Despite all the attacks on the religion...it's such a miracle that Hinduism survived to this day...i feel so thankful to our forefathers who despite the threat to their lives refused to convert or carried the religion and kept it alive !
@@seemaseema9720 they did not kill them like what peacefools did. You need read a few books to enlighten yourself. I agree that there was a serious class division amongst hindus and dalits were treated bad. But, I will blame british as well for this as they segregated people based on profession (caste for brits). For more details read "Breaking India" book written by Rajiv Malhotra.
WHAT IS NEW? Barkha Dutt and khan market have been trying this all the time but now they are countered by qualified historians with such facts that expose false narratives of Barkha types are shattered
As all Muslim rulers were. Don't you see, even today these Muslims claim to be of Turkish or Iranian origin. What do you think the attitude of these kings would have been?
He was born in Devanahalli and spoke Kannada. Common sense would say that makes him a Kannadiga. But common sense evades many people. especially sanatanis.
The very fact that Muslim fundamentalists and bigots love Tipu itself should tell something. Do they live Tipu because he was kind and accommodating to the native Hindus? No. It’s because he tormented Hindus.
Lol no peiece of shit we love tipu cause he had done something which hindu rajas can't able to do And side note why do you f ucking love savarkar cause he wrote apology to the Britishers or cause bigot spit hate against muslims lol
True, Tippu was a cult jihadi who oppressed non muslims, but other hindu kings were no better since they were as bigoted and oppressed the dalits or untouchables.. in fact untouchedables were treated even worse by other hindus.. they couldn’t even walk anywhere near the upper ruling castes
@danm7523 no matter how bad or good were hindu kings...but they were our own...hayder and tipu had foreign ancestors and top of that they were muslims Jihadi muslim...that's enough to hate them. If I have chosen between the two i would choose hindu kings over these circumcised muslims.
@@danm7523 don't try to play a strawman argument here. It's not about hindu kings but hindu society in general. I can give however give three examples here which are interesting. Shivaji Maharaj, the people's king which is revered both by high caste Hindus and dalits, even today. Second was the kakatiyas of warangal who were proud shudra kings. And yes the Mauryas who were low born caste of peacock trainers.
@@danm7523then jihadis are more worse bcos they also oppressed Dalits and untouchables. Historians don't talk about this. But lower castes are the victims of jihad. Our ancestors have fought bravely against jihadis and bcos of them today we are fortunate to be a Hindu
Barkha tried to justify Tipu's genocide of Brahmins as being pro Dalits and showed him as inclusive 🎉but Vikram Sampath demolished the bigoted leftist arguments
Sanjay Khan fed false narrative to the country about Tipu through his Doordarshan aired 'Sword of Tipu Sultan'. Kudos to Vikram Sampath for his courage to defy that belief through his well-researched book, supported by citations. I am in awe of this author
I have heard lots of tales of Tipu's cruelties from our ancestors who lived in north Kerala. He was an out and out Jihadi who converted Hindus forcibly, and destroyed and looted Hindu temples.
yes, yes, even i heard that he use to go to mysore bakery to get mysore pak in his royal enfied bullet. he did not even share petrol with local hindus and chiristians there, cruel man this tippu, thank god that we are discussing tippu here,, after 500 years of his death. remember barkha dutt is employed you are not
Were you there?? It's just a story which you people have cooked as always....but we all saw the garlanding of the rapists and those rejoicing it...clearly shows their character
@@nagabhushanar.s6113in kannada?? that will be the most biased history...the harsh truth is that history is always written by the victors...do you really think that wodiyar puppets and their masters the british will want anything good written of their usurpers and opponents?...even in the interview when asked about positives of tipu sultan Vikram sampath cleverly uses words like probably, might be making it unsure and yet he ruled for 17 years without having social harmony at large and order in his kingdom?? Quite unlikely..
@@alta429 So you mean to say, literally everyone is lying and we are supposed to just believe what you say because you love Tipu and follow the same religion as him?? Sure 🤡
@@ThePolymerisstthere are a lot of contradictions among historians let alone the fairy tales of the masses....actually the majority community is a class apart in building false narratives but at any rate there are a lot of contradictions among historians as mentioned before...and you don't have to hate him just because he is not of your religion 🤡
Tipu fought with Britishers he is freedom fighter...so by this logic French and Portuguese also fought with Britishers so give them also freedom fighter tag....what nonsensical and illogical, madarsachaap knowledge 😅😂😂
500000 Hindus of Kashmir were evicted under Pak policy of Raliv, Chaliv t Galiv= Convert , Runaway or Die during 7th & last migration in 1990 .Property looted , women raped & men killed . Hindu population in Kashmir reduced in 800 years from 100% in 1320 to .001% in 2024.
A muslim zealot, a ruthless ruler who came from outside without being able to have a connect with the very people whom he ruled, the ill-luck or misfortune of the then Mysore that an alien ruler was forced on them.....not a loved king. That is Tipu Sultan. The tragedy is that the Muslims in Karnataka, and elsewhere in India, have idolised him, given him an iconic status and made a hero out of him, because he was a muslim and was a ruler of a Hindu Kingdom. The political parties like Congress and the communist intellectual and historians distorted and procrustreated and cherrypicked facts to suit their narrative and for appeasement of the Muslims for electoral gains. How can a usurper of throne, a foreigner who believed in the supremacy of his religion..... be considered a hero, though he was a part of the history of which we Kannadigas would be ashamed of.
There is nothing redeeming or glorious about Tipu Sultan in the entire conversation that Tipu Sultan lived and died for his country and people but there are evidence that he wanted to perpetuate his rule and seek islamisation of his kingdom through cruelty like the Mughal rulers of north India. Thanks to Dr.Vikram Sampath for presenting the true history of this Muslim ruler whose Jayanthi the misguided politicians and people with vested interest want to celebrate.
