Pathetique is my favourite Beethoven sonata even though I am not a big Beethoven fan as his other compositions seem a bit too much of 'tormented soul' to me. This is a piece that I think that I can really 'get' it and 'feel' the music. Your explanation of interpretation and technique is very enlightening and inspiring. Thank you. Now my problem is, having watched some videos in your channel, I suddenly have too many pieces I want to refresh and polish again, and there is not enough time!
Great video. Thank you for your insights into the workings of the music. I am currently working to revive this piece after a few years, watching your video I realize just how much I missed with my first attempt to master this sonata.
Lovely 'masterclass'! My son is learning this currently and the way you highlight the subtle details of phrasing, intent and techniques are very valuable for young kids learning this piece. Lot of times he (and I am sure other kids as well) don't pick up on a lot of these when they are in their lesson or even during their practice. Your interpretation style is soft, subtle and sophisticated - very much appreciated Clive!
I found your tutorials a few days ago while trying to play pathetique sonata better and with more emotions, and your videos have certainly helped! Thank you so much!
This is a terrific tutorial that is comprehensive and very accessible and meaningful. Thanks very much for everything with the Pathetique tutorials on You Tube you have generously made available.
Thank you Clive for such informative tutorials - full of invaluable tips. I particularly enjoyed your explanation of circular fingering, something I'm more aware of when playing ANY piece now. Your indepth analysis of the 3 movements of the Pathetique Sonata have certainly enhanced my own interpretation of this wondrous piece.
@@pianoinsights6092 I work this piece confined to the house in France and private from my teacher. You have helped me a lot, I am very grateful to you.
I love these videos, thank you so much!!☺ even though i am just a advanced beginner and these pieces i challenge myself with are a bit to diffucult still, i still learn so much🤗🌹
Your middle c, possibly d and e-flat, have a mechanical click sound, to the key. A good tuner/tech should be able to isolate the cause and eliminate that
Thank you very much for your great tutorial lessons for pathetic sonata. It is really helpful! The teacher of Beethoven sonata on line!! I watch your videos many times when practicing. Will you do Tempest third movement?
These videos are designed for students with a working knowledge of the music. Calling out measure numbers would slow everything down unnecessarily and be very tedious for most listeners.
Pathetique is my favourite Beethoven sonata even though I am not a big Beethoven fan as his other compositions seem a bit too much of 'tormented soul' to me. This is a piece that I think that I can really 'get' it and 'feel' the music. Your explanation of interpretation and technique is very enlightening and inspiring. Thank you. Now my problem is, having watched some videos in your channel, I suddenly have too many pieces I want to refresh and polish again, and there is not enough time!
Thank you so much! Not only did your tutorial helped me interpreting the piece, it also let me admire the piece even more.
Great to hear!
Me same!
Great video. Thank you for your insights into the workings of the music. I am currently working to revive this piece after a few years, watching your video I realize just how much I missed with my first attempt to master this sonata.
This video is awesome, the interpretation really helps alot, very thorough! Thanks alot!❤
Lovely 'masterclass'! My son is learning this currently and the way you highlight the subtle details of phrasing, intent and techniques are very valuable for young kids learning this piece. Lot of times he (and I am sure other kids as well) don't pick up on a lot of these when they are in their lesson or even during their practice. Your interpretation style is soft, subtle and sophisticated - very much appreciated Clive!
Thanks so much, Anand! Your comments mean a lot to me. All the best to your son.
I found your tutorials a few days ago while trying to play pathetique sonata better and with more emotions, and your videos have certainly helped! Thank you so much!
Excellent tutorials! I watch your videos many times while practicing this piece. It's very very helpful!
Thanks, Daphne. I appreciate it.
This is a terrific tutorial that is comprehensive and very accessible and meaningful. Thanks very much for everything with the Pathetique tutorials on You Tube you have generously made available.
You're very welcome, Alan!
My son is learning this piece, and we do appreciate much the fingering and articulation tips! Thanks!
You are very welcome!
Thank you Clive for such informative tutorials - full of invaluable tips. I particularly enjoyed your explanation of circular fingering, something I'm more aware of when playing ANY piece now. Your indepth analysis of the 3 movements of the Pathetique Sonata have certainly enhanced my own interpretation of this wondrous piece.
Thanks William for your appreciation comments. My appreciation back to you for them.
Thanks for teaching this piece! I have just picked this up from years ago this definitely helps!
Well said!
Great video! Thank you very much
Thank you so much ... very rich tutorial
You're welcome!
@@pianoinsights6092 I work this piece confined to the house in France and private from my teacher. You have helped me a lot, I am very grateful to you.
It's a great way to spend time, no?
@@pianoinsights6092 Ah yes.
I'm studying this piece at the moment, really great analysis.
I love these videos, thank you so much!!☺ even though i am just a advanced beginner and these pieces i challenge myself with are a bit to diffucult still, i still learn so much🤗🌹
Excellent instruction. You are an inspiring teacher.
Thanks Shelby. I appreciate it!
Thank you so much!🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻👌🏼👌🏼👌🏼👌🏼👌🏼
Regards from India.
You are most welcome.
This is so, so good. Thank you very much.
Your middle c, possibly d and e-flat, have a mechanical click sound, to the key. A good tuner/tech should be able to isolate the cause and eliminate that
Sssoooo helpful. Thank you.
Fantastic! Very useful thank you!
Thanks so much for a great tutorial
Wonderful tutorial, thank you !
I enjoyed this video! It was very informative, and helped me to reinforce some teaching ideas as I teach this piece myself
Thanks Helene. Great feedback.
Thank you very much it really helped me❤️
Thanks a lot for the video!
A very helpful video sir. Thank you very much. Such precise instructions...I really enjoyed it :)
Good to hear. You are most welcome!
Learned a lot , thank’s !!!
Another great video! Thank you
Mille grazie, Stefano!
@@pianoinsights6092Clive, no more videos? I miss your awesome tutorial...😉
thank you so much!!!
Thanks for making this
Very good tutorial!
Thank you.
Wonderful tutorial, thank you very much. So much insight and useful advice. May I ask which model is your piano? The tone is gorgeous :)
Thank you!
You're welcome!
Thanks a lot
Thank you very much for your great tutorial lessons for pathetic sonata. It is really helpful! The teacher of Beethoven sonata on line!! I watch your videos many times when practicing. Will you do Tempest third movement?
At 4:23 I've been using pedal to cover up the chops in the RH, is that acceptable? Or do I do it without pedal and make it sound legato??
Thanks 💙
The agitated and non agitated sound the same .
I'm having trouble with the notes at the beginning of the theme where they're played so quickly it's a bit confusing to me.
I'd be happy to help you out with any specifics, Andrew.
You might also try playing back the music examples and performances at half speed.
Should have called out measures by citing measure numbers.
Are music students supposed to follow based on telepathy?
These videos are designed for students with a working knowledge of the music. Calling out measure numbers would slow everything down unnecessarily and be very tedious for most listeners.
@@pianoinsights6092 Spoken like a true classical music "ivory tower" elitist, congrats.
Thank you
What are you doing interpreting a piece if you don't know the notes?
@@pepega3344 @@pepega3344 What are you doing replying to my comment when you don't know my goal ?