@@iosebdzamukashvili5360 Not all her jumps. Rika has underrotated 3As as well. Besides, saying THEY "underrotate" is uncorrect. They try their best on a difficult jump that's all. If their jump is underrotated they will get deductions, like in any sport. Besides, just a reminder that a jump landed between the quarter and the full rotation is considered valid.
Alena has more difficult entrance and her jumps look more grand. However, in combo there is almost always slight under rotation. Rika’s jumps has more spinning speed but look tenser to me. Nevertheless, let’s appreciate both ladies. They have put enormous effort into their performances.
Rika seems to use slightly more prerotation, which helps to gain that advantage on landing. Can't say whose jump is better itself, but Alena's speed and entry is unmatched.
Aliona's entry is extremely difficult. She does not have that 'buffer' you see in many other skaters... Both Rika and her were consistent skaters in 2019!
their jumps is like comparing midori ito’s to mao asada’s, alena’s 3As are more explosive and powerful with a ton of height, rika’s are more tightly rotated and closer to the ground. i personally like alena’s more, i also feel that rika tends to pre rotate a bit while alena completes her rotations in the air
Rika is a good skater, but I really like Aliona so much more. The air position is crazy and the hight is just amazing!😍 I whant her 3A beck🥺❤ (yes I stan her👑)
I agree, she is amazing but her 3a in combination is under rotated , anyways, I love her entrance, it is very difficult but she should fix a few problems and maybe rotate faster, it would help her get a full rotation
@@СВЕТЛАНАКоротких-ы8я прыгает Алёна высоко,пролётно все прыжки которые и прыгала...вот только 3А ещё не востановила...но как пишет история...у всех фигуристов к сожалению есть проблемы в 17 лет...
Aliona actually has the better axel technique. Rika starts the rotation into the jump ala Tara Lipinski and doesnt step up into the jump. Unlike Kostornaia who has a true step up, You can tell by the sepration of the knees at the step up. If you watch how Tonya Harding and Midori Ito did their triple axels you will see the same step up.
Her Triple axels are under rotated.. She finishes the twist on the ice. Giving a under rotated jump nearly 3 points in Grade of execution is laughable.
Rika for sure. Her triple axel is much less prone to under-rotation and she is able to pull off a triple axel somewhere near the second half of the programme. Also, she is able to do a rotated 3-3 axel combo, which is pretty amazing. Lastly, she has been doing it for many seasons, while Alena seems to lose it this season. The only think Rika is lacking is confidence and consistency. It seems so easy and effortless to her in open practice.
Kostornaia 3A used to be quite more beautiful than Rika's. More beautiful and elegant legs extension. Such a pity that her new programs are not as beautiful and complex.
@@qiqisongs Not necessarily larger as well according to i-stats. But i would actually argue that Alena has more flow in and out of the jump. They both have different problems on airborne position thought, rika sometimes have tilted axis while alena has loose leg-cross.
@@qiqisongs And that scratchy landing is because of ur. But when fully rotated, she has a bit more flow (exit speed to be exact) And according to i-stat, they have similar height
Kihira's jumps are more correct, classic, like in a textbook. Every movement and position is on time. Aliona's technique is different: slower at the beginning and faster at the end. Aliona also has an emphasis on jumping - she jumps higher to catch up, her rotation speed is not as high as Kihira's. Of course, Aliona's technique is worse, but her jumps look more spectacular, unusual.
This is an "I had Eteri as a coach" problem. Every single skater under Eteri has the same under-rotation and entry mistakes that forces them to muscle through the jump and then put her arms up in an attempt to make the jump look higher and more grandiose than it actually is.
what are you talking about? Kihira's axel is not textbook, she does not have a "step up" for the axel jump, it still counts as an axel but there's a clear difference in how they approach the jump
Alenas is great. But Midori ito tops any male or female skater till now.... Her technique on take off is 10 times more explosive and she still skates till now. Figures helped reduce injuries 100 %
I found some mistakes when I was looking at the video. That is a Rika used song. Autumn Classic 2019 FS❌ Autumn Classic 2019 SP⭕️ NHK Trophy 2019 SP❌ NHK Trophy 2019 FS⭕️ but both look so beautiful and excellent.
