At around 3:05 there's a photo of a group of men quite casually standing around three severed heads. I need to know wtf is that about? Where's the pic from and whom did the heads belong to?
They were not even alive. No one bares the sins of their ancestors. That is a rediculous notion. Besides, historically speaking, conquest is a natural phenomena. All throughout history groups of people were conquered by others. The people who did are dead and gone, so get over it.
@@clay7182He’s talking about how individuals in this comment section have a perspective to this Topic. You think he already knows this was long time ago Mr. Sherlock Gremlin Nerd. You sound hella slow ngl.
@@BitcoinBulgaria1992 I don't need to. At least in my country I don't have to worry about dying from COVID. Good luck with your 3 million cases and 60,000 deaths 😁😁
Did this man just say the French could no longer hold it down bc the region was “more organized” and “more civilized” after the French helped develop it?!?! So was it not a valid civilization before the French invaded? Whose definition of “civilized” are we using here? This is so euro-centric
Don't get upset. What he said was that the aggrieved locals were more organised and more civilised than they were when the French originally came and took over. That is what allowed them to mount a more effective resistance to French rule. He didn't say the French had brought about that advance. In fact, I believe the implication was that it was simply caused by the passage of time. _Every_ country was more civilised and more organised in 1945 than it was in 1858.
@Person Hello 1945 Vietnamese soldiers [aka Viet Minh] can not and did not beat the Japanese. Japan 8/1945 surrender to the allies after 2 atomic bombs on Nagasaki & Hiroshima..... hence Japan left vn autumn 1945.
The only genocid i know in Indochina was commit by the comunist... you should definitly learn what is a genocide but as you're probably muslim you should know very well about genocide like in India or middle east...
@2:41 So... Could I get some context on whose heads those are? Very weird thing to just show without explaining. Cause, ya know, human dead body parts on a table.
my grandpa had a pic like this from the Philippines WWII, very disturbing, he said it haunted him and he felt horrible about being apart of it, he passed in 93 or so
@@JoeHynes284 my grandpa was in Corregidor and was captured by the Japanese. He was part of the Bataan March. He had nightmares/night terrors for the rest of his life. War is hell and to see that much death is unnatural. It’s part of the reason I didn’t join the military.
The heads of those people were ethic Tay people who are native of Yen The region. The Vietnamese and the French hunted them and beheaded the Tay. Vietnamese (Kinh) had been the colonialists and oppressors in the region until the French cae
President Hồ Chí Minh declared independent in 2/9 in our Vietnam's regions from north to south not just the north as you mentioned, though the French would invade the south of Vietnam soon after but the faced serious resisstant.
@@LevisOriginal nguồn ? Việt Nam bây giờ là đất nước xã hội chủ nghĩa còn nói về luật của cộng sản thì đã tan rã sụp đổ cùng thời với liên bang Xô Viết sụp đổ rồi . Còn nếu nói Việt Nam là đất nước cộng sản từ bây giờ thì đáng lẽ ra Việt Nam nên hợp tác kinh tế thương mại với Trung Quốc và liên bang Nga chứ không phải là Hoa Kỳ ///
From the way I see it, the French came here for business. Then they saw a huge oppoturnity for a colonization. And during that colonizing process they accidentally helped to liberate the country
@@JoeHynes284 interference? so Indochina was better off when it was being brutalized by Siam and then the communist thugs who took over from the French?
@@califtom actually Yes everybody would of assimilated into one culture and peoples, Thais, Laotians and Cambodians all one big family you could only imagine
@@everydaysoopsaaah yea I'm real sure the same people who spent centuries fighting each other would have lived together as one happy family. You're clueless. The Siam Empire trashed Angkor Wat and enslaved literally the entire population of Vientienne. Some happy family eh?
Indochine fascinates me, from history to architecture...Im Australian born to immigrants but have lived 90% of my life in South East Asia... It amazes me the wokes that are completely detrimental to Colonialism. It had its place in history beit positive or negative. But what is certain that NOBODY CAN DENY is that South East Asia has always been and will "ALWAYS" be "ENDEMICALLY CORRUPT" both politically, culturally and in any other way you want to place a label on it in EVERY SEGMENT OF SOCIETY. If it was not for Colonialism, South East Asia would be like Africa is today, a fractured war torn part of the world that would & could never become ANYTHING like Europe !!!!! I love South East Asia and it is my home, my children are South East Asians & they see first hand at the racism i endure because of my crime being born "WHITE".... There are "ALWAYS" 2 sides to a coin....
