Novaboi that shit annoys me so bad, they use it every damn video like 3,000 times, it literally isn’t funny anymore, it’s like listening to the same song on the radio that has come on 4 times in the past hour
Just wanna point out, they DIDNT hire 5 or 6 counselors. They literally only hired one, and got lucky when he brought all his friends along. No other counselors showed up over that day so that means if they hadn't agreed to join him when he went then they would only have him. Which makes things even more suspicious.
Spoilers for episode 2 I could be way off on this but think you're right because in this week's episode we find out Xavier did "movies" in the past, & Margaret being friends with Charles Keating might be a hint that she led him to her camp to murder him for that reason. I think Margaret is really the killer and she's offing people who in her eyes have sinned in some way.
See, The Hiker sticks out to me. He is dressed VERY 70's, and asks what year it is and says it's happening again and the like. I think we are going to have some time looping fun times here this season.
Mr Jingle is a serial killer so it's strange he wouldn't take the ears. Most serial killers only kill to fulfill their psychopathic urges so in theory he'd take the ears unless he was in a rush then he may abandon that but his next kills would be worst to fill the urge again
Could be something god related, purity maybe? Godliness? Hear no evil type of thing. Lol I’m not serious about this, just kind of gave me that vibe lol
There is a movie named “Mr.Jingles” about someone who got imprisoned for a crime he didn’t commit and then escaped from prison to have his revenge. Could that be a clue? Also Mr. Jingles (movie) was a killer clown, and I find it interesting that John Carroll Lynch already played a killer clown before as Twisty and now playing as Mr.Jingles.
Oh my goodness wasn't he great as twisty ?? You can find twisty t-shirts on ebay He also played john Wayne gacy in AHS hotel wasn't he a killer dressed as clown
Aaaww!!! Dont feel bad. You aren't the only 1. I say it all the time also, and NOBODY gets it!! That's when I realize, they cant be my friends. Repeat it and laugh to myself. Lol
There’s no scenario aside from serving soups for a living where you would have to use that every single day. Maybe some people DO get your reference and just don’t laugh because just quoting a random reference isn’t funny.
@@ryanerikpeterson Of course i mean the nurse. That was one of the first things I picked up and no one is talking about that connection. She could be more sinister then we realize.
To further support the multiple killer theory and how the camp owner is probably a killer too is the fact that jingles killed the guard and the gas station attendant and did not take their ears but he did take those keys 🔑
The sinner kill is Margaret, on une of the teasers the killer is under the van and has like three golden threads and who has beautiful golden hair? Exactly Mr Jingles, ok no but I think She kills the sinners and take the ears bc she lost her before and like they said it was easier to blame Mr Jingles .
Plus when they were talking about the suspicion of what happened to Margaret’s husband, I wouldn’t be surprised if that was her first kill. Like maybe he didn’t want her buying the camp but she needed to to fulfill her purpose of getting rid of the sin there but got out of hand with it, who knows?
It's also possible that the camp owner WAS the killer in the cabin and she stabbed herself, cut off her own ear, AND blamed Jingles for the murders. She started with the "sinning" threesome and then slayed the rest of the cabin.
Ok why is nobody talking about the fact that when we actually see Mr. Jingles kill, he doesn’t cut off either of their ears.... it’s obviously not his M.O.
Agree, I suspect someone else will turn up later with the ears collection, although to be fair both times we saw Mr Jingles killing while escaping the hospital and at the gas station, he didn't have access to a knife yet. I now wonder if his back story about being a murderous Vietnam veteran is true...
Kaitlin Nuchols just a theory, but if it is Margaret, she could have easily made up the story about what happened in that cabin that night, plus I think it’s more than a coincidence that Brooke screamed when she thought she saw Mr. Jingles again but it was just Margaret
Hollie Oconnor I'm just now starting the series because I like to binge watch lol... But I like that theory! Maybe she was born that way and was picked on then got fed up with everyone and killed them...
Glad you both are both back! You are the best team recapping American Horror Story each week. Excellent attention to detail and always fun banter. Looking forward to 1984!
I honestly think the bad acting is intentional. The plotholes seem too intentionally obvious. It's going to be a breaking the fourth wall scenario I think
@@sunxbeams6635 Well almost every season has a supernatural element to it (ghosts/witches) except Cult. I'm thinking this might be a Freddy Kreuger dream nightmare scenario. On the van, the license plate said VANTA C as in "fantasy" leading me to think none of what we're seeing is real. They could also be actors in a movie but they already did that in Roanoke.