I love both these girls' triple axels... Kostornaia's is higher but I think Kihira's is better because she: 1. jumps more straight through than Kostornaia therefore carries a higher percentage of the entry speed on the landing which is better for combinations. 2. The jump entrance, setup and pattern is more standard and fluid as opposed to Kostornaia's elaborate pattern that takes a lot of time in a warm up to execute and wastes a lot of time especially if somebody gets in her way. This makes for less stress mentally and physically in competition. Think of how Hanyu can do the triple Axel as a warm up jump off the counter turn(fluid timing that takes very little space patteen-wise/effort to accomplish)....So under this line of reasoning, Kostornaia's pattern makes it look like this jump is a bigger deal in her mind than for Kihira and is more stressful mentally and physically... 3. Kihira has done many triple Axel-triple toe combinations in competition and Kostornaia has done none to my knowledge... Kihira's jump technique is far superior to all of the Russian girls on every jump. Even though she may not get as high or seem as powerful, her jumps are of a much higher quality in terms of pattern, technique, timing, trajectory and having the correct amount of textbook pre rotation. The Russian girls go 3/4 revolutions on toe loop and Salchow takeoff vs Kihira getting up before or at 1/2 revolution on those jumps. The Russian girls do full blade 3/4 or more pre rotation on flip and Lutz. Not only do they do this but the Russian girls do not even do a Lutz because even if their left foot may be on some shallow outside edge as it skids through and off the ice for the takeoff, their body is way to the right and inside the circle "in a hurry to get the rotation" using none of the potential active edge power that is possible with the Lutz (Tuktamysheva is the exception on the Lutz for the Russian girls as hers is technically flawless and phenomenal) Kihira has great, pure, clean Lutz technique with fantastic active edge... I think Rika can beat all these Russian girls this year if she gets great programs that highlight her feminine beauty and her incredible blend of pure technique and consistency. She needs two Triple Axels, one in combo with triple toe, one by itself, a quad Salchow and the rest of the triples like she does with more speed and power than previous years.... Trusova is getting taller and taller is not working on her artistry enough and is trying to do more that she can do to be consistent and her triple Axel has terrible technique. Unless Plushenko can convince her to do less and be artistic so she can be consistent, she will be their or 4th at best this year. Kostornaia needs to get her triple Axel back and get her jumps like they were last year her Lutz is much worse and everything is jumping around and landing too far into the circle. She has filled out a bit but looks to be down on power. Power to weight has dropped for Kostornaia so far this year... Scherbakova is only getting taller and taller with higher polar moment of inertia. I think we will see more and more if the Lipnitskaya effect for her as time goes on. By next year, she will not even be a factor if she keeps growing because there is only so much somebody can starve themselves to maintain low polar moment of inertia to make up for technique that does not use the power afforded to people who learn the jumps with the proper technique, pattern, active edge timing and proper trajectory. It is a shame because she is a beautiful girl who wants to interpret and skate beautifully but she has been taught short term technique at the expense of her career more than any of the other girls... I think Rika has the chance to win it all this year and be the favorite going into the Olympics. One more year of the a Russian girls in the following season will give Kihira an even greater advantage for the Olympic season since she has already finished growing and has only to tweak her quad Salchow and toe loop jumps to be consistent on those as well. If Rika does 2 quads and 2 triple Axels with great programs and interpretation, it's game over for the Russian girls IMO...
I agree with you so much! Rika’s jump technique deserves more recognition. Her Lutz is so satisfying to watch. I hope Plush can convince Sasha doing less jumps... But I think he won’t insist because he knows Sasha left Eteri because of that. Last competition is a big tough lesson for her though. Also I think she realised the importance of artisy after moving to Plush.
@@ilyh1688 I agree with you. But I do think that one of the more defining qualities of a great coach is to be able to see the big picture end game and be able to convince the student why it would be in their best interest to adopt the correct/proper mode of thinking to have the best chance to reach the ultimate potential of the skater... Plushenko is new to the whole top level coaching. Sure he knows training and technique but the mastery of student's mindset is not something every newer level coach possesses. Plushenko did it, still knows how to do it if he were skating, but to translate that knowledge to someone as stubborn and bad-ass as he is(bit who may be motivated Inna slightly different manner) is a delicate matter reserved by the professionals. He needs to dig deep and figure out Trusova's psyche and transform her thinking so she can succeed.
