Это видео недоступно.
Сожалеем об этом.
Waqia Karbala | واقعہ کربلا | Javed Ahmad Ghamidi
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 июл 2024
- Official Websites: www.al-mawrid.org and www.javedahmadghamidi.com
Official email: info@al-mawrid.org
Submit a question: www.al-mawrid.org/askaquestion
#islam #quran #almawrid #farahi #islahi #javedahmadghamidi #ghamidi #sajidhameed #talibmohsin #rafimufti #izharahmad #shehzadsaleem #moizamjad #karbala #hussain #yazeed #muharram
![📌🔥 RESPONSE TO Orientalists on Multiple Marriages of the PROPHET ﷺ [COMPLETE] ‼️ JAVED AHMAD GHAMIDI](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/PXPjtyThxAI/mqdefault.jpg)
![📌🔥 RESPONSE TO Orientalists on Multiple Marriages of the PROPHET ﷺ [COMPLETE] ‼️ JAVED AHMAD GHAMIDI](/img/tr.png)
![Jordan Adetunji - KEHLANI REMIX (feat. Kehlani) [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EeJ8n5PxFGE/mqdefault.jpg)
Waqia e karbala 28:01
Thanks
Thanks
thanks
Waqita Karbala ko samjhnay Sy pehlay Tareekh ka Background samjhna bhot zarori tha... Don't miss that
May Allah bless ustad imam long healthy life ❤
Kindly fix voice issues soo many important issues are discussed every body should listen carefully may Allah bless ghamidi sahb and his beloved.
kindly wear headphones even with the half volume I can hear him clear and loudly.
غامدی صاحب کی گفتگو کے وقت مائک کا خیال رکھ لیا کریں
Wonderful insight
Assalam
Why voice is very low in all your recordings
please set ghamdi mic..Jo sawal Puch rha Hy us ka mic zabrdst Hy wo mic hona chaye ghamdi ka kindly is baat ka khyal rekhain asal baat hi jb awaz Sahi na honay pr sunayee na day to puri mehnat bekaar hy
Masha Allah. Ghamidi sb bohat behtareen andaz say apnay sara waqiya samjhaya
Assalamu Alaikum, Ghamidi Sahib!
I hope this message finds you in good health. I have been greatly benefiting from your knowledge and find immense peace in watching your videos. I will be traveling from Pakistan to Toronto on the 20th and am very eager to meet you in person. I kindly request your prayers for a safe and smooth journey and hope that a meeting with you will be possible.
JazakAllah Khair.
Jiski Rago me Atishe badr o hunain hai,
Us soorma ka Ism e garami Hussain hai...
Josh Malihabadi
Umdaa sholors
Jazakallah khair 🥰
❤
No doubt Javed Ghamdi Sahab is a good scholar, his philosophy method is very nearer to Ibn e Taymiyah. But a difference is hadith interpretation
How about Hazrat Ali, please provide details about how Hazrat Ali was elected you mentioned 3 Kalifa's name
So Many thanks
AoA.
غامدی صاحب کی خدمت میں عرض ہے کہ ان واقعات کے بارے میں خود رسول اللہ کی جو رائیے علمی طور پر مانی گیئ میں وہ کیسے نظر انداز کی جا سکتی ہیں۔
Salam ghamdi sb
Ws
Jzzak.ALLAH❤
غامدی صاحب نے حق بیان فرمایا ہے۔۔جزاک اللہ
جناب یہ غامدی صاحب مسلم سکالرز میں ایک ڈھنگ کے آدمی ہیں، ان کو امام، مولانا، وغیرہ جیسے القابات سے دور ہی رکھیں تو زیادہ مناسب ہوگا۔ اسی شخصیت پرستی نے اسلام کو بہت نقصان پہنچایا ہے۔ تنقید کا راستہ ہی بند کردیا ہے۔ جبکہ غامدی صاحب اسلام میں تحقیق و تنقید کے علمبردار ہیں۔ جزاک اللہ
@@quest...6246 جزاک اللہ۔
Most scientific explanation
God bless you❤
@Al-Mawrid Could you please provide information or suggest a link where Ghamidi Sahib explains the allegations of abuse against Ahle Bait by Ameer Muawiya/ Umayyad reign? Much appreciated.
