I would have never thought I would be making shoes, let alone feature in one of the channels I admire! Thank you so much Jon (and Steve!) for this! You both are amazing people.
I like the individual videos a bit better than the roundups. Especially if you’re including things in the roundups that you don’t have or are just showing the webpage for some of your recommendations.
I own a pair of Carlos Santos monk straps in a nice mid brown with a matching belt and I agree that the color and quality is fantastic. Sadly I bought the belt a while back and I have since put on 15ish pounds and no longer can wear the belt.
I prefer the individual videos when it comes to shoes and suits. When it comes to more ancillary items like dress shirts, polos, tees, shorts etc I prefer occasional round-up videos. Thanks again.
Don't like the stark white soles on the sneaks. For the navy, black soles would bring out the clour of the navy uppers, and for the brown (which are beautiful) taupe would be less obtrusive.
Why are you scared to say what other brand that falls 2nd to carlos sneaker, ? That info can help consumers to watch for difference.. so if you don't say other brand I guess they paid you for a good review and now you can take it back.
Why are you scare to mention what was the other brand that was dull ? It's important for us viewers to know just in case we want to buy the best out there. If your afraid because the other company paid you to say good things then shame shame because you would be giving consumers bad info...so yes wish you would've mentioned others that you compare the santos carlos to..
I'm always a sucker for a good hand painted patina and those loafers are absolutely gorgeous. As to your concerns at the end I like roundups and individual reviews, but I did just watch a good roundup on all the Johnnie Walker labels and found it the most helpful, so maybe that would be a good idea!
Your round up videos make you stand out in the YT Men Lifestyle world for sure and you need to keep that! But I do like your individual deep dive into more niche brands. I like knowing the history and how they operate, where they source their materials, etc. You have put me on to so many brands over the years and I like your focus on quality which I value a lot. You have shifted the way I buy clothes and accessories (in a good way). I would like your channel to stick with the quality over trend theme.
I have two pairs of carlos santos shoes and i think they are the best value in gyw shoes. just remember to size down on derbys boots and monks great shoes!'
I have a pair of their Chelsea boots and wingtip boots. Both are amazing and I get wows from my Chelsea's. There's a bit of a break in with the wingtip boots. But after about 5 wears, they feel great.
Great brand, great quality. With this brand I entered the world of Goodyear Welded shoes. Price is lower than Carmina. Especially on Herring shoes winter or summer sales, you can buy last size pair for $200. CS offers awesome hand-made patina pairs, though you won't find museum calf or cordovan among their models. Loafers showed by Kavalier have lining, so I'm in doubts whether they are suitable for summer. CS doesn't provide unlined loafer models. Compared to other brands like Meermin or Carmina they have quite limited number of models which are no doubts cool. Sneakers shown in review are rather for cold autumn, I own a pair. Compared to Wolverine 1000 Mile sneaker CS's rubber sole erases faster (wolverines have Vibram sole). Never use Renomat it destroys patina! Renovator is ok.
I think you are overthinking the lined or unlined loafers, unless you live in a very hot state. I prefer the way lined shoes keep their shape. However it’s up to the retailer to make the shoes, so I could for example request them unlined. Everything has its merit though and personal preference! Tlb and Carmina are excellent brands for this as well! The sneakers are more versatile in these colors, but customizable in 18 more through the patina service by the way! Thank you for your feedback Pavel!
@@MisiuAcademy thanks Kostas! Still waiting for CS's Dainite sole suede chukka 7991 restock on thenobleshoe. By the way would be cool if that model sizing started from size 5 UK (mine is 5.5 for perfect fitting).
@@pnetesa the restock actually came today but unfortunately not in such small sizes. I have to be very careful with my stock! However the normal ones with a city sole are always available! I also have a wingtip in UK 5 that I can give you for a great price! If you ever want a model in the shop in a small size, just reach out to me by mail and I can include you in the next restock too!