YeS he WaS for British east india Co., for The Kaodva Chickveerajendra of Nalakanda lWho run from Brirish Later her daughter was taken by English men & Converted her to Victoria GowrammA... Hope Neo 2014 India Historiyan Vikram sampath may write about Nalkanda palace histroy which stand till today near KAKABE coorg..srinivas stop taking GyaN from Wattsupp University..
@@shabanawahab6317It's not him who is taking Gyan from WhatsApp university. It's people like u who are born & bred from that university... Tipu was an enemy to Hindus. him recruiting a few Hindus in his administration doesn't mean he was some saint.. What his father Hyder Ali did to the Wodeyars is what Mir Sadiq did to Tipu? If Mir Sadiq was a Gaddar then Hyder Ali was a bigger Gaddar...
@@shabanawahab6317Vikram Sampath is a well researched Historian. Even Sashi Tharoor learns from him. Just because u got used to the Fictionalized version that Glorifies Islamic Rulers for too long it won't be easy for people like u to digest actual fact based point of view...
True, Tippu was a cult jihadi who oppressed non muslims, but other hindu kings were no better since they were as bigoted and oppressed the dalits or untouchables.. in fact untouchedables were treated even worse by other hindus.. they couldn’t even walk anywhere near the upper ruling castes
@@danm7523 Glad that people like you are voicing out ur opinions. Tipu was the Religious fundamentalist who wanted to establish a theological state. He even sought help from the Ottomans. British & Tipu both were enemies of the Hindus, but at least the Britishers handed the power back to the original rulers of Mysore..
Burkha tried her best to ignore the atrocities done by Tipu and put him in good light as expected. However Vikram made it clear that Tipu was indeed a cruel bigot. Personally, I have evidence right in front of my house. The idol in the Siva temple in front of my house was attacked and broken by Tipu. There is no reason to celebrate Tipu in India and anyone does that must be considered anti-national.
The more Barkha tried to get it attested that "At least Tipu did stood up to the British ..., died fighting the British ..." again and again, Each time Mr. Sampat gave her a patient thrashing destroying it with facts and argument. Great Respect for you Sir 🙏
Great interview Barkha. Please also look at the comments section below. You won't find a single person who supports the Cong claim that Tipu was a great person
1. Vikram and Aniruddha are coming up as young historians doing amazing evidence based work on the Indian history and demolishing the myths and deeply biased historical narratives. Of course, sickulars cannot stand them!! But they are rendering yeoman's service to the cause and enriching our understanding of Indian history. 2. Vikram talks sweet and smooth but he pierces the hearts and brains of sickulars with devastating effects!!!! he he!! 3. Sickulars have to project some Muslims rulers from our medieval / modern history as Muslim role models for politicking but there are hardly anyone who could eulogized except perhaps Tipu on a thin ground that he fought against the British.
When there are heaps of records in Mysore & Malabar gazettes, many historians from Karnataka and Kerala and records maitained by Britishers of the time , to testify the true nature of Hyder or Tippu , we need not ask for Burkha Dutt, for any kind of certificates. There need be no doubts of any Muslim invaders , Sultans, Emperors ever being considerate to their Hindu subjects or hapless victims of their monsterous invasions or rules. All were equally cruel and monsterous while dealing with Hindus. It is and IS the " dharma of the " Prophet.Doing some offering to a temple or employing a Kafir , was only a way of buying peace for the interrugnm before the next attack. This was the dictum of all the invaders. Dont, make a mistake, this is true even for our times. Let us be conscious, day & night. VIGIL for saving the hard earned freedom from Muslim & British rule.
I truly appreciate Barkha for giving the presenter time to explain his point of view and never once did she interrupt or interject ...this is something that other podcast hosts can learn from Barkha ....
A very good insight into this tyrant who was painted as a great patriot in my childhood days! Obviously those days were completely in control of communal divisive alliance of congress, communists and fanatic peacefuls
As soon as she heard the word Bramhin, the leftist within her suddenly had an upsurge, she literally responded like here is my chance😂😂 but sampath I think is used to such leftist bigotry so he has dogded her successfully.
I am from Karnataka tippu sulatan is mass murderer and he done forceful conversation and what not the local kannadigas know how cruel he was now some muslims are defending him it us anti humanity how are defending tippu and his father but Dr.Vikram Sampath book give us true history of tippu and his religious bigotry and in one sentence tippu is " hardcore Islamic radical "
After,Partition,Tipu even should not be matter off discussion ,and look this bastrad congress which allowed serial of Tipu sultan,we should learn from Pakistan they just not accept truth of past for their existence and here this nasty Congress regime,made hindu to forget truth of past
Nothing matters. For marxist historians, congress and Muslims there's only one binary Muslims- secular Hindus- religious bigot 😂😂 "How do tou reconcile destruction of temples with grants given to temples" BJP is seen as party with a prejudice against muslims. But bjp govt gives large grants to madrasas and plans for muslims. Will burkha ever take that point to say BJP is secular and loves muslims? 🤔🤔 So why the double standards?
This highly decorated writer had authored many best sellers. I am immensely grateful to you, Barkhajee for initiating him for a tete-a-tete with this famous author. Thanks from the bottom of my heart and i really mean it
As for the Bogus theory of Tipu being 'freedom fighter '-: Tipu befriended and employed the formidable French and other Europeans to his active assistance. The French at that time under Napoleon were horribly dangerous to the Indian states. If fate would turn into the French favor, India would be more miserably doomed to servitude and horrific Catholic cultural imposition than the English in guise of parliamentary restrictions. So when the Marathas had sided with the English for a while, Tipu favored the French entirely. Napoleon had sent an army to invade India, however, India was saved by his engagement in the Egyptian land and the superior preparation of the English to face the danger in India. Please read simple history books, it all consisted with there 🙏
valuable conversation. thank you both Barkha and Vikram. just wish Barkha would actually look at Vikram while he is answering her questions instead of being distracted by looking at something in front of her.