الحاد پر کوئی سیریز ریکارڈ کروا دیں
الحاد پہ غامدی صاحب کیا بولیں گے جبکہ یہ فلسفہ اسلامی سے ہی دور ہیں ۔ کلاسیکی الحاد کے خلاف صرف ہمارے عظیم مسلم فلاسفہ جیسے بوعلی سینا نے کام کیا ہے۔ جبکہ الحاد جدید کے خلاف مسلمانوں کے پاس کچھ نہیں
بو علی سینا کا کہا پڑھا جاسکتا؟@@syedpak9549
Nabi ke dour may pehla mahina MOTEMEER thaa phir Moharram kaise bana😮😮
ماشاءالله
ایک ایک الفاظ قیمتی ہےغامدی صاحب کا مائک کا رکھ لیا ہوتا اللّه صحت و تندرستی دے غامدی صاحب کو ❤
کیا مدینہ چھوڑ کر دارالخلافہ کوفہ منتقل کرنا کیسا تھا کیا صحیح فیصلہ تھا؟ جواب ضرور دیں اگر جواب پہلے دیا ہوا ھے تو اس تک رسائی حاصل کیسے کی جائے ؟
Waiting for the next episode
jo jo ghamdi sahib ko sunta ha wo bano ummayya ki tareeq parly. yanhan do qisim ke islam chal rahain hain. aik banu umayya ka islm or aik resool e khuda ka islam.
this is the beauty of real life. Its combination of everything , its not black or white . Nobody is pure evil and nobody is angel.....History is human..Insan ko isan hi rehne dein is me koi harj nahi...Accept the history as is.....
Please fix voice issue
sawal ba sawal ya mouzu der mauzu title dalna start keren shukriya !
Ghamdi sab taasub q rakhtay hain hazrat Imam Hassan ki shahaadat k baaray mai baat kartay howay. Mai shia nai lakin mai boht aqeedat rakhti hun un say or samjhti hun k aale rasool ko shaheed kia giaya or unko shaheed karnay walay munafiqat k tareekay sai iqtadaar par qabza kar k aai.
Historical reference of the detail of History karabla, Aaal Hazar kuch guaar frameen
"Tarikh al-Tabari" (The History of al-Tabari):
Author: Muhammad ibn Jarir al-Tabari
Description: This multi-volume work is one of the most comprehensive early Islamic histories. Volume XIX, "The Caliphate of Yazid ibn Mu‘awiyah," specifically covers the events of Karbala.
Language: Originally in Arabic, but translated into English by various scholars.
"Tarikh Ibn Kathir" (The History of Ibn Kathir):
Author: Ismail ibn Kathir
Description: A prominent historical work that includes detailed accounts of the Battle of Karbala. Ibn Kathir’s narratives are considered important for their detail and perspective.
Language: Originally in Arabic, with English translations available.
"Tarikh al-Yaqubi" (The History of al-Yaqubi):
Author: Ahmad ibn Abi Yaqub ibn Ja'far ibn Wahb ibn Wadih al-Ya'qubi
Description: An early Islamic history that includes an account of the Karbala incident, offering a different perspective from other historians.
Language: Originally in Arabic.
"Al-Futuh" (The Conquests):
Author: Ibn A'tham al-Kufi
Description: This book provides a detailed account of the Battle of Karbala and the events leading up to it. It is a primary source for many later historians.
Language: Originally in Arabic.
Simple si baat hai Jab Ali Moula Jesi Hasti Mojood ho Uske samne koi b ajaye wo Batil hai wo Haq par nahi....Ya Ali ❤️
Great mind
voice is low
bhai hamary nabi S.A.W.W. ne hazrat Ali A.S. ko apni jagha zimmedar bana kar gae. jo hamary nabi ko nahi manta wo musalman hi nahi ha.
حضور نے کسی کو اپنا جانشین مقرر نہیں کیا ۔
video quality very inferior to GCIL uploads
❤❤❤❤❤ ustad
Excellent❤
Aap logo ki sound quality bahot hi kharaab hai, ghamdi sahab ka sound hi nhi aata
Jung e siffin me haq per kaun tha
Gamadi sir jawab de please
It was a power struggle so dono hap per thay.