I like both, honestly. If you get enough stuff for a yearly round-up like the performance dress shirt, that would be cool, but if you do round-ups to piggyback off your previous ones, that's cool as well.
They have two lines. The $400 price you mentioned is the handgrade line, which have some upgraded features (beveled waist, closed channel stitching, etc.). The regular line is around the $300 figure and I think what your loafers are. Haven't handled the main line but those loafers look nice! Also Kostas at Noble Shoe is the man.
Not to be confused with Carlos Santana. (The musician also has a line of goodyear welted shoes available for relatively cheap, but they're probably not the best values).
I've bought two pairs of Carlos Santos from Kostas. Guy is a legend and his service is excellent. He's the only one the place and service is awesome. One thing John missed though: CS has two lines for their dress shoes, a regular and the handgrade line. I own one pair from each. The handgrade has a closed channel sole and fantastic sole finishing and I feel the leather is a little nicer. They retail around $400. The regular line has an open channel sole and leather (for me at least) felt a little stiffer, but not like breaking in a pair of red wing boots and retails $250 to $300 depending on the style and currency. The regular line has an amazing patina service as well where you pick your patina and shoe style. I got oxfords in wine shadow and they're probably one of my best looking shoes. Everything ships via DHL, so even being in the US, I got my stuff in 2 days shipping from Sweden. Highly recommend Kostas. 🙂
I think a review of the Wolf and Shepherd Crossover Longwing would be great. Those shoes/sneakers (I do not know how to call them haha) look pretty interesting. Your content is as always awesome. Your reviews have been really helpful.
I really like your reviews and comparisons, keep it up. From your experience, how do you compare the Carlos Santos sneaker to the Crown Northampton ? Am really looking forward to hear your opinion ?
Hello if you don’t mind me asking what color are the penny loader I was trying to buy the same based on your review but I like the color of the loafer you reviewed in this video
I like both kinds of videos. Nice to get an in-depth review of an individual product. and the round-up videos are perfect as an efficient buying guide. love all your work. the roundups are what make your channel better than the rest - but that doesn't need to be every video. that's a lot of time and money for just one video. happy to see some smaller ones.
Can you still wear leather loafers when it's hot outside with lightweight breathable dress socks? If you're not really into no show socks anymore would appreciate anyones input on this. Appreciate the content! Also saves some money from buying a suede pair but maybe someday.
@@HeathyRoidz I respectfully disagree I believe they can also look good with dress socks especially for semi formal and formal events when you want to switch it up from no shows also sockless is difficult since my feet tend to sweat at times. I can try sockless but idk my loafers are regular leather not woven so not sure it would be comfortable.
@@HeathyRoidz By the way don't mean to sound mean. I was just stating an opinion I could try going barefoot in my loafers as well since I'm a little tired of no show socks. But like I said I just worry about blisters or bruising on the ankle also if my feet start sweating inside. I've been getting in better shape so overall been trying to improve my style appreciate your feedback.
@@Manuel421 yeah that’s fine, to each their, I’ve always been told that loafers shouldn’t be worn with socks that show, or even dress socks, so it’s something that I don’t appreciate seeing that much, and I personally like wearing calf leather shoes with no socks, I didn’t have any blisters as of yet, Have fun with your style! Make it your own!
@@HeathyRoidz I'll definitely test it out you have me convinced that I wouldn't get blisters but I guess I'll just have to experiment. Can regular leather be breathable or does it have to be woven? My loafers are regular leather not Woven which tend to be more breathable as I read. However I think for situations like church Dress socks would be considered appropriate you can disagree if you want though no worries I respect others perspectives. I'm a man who use to wear t shirts and shorts or t shirts and jeans etc.. so definitely a great experience to step up the style. I'm not into Boat shoes or sneakers anymore really so I can probably survive on just 5 pairs of shoes. With Oxfords though not sure if you should be barefoot in them again I guess everyone has had their own tests with the shoes.
