I'm a retired New York City hospital administrator who was admitted to Lenox Hill and I can tell you I almost signed myself out, I was so upset with the quality of care I was receiving FYI I was admitted on October 26th of this year
For the last 7-8 years of my mother’s life, I moved into the hospital with her during the 7-9 stays she had (strokes mostly). I absolutely know this prolonged her life‼️
Best thing that AI can do is formulate the patient interview. Docs do not do good histories on patients. Most of em don't even DO the history. It's done by a form in the waiting room and then gone over by the med assistant and glanced at by the doc. Taking a thorough history is the most important step in diagnosis.
Diagnosis is only the first step. How will AI help people afford prescription medication and to take that medication correctly whether po, inhaled or IV?
I am delighted but not surprised. I have been going to Dr ChatGPT since it appeared and before that to Dr Google. Saves me time and money and I would never go to a human doctor unless I had a bullet wound or a broken leg.
The headline is very click baity, the original study was looking at LLM as an aid for physicians for clinical reasoning compared to conventional resources. (MD here)
No. All these cases are designed examples, not real patients. It means if we know the diagnosis and make up answers for possible questions, AI performs better than doctors. We don't know what happens when real patients came in and answer the "open-ended" questions. Expert system was among the first use cases for AI when computer science came up with the concept of AI, so this kind of scenario are bound to happen. The question is how to extend the current healthcare system to serve more people with the help of AI, not how to replace doctors to serve the same number of people cheaper.
MD here too. Super baity. Feed it nice neat data that no computer will EVER get out of a patient. Lmao. History taking is as important to medicine as any of our lab tests or imaging studies. Just patently irresponsible to put this out here without that stipulation upfront.
It's not even about "more human medical encounter". Do Americans have enough doctors? Are all Americans have all their medical needs met with the current resource? Can all Americans afford all their medical needs? AI should be implemented to expand the medical resources, and make them affordable to everyone. Like $1 general medical consultation for everyone. Many people check WebMD when they feel something's wrong, not because of hypochondria but because they can't afford to visit a real doctor. Start with that.
It’s no surprise to me. The good news? AI should help reduce insurance costs. Medicare/Medicaid will benefit. Edit: next test - AI vs CDC Recommended Guidelines
It's not hard to be better than a GP. ChatGPT wouldn't have addicted me to a massive dose of narcotics - and then been an a**hole about it and blamed me for it, tried to shirk responsibility etc.
Not in reality, no. Chat gpt just assumes the patient accurately reports all their symptoms and has no genuine intuition. It's not even close to being better than a doctor.
I am a nurse in a rural area. Trust me. I am ready for AI. Awesome show!!!
Casey is actually handsome. We diagnosed him with my friend recently😊
WHY IS THAT GUY HOLLERING?
Also interesting fidgeting with the glasses.
I'm a retired New York City hospital administrator who was admitted to Lenox Hill and I can tell you I almost signed myself out, I was so upset with the quality of care I was receiving
FYI I was admitted on October 26th of this year
For the last 7-8 years of my mother’s life, I moved into the hospital with her during the 7-9 stays she had (strokes mostly). I absolutely know this prolonged her life‼️
dude sounds like adam from 'adam ruins everything'
Best thing that AI can do is formulate the patient interview. Docs do not do good histories on patients. Most of em don't even DO the history. It's done by a form in the waiting room and then gone over by the med assistant and glanced at by the doc. Taking a thorough history is the most important step in diagnosis.
Diagnosis is only the first step. How will AI help people afford prescription medication and to take that medication correctly whether po, inhaled or IV?
It seems inevitable that computers will replace doctors.
And the thing is the o1 model is waaaay better at this sort of thing than 4.0. And even o1 is AI in its infancy.
Try Claude Sonnet
I am delighted but not surprised. I have been going to Dr ChatGPT since it appeared and before that to Dr Google. Saves me time and money and I would never go to a human doctor unless I had a bullet wound or a broken leg.
The headline is very click baity, the original study was looking at LLM as an aid for physicians for clinical reasoning compared to conventional resources. (MD here)
yea but the result showed the AI was more accurate, literally without the doctor.
LoL...who funded the study?... Meta, Microsoft and Google ?
No. All these cases are designed examples, not real patients. It means if we know the diagnosis and make up answers for possible questions, AI performs better than doctors. We don't know what happens when real patients came in and answer the "open-ended" questions.
Expert system was among the first use cases for AI when computer science came up with the concept of AI, so this kind of scenario are bound to happen. The question is how to extend the current healthcare system to serve more people with the help of AI, not how to replace doctors to serve the same number of people cheaper.
MD here too. Super baity. Feed it nice neat data that no computer will EVER get out of a patient. Lmao. History taking is as important to medicine as any of our lab tests or imaging studies. Just patently irresponsible to put this out here without that stipulation upfront.
@@Brendonherring522 what do you expect from a tech writer?
It's not even about "more human medical encounter". Do Americans have enough doctors? Are all Americans have all their medical needs met with the current resource? Can all Americans afford all their medical needs? AI should be implemented to expand the medical resources, and make them affordable to everyone. Like $1 general medical consultation for everyone.
Many people check WebMD when they feel something's wrong, not because of hypochondria but because they can't afford to visit a real doctor. Start with that.
If you have a white collar job, you will feel what factory workers felt like during de industrialization.
Ok cool. I’m glad. Can we automate the dock workers now? Let’s get rid of the whole capitalism thing too while we’re at it.
@ClementinesmWTF And that attitude is why democrats lost
@ ok cool. Thanks for showing us all why you’re an idiot lol
It’s no surprise to me. The good news? AI should help reduce insurance costs. Medicare/Medicaid will benefit.
Edit: next test - AI vs CDC Recommended Guidelines
It's not hard to be better than a GP. ChatGPT wouldn't have addicted me to a massive dose of narcotics - and then been an a**hole about it and blamed me for it, tried to shirk responsibility etc.
Not in reality, no. Chat gpt just assumes the patient accurately reports all their symptoms and has no genuine intuition. It's not even close to being better than a doctor.
day 1 of reminding democrats that trans rights are human rights!🏳⚧🏳⚧🏳⚧