If you are fascinated with this guy's performance, then watch the video in slow motion...you will be surprised to see numerous mistakes that he has hidden behind his blinding speed...
Agreed. His techniques are lighting fast, but the timing of the moves seemed awkward -- although that may just be the way he learned the kata. Futhermore I noticed a lack of use of his hands during move transitions and open fingers during knife hands (may be acceptable in tournament, idk)
o significado do Kanku dai é "contemplando o céu" e o primeiro movimento é exatamente pra isso, mas acho que ele ficou tão focado em olhar pra frente que esqueceu.
Every karateka who knows Valdesi's style also knows that he is certainly not the right guy for Kanku Dai! With few fancy movements to show off, Kanku Dai is a very honest kata that shows how beauty can derive from simplicity (remember: heian katas derive from Kanku Dai). It's length and basic techniques make it easy to spot the practitioner's basic mistakes- and Valdesi makes a lot of those. Although I am definitely not a fan of his style I aknowledge his speed and charisma. When doing Shotokan Kata, he should stick to Gankaku, Gojushiho Sho, Unsu....
Kanku dai is a Chinese kata. It was later split up to make the hian katas. This guy has no understanding of the rhythm of kanku dai. The kata should take at least 1.40 to complete. I did this kata for my brown belt. Next I am doing empi.
@Capitan Pollito No, it's the other way around. Kanku-Dai derives from "Kūsankū" which was a named after a Chinese diplomat that traveled to Okinawa. "Tōde" Sakugawa trained for Kūsankū and developed a kata from his teachings. Later on Itosu Anko split the Kūshankū kata into the Heian katas (Pinan at that time). Gichin Funakoshi then changed the name to more Japanese names and called them Kanku-Dai and Heian.
@ TheLeviathanFilm I agree with you! This also probably being a WKF tournament (not JKA or other shotokan) means that all katas are transformed into something they where not ment to be :(
No matter what haters say , the guy is good... And as a human being he could have mistakes performing a Kata. But my question is could any of the haters do better than him???
Its not hating my friend the people in the comments said basic small mistakes that he have done while doing this while for example his kotkutsu dachi was wider and at one point he was in zen kutsu dachi with his toes.....these are some basic mistakes that a black belt wont do.....in kata the timing , the flow , speed and mainly more than that technique matters...... mistakes can happen but u hav e to know pointing mistakes isnt hating !!!
this man has great execution in terms of power and focus, but I would argue that the accuracy of his moves and his timing in many places falls short of what this kata is supposed to look like
I don't like his rendition. I know that almost each dojo has its own way of interpreting of some movements and the same kata may seem slightly different still remaining on the master's level but here I see the apparent mistakes (or - at least - very weird interpretation) in a few techniques. Undoubtly, he would get quite poor notes on the shotokan competitions I used to participate in. I'd like to see his bunkai of some moves (especially in the final part of the kata).
He is fast and that is ok but technique is very bad..but that is today's karate..poor techinqe and all of that is more like modeling than real karate...
his technique is horrible ... if you want to see technique go watch ueda, hidemoto kurihara, nozomi oshima, fukuhara etc ... they're just as fast if not faster than valdesi , but they show proper hip work, proper shifting of weight and balance from one move to the next, proper pivoting on turns, and nothing of this flashy stuff that has ruined shotokan karate
I am old fashion practitioner who see those flashy movement with poor definition of the technique...if you go to the best karate series and see the katas you will understand what I mean...
It's sport or show karate, like gymnastics routines at the Olympics, not genuine combat karate, for that see H. Kanazawa do this & the difference will be obvious.
he's fast. yet too jumpy. too much adjusting of leg positions when changing stances and these katas he's doing lack the spiritual flow. it's like he can't wait to get done!
No estuvo nada mal, solo tenía un mínimo vibrato en los puños (las patadas salieron perfectas), y parece haber gastado mucha energía corporal durante toda su ejecución...
amigo saludos hermano soy black belt en shotokan la kata salio bien pero,,,, tienes que ejecutarla menos rapido ya que no se destingues algunos suki y esa kata es para cinturones mas avanzado. marron o negra.
Madre mia tio te has coronado. Ese cinturon azul es porque está en competición (rojo o azul / aka o ao). Valdesi es cinturon negro y campeon del mundo de kata
He is cheating by taking shortcuts when executing the techniques. His heels are not ankered. This is just a fancy show off. Karateka who train the traditional shotokan know that kata is way deeper than this.
