The man is lying 100%. First, he is not a doctor Virginia Mutheu Nzomo, [PW 2], was at her house at Kibera sometimes in October, 2009 when Clement Munyao Katiku [A 4], a neighbour asked her for a loan of 1,000/=. As security Clement gave her a Nokia mobile model 1208 admitted in evidence as exhibit No. 1. Clement, however, did not commit when he would re-pay the loan. Two weeks later, her child fell sick. She [PW 2] approached Clement Munyao for the repayment of the loan in vain. As a stop gap measure she got a loan from Justus Mutinda Ndeko. [PW3] As security, she pledged the Nokia phone which Clement Munyao [A4] had pledged as security for a loan of shs. 1000/= .kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/90652/
@@nelsonmaingi1297 Am shocked, I have read every bit from the link, I have no words...How can someone fabricate such a story? His mental status should be checked
DW5, Clement Munyao Katiku, [A4], in his sworn statement, testified that he owns a bar christined Munyao Pub, at 42 Kibera Estate, and is also an employee of Keyatta National Hospital, in the capacity of a casual labourer. His personal number is 314316. That his bar-maid and some customers were arrested on 27th September, 2009. To bail them out the police required a sum of sh. 5000/-. He did not have enough money so he approached, inter-alia, Virginia [PW2] who loaned him a sum of sh. 1000/=. As consideration of the said loan he pledged his Nokia model 1200 to Virginia. On 30th October, 2009 he went to Kileleshwa to see his cousin, Christopher Munyao. He met Mark Makau Mathaa [DW8]. He asked Mark if he could take up a job at a canteen belonging to his boss at Kenyatta National Hospital. Mark declined and in turn called Andrew Muua Kimomo who accepted the offer. However, in order to be employed, at the canteen, Andrew Muua Kimomo [A5] had to get a health certificate at a cost of sh. 2400/=. Andrew had only sh. 1700/=. He loaned Andrew sh. 700/= to make a grand total of sh. 2400/=. In consideration of a loan of sh. 700/= Andrew pledged to him Nokia model 1200. However, when he came to court he was charged with the offence of theft of Nokia 6300. He denied the charge. DW6, Florence Nduki Mutiso, an employee of Kenyatta National Hospital since 1981 is the head of Human Resources. She maintains records of all employees. She categorically testified that the code for Kenyatta National Hospital starts with 52 or 53. She confirmed that the said hospital does not have personal number 314316. She denied that Clement Munyao Katiku [A4] was an employee of Kenyatta National Hospital at any given time. That personal number 314316 is fake. She further testified that casual workers were not given personal numbers hence Clement Munyao Katitu was an imposter. She totally disowned Clement Munyao Katiku [A4] and branded him a liar.
Heartbreaking and you can see through his heart how innocent he is. How can we help this accomplished doctor to get justice? Even if it means trending him on social media
@@nelsonmaingi1297 That is very true. After you do medicine you then do Masters in pathology and forensic medicine to become a consultant pathologist not a neurosurgeon. He's too smart a liar but the judge didn't fall to his lies.
@@josephkanyingi9710 The man is lying 100%. First, he is not a doctor Virginia Mutheu Nzomo, [PW 2], was at her house at Kibera sometimes in October, 2009 when Clement Munyao Katiku [A 4], a neighbour asked her for a loan of 1,000/=. As security Clement gave her a Nokia mobile model 1208 admitted in evidence as exhibit No. 1. Clement, however, did not commit when he would re-pay the loan. Two weeks later, her child fell sick. She [PW 2] approached Clement Munyao for the repayment of the loan in vain. As a stop gap measure she got a loan from Justus Mutinda Ndeko. [PW3] As security, she pledged the Nokia phone which Clement Munyao [A4] had pledged as security for a loan of shs. 1000/= .kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/90652/
DW5, Clement Munyao Katiku, [A4], in his sworn statement, testified that he owns a bar christined Munyao Pub, at 42 Kibera Estate, and is also an employee of Keyatta National Hospital, in the capacity of a casual labourer. His personal number is 314316. That his bar-maid and some customers were arrested on 27th September, 2009. To bail them out the police required a sum of sh. 5000/-. He did not have enough money so he approached, inter-alia, Virginia [PW2] who loaned him a sum of sh. 1000/=. As consideration of the said loan he pledged his Nokia model 1200 to Virginia. On 30th October, 2009 he went to Kileleshwa to see his cousin, Christopher Munyao. He met Mark Makau Mathaa [DW8]. He asked Mark if he could take up a job at a canteen belonging to his boss at Kenyatta National Hospital. Mark declined and in turn called Andrew Muua Kimomo who accepted the offer. However, in order to be employed, at the canteen, Andrew Muua Kimomo [A5] had to get a health certificate at a cost of sh. 2400/=. Andrew had only sh. 1700/=. He loaned Andrew sh. 700/= to make a grand total of sh. 2400/=. In consideration of a loan of sh. 700/= Andrew pledged to him Nokia model 1200. However, when he came to court he was charged with the offence of theft of Nokia 6300. He denied the charge. DW6, Florence Nduki Mutiso, an employee of Kenyatta National Hospital since 1981 is the head of Human Resources. She maintains records of all employees. She categorically testified that the code for Kenyatta National Hospital starts with 52 or 53. She confirmed that the said hospital does not have personal number 314316. She denied that Clement Munyao Katiku [A4] was an employee of Kenyatta National Hospital at any given time. That personal number 314316 is fake. She further testified that casual workers were not given personal numbers hence Clement Munyao Katitu was an imposter. She totally disowned Clement Munyao Katiku [A4] and branded him a liar.