Kihira is complete skater with unique technique. She has good jumps, spins and ice coverage. The only problem with her is that she has limited height for quads. It's problem, because Russian girls are doing multiple quads in single program and judges inflate their components, close eyes to full blade or underrotated jumps....
@@jamoliddinakhmedov6949 I agree with you, but I think the Russian girls' time is running out in terms of growth and the new stock will not have the overall level of maturity and jump quality. I have recently come to this conclusion after more closely examining the Russian girls' technique especially for the 3/4 revolutions pre-rotation on the triple/quad toe and watching Kihira again recently. I kind of stopped watching her because the Russian girls came on strong and seemed to be more explosive and exciting. I think the Russian girls are trained to be super strong and explosive in their off ice jumping to such a degree that they don't really "Need" proper technique to do or be consistent on the jumps as long as they are super skinny with little girl bodies. By the time this short term strategy plays out, it is time for the next little girls to take their place.... all the while Kihira keeps getting more powerful, more refined, more consistent with now quads and the triple Axels.
Alena's 3A combo looks under-roated. after landing the iced always scattered. Kihira's 3A is not high but her rotation is so fast which makes her landing very clear. However, I like both skaters.
@@Plaspos You have a mistaken idea. Rika was born on 21st September 2002. And Alena was born on 24th August 2003. So Rika was born one year earlier than Alena. Mao and Tuktamysheva are how skaters should be. They're great fighters.
코스톨은 비거리랑 점프력이 좋아서 여유있게 도는 느낌, 키히라는 악착같이 빠르게 도는 느낌? 근데 회전수 자체는 키히라가 더 꽉채움. 또 3A+2T에서 2T 콤비 비거리는 다른선수들은 거의 제자리점프인데 키히라는 비거리가 좀 있네. 그리고 3A+3T는 진짜 2022 올림픽때 꼭 보고싶다 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
Aliona has a much harder entrance to her 3A than Rikas. Also Alionas is much more easier done. Looks like a double she does it with such grace and beauty.
Though she has a harder entrance she has quite a limited entrance. Even in warm up and practice I have never seen her not do the full entrance, that means she is less versatile. You also get points for unexpected entrance, not necessarily a hard one. Meaning that she should receive no entrance GOE for the second axel she performs with the same entrance. You could also lose transition points given it doesn't show versatility. That's not gonna happen of course, but needs to be taken into account.
@@agronom_son_of_agroprom for one, japan had a better covid response than russia. And rika was able to get more ice time. For two, alyona only put it in her program last year while rika had it since juniors, so shes probably more sure about it, while alyona probably wants to not take too many risks
@@lenap319 Actually, during most time of 2020, Rika stayed in Switzerland... not in Japan... She went back to Japan just few days before Japanese Nationals.
Rika's are fully rotated. Alena's 3A+2T is under rotated and her 3A is q But she has difficult entry, better heightand distance. I think Alena's 2.97 GOE for underotated 3A combo is ridiculous. Anna should have won Euro 2020
look-wise - Kostornaya, techically - too :) Kihira did heavy pre-rotaions although, there is no rule to penalize stakers tor it, so, there are at par :)
@@ШлябинаТатьяна вы можете как угодно по кадрам рассматриватькто где начинает крутится и где ребро, а гдебедро, но спорить бесполезно-Косторная при такой же сложности намного красивее и эффектнее, элегантнее и пластичнее, и в итоге интереснее, совершенства в мире нет, но Косторная шикарнее
Сравнили божий дар и яичницу! Доморощенный 3А Косторной и Кихиры. Никогда Косторная не делала идеально правильно 3А , разве один единственный раз на Гран При, где она блеснула. Ну да, а кроме Касторки кто еще бы мог соперничать с Кихирой? А сейчас совсем никто. (спустя 4 месяца) А сейчас очень даже может кто
Юлия, много желчи! Кихира 7-ая в мире, ее 3А в этом году увидел мир валяющемся на льду! И не только 3А, но все остальное не вызывает опасений за ее конкурентноспособность с нашими девочками. Алена восстановит 3А и будет на пьедестале выше Кихиры в следующем сезоне! У Алены все получится! Мы любим ее красивое катание!