I would have never thought I would be making shoes, let alone feature in one of the channels I admire! Thank you so much Jon (and Steve!) for this! You both are amazing people.
I like the individual videos a bit better than the roundups. Especially if you’re including things in the roundups that you don’t have or are just showing the webpage for some of your recommendations.
1:36 - Paul Evans shouldn't even be in the conversation. They take really beautiful pictures of over priced blake stitched cheap shoes
Any day where the Kavalier refers to me as one of the "gents" is a good day.
Agreed!
Looks great. Kostas is a great guy and Carlos Santos makes incredible shoes for the price.
Hands down prefer more individual review videos! Keep me coming!
I own a pair of Carlos Santos monk straps in a nice mid brown with a matching belt and I agree that the color and quality is fantastic. Sadly I bought the belt a while back and I have since put on 15ish pounds and no longer can wear the belt.
Great loafers and sneakers! Kostas is a great guy. Hoping to work with him one day too. You know, when I'm big time like you on RUclips!
I prefer the individual videos when it comes to shoes and suits. When it comes to more ancillary items like dress shirts, polos, tees, shorts etc I prefer occasional round-up videos. Thanks again.
This is the way.
Don't like the stark white soles on the sneaks. For the navy, black soles would bring out the clour of the navy uppers, and for the brown (which are beautiful) taupe would be less obtrusive.
Why are you scared to say what other brand that falls 2nd to carlos sneaker, ? That info can help consumers to watch for difference.. so if you don't say other brand I guess they paid you for a good review and now you can take it back.
Why are you scare to mention what was the other brand that was dull ?
It's important for us viewers to know just in case we want to buy the best out there. If your afraid because the other company paid you to say good things then shame shame because you would be giving consumers bad info...so yes wish you would've mentioned others that you compare the santos carlos to..
Can you mention the precise color? As I’m planning to order them.
Please help me choose a color between the two sneakers,I want one which will be more visitale,will be ordering at norble in Sweden
I'm always a sucker for a good hand painted patina and those loafers are absolutely gorgeous.
As to your concerns at the end I like roundups and individual reviews, but I did just watch a good roundup on all the Johnnie Walker labels and found it the most helpful, so maybe that would be a good idea!
Make sure to check out the other 2-3 loafers in the shop!
Your round up videos make you stand out in the YT Men Lifestyle world for sure and you need to keep that! But I do like your individual deep dive into more niche brands. I like knowing the history and how they operate, where they source their materials, etc. You have put me on to so many brands over the years and I like your focus on quality which I value a lot. You have shifted the way I buy clothes and accessories (in a good way). I would like your channel to stick with the quality over trend theme.
I have two pairs of carlos santos shoes and i think they are the best value in gyw shoes. just remember to size down on derbys boots and monks great shoes!'
I have a pair of their Chelsea boots and wingtip boots. Both are amazing and I get wows from my Chelsea's. There's a bit of a break in with the wingtip boots. But after about 5 wears, they feel great.
Where can I buy carlos sneakers ,I'm in nyc ?
Great brand, great quality. With this brand I entered the world of Goodyear Welded shoes. Price is lower than Carmina. Especially on Herring shoes winter or summer sales, you can buy last size pair for $200. CS offers awesome hand-made patina pairs, though you won't find museum calf or cordovan among their models. Loafers showed by Kavalier have lining, so I'm in doubts whether they are suitable for summer. CS doesn't provide unlined loafer models. Compared to other brands like Meermin or Carmina they have quite limited number of models which are no doubts cool. Sneakers shown in review are rather for cold autumn, I own a pair. Compared to Wolverine 1000 Mile sneaker CS's rubber sole erases faster (wolverines have Vibram sole). Never use Renomat it destroys patina! Renovator is ok.
I think you are overthinking the lined or unlined loafers, unless you live in a very hot state. I prefer the way lined shoes keep their shape. However it’s up to the retailer to make the shoes, so I could for example request them unlined. Everything has its merit though and personal preference! Tlb and Carmina are excellent brands for this as well!
