People think it's aurora because it is often described as the calling of the aurora borealis / northernlights and if people just put snappy titles on youtube like Aurora calling or something... then people think it's her.
I thought the same thing, but I wouldn't exactly be surprised if Aurora had done something equally......unusual Not that that is a bad thing, by any means.
Thanks for calling them out. Back on their bullshit of comparing singular talents to one another in an effort to compartmentalize unique voices under one superficial category. Celtic and Germanic languages are not the same. They each represent a myriad of languages/regions/ethnicities. Nordic regions include: Denmark, Norway, Sweden, Finland, Faroe Islands, Iceland and Greenland. Celtic regions include: Brittany, Cornwall, Wales, Scotland, Ireland and Isle of Man, and, possibly, some parts of present day Portugal. These are privileged people who have no reason/excuse for being ignorant. Maybe they don’t have adequate vocabulary or are too lazy to analyze her voice/intonation. Maybe they just want to say easy lazy things like her voice is “similar” to Dolores O’Riordan, Florence Welch, and Jonna Jinton. They are unique voices these four artists. Do these men have ears at all? Further than that, their musical styles and production are so different. Also, how nice is it that they don’t even know the proper names of the female singer’s they are lazily comparing. How does this vid have any views at all? I bet they couldn’t find Norway on a labeled map. The best part is they are too fucking disrespectful to even correct their case of mistaken/marginalized identity.
I don't believe this is her first time round on this planet either, she is an 'old soul' filled with much wisdom for her age. Aurora has a great voice & is a gifted Artist, her lyric's are always so profound too. In some songs I hear bits of Bjork, even Aurora's quirkiness reminds me of the young Bjork but that's as far as their similarities go. Aurora has a 'techno' beat in a couple songs & her cover of Massive Attacks song 'Teardrop' is fantastic! Another cover she does brilliantly is called "God is a Woman", by Ariana Grande. ruclips.net/video/fn_6i7Wed-c/видео.html Thanks for your reaction & thoughts guys.
No, thats Jonna jinton who is doing "kulning" From Swe. (yelling to the cows), This is AURORA from Norway, and yes, she is using our culture in her music who is Scandinavic sound... You can hear her own kulning in her music sometimes..
I wanted to hear your take on this, but I also came here now because I'd just come from a reaction to the "Live at Current" version of this song, and I wanted to double-check that I prefer that version. Yep, I do. It's just Aurora backed by Silja Sol on acoustic guitar & harmony vocal. Aurora's performance is, to my ears, SO much more delicate and vulnerable, which expresses _this_ song better (PMHO).
I one hundred percent agree. This version sounds like she's singing under duress. It's much more relaxed and controlled and, like you said, delicate and vulnerable in the Current version. I love how every performance brings a different angle to the song. It's like that with all of her songs.
what a great start to my day! two It Happened Quiet reactions in an hours time. great react! the Goodbye to Cows you're thinking about isnt AuRoRa but Jonna Jinton. does look and sound a lot alike. thx!!
You should listen to the same song but on CURRENT👍 Her backup wocal is sang by Silja Sol, witch has been with her for a long time. The harmony between them are beautiful 🥰🥰
Make up your mind. Either react to and comment on the artist or react to the comments being made by the people you can't see. Trying to do both is distracting from the artist's performance. Comment on the comments people have made at the end. If you are trying to introduce people to an artist they haven't seen before, all your pauses are also distracting.
This song is about domestic abuse, and these two are neither analytic nor informed. They don't understand music for instance why she chose a 12/8 over a 6/8 when she did , I gave this example because it was important and simple to notice, how she changes from a minor to a major and many more little notes that should have been explained. These two combined have the intellect of a 12 year old. lol
Interesting that you compare her to Marko, in that Aurora and Floor are my two favorite vocalists. Although Aurora and Floor are very different singers, they both are elite at storytelling and conveying emotion.
@@kippys1 She is from the Western parts of Norway. Back in the days the connection between the Celtics and western Norwegians were closer than to rest of Norway. Many would be surprised if they listen to folk music from those parts, at how similar it is to Irish/celtic music and how different from other Norwegian folk music.
This is not the best of her performances of this song. The live video from The Current with only an acoustic guitar and soprano backup singer, is even more impressive.