That would be rather funny to see Emma Roberts wake up years later in an insane asylum or next to Cody fern screaming from a nightmarish flashback from camp redwood... I still think it should have been called camp dedwood
I'm very suspicious of Xavier. I feel like he's connected to the night stalker. And oh yeah, does anyone else remember the time when Emma Roberts played a killer in Scream 4?
I feel like Xavier is just an earlier iteration of Michael. The last thing they showed us last season was that no amount of killing him off will stop others from being born...which means Michael wasn't necessarily the FIRST anti-Christ to walk the planet. I also noticed that he was pretty much responsible for everyone going to the camp. And when Emma wouldn't come, she was conveniently nudged away from the city by the Satanist (who sounded like the same bitter lover on Xavier's voicemail).... I'm SOOOO excited for this season now *Shimmyin with knives
I was unsure how I'd feel without Evan and Sarah but I actually really enjoyed this episode and I don't even like slashers. However AHS seasons don't usually start going down hill until after the halfway point, so I'm still apprehensive.
That jewelry box of Brooke is super suspicious, I know the killer is famous for collecting ears but I wouldn't be surprised if they also collect other things, like pieces of jewelry that their victims are having on for example...
Ryan missed the *'engagement ring'* significance, though... Is Brooke's fiancee... 'Dead'? *Edit* - I was right, as per Episode #2 ☠ 'Disappeared'? 'Dimensionally trapped in an earlier AHS series'...? 🌌😏🌌
Yeah her jewelry box is probably stolen things from her victims and they never said why she moved to a whole new town by herself. (Maybe she's on the run?)
I look foward to you guy breaking down AHS every season, what do you think about a possible timeloop with the hiker for some reason I was getting some heavy dark city vibes.
She’s the “one sole survivor”...that in itself is suspicious...I’m just saying in the original/first Friday the 13th the killer was Jason’s mother...I’m not saying she’s the killer but I wouldn’t be surprised if she was related to him or linked to him in some way...
I remember there being a similar scene in Children of the Corn by Stephen King (the original from the 80s). Burt and Vicky (played by Linda Hamilton) were looking at a road map while driving when all of a sudden there was a boy, Job (biblical spelling) standing in the road (already dead from being murdered by Malachai). And the man being murdered in the gas station also happened in the movie as well (Children of the Corn). So I'm wondering if we're going to get any more callbacks to Stephen King's movies/books this season. Which I would love to see.
@@newboyzfiend94 Roanoke is already connected with MH about the legends of Piggy Man and the Croatoan spell, my bet is this season will connect with Asylum.
@@joijiparra yeah you're right gosh there is so much to remember but my theory is that this season may have something to do with the dad from Murder House and the people he said he murdered. I believe he's actually Constance's son and thats why he was drawn to the Murder House. Also Constance is from Virginia and Roanoke took place in Virginia. However, I agree this season may be tied to Asylum. Honestly at this point this season maybe the season we've all been waiting for, the season that ties ALL the seasons together. 😯😍
And before that it also was done in Apocalypse now. To be honest, i read somewhere that some soldiers during the Vietnam war really made and was wearing this ear necklaces for real. So it originates from much further back then the Walking Dead or Universal Soldier. ;)
I think what I like about American Horror Story is that everyone is on the table. You never feel like anyone is safe. Of course, this sometimes back fires. If tropes start to flip and Brooke end up surprise dying in the next few episodes , I'd be personally sad.
I am So addicted to you guys!!!!! Since finding you last season every AHS breakdown I live for .. when the show was over yesterday I told myself now I gotta wait for you guys to post a video!!! I love your content
Is it just me or did the message Xavier was listening to sound like it was his own voice? I’m getting split personality vibes like Norman Bates style. Also, I absolutely love how Ryan Murphy is so true to genre with the perfectly replicated 80’s camera shots, acting, and directing. Brilliant on the intro remix too!!
It’s so refreshing to have found a channel where y’all point out and find things that I do when I watch the show. The in-depth feel makes me love AHS even more!