+Draconic Dk Nope, it was correct. This was a "shitei kata". In WKF tournaments there were 8 katas, and you had to be able to do at least one of them, if not two, it has been too long since I competed. Different major schools were given control over different kata. Empi and Kankudai were the official "Shotokan kata" and this is done correctly in the Shotokan style. This requirement was dropped at the end of 2012. Of course that does not make this kata right and yours wrong, or vice versa. Different schools have different versions of kata. If a kata works, it works and is not "wrong".
Taylor GangGaming So you claim that referees who judge kata competitions can do them better than the competitors themselves? I don't need to have his speed to see his errors.
very poor technique. as ever, he turns on the ball of the foot on ashi-zenkutsu instead of on the heel; hikite is shit; and he keeps doing these weird little flicking movements with his arms before each technique, which is kind of useless and weak.
Sputi, tempi sballati, niente kime, e leggo qui sotto che in molti lo chiamano sensei, ma sensei di cosa che non avrà mai fatto nemmeno un tameshiwari?
@@Xhina7 observa como o calcanhar dele rotacionar para trás no minuto 43 e 46 na transição para zenkutsu dachi, acontece o mesmo em outros momentos do vídeo, Essa rotação para trás faz com que a força seja dispersada para trás quando na verdade todo o impulso do corpo deveria ir para frente, isso é apenas um dos vários erros
@@Xhina7 Procura os vídeos das escolas: JKA, JKS, KWF. Vc vai sentir a diferença, também tem ótimos vídeos de sensei Naka da JKA, transmitindo detalhes do kata, ele tem uma ótima didática, espero ter ajudado amigo, Osu🇯🇵
Sensei Jesse, i just got my black belt in karate few minutes ago, you helped me a lot to learn and i wanted to thank you
Congrats!!
When I started karatê he was The only on RUclips and I learned watching him :)
If you are fascinated with this guy's performance, then watch the video in slow motion...you will be surprised to see numerous mistakes that he has hidden behind his blinding speed...
Agreed. His techniques are lighting fast, but the timing of the moves seemed awkward -- although that may just be the way he learned the kata. Futhermore I noticed a lack of use of his hands during move transitions and open fingers during knife hands (may be acceptable in tournament, idk)
Oss
You're right, and he's not smooth in his movement, i didn't like his kata style
His heel keeps moving backwards
This was the peak kata standard 10 years ago, a decade comes with alot of change.
o significado do Kanku dai é "contemplando o céu" e o primeiro movimento é exatamente pra isso, mas acho que ele ficou tão focado em olhar pra frente que esqueceu.
One of my favorite forms of all time. I performed in many demonstrations, testings, and competitions.
Every karateka who knows Valdesi's style also knows that he is certainly not the right guy for Kanku Dai! With few fancy movements to show off, Kanku Dai is a very honest kata that shows how beauty can derive from simplicity (remember: heian katas derive from Kanku Dai). It's length and basic techniques make it easy to spot the practitioner's basic mistakes- and Valdesi makes a lot of those. Although I am definitely not a fan of his style I aknowledge his speed and charisma. When doing Shotokan Kata, he should stick to Gankaku, Gojushiho Sho, Unsu....
Kanku dai is a Chinese kata.
It was later split up to make the hian katas.
This guy has no understanding of the rhythm of kanku dai. The kata should take at least 1.40 to complete. I did this kata for my brown belt.
Next I am doing empi.
I agree. Too many shortcuts and wrong timing on his pauses and slow emphasizing movements. He also almost went Sandan after the second Nukite. xD
@Capitan Pollito No, it's the other way around. Kanku-Dai derives from "Kūsankū" which was a named after a Chinese diplomat that traveled to Okinawa. "Tōde" Sakugawa trained for Kūsankū and developed a kata from his teachings. Later on Itosu Anko split the Kūshankū kata into the Heian katas (Pinan at that time). Gichin Funakoshi then changed the name to more Japanese names and called them Kanku-Dai and Heian.
@
TheLeviathanFilm I agree with you! This also probably being a WKF tournament (not JKA or other shotokan) means that all katas are transformed into something they where not ment to be :(
@@EneSacarification right and where did you get this information 😂.
Kanku-dai originates from China, that's a fact.
No matter what haters say , the guy is good...
And as a human being he could have mistakes performing a Kata.
But my question is could any of the haters do better than him???