If you didn't slurp at the end of every video or at least gave some kind of warning that the analysis portion is over, I would subscribe in a heartbeat. But alas...
Are you sure you're not thinking of Jonna Jinton with the cows? She's a big kulning (cow calling) artist here on RUclips. Never seen Aurora do it...
it is. just watched a couple a few months back. one of my fav comments is in one.
my norse chant brings all the cows to the yard. hilarious!
People think it's aurora because it is often described as the calling of the aurora borealis / northernlights
and if people just put snappy titles on youtube like Aurora calling or something... then people think it's her.
Yup, was looking for that comment so I didn't double post 😉
I thought the same thing, but I wouldn't exactly be surprised if Aurora had done something equally......unusual
Not that that is a bad thing, by any means.
Thanks for calling them out. Back on their bullshit of comparing singular talents to one another in an effort to compartmentalize unique voices under one superficial category. Celtic and Germanic languages are not the same. They each represent a myriad of languages/regions/ethnicities. Nordic regions include: Denmark, Norway, Sweden, Finland, Faroe Islands, Iceland and Greenland. Celtic regions include: Brittany, Cornwall, Wales, Scotland, Ireland and Isle of Man, and, possibly, some parts of present day Portugal. These are privileged people who have no reason/excuse for being ignorant. Maybe they don’t have adequate vocabulary or are too lazy to analyze her voice/intonation. Maybe they just want to say easy lazy things like her voice is “similar” to Dolores O’Riordan, Florence Welch, and Jonna Jinton. They are unique voices these four artists. Do these men have ears at all? Further than that, their musical styles and production are so different.
Also, how nice is it that they don’t even know the proper names of the female singer’s they are lazily comparing.
How does this vid have any views at all? I bet they couldn’t find Norway on a labeled map. The best part is they are too fucking disrespectful to even correct their case of mistaken/marginalized identity.
Her voice is the most beautiful instrument I've ever heard 🙌🏻
This isn't the goodbye to cows girl. Her name is Jonna Jinton and is swedish.
Jonna Jinton is the one who did those 'goodbye to cows' videos.
Yep
maybe u should check out artists before telling fake info
I don't believe this is her first time round on this planet either, she is an 'old soul' filled with much wisdom for her age.
Aurora has a great voice & is a gifted Artist, her lyric's are always so profound too.
In some songs I hear bits of Bjork, even Aurora's quirkiness reminds me of the young Bjork but that's as far as their similarities go.
Aurora has a 'techno' beat in a couple songs & her cover of Massive Attacks song 'Teardrop' is fantastic!
Another cover she does brilliantly is called "God is a Woman", by Ariana Grande.
ruclips.net/video/fn_6i7Wed-c/видео.html
Thanks for your reaction & thoughts guys.
I completely agree -- her Massive Attack cover is spellbinding!
She does remind me of Bjork sometimes too, something in the tone and dark, childlike quirkiness… but they are nothing alike at the same time
No, thats Jonna jinton who is doing "kulning" From Swe. (yelling to the cows), This is AURORA from Norway, and yes, she is using our culture in her music who is Scandinavic sound... You can hear her own kulning in her music sometimes..
Enjoyed your reaction to this song by AURORA! She just pulls me in -- mesmerizing! She is also quite a songwriter/storyteller!
I too hear Dolores O'Riordan (Cranberries) in her voice. I also hear an influence from Elizabeth Fraser (Cocteau Twins).
She is unique. Her voice is so pure and touches the soul...
I wanted to hear your take on this, but I also came here now because I'd just come from a reaction to the "Live at Current" version of this song, and I wanted to double-check that I prefer that version. Yep, I do. It's just Aurora backed by Silja Sol on acoustic guitar & harmony vocal. Aurora's performance is, to my ears, SO much more delicate and vulnerable, which expresses _this_ song better (PMHO).
I one hundred percent agree. This version sounds like she's singing under duress. It's much more relaxed and controlled and, like you said, delicate and vulnerable in the Current version. I love how every performance brings a different angle to the song. It's like that with all of her songs.
She reminds me so much of Joni Mitchel and Kate Bush.
I think you confused, the singer you were commenting on was not aurora lol
The QUEEN of pureness....
what a great start to my day! two It Happened Quiet reactions in an hours time. great react! the Goodbye to Cows you're thinking about isnt AuRoRa but Jonna Jinton. does look and sound a lot alike. thx!!