I think Brook is going to be a killer and she collects one piece of jewelry from each person she kills, and that's why she was looking at them fondly since she's so knowledgable about killers lol but Idk
My favorite sub-genre of horror is slashers, so I really like this season so far!! It’s a nice change up to the more modern and meta slasher shows like Scream: The TV Series and Scream Queens. This could easily become one of my favorite seasons if there’s not too many crazy twists that make it less slashery
In the beginning when we see all the bodies on the floor of the cabin Mr. Jingles walks right over Margaret without taking her ear...and he didn't take the ear from the gas station dude or the guard in the hospital...Margaret is giving me Mrs. Vorhees vibes big time!! Also I think the hiker is a ghost...he looks waaaay too 70's, and he said the phone lines were down when they weren't.
Great first episode. I clocked out after episode 3 of Apocolypse, and forget the season before that. I was SO refreshed after this first episode. I'm really excited for this season. Also, conspiracy theory: the hiker is a ghost ala murder house
I literally said "they did that in The Goonies" when i saw Mr Jingles in the cell lmfaoo and also when Brooke (Emma Roberts) was drenched head to toe in mud I was getting MAJOR Carrie vibes
you guys do such a good job of analyzing and explaining things! Cant believe the episode aired wednesday and you uploaded thursday- phenomenal! keep up the great work :)
Brooke's last name Thompson is also the last name of Nancy, the final girl on Nightmare of Elm Street. I wonder if that's a clue. I'm very sure there will be some supernatural elements.
I am born 1961...i always found such acting style boring... I miss seasons like coven, cult, freak show, murder House... This is a yawn... Was hoping for a George Orwell theme...
"how does she wear glasses with one ear?" this is easily one of the most important questions that need to be asked because holy shit, I didn't even think of that.
It's actually pretty easy, I once broke my glasses so one of the arms came off but the glasses still stayed perfectly on, I guess it's the same as not having an ear
If the scenes with Mr Jingles escaping happened the same night as the main story, then there's no way that kid who was hit by the van was running from Mr Jingles as hadn't made it to the camp yet. So then who cut off his ear? Also, just speculating... maybe Mr Jingles didn't kill the campers back in the day. Maybe it was the "star witness" who framed Mr Jingles and now he's coming back for his revenge....
What would it take to get you to work at Camp Redwood for a summer?
GameSpot Universe If Emma is there then so am I lol
A bunch of locks cause I'm so not getting killed by no killer
a rocket launcher
Iron man’s suit and 10 billion dollars
Evan peters.
Couldn't even make it to 20 seconds before we got hit with "The stew is STU!!" Love that for us
Novaboi that shit annoys me so bad, they use it every damn video like 3,000 times, it literally isn’t funny anymore, it’s like listening to the same song on the radio that has come on 4 times in the past hour
Novaboi it’s my favorite bit 😂❤️
Jesús Malverde it’ll never get old for me you trippin
That's why I subscribed😂😂
THE STEW IS STU!!!
It is so weird to see emma roberts play a character like that I keep expecting her to yell at someone
Sylvie Evergreen i thought the same thing lol I’m happy they switched it up and didn’t make her character so predictable
I mean Maggie wasn’t like Madison or Serena so
It was so unfabulous
Sylvie Evergreen She is so everrated
It’s like she’s back in aqua marine lmao
Just wanna point out, they DIDNT hire 5 or 6 counselors. They literally only hired one, and got lucky when he brought all his friends along. No other counselors showed up over that day so that means if they hadn't agreed to join him when he went then they would only have him. Which makes things even more suspicious.
Or hes somehow still the antichrist...remember how michael Langdon went to bed and woke up older...maybe that's some kinda of connection?!..
I think that might just of been bad writing/plothole
Spoilers for episode 2
I could be way off on this but think you're right because in this week's episode we find out Xavier did "movies" in the past, & Margaret being friends with Charles Keating might be a hint that she led him to her camp to murder him for that reason. I think Margaret is really the killer and she's offing people who in her eyes have sinned in some way.
I’m sure he would have left or quit lol
they should have DUMPED him at the Camp and went back to the city..... you missed that the Nurse Rita we ended up with wasn't the Original nurse..
Even if Mr. Jingles killed 1/4 of the world's population I still couldn't take that name seriously.
DezzmanX same
That's what makes it terrifying
We were about to name our cat mr jingles when we adopted him over 10 years ago lol
"What's his name???....Naw, I'm good. Whatever."
DezzmanX he sounds like a drug lord from river dale lol, or some creepy perv
See, The Hiker sticks out to me. He is dressed VERY 70's, and asks what year it is and says it's happening again and the like. I think we are going to have some time looping fun times here this season.
Also says he doesn't remember his name! Interesting
That would be pretty dope
Looking forward to a time fuckery season as long as its ONLY this season.
