How should we assess The Washington Post article on the Pannun plot?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 1 май 2024
- Join us live at 5.30 p.m. (8.00 a.m. in Washington DC) to hear Daniel Markey, Senior Advisor at the United States Institute of Peace, analyze The Washington Post’s claims about the alleged attempt by Indian officials to assassinate Gurpatwant Singh Pannun? Does this have the hallmark of Indian state sanction? Has The Post convincingly established a link to the then RAW Chief and to the present NSA? What should we make of The Post’s comments about the Prime Minister? Does The Post provide convincing evidence of RAW’s involvement in Australia, Germany and Britain? And what impact is all of this likely to have on how the Biden Administration views the Modi Government? Join us live at 5.30 p.m. to hear Daniel Markey’s answers.
He lost me at the US has a legal framework for assaniations....love it how such things can be said with a straight face !!
well perhaps you should find yourself, straighten your face and take him seriously especially since modi's government handled the botched assassination plot of Pannun like a 16 year old on a bad prom date.
@@bhishammansukhani3469
Yes, Gandhian India is fast catching up both with Economy and in Geo Politics.
Take care.
@@dhruvnarayan8169 as in catching up in what way. Finding new ways to embarrass itself on tjr international stage. The vishwa guru is killing it, man. He is protecting the mangal sutra and stopping the war. Splendid
@@bhishammansukhani3469
Take care.
@@dhruvnarayan8169 excellent answer
Bitter but true ji
Modi thinks RAW is MOSSAD.
Just like any kid thinks himself to be Salman Khan & wants to get into a brawl !!
They don’t do this kind of stuff to the citizens of the friendly democracies
@@harsingh3702 No Mossad can go out of control and nobody seems to mind that much bit like the Russians though with them its more nothing you can do about it
Even Mossad used to think they were KGB in the late 40s.
Later they became one.
@@dipjyotimitra186 That's right ! Think Positive, yeah ?
You are an inspiration to many sir, unlike those sycophants who do just their bosses want throwing journalistic objectivity to the wind. One among the very few bold brave fearless journalist
Very important talk.....
Karan sir, your interviews scare me to no end. 🥺
I now understand the true meaning of : Ignorance is Bliss . 😟
Brilliant
@ Karan Thapar - what value is your line of questioning bringing to your audience at large? You seem to have the same leading tone as that with the NYPost author posted in India.
You are one of the best journalist which gives insight to public....
This govt can be characterized by just one word - incompetent. Did you see how he scoffed at the agents capability?
Raw is no Mossad.
😂😂😂😂😂
u r right RAW is better
While the interview provides insightful analysis from a U.S. perspective, a more rounded and fair assessment would benefit from incorporating detailed Indian viewpoints, considering India's own strategic, legal, and ethical frameworks, and acknowledging the complex interplay of regional security dynamics that influence decisions in New Delhi. This inclusion would provide a clearer, more equitable view of the bilateral challenges and opportunities facing both nations.
In this episode, Karan Thappar has proven to be the most useless anchor in any formal or informal media put together.
@@shielarobertsKaran Thapar doesn't really care about journalistic principles or India he is a businessman using india is a market.
Thanks
You pay for an anti-India rhetoric! OMG
In india accountability in india gvtments has never had been.
India's foreign policy has proven to be Narendra Modi's Achilles heel. Time and again he has been found wanting. Instead of blaming RAW for its brazenness, it is India's totalitarian leader who should be questioned in this regard.
The problem is perhaps Modi confuses between his domestic and global audiences; he can get away with muscular and questionable policies at home but global leaders aren't likely to be pushovers.
@@Asterix0110It is lawlessness he perpetrates, very dangerous for India.
Mahangai aur Bhrashtachaar Aam Janta ko Rulaa Rahee hai aur Kasht Pahuncha Rahee Hai.---- AJAM, Buxar, Bihar.
Ajam why you changed the name sanjay dubey
@@richardskingFind Holes in his argument. Personal insults just make you look like a loser.
@@harsingh3702 not doing any personal attack, but see hE has written His name as ajam, but in Hus profile his name is Sanjay dubey, he is an imposter, Muslim with Hindu name and talking about mahangai and bhrastachar, and you are asking me to not do any personal attack,🙄😏
India had got many criminals extradited from foreign countries in the past through international laws. What was the need of doing all this.
Extraditions are legally fought in courtrooms where one needs proof. Simply labelling your political enemies as “terrorists” or anti-nationals doesn’t really cut it …
Because Panun is a CIA asset to prick India
I am not ashamed if RAW had done it. After all US went after Osama. When countries sponsor terrrorism (under garb of freedom of speech and a law framework which biases towarrds them), they need to be countered in equal terms. We have to be bold to tell them off. Much as BJP confuses Nationalism as equivalence of supporting BJP, Karan seems to have confused as well, his anti-BJP posture should not encourage him to put down India.