Wooooiiii, ngai fafa. Why was the only one picked on? This doesn't need one to go to a law school, leave alone being a judge. God is the only unquestionable judge. I shed tears
This is why police force should have a special unit for high level investigation assignments. We need very bright students for forensic science to join police force just like in the US
I think police don't do due diligence because of our judicial system doesn't care of the case brought in there table and should dismiss some case for police to bring tangible evidence
This is why sometimes i understand when some of my family members and other kenyans abroad decide to stay abroad not to come back to their motherland when they hear such stories. It's so inhuman. Well educated man giving out to society with bright promising future turned into nightmare. God will reveal himself coz NO stone shall remain unturned. Starting from prosecutors to judiciary whome gave the true justice a deaf ear. they should remember no one shall overcome the true justice of the most high God. Sometimes is so shameful to be a kenyan.
@@rosminevents2055 he should be rotting in jail. First, he is not a doctor Virginia Mutheu Nzomo, [PW 2], was at her house at Kibera sometimes in October, 2009 when Clement Munyao Katiku [A 4], a neighbour asked her for a loan of 1,000/=. As security Clement gave her a Nokia mobile model 1208 admitted in evidence as exhibit No. 1. Clement, however, did not commit when he would re-pay the loan. Two weeks later, her child fell sick. She [PW 2] approached Clement Munyao for the repayment of the loan in vain. As a stop gap measure she got a loan from Justus Mutinda Ndeko. [PW3] As security, she pledged the Nokia phone which Clement Munyao [A4] had pledged as security for a loan of shs. 1000/= .kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/90652/
Learned where? That guy is not even qualified to teach any reasonable guy something, let's thing, just from his grammar you'd realise he is not among the less than 15 neurosurgeons we have in Kenya
DW5, Clement Munyao Katiku, [A4], in his sworn statement, testified that he owns a bar christined Munyao Pub, at 42 Kibera Estate, and is also an employee of Keyatta National Hospital, in the capacity of a casual labourer. His personal number is 314316. That his bar-maid and some customers were arrested on 27th September, 2009. To bail them out the police required a sum of sh. 5000/-. He did not have enough money so he approached, inter-alia, Virginia [PW2] who loaned him a sum of sh. 1000/=. As consideration of the said loan he pledged his Nokia model 1200 to Virginia. On 30th October, 2009 he went to Kileleshwa to see his cousin, Christopher Munyao. He met Mark Makau Mathaa [DW8]. He asked Mark if he could take up a job at a canteen belonging to his boss at Kenyatta National Hospital. Mark declined and in turn called Andrew Muua Kimomo who accepted the offer. However, in order to be employed, at the canteen, Andrew Muua Kimomo [A5] had to get a health certificate at a cost of sh. 2400/=. Andrew had only sh. 1700/=. He loaned Andrew sh. 700/= to make a grand total of sh. 2400/=. In consideration of a loan of sh. 700/= Andrew pledged to him Nokia model 1200. However, when he came to court he was charged with the offence of theft of Nokia 6300. He denied the charge. DW6, Florence Nduki Mutiso, an employee of Kenyatta National Hospital since 1981 is the head of Human Resources. She maintains records of all employees. She categorically testified that the code for Kenyatta National Hospital starts with 52 or 53. She confirmed that the said hospital does not have personal number 314316. She denied that Clement Munyao Katiku [A4] was an employee of Kenyatta National Hospital at any given time. That personal number 314316 is fake. She further testified that casual workers were not given personal numbers hence Clement Munyao Katitu was an imposter. She totally disowned Clement Munyao Katiku [A4] and branded him a liar.
@@Cryptoshifuu this is a case against a senior person in kenya how sure are we that the human resource department was asked to say this and tampered with the information why does this guy have legal papers showing of his career and credibility alot still doesn't add up with all this story
@@ivykimani8692 which senior person??? I don't know why you are lazy at reading information which is readily online rather than acting on emotions...CALM DOWN AND READ THE CASE AND ALL HIS APPEALS then tell us which that SENIOR person is. Mfarasa has mentioned Katiku's sworn statement to the court and the suspect fails to indicate that he is a neuro-surgeon but a causal laborer...Did you first hear his broken English when the video is beginning????
DW5, Clement Munyao Katiku, [A4], in his sworn statement, testified that he owns a bar christined Munyao Pub, at 42 Kibera Estate, and is also an employee of Keyatta National Hospital, in the capacity of a casual labourer. His personal number is 314316. That his bar-maid and some customers were arrested on 27th September, 2009. To bail them out the police required a sum of sh. 5000/-. He did not have enough money so he approached, inter-alia, Virginia [PW2] who loaned him a sum of sh. 1000/=. As consideration of the said loan he pledged his Nokia model 1200 to Virginia. On 30th October, 2009 he went to Kileleshwa to see his cousin, Christopher Munyao. He met Mark Makau Mathaa [DW8]. He asked Mark if he could take up a job at a canteen belonging to his boss at Kenyatta National Hospital. Mark declined and in turn called Andrew Muua Kimomo who accepted the offer. However, in order to be employed, at the canteen, Andrew Muua Kimomo [A5] had to get a health certificate at a cost of sh. 2400/=. Andrew had only sh. 1700/=. He loaned Andrew sh. 700/= to make a grand total of sh. 2400/=. In consideration of a loan of sh. 700/= Andrew pledged to him Nokia model 1200. However, when he came to court he was charged with the offence of theft of Nokia 6300. He denied the charge. DW6, Florence Nduki Mutiso, an employee of Kenyatta National Hospital since 1981 is the head of Human Resources. She maintains records of all employees. She categorically testified that the code for Kenyatta National Hospital starts with 52 or 53. She confirmed that the said hospital does not have personal number 314316. She denied that Clement Munyao Katiku [A4] was an employee of Kenyatta National Hospital at any given time. That personal number 314316 is fake. She further testified that casual workers were not given personal numbers hence Clement Munyao Katitu was an imposter. She totally disowned Clement Munyao Katiku [A4] and branded him a liar.