Too bad this history told in this clip doesn’t outline how the Hmong were vital to the French imperial empire and the Laos Kingdom during world war 2 against the Japanese, to the locals it was called the Japanese War. Because of some guerrilla Hmong local forces who saved the king because the French and Laos cowered, the Hmong became recognized citizens of Laos. The facts are out there, this summary in the video glosses over a lot. By the time they were recognized, a 13 year old Vang Pao would enlist in the Hmong Army, later recruited into the French army and CIA which led to the Secret War in Laos otherwise in Laos known as a Civil War which was happening in tandem with the Vietnam War.
@Sami Ahmed , i agree with you, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/M%E1%BB%B9_Tr%E1%BA%A1ch_massacre >> >The My Trach Massacre (Vietnamese: Thảm sát Mỹ Trạch') was a massacre of Vietnamese civilians carried out by the French army during French rule in Vietnam. The massacre occurred in Mỹ Trạch village, Mỹ Thủy commune, Lệ Thủy District, Quảng Bình Province, Vietnam from 12 pm to 2 am on 29 November 1947. In this operation, 326 houses were burnt. Many women were raped by the French soldiers before being killed. Over 300 civilian residents in Mỹ Trạch were killed, of whom 170 were women and 157 were children. Many entire families were killed. The location of the massacre was in the foot of Mỹ Trạch Bridge, a bridge on the North-South Railway, next to Mỹ Trạch Railway Station. The victims were forced to the foot of the bridge and lined up before being killed with machine gun fire. Nearly half of the village's residents were killed in this massacre. Every year, 29 November is mourned as "Hatred Date" by the residents in this village. The memorial park in which the memorial site is located was classified by the Ministry of Culture of Vietnam as one of the National Historical Relics of Vietnam on 27 December 2001.[1]
I'd recommend 1.25 speed
Thanks
I needed .75
Thx
@@brigitalarsen7335 1.5
Thanks
At around 3:05 there's a photo of a group of men quite casually standing around three severed heads. I need to know wtf is that about? Where's the pic from and whom did the heads belong to?
I know right
Some people say its _Tay peoples_
They been hunted by racist vietnam who helped by european white colonialist back then.
They enslaved the Indochinese and called it helping the natives "more civilized".
Bạn nói chính xác ! đó là lí do tại sao người bản xứ họ đã đứng lên chống lại ách đô hộ tàn bạo của thực dân
They did not enslave them but forced labour did occur unfortunately.
How could this narrator stay awake for the whole 5 minutes and 28 seconds?
2:50 there is a ghost in the back
Angry Soul of beheaded man.
@Justin Y. what ? 😫
Dammn europeions.they conquer innocent counties get resources and make people slave.good battle has been gave by vitetnameese.respect and brave people
Learn english first, then comment 🤣
Vae victus
Looking at the comments, I realized that the French do not have the slightest remorse for the Vietnamese.
@georgesj.5995 Americans, French, Italians, Spanish, Portuguese, British, they all treated Asians and Africans as objects, and I won't forgive them.
They were not even alive. No one bares the sins of their ancestors. That is a rediculous notion. Besides, historically speaking, conquest is a natural phenomena. All throughout history groups of people were conquered by others. The people who did are dead and gone, so get over it.
Just like Algeria, or British with Australian aborigines, that’s white people for ya
@@clay7182He’s talking about how individuals in this comment section have a perspective to this Topic. You think he already knows this was long time ago Mr. Sherlock Gremlin Nerd.
You sound hella slow ngl.
The heads of those people were ethic Tay people who are native of Yen The region. The Vietnamese and the French hunted them and beheaded the Tay
The heads are Hoang Hoa Tham rebelians after 30 years ressistant, the france take a picture for newspapers in france for celebration.
why is there like no documentary about french colonization of vietnam?
because asian people are proud and don't need you to cry about them?
@@BitcoinBulgaria1992 or probably because colonizers want to hide their past.
@@nguyenbaokhiem6728 you need to cry baby?
@@BitcoinBulgaria1992 I don't need to. At least in my country I don't have to worry about dying from COVID. Good luck with your 3 million cases and 60,000 deaths 😁😁
@@nguyenbaokhiem6728 vietnam is just ugly thailand
Did this man just say the French could no longer hold it down bc the region was “more organized” and “more civilized” after the French helped develop it?!?! So was it not a valid civilization before the French invaded? Whose definition of “civilized” are we using here? This is so euro-centric
@Maël he got the point
Don't get upset. What he said was that the aggrieved locals were more organised and more civilised than they were when the French originally came and took over. That is what allowed them to mount a more effective resistance to French rule. He didn't say the French had brought about that advance. In fact, I believe the implication was that it was simply caused by the passage of time. _Every_ country was more civilised and more organised in 1945 than it was in 1858.