Behtareeeen guftogo g
hazrat Ali A.S. ne tamam jang ( jang e badar. ohad khandak ) ma bary bary sormaon ko tahe degh kiya jis ki wajha se unke bety se karbala ma inteqam lia geya.
jhoot mat gharo apne paas se ya jaahil rafidi
I'm loving the pure, unadulterated sectarian divide in the comments. I'm particularly impressed by Syeds/Shahs' inability to handle neutrality. 😊
😅
All cults suppress crititcal thinking in their followers, the shia cult is no different.
😂😂
Neutral views.... i dont know what personnal / issue you have with syeds/ shahs..
But if you think ghamidi was having a neutral point of view. You yourself are unaware of what neutral means .
Read actual literature And go throughs reading material yourself.. only watching videos on net witbout actually reading something will lead you and other youth like you astray...
@@syedmuhammadalishah9568 There is no 'Actual' literature. If you knew anything about islamic history you would know that there is no recorded Islamic history for its first 200 years (I think Ghamidi mentions this also). The acutal literature you are talking about has been fabricated by third rate maulvis. Take for example the case of making Hussain into an infalible imam. How can a sane self-respecting person who reads the Quran can believe in such BS is beyond me. As for Syeds, the fact that your great great grandmother was ravaged by some maurading Arab is no sign of greatness or pride. All you need to know about Islamic history is summed up be Iqbal when he says:
Haqiqat Khurafat Mein Kho Gyi
Ye Ummat Rawayat Mein Kho Gyi
The truth has been lost in absurdities,
And the Ummah is lost in traditions.
@@omarkhan3256
There IS a lot of islamic literature if you want to find ... dont say there is none becoz you dont want to read.
If you want to become atheist and have sex with your mother and sister . Do it freely . But dont say that islam is imperfect.
Janab javed ghamidi sahab se guzarish hai ke hazrat mouavia(ra) ne jo hazrat Ali (as) ke khilaaf mimbar par jo shab o sitam ya burai karwaya uske baare mein batayen aur ghadeer khum ki hadees, hazrat saad abee waqqas wali hadees , hazrat Ammar bin Yasir ke shaheed hone wali peshan goi wali hadees. Poore Aale rasool ko shaheed kin logon ne kiya uspar bolen.
Garz ke Mirza mohd Ali engineer ne jo iss issue par ghamidi sahab par tanqeed ki uski wazahat kijiye
Ghamidi sahab pehle hi yeh sab batein bayan kar chuke hai.aap search mein type kare ....
@@expert00775
barai meherbani agar koi link ho toh bhej do. Maine ustad javed ghamidi se bohot kuch seekha khaas taur se jihad ko lekar unka narrative qabil e taareef aur sahi hai.
Thanks
او بھائی یہ تاریخی روایات شیعوں سے منقول ہیں ان کے راوی سارے شیعے ہیں
ہوش کرو بھائی خود تحقیق کرو
Gentleman and The Scholar.
Badri sahabi or ashra mubashira jalil ul daer hoga ya muaviia??? Kon shak kry ga badri sahbi py wo bhi ali jaisay py ??? Sawal e paida nhi hoga...muavia ki category btayen ap
Tameez say naam low! Kaatib e wahi hen! Musalmano kay pehla behri bera bhee unho ne sir kiya! Nabi S.A.W unkay behnoi hen!
@@danyalparacha1761 filhal to tamiz ha agar mainy Yaha Muslim or bukhari ki ahadees send krdi na to itni izat bhi nhi hogi jitni ma kr rha hu mujy fark nhi prta Kya tha Jo tha apny liay tha... Jao Muslim ki hadees parho jisma muavia katal or maal lootnay ka hukqm dy rha ha ...hazrat ali par lanat ka hukqm dy rha ha ..pehly ja ky books parho...koi kaatib nhi ha or behri bayra wali drama bzi sari Nikal gye ha ...iski jurat kaisay hui badri sahabi sy Jang krny ki ..Quran kehta ha ky Fatah makah sy pehly or baad waly brabr nhi to iski kaisay jurat hui hazrat ali ky brabr aya..jisky ajdad mar kha kha ky kuch jahanum ma gye or kuch last option ky baad musalman huay..Jao ja ky pehly vughz Ali sy Nikal ky Quran or hadees parho m..isko to koi khalifa Rashid bhi nhi kehta .na he yay tha
What about gadeer (man kontm mola fa haza ali yonmola???
Very poor sound quality of this video
I think it's incomplete?
According to Islamic teaching its make disqualification wish to become leader; unless it comes from consultation . Ali does not think like that.