The sneakers are more versatile in these colors, but customizable in 18 more through the patina service by the way!
Thank you for your feedback Pavel!
@@MisiuAcademy thanks Kostas! Still waiting for CS's Dainite sole suede chukka 7991 restock on thenobleshoe. By the way would be cool if that model sizing started from size 5 UK (mine is 5.5 for perfect fitting).
@@pnetesa the restock actually came today but unfortunately not in such small sizes. I have to be very careful with my stock! However the normal ones with a city sole are always available! I also have a wingtip in UK 5 that I can give you for a great price!
If you ever want a model in the shop in a small size, just reach out to me by mail and I can include you in the next restock too!
I like both, honestly. If you get enough stuff for a yearly round-up like the performance dress shirt, that would be cool, but if you do round-ups to piggyback off your previous ones, that's cool as well.
Definitely my favorite brand of shoes if I was buying new. My only regret was buying most of my shoes in black when I should've went for brown.
Jon, how do these compare to something like a Koio or Crown Northampton?
Question? Do you think hand painted, burnished or patina. Are in the timeless category? I tried that minimal sneaker thing. It became boring.
Has to be very tasteful. I've come across plenty that look more trendy and that's what you'd want to avoid. All in the eye of the beholder though
Carlos Santos? That’s my cousin 🤷🏻♂️
That unboxing angle is giving me Vertigo
I feel like I'm on the edge of a cliff about ready to fall off my couch
Have you lookt at Magnanni
They have two lines. The $400 price you mentioned is the handgrade line, which have some upgraded features (beveled waist, closed channel stitching, etc.). The regular line is around the $300 figure and I think what your loafers are. Haven't handled the main line but those loafers look nice! Also Kostas at Noble Shoe is the man.
Thank you Thomas! There’s even a handcrafted line around the 599$ mark!
gonna check them out 🤔
Will be glad to help if you have questions John!
Not to be confused with Carlos Santana. (The musician also has a line of goodyear welted shoes available for relatively cheap, but they're probably not the best values).
that is actually very true! Autocorrect or google suggestion can be very interesting!
Curious to know your thoughts on the Italian DTC brand “Pini Parma”
I second this notion.
I have a pair of their cap toes with a beautiful patina and fiddle back waist. Fantastic quality for the price. And very comfortable.
thx for the video, just ordered the loafers. love at first sight i guess
Thank you Julian! Will ship them today!
I have 6 pairs of CS, still planning to buy a couple more in a month.
Will be more than glad to service you!
I've bought two pairs of Carlos Santos from Kostas. Guy is a legend and his service is excellent. He's the only one the place and service is awesome.
One thing John missed though: CS has two lines for their dress shoes, a regular and the handgrade line. I own one pair from each. The handgrade has a closed channel sole and fantastic sole finishing and I feel the leather is a little nicer. They retail around $400. The regular line has an open channel sole and leather (for me at least) felt a little stiffer, but not like breaking in a pair of red wing boots and retails $250 to $300 depending on the style and currency. The regular line has an amazing patina service as well where you pick your patina and shoe style. I got oxfords in wine shadow and they're probably one of my best looking shoes. Everything ships via DHL, so even being in the US, I got my stuff in 2 days shipping from Sweden. Highly recommend Kostas. 🙂
Jon, I trust your reviews but Paul Evans gets a lot of hate on the web. Are they a worthy competitor to Carmina and Carlos Santos?
I think a review of the Wolf and Shepherd Crossover Longwing would be great. Those shoes/sneakers (I do not know how to call them haha) look pretty interesting. Your content is as always awesome. Your reviews have been really helpful.
Do you own any Thursday Boot shoes? Are the carlos Santos the same size? I cant find a retailer here in the USA
I really like your reviews and comparisons, keep it up.