@Person Hello 1945 Vietnamese soldiers [aka Viet Minh] can not and did not beat the Japanese. Japan 8/1945 surrender to the allies after 2 atomic bombs on Nagasaki & Hiroshima..... hence Japan left vn autumn 1945.
just to re confirm what your saing
all history written in English,
is by nature, euro-centric
@D Anemon most of this part of the world did not have modern militaries until being confronted by western power in the 19th century...yes?
France commit genocide in Indochina and it was never acknowledge.
They were ruthless
France has gotten away with a lot of shit, let's be real. They still have neo colonies in west Africa trapped in debt
The only genocid i know in Indochina was commit by the comunist... you should definitly learn what is a genocide but as you're probably muslim you should know very well about genocide like in India or middle east...
@@cyril6574 communist this communist that my asss
@@zPePhungz Vietcong
Vietnamese had been active colonialists and oppressors in the region until France came
Oh! That is good.
@2:54, 3 heads cut off AND on display, obviously for someone's sick mind?
@2:41 So... Could I get some context on whose heads those are? Very weird thing to just show without explaining. Cause, ya know, human dead body parts on a table.
my grandpa had a pic like this from the Philippines WWII, very disturbing, he said it haunted him and he felt horrible about being apart of it, he passed in 93 or so
Easy. Could be heads of rebels or troublemakers or both
@@JoeHynes284 my grandpa was in Corregidor and was captured by the Japanese. He was part of the Bataan March. He had nightmares/night terrors for the rest of his life. War is hell and to see that much death is unnatural. It’s part of the reason I didn’t join the military.
probably heads of peasant unionists trying to get a better deal for their labor on French Plantations...Michelin
The heads of those people were ethic Tay people who are native of Yen The region. The Vietnamese and the French hunted them and beheaded the Tay. Vietnamese (Kinh) had been the colonialists and oppressors in the region until the French cae
President Hồ Chí Minh declared independent in 2/9 in our Vietnam's regions from north to south not just the north as you mentioned, though the French would invade the south of Vietnam soon after but the faced serious resisstant.
I'm thinking the USA pushed the French to stay.
Từ 2/9/1945 tới bây giờ 2022 người Việt Nam vẫn sống trong áp bức khi bị chủ nghĩa cộng sản cai trị.
@@LevisOriginal thôi thôi ba que câm mẹ mồm đi
@@LevisOriginal Oh shut up you learn nothing of history. If it no the Communist would you bow down to the French.
@@LevisOriginal nguồn ? Việt Nam bây giờ là đất nước xã hội chủ nghĩa còn nói về luật của cộng sản thì đã tan rã sụp đổ cùng thời với liên bang Xô Viết sụp đổ rồi . Còn nếu nói Việt Nam là đất nước cộng sản từ bây giờ thì đáng lẽ ra Việt Nam nên hợp tác kinh tế thương mại với Trung Quốc và liên bang Nga chứ không phải là Hoa Kỳ
///
votre miniature ne montre pas une ambition de réconciliation
That picture omg...
2：50 shows how civilized the french were.
From the way I see it, the French came here for business. Then they saw a huge oppoturnity for a colonization. And during that colonizing process they accidentally helped to liberate the country
@@levinh9294 that is probably a true statement for all western interference in this part of the world
@@JoeHynes284 interference? so Indochina was better off when it was being brutalized by Siam and then the communist thugs who took over from the French?
@@califtom actually Yes everybody would of assimilated into one culture and peoples, Thais, Laotians and Cambodians all one big family you could only imagine
@@everydaysoopsaaah yea I'm real sure the same people who spent centuries fighting each other would have lived together as one happy family. You're clueless. The Siam Empire trashed Angkor Wat and enslaved literally the entire population of Vientienne. Some happy family eh?
Vive la France 🇨🇵
Vive l'Indochine Française 🇨🇵 🇻🇳 🇱🇦 🇰🇭
They enslaved the Indochinese and called it helping the natives "more civilized".
@@ww3297 and you killed them because they are communist
Who is the most stupid between you and i
@@ww3297 Vae Victus...
Vive l'indochine française perle de l'empire 🇨🇵
@@ww3297 Vietnamese treating native Cham, Degar, Cambodian..