There is no such Islamic teachign like that. Quran and Muhammad clearly did a very bad job of explaing how political power should be transfered and how to govern a large empire and that is why the arabs got into the mess that they did.
Hazrat Ali ka adam ta'awan nahi tha??????? jang e yamama,yarmook and Qadesia me kia participation thi???
اللہ غامدی صاحب کو صحت مند زندگی عطا فرمائے، بڑی اچھی تحقیق کی ہے۔ پھر اس تحقیق کو اتنی تفصیل اور اتنے اچھے طریقے سے پیش کیا ہے کہ نا صرف اسلامی تاریخ کے انتہائی نازک موڑ کو بڑے اچھے طریقے سے واضح کیا ہے، بلکہ دور جدید کے لیئے بھی اسلام میں اقتدار کے تعین کے لیئے اسلامی اصول بیان کردیئے ہیں۔
Ghamandi is defender of moviyah and banoo ummeh
He is telling truth......not factitious stories like zakirs
There should be english subtitles instead of hindi...
All recordings are very poor sound
السلام علیکم
غامدی صاحب ذرا آسان زبان استعمال کیا کریں، مہربانی۔
اگر غامدی صاحب نہ ہوتے تو اج میں مسلمان نہ ہوتا میں اسلام چھوڑ چکا تھا علمائے سو کی وجہ سے پر جسے اللہ نے ہدایت دینی ہوتی ہے ذرائع خود بن جاتے ہیں اللہ کرے میری زندگی بھی غامدی صاحب کو لگ جائے بس ایک عاجزانہ سے گزارش ہے اگر شاگردگی کی امان پاؤں تو اسلام اور سائنس میں تھوڑا سا فرق ہے میرے روحانی استاد واصف علی واصف رحمتہ اللہ علیہ میں فرمایا (تسلیم کے بعد تحقیق گمراہ کرتی ہے) استاد محترم میں خود ہمیں یہ درس دیا اپ جیسے اس دور کے سب سے عظیم اسکالر تو یہ کہہ سکیں کہ مجھے اپ کی سینکڑوں ویڈیوز دیکھنے کے بعد اہل بیت سے عشق کی تھوڑی سی کمی نظر ائی ہے 🙏
inki wje se to me bhi Mulhidun k Chungal se nikla ❤
Prompt: Consider yourself as an unbiased Islamic history researcher and if you had to lean slightly towards one side, Shia or sunni, which side you will choose and why?
Meta AI: As an unbiased Islamic history researcher, I would lean slightly towards the Shia perspective for the following reasons:
1. Historical continuity: The Shia perspective maintains a direct line of succession from the Prophet Muhammad to his family, specifically his son-in-law Ali and their descendants. This continuity is rooted in the Prophet's teachings and the early Islamic community's recognition of Ali's leadership.
2. Spiritual guidance: The Shia emphasis on the Imams as spiritual guides and interpreters of Islamic teachings resonates with the Quranic emphasis on guidance and the importance of spiritual leadership.
3. Justice and equality: The Shia tradition places a strong emphasis on social justice, equality, and the fight against oppression, reflecting the Prophet's teachings and the early Islamic community's values.
4. Theological coherence: Shia theology, particularly in its Twelver and Ismaili branches, presents a more comprehensive and systematic approach to understanding the nature of God, the Prophet, and the Imams, aligning with the Quranic emphasis on reason and intellect.
5. Historical records: While both sides have their own narratives, Shia historical records and accounts from the early Islamic period appear more detailed and consistent, providing a richer understanding of the events and personalities involved.
Mubarakbad.😂😂😂😂
Ahle Bait Beewiyo ko bolte hai. unka is par bhi ek video hai. Ahle bait Arabi me Ahle khana ko kahte hai.. Ahle bait rafziyo ka khela hua khel hai jis se Islam me sirf Shaksiyat parasti ko baab khula hai.