Hyder Ali initially sought friendship with the British but they didnt trust him because he had already betrayed the mysuru rulers, what was the guarantee that he will not betray them.
Tipu is indeed a polarizing figure. He exhibited different shades of his personality In each place he was in. The region I belong to, the Kongu region of TN was under indirect Mysorean rule since the time of Dalawai Nanjaraja. The local chieftains paid kisht and they were allowed to rule the country side and small towns while major cities such as coimbatore, Erode and Salem housed Mysorean military outposts and civil administrators(largely composed of locals). Here he is seen in a positive light. He also roped in a Kongu chieftain (Dheeran Chinnamalai) in his struggle against the British. His men trained in Tipu's army and Dheeran even carried on his fight against the British even after the demise of Tipu. He is generally seen by the population here as a "Friend of Tipu". But when I speak to my colleagues from the Kodagu or Malabar region, their account of Tipu varies completely. We have no such contradictory views when it comes to his father, Hyder Ali. He is seen even by his detractors only as a usurper and not as a religious zealot.
How a person who is faithful to the French and the Khalifa of bagdad is our freedom fighter. He is just a ruler of a region that was captured by his father and he just wanted to enjoy is rule by hook or crook.
It is almost as if Barkha is disappointed at truth surfacing with scathing proof. How easily we were served blatant lies about so many and lured into revering and respecting such tyranical characters. Sanjay Khan goes on to immortalise a tyrant in his TV serial probably deleberately to shield his actions. So much misiformation.
Thanks to "chacha Nehru" who promoted & granted scholarship to Progressive Writer's Association. Which later responsible for all the "left wing" narrative in films and books.
India's recent history has so many stories where (1) Muslim rulers were oppressive towards Hindus (2) Hindus undermined muslim rulers by supporting European powers, like the Portugese first and the British later, and (3) Europeans took full advantage, essentially siphoning out all of India's wealth and (4) The British went one level lower - essentially destroying all Indian industry, using Indian soldiers to conquer Africa/China, and levying oppressive taxes (something similar to what muslim rulers were doing in the first place). So what can we learn from this?
Seems like didi is fond of Tiplu. Strange obsession from dreams. Tiplu was megalomaniac, arrogant, tyrant & a hardcore radical Ghadi. His attrocities still pains & troubles our Hindu brothers & sisters
Frankly, it is very very unlikely of Burkha to discuss a book that shows Tipu as a jihadi. If she does, it would be only to resurrect him into a whitewashed version. I opened the clip just to confirm my suspicions. I am right, Burkha proved to be Burkha. No point in watching rest of the clip. I am abandoning it, half the way. Zebra may lose stripes and snake its fangs, but not Burkha, she will always be a Jihadi lover.😢😢
@@uk2261 kabhi nahi sudharoge. Imaan se dimagh me gobar bhar jatha hai. Imaan chodo aur insaniyath ki badho aur Ilm leaao. Kithaab ko phenko aur Gyaan ko apnaao
Being my maternal side from Mysore, I have heard a lot of what Vikram Sampath said about Unnecessarily hyping this person who has looted the state and did only wrong doing !!
Ms D made a great start' Tipu made grants & 1000 gold coins to Hindus temple, symbol of resistance against British la la" but flustered, speechless Ms Dutta face's was a sight,at being defeated by Mr Sampath articulate rebuttal backed up with factual, evidence based information one after the other,setting the record straight. The duel was fun to watch. Though Mr S broke promise given to his late mother (whom he reveres all the time) and wrote this magnanimous book, but I doubt (though hope) the book is going to change anything academically, socially or politically. Saving grace for the leftist and they can continue with their bigotry🙄.
Always pleasure listening Vikram Sampath ji although not a fan of Barkha. But I feel of late she has ditched her narrow minded ness a little and has started giving space to people from opposite spectrum as well
Why is there a controversy regarding the intent of the Muslim invaders? Their autobiography and the biographies written by them or their associates very clearly states that their primary aim is to spread Islam. Mulfuzat Tumuri , of the invader, Taimur, should be a mandatory reading in every school and college
@@Paulsmiththea .. Yes , Islamic invaders mention their act of invasion , killing kaffir and temple destruction as pride in their books and biographies .
I'm just fan of his work ethics and reference,truths and myths blast done by our old-age person 😂soon after independence many things are misplaced no evidence ,no point in articulations and worst part is we blindly followed this about 75 years without arguments may be some agends by some of people I'm proud these things happening,Tippu is king no doubt bt what he done what happned in history past and how these are things came should be aware ,people of Indians should be cautious bcz nowdays social media also came with one side story these kind of people are much needed TQ U MR Sampath ji , EXPLORE INDIA , ANCIENT INDIA by ur books are much needed ❤❤❤❤
Anachronism is the greatest enemy of critical history. As far as possible we should refrain from identifying with historical persona or debunking them on the basis of our prejudices. By the way, Tipu also wrote for support to the Marathas and the Nizam saying clearly that his defeat would mean the victory of the hat wearers and the defeat of pagri wearers. Tipu remains an interesting 18th century ruler in many ways. I have gone through his record of dreams and there is no doubt that he saw himself as an 'ideal' Muslim ruler, whatever that meant in the 18th Century. A good interview.