@@cyril6574 Việt Nam là quốc gia độc lập không phải của Pháp
Indochine fascinates me, from history to architecture...Im Australian born to immigrants but have lived 90% of my life in South East Asia...
It amazes me the wokes that are completely detrimental to Colonialism.
It had its place in history beit positive or negative.
But what is certain that NOBODY CAN DENY is that South East Asia has always been and will "ALWAYS" be "ENDEMICALLY CORRUPT" both politically, culturally and in any other way you want to place a label on it in EVERY SEGMENT OF SOCIETY.
If it was not for Colonialism, South East Asia would be like Africa is today, a fractured war torn part of the world that would & could never become ANYTHING like Europe !!!!!
I love South East Asia and it is my home, my children are South East Asians & they see first hand at the racism i endure because of my crime being born "WHITE"....
There are "ALWAYS" 2 sides to a coin....
Great documentary.
How?
I love history
#hmong
Too bad this history told in this clip doesn’t outline how the Hmong were vital to the French imperial empire and the Laos Kingdom during world war 2 against the Japanese, to the locals it was called the Japanese War. Because of some guerrilla Hmong local forces who saved the king because the French and Laos cowered, the Hmong became recognized citizens of Laos. The facts are out there, this summary in the video glosses over a lot. By the time they were recognized, a 13 year old Vang Pao would enlist in the Hmong Army, later recruited into the French army and CIA which led to the Secret War in Laos otherwise in Laos known as a Civil War which was happening in tandem with the Vietnam War.
Imagine vietnamese comfort women to the french
French comfort women to the Germans.
@@roskcity German comfort woman to French
@@lullul6180 German comfort women to the Soviets.
@@roskcity 🤮
@@lullul6180 Soviet comfort woman to the Germans.
Combodian ?
No
Yes
LOL the French more Civilized LOL.
The Nazis treated the occupied French more humanely more than the French did to their subjects
.
?
@@syafsmith5085 bullshit
@georgesj.5995
Nos vale verga, toda acción es juzgada, y pagaran con sangre l que hicieron hace 70 años.
SOURCE OF INCOME///40% CASH CROP///
oof no one commented
The French established "indochina". Why were the French there? Money.
... and ...?
These head belonged to Khmer people...
Congrats on France for the only country in history to conqueror Vietnam
Ehem - China
@@chaoticneutral7573 not all of it just the northern part
@@thequestioner5916 What about Japan?
@@matthewtolentino5141 that was part of France and not when Vietnam was a country
Shame on France for the only country conquered Vietnam.
Cruel and inhumane!
greedy of french to make it here.
OMG////
!!!!!
omg 3:04
indonesian & china = indochina
it's india and China not indonesia
There are lies french people wouldn't do this, they love us
@Sami Ahmed french xere not racist
Look at 2:40 in the rigth they are a Viet
@Sami Ahmed , i agree with you, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/M%E1%BB%B9_Tr%E1%BA%A1ch_massacre >> >The My Trach Massacre (Vietnamese: Thảm sát Mỹ Trạch') was a massacre of Vietnamese civilians carried out by the French army during French rule in Vietnam. The massacre occurred in Mỹ Trạch village, Mỹ Thủy commune, Lệ Thủy District, Quảng Bình Province, Vietnam from 12 pm to 2 am on 29 November 1947. In this operation, 326 houses were burnt. Many women were raped by the French soldiers before being killed. Over 300 civilian residents in Mỹ Trạch were killed, of whom 170 were women and 157 were children. Many entire families were killed.
The location of the massacre was in the foot of Mỹ Trạch Bridge, a bridge on the North-South Railway, next to Mỹ Trạch Railway Station. The victims were forced to the foot of the bridge and lined up before being killed with machine gun fire.
Nearly half of the village's residents were killed in this massacre. Every year, 29 November is mourned as "Hatred Date" by the residents in this village.
The memorial park in which the memorial site is located was classified by the Ministry of Culture of Vietnam as one of the National Historical Relics of Vietnam on 27 December 2001.[1]
@@leroiarouf1142 On est partout
@@leroiarouf1142 this photo is the equivalent of saying "I have black friends"
@@nguyenbaokhiem6728 shut of fuck up
there was basically no history, no organized civilization before the french in other words
No history? So you don't know about Indochina history.
That’s not true. Every place has history.
ahhaha stupid overseas vietnamese french apologist with an inferiority complex
@Khiêm Nguyễn but not too long compare Dutch , British , Spain in Asean
I am a Vietnamese-American, but I despise the French occupation. They brought nothing but humiliation and shame.