he should be rotting in jail. First, he is not a doctor Virginia Mutheu Nzomo, [PW 2], was at her house at Kibera sometimes in October, 2009 when Clement Munyao Katiku [A 4], a neighbour asked her for a loan of 1,000/=. As security Clement gave her a Nokia mobile model 1208 admitted in evidence as exhibit No. 1. Clement, however, did not commit when he would re-pay the loan. Two weeks later, her child fell sick. She [PW 2] approached Clement Munyao for the repayment of the loan in vain. As a stop gap measure she got a loan from Justus Mutinda Ndeko. [PW3] As security, she pledged the Nokia phone which Clement Munyao [A4] had pledged as security for a loan of shs. 1000/= .kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/90652/
Do your deligence,he is not one,I have read the story on Kenya law courts and the story does not add up. Inooro TV should pull down this story which i s a lie to sway the masses of people to mercy instead of serving justice
@@tessywachira2202 Thanks for this Tessy. Most guys don't want to read! And iNooro should take the blame. For example the lady he is calling his daughter was his neighbor in Kibera who was found with the victim's phone. Munyao had given the phone to her.
@@tessywachira2202 No authenticity in most of these stories aired by these village media houses.It's about the number of comments and likes.Professional journalism under siege.😪
@@catherinemwema3400 It is funny how people believe that the inmates could tell the true stories. Do you think they can tell the truth on live media..No. But this so called doctor has gone too far in his lies. And the media should do due diligence in investigating their stories to air.
The man is lying 100%. First, he is not a doctor Virginia Mutheu Nzomo, [PW 2], was at her house at Kibera sometimes in October, 2009 when Clement Munyao Katiku [A 4], a neighbour asked her for a loan of 1,000/=. As security Clement gave her a Nokia mobile model 1208 admitted in evidence as exhibit No. 1. Clement, however, did not commit when he would re-pay the loan. Two weeks later, her child fell sick. She [PW 2] approached Clement Munyao for the repayment of the loan in vain. As a stop gap measure she got a loan from Justus Mutinda Ndeko. [PW3] As security, she pledged the Nokia phone which Clement Munyao [A4] had pledged as security for a loan of shs. 1000/= .kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/90652/
he should be rotting in jail. First, he is not a doctor Virginia Mutheu Nzomo, [PW 2], was at her house at Kibera sometimes in October, 2009 when Clement Munyao Katiku [A 4], a neighbour asked her for a loan of 1,000/=. As security Clement gave her a Nokia mobile model 1208 admitted in evidence as exhibit No. 1. Clement, however, did not commit when he would re-pay the loan. Two weeks later, her child fell sick. She [PW 2] approached Clement Munyao for the repayment of the loan in vain. As a stop gap measure she got a loan from Justus Mutinda Ndeko. [PW3] As security, she pledged the Nokia phone which Clement Munyao [A4] had pledged as security for a loan of shs. 1000/= .kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/90652/
WaAah n yu look still young 1980 ata sikujua kama ntapatikana ooh pole may God protect and open a way for yu iko siku utatoka thanks for sharing thank God for gift of life wengi wamekufa n yu are alive.aki simu ndo imekufunga miaka yote n wauwaji wanaachiliwa very fast may God intervene this too much.
he should be rotting in jail. First, he is not a doctor Virginia Mutheu Nzomo, [PW 2], was at her house at Kibera sometimes in October, 2009 when Clement Munyao Katiku [A 4], a neighbour asked her for a loan of 1,000/=. As security Clement gave her a Nokia mobile model 1208 admitted in evidence as exhibit No. 1. Clement, however, did not commit when he would re-pay the loan. Two weeks later, her child fell sick. She [PW 2] approached Clement Munyao for the repayment of the loan in vain. As a stop gap measure she got a loan from Justus Mutinda Ndeko. [PW3] As security, she pledged the Nokia phone which Clement Munyao [A4] had pledged as security for a loan of shs. 1000/= .kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/90652/
Oh, Lord Jesus Christ! This is so sad and such a waste of justice, taxpayers' money, and great skills. He is not guilty at all. The dead man and his family has no justice yet. The Dr. would have been of so much help in our health system. How do they conduct their investigations? Jameni, so sad.
The man is lying 100%. First, he is not a doctor Virginia Mutheu Nzomo, [PW 2], was at her house at Kibera sometimes in October, 2009 when Clement Munyao Katiku [A 4], a neighbour asked her for a loan of 1,000/=. As security Clement gave her a Nokia mobile model 1208 admitted in evidence as exhibit No. 1. Clement, however, did not commit when he would re-pay the loan. Two weeks later, her child fell sick. She [PW 2] approached Clement Munyao for the repayment of the loan in vain. As a stop gap measure she got a loan from Justus Mutinda Ndeko. [PW3] As security, she pledged the Nokia phone which Clement Munyao [A4] had pledged as security for a loan of shs. 1000/= .kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/90652/
@@annahmutahi6163 Not really. there are many things that do not really add up. I picked some that I will list here: 1. No neurosurgeon is naive/gullible enough to buy a second-hand phone. These are bright enough people to know the dangers involved 2. He did masters in pathology, how did he end up as a neurosurgeon???? 3. His diction is too basic for a neurosurgeon. These simple observations made me do a simple google search on his case only to find out that the dude is an imposter who owns a pub in Kibera and lives there. The wife of the victim was his co-accused and she got the death sentence. KNH the hospital he supposedly works for stated that he has never worked for them and he is an imposter. read his own affidavit that was submitted in court for his defense. the link is kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/90652/
What a shame! It seems the jails in Kenya are for the innocent guilty are out there!! God give this man strength , hope when he comes out hell continue with his work
I was once accused with rape case but in two weeks time it had changed and I was freshly accused of having been in affairs with a student.for who doubting this man's innocent is because they don't know Kenya well.
