Mind you, this is the performance where their feet were hurting and bruised, Sica was sick, they were horribly sleep deprived and still managed to do this!!!!! They were just a 4 year old group at that time! They didn't become queens of k-pop only because of hit songs, but because of this passion, persistence and humility.
Jessica was sick, which is why she lipsynced in the real performance. The members here helped her sing her parts because she couldn't and her voice was hurt.
@@hackmehust sooyoung was just lip sync it, tiffany did it with hyoyeon, but hyo stop in the middle and tiffany still continued doing the high note, it was supposed to be fun challenge cuz tiffany ask hyoyeon to do it too, cuz its an encore stage yet. Hahaha (notice how taeyeon yuri, jessica, sunny turn to tiffany side after she belts the high note part)
@@Lynn-oh3tplol it's tiffany and hyoyeon, Sooyoung wasn't easy like at the video, why I said that look at the forever 1 recording session that Sooyoung said that her part was too higher
Queen taeyeon sounds just like the recording version (even the high note too). I just watched twice I can’t stop encore stage and jihyo and nayeon can’t even do the chorus part (high note) properly while just standing. But taeyeon if she could do it in recording she could do it on live performance too (high notes in Fine, I, why, U R, stress, and many more)
Many people forget or not aware that Sunny is actually the 4th lead vocalist in SNSD 9. This is the original line up for the group's vocal line: Taeyeon, Jessica - main vocalist. Seohyun, Sunny, Tiffany - lead vocalist. Hence, she is not a hidden vocalist.
Who knew Sunny be singing that part from now on. same with TaeYeon on the “girls bring the boys out!” Part, if y’all notice TaeYeon was singing it.. omg!
Sunny sang Jessica's part really well, I wish they'd give Sunny better parts >< Tiffany's primitive scream! XDDDD & Taeyeon did Jessica's last high note O:
TaeYeon doesn't do the last one, it is 100% Jessica studio/live, Jessica doesn't do that note live all the time because she would have to do it in head voice or falsetto everytime she did it so it wouldn't over power the BGM so it could still keep the same feeling and the same frequency and tone, it is just that doing that all the time would really take a toll on her voice. Trust me belting is much easier than doing falsetto/head voice, and TaeYeon's "My Heart" is belting.
Of course taeyeon did the last one. You can hear taeyeon’s voice over jessica’s. Are you deaf? Just because jessica doesn’t do it live doesn’t mean taeyeon can’t
Finally someone said it. I don't understand people that always commenting on Jessica's vocal as if they can do better than her. Also, why trying so hard comparing the ability of Taeyeon and Jessica vocal on singing the high note, obviously Taeyeon can do the high note she is the FIRST MAIN VOCAL so of course her singing ability is better than Jessica even she herself praised Taeyeon being a good singer. Jessica being the SECOND MAIN VOCALIST have her own technique and ability. For this song, personally I don't really mind if Jessica doesn't sing that part in original notes everytime they sang this song since it's too high and affect her vocals. Plus they sang this song many times how can a human sang that high notes live everytime and it's not like Jessica doesn't sing that part live, she does sing just not in original technique. I always hear her live vocal when that high note part came people should have known that if they really pay attention to the live performance
Well TaeYeon CAN hit an F5, Tiffany actually hits one in this performance. But TaeYeon would not be able to give it the same feel or give it the same frequency as Jessica can (high pitched sound, almost sounding like a sonar with out or without tune) TaeYeon also wouldn't be able to give it the same kind of feel. Not saying that TaeYeon can't do it she just can't do it like Jessica.
this video show us why sunny r the most affected member of sica's departure. sica know sunny love her sm. seohyun yoona and sunny r the closest member with sica thats why they against the idea to kick sica out.
Never said she couldn't, I said she could do it like Jessica..so please take a seat. TaeYeon's F#5 is a lot more strained than Jessica's. Also Jessica has an F#5 in "INTW" and she does that one ALL the time. I don't understand your need to quote my post three times.
It's not that she can't reach it, it's just that during a live performance the REALLY high notes they usually don't sing. It's to save their voice. Ex: Taengoo's note after "my heart." IU's note in good day
No I got what you were saying before. It's just my point is the last "girls bring the boys out" is higher than Taeyeon's "my heart." I know Sica recorded it and she can sing it. I've heard her sing that note a few times. But for a singer to constantly sing a really really high note like that during every live performance could take a toll on their voice. That may or may not be the case here. The only person that knows that for sure is sica.
💯 agree. A lot of people just ignore the fact that they're also a human not a robot who can sing the high note every single time. They're idols, their voices is very important to them so obviously they will take care of their voices
I don't want to mention any group or else but the group that claimed 'nation girl group' rn cant even do the high-notes as in their own song(which consist lot of hightnotes). They just randomly put the high-notes on their song but they never actually sing it. I mean why do you even brother to add hightnotes when you cant deliver it? Is that high-notes just a add-on or something? This video would be proof who is the actual 'nation girl group' is. Sunny which is only lead vocal supporting Taeyeon in-and-out. And also take a notes Tiffany and Hyoyeon was not even main vocal but they know how to continue Taeyeon highnotes.