I'm a little ashamed because they got caught red handed doing it. I don't think the world will look at RAW with more respect now this news is out. I'm praying now that our intelligence agencies don't get mentioned in the comedy shows in US.
@@aakashdeepsarkar9503 Actually, US and its Citizen now worried. Because they have also been caught supporting Khalistan against India. That is good. So that is the real humour in US.
Quite poor you get the R&AW's chief name wrong. Equally poor that you keep saying RAW. It is R&AW.
But then you'd be forgetting the oxford comma. So its really R&,AW or should that be rather R.&,A.W. I'm going to have to discuss with the committee that decides these matters and get back to you.
Sir I'm unemployed
But i have researched west asia and Europe very deeply
I may not be helpful to you on money but i assure you i will definitely help you on research
Why did the Indian government NOT "confuse the issue" and say that they were conducting a training routine - without a kill command there is no formal assassination mission? There could be a rogue agent who did not follow policy properly but the idea was a "realistic" training mission all along.
A concocted case handed over to the hoodwinks in the US press to keep them occupied. Even the questions you ask are frankly hideous!
An individual working to split the country and how do you deal with him..?
You have to finish him or what..?
Fearless has to part with .......
When incompetency is the hallmark of this regime.
Criminalty is more like it.
its "R&AW" Mr.Thapar not "RAW". Thank you kindly
Just to add to my previous the ampersand is silent.
When Karan Thapar is concerned, we are headed in right direction
Seems Pannu and Thapar are brothers determined to brake the country
What a colonial mindset.....just invite a random white person and believe whatever he is saying.
❤❤❤
Thapar Saab, I think we're doing America's part of thinking about this matter
This is the failure of our agencies.
The agencies have become rouge.
Karan Thapar not asking right question. Very sad. He has already come to the conclusion that India is implicated
Karan sir,
Can you ask one question in next interview
Why USA and its allies give citizenship to people who are recognized as terrorists, most wanted by other countries
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Public, voters need to ask for “transparency” from regime, guest emphasizes as host suggests.
Transparency for Spy agency? 🙂
Government operates with tax payers’ money, public, as taxpayer is entitled to know the details of that operation of all government
agencies as they fund their existence!
चुनाव आयोग ने ११ दिन बाद वोटिंग ६-७% बढ़ा के जारी किये मोदी के कहने पर- याने विपक्ष ने ठीक से विरोध नहीं किया तो मोदी की जीत, और अगर भयंकर विरोध किया तो चुनाव स्थगित होगा ,तब भी मोदी को फ़ायदा क्योंकि अभी तो माहौल १००% उनके ख़िलाफ़ है तो उनको समय मिल जायेगा गरम मुद्दे ठंडे करने के लिये ॥ याने चित भी मेरी और पट भी मेरी-
हारने के कारण अभी से ढूंढ रखो.मुहं छुपाने को जगह भी तो चाहिए.
@@dhruvnarayan8169 10-11 दिन लेट करने और वोटिंग numbers न बताने(सिर्फ़ %) की धांधली और चुनाव आयुक्त को बिना सुप्रीम कोर्ट के मुख्य न्यायाधीश के नियुक्त करने संसद में क़ानून पास करने की तानाशाही के बारे में कुछ नहीं बोलना चाहोगे ??मोदी जैसे सिर्फ़ एकतरफ़ा बात करने की आदत उनके सभी अंधभक्तों को पड़ गई है ॥पहले जैसे १ दिन में वोटिंग की डिटेल क्यों नहीं इंटरनेट पर डाली ?? मुँह तो १० सालों से मोदी छुपाते फिर रहा है खुले में पत्रकारों से बात करने से -पुलवामा,मणिपुर,रातों रात ED,CBI, ECs की नियुक्ति, लद्दाख(चीन ४००० वर्ग किलोमीटर कब्जा), अदानी(हिंडनबर्ग), बृजभूषण, प्रज्वल रेवन्ना, इलेक्टोरल बॉण्ड, पीएम केयर फण्ड, किसान आंदोलन ,कोवेक्सिन ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,??
@@dhruvnarayan8169 10-11 दिन लेट करने और वोटिंग numbers न बताने(सिर्फ़ %) की धांधली और चुनाव आयुक्त को बिना सुप्रीम कोर्ट के मुख्य न्यायाधीश के नियुक्त करने संसद में क़ानून पास करने की तानाशाही के बारे में कुछ नहीं बोलना चाहोगे ??मोदी जैसे सिर्फ़ एकतरफ़ा बात करने की आदत उनके सभी अंधभक्तों को पड़ गई है ॥पहले जैसे १ दिन में वोटिंग की डिटेल क्यों नहीं इंटरनेट पर डाली ?? मुँह तो १० सालों से मोदी छुपाते फिर रहा है खुले में पत्रकारों से बात करने से -पुलवामा,मणिपुर,रातों रात ED,CBI, ECs की नियुक्ति, लद्दाख(चीन ४००० वर्ग किलोमीटर कब्जा), अदानी(हिंडनबर्ग), बृजभूषण, प्रज्वल रेवन्ना, इलेक्टोरल बॉण्ड, पीएम केयर फण्ड, किसान आंदोलन ,कोवेक्सिन ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,??