And Jonna is from sweden 💓💓💓🇸🇪🇸🇪
You should listen to the same song but on CURRENT👍 Her backup wocal is sang by Silja Sol, witch has been with her for a long time. The harmony between them are beautiful 🥰🥰
Her music should be played in like a haunting movie scenes.
it probably will be
It isn't aurora who does the cow calling.
The cow video is Jonna Jinton.
Spellbinding. A true artist, 21 years of age!!
Jonna Jinton is a Sami singer from Sweden🇸🇪
You must listen to her new album! She has incredible versatility. At she is coming into her own as a poet, singer, songwriter and producer.
She is not Jonna Jinton.
Um no Aurora is not singing that, it was Jonna Jinton
Aurora is not human. She's art
Make up your mind. Either react to and comment on the artist or react to the comments being made by the people you can't see. Trying to do both is distracting from the artist's performance. Comment on the comments people have made at the end. If you are trying to introduce people to an artist they haven't seen before, all your pauses are also distracting.
Lol
I was annoyed too.
@@CodyTheReactor You do a better job Cody.
@@daturanights There are plenty of others who do a better job to follow.
@@John-gv2ug yeah I found some others which were good. Thank you.
For this song u should listen live in studio.this is when she was 16 if im not mistaken
you should react to her singing murder song (5,4,3,2,1) or maybe running with the wolves!! loved the reaction ♥️♥️
This song was much better in the version where she was singing a duet and only "orchestrated" with a classical guitar.
i'm wondering if you don't confuse Aurora and Jonna Jinton ! >< They are Two differents people even if they have some similitudes
The second two blonde nordic ladies sing on youtube they get mixed up with one another. xD Anyways, much love from Sweden
If Kate Bush, Dolores O'Riordan (The Cranberries lead singer), and Enya had a baby... This right here. Love Aurora!!
1:52 open cc. Im sorry.
This song is about domestic abuse, and these two are neither analytic nor informed. They don't understand music for instance why she chose a 12/8 over a 6/8 when she did , I gave this example because it was important and simple to notice, how she changes from a minor to a major and many more little notes that should have been explained. These two combined have the intellect of a 12 year old. lol
Interesting that you compare her to Marko, in that Aurora and Floor are my two favorite vocalists. Although Aurora and Floor are very different singers, they both are elite at storytelling and conveying emotion.
Dolores O'Riordan. Youre not the first ones to say that!
It's too bad that Dolores O'Riordan passed away in 2018. AURORA does also lend this Celtic quality to her vocals
@@kippys1 She is from the Western parts of Norway. Back in the days the connection between the Celtics and western Norwegians were closer than to rest of Norway. Many would be surprised if they listen to folk music from those parts, at how similar it is to Irish/celtic music and how different from other Norwegian folk music.
@@ragnarkisten That's really interesting, and makes a lot of sense
@@kippys1 I would link to some if I could, but I assume the comment field does not allow for links
I dont like this version that much, current's live is WAAYYYY better!!
💙💙💙💙
It's almost as if she wrote the song. Seriously.
2/3 Bjork 1/3 Cranberries
1/1 of Aurora Aksnes
This is not the best of her performances of this song. The live video from The Current with only an acoustic guitar and soprano backup singer, is even more impressive.
If you didn't slurp at the end of every video or at least gave some kind of warning that the analysis portion is over, I would subscribe in a heartbeat. But alas...
You look like rich cambell lol
Eneste norske?
Nei
Slurping is NOT welcoming to those with misphonia
Crap analysis
What's with the slurping at the end? Is it supposed to be funny? Why not just rip off a big fart while you're at it?
AMY LEE (AMAZING) HIGH NOTES -> EVANESCENCE - THE END OF THE DREAM (SYNTHESIS DVD LIVE). Beautiful, powerful, emotional! Amazing!
The comparison is like trying to compare Wagner (Evan) to Franz Schubert (Aurora) an impossible task.
She has a very childish voice. I mean that in a good way.
oof these guys are pretentious lmao
Listen to her concert HAIK instead.. Way better version and way more subtle.. Just a guitar and two voices.. SO much better than this pretentious crap