Maybe the aliens from Asylum ?
maybe he’s just a ghost idk
*did anyone notice that Mr. Jingles never tried to take the ears of the few people he actually killed when he escaped*
Maybe he was in a rush or they were kills of necessity
Mr Jingle is a serial killer so it's strange he wouldn't take the ears. Most serial killers only kill to fulfill their psychopathic urges so in theory he'd take the ears unless he was in a rush then he may abandon that but his next kills would be worst to fill the urge again
@T K that's so damn obvious that it would be lame If it's the case
Could be something god related, purity maybe? Godliness? Hear no evil type of thing. Lol I’m not serious about this, just kind of gave me that vibe lol
@@FullMetalAtheist They are basing the show on 80's slasher films, a lot of stuff was obvious in those kind of movies so it is a possibility so far.
As much as I want Emma's character to survive, she doesn't have the best AHS survival rate.
Brooke is most likely to be the Final Girl
She seems to be a prime candidate but Emma Roberts characters alway die on AHS
Based off 80's horror movie tropes, she is definitely set up to be the final girl...whether she survivors or not we will see
Omg ur right 🤣🤣🤣
facts.
There is a movie named “Mr.Jingles” about someone who got imprisoned for a crime he didn’t commit and then escaped from prison to have his revenge. Could that be a clue? Also Mr. Jingles (movie) was a killer clown, and I find it interesting that John Carroll Lynch already played a killer clown before as Twisty and now playing as Mr.Jingles.
Fritz Heward WOAH I love this! I hope it’s true, they just mentioned in this video about maybe learning Mr. Jingles back story so it could be true
That wouldn't surprise me with the other horror movie references
Oh my goodness wasn't he great as twisty ??
You can find twisty t-shirts on ebay
He also played john Wayne gacy in AHS hotel wasn't he a killer dressed as clown
Maybe they're characters in an old slasher...and the hiker somehow crossed over into the film?
That’s what I was thinking too
The acting is supposed to be cheesy it’s the 80’s
cody,matt and billie are killin it for me(the good way) in this regard
last season, codys acting wasnt that good either. also his acting is exceptionally bad compared to all the other actors besides chet
@@edgeakmass7382 literally how he was good in Apocalypse
Omg I didnt even realize the comparison of Cody Fern getting hit by a car /hitting someone with a car! Good call guys!
when did he get hit by a car?
@@soonsims in Apocalypse season, last year
@@93JRow Ohh right, thanks!
@@soonsims No problem! There has been many seasons so it can be easy to forget
@@soonsims sleep asf
The amount of times I use "The Strew is Stu!" Is every day and people don't understand my reference. It saddens me.
Patrick Notah LOLLLL
Aaaww!!! Dont feel bad. You aren't the only 1. I say it all the time also, and NOBODY gets it!!
That's when I realize, they cant be my friends.
Repeat it and laugh to myself. Lol
Patrick Notah what's it from?
There’s no scenario aside from serving soups for a living where you would have to use that every single day. Maybe some people DO get your reference and just don’t laugh because just quoting a random reference isn’t funny.
@@lucapeyrefitte6899 last season
The REAL Question for Season 9 is "how DO YOU wear glasses with 1 ear???"
Exactly! My Mom is missing the top section of her ear, on one side, and she has a heck of a time with her glssses.
That's another glitch I had noticed... Not even a BC (birth control) eyeglass chain so popular back then to hold them to the back of your head
That was my first thought too. Unless she has a prosthetic ear that we didn't see it would be next to impossible.
Lol
@@kathyharris1627 shes rich so maybe she bought custom ones, but she is also definitely shady so maybe her story is bunk lol we will have to see! :)
Is no one going to say that she came from Hawthorn Hospital, Shares the same name as Hawthorn School for Boys, the Warlocks academy
Cmacpride1 omggggggggg you’re right
@@ryanerikpeterson Of course i mean the nurse. That was one of the first things I picked up and no one is talking about that connection. She could be more sinister then we realize.
She could even be a witch and heal the dead. Thats how The nightstalker could die during this season but still live till 2013.
Makes me wonder if she knows the other black character as he said he was a medical orderly.