@@dhruvnarayan8169 10-11 दिन लेट करने और वोटिंग numbers न बताने(सिर्फ़ %) की धांधली और चुनाव आयुक्त को बिना सुप्रीम कोर्ट के मुख्य न्यायाधीश के नियुक्त करने संसद में क़ानून पास करने की तानाशाही के बारे में कुछ नहीं बोलना चाहोगे ??मोदी जैसे सिर्फ़ एकतरफ़ा बात करने की आदत उनके सभी अंधभक्तों को पड़ गई है ॥पहले जैसे १ दिन में वोटिंग की डिटेल क्यों नहीं इंटरनेट पर डाली ?? मुँह तो १० सालों से मोदी छुपाते फिर रहा है खुले में पत्रकारों से बात करने से -पुलवामा,मणिपुर,रातों रात ED,CBI, ECs की नियुक्ति, लद्दाख(चीन ४००० वर्ग किलोमीटर कब्जा), अदानी(हिंडनबर्ग), बृजभूषण, प्रज्वल रेवन्ना, इलेक्टोरल बॉण्ड, पीएम केयर फण्ड, किसान आंदोलन ,कोवेक्सिन ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,??
@@dhruvnarayan8169 10-11 दिन लेट करने और वोटिंग numbers न बताने(सिर्फ़ %) की धांधली और चुनाव आयुक्त को बिना सुप्रीम कोर्ट के मुख्य न्यायाधीश के नियुक्त करने संसद में क़ानून पास करने की तानाशाही के बारे में कुछ नहीं बोलना चाहोगे ??मोदी जैसे सिर्फ़ एकतरफ़ा बात करने की आदत उनके सभी अंधभक्तों को पड़ गई है ॥पहले जैसे १ दिन में वोटिंग की डिटेल क्यों नहीं इंटरनेट पर डाली ?? मुँह तो १० सालों से मोदी छुपाते फिर रहा है खुले में पत्रकारों से बात करने से -पुलवामा,मणिपुर,रातों रात ED,CBI, ECs की नियुक्ति, लद्दाख(चीन ४००० वर्ग किलोमीटर कब्जा), अदानी(हिंडनबर्ग), बृजभूषण, प्रज्वल रेवन्ना, इलेक्टोरल बॉण्ड, पीएम केयर फण्ड, किसान आंदोलन ,कोवेक्सिन ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,??
US does not mind India executing such operation in Pak but not in US.
The people killed in Pakistan have done terrorist acts against India. Also Pakistan doesn’t have functioning judiciary.
Lack of Indian Perspectives: Defensive Needs and Security Concerns: The interview does not thoroughly explore India's security challenges, particularly its concerns about terrorism and external threats, which might have influenced the actions attributed to RAW. Understanding India's security landscape is crucial for a balanced analysis.
Political and Social Context: The interview scarcely touches upon the internal political dynamics in India, public opinion, or the political pressures facing the Indian government, all of which could provide important context for the actions taken.
Indian Legal and Ethical Frameworks: There's minimal discussion on whether India has its own checks and balances or accountability mechanisms for intelligence operations, which might differ from U.S. practices but still function within the framework of Indian law.
US used WMD in Iraq and was a bluff. What accountablity is this guy talking about?
Did Karan ask about the attacks on the Indian missions by the khalistanis in USA and other countries. I didn't see the interview bcos i cannot stand Karan Thapar. So please let me know if he asked or was just facilitating the USA line of thought as a true colonial minded "Indian"
No one should care about washington post or US opinions-No value or meaning whatsoever
Lies, Lies and Superlies
All major powers do black ops . The point is not to get caught doing a shoddy job with your pants down . R&AW needs to invest more on training & better resourses. And for god`s sake , next time don`t communicate with agents using 'wattsapp' ..!!!
ROFL
Let's talk about America killing thousands of civilians in Vietnam.
Why only Vietnam, what about Syria, Iraq, Afghanistan, Palestine, Gaza and many more?
@@nasreensyed6451 all were enemy countries at the time. US is supposed to our strategic ally. There is probably no instance of America killing the citizen of a friendly country on their soil. So what India allegedly did is not comparable
@@generalcontactid3023then why strategic ally is harboring a man who openly threat indua every week, can you explain?