Anyone who fight British gets labeled as Patriot... Exactly why Xavier is seen as saint and many colleges run, even though Portuguese were way much more brutal to locals than British
I anticipated this foul play of Sampath when he downplayed the achievement of Tipu against British. He cleverly puts Haider to sound politically correct. The fact is at the following battle Tipu inflicted upon British the biggest defeat till then. --------- The Battle of Pollilur (a.k.a. Pullalur), also known as the Battle of Polilore or Battle of Perambakam, took place on 10 September 1780 at Pollilur near Conjeevaram, the city of Kanchipuram in present-day Tamil Nadu state, India, as part of the Second Anglo-Mysore War. It was fought between an army commanded by King Tipu Sultan of the Kingdom of Mysore, and a British East India Company force led by William Baillie.
Barkha: I was once enchanted with your left of the center journalism but the Neera Radia tapes destroyed that. I would request you to broadcast your POV ( as a journalist and not a victim). People are smart enough to read between the lines ( obviously people would judge you). Would request for the truth.
Despite all the attacks on the religion...it's such a miracle that Hinduism survived to this day...i feel so thankful to our forefathers who despite the threat to their lives refused to convert or carried the religion and kept it alive !
@@YG-ci9pg not a miracle
It is because of weapons and ammunition our ancestors survived this continuous murderous campaigns by two religions
Mangalorean Christians and North Kerala Hindus haven't forgotten the atrocities perpetrated by Tippu Sulthan.
Mangalorean Christians were massacred by this violent fellow Tipu.
@@Vdbail Just like Dalits have not forgotten the atrocities of Sanatanis?
@@seemaseema9720 just like how they were kicked out of Pakistan soon after independence. Just like how they were treated by muslims in Kashmir.
@@seemaseema9720 they did not kill them like what peacefools did. You need read a few books to enlighten yourself. I agree that there was a serious class division amongst hindus and dalits were treated bad. But, I will blame british as well for this as they segregated people based on profession (caste for brits). For more details read "Breaking India" book written by Rajiv Malhotra.
@@seemaseema9720 Abdul come up with ur original id!
Barkha Dutt tried to bring out some positive points about Tipu Sultan but Mr Vikram has set the record straight with factual information.
There is a reason she is called "Burkha Dutt"
WHAT IS NEW? Barkha Dutt and khan market have been trying this all the time but now they are countered by qualified historians with such facts that expose false narratives of Barkha types are shattered
Burqa Butt-Drabu. She had a steaming affair with a Kashmiri separatist Haseeb Drabu, who was also tainted in J & K Bank Scam.
She is traitor of Kargil. Never forget that.
Ultra leftist Barkha Dutt criticized BJP and Modi for 20 yrs. To gain viewership, she has suddenly become centerist.
Honestly speaking, Tipu was not even a native Kannadiga. He fought the British but he himself was an outsider in the land he ruled.
As all Muslim rulers were. Don't you see, even today these Muslims claim to be of Turkish or Iranian origin. What do you think the attitude of these kings would have been?
He fought the British not as a liberator but for his throne.
He was born in Devanahalli and spoke Kannada. Common sense would say that makes him a Kannadiga. But common sense evades many people. especially sanatanis.
@@seemaseema9720you're one too😂 just that someone converted you few years ago doesn't change who you are😂
@@vvshetty1 Dude. Get better soon. When that happens. write carefully so that you do not massacre grammar and logic.
The very fact that Muslim fundamentalists and bigots love Tipu itself should tell something. Do they live Tipu because he was kind and accommodating to the native Hindus? No. It’s because he tormented Hindus.
Lol no peiece of shit we love tipu cause he had done something which hindu rajas can't able to do
And side note why do you f ucking love savarkar cause he wrote apology to the Britishers or cause bigot spit hate against muslims lol
@patmclaughlin107: you analysed very correctly.
List of Exmuslims Channel:
1) Ex-Muslim sahil
2) Exmuslim Sameer
3) Adam seeker
4) Exmuslim Sachwala 5) Suleimani Zalebiya
6) Zafar Heretics
7) Apostate the Imam
8) Exmuslim Angel
9) Imam Wala Kafir
10) pretty human
And the fact that Vikram Sampath was threatened with death for reading letters is a testimony to the nature of Izzzlam and Muzzzlims.
Tipu was a top level jihadi.
True, Tippu was a cult jihadi who oppressed non muslims, but other hindu kings were no better since they were as bigoted and oppressed the dalits or untouchables.. in fact untouchedables were treated even worse by other hindus.. they couldn’t even walk anywhere near the upper ruling castes
@danm7523 no matter how bad or good were hindu kings...but they were our own...hayder and tipu had foreign ancestors and top of that they were muslims Jihadi muslim...that's enough to hate them. If I have chosen between the two i would choose hindu kings over these circumcised muslims.
@@danm7523 don't try to play a strawman argument here. It's not about hindu kings but hindu society in general. I can give however give three examples here which are interesting. Shivaji Maharaj, the people's king which is revered both by high caste Hindus and dalits, even today. Second was the kakatiyas of warangal who were proud shudra kings. And yes the Mauryas who were low born caste of peacock trainers.
@@danm7523then jihadis are more worse bcos they also oppressed Dalits and untouchables. Historians don't talk about this. But lower castes are the victims of jihad. Our ancestors have fought bravely against jihadis and bcos of them today we are fortunate to be a Hindu
Shivaji Maharaj had muslim bodyguard.when shivaji was not communal why should his supporters be? @@vinod.19
Barkha tried to justify Tipu's genocide of Brahmins as being pro Dalits and showed him as inclusive 🎉but Vikram Sampath demolished the bigoted leftist arguments
A splendid job done by Vikram Sampath for exposing Tipu.