![Rare Documentary on the Bolshoi Ballet Academy [1967]](/img/1.gif)
Which skaters would you like to see next?
Щербакову и Алису лью их лутцы
@@wookongyisan me too
I want to see the latest videos of Hanyu training...
@@paolocastellano2771 I prepared a Hanyu video, but unfortunately they don't share his training videos. I'd love to see it too though...
Why don’t you do the same videos with skaters of the past ? I’m sure it will be a success ... I’d like to see Kostner, Asada and Kim ... please !!
Aliona's entrance to 3A is art.
))) yeah
Her exit is art too....
Yet she underrotates.
@@iosebdzamukashvili5360 Not all her jumps. Rika has underrotated 3As as well. Besides, saying THEY "underrotate" is uncorrect. They try their best on a difficult jump that's all. If their jump is underrotated they will get deductions, like in any sport. Besides, just a reminder that a jump landed between the quarter and the full rotation is considered valid.
@@Nunelii Nope. Rika's Axel clean. Open your eyes
Alena has more difficult entrance and her jumps look more grand. However, in combo there is almost always slight under rotation. Rika’s jumps has more spinning speed but look tenser to me. Nevertheless, let’s appreciate both ladies. They have put enormous effort into their performances.
Rika seems to use slightly more prerotation, which helps to gain that advantage on landing. Can't say whose jump is better itself, but Alena's speed and entry is unmatched.
Aliona's entry is extremely difficult. She does not have that 'buffer' you see in many other skaters... Both Rika and her were consistent skaters in 2019!
Agree
Aliona’s entry really takes an enormous amount of confidence, it’s crazy.
I love how they both have such different techniques but they're both lovely and legit and not cheated.
Rika's 3As are more rotated than Aliona's , and Aliona's has greater height and distance than Rika's.
Risks has more distance and higher if you see on the ice-scope in the reviews
Alena's entry is INSANE. I would give it a 3.0 GOE.
their jumps is like comparing midori ito’s to mao asada’s, alena’s 3As are more explosive and powerful with a ton of height, rika’s are more tightly rotated and closer to the ground. i personally like alena’s more, i also feel that rika tends to pre rotate a bit while alena completes her rotations in the air
正確さは紀平梨花
高さと美しさはアリョーナ・コストルナヤ
2人とも大好きなのでこういう動画はありがたい
Aliona jumps higher and more beautiful🔥🔥🔥😍
Alena tested postive for Covid-19! Hope she gets well soon ❤
1:37 Rika's landing flow is just perfection
Аксель Косторной произведение искусства. Вау эффект
🤝👏👌
Alena is the only skater from the 3As of Eteri camp whose style I love ♥️
Me too.
どちらのアクセルもそれぞれ良いところがあって好きです！コストルナヤさんのアクセルは男子でも難しい入り方をしてるのでそこは毎度見ててすごいと思ってます！
あと今期はコストルナヤさんは今のところアクセルを封印してるので悲しいです😭早く見たい！
Rika is a good skater, but I really like Aliona so much more. The air position is crazy and the hight is just amazing!😍 I whant her 3A beck🥺❤ (yes I stan her👑)
Yazz
Actually according to i stats their height of jump are more or less the same
You are right. She is the remaining Queen who needs her jumps back!
I agree, she is amazing but her 3a in combination is under rotated , anyways, I love her entrance, it is very difficult but she should fix a few problems and maybe rotate faster, it would help her get a full rotation
Rika Kihira❤️
🤦🏽♀️😅
Aliona Kostornia ❤
Кто бы сомневался🙄
@@ashleyvita5092 понятия не имею...кто вообще может сомневаться !?
Аленка красотка,но все видео ещё у Тутберидзе, сейчас она так к сожалению не прыгает.Дай бог,чтоб восстановила всё
@@СВЕТЛАНАКоротких-ы8я прыгает Алёна высоко,пролётно все прыжки которые и прыгала...вот только 3А ещё не востановила...но как пишет история...у всех фигуристов к сожалению есть проблемы в 17 лет...
@@user-tamila-toma вот именно прыгает пролетно,вот и пролетела мимо
Aliona actually has the better axel technique. Rika starts the rotation into the jump ala Tara Lipinski and doesnt step up into the jump. Unlike Kostornaia who has a true step up, You can tell by the sepration of the knees at the step up. If you watch how Tonya Harding and Midori Ito did their triple axels you will see the same step up.