@richardsking There is no threat from Pannu. He is getting referendum conducted all over the world regarding the future fate of Panjab. This is the fundamental right. When the UK wanted to exit the European Union, it held the referendum. India has been unjust towards Panjab since 1947. Chandigarh completely belongs to Panjab. Indian state denied Panjab its capital. Many Panjabi speaking areas were kept outside Panjab. Panjab waters were looted brazenly. There was no separatist movement until 1984. People of Panjab were fighting for the implementation of Anandpur Sahib resolution. There was nothing unconstitutional about those demands. Instead, India waged a war against Sikhs by attacking Darbar Sahib. India never considered Sikh religion as an independent and sovereign religion. Instead, it considered Sikh religion as a branch of Hinduism, which is not acceptable to Sikhs. There were many other issues that needed immediate attention. But India took them very lightly. And it is still not ready to give Panjab its due right. India's attitude towards Sikhs has led to such a situation. India is still not ready to respond positively to the demands of Panjab. And now this issue has become an international issue. It is completely India 's fault. Thanks
@@richardskingIt is just sloganeering, he has not done anything criminal. Modi on the other hand is using Government agencies to jail opposition. Indian Embassies are actively creating divide among Hindu and Sikh diaspora. Indian press is demonizing Sikh diaspora. Majority of Sikh families in India have family members living abroad.
Historical Permanent opponent to unusual priority place doesn’t it sounds like better foreign policy by modi govt. thappad should consult with isi or pakistan to get some secret information which can be used against india.
Mr Thapar thanks for working overtime to make sure Modi wins again. Whatever this channel try to do will have opposite effect on elections.
Well Said! Modi is 1000 times better khangress leader
Thapar do one video on death of Homie Bhabha too…. Don’t be a slave for the western media
Mr. Thapar, it is Samant Goel, not Satwant Goel. You are otherwise precise and incisive.
Karan did not get the answers he wanted with the earlier interview on the same topic …he chose some elastic wall to get the same results as he want .
Modi is incompetent and brazenly corrupt. The people of India deserve to know.
Kudos to Karan!
Are you gomuthra nagpur half knickers?
I agree
I know Mr Thapar your legions for US/UK But com'on in the midst of Country on the verge contd. debacle - This is 2nd dialogue on the topic - Jesus, Give me a break!
Why, we want to know criminal wrong doings of the government.
And this joker says or indicates that US is ok if same happens in Pakistan but not in US? Shows the weakness is US framework.
You are a rich man. Why do you need more money from subscribers. Truth is your claim. Do you exchange truth for money
Usa ne india ke face par kalikh b maldi hai aur apne relationship bhi kharab hai hone di.Aur India ki under kneebhi kar Diya hai.
Excellent interview, exposes the profundity of modi govt. ; the venture however backfired due to incompetence of Indian intelligence as they were blindsided into hiring the hitman who was in fact a CIA implant..
What the F**k is happening, Karan?? 😂😂😂😂
Karan Thapar's obsession on this topic seems like he doesn't like India is killing its enemies. Maybe he wants India to be weak and more "democratic".
Not weak but certainly democratic.
To not be democratic is unconstitutional.
Let's talk about America hunting down Sadam, uday and kusay - two sons of sadam - in iraq.
These people committed heinous crimes in USA.
They hide behind legal framework, lets get some good lawyers on our side first
Let's talk about America killing Osama in Pakistan
Obama went on air and told the Nation what he had ordered. Accountability is what the focus is on according to Dr. Markey and so far the Indian government has only claimed An Investigation is under way. Investigations in India sadly take hundreds of years to see the light of Day
Americans are funny people.
Karan - this guy is not helping you ni progagating anti-India agenda, right? I can see frustrations. Your handlers are doing a poor job, isn't it?
Truth hurts, go back to government propaganda channels.
If this story gains more traction, it could prove to be a HUGE boon for Modi, ensuring his re-election. It could be 2024's Balakot.
Same as in 1984. More the government kills minorities or opposition more Hindu votes. History repeats itself.
He is trying to create a Khaljstan. What joke is thzt😊
You have been fed lies.
It’s not your fault it’s just that fake news has become mainstream in India… they want you to see enemies everywhere you turn.. they are creating an illusion like the one created in Germany in the 30s.
There already is a political party in Punjab which wants to create an independent state lead by Simranjit Singh Mann. They’ve never done well in elections which goes to show that the ppl of Punjab aren’t interested in secession. The idea is not popular abroad as well but mainstream media keeps on peddling propaganda . It’s not going to end well if this continues
I believe if BJP gets full majority this time - Modi ji might declare new policy from the red fort to neutralize India' s enemy where ever they might be and a new bill will be passed in parlament
Thanks