It was Tiffany and/or Hyoyeon :) sooyoung lip synced that part. You can see she moved the mic a little too fast and closed her mouth too fast for it to be her
What makes you say that Taeyeon can't reach that note? Not questioning you, cause I have no idea about any singing techniques. But can you elaborate further on how Taeyeon wouldn't be able to do that?
this video taken in s. korea right?? who said HYOYEON less popular than the others?? who said HYOYEON less popular than the others?? this is the answer for her popularity 0:54
@Squlrrel09 nah Jessica does it when it's a real performance but guess she was too lazy lol or too tired during encore. even seobaby and tiff sang Jessica's other lines.
There is NO WAY TaeYeon could do the High Note, even though it is an F5 there is no way TaeYeon could do the kind of frequency, not give it that kind of tone.
LZA actually jessica only sung that note live one time, taeyeon just did it with no problem, and she also did many times at their fan meetings after jessica left the group
![[HD] 140306 SNSD - Mr. Mr. 1st Win Full Encore Stage](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kICe0V5Vcs8/mqdefault.jpg)
![Noob To Max With DRAGON REWORK In Blox Fruits [FULL MOVIE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LnBMOinoOvA/mqdefault.jpg)
![[MPD직캠] 소녀시대 1위 앵콜 직캠 PARTY Girls' Generation Fancam No.1 Encore full ver. Mnet MCOUNTDOWN 150716](/img/1.gif)
Mind you, this is the performance where their feet were hurting and bruised, Sica was sick, they were horribly sleep deprived and still managed to do this!!!!! They were just a 4 year old group at that time! They didn't become queens of k-pop only because of hit songs, but because of this passion, persistence and humility.
7 hear old group
Jessica was sick, which is why she lipsynced in the real performance.
The members here helped her sing her parts because she couldn't and her voice was hurt.
*Her throat
1:37
Sunny doing the high note with taeyeon just like the tokyo dome vr omg
1:23 Seobaby facing the other way and supporting Taeyeon's high note with her harmony
I like how Sunny and Seohyun covered Jessica's line at 1:05. And Sunny & Taeyeon even did the high note at 1:44
Sunny Seohyun and Yuri at 1:05
But why didn't Jessica sing her own part?
@@blake6380 she got a sorethroat
@@blake6380she was sick
Who would've thought that Sunny would really have to sing Jessica's line in the bridge part in the future? :((
1:44 also taeyeon
@@brucishsunny after the rap
Love how Sunny took Jessica's part!! ♥
Anastasia ended up being hers
TAEYEON SANG LAST HIGHEST NOTE OF JESSICA'S PART
TAEYEON JANGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Princess Jessica is sick and Energizer pill Sunny take the lead :D Sunsica moment :3 great job sunny bunny :3 but before was Seo Yul Yoon too :3 aww
Sunny did a great job replacing Sica
Hwang Chloe and that part ended up being hers
Sunny did a great job and she is so cooool!
they're literally all vocalists.............................. no other group has had stable vocals like they do. not even close. damn.
tiffanys such a dork in here haha love hit when she attempted to do the sliding down move xD
Tiffany extra high note.. woahhh!!!! DAEBAK! :')
i think it was sooyoung who did it !
tiffany took away the mic meanwhile , sooyoung is doing it
I think it's tiffany too. It sounds more tiffany to me.
Sooyoung make it
@@hackmehust sooyoung was just lip sync it, tiffany did it with hyoyeon, but hyo stop in the middle and tiffany still continued doing the high note, it was supposed to be fun challenge cuz tiffany ask hyoyeon to do it too, cuz its an encore stage yet. Hahaha (notice how taeyeon yuri, jessica, sunny turn to tiffany side after she belts the high note part)
@@_tiffany_universe Oh. I replay and I did see Tiffany's high note.
soo hyo and tiff are so cute trying to get that high note hahaha. hyoyeon went a little early hahaha
That dorky sooyoung hyoyeon tiffany seohyun try to imitating taengoo high note lol🤣🤣
Real encore legit
sooyoung's high note is so funny hahaha
I think it was Taeyeon
+Lenn that's sooyoung,fany and hyo....but you can hear sooyoung voice
🌷👋them pretty girls will definitely bring the boy's out 👋🌷😎🍑😮💮🤩🥰👋🌷
Hyo sang along to Tae's highnote and Sooyoung singing the back vocal after Tae's highnote lol... the girls are so cute and funny
@@Lynn-oh3tplol it's tiffany and hyoyeon, Sooyoung wasn't easy like at the video, why I said that look at the forever 1 recording session that Sooyoung said that her part was too higher
Queen taeyeon sounds just like the recording version (even the high note too). I just watched twice I can’t stop encore stage and jihyo and nayeon can’t even do the chorus part (high note) properly while just standing. But taeyeon if she could do it in recording she could do it on live performance too (high notes in Fine, I, why, U R, stress, and many more)
1:26 Hyoyeon and Tiffany sang the high note.