بھاءی اگر آپ نے حق کو حق تسلیم کیا ہے تو تحقیق گمراہ کیوں کریگی ۔تحقیق تو تصدیق کریگی ۔اس طرح کی باتیں وہ لوگ کرتے ہیں جنکے پاس جواب نہیں ہوتا ۔اسلام دین حق ہے ۔تحقیق کی پھونکیں اسے بجھا نہ سکیں گی بلکہ اسے مزید روشن و واضح کر دیں گی۔
آپ کے دوسرے اشکال کے بارے میں عرض ہے کہ کیا ہمارا عشق اہل بیت فریق ثانی کو بیجا لعنت ملامت کرنے کا باعث بن جانا چاہیے ۔غامدی صاحب نے کہیں بھی اہل بیت کی شان ورفعت و مرتبہ پر کوئی حرف نہیں آنے دیا ہے ۔
Banu ummaya sa itni nafrat ku hy….awam kon tareeekh perhni chahyai asbiyat ki ainak otar ker…phir samjh aega k banu ummaya na hoty to kia hota.
Loag nahin samjhenge bhai
Messiah to shia then nestorian rituals ?
حسن بھائ محترم غامدی صاحب عمران خان کا نام کیوں نہیں لیتے
اسکا نام لینے سے وضو فرض ھوجاتاھے
Sound problem solve it
Excellent interpretation
Shutar Keena, Pur Aman Inteqal i Iqtedar Honay Laga Hai,Bhala Ho Science Ka
How can Moulana sahib can give a scientific analysis while he has published 20 lectures against Imam Ali, his biased remains a hurdle for a just analysis! One thing Prophet stood against was Zulm , yet brother Ghamdi continues to make a case for Zalim leader! 😢😢😢
I think you have been brainwashed by the maulvis of the shia cult that is why you can't even understand an academic study of history when it is presented to you. You should look at the period following Muhammad's death as a time of struggle for political power among the various Arab tribes. There is nothing sacred about it. The clergy of shia sect has successfuly made Ali into a demigod so that they can claim power and there followers lap it up without using their brains.
Rizvi sahab i am sure you understand the DIFFERENCE between a Prophet and a Sahabi?
He is not biased as he is not rafzi or shia :P just explained both the political and historical situation of that time in those videos
Karbala ka sawal . Jawab mai idar udar se utha k ummayad ko acha banane laga
اس کی قیمت وہ دنیا میں مشغول کر رہا ہے
Poori guftagoo meiñ KARBALA ka zikr kahāñ hei...??
BEWAQOOF banaaya...??
Title hai waqia e karbala... karbala ka aik dafa bhi zikr nahin huwa... tmam jhot par mabni.
Gamdicsb agr ap hazrat ali ko jhalifa rashid kehty ha to muavia ka kharioj kaisay justify hua khalifa rashid jy khilaf ...???'30 saal wali hadees ky bhi munkir hain ap kya?? Or janb muavia ki shab ahdess main byayen
Bahut moti rakam lekar imaan becha hai ghamdi ji ne
Imam HASSAN ka established Qatil Moaviya hey.
Hussain baghawat na karty to qatal na hoty bat khatam
Aik tareekhi reference ni
@@noornashad1141 to bolo Allah tumhara faisla yazeed ke sath kare, or unka hussain ke sath....(kitna bada zumla bol diya ghaur krna..baaghi bol diya tumne hussain ko..Allah rehem kre)
Ameen
لا کم دینکم ولی یادین
Please change the logo of twitter
Kha yazeed paleed aur kha Hussain Ibn e Ali A.S.
Jo bhe muhabat rakhta ha qatleen e hussain k sath Allah talah isi muhabat k tufail banu umaya aur yazeed o muwiya k sath mehshoor kry ..
Kio k Jis janat k shab o roz khawb dekhty hen ap aur ap jesy..us janat ka sardaar Hussain A.S ha..
Ghamdi sb ta qyamat bhe ap jesy koshish krty rhy defend krne ki nhi kr skty..
Agr power struggle hoti to Imam apne sath 6 maa ka bacha le k aty karbala mein ? 72 ke muqable me sawa lakh , ye jang nhi massacre tha..aur kisi aur ka nhi..usi rasool k khandan ka jiska muslman kalma prthy hen..
Bhai imam kissi jang mai ni jarahe the..woh koofa ja rahe the..yazeed ko koi bhi musalmaan acha ni samajhta hai
Ji Bhai me bhe whi arz kr rha hu..jang me jana hota to sath aurten aur bachy na hoty..
Afsos yhi k hen aj bhe esy musalman jo defend krty he qatileen e imam ko..
