I saw this song sang live as good if not better than this and anyone saying this is pre recorded is wrong. she was right in front of me bent down and I could hear her voice up close coming out of her mouth not out of a speaker or the mic. I was not a huge fan going into the concert, had gone with a friend but I walked out a super fan haha. she was amazingly good!
it's incredible how it involves the crowd she is not like other artists, you just do not watch the concert you sing and dance, I felt the music beyonce is so adorable with their fans ! QUEEN
Keep in mind.. 4 was not filtered and majority of the songs were recorded live and raw.. So that's why she sounds just like the track. If u listen to B'Day and then listen to 4 you'd notice the difference.
Playing the devil's advocate here, but it could very we be a pe-recored version of the track. That's the most convincing way to manage it. Thus, it's still a live version of the song, but recorded in studio standing in place verses singing on stage, dancing about, which is significantly more difficult. End and beginning are definitely live either way, though. And, either way, she's a fantastic performer.
ashrick718 Like I said, either way she's fantastic. XD Honestly even if she DOES lip sync (and if she does, she's brilliant at it - way more convincing than most bother to be) that doesn't make her any less amazing. I'm fairly sure she does a mix of both, especially on dance heavy numbers. Moving around the much while maintaining enough breath and energy to carry notes properly would be horribly stressful. xD
BartimaeusTrilogyFan Even if she did lip sync she has to have the voice to even record it...Lmao. And, i think she def is singing over pre-recorded because dancing while moving up that register would be sooooo hard o-o.
I just want to tell to Beyoncé, that I am from Hungary, and my 18th birthday present was a ticket for this tour in Zagreb. I went there with my daddy, we danced the whole time through the show, my voice was extremely weak for to days after it because of screaming the whole night :D, and i didnt even had a phone with me at the show. Love you so Much !!! I mean it really much :)
She is singing live! Went to her show in Dalls and Houston. What you guys don't see is the Moma's on the other stage singing background! I love this performance but check out why you don't love me and bow down in Houston was off the chain! You must experience her live! You will want more:0)
not going to lie, i've seen her in concert and she does lip-sync (on certain songs, generally towards the end) and someone coming from a background in music yes ARTIST USE PRE-RECORDINGS especially at concerts, their voice is tired after a while so it's necessary, now I will give it to Bey, she can sing a majority of her concerts but YES there are certain songs that are pre-recorded, Artist are also given a choice if they get sick (cause they are humans too!) to cancel the city date or to sing to pre-recordings to prevent the hassle of disappointing fans. NOW I do not care what the stans say! I LOVE BEY and you are a true fan if you acknowledge the good and bad! she is not perfect!
Well yeah I’m a BeyHive since forever and I do not care that she use pre-record tunes cuz we all know she sings lot of her songs live and for all the people that say it’s not true she admitted herself but it won’t take away her credit as a singer cause gosh she sings like an angel 👼
No they're not. At all. I believe this is live. However, the VMA performance of Love On Top IS suspiciously similar to her Roseland performance, if you listen to the audio.
***** yeah i know but think for all the love on top performances it's pre recorded because it's a very hard song to sing especially at the end when it's getting higher and higher
Was at her show in Manchester on May 8th OMG never been to a show so amazing as hers. From the word go it was nothing but non stop entertainment and I was on my feet for the whole 2 hour show! Would definitely go again
Why everyone say that she lip-sycing or not bitches please as beyoncé said put your negativity damn down and just enjoy her performance and if you know what's your problem if she lip sycing? have you ever seen her perfom acapella i just wanna say BOW DOWN
beyonce is never lip syncing ill tell you that if she does anything on this performance is SING WITH THE TRACK but what i love about this performance wheather she did or didn't i love how she always does a acapella skit at the end to show like if i wanna do this live i can so chill
Yess I agree, I listen to the Roseland and VMA performance on my ipod all the time and they are EXACTLY the same. And when she does the crowd singalong bit you can tell how different her voice is singing it love. I get why she'd do it though!
No she doesn’t this song is so hard live, and she doing too much at the same time . But sometimes she does some concerts like Coachella she did it live
2:04 huups little mistake redhead ^^ sorry im joking. i saw her concert 2 days ago and it was amazing. this is my absolute favorite song and it was an amaaaaaazing concert! thank you for this experience i could make.. i actually wait 4 years that you come to berlin.. love you!!
0:18 "Are y'all gonna put the cameras and phones down for one second and actually enjoy this moment?"
SO. TRUE.
I saw this song sang live as good if not better than this and anyone saying this is pre recorded is wrong. she was right in front of me bent down and I could hear her voice up close coming out of her mouth not out of a speaker or the mic. I was not a huge fan going into the concert, had gone with a friend but I walked out a super fan haha. she was amazingly good!