Were is that last person who had the phone,so called sergeant.!!!! justice for the Dr! Kenya's we can do this demonstration for this case! # RELEASE the DOCTOR!
Oh my God🙆🙆I can relate to this,I feel for this man though😢...I found myself in search a scenario nikiwa high school but God fought for me....watu wajihathari sana na simu za second hand
He is not a doctor let him say the truth. His English and course taken in medicine do not add up. Listen to him mixing up courses taken in medicine. Good command in English is a requirement in undertaking a degree in medicine
@@mercynduati6381 The man is lying 100%. First, he is not a doctor Virginia Mutheu Nzomo, [PW 2], was at her house at Kibera sometimes in October, 2009 when Clement Munyao Katiku [A 4], a neighbour asked her for a loan of 1,000/=. As security Clement gave her a Nokia mobile model 1208 admitted in evidence as exhibit No. 1. Clement, however, did not commit when he would re-pay the loan. Two weeks later, her child fell sick. She [PW 2] approached Clement Munyao for the repayment of the loan in vain. As a stop gap measure she got a loan from Justus Mutinda Ndeko. [PW3] As security, she pledged the Nokia phone which Clement Munyao [A4] had pledged as security for a loan of shs. 1000/= .kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/90652/
My question? If I am wrong correct me. So, his CV says he was born in 1957. Began school in 1962 when he was 5 years old and completed CPE 1968 when he was 11 years old. He further says he is a surgeon then a pathologist. He was a surgeon, without a lawyer? 🤔
This is just a smart con, that English is wanting of a neurosurgeon plus I have gone through into his story (in details) and they didn't add up when he was convicted
Thanks to having someone who can see through BS when they see one. Some of the things I picked while reading this story: 1. No neurosurgeon is naive/gullible enough to buy a second-hand phone. These are bright enough people to know the dangers involved 2. He did masters in pathology, how did he end up as a neurosurgeon???? This made me do a simple google search on his case only to find out that the dude is an imposter who owns a pub in Kibera and lives there. The wife of the victim was his co-accused and she got the death sentense
@@SuperVostie exactly my thoughts, he says he did pathology, actually forensic pathology, the 2 are completely different. I can't imagine a full neurosurgeon earning more than 200k at that time for one operation dealing with such petty issues.
It's very nice that you can see through his lies. And Kenyans are here wondering why this psychopath should be in jail instead of saving lives out here.
he should be rotting in jail. First, he is not a doctor Virginia Mutheu Nzomo, [PW 2], was at her house at Kibera sometimes in October, 2009 when Clement Munyao Katiku [A 4], a neighbour asked her for a loan of 1,000/=. As security Clement gave her a Nokia mobile model 1208 admitted in evidence as exhibit No. 1. Clement, however, did not commit when he would re-pay the loan. Two weeks later, her child fell sick. She [PW 2] approached Clement Munyao for the repayment of the loan in vain. As a stop gap measure she got a loan from Justus Mutinda Ndeko. [PW3] As security, she pledged the Nokia phone which Clement Munyao [A4] had pledged as security for a loan of shs. 1000/= .kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/90652/
why? he should be rotting in jail. First, he is not a doctor Virginia Mutheu Nzomo, [PW 2], was at her house at Kibera sometimes in October, 2009 when Clement Munyao Katiku [A 4], a neighbour asked her for a loan of 1,000/=. As security Clement gave her a Nokia mobile model 1208 admitted in evidence as exhibit No. 1. Clement, however, did not commit when he would re-pay the loan. Two weeks later, her child fell sick. She [PW 2] approached Clement Munyao for the repayment of the loan in vain. As a stop gap measure she got a loan from Justus Mutinda Ndeko. [PW3] As security, she pledged the Nokia phone which Clement Munyao [A4] had pledged as security for a loan of shs. 1000/= .kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/90652/
The man is lying 100%. First, he is not a doctor Virginia Mutheu Nzomo, [PW 2], was at her house at Kibera sometimes in October, 2009 when Clement Munyao Katiku [A 4], a neighbour asked her for a loan of 1,000/=. As security Clement gave her a Nokia mobile model 1208 admitted in evidence as exhibit No. 1. Clement, however, did not commit when he would re-pay the loan. Two weeks later, her child fell sick. She [PW 2] approached Clement Munyao for the repayment of the loan in vain. As a stop gap measure she got a loan from Justus Mutinda Ndeko. [PW3] As security, she pledged the Nokia phone which Clement Munyao [A4] had pledged as security for a loan of shs. 1000/= .kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/90652/
This story depicts how pathetic our investigating arms are, to them closing a case is more important than getting justice. The sergeant major At Iteere's is the person supposed to be behind bars he was the first contact with the phone, but juu ni mwenzao waka amua ku sacrifice daktari, Lord have mercy on the doctor
This is my real brother ours first born ,,, pray GOD that one day he shall out of jail ,, after we tried All our best to rescue him,, but money was problem but I know GOD will rescue him
What kind of investigation was taken,if the CID got to know he was on duty that night,despite even taking them where he got the phone ad chain of other guys,he ended up jailed innocently🙄😳 he lost his wife very sad.😥Government should stop throwing guys in prison like that.nkt😔