Melissa Schulz True, maybe Ray already knew about the camp history and there is something going on that we don’t know about •o•
To further support the multiple killer theory and how the camp owner is probably a killer too is the fact that jingles killed the guard and the gas station attendant and did not take their ears but he did take those keys 🔑
True. And the camp counselor just seems strange in general there’s something off about her for sure
The sinner kill is Margaret, on une of the teasers the killer is under the van and has like three golden threads and who has beautiful golden hair? Exactly Mr Jingles, ok no but I think She kills the sinners and take the ears bc she lost her before and like they said it was easier to blame Mr Jingles .
Plus when they were talking about the suspicion of what happened to Margaret’s husband, I wouldn’t be surprised if that was her first kill. Like maybe he didn’t want her buying the camp but she needed to to fulfill her purpose of getting rid of the sin there but got out of hand with it, who knows?
It's also possible that the camp owner WAS the killer in the cabin and she stabbed herself, cut off her own ear, AND blamed Jingles for the murders. She started with the "sinning" threesome and then slayed the rest of the cabin.
@@nicholebeamer8658 I was thinking the same thing!!!🙋
Ok why is nobody talking about the fact that when we actually see Mr. Jingles kill, he doesn’t cut off either of their ears.... it’s obviously not his M.O.
Agree, I suspect someone else will turn up later with the ears collection, although to be fair both times we saw Mr Jingles killing while escaping the hospital and at the gas station, he didn't have access to a knife yet. I now wonder if his back story about being a murderous Vietnam veteran is true...
Kaitlin Nuchols just a theory, but if it is Margaret, she could have easily made up the story about what happened in that cabin that night, plus I think it’s more than a coincidence that Brooke screamed when she thought she saw Mr. Jingles again but it was just Margaret
I hope ! because this characted is not even scary
Maybe Margaret is the one collecting ears because she is angry that she doesn’t have hers so she’s reliving her trauma by causing other trauma
Hollie Oconnor I'm just now starting the series because I like to binge watch lol... But I like that theory! Maybe she was born that way and was picked on then got fed up with everyone and killed them...
I wonder how Xavier knows Marg?How did he get the job?
I think he’s her son.
It would make since then if she’s the killer.
It’d almost be like the first Friday the 13th!
@@kaylastewart6160 if she was a kid in 1970 she too young to be his mother.He seems to be like 18-20.She would have had him 4 yrs before camp.
Glad you both are both back! You are the best team recapping American Horror Story each week. Excellent attention to detail and always fun banter. Looking forward to 1984!
washkoskat thank you so much for the kind words!
I concur.
They also played the song "cruel summer" at the gym while the kids are leaving ;)
Nick Wilson by taylor swift?
vee beato no
beato bananarama
vee beato Are you joking or are you for real? 🤦🏽♀️🤦🏽♀️🤦🏽♀️
I honestly think the bad acting is intentional. The plotholes seem too intentionally obvious. It's going to be a breaking the fourth wall scenario I think
Agreed. The style of 84 movie production.
What are your thoughts on the fourth wall break?? I’m really interested in that idea/theory X
@@sunxbeams6635 Well almost every season has a supernatural element to it (ghosts/witches) except Cult. I'm thinking this might be a Freddy Kreuger dream nightmare scenario. On the van, the license plate said VANTA C as in "fantasy" leading me to think none of what we're seeing is real. They could also be actors in a movie but they already did that in Roanoke.
That would be rather funny to see Emma Roberts wake up years later in an insane asylum or next to Cody fern screaming from a nightmarish flashback from camp redwood...
I still think it should have been called camp dedwood
Yea it's the 80s
I'm very suspicious of Xavier. I feel like he's connected to the night stalker. And oh yeah, does anyone else remember the time when Emma Roberts played a killer in Scream 4?
I feel like Xavier is just an earlier iteration of Michael. The last thing they showed us last season was that no amount of killing him off will stop others from being born...which means Michael wasn't necessarily the FIRST anti-Christ to walk the planet. I also noticed that he was pretty much responsible for everyone going to the camp. And when Emma wouldn't come, she was conveniently nudged away from the city by the Satanist (who sounded like the same bitter lover on Xavier's voicemail).... I'm SOOOO excited for this season now *Shimmyin with knives
@@IAmJustR oh I like that!!! That's a good observation
Unfortunately I do remember Scream 4 😂
The green van is a Easter egg to the Texas chainsaw massacre.
No it's not
I thought that too
The van is also similar to the van in Friday the 13th chapter 3
The long run away was a nod to TCM
I was unsure how I'd feel without Evan and Sarah but I actually really enjoyed this episode and I don't even like slashers. However AHS seasons don't usually start going down hill until after the halfway point, so I'm still apprehensive.