Aliona❤❤❤❤ What a grace and lightness!
Aliona's 3A is the best.
Her Triple axels are under rotated.. She finishes the twist on the ice. Giving a under rotated jump nearly 3 points in Grade of execution is laughable.
@@davidreign7724 I agree, but I mean we see skaters like her being given the points no matter what
@@sebastianenjcb193 that’s just one of the issues with the Judging System
Rika for sure. Her triple axel is much less prone to under-rotation and she is able to pull off a triple axel somewhere near the second half of the programme. Also, she is able to do a rotated 3-3 axel combo, which is pretty amazing. Lastly, she has been doing it for many seasons, while Alena seems to lose it this season. The only think Rika is lacking is confidence and consistency. It seems so easy and effortless to her in open practice.
Kostornaia 3A used to be quite more beautiful than Rika's. More beautiful and elegant legs extension. Such a pity that her new programs are not as beautiful and complex.
Not more beautiful but larger. Rika’s 3A is definitely much more beautiful and smooth
@@qiqisongs well, beauty is subjective. They might just prefer Aliona over Rika
@@qiqisongs Not necessarily larger as well according to i-stats. But i would actually argue that Alena has more flow in and out of the jump. They both have different problems on airborne position thought, rika sometimes have tilted axis while alena has loose leg-cross.
@@liitbro Rika has more flow. Alena has larger jump but more scratchy landing most of the time
@@qiqisongs And that scratchy landing is because of ur. But when fully rotated, she has a bit more flow (exit speed to be exact) And according to i-stat, they have similar height
Hoping for Aliona's fast recovery.
Rikas 3A is cleaner and fully rotated....even in combination. Alena has a slight under rotation but a more difficult entry. I like both.
and also pre rotated
コストルナヤの3Ａの美しやたるや…！
紀平の3Ａは年齢上がってもずっと飛べそうな安心感がある。2ndの正確さや安定感がそれを物語っているように思う。それって女子的にはとても凄い事。
いやー、でも本当にコストルナヤの3Ａ美しいわぁ〜
何回も見てて気づいたんだけど、跳び出す時の右足の使い方が二人の間で大きく違うと思う。コストルナヤ選手は跳び上がると同時に右足を大きく振り上げてる。逆に紀平選手は右足をあまり振り上げてない。前者は上手く決まればダイナミックな高さのある3Aになるけど、すごく労力がかかるし難しそう。後者は見た目のインパクトは劣るけどすごく効率的であまり回転不足にはならなそう。素人の勝手な憶測ですけどね。もちろんどちらも本当に凄いと思います。✨私はコストルナヤ選手のダイナミックな3Aの方が好きですが、紀平選手の跳び方の方が軽やかで、長く跳び続けられるジャンプなのかなと思います。
こちもそう思います〜梨花のジャンプ方が軽い感じますね、男たちの3Aと似てるです
アレナの方は、もし未来の試合体調が悪いや力不足になる時、3Aが飛べないかと心配です
Алена лучшая!
Kihira's jumps are more correct, classic, like in a textbook. Every movement and position is on time. Aliona's technique is different: slower at the beginning and faster at the end. Aliona also has an emphasis on jumping - she jumps higher to catch up, her rotation speed is not as high as Kihira's. Of course, Aliona's technique is worse, but her jumps look more spectacular, unusual.
This is an "I had Eteri as a coach" problem. Every single skater under Eteri has the same under-rotation and entry mistakes that forces them to muscle through the jump and then put her arms up in an attempt to make the jump look higher and more grandiose than it actually is.
what are you talking about? Kihira's axel is not textbook, she does not have a "step up" for the axel jump, it still counts as an axel but there's a clear difference in how they approach the jump
Alenas is great. But Midori ito tops any male or female skater till now.... Her technique on take off is 10 times more explosive and she still skates till now. Figures helped reduce injuries 100 %
3A+2T distance
3A : Kihira < Aliona
+2T : Kihira > Aliona
The most beautiful 3A from Alena of course😍😊☺️
コストルナヤの3Aは綺麗すぎる
Аленка лучшая!!! Таких нет!!!