DW5, Clement Munyao Katiku, [A4], in his sworn statement, testified that he owns a bar christined Munyao Pub, at 42 Kibera Estate, and is also an employee of Keyatta National Hospital, in the capacity of a casual labourer. His personal number is 314316. That his bar-maid and some customers were arrested on 27th September, 2009. To bail them out the police required a sum of sh. 5000/-. He did not have enough money so he approached, inter-alia, Virginia [PW2] who loaned him a sum of sh. 1000/=. As consideration of the said loan he pledged his Nokia model 1200 to Virginia. On 30th October, 2009 he went to Kileleshwa to see his cousin, Christopher Munyao. He met Mark Makau Mathaa [DW8]. He asked Mark if he could take up a job at a canteen belonging to his boss at Kenyatta National Hospital. Mark declined and in turn called Andrew Muua Kimomo who accepted the offer. However, in order to be employed, at the canteen, Andrew Muua Kimomo [A5] had to get a health certificate at a cost of sh. 2400/=. Andrew had only sh. 1700/=. He loaned Andrew sh. 700/= to make a grand total of sh. 2400/=. In consideration of a loan of sh. 700/= Andrew pledged to him Nokia model 1200. However, when he came to court he was charged with the offence of theft of Nokia 6300. He denied the charge. DW6, Florence Nduki Mutiso, an employee of Kenyatta National Hospital since 1981 is the head of Human Resources. She maintains records of all employees. She categorically testified that the code for Kenyatta National Hospital starts with 52 or 53. She confirmed that the said hospital does not have personal number 314316. She denied that Clement Munyao Katiku [A4] was an employee of Kenyatta National Hospital at any given time. That personal number 314316 is fake. She further testified that casual workers were not given personal numbers hence Clement Munyao Katitu was an imposter. She totally disowned Clement Munyao Katiku [A4] and branded him a liar.
The guy who was killed was Janet Karamana's husband (featured on case files). She was also sentenced alongside Clement and five others. This case is very complicated indeed.
Here from Mkurugenzi🔥🔥
Bt story looks different from mkuruu
@@rodrickmuteya2239 manze
Same here
Me too
Me too
This guy should be saving lives out there, pls God help him
The man is lying 100%. First, he is not a doctor
Virginia Mutheu Nzomo, [PW 2], was at her house at Kibera sometimes in October, 2009 when Clement Munyao Katiku [A 4], a neighbour asked her for a loan of 1,000/=. As security Clement gave her a Nokia mobile model 1208 admitted in evidence as exhibit No. 1. Clement, however, did not commit when he would re-pay the loan. Two weeks later, her child fell sick. She [PW 2] approached Clement Munyao for the repayment of the loan in vain. As a stop gap measure she got a loan from Justus Mutinda Ndeko. [PW3] As security, she pledged the Nokia phone which Clement Munyao [A4] had pledged as security for a loan of shs. 1000/= .kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/90652/
@@nelsonmaingi1297 Am shocked, I have read every bit from the link, I have no words...How can someone fabricate such a story? His mental status should be checked
@@minazufa4636, what? Lemme go to that link
@@rwenji22 just read,you won't believe
DW5, Clement Munyao Katiku, [A4], in his sworn statement, testified that he owns a bar christined Munyao Pub, at 42 Kibera Estate, and is also an employee of Keyatta National Hospital, in the capacity of a casual labourer. His personal number is 314316. That his bar-maid and some customers were arrested on 27th September, 2009. To bail them out the police required a sum of sh. 5000/-. He did not have enough money so he approached, inter-alia, Virginia [PW2] who loaned him a sum of sh. 1000/=. As consideration of the said loan he pledged his Nokia model 1200 to Virginia. On 30th October, 2009 he went to Kileleshwa to see his cousin, Christopher Munyao. He met Mark Makau Mathaa [DW8]. He asked Mark if he could take up a job at a canteen belonging to his boss at Kenyatta National Hospital. Mark declined and in turn called Andrew Muua Kimomo who accepted the offer. However, in order to be employed, at the canteen, Andrew Muua Kimomo [A5] had to get a health certificate at a cost of sh. 2400/=. Andrew had only sh. 1700/=. He loaned Andrew sh. 700/= to make a grand total of sh. 2400/=. In consideration of a loan of sh. 700/= Andrew pledged to him Nokia model 1200. However, when he came to court he was charged with the offence of theft of Nokia 6300. He denied the charge. DW6, Florence Nduki Mutiso, an employee of Kenyatta National Hospital since 1981 is the head of Human Resources. She maintains records of all employees. She categorically testified that the code for Kenyatta National Hospital starts with 52 or 53. She confirmed that the said hospital does not have personal number 314316. She denied that Clement Munyao Katiku [A4] was an employee of Kenyatta National Hospital at any given time. That personal number 314316 is fake. She further testified that casual workers were not given personal numbers hence Clement Munyao Katitu was an imposter. She totally disowned Clement Munyao Katiku [A4] and branded him a liar.
Oh God remember this Man with gifted hands to save lives hope his years of hard work and study won’t go to waste so painful
Here from Mkurugenzi
Me too
Heartbreaking and you can see through his heart how innocent he is.