Same, I really like Gus and Angelica.
And for me Cody Fern is a pretty good replacement for Evan peters.
I think you meant to say apprehensive. Calling yourself abrasive is kind of insulting yourself.
@@gotanyketchup3422 Yes I did 😆. Thanks for the correction. 😊
cxrs asylum had a bad beginning? Were you drunk when you watched it?
The fact that you can't still get over "the stew is stu" 😂😂😂
*5 seconds after hitting hitchhiker*
Brook: "We didn't hit him, did we?"
Xavier: "No."
😆😆😆
That jewelry box of Brooke is super suspicious, I know the killer is famous for collecting ears but I wouldn't be surprised if they also collect other things, like pieces of jewelry that their victims are having on for example...
Vy Nguyen that sunflower earring!!
Ryan missed the *'engagement ring'* significance, though...
Is Brooke's fiancee...
'Dead'? *Edit* - I was right, as per Episode #2 ☠
'Disappeared'?
'Dimensionally trapped in an earlier AHS series'...? 🌌😏🌌
It sure is!
I think she’s having delusions and perhaps split personality disorder...the good girl is actually a total psycho 👌
Alina - Aka...
"Sleepaway Camp" (1983)...with one of *THE* best 'plot twists' in slasher film history.👍
Yeah her jewelry box is probably stolen things from her victims and they never said why she moved to a whole new town by herself. (Maybe she's on the run?)
@@CynAnne1 I just thought the same while we all get sidetracked by Mr Jingles as a side plot.
All I could think about was Mr.Schuester singing the Thong Song
Caitlin Parks me too 😭
him dancing around emma lmaoooo
Why? Which scene I wanna know how Glee season 1 is related to AHS1984 🙂 because I love Glee.
Ill predict Mr.Jingles was sent to Briarcliff at some point in the 70s.
Yeahhhhhhh that sounds tasty!!!! Lol
I look foward to you guy breaking down AHS every season, what do you think about a possible timeloop with the hiker for some reason I was getting some heavy dark city vibes.
I'm skipping this season. So I'm just going to watch their reviews.
I got that vibe too. It felt like he was the last survivor of another massacre at the camp... but when?
Matt Becker i would kill for a time loop! I need something supernatural to make its way into this season! Great theory!
She’s the “one sole survivor”...that in itself is suspicious...I’m just saying in the original/first Friday the 13th the killer was Jason’s mother...I’m not saying she’s the killer but I wouldn’t be surprised if she was related to him or linked to him in some way...
Did you notice that the hiker got his ear cut off before Mr. Jingles got to the camp?
You're right
I remember there being a similar scene in Children of the Corn by Stephen King (the original from the 80s). Burt and Vicky (played by Linda Hamilton) were looking at a road map while driving when all of a sudden there was a boy, Job (biblical spelling) standing in the road (already dead from being murdered by Malachai). And the man being murdered in the gas station also happened in the movie as well (Children of the Corn). So I'm wondering if we're going to get any more callbacks to Stephen King's movies/books this season. Which I would love to see.
This season looks very promising!!
InDEED! :-)
I knew I wasn't crazy thinking Roy looked like Patrick Swayze.
... I had no idea he even had a brother.
What if Mr. Jingles is related to the Polks? Lee’s ear was cut off by the Polks.
Well his name is Benjamin Rchter or sth like that so I think he isn't, but wuld be cool that connection with Roanoke
I definitely think this season is connected to Roanoke but I also have a theory that both Roanoke and this season are connected to Murder House.
@@newboyzfiend94 Roanoke is already connected with MH about the legends of Piggy Man and the Croatoan spell, my bet is this season will connect with Asylum.
@@joijiparra yeah you're right gosh there is so much to remember but my theory is that this season may have something to do with the dad from Murder House and the people he said he murdered. I believe he's actually Constance's son and thats why he was drawn to the Murder House. Also Constance is from Virginia and Roanoke took place in Virginia. However, I agree this season may be tied to Asylum. Honestly at this point this season maybe the season we've all been waiting for, the season that ties ALL the seasons together. 😯😍
Stringing all the ears together made me think of Daryl from season 2 walking dead
And before that it also was done in Apocalypse now.
To be honest, i read somewhere that some soldiers during the Vietnam war really made and was wearing this ear necklaces for real.