Однозначно лучше у Алены
Rika's axel is much longer and cleaner.
Alena the best!
Unfortunately, Alena 3A only lasted for one season...its not with her new program anymore
Rika did not even skate this season so...
@@nikitashaitan9984 She'll skate on Japan National this December.
Come on, guys.. The Future s by the Alena... Rika s previous.. 😊
I hope she will back it again
Actually, Alena has a triple axel but it's not consistent enough to put it in her programs.
RIKA KIHIRA
🤦🏽♀️😂
I found some mistakes when I was looking at the video.
That is a Rika used song.
Autumn Classic 2019 FS❌
Autumn Classic 2019 SP⭕️
NHK Trophy 2019 SP❌
NHK Trophy 2019 FS⭕️
but both look so beautiful and excellent.
I love both these girls' triple axels... Kostornaia's is higher but I think Kihira's is better because she:
1. jumps more straight through than Kostornaia therefore carries a higher percentage of the entry speed on the landing which is better for combinations.
2. The jump entrance, setup and pattern is more standard and fluid as opposed to Kostornaia's elaborate pattern that takes a lot of time in a warm up to execute and wastes a lot of time especially if somebody gets in her way. This makes for less stress mentally and physically in competition. Think of how Hanyu can do the triple Axel as a warm up jump off the counter turn(fluid timing that takes very little space patteen-wise/effort to accomplish)....So under this line of reasoning, Kostornaia's pattern makes it look like this jump is a bigger deal in her mind than for Kihira and is more stressful mentally and physically...
3. Kihira has done many triple Axel-triple toe combinations in competition and Kostornaia has done none to my knowledge...
Kihira's jump technique is far superior to all of the Russian girls on every jump. Even though she may not get as high or seem as powerful, her jumps are of a much higher quality in terms of pattern, technique, timing, trajectory and having the correct amount of textbook pre rotation. The Russian girls go 3/4 revolutions on toe loop and Salchow takeoff vs Kihira getting up before or at 1/2 revolution on those jumps. The Russian girls do full blade 3/4 or more pre rotation on flip and Lutz. Not only do they do this but the Russian girls do not even do a Lutz because even if their left foot may be on some shallow outside edge as it skids through and off the ice for the takeoff, their body is way to the right and inside the circle "in a hurry to get the rotation" using none of the potential active edge power that is possible with the Lutz (Tuktamysheva is the exception on the Lutz for the Russian girls as hers is technically flawless and phenomenal) Kihira has great, pure, clean Lutz technique with fantastic active edge... I think Rika can beat all these Russian girls this year if she gets great programs that highlight her feminine beauty and her incredible blend of pure technique and consistency. She needs two Triple Axels, one in combo with triple toe, one by itself, a quad Salchow and the rest of the triples like she does with more speed and power than previous years.... Trusova is getting taller and taller is not working on her artistry enough and is trying to do more that she can do to be consistent and her triple Axel has terrible technique. Unless Plushenko can convince her to do less and be artistic so she can be consistent, she will be their or 4th at best this year. Kostornaia needs to get her triple Axel back and get her jumps like they were last year her Lutz is much worse and everything is jumping around and landing too far into the circle. She has filled out a bit but looks to be down on power. Power to weight has dropped for Kostornaia so far this year... Scherbakova is only getting taller and taller with higher polar moment of inertia. I think we will see more and more if the Lipnitskaya effect for her as time goes on. By next year, she will not even be a factor if she keeps growing because there is only so much somebody can starve themselves to maintain low polar moment of inertia to make up for technique that does not use the power afforded to people who learn the jumps with the proper technique, pattern, active edge timing and proper trajectory. It is a shame because she is a beautiful girl who wants to interpret and skate beautifully but she has been taught short term technique at the expense of her career more than any of the other girls...
I think Rika has the chance to win it all this year and be the favorite going into the Olympics. One more year of the a Russian girls in the following season will give Kihira an even greater advantage for the Olympic season since she has already finished growing and has only to tweak her quad Salchow and toe loop jumps to be consistent on those as well. If Rika does 2 quads and 2 triple Axels with great programs and interpretation, it's game over for the Russian girls IMO...