How can we help this accomplished doctor to get justice? Even if it means trending him on social media
Khaii mungu akusaindie utoke very painful
@@nelsonmaingi1297 we unachanganya story mbili tofauti ww
@@nelsonmaingi1297 wueh have read 🙆
@@eliaskamau8990 can you read the link provided and follow up on appeals made which are available online
@@nelsonmaingi1297
That is very true. After you do medicine you then do Masters in pathology and forensic medicine to become a consultant pathologist not a neurosurgeon.
He's too smart a liar but the judge didn't fall to his lies.
Uhuru kenyatta should watch this,very sad story 😓😓
So unfortunate he can't have time for this. I shed tears for him. Oh Lord.
@@josephkanyingi9710 The man is lying 100%. First, he is not a doctor
Virginia Mutheu Nzomo, [PW 2], was at her house at Kibera sometimes in October, 2009 when Clement Munyao Katiku [A 4], a neighbour asked her for a loan of 1,000/=. As security Clement gave her a Nokia mobile model 1208 admitted in evidence as exhibit No. 1. Clement, however, did not commit when he would re-pay the loan. Two weeks later, her child fell sick. She [PW 2] approached Clement Munyao for the repayment of the loan in vain. As a stop gap measure she got a loan from Justus Mutinda Ndeko. [PW3] As security, she pledged the Nokia phone which Clement Munyao [A4] had pledged as security for a loan of shs. 1000/= .kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/90652/
DW5, Clement Munyao Katiku, [A4], in his sworn statement, testified that he owns a bar christined Munyao Pub, at 42 Kibera Estate, and is also an employee of Keyatta National Hospital, in the capacity of a casual labourer. His personal number is 314316. That his bar-maid and some customers were arrested on 27th September, 2009. To bail them out the police required a sum of sh. 5000/-. He did not have enough money so he approached, inter-alia, Virginia [PW2] who loaned him a sum of sh. 1000/=. As consideration of the said loan he pledged his Nokia model 1200 to Virginia. On 30th October, 2009 he went to Kileleshwa to see his cousin, Christopher Munyao. He met Mark Makau Mathaa [DW8]. He asked Mark if he could take up a job at a canteen belonging to his boss at Kenyatta National Hospital. Mark declined and in turn called Andrew Muua Kimomo who accepted the offer. However, in order to be employed, at the canteen, Andrew Muua Kimomo [A5] had to get a health certificate at a cost of sh. 2400/=. Andrew had only sh. 1700/=. He loaned Andrew sh. 700/= to make a grand total of sh. 2400/=. In consideration of a loan of sh. 700/= Andrew pledged to him Nokia model 1200. However, when he came to court he was charged with the offence of theft of Nokia 6300. He denied the charge. DW6, Florence Nduki Mutiso, an employee of Kenyatta National Hospital since 1981 is the head of Human Resources. She maintains records of all employees. She categorically testified that the code for Kenyatta National Hospital starts with 52 or 53. She confirmed that the said hospital does not have personal number 314316. She denied that Clement Munyao Katiku [A4] was an employee of Kenyatta National Hospital at any given time. That personal number 314316 is fake. She further testified that casual workers were not given personal numbers hence Clement Munyao Katitu was an imposter. She totally disowned Clement Munyao Katiku [A4] and branded him a liar.
Hio kizungu ni ya surgeon
Wooooiiii, ngai fafa. Why was the only one picked on? This doesn't need one to go to a law school, leave alone being a judge. God is the only unquestionable judge. I shed tears
I believe God has a reason, and He is going to bring him out to change history.
Tumuombee saana.
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 Lord have mercy....
Yaaani wauwaji wako huru na wenye hawana hatia wako jela😭😭😭
Akina babu owino ati juu wanaimba BBI
Kenya imezidi
So sickening it really hurts.
He's a criminal. Just Google his case vs State
@@anthonyngocihkisilu2973 argue with your keyboard!
The government should award this guy for being pinned on something he didn't do
This is why police force should have a special unit for high level investigation assignments. We need very bright students for forensic science to join police force just like in the US
I second this.
Justice for Munyao... Painful story ever😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
I think police don't do due diligence because of our judicial system doesn't care of the case brought in there table and should dismiss some case for police to bring tangible evidence
Which US..?
@@Bantumumbui United States
This is why sometimes i understand when some of my family members and other kenyans abroad decide to stay abroad not to come back to their motherland when they hear such stories. It's so inhuman. Well educated man giving out to society with bright promising future turned into nightmare. God will reveal himself coz NO stone shall remain unturned. Starting from prosecutors to judiciary whome gave the true justice a deaf ear. they should remember no one shall overcome the true justice of the most high God. Sometimes is so shameful to be a kenyan.
This man is a liar....serial liar....read the case and am shocked
God have Mercy on this doctor he is supposed to be saving lives
This is a con
He was a casual in knh
Oh..my God Remember mr munyao in jesus Name
Wah!! Jela haichagui mfungwa....please pple take care of your freedom jera si boading school...pole dr Munyao
Dr you ar very strong man mungu akuride
Ngai witu tondu wonaga Gina hithoini... Igwa thaa iguru ria muthuri uyu aume jela, Amen 🙏🙏
Uyu ni mukora munene
Such a learned man who should be saving souls in hospitals ending up in jail🥲🥲
An innocent Dr wasting in jail while Kenyans are suffering lack of Dr's in our damn hospitals.. Very very sad
@@rosminevents2055 he should be rotting in jail. First, he is not a doctor
Virginia Mutheu Nzomo, [PW 2], was at her house at Kibera sometimes in October, 2009 when Clement Munyao Katiku [A 4], a neighbour asked her for a loan of 1,000/=. As security Clement gave her a Nokia mobile model 1208 admitted in evidence as exhibit No. 1. Clement, however, did not commit when he would re-pay the loan. Two weeks later, her child fell sick. She [PW 2] approached Clement Munyao for the repayment of the loan in vain. As a stop gap measure she got a loan from Justus Mutinda Ndeko. [PW3] As security, she pledged the Nokia phone which Clement Munyao [A4] had pledged as security for a loan of shs. 1000/= .kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/90652/
Learned where? That guy is not even qualified to teach any reasonable guy something, let's thing, just from his grammar you'd realise he is not among the less than 15 neurosurgeons we have in Kenya
Hii ni lesson watu wajifunze kutoka kwa huyu mzee, watu waache vitu za sec hand,
Kununua kitu bila recite big problem!!!