Hitler was also a dog lover
List of Exmuslims Channel:
1) Ex-Muslim sahil
2) Exmuslim Sameer
3) Adam seeker
4) Exmuslim Sachwala 5) Suleimani Zalebiya
6) Zafar Heretics
7) Apostate the Imam
8) Exmuslim Angel
9) Imam Wala Kafir
10) pretty human
Sanjay Khan fed false narrative to the country about Tipu through his Doordarshan aired 'Sword of Tipu Sultan'. Kudos to Vikram Sampath for his courage to defy that belief through his well-researched book, supported by citations. I am in awe of this author
@@lakshmibalaji8172 I know right
I have heard lots of tales of Tipu's cruelties from our ancestors who lived in north Kerala. He was an out and out Jihadi who converted Hindus forcibly, and destroyed and looted Hindu temples.
yes, yes, even i heard that he use to go to mysore bakery to get mysore pak in his royal enfied bullet. he did not even share petrol with local hindus and chiristians there, cruel man this tippu, thank god that we are discussing tippu here,, after 500 years of his death. remember barkha dutt is employed you are not
@hk4848 It seems, Your ancestors were advisors to the Discovery of India book. And they left for Pakistan in 1947, while you stayed back 🤣🤣🤣
@@indiafirst-secularindian8917 proud of you, you are indias strength we need visonary thinkers like u.
@@hk4848 missed the train?
@@hk4848 lol
Tippu sultan raped purnayy's daughter. Purnayya was a minister in his admn. That is enough to tell about tippu's charrecter.
Were you there?? It's just a story which you people have cooked as always....but we all saw the garlanding of the rapists and those rejoicing it...clearly shows their character
Read books about Tippu by historians in kannada.
@@nagabhushanar.s6113in kannada?? that will be the most biased history...the harsh truth is that history is always written by the victors...do you really think that wodiyar puppets and their masters the british will want anything good written of their usurpers and opponents?...even in the interview when asked about positives of tipu sultan Vikram sampath cleverly uses words like probably, might be making it unsure and yet he ruled for 17 years without having social harmony at large and order in his kingdom?? Quite unlikely..
@@alta429
So you mean to say, literally everyone is lying and we are supposed to just believe what you say because you love Tipu and follow the same religion as him??
Sure 🤡
@@ThePolymerisstthere are a lot of contradictions among historians let alone the fairy tales of the masses....actually the majority community is a class apart in building false narratives but at any rate there are a lot of contradictions among historians as mentioned before...and you don't have to hate him just because he is not of your religion 🤡
Barkha dont portrait him hero... After giving so much explanation by vikram... Tippu is not freedom fighter
Tipu fought with Britishers he is freedom fighter...so by this logic French and Portuguese also fought with Britishers so give them also freedom fighter tag....what nonsensical and illogical, madarsachaap knowledge 😅😂😂
This is leftists logic. Simple. This is the same logic that Jha, Thapar, Sharma and Habib coterie tried to inculcate in our school books.
Exactly
French and Portuguese were non Indians bro 😂
@althafk6956 So was Tipu and Islam....nothing to do with India
@@althafk6956 Tipu had nothing Indian about him, neither name or faith.
500000 Hindus of Kashmir were evicted under Pak policy of Raliv, Chaliv t Galiv= Convert , Runaway or Die during 7th & last migration in 1990 .Property looted , women raped & men killed . Hindu population in Kashmir reduced in 800 years from 100% in 1320 to .001% in 2024.
No hindu is concerned they are selfish and no unity
Sad. Unfair. The other states should be seething and protesting. The rich 1 percent should raise a funds for kashmiri hindus.
A muslim zealot, a ruthless ruler who came from outside without being able to have a connect with the very people whom he ruled, the ill-luck or misfortune of the then Mysore that an alien ruler was forced on them.....not a loved king.
That is Tipu Sultan. The tragedy is that the Muslims in Karnataka, and elsewhere in India, have idolised him, given him an iconic status and made a hero out of him, because he was a muslim and was a ruler of a Hindu Kingdom. The political parties like Congress and the communist intellectual and historians distorted and procrustreated and cherrypicked facts to suit their narrative and for appeasement of the Muslims for electoral gains.
How can a usurper of throne, a foreigner who believed in the supremacy of his religion..... be considered a hero, though he was a part of the history of which we Kannadigas would be ashamed of.
@@rameshmariyappa5021 secular Hindus are voting congress party who are supporting jihaadis that is sad part of it and in India also.
There is nothing redeeming or glorious about Tipu Sultan in the entire conversation that Tipu Sultan lived and died for his country and people but there are evidence that he wanted to perpetuate his rule and seek islamisation of his kingdom through cruelty like the Mughal rulers of north India. Thanks to Dr.Vikram Sampath for presenting the true history of this Muslim ruler whose Jayanthi the misguided politicians and people with vested interest want to celebrate.
Tipu was Osama bin Laden & Baghdadi of that Era .
YeS he WaS for British east india Co., for The Kaodva Chickveerajendra of Nalakanda lWho run from Brirish Later her daughter was taken by English men & Converted her to Victoria GowrammA... Hope Neo 2014 India Historiyan Vikram sampath may write about Nalkanda palace histroy which stand till today near KAKABE coorg..srinivas stop taking GyaN from Wattsupp University..
@@shabanawahab6317It's not him who is taking Gyan from WhatsApp university. It's people like u who are born & bred from that university... Tipu was an enemy to Hindus. him recruiting a few Hindus in his administration doesn't mean he was some saint.. What his father Hyder Ali did to the Wodeyars is what Mir Sadiq did to Tipu? If Mir Sadiq was a Gaddar then Hyder Ali was a bigger Gaddar...
@@shabanawahab6317Vikram Sampath is a well researched Historian. Even Sashi Tharoor learns from him. Just because u got used to the Fictionalized version that Glorifies Islamic Rulers for too long it won't be easy for people like u to digest actual fact based point of view...