I won't call myself a hater, just a critic, I think I can take him on at least I'd love to try
Its not hating my friend the people in the comments said basic small mistakes that he have done while doing this while for example his kotkutsu dachi was wider and at one point he was in zen kutsu dachi with his toes.....these are some basic mistakes that a black belt wont do.....in kata the timing , the flow , speed and mainly more than that technique matters...... mistakes can happen but u hav e to know pointing mistakes isnt hating !!!
Omg this will really help me to bring black belt first den. I am your new fan. Subscribed!!
this man has great execution in terms of power and focus, but I would argue that the accuracy of his moves and his timing in many places falls short of what this kata is supposed to look like
I am very very like luca valdesi i am also play karate shotokan on green belt my dream i will play karate shotokan same to same luca valdesi🖒🖒🖒
Gran Maestro Luca baldeci
I will be performing kanku dai at a tournament this weekend and uploading it (already uploaded basai dai and empi)
Apesar de alguns golpes não ficar nítidos, pra mim é o melhor em lata que já vi, kime força e velocidade,oss
é mesmo? entao da uma olhada na Ayano Nakamura e vais ver que ela é mais veloz e se ve todos os movimentos nitidos porque é perfeita
Tenk you brou
Haven’t done this kata in years
Waw! ❤it's so good ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤😊
This guy is very good at kata
Great technic and he's very fast. Ossu!
este es su ritmo o es que va un poco rapido ??
Spero sia migliorato in questi anni... si mangia i caricamenti delle tecniche! Ritmo kata sensa senso... tra pause innutili (inventate)
Спасибо за все видео💪👊✌
Waoo...very good...
I don't like his rendition. I know that almost each dojo has its own way of interpreting of some movements and the same kata may seem slightly different still remaining on the master's level but here I see the apparent mistakes (or - at least - very weird interpretation) in a few techniques. Undoubtly, he would get quite poor notes on the shotokan competitions I used to participate in. I'd like to see his bunkai of some moves (especially in the final part of the kata).
Jittery movements! Very powerful, yet ...
Very good performance of the KATA.
Demonstração excelente de kimen, porém, acho q engoliu alguns golpes na apresentação, mas muita velocidade nos golpes também.
Parabéns.
superb performance nice speed i like it
Kangen gabung Dojo lagi 🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰 minimal bassa dai lah
Amazing!
Good.
Oss!!!!Sensei Luca Valdesi !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
it is not the correct way i think.. still, very talented
@ Jesse or someone else, I'm wondering if Kanku Dai is the Shotokan version for Chatanyara no Kushanku ?
No
Too fast to be Kanku dai. It should be slower than this performance, with properly rithm changes. An example of good Kanku dai is Koji Arimoto
You re right! Some hand movements left too short or incomplete because of speeding. Excellent power expression thou.
I agree
NICE....
He has great form excellent technique. Brings it together really well. But have seen lanky Dao performed much better.
Muito bom
he's a very fast guy.
Osu!
The most powerful ever.
He is fast and that is ok but technique is very bad..but that is today's karate..poor techinqe and all of that is more like modeling than real karate...
+Zoran Petrovic I'd like to see you do better. His technique is amazing.
+Robert Fox you obviously don't know what good technique is then
+Robert Fox you obviously don't know what good technique is then
his technique is horrible ... if you want to see technique go watch ueda, hidemoto kurihara, nozomi oshima, fukuhara etc ... they're just as fast if not faster than valdesi , but they show proper hip work, proper shifting of weight and balance from one move to the next, proper pivoting on turns, and nothing of this flashy stuff that has ruined shotokan karate
Zoran Petrovic i agree
good . energy
Kata man !
powerful and dangerous !
You are Freind of Luca Valdesi?
Oss top kata
I am old fashion practitioner who see those flashy movement with poor definition of the technique...if you go to the best karate series and see the katas you will understand what I mean...
Shotokan kata site,
This guy is a damn shotgun.
This is Karate?
Alan Previley No this is KATA
It's sport or show karate, like gymnastics routines at the Olympics, not genuine combat karate, for that see H. Kanazawa do this & the difference will be obvious.
Alan Previley yes is karate
No this is footballe
Ahahah!! No...! Karate sport...
The spitting competition, not being able to make the real sound of the gi during the execution of the kata, therefore he decides to make these verses.
I feel a bit irrelevant but I can't see where its kata is wrong.
Rozieris the technique
he's fast. yet too jumpy. too much adjusting of leg positions when changing stances and these katas he's doing lack the spiritual flow. it's like he can't wait to get done!
mantap
I do karate shito-ryu
No estuvo nada mal, solo tenía un mínimo vibrato en los puños (las patadas salieron perfectas), y parece haber gastado mucha energía corporal durante toda su ejecución...