From your experience, how do you compare the Carlos Santos sneaker to the Crown Northampton ?
Am really looking forward to hear your opinion ?
Hello if you don’t mind me asking what color are the penny loader I was trying to buy the same based on your review but I like the color of the loafer you reviewed in this video
Would you be able to cover the greats/steve madden merger soon? Might be too early to say but I feel like it's bad news
Hi Jon I would like to know which u prefer koio or carlos santos sneakers. Ur honest opinion is always appreciated. Thks
I like both kinds of videos. Nice to get an in-depth review of an individual product. and the round-up videos are perfect as an efficient buying guide. love all your work. the roundups are what make your channel better than the rest - but that doesn't need to be every video. that's a lot of time and money for just one video. happy to see some smaller ones.
Hey Jon, I prefer to see you more often. It doesn’t need to be reviews. You have always brought quality contents.
tldr. roundups are the best. but individual videos are cool too. do both. we like it all.
Do more videos. More videos made = more videos I watch = more ad $ for you; everyone wins!
Finally a review!
This brand is amazing!
Glad you like my shoes!!
I love my Carlos Santos shoes. I have 2 pairs. They do tend to run large.
Just love your work sir
Much love from india ❤❤
Good review. I enjoy this format. Well done.
Nice video, again
I like his haircut.
Great Review do they have wide width?
Thanks for the video!
Hey Jon, how do the Carlos Santos sneakers compare to the Koio sneakers? Which do you prefer?
That’s the million dollar question 🤔
Those penny loafers are so sexy.
One other piece of feedback regarding shoe brands - please consider doing a review of some of the Archibald London shoes. Thanks.
Have one in the works!
omg l love the shoe
Excellent
CS got a lot more love when they were ~$100 cheaper... oh well.
I don't recall any day where Carlos Santos shoes on the Goodyear Welted Line were 189.99$
:)
I love the loafers!
Quick question, any advice on how to wear white boots?
Why did u buy white boots?
@@HeathyRoidz a friend is selling me a pair, but still not sure.
I appreciate these videos man.
I appreciate you!
Can you still wear leather loafers when it's hot outside with lightweight breathable dress socks? If you're not really into no show socks anymore would appreciate anyones input on this. Appreciate the content! Also saves some money from buying a suede pair but maybe someday.
I believe loafers should only be worn sockless or with no show socks
@@HeathyRoidz I respectfully disagree I believe they can also look good with dress socks especially for semi formal and formal events when you want to switch it up from no shows also sockless is difficult since my feet tend to sweat at times. I can try sockless but idk my loafers are regular leather not woven so not sure it would be comfortable.
@@HeathyRoidz By the way don't mean to sound mean. I was just stating an opinion I could try going barefoot in my loafers as well since I'm a little tired of no show socks. But like I said I just worry about blisters or bruising on the ankle also if my feet start sweating inside. I've been getting in better shape so overall been trying to improve my style appreciate your feedback.
@@Manuel421 yeah that’s fine, to each their, I’ve always been told that loafers shouldn’t be worn with socks that show, or even dress socks, so it’s something that I don’t appreciate seeing that much, and I personally like wearing calf leather shoes with no socks, I didn’t have any blisters as of yet, Have fun with your style! Make it your own!
@@HeathyRoidz I'll definitely test it out you have me convinced that I wouldn't get blisters but I guess I'll just have to experiment. Can regular leather be breathable or does it have to be woven? My loafers are regular leather not Woven which tend to be more breathable as I read. However I think for situations like church Dress socks would be considered appropriate you can disagree if you want though no worries I respect others perspectives. I'm a man who use to wear t shirts and shorts or t shirts and jeans etc.. so definitely a great experience to step up the style. I'm not into Boat shoes or sneakers anymore really so I can probably survive on just 5 pairs of shoes. With Oxfords though not sure if you should be barefoot in them again I guess everyone has had their own tests with the shoes.
is everything on this channel a sponsored ad?