Sorry 'there is nothing much about Karbla specifically Ghamdi Sahib just generalised the topic
Imam Ki bat hi Nahi hay Puri guftago me ajeeb jahalat
Very well confusion created and diverted Ghamidi sahab! ..,,, Karbala and Lal Masjid.. Karbala and Akbar Badshah.. .. Shahdat-e- Hazrat Usman .. hazrat Ali and Hazrat Muawia political conflict .. and hiddenly disrespecting harat ali.. relatively irrelevant debate but no word of Karbal of Yazeed and Imam Hussain.... aap ny tu Karbal ko islam sy hee kharij kar diya.. aur islam ki bunyad sy hee munafi thehra diya.. aur established history aur translated History ky nam pay very well played..... kiya yeh Allah ky Rasool Allah SAW sy khuli bewafi aur Ghaddari nahi .. jinhon ny husnain e kareemain ko jaawanan e jannat ka sardar bataya hai.. Hazrat Abu bakar ka Qaul hai.. Rasool Allah ki Muhabbat ko unky Ahul bait main talash karo.. aur muslim aur sahee bukhari ki daleelain bhari pari hain.. unki shan main.. sirf ye sochiye ky qayamat ki din Allah aur unki habeeb ko kiya moun dikhain gay.. agar nafrat karni hai tu .. un sy karyn jo in pak hastiyoun ky nam pay biddatain farough dety hain .. na ky Ahle bait sy.. ..is main koi shaq nhi ky roz akhirat yazeed ya uska khandan .. kisi shfa'at ky mansub pa faiz hoon gy.. lekin is bat ki guarantee apko bhi hai ky nbi k khandan zarur i mansub pa faiz hoga.. main aik intahayee kamzor aur natanawa suuni musalman hoon.. lekin .. lekin is bat ka mujhy mukamal yaeen aur eemaan hai ky ahle bait ky bina eemaan mukamal nhi hota.. ye hamary rab aur unky habib ka farmaan hai.... aap aik intahayee qabil e ahtaram zeerak aalim deen hain.. lekin sirf is bat sy khabraty hain .. ky log kiya kahain gy.. toheed aur khilafat ki raghbat chorr ky.. imamat ky peechy chal pary,, Ap jis jaga hain wahin aftab hain.. lekin.. Ahle bait ki ismat azmat aur haqeeqat rab ki taraf sy atta ki gayee izzat ko deeda danista nazar andaz ya .. chasham poshi na karen.... Kiuyn ky inki shan ma namaz ma bayan kiye gay Alhamd shareef aur drood shareef dono hee sy Ahle bait ko nhi nikala ja sakta,,
Shia is the Yazidi religion not the Hussaini.
Ghamidi Sahib has been on record saying that Ali R.A was nothing more than a " Jaleel ul Qadr sahabi " . He totally ignores his services and his stature during Prophet SAW times, he practically "demotes" him to an ordinary Sahabi. In this scenario , how could his opinion be regarded as neutral. This is the softest version of my two scents.
Bro what u on about? hes just a sahabi but his duties fir islam are much great no one disagrees because after prophet we all are mere humans why u worshipping him
His services were for Islam and they don't not grant him any right to political power nor do they make him something above a normal human being. The services of the Ansar were far greater but they were kept out of power. BTW what kind of "scents" are we talking about here :) did you mean 'cents'?.
So what ' he was a human being he was a Jaleel ul Qadr sahabi that's all Ghamidi sahab is absolutely correct .
Repitation of some statements. Poor editing
bhai ye hi tu masla ha. risalat manb jab islam ke lia kam kar rahy teh aksaryat tu chahrahi thi wo kaam na karaiin.tu hamry nabi ko aksarriyat ka kheyal rakhty howay islam ka kam (hatam kar dety. naozubillah.
Bad sound quality
sharam karain ghamdi sahb
Imam Zain ul abideen 40 saal waqey Karbala ko Beyan ker ke rotey rahey hain
Poor voice quality
Ghamidi shb, afsos hay ap pay ...
Agr Moavia itny hi deen e Islam say mokhlis hoty tu
Jb un ko moula Ali (a.s) ki khilafat aur bait ka ilm hota tu woh lashkar lay kr na nikal aty.
Moavia nay bagavat ki the aur us ki ek daleel us ka apny bety kay haq may bait lena apni hi zindage may
He was asking for justice for Usman radiallahu anhu
@@maverick99995 bhai, ap moavia ka dor e hakomat dekh lain pta chal jaye ga kay hazrat Usman (r.a) kay liye justice chahiye tha hakomat ki lalach the ...