Me gustaria ver como haces tu esa kata..
oss
ha ok ta bien
At 00:16, has someone let a fox in?
👍👍
👍👍👏👏👏
ya mensooooooouuuuuuuuurrrr Ptddddrrrrrrr jpppppp (jfais du karaté aussi(ceinture marron)
Sheet
Where the heck is Bobbi wasabi
Lol
Too fast
Tiger zinda rahaga
Strange tempo.
amigo saludos hermano soy black belt en shotokan la kata salio bien pero,,,, tienes que ejecutarla menos rapido ya que no se destingues algunos suki y esa kata es para cinturones mas avanzado. marron o negra.
Madre mia tio te has coronado. Ese cinturon azul es porque está en competición (rojo o azul / aka o ao). Valdesi es cinturon negro y campeon del mundo de kata
+Carlos Rodriguez ¿Cómo llegaste a cinturón negro sin haber ido nunca a un torneo?
Anda, que por lo menos a uno cuando eras niño.
Kiske Badguy n2k80
That wasnt the kanku dai kata ...
parvesh Ramessersing Well, and what was it then?
parvesh Ramessersing it was the kanku dai kata, have you seen something wrong bro??
+parvesh Ramessersing Are you serious?? -.-
I train at kamakura dojo in the netherlands and by my it is different
parvesh Ramessersing What's your karate style??
This Kankudai is the original shotokan kanku dai.
Hes like a robot on steroids. Don't like it he needs to relax way more
Ah....unagi
invalid techniques
How so?
He is cheating by taking shortcuts when executing the techniques. His heels are not ankered. This is just a fancy show off. Karateka who train the traditional shotokan know that kata is way deeper than this.
@@qualityshoe true
@@qualityshoe true
qualityshoe true
okay
1:12 wrong spinning direction...should be clock wise
+Draconic Dk Nope, it was correct. This was a "shitei kata". In WKF tournaments there were 8 katas, and you had to be able to do at least one of them, if not two, it has been too long since I competed. Different major schools were given control over different kata. Empi and Kankudai were the official "Shotokan kata" and this is done correctly in the Shotokan style. This requirement was dropped at the end of 2012. Of course that does not make this kata right and yours wrong, or vice versa. Different schools have different versions of kata. If a kata works, it works and is not "wrong".
I had no idea Ben Shapiro did karate 😮
Sorry, but I didn't like it. Looks very spastic to me.
so you can do better ? go you are the best of the world .
Just because I can't do it better, doesn't mean that I am not allowed to have a critical mind. Also "better" is very subjective when it comes to kata.
Taylor GangGaming So you claim that referees who judge kata competitions can do them better than the competitors themselves? I don't need to have his speed to see his errors.
that wasn't very impressive. drops his back hand a lot.
Omg, illuminati
Horrível!
Jh bulb
osu
めちゃくちゃ雑
very poor technique. as ever, he turns on the ball of the foot on ashi-zenkutsu instead of on the heel; hikite is shit; and he keeps doing these weird little flicking movements with his arms before each technique, which is kind of useless and weak.
Garry Smalls Yes!! Thank you!
😢 you ruined it
So bad
Sputi, tempi sballati, niente kime, e leggo qui sotto che in molti lo chiamano sensei, ma sensei di cosa che non avrà mai fatto nemmeno un tameshiwari?
este no hace karate pobres italianos se ciegan por ser su paisano.
Yuck. Full of shortcuts.
Terrible performance
Horrível, sem fundamento apenas velocidade, cadê a contração e expansão da técnica?!
Como assim?
@@Xhina7 observa como o calcanhar dele rotacionar para trás no minuto 43 e 46 na transição para zenkutsu dachi, acontece o mesmo em outros momentos do vídeo, Essa rotação para trás faz com que a força seja dispersada para trás quando na verdade todo o impulso do corpo deveria ir para frente, isso é apenas um dos vários erros
@@Xhina7 Procura os vídeos das escolas: JKA, JKS, KWF. Vc vai sentir a diferença, também tem ótimos vídeos de sensei Naka da JKA, transmitindo detalhes do kata, ele tem uma ótima didática, espero ter ajudado amigo, Osu🇯🇵
@@yagobrito6190 falou o samurai...
@@Lukassp Oss amigo, exponha melhor seu ponto de vista.
Shotokan kata site,