So it originates from much further back then the Walking Dead or Universal Soldier. ;)
YES I thought I was the only one!
I thought of Roanoke when the teeth where stringed together in the promo!
Sameeee yep I thought I was the only oneee
I think what I like about American Horror Story is that everyone is on the table. You never feel like anyone is safe. Of course, this sometimes back fires. If tropes start to flip and Brooke end up surprise dying in the next few episodes , I'd be personally sad.
"you know when people have sex they're gonna die" yes guys! I'm immortal!
I thought of Heathers with the fake hanging scene B~)
Goonies opening scene
I thought of Heathers too
Same!
I am
So addicted to you guys!!!!! Since finding you last season every AHS breakdown I live for .. when the show was over yesterday I told myself now I gotta wait for you guys to post a video!!! I love your content
Is it just me or did the message Xavier was listening to sound like it was his own voice? I’m getting split personality vibes like Norman Bates style.
Also, I absolutely love how Ryan Murphy is so true to genre with the perfectly replicated 80’s camera shots, acting, and directing. Brilliant on the intro remix too!!
It’s so refreshing to have found a channel where y’all point out and find things that I do when I watch the show. The in-depth feel makes me love AHS even more!
Is this gonna be your default outfit for AHS 1984 breakdowns? I dont mind tho. 😂
Erina Ray we think so lol
@@ryanerikpeterson You all should alternating outfits every week.
I was excited for the new premiere of AHS but i was even more excited for this video
Less than thirty seconds to get the Stu/Stew joke. I'll admit: I don't watch the show. I just listen to you guys. Love it!
Please get these out sooner if at all possible! Love these so much every week!
I've been looking forward to this recap!
Unless I missed something, we didn't actually see the face of Mr Jingles prior to 1984.....
I think Brook is going to be a killer and she collects one piece of jewelry from each person she kills, and that's why she was looking at them fondly since she's so knowledgable about killers lol but Idk
Love this theory. Also who tf goes off in the woods with strangers after just being attacked by a serial killer? Someone as equally crazy? 🤔
That actually makes sense
I thought about that too during the ep. But then I said nah...lol
Maybe Xavier is Margaret’s son bringing the other counselors to be killed one by one.
DUDE that would be crazy
And he said he is an actor so maybe he is just acting to get them to camp redwood to please his mom or Mr jingles if he is obsessed with Mr jingles
This is such an AMAZING theory! 👏🏾👏🏾 good job!
Was i the only one that thought the hiker looked like Kevin bacon
I thought that too!!
It probably because Kevin bacon was in the very first Friday the 13th
Or Jamie Kennedy(Randy Meeks in Scream)
I thought it was him at first too
Y'all need your vision checked. Kevin Bacon is an old man
My favorite sub-genre of horror is slashers, so I really like this season so far!! It’s a nice change up to the more modern and meta slasher shows like Scream: The TV Series and Scream Queens. This could easily become one of my favorite seasons if there’s not too many crazy twists that make it less slashery
AHS season is the best part of the year cause it means more GSU content! Always looking forward to your vids :)
I thought the suicide scene was more of a callback to Heathers
Alex Romo shut up heather 😁
Sorry heather
In the beginning when we see all the bodies on the floor of the cabin Mr. Jingles walks right over Margaret without taking her ear...and he didn't take the ear from the gas station dude or the guard in the hospital...Margaret is giving me Mrs. Vorhees vibes big time!! Also I think the hiker is a ghost...he looks waaaay too 70's, and he said the phone lines were down when they weren't.
*Looks for Gamespot breakdown of AHS. Can’t find it, closes RUclips app. 40 minutes later... YESSSSSS! 🙌🏻
Great first episode. I clocked out after episode 3 of Apocolypse, and forget the season before that. I was SO refreshed after this first episode. I'm really excited for this season.
Also, conspiracy theory: the hiker is a ghost ala murder house
I literally said "they did that in The Goonies" when i saw Mr Jingles in the cell lmfaoo and also when Brooke (Emma Roberts) was drenched head to toe in mud I was getting MAJOR Carrie vibes
The anticipation of this breakdown was REAL.. Great job guys 😎
I was waiting patiently for this video to come out and I can’t wait to dig in.
Btw lovin the new looks😻
This video is absolutely amazing!!! Thank you so much!! This is just so perfect in depth and the scenes.. wow. Thank you. Love your channel!
