the order from the authentic site).
This is the only solution in a society where women are not allowed to work.
Because theese mahrams can simply refuse to take her responsibility after she gets widowed or divorced, my opinion is that women should be made to learn concrete, meaningful skills that they can utilise if such a situation arises where her male relatives refuse to support her or if they support, they do so with making her realise their favour upon her or give her so little that does not fulfil her needs.