I agree with you so much! Rika’s jump technique deserves more recognition. Her Lutz is so satisfying to watch. I hope Plush can convince Sasha doing less jumps... But I think he won’t insist because he knows Sasha left Eteri because of that. Last competition is a big tough lesson for her though. Also I think she realised the importance of artisy after moving to Plush.
I agree with you 👏
@@ilyh1688 I agree with you. But I do think that one of the more defining qualities of a great coach is to be able to see the big picture end game and be able to convince the student why it would be in their best interest to adopt the correct/proper mode of thinking to have the best chance to reach the ultimate potential of the skater... Plushenko is new to the whole top level coaching. Sure he knows training and technique but the mastery of student's mindset is not something every newer level coach possesses. Plushenko did it, still knows how to do it if he were skating, but to translate that knowledge to someone as stubborn and bad-ass as he is(bit who may be motivated Inna slightly different manner) is a delicate matter reserved by the professionals. He needs to dig deep and figure out Trusova's psyche and transform her thinking so she can succeed.
Kihira is complete skater with unique technique. She has good jumps, spins and ice coverage. The only problem with her is that she has limited height for quads. It's problem, because Russian girls are doing multiple quads in single program and judges inflate their components, close eyes to full blade or underrotated jumps....
@@jamoliddinakhmedov6949 I agree with you, but I think the Russian girls' time is running out in terms of growth and the new stock will not have the overall level of maturity and jump quality. I have recently come to this conclusion after more closely examining the Russian girls' technique especially for the 3/4 revolutions pre-rotation on the triple/quad toe and watching Kihira again recently. I kind of stopped watching her because the Russian girls came on strong and seemed to be more explosive and exciting. I think the Russian girls are trained to be super strong and explosive in their off ice jumping to such a degree that they don't really "Need" proper technique to do or be consistent on the jumps as long as they are super skinny with little girl bodies. By the time this short term strategy plays out, it is time for the next little girls to take their place.... all the while Kihira keeps getting more powerful, more refined, more consistent with now quads and the triple Axels.
Alena of course
Алена!!!
ALENA KOSTARNAIA 👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
Хорошая фигуристка Кихира, слов нет. И аксель у неё отличный. Но с Алёной и рядом не стоит.
@@GavapPavag Восстановит обязательно, никаких сомнений. Это вопрос только времени.
@@GavapPavag Алена будет снова на пьедестале!
Rika Kihira Queen of 3A, you really can’t ask for a more perfect 3A than hers in ladies.
alyona's is just beatiful
Rika is a good skater, but I prefer Alena's a lot better. I love how Alena jumps into it and then starts rotating
У Алены 3А лучший! Кихира не докручивает 3А в каскаде с тулупом, но GOE у Рики зашкаливает!
Видно невооруженным глазом, что Косторная лучше Кихиры.
У Алёнки воздушный аксель! Загляденье!😍
コストルナヤちゃんの助走部分好きだなぁ
Kostornaia has the superior 3A
Alena Kostornaia
Alyona's entrance into the jump is much more difficult than Rika's
Is Rika still active in the amateur skating scene? I love her 3A!
Rika 的轉速跟進入旋轉的時間比Alena快跟早，但是Alena的entrance比Rika難
Aleona is fire🔥
Alena's 3A combo looks under-roated. after landing the iced always scattered.
Kihira's 3A is not high but her rotation is so fast which makes her landing very clear.
However, I like both skaters.
Rika is older. That is a big disadvantage of jumps in figure skating. Great effort of her💕
Rika is less than a year older. Tuktamysheva and Asada are very impressive for keeping the triple axel past age 23
@@Plaspos You have a mistaken idea.
Rika was born on 21st September 2002. And Alena was born on 24th August 2003.
So Rika was born one year earlier than Alena.
Mao and Tuktamysheva are how skaters should be. They're great fighters.
Rika is best
Косторная вон как прыгала у Тутберидзе, аж с подскоком в конце!
Ну так. Я ей аксель ставил
코스톨은 비거리랑 점프력이 좋아서 여유있게 도는 느낌, 키히라는 악착같이 빠르게 도는 느낌? 근데 회전수 자체는 키히라가 더 꽉채움. 또 3A+2T에서 2T 콤비 비거리는 다른선수들은 거의 제자리점프인데 키히라는 비거리가 좀 있네. 그리고 3A+3T는 진짜 2022 올림픽때 꼭 보고싶다 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
Косторная легче прыгала.