1:20 앵콜인데 애드립 칼 같이 지르고 게다가 존잘...
Not Sunny did so good jessica part, she's trury hidden vocalist. Yuri voice is so strong here.
Many people forget or not aware that Sunny is actually the 4th lead vocalist in SNSD 9. This is the original line up for the group's vocal line: Taeyeon, Jessica - main vocalist. Seohyun, Sunny, Tiffany - lead vocalist. Hence, she is not a hidden vocalist.
SNSD encore is always hillarious in some ways 😂😂😂
They're imitating their own members lolol
My sone heart 😍
써니 노래 완전 잘한다! 재평가가 시급한 영상. 제시카 파트 무난히 소화하네!😮
@1:26 tiffany's high note
Who knew Sunny be singing that part from now on. same with TaeYeon on the “girls bring the boys out!” Part, if y’all notice TaeYeon was singing it.. omg!
sunny sings very well!!!!
taeyeon did that.
Since jessical left from SNSD, sunny has sung that verse forever 🥺
that "AHHHHHHHHHH" PART right after Taeyeon's part is Hyoyeon's
They are queen
Sunny sang Jessica's part really well, I wish they'd give Sunny better parts ><
Tiffany's primitive scream! XDDDD
& Taeyeon did Jessica's last high note O:
かるく歌っている
生歌が上手いなんて格好良すぎる！！！
in love with tiffany energy
Hyoyeon copying tae's high notes Omygoddhhwjdnajw HHSHAHSHHA
I don't know whether Sooyoung really sang the last high notes of the part "my heart", but it sounded pretty good.
taeyeon high notes in twinkle= jessica high notes in the boys
taeyeon did it live almost all the time. jessica did hers 1 time
Tiffany hyo pleaseee 😂😂😂
Sooyoung highnote wow
Her voice so powerful
TaeYeon doesn't do the last one, it is 100% Jessica studio/live, Jessica doesn't do that note live all the time because she would have to do it in head voice or falsetto everytime she did it so it wouldn't over power the BGM so it could still keep the same feeling and the same frequency and tone, it is just that doing that all the time would really take a toll on her voice. Trust me belting is much easier than doing falsetto/head voice, and TaeYeon's "My Heart" is belting.
Of course taeyeon did the last one. You can hear taeyeon’s voice over jessica’s. Are you deaf? Just because jessica doesn’t do it live doesn’t mean taeyeon can’t
@@brucish jessica already did the note lmao
@@udebrl jessica only did her last note live once
@@brucish the high note is actually Jessica. She did it live at the Osaka Encore.
Finally someone said it. I don't understand people that always commenting on Jessica's vocal as if they can do better than her. Also, why trying so hard comparing the ability of Taeyeon and Jessica vocal on singing the high note, obviously Taeyeon can do the high note she is the FIRST MAIN VOCAL so of course her singing ability is better than Jessica even she herself praised Taeyeon being a good singer. Jessica being the SECOND MAIN VOCALIST have her own technique and ability. For this song, personally I don't really mind if Jessica doesn't sing that part in original notes everytime they sang this song since it's too high and affect her vocals. Plus they sang this song many times how can a human sang that high notes live everytime and it's not like Jessica doesn't sing that part live, she does sing just not in original technique. I always hear her live vocal when that high note part came people should have known that if they really pay attention to the live performance
lol at yoong hyo at the end..hahha
OMG I LOVE YOU TIFFANY
Jessica training them for life after Jexit (sorry, but had to)
Jessica
haha tiffany's scream was so cute xD
Well TaeYeon CAN hit an F5, Tiffany actually hits one in this performance. But TaeYeon would not be able to give it the same feel or give it the same frequency as Jessica can (high pitched sound, almost sounding like a sonar with out or without tune) TaeYeon also wouldn't be able to give it the same kind of feel. Not saying that TaeYeon can't do it she just can't do it like Jessica.
this video show us why sunny r the most affected member of sica's departure. sica know sunny love her sm. seohyun yoona and sunny r the closest member with sica thats why they against the idea to kick sica out.
Omg!!tiffany
SNSD playful cool.
Never said she couldn't, I said she could do it like Jessica..so please take a seat. TaeYeon's F#5 is a lot more strained than Jessica's. Also Jessica has an F#5 in "INTW" and she does that one ALL the time. I don't understand your need to quote my post three times.
It's not that she can't reach it, it's just that during a live performance the REALLY high notes they usually don't sing. It's to save their voice. Ex: Taengoo's note after "my heart." IU's note in good day
No I got what you were saying before. It's just my point is the last "girls bring the boys out" is higher than Taeyeon's "my heart." I know Sica recorded it and she can sing it. I've heard her sing that note a few times. But for a singer to constantly sing a really really high note like that during every live performance could take a toll on their voice. That may or may not be the case here. The only person that knows that for sure is sica.
💯 agree. A lot of people just ignore the fact that they're also a human not a robot who can sing the high note every single time. They're idols, their voices is very important to them so obviously they will take care of their voices
GWS SICAA-3
HAHA TIFFANY'S ENDING
Taeyeon WOW!
Pani ah~ go home you're drunk
I don't want to mention any group or else but the group that claimed 'nation girl group' rn cant even do the high-notes as in their own song(which consist lot of hightnotes).
They just randomly put the high-notes on their song but they never actually sing it. I mean why do you even brother to add hightnotes when you cant deliver it? Is that high-notes just a add-on or something?
This video would be proof who is the actual 'nation girl group' is. Sunny which is only lead vocal supporting Taeyeon in-and-out. And also take a notes Tiffany and Hyoyeon was not even main vocal but they know how to continue Taeyeon highnotes.
''Yeogi moyo laaaaaaaa~''
And after Taengoo's high note ...
''AHHHHHHHHHHHHH''
Keke xD
Who's watching this 2020? Just because of crappy new kpoppers of this generation bashing our Goddesses/Queens.
🙋♀️🙋♀️🙋♀️
Sica didn't sing here because she was sick...
She even had to lipsync the live performance because she wasn't feeling well..
Okay but did sooyoung just reached the high note in 1:26? She's not even in the vocal line
It was Tiffany and/or Hyoyeon :) sooyoung lip synced that part. You can see she moved the mic a little too fast and closed her mouth too fast for it to be her
@@nosananolife9894 its actually both Tiffany & Hyoyeon with supporting.
fany sings sica's very well
What makes you say that Taeyeon can't reach that note? Not questioning you, cause I have no idea about any singing techniques. But can you elaborate further on how Taeyeon wouldn't be able to do that?
actually sica has sung the highest note before..please watch 'SNSD - The Boys Encore 11 Golden Disk Award Feb26.2012 GIRLS' GENERATION 720p HD' :D
no she hit it, thats why everyone was looking in her direction
They don't need autotune at all
What the hell Tiffany 😂
LOL sooyoung and fany are just messing around with hyoyeon and seohyun.
Taeyeon jjang!!!
So, it's still an F#5 no matter what, that also doesn't change the fact that Jessica F#5>TaeYeon's F#5.
yeah right. it's just one word
sunny... ^_^
a spider pretending to be a butterfly
sunny singing jessica's part at 1:06! ^^
this video taken in s. korea right??
who said HYOYEON less popular than the others??
who said HYOYEON less popular than the others??
this is the answer for her popularity 0:54
yogi moyo daaaa~
lol YUri and Jessica imitating Seohyun xD
Jessica is sick.
1:22 i thought taeyeon noona's voice did cracked hehe
No, that's hyoyeon
Why isn't Sica singing?
She was sick
SunSica.
I THINK TAEYEON SANG LAST HIGHEST NOTE OF JESSICA'S PART
i think tae so strain
WOW,TAEYEON AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
fany singing like she is completely wasted oh ok
tiffany is drunk af....
taeyeon
Cool, I see what you mean.
It was Sooyoung.
@Squlrrel09 nah Jessica does it when it's a real performance but guess she was too lazy lol or too tired during encore. even seobaby and tiff sang Jessica's other lines.
hahahahahaha, Jessica não canta as partes dela....hahahahahahahah
Ela tava doente
TAEYEON IS THE BEST
0:13 Sunny awkward dance :3
does sica too lazy to sing hers?
X
No one sang the high note.....and jessica was sick....
There is NO WAY TaeYeon could do the High Note, even though it is an F5 there is no way TaeYeon could do the kind of frequency, not give it that kind of tone.
WHAT? why not? taeyeon has more vocal technique than jessica
@@brucish actually, Jessica had a better technique. Taeyeon is more of a natural singer. Jessica had great technique, but she was really insecure.
LZA actually jessica only sung that note live one time, taeyeon just did it with no problem, and she also did many times at their fan meetings after jessica left the group
@@lucasaugusto36 Lol. Technically wise Taeyeon is far better than Jessica.
And why would Taeyeon can't hit that note? she can hit it in her own ways. Do you expect that she will hit it like how Jessica did that note? Lmao.
TAEYEON HITS HIGH NOTE OF JESSICA IS PERFECT,JESSICA CAN'T DO IT IN LIVE
Jessica