True, Tippu was a cult jihadi who oppressed non muslims, but other hindu kings were no better since they were as bigoted and oppressed the dalits or untouchables.. in fact untouchedables were treated even worse by other hindus.. they couldn’t even walk anywhere near the upper ruling castes
@@danm7523 Glad that people like you are voicing out ur opinions. Tipu was the Religious fundamentalist who wanted to establish a theological state. He even sought help from the Ottomans. British & Tipu both were enemies of the Hindus, but at least the Britishers handed the power back to the original rulers of Mysore..
Burkha tried her best to ignore the atrocities done by Tipu and put him in good light as expected. However Vikram made it clear that Tipu was indeed a cruel bigot.
Personally, I have evidence right in front of my house. The idol in the Siva temple in front of my house was attacked and broken by Tipu. There is no reason to celebrate Tipu in India and anyone does that must be considered anti-national.
Tipu was way more worse than Aurangzeb
Kudos to Vikram Sampath for putting forward authentic account for general public. Jai Hind
The more Barkha tried to get it attested that "At least Tipu did stood up to the British ..., died fighting the British ..." again and again, Each time Mr. Sampat gave her a patient thrashing destroying it with facts and argument. Great Respect for you Sir 🙏
Tipu was a rabid fanatic. Checkout his history from Kodagu, Kasaragod, Mangalore, Udupi and Central Kerala. His was a violent animal.
This is what forced writers like William darlymple to write real history of India. Because now if he doesn't, Vikram will.
Nazi killed Jew Mughal killed Hindu. Hindu forced to worship Mughal and world destroyed nazi (fascism) Why they both treated differently
Great interview Barkha. Please also look at the comments section below. You won't find a single person who supports the Cong claim that Tipu was a great person
Tipu Sultan is like Khangress. Probably related to Nehru. That is why such a rogue is a hero
Excellent command of the subject and language - kudos Vikram 🎉
1. Vikram and Aniruddha are coming up as young historians doing amazing evidence based work on the Indian history and demolishing the myths and deeply biased historical narratives. Of course, sickulars cannot stand them!! But they are rendering yeoman's service to the cause and enriching our understanding of Indian history. 2. Vikram talks sweet and smooth but he pierces the hearts and brains of sickulars with devastating effects!!!! he he!! 3. Sickulars have to project some Muslims rulers from our medieval / modern history as Muslim role models for politicking but there are hardly anyone who could eulogized except perhaps Tipu on a thin ground that he fought against the British.
When there are heaps of records in Mysore & Malabar gazettes, many historians from Karnataka and Kerala and records maitained by Britishers of the time , to testify the true nature of Hyder or Tippu , we need not ask for Burkha Dutt, for any kind of certificates.
There need be no doubts of any Muslim invaders , Sultans, Emperors ever being considerate to their Hindu subjects or hapless victims of their monsterous invasions or rules. All were equally cruel and monsterous while dealing with Hindus. It is and IS the " dharma of the " Prophet.Doing some offering to a temple or employing a Kafir , was only a way of buying peace for the interrugnm before the next attack. This was the dictum of all the invaders.
Dont, make a mistake, this is true even for our times. Let us be conscious, day & night.
VIGIL for saving the hard earned freedom from Muslim & British rule.
@29:10 ... If Tipu had won with French's help, "We in Karnataka would have been speaking French today , rather than Kannada !" 🤪🤪
Yes brother the part of India French ruled still speak French 😂😂😂😂
No urdu and your name would have been tamatar khan
I truly appreciate Barkha for giving the presenter time to explain his point of view and never once did she interrupt or interject ...this is something that other podcast hosts can learn from Barkha ....
Remember her role in 2008 terrorist attacks killing as a journalist
Barkha appears to have changed from her NDTV days... Atleast publicly 😊
@@minerjopeace5915the I-injection dose from her ex kashmiri muslim husband has worn off😢
Barkha kept on trying to clear Tipu.... she's not different from before
@ she is injected with Ivirus by her ex-husband a Kashmiri musalmaan. But the needle of the injection was broken when young due to Khatna!
A very good insight into this tyrant who was painted as a great patriot in my childhood days! Obviously those days were completely in control of communal divisive alliance of congress, communists and fanatic peacefuls
Huge Respect for Vikramji... 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙂🙂
As soon as she heard the word Bramhin, the leftist within her suddenly had an upsurge, she literally responded like here is my chance😂😂 but sampath I think is used to such leftist bigotry so he has dogded her successfully.
Please make one day of national mourning for thousands of people who was killed by Tipu
I am from Karnataka tippu sulatan is mass murderer and he done forceful conversation and what not the local kannadigas know how cruel he was now some muslims are defending him it us anti humanity how are defending tippu and his father but Dr.Vikram Sampath book give us true history of tippu and his religious bigotry and in one sentence tippu is " hardcore Islamic radical "
After,Partition,Tipu even should not be matter off discussion ,and look this bastrad congress which allowed serial of Tipu sultan,we should learn from Pakistan they just not accept truth of past for their existence and here this nasty Congress regime,made hindu to forget truth of past
I’ll be buying this book; looking forward to reading it! ❤
List of Exmuslims Channel:
1) Ex-Muslim sahil
2) Exmuslim Sameer
3) Adam seeker
4) Exmuslim Sachwala 5) Suleimani Zalebiya
6) Zafar Heretics
7) Apostate the Imam
8) Exmuslim Angel
9) Imam Wala Kafir
10) pretty human
Indian Muslims must be treated the way Aurangazeb and Tipu treated Hindus
Indian hindus must treated in Dubai and middle East the way current situation of muslims in India 😂lol
He was a jihadi who killed thousands of hindus and destroyed thousands of temples. Also please read "tipu: hero or villlain" written by Sita Ram Goel.
If tipu live today he was the leader of terrorism and handle a terrorist group 😂😂😂😂
No shades of grey there. Only black at this point. Shame on Barkha for continuously calling him ‘controversial’.
Nothing matters.