Cant help laughing at Mathew Morrison so used to seeing him playing Mr Shue in glee cant take him seriously 😂😂😂
you guys do such a good job of analyzing and explaining things! Cant believe the episode aired wednesday and you uploaded thursday- phenomenal! keep up the great work :)
I hope Brooke by the end of the season turn's into Erin from your next, That would be amazing.
I love these breakdown videos. I love how these guys pick the episode apart and point out things that I always miss.
The fake suicide is similar to Veronica Sawyer's from Heathers which is also from the 80s.
I look forward to these reviews. I can’t watch the actual show because I have a weak stomach but I enjoy how in depth you both get for each episode!
the nurse is actually a journalist. the young version of the journalist from ahs cult played by adina porter (beverly hope).
Yesss I couldn’t wait to be able to watch u guys review!!!!
Brooke's last name Thompson is also the last name of Nancy, the final girl on Nightmare of Elm Street. I wonder if that's a clue. I'm very sure there will be some supernatural elements.
kept refreshing waiting for this video lol the outfits, the editing, without your videos the AHS experience isn't complete! love you guys! THANK YOU
I feel like the acting is a deliberate choice and a callback to the stilted and unintentionally goofy acting of the all the 70s/80s slasher movies.
True did give me that vibe
I am born 1961...i always found such acting style boring... I miss seasons like coven, cult, freak show, murder House... This is a yawn... Was hoping for a George Orwell theme...
Especially all the falling down. Geesh. Why are people always falling down in horror flicks?
Love you guys! Favorites on this channel!
I legit just finished watching the first episode not even ten minutes ago, holy shit 😂
Shara Gonzales perfect timing 👍🏼
Got my snacks and I'm ready to settle in, I was constantly refreshing the homepage to see when a breakdown was happening, I'm ready!
leslie tweeted that the glasses rest on her ear nub lmao
I'm so glad you guys are back
Does Ryan look like a mixture of Jimmy Fallon and Justin Timberlake or is it just me?
I knew they were to close to not have a child lol
Idk about Justin Timberlake.. I see a mix of Jimmy Fallon and Dane Cook
YES
Jimmy Timberlake and Berrnie The Entertainer.
Of two white men? Yeah I guess.
Welcome back guys! Now AHS weeks are complete 😁 I'm loving this season so far, the music is fantastic!!
The stew is stu never gets old 😂😂😂😂
I missed these weekly videos ! 😭👏🏻 ❤️
Xaviers answering machine message sounds like it's from himself, its his voice.
Finally been waiting all day for this
The payphone scene, would that be considered a call back to Scream?
Emett Penaloza haha...CALL back? Because...phone?
Fifi Mercer what other classic slasher movie’s ICONIC scene has a mysterious phone call 🧐
Finally starting to marathon the season, which means marathoning your recaps. I have so missed the Stew is Stu scene!
"Chanel #3" (Billie Lourd) *keepin'* those totes-adorbs ears covered, even on another show... 👂😏👍
You guys made me laugh so hard hahahhaha. You went ALL in with this one 😂
Tooook sooo long to upload i love u guys been watching since stew xD
LOOKING forward to ALL of you guys's season long breakdowns 😏🙃😊🎈🎉⭐😀😀😀
I was more excited for this video than the actual show
You guys won't let the "the Stew is Stew line" die and I love it!
The movie in Scream was Stab. And Emma Roberts was in Scream 4!
Oh boy I was waiting for this guys and you did NOT disappoint!!!
I've never clicked like on a video so fast those outfits 😂
Hawthorne is the hospital the nurse works at, but also in Apocalypse, Outpost 3 was Hawthorne School for Exceptional Young Men
Great catch!
I could see a Truman Show ending where all of this was acting? Like a cruel social experiment.
OH that would be really cool this or the time loop theory
"how does she wear glasses with one ear?" this is easily one of the most important questions that need to be asked because holy shit, I didn't even think of that.
It's actually pretty easy, I once broke my glasses so one of the arms came off but the glasses still stayed perfectly on, I guess it's the same as not having an ear
If the scenes with Mr Jingles escaping happened the same night as the main story, then there's no way that kid who was hit by the van was running from Mr Jingles as hadn't made it to the camp yet. So then who cut off his ear?
Also, just speculating... maybe Mr Jingles didn't kill the campers back in the day. Maybe it was the "star witness" who framed Mr Jingles and now he's coming back for his revenge....
This Theory make sense to me.
The Broken Matt Hardy delete clip just won me over. I have officially subscribed to your channel