Jb bnu ummayah ko hakomat mil gye tb un ko qatal e Hazrat usman ka faisla krna chahiye tha
Tb tu unhn nay kuch nhi kia
Aur agr man bhi liya jaye kay moavia Hazrat Usman kay qatal ka badla chahta tha
Tu pehly moula Ali ki bait krta phr justice ki demand krta
Yh kon sa trika hay kay khalifa ki bait krni nhi ulta lashkar ly ky jung shuru krdo
@@ahsanali7269Bhai tm bechare jazbati or kund zehn ho Zara aik dfa khd se tareekh prh ker ana. Qasas hazrat ameer muaviya ne lia tha ashtar or Muhammad bin abibkr ko qatal ker ke jinka name Hazrat Usman ke wife ne lia tha, dosra qatl e Usman ke foran bad Ali ra ne tamam governor ko mazooli ke khat lkhe ab agar wo mazooli qubool krte TU qatleen e Usman unke sath kya salook krte jabke inho ne Hazrat Usman ke sath Jo kia wo sab ko maloom tha. Hazrat Ameer Muaviya ne bait ni ke na mazooli accept ki jab tk qasas e Usman na kia jae Jo ke Ali ra le ni skte the kyunke wo politically itne strong ni the. Phr hazrat Ali he Jung krne muaviya ra ke pas gaye the. Thora ilm hasil kro zakiro or engineer se Deen na lia kro. Situation itne khrab the ke ashra mUbashra jinke jannat confirmed he inho ne bait tore or baqi ashra mubashra siwae Ammar ke sab ne Ali ra ke bait ni ke. Jabke jung me Ali ra ka sath ni dia
Back ground
The entire Shia Belt is from Iraq first and then Faras (modern day Iran) converted to Islam from Christianity.
Exception is Iran converted from Zorosterian majority and Christians in minority.
Point one.
When there is no historical evidence or record in history for atleast 2 to 3 centuries. This is evident,
Karbala event is cultivated story,
Point Two.
There are Nizari Shia, Mastalin Shia (Bhohra Community today) and Itna Ashri or twelver (believe in twelve imam).
Mastalin and Nizari remain away from Bloody Matam.
But twelver are more in favour of Matam.
Why this question arises , because majore Part of Iraq in 6, 7 and 8th Century were Christians.
The Pir (shia Aalim or Scholar, particularly Qasim Shahi Scholars) utilize a unique way to convert but adopted a more liberal form of Islam where new Converts or targeted group of community allowed to follow their previous or cultural rituals and Abbasid Rulers provided patronage.
Unique liberal method were slow and gradual in conversion, with passage of time Those Scholars replaced entire narration of the Concept with Story of Killing at Karbala.
Few christian groups even today they flagging (inflict pain by hurting self (Not Matam matam is hurting in morning)).
question.
There is any connection of Matam to christianity?.
Further more
In Christianity, self-flagellation is practiced in the context of the doctrine of the mortification of the flesh and is seen as a spiritual discipline. It is often used as a form of penance and is intended to allow the flagellant to share in the sufferings of Jesus, bringing his or her focus to God.
Entire event of Karbala is cultivated story to keep Flagellation ritual among those Christian communities believe in fllagellation.
In turn this fllegenation ritual coming from Judaism.
Even Twelver concept is coming from 12 Apostales
Abu sufiyan ne jindagi bhar paigambar Hazrat pahunchai me maviya Abu sufiyan ibne sufiyan aamin Hazrat Ali ko Hazrat pahunchata Raha aur yajid maloom nahin imame Husain ke sath hu ke leye bhejye aur Mavia ki hinda ne Nabi ke Shahid chacha ka kaleja chabaya aisi maluna ka beta hota hai vah yadi maloom lanat hai uske pure nasl per lanat
امام النواصب کیا کہنے اپ کے
بنو امیہ کی اتنی کارستانیوں کے باوجود اتنے آرام سے دفاع کرنے پر،جیسا کہ انہوں نے کچھ کیا ہی نہ ہو،غامدی صاحب پر حیرت ہوتی ہے ۔
Vo knsa inkar rahay hn Karbala me huway zulam se
un pr ilzamat k saboot me sirf jo gawahiyan hamary pas pohanchi hain wo na to mustanad zaray se hum tk pohanchi hai or jo kuch pohanchi b hain wo sb k sb dono garoho me se kisi ak garoh me shamil thy. ab ap btao k is dowr me baith kr koi b shakhas hatmi faisla kesy kr sakta hai k haqiqat me kia hua tha ??