Mimi nimeacha kabisa I used to buy hata phones kwa vijana WA kupora watu
@@eunicewairimu5015 wacha kabisa mum itakuletea shida one day
Nililala cell Kwa kuuziwa stolen meko(naniliuziwa na my best friend).....I learned my lesson in hard way
Ngai, my heart is so heavy after watching this, may God intervene
DW5, Clement Munyao Katiku, [A4], in his sworn statement, testified that he owns a bar christined Munyao Pub, at 42 Kibera Estate, and is also an employee of Keyatta National Hospital, in the capacity of a casual labourer. His personal number is 314316. That his bar-maid and some customers were arrested on 27th September, 2009. To bail them out the police required a sum of sh. 5000/-. He did not have enough money so he approached, inter-alia, Virginia [PW2] who loaned him a sum of sh. 1000/=. As consideration of the said loan he pledged his Nokia model 1200 to Virginia. On 30th October, 2009 he went to Kileleshwa to see his cousin, Christopher Munyao. He met Mark Makau Mathaa [DW8]. He asked Mark if he could take up a job at a canteen belonging to his boss at Kenyatta National Hospital. Mark declined and in turn called Andrew Muua Kimomo who accepted the offer. However, in order to be employed, at the canteen, Andrew Muua Kimomo [A5] had to get a health certificate at a cost of sh. 2400/=. Andrew had only sh. 1700/=. He loaned Andrew sh. 700/= to make a grand total of sh. 2400/=. In consideration of a loan of sh. 700/= Andrew pledged to him Nokia model 1200. However, when he came to court he was charged with the offence of theft of Nokia 6300. He denied the charge. DW6, Florence Nduki Mutiso, an employee of Kenyatta National Hospital since 1981 is the head of Human Resources. She maintains records of all employees. She categorically testified that the code for Kenyatta National Hospital starts with 52 or 53. She confirmed that the said hospital does not have personal number 314316. She denied that Clement Munyao Katiku [A4] was an employee of Kenyatta National Hospital at any given time. That personal number 314316 is fake. She further testified that casual workers were not given personal numbers hence Clement Munyao Katitu was an imposter. She totally disowned Clement Munyao Katiku [A4] and branded him a liar.
@@Cryptoshifuu this is a case against a senior person in kenya how sure are we that the human resource department was asked to say this and tampered with the information why does this guy have legal papers showing of his career and credibility alot still doesn't add up with all this story
@@ivykimani8692 which senior person??? I don't know why you are lazy at reading information which is readily online rather than acting on emotions...CALM DOWN AND READ THE CASE AND ALL HIS APPEALS then tell us which that SENIOR person is. Mfarasa has mentioned Katiku's sworn statement to the court and the suspect fails to indicate that he is a neuro-surgeon but a causal laborer...Did you first hear his broken English when the video is beginning????
@@ivykimani8692 Is a CV a legal paper in Kenya? I think certificates are!!!
@@nelsonmaingi1297 the 'parallegal' spelling alone tells you all you need to know here.
God just hear cry of this innocent doctor haki have felt him
It's soo painful, justice for this man...
DW5, Clement Munyao Katiku, [A4], in his sworn statement, testified that he owns a bar christined Munyao Pub, at 42 Kibera Estate, and is also an employee of Keyatta National Hospital, in the capacity of a casual labourer. His personal number is 314316. That his bar-maid and some customers were arrested on 27th September, 2009. To bail them out the police required a sum of sh. 5000/-. He did not have enough money so he approached, inter-alia, Virginia [PW2] who loaned him a sum of sh. 1000/=. As consideration of the said loan he pledged his Nokia model 1200 to Virginia. On 30th October, 2009 he went to Kileleshwa to see his cousin, Christopher Munyao. He met Mark Makau Mathaa [DW8]. He asked Mark if he could take up a job at a canteen belonging to his boss at Kenyatta National Hospital. Mark declined and in turn called Andrew Muua Kimomo who accepted the offer. However, in order to be employed, at the canteen, Andrew Muua Kimomo [A5] had to get a health certificate at a cost of sh. 2400/=. Andrew had only sh. 1700/=. He loaned Andrew sh. 700/= to make a grand total of sh. 2400/=. In consideration of a loan of sh. 700/= Andrew pledged to him Nokia model 1200. However, when he came to court he was charged with the offence of theft of Nokia 6300. He denied the charge. DW6, Florence Nduki Mutiso, an employee of Kenyatta National Hospital since 1981 is the head of Human Resources. She maintains records of all employees. She categorically testified that the code for Kenyatta National Hospital starts with 52 or 53. She confirmed that the said hospital does not have personal number 314316. She denied that Clement Munyao Katiku [A4] was an employee of Kenyatta National Hospital at any given time. That personal number 314316 is fake. She further testified that casual workers were not given personal numbers hence Clement Munyao Katitu was an imposter. She totally disowned Clement Munyao Katiku [A4] and branded him a liar.