For marxist historians, congress and Muslims there's only one binary
Muslims- secular
Hindus- religious bigot
😂😂
"How do tou reconcile destruction of temples with grants given to temples"
BJP is seen as party with a prejudice against muslims. But bjp govt gives large grants to madrasas and plans for muslims.
Will burkha ever take that point to say BJP is secular and loves muslims? 🤔🤔
So why the double standards?
Very well spoken with clarity.
Thank you for the research and the book, Doctor.
This highly decorated writer had authored many best sellers. I am immensely grateful to you, Barkhajee for initiating him for a tete-a-tete with this famous author. Thanks from the bottom of my heart and i really mean it
As for the Bogus theory of Tipu being 'freedom fighter '-:
Tipu befriended and employed the formidable French and other Europeans to his active assistance. The French at that time under Napoleon were horribly dangerous to the Indian states. If fate would turn into the French favor, India would be more miserably doomed to servitude and horrific Catholic cultural imposition than the English in guise of parliamentary restrictions. So when the Marathas had sided with the English for a while, Tipu favored the French entirely. Napoleon had sent an army to invade India, however, India was saved by his engagement in the Egyptian land and the superior preparation of the English to face the danger in India. Please read simple history books, it all consisted with there 🙏
Hats off to vikram sampath for speaking his heart out and remining unbiased
valuable conversation. thank you both Barkha and Vikram. just wish Barkha would actually look at Vikram while he is answering her questions instead of being distracted by looking at something in front of her.
Tipu invited afghan king to invade hindus and usurp their lands. He fought with british for his power, not for the independence.
*Because of english lanuage no Madarsachhap were harmed*
Shivaji Nagar in Bangalore is testament to forced conversions....imagine named as shivaji nagar but with 90% muslims in the area
Hyder Ali initially sought friendship with the British but they didnt trust him because he had already betrayed the mysuru rulers, what was the guarantee that he will not betray them.
Tipu is indeed a polarizing figure. He exhibited different shades of his personality In each place he was in. The region I belong to, the Kongu region of TN was under indirect Mysorean rule since the time of Dalawai Nanjaraja. The local chieftains paid kisht and they were allowed to rule the country side and small towns while major cities such as coimbatore, Erode and Salem housed Mysorean military outposts and civil administrators(largely composed of locals). Here he is seen in a positive light. He also roped in a Kongu chieftain (Dheeran Chinnamalai) in his struggle against the British. His men trained in Tipu's army and Dheeran even carried on his fight against the British even after the demise of Tipu. He is generally seen by the population here as a "Friend of Tipu". But when I speak to my colleagues from the Kodagu or Malabar region, their account of Tipu varies completely. We have no such contradictory views when it comes to his father, Hyder Ali. He is seen even by his detractors only as a usurper and not as a religious zealot.
How a person who is faithful to the French and the Khalifa of bagdad is our freedom fighter. He is just a ruler of a region that was captured by his father and he just wanted to enjoy is rule by hook or crook.
Tipu was just a Nawab...Not a Sultan or Emperor....
Don’t know why Barkha invited Vikram Sampath when she knew that he would demolish her idol I.e. Tipu (Not a Sultan)
in Udupi, South Kanara, Shimoga,Chickmagalur, Koorg popular name for pet dogs was Tipu
It is almost as if Barkha is disappointed at truth surfacing with scathing proof. How easily we were served blatant lies about so many and lured into revering and respecting such tyranical characters. Sanjay Khan goes on to immortalise a tyrant in his TV serial probably deleberately to shield his actions. So much misiformation.
Thanks to "chacha Nehru" who promoted & granted scholarship to Progressive Writer's Association. Which later responsible for all the "left wing" narrative in films and books.
Whatever one may say, Barkha is great at interviewing. Even AIM commended her.
Jai Vikram Sampath ❤
India's recent history has so many stories where (1) Muslim rulers were oppressive towards Hindus (2) Hindus undermined muslim rulers by supporting European powers, like the Portugese first and the British later, and (3) Europeans took full advantage, essentially siphoning out all of India's wealth and (4) The British went one level lower - essentially destroying all Indian industry, using Indian soldiers to conquer Africa/China, and levying oppressive taxes (something similar to what muslim rulers were doing in the first place). So what can we learn from this?
‘Story’ is wrong word. Incidents
Seems like didi is fond of Tiplu. Strange obsession from dreams. Tiplu was megalomaniac, arrogant, tyrant & a hardcore radical Ghadi. His attrocities still pains & troubles our Hindu brothers & sisters
Did likes Teepu’s sword and reminds her of stunted sword of her divorced kashmeeri muslim husband - ooommmm wet dreams😢
Good for you Barkha. For being impartial . Be bashful even on Hindus. Only if they are wrong
Just because Tipu had Hindus in his Army administration doesn't make him Pro Hindu or Liberal .
Even British had Indians.
Barkha.the Muslims were also colonisers, they didn't come with altruistic intent!
Frankly, it is very very unlikely of Burkha to discuss a book that shows Tipu as a jihadi. If she does, it would be only to resurrect him into a whitewashed version. I opened the clip just to confirm my suspicions.
I am right, Burkha proved to be Burkha.
No point in watching rest of the clip.
I am abandoning it, half the way.
Zebra may lose stripes and snake its fangs, but not Burkha, she will always be a Jihadi lover.😢😢
🙏🙏🙏 thx Barkha and thx Dr Vikram Sampath for a very lucid talk. I got clarity for the very first time on this subject.
Clarity that Teepu as freedom fighter or a tyrant?
@@nand3576gober bhakt saar... jai gomootra 😂😂😂
@@uk2261 kabhi nahi sudharoge. Imaan se dimagh me gobar bhar jatha hai. Imaan chodo aur insaniyath ki badho aur Ilm leaao. Kithaab ko phenko aur Gyaan ko apnaao
@@uk2261... Madarsa chaap , jai nobi ki peshab Mubarak , thook Mubarak
Is Barkha Dutt on the path of Ghar Wapsi?