کھلے دل دماغ سے سن لیں تو ان کی باتوں سے بہت کچھ سیکھ سکتے ہیں۔ ضروری نہیں کہ بچپن سے سنی سنائی باتیں ہی درست ہوں۔ غامدی صاحب تو تحقیق کا طریقہ کار بھی بیان کر رہے ہین۔
@@quest...6246 bilkul theek
تاریخ سے یہ پتا چل سکتا ہے کہ یزید کو کس اصول پر منتخب کیا گیا اور کس نے کیا؟ کیا اس وقت یزید کے والد زندہ تھے؟ اگر وہ زندہ تھے تو مطلب انہی نے اصول بنا کر منتخب کیا ؟ اور اگر وہ نہیں تھے تو وہ خود کوئی اصول بنا گئے تھے؟
Pure and brutal defence of bani ummaiya and muavia
lol, you just wasted your time listening to this
open ut brain and try to understand
No one is bound to agree with what he says on the issue. These are his views on the subject matter. We as shia and sunni dnt need to fight within ourselves over this. Whatever we believe is true interpretation, nobody can force us to distance from that.
@@wwaqashussainhbu try to understand the oppression of prophet’s family
Local made syeds don't have courage to listen the truth. As you people have changed your lineage from shodaar hindu to Qureshi so called Syed.
واقعہ کربلا قوم پرستی کی بد ترین مثال ھے ۔
Jannat ke sardaron ka katla karke apne aap ko Musalman kahane wale munafiqeen
Respectfully disagree with you Ghamdi sahab. You started with taking support from Hadith and acknowledging the work done by Mohaddiseen and then totally ignored the huge data of Ahadith clearly telling us what amir muawiya was doing and why he did so. Anyway while we love your efforts we know that you are always biased for muawiyah. May Allah NOT get you standing with him when you are presented to Allah.
"May Allah NOT get you standing with him"? what does that mean?
APKA boht ehtram hey afsos se kehna parhta hey AP jesa admi bno umeya ko defend kar Raha hota hey umoman
Repeating same thing again and again.... samajh nahi aye k ye kya samjhana chahtay hain..., nothing about waqia karbala... no references no logic ..... taking side of ameer muaviya r.a
Ur level of intelligence is enough for a sermon by a Zakir
منطق اور لوجک ممکنہ طور پر کسی کے لیے دل آزاری کا باعث بنتا ہے۔ میرا خیال ہے کہ اہلِ سنت کا طریق بہتر ہے۔اہل بیت سے محبت لازم ہے مگر معاویہ پر کفر کے فتویٰ لگانا احسن طریق نہیں۔ انکا معاملہ اللّٰہ پر چھور دینا ہی بہتر ہے۔
یہ لازم کیا چیز ہے ؟
اہل بیت کون سے ؟
قرآنی یا حدیثی ؟
میں تو صرف قرآنی اہل بیت کا قا ئل ہوں وہ ہیں صرف ازواج المطہرات رضی اللہ عنھما
@@ashrafkashmiri6993 اہلبیت ہمارے ہاں ایک اصطلاح بن چکی ہے۔ اہلبیت کا ترجمہ نہیں کیا جاتا کیونکہ ترجمہ کرنے سے مفہوم واضح ہوجاتا ہے۔ (اہلبیت = گھر والے)
کیوں چھوڑ دو اللہ پر اللہ تو دے جہنم کی آگ دینا میں لعنت پڑتی رہے گی انشاللہ
اہل بیت ازواج مطہرات ہیں، جو امہات المومنین ہیں، اور تمام مسلمان ان سے اپنے ماں باپ سے بڑھ کر محبت کرتے ہیں۔
حضرت معاویہ رضی اللہ عنہ صحابی رسول اللہ صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم ہیں، ان پر کفر کا فتوی کون لگا سکتا ہے؟
یہ کام تو کوئی فرقہ پرست فسادی ہی کر سکتا ہے۔
اہلبیت ہمارے ہاں ایک اصطلاح بن چکی ہے۔ اہلبیت کا ترجمہ (گھروالے) کرنے سے مفہوم واضح ہوجاتا ہے۔