This guy is just lying
Wimuthaka juliet
There is no justice in kenya
From mkurugenzi😢😢😢
Achaneni na simu za second hand go and get new one from the shop hizi vitu ndogo watu hu ignore inaweza ku destroy your life within a second 😥😥😓
Tell them
Hata mpya ni issue. You need new from authorized dealers. Get a receipt too.
i love you Doctor😆
Ooh my God. Thankyou for saving me from the traps on the enemy. Am sorry for complaining for the things I don't have.
Pole sana
my heart is so heavy. God have mercy on this man haki
Wah...sad sad indeed 😢...freedom is coming rutoo 💚 rutooo fifth
God fight for this man he has gone through enough 😭😭
Woooiii naria maiyaga marainia mibuto barabara jehovah igua thaa
Pole sana my collegue..Its sad kupitia hayi knowing how you struggle to reach such a level in heights of education
he should be rotting in jail. First, he is not a doctor
Virginia Mutheu Nzomo, [PW 2], was at her house at Kibera sometimes in October, 2009 when Clement Munyao Katiku [A 4], a neighbour asked her for a loan of 1,000/=. As security Clement gave her a Nokia mobile model 1208 admitted in evidence as exhibit No. 1. Clement, however, did not commit when he would re-pay the loan. Two weeks later, her child fell sick. She [PW 2] approached Clement Munyao for the repayment of the loan in vain. As a stop gap measure she got a loan from Justus Mutinda Ndeko. [PW3] As security, she pledged the Nokia phone which Clement Munyao [A4] had pledged as security for a loan of shs. 1000/= .kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/90652/
Do your deligence,he is not one,I have read the story on Kenya law courts and the story does not add up.
Inooro TV should pull down this story which i s a lie to sway the masses of people to mercy instead of serving justice
@@tessywachira2202 Thanks for this Tessy. Most guys don't want to read! And iNooro should take the blame. For example the lady he is calling his daughter was his neighbor in Kibera who was found with the victim's phone. Munyao had given the phone to her.
@@tessywachira2202 No authenticity in most of these stories aired by these village media houses.It's about the number of comments and likes.Professional journalism under siege.😪
@@catherinemwema3400 It is funny how people believe that the inmates could tell the true stories. Do you think they can tell the truth on live media..No. But this so called doctor has gone too far in his lies. And the media should do due diligence in investigating their stories to air.
May God have mercy on you do .pole r sana
This gentleman should be out there saving lives , but not wasting his, behind bars.
The man is lying 100%. First, he is not a doctor
Virginia Mutheu Nzomo, [PW 2], was at her house at Kibera sometimes in October, 2009 when Clement Munyao Katiku [A 4], a neighbour asked her for a loan of 1,000/=. As security Clement gave her a Nokia mobile model 1208 admitted in evidence as exhibit No. 1. Clement, however, did not commit when he would re-pay the loan. Two weeks later, her child fell sick. She [PW 2] approached Clement Munyao for the repayment of the loan in vain. As a stop gap measure she got a loan from Justus Mutinda Ndeko. [PW3] As security, she pledged the Nokia phone which Clement Munyao [A4] had pledged as security for a loan of shs. 1000/= .kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/90652/
@@nelsonmaingi1297 they need to go through this man's case.In fact there was not graduation in 1980 hapo UoN
Very true I felt sorry for the guy honestly
@@elizabethpeter8798 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@nelsonmaingi1297 wow 😲, thanks for sharing, went through it, I think 💬 the journalist needs to do some research before bringing the guys here!
I learne alot about all story when am angry only to run or to cross my mouth
Very sad story though with a lot of lessons to learn
Wooiye pole sana
Woiye surely!Hiyo masomo yote.aachiliwe walai hii si poa
he should be rotting in jail. First, he is not a doctor
Virginia Mutheu Nzomo, [PW 2], was at her house at Kibera sometimes in October, 2009 when Clement Munyao Katiku [A 4], a neighbour asked her for a loan of 1,000/=. As security Clement gave her a Nokia mobile model 1208 admitted in evidence as exhibit No. 1. Clement, however, did not commit when he would re-pay the loan. Two weeks later, her child fell sick. She [PW 2] approached Clement Munyao for the repayment of the loan in vain. As a stop gap measure she got a loan from Justus Mutinda Ndeko. [PW3] As security, she pledged the Nokia phone which Clement Munyao [A4] had pledged as security for a loan of shs. 1000/= .kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/90652/
WaAah n yu look still young 1980 ata sikujua kama ntapatikana ooh pole may God protect and open a way for yu iko siku utatoka thanks for sharing thank God for gift of life wengi wamekufa n yu are alive.aki simu ndo imekufunga miaka yote n wauwaji wanaachiliwa very fast may God intervene this too much.
Soo soo sad for this innocent doctor may God see him thru and vidicate him.
he should be rotting in jail. First, he is not a doctor
Virginia Mutheu Nzomo, [PW 2], was at her house at Kibera sometimes in October, 2009 when Clement Munyao Katiku [A 4], a neighbour asked her for a loan of 1,000/=. As security Clement gave her a Nokia mobile model 1208 admitted in evidence as exhibit No. 1. Clement, however, did not commit when he would re-pay the loan. Two weeks later, her child fell sick. She [PW 2] approached Clement Munyao for the repayment of the loan in vain. As a stop gap measure she got a loan from Justus Mutinda Ndeko. [PW3] As security, she pledged the Nokia phone which Clement Munyao [A4] had pledged as security for a loan of shs. 1