@@shyama4960 she a Muslim?
Being my maternal side from Mysore, I have heard a lot of what Vikram Sampath said about Unnecessarily hyping this person who has looted the state and did only wrong doing !!
Look at how uncomfortable she becomes as she can't disprove him
We were made to believe tippu was our savior thru text books in school by Congress led pseudo governments...Hats off to Dr. Vikram
Rahul Gandhi acts like Tipu when he asks external powers to help him overthrow BJP govt
Great interview..we need balanced historians , using primary research from resources, and articulately writing histories for all ..
Ms D made a great start' Tipu made grants & 1000 gold coins to Hindus temple, symbol of resistance against British la la" but flustered, speechless Ms Dutta face's was a sight,at being defeated by Mr Sampath articulate rebuttal backed up with factual, evidence based information one after the other,setting the record straight. The duel was fun to watch. Though Mr S broke promise given to his late mother (whom he reveres all the time) and wrote this magnanimous book, but I doubt (though hope) the book is going to change anything academically, socially or politically. Saving grace for the leftist and they can continue with their bigotry🙄.
And Karnataka Hindus vote for Congress...😅
not me but sold people
People of karnataka vote for 5 kg rice and other freebies and we call our selves greatest democracy
He was purely selfish !! whether religion or politics
Always pleasure listening Vikram Sampath ji although not a fan of Barkha. But I feel of late she has ditched her narrow minded ness a little and has started giving space to people from opposite spectrum as well
Smart way of adding some base of current political understandings of Tipu and going back to history to add it to his book…
He is bigot, but medialike u,politicians, Maethaavulu supporting him are jihaadhees😂😢😮😮😊🎉
Tipu was destroyed multiple times by the Marathas 💪💪💪⛳⛳⛳
Why is there a controversy regarding the intent of the Muslim invaders? Their autobiography and the biographies written by them or their associates very clearly states that their primary aim is to spread Islam. Mulfuzat Tumuri , of the invader, Taimur, should be a mandatory reading in every school and college
@@Paulsmiththea ..
Yes , Islamic invaders mention their act of invasion , killing kaffir and temple destruction as pride in their books and biographies .
Vikramji is himself an ICON bringing about such a hugely researched volume,I bought it yesterday and want to have his autograph,how can I reach him?
I'm just fan of his work ethics and reference,truths and myths blast done by our old-age person 😂soon after independence many things are misplaced no evidence ,no point in articulations and worst part is we blindly followed this about 75 years without arguments may be some agends by some of people I'm proud these things happening,Tippu is king no doubt bt what he done what happned in history past and how these are things came should be aware ,people of Indians should be cautious bcz nowdays social media also came with one side story these kind of people are much needed TQ U MR Sampath ji , EXPLORE INDIA , ANCIENT INDIA by ur books are much needed ❤❤❤❤
Anachronism is the greatest enemy of critical history. As far as possible we should refrain from identifying with historical persona or debunking them on the basis of our prejudices. By the way, Tipu also wrote for support to the Marathas and the Nizam saying clearly that his defeat would mean the victory of the hat wearers and the defeat of pagri wearers. Tipu remains an interesting 18th century ruler in many ways. I have gone through his record of dreams and there is no doubt that he saw himself as an 'ideal' Muslim ruler, whatever that meant in the 18th Century. A good interview.
Just as water takes the shape of the container that holds it. Absolute truth must take the necessary form for each mind. Padmasambhava
I just don't understand how sophisticated/decent people like Vikram Sampat agrees to a session like this with WORST ANTINATIONAL's like this CREATURE!
Less spoken about this cruel person.
Tipu the pride of India..
Burkha Dutt doesnt like hearing anything against her fascination tipu baby
Barkha Dutt ❌ Govinda ✅😂😂😂😂😂
Anyone who fight British gets labeled as Patriot... Exactly why Xavier is seen as saint and many colleges run, even though Portuguese were way much more brutal to locals than British
I anticipated this foul play of Sampath when he downplayed the achievement of Tipu against British. He cleverly puts Haider to sound politically correct. The fact is at the following battle Tipu inflicted upon British the biggest defeat till then.
---------
The Battle of Pollilur (a.k.a. Pullalur), also known as the Battle of Polilore or Battle of Perambakam, took place on 10 September 1780 at Pollilur near Conjeevaram, the city of Kanchipuram in present-day Tamil Nadu state, India, as part of the Second Anglo-Mysore War. It was fought between an army commanded by King Tipu Sultan of the Kingdom of Mysore, and a British East India Company force led by William Baillie.
I thought you retired after leaving NDTV...RUclips algorithem suddenly shown u r channel...may be due to Vikram Sampath...
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Tipu was Invader .
OMG please save India like people
Dont you think our cities are already international...what country is left, tell me ?
Uff barkha b glowing when someone said anything against bjp
Don't know whom to believe in life? Is history important!
yes...becoz privthviraj chauhan never leartn from history..and kept pardoning ghori...India was eventually colonized..case closed
God is watching everything, every liar will face gods justice in this life only, that is the final truth....
Your God is hiding in Gaza...😅
@@mohammedali39111 ...
Read letters of Tipu Sultan .
Where is Allah? Gazans are waiting.
Barkha: I was once enchanted with your left of the center journalism but the Neera Radia tapes destroyed that.
I would request you to broadcast your POV ( as a journalist and not a victim).
People are smart enough to read between the lines ( obviously people would judge you). Would request for the truth.
Sad. Unfair. The other states should be seething and protesting. The rich 1 percent should raise a funds for kashmiri hindus.