И красивее
была да сплыла
Пока она наша первая фигуристка. Другие только на показательных да шоу.
@@metrom8961, не дождётесь.
Зина Занзибар Да ,была когда-то.Да и то благодаря Этери Тутберидзе.Я имею ввиду первой.
Aliona has a much harder entrance to her 3A than Rikas. Also Alionas is much more easier done. Looks like a double she does it with such grace and beauty.
Not as effortless as Rika’s. Just look at the landing of elena’s 3a. Her body was bent forward and landing scratchy
Rika's 3A is so much effortless than Aliona’s. Tha’s obvious.
Aliona’s jump looks more effortless, and she jumped higher.
Though she has a harder entrance she has quite a limited entrance. Even in warm up and practice I have never seen her not do the full entrance, that means she is less versatile. You also get points for unexpected entrance, not necessarily a hard one. Meaning that she should receive no entrance GOE for the second axel she performs with the same entrance. You could also lose transition points given it doesn't show versatility. That's not gonna happen of course, but needs to be taken into account.
I love both😍
Заход сложнее у Косторной.
Косторная круче.
Alena has lost her 3A.
Due to covid she was largely unable to get on ice training
@@lenap319 and why can Rica still jump 3A?
@@agronom_son_of_agroprom for one, japan had a better covid response than russia. And rika was able to get more ice time. For two, alyona only put it in her program last year while rika had it since juniors, so shes probably more sure about it, while alyona probably wants to not take too many risks
@@lenap319 Actually, during most time of 2020, Rika stayed in Switzerland... not in Japan...
She went back to Japan just few days before Japanese Nationals.
Also, Alena's body is growing... She needs more time to adapt her new body.
どっちも好き～。
Rika's are fully rotated. Alena's 3A+2T is under rotated and her 3A is q But she has difficult entry, better heightand distance. I think Alena's 2.97 GOE for underotated 3A combo is ridiculous. Anna should have won Euro 2020
Rika is the queen of 3 A after Mao!
Aliona is much better, stronger and higher
紀平さんがコストルナヤのような飛び方で3A跳んだら高さ幅がもっと出そう
Does Kihira prerotate more on these jumps in this video??
Pls correct me if I’m wrong.
I personally like Alena's more, she has greater speed and height, and a more difficult entrance. Rika's jumps always look quite "forced" to me
look-wise - Kostornaya, techically - too :) Kihira did heavy pre-rotaions although, there is no rule to penalize stakers tor it, so, there are at par :)
Rika did not pre-rotated on her 3A...
на акселях у Кихиры прироты по 3/4 оборота , вот как судят
net. eto lozh. ona prigaet iz rebra a u aleny da est prerotation.
@@iosebdzamukashvili5360 по кадрам посмотрите
@@ШлябинаТатьяна вы можете как угодно по кадрам рассматриватькто где начинает крутится и где ребро, а гдебедро, но спорить бесполезно-Косторная при такой же сложности намного красивее и эффектнее, элегантнее и пластичнее, и в итоге интереснее, совершенства в мире нет, но Косторная шикарнее
@@pilot60-287 🤝👏👌🌹
比べるな
どっちもすごい
以上
Сравнили божий дар и яичницу! Доморощенный 3А Косторной и Кихиры. Никогда Косторная не делала идеально правильно 3А , разве один единственный раз на Гран При, где она блеснула. Ну да, а кроме Касторки кто еще бы мог соперничать с Кихирой? А сейчас совсем никто.
(спустя 4 месяца) А сейчас очень даже может кто
? А что Кихира не доморощеная.
это правда, 3а косторной недокрученный(
Только тебя тут не хватало, эксперт с потными подмышками.
Жаль, но сезон у Рики не очень удачный... это к словам о соперничестве))
Юлия, много желчи! Кихира 7-ая в мире, ее 3А в этом году увидел мир валяющемся на льду! И не только 3А, но все остальное не вызывает опасений за ее конкурентноспособность с нашими девочками. Алена восстановит 3А и будет на пьедестале выше Кихиры в следующем сезоне! У Алены все получится! Мы любим ее красивое катание!
3A以前に顔面やスタイルで大敗してる紀平
失礼なコメント。恥知らず