B4 I DIE, I NEED TO SEE THIS WOMAN LIVE!!
me too
I hope you have 😊
NEED
i hope you have ❤
it's incredible how it involves the crowd
she is not like other artists, you just do not watch the concert
you sing and dance, I felt the music
beyonce is so adorable with their fans ! QUEEN
She's dancing and singing amazingly. Jesus Christ, she's great.
Keep in mind.. 4 was not filtered and majority of the songs were recorded live and raw.. So that's why she sounds just like the track. If u listen to B'Day and then listen to 4 you'd notice the difference.
Playing the devil's advocate here, but it could very we be a pe-recored version of the track. That's the most convincing way to manage it. Thus, it's still a live version of the song, but recorded in studio standing in place verses singing on stage, dancing about, which is significantly more difficult. End and beginning are definitely live either way, though. And, either way, she's a fantastic performer.
BartimaeusTrilogyFan when ya'll can go on stage and do what Beyoncé does.. holla!
ashrick718 Like I said, either way she's fantastic. XD
Honestly even if she DOES lip sync (and if she does, she's brilliant at it - way more convincing than most bother to be) that doesn't make her any less amazing. I'm fairly sure she does a mix of both, especially on dance heavy numbers. Moving around the much while maintaining enough breath and energy to carry notes properly would be horribly stressful. xD
BartimaeusTrilogyFan Even if she did lip sync she has to have the voice to even record it...Lmao. And, i think she def is singing over pre-recorded because dancing while moving up that register would be sooooo hard o-o.
bloodkiller33
Near impossible I would think! Well, alright, for us mere mortals, anyway. But this IS Queen Bey, after all. :O
You can tell she isn't lip-syncing at the end of the song during the highest vocals where her vibrato is shaky.
this song gets me all the time.. Beyonce is simply awesome!!
SO WHAT SHE IS THE QUEEN SHE CAN HAVE A LITTLE BIT OF RESPECT
Mon Bilal !
Literally my only regret is never having seen this song live. I wish I could have but I guess she's not singing that in concerts anymore, Dx
I just want to tell to Beyoncé, that I am from Hungary, and my 18th birthday present was a ticket for this tour in Zagreb. I went there with my daddy, we danced the whole time through the show, my voice was extremely weak for to days after it because of screaming the whole night :D, and i didnt even had a phone with me at the show. Love you so Much !!! I mean it really much :)
Beyonce is a Queen! I love her sooo much!
Beyoncé has earned the title "QUEEN B" for a reason. 😊💝
She is singing live! Went to her show in Dalls and Houston. What you guys don't see is the Moma's on the other stage singing background! I love this performance but check out why you don't love me and bow down in Houston was off the chain! You must experience her live! You will want more:0)
not going to lie, i've seen her in concert and she does lip-sync (on certain songs, generally towards the end) and someone coming from a background in music yes ARTIST USE PRE-RECORDINGS especially at concerts, their voice is tired after a while so it's necessary, now I will give it to Bey, she can sing a majority of her concerts but YES there are certain songs that are pre-recorded, Artist are also given a choice if they get sick (cause they are humans too!) to cancel the city date or to sing to pre-recordings to prevent the hassle of disappointing fans. NOW I do not care what the stans say! I LOVE BEY and you are a true fan if you acknowledge the good and bad! she is not perfect!
I know u a whole lie girl we not talking them locally talent shows down at the Walmart : you sound Crazy.
Well yeah I’m a BeyHive since forever and I do not care that she use pre-record tunes cuz we all know she sings lot of her songs live and for all the people that say it’s not true she admitted herself but it won’t take away her credit as a singer cause gosh she sings like an angel 👼
i am IN LOVE with her outfit and the song
All the positive energy! I wish I was there :(
the vocals of this live and the vocals at the vmas she did 2 years ago are exactly the same
No they're not. At all. I believe this is live.
However, the VMA performance of Love On Top IS suspiciously similar to her Roseland performance, if you listen to the audio.
***** yeah i know but think for all the love on top performances it's pre recorded because it's a very hard song to sing especially at the end when it's getting higher and higher
01:18 checks fan.... Iconic
i love that she is ALWAYS tryna fix stuff...did u see her adjust that damn fan! she is about that life n i am personally here for allll of it.
hayyy beyonce i am so inlove with your song
one of the best singer in the universe?..tell who's another performer just like beyonce?..best singer and dancer..TOTAL PERFORMER..i LOVE YOU BEYONCE!
Preach "why wasn't I living in the moment"
Some people obviously never heard of backing vocalists...
looving this QUEEN !
My gosh she truly a performer. I love you beyonce
Was at her show in Manchester on May 8th OMG never been to a show so amazing as hers. From the word go it was nothing but non stop entertainment and I was on my feet for the whole 2 hour show! Would definitely go again
Why everyone say that she lip-sycing or not bitches please as beyoncé said put your negativity damn down and just enjoy her performance and if you know what's your problem if she lip sycing? have you ever seen her perfom acapella i just wanna say BOW DOWN
I can jam to anything by Beyonce. :) God bless you, Bey.
In tears.
She's amazing! Absolute perfection
this sound is magic
Thank u for thiz hq one. :)
My favorite Beyonce performance ever!!!
Love this song
i went to go see her the other day i cried so much i passed out shes just perfect
She's amazing as always.
beyonce is never lip syncing ill tell you that if she does anything on this performance is SING WITH THE TRACK but what i love about this performance wheather she did or didn't i love how she always does a acapella skit at the end to show like if i wanna do this live i can so chill
- i just LOVE her, amazing
I still love her even this song "Love on top" she lip-Sync it just because she's so tire from many previous songs and performance she did. :-)
Need to know what camera are you using? This is by far the clearest recording ever.
She. Is. So. Amazing!
Great Videos!
Love come first and makes love come first before everything things.
One top comment can be about calling out lost fans, but one MUST be about how AWESOMEEEEEE Beyonce forever is......!!!
This is the evidence that there will be never another Beyoncé :) She i only one and she's perfect
love the break in music @ 3:05 where the audience was singing...
a GREAT moment as artist
She is the one that I love
Okay jasmine u done said it all nothing but the truth I love how u put it
Yess I agree, I listen to the Roseland and VMA performance on my ipod all the time and they are EXACTLY the same. And when she does the crowd singalong bit you can tell how different her voice is singing it love. I get why she'd do it though!
amazing beyonce!..
She was great. And the crowd was hype!
Its definitely live, I was there and I could hear it :) Love that performance
I've always wondered if she actually sings this live every single time
I've always wondered that too. Like, she always seems lip-syncing
My queston was definitley a rethoric one. I Know she sings all the acapella parts, but it's obvious that not the whole song is live.
meagan alise roberson Yeah, i fully agree.!
She does sing it live.
No she doesn’t this song is so hard live, and she doing too much at the same time . But sometimes she does some concerts like Coachella she did it live
She is really Amazing!!!!!
Lip sycing or not great performance love it
DON'T YOU EVEN THINK ABOUT IT!!
melnjada2
Yeah, what is she talkin' about?!!
Says the one that looks like a man, ok..
Amazing crowd! Love it!
Queen >>>
ok i just cried
What can I say?? You nailed me.
OOOOOOHHHH!!!!! SHE GOT THEM TOGETHER IN THE BEGINNING!!!
QUEEN
Canta Muito!
Diva Demais Essa mulher!!!
that's what i'm talking about! loveeeee
AMAZING~~~~~~
my favorite song from 4!
♫ pa pa pa ra, pa pa pa ra ♪
love her!!!
thankyou you can tell too
She song her heart out
beyonce the queen...
Love her 💖
DIVA I LOVE SO MUCH BEY! ♥ ♥ =)
She’s another level
Yaaaasss You tell them B!!!
What kind of camera is this, it's amazing!
In theAmster we had to repeat 'you'a million time ,it was so much fun when she said , i can do this all night
WOOOW is this definitely live?? ahhahaa what a voice!!
raw talent!
2:04 huups little mistake redhead ^^
sorry im joking. i saw her concert 2 days ago and it was amazing. this is my absolute favorite song and it was an amaaaaaazing concert!
thank you for this experience i could make.. i actually wait 4 years that you come to berlin.. love you!!
everytime she changes keys at the end of the song, i get more and more goosebumps lol
yup she did!
Loving that blue jumpsuit
BTW i LOVE beyonce so much......i just comment about her voice.....'cause i put my LOVE ON TOP for her
MARAVILHOSA!
SHE'S SO FUCKING AWESOMEEEE
OMG I WAS THERE !!!! :')
I love Beyoncé Bb5
Man if I had those spots. I would be fucking going crazy. jamming out.
SHE REALLY DID SMFH
She doesn't lip sync. She doesn't have to. She can dance and still hit all the notes. That's real talent.
Just look at all the other concerts or performances
this lady knows what music is
rock in rio, N SEI SEI VOU AGUENTAR! OMG
She sings exaclty the same as she did on the vma perfomance in 2011, she is not lipsinking is she?? She is amazing!
my bby my queen
That is a beautiful audience.
how are they not freaking out I'd be jumping and hollering
Preach!
How can they just smile? I would PASS THE FUCK OUT.
This is not a prerecorded track. At the 2:09 mark, you can hear her mess up. She's says, "you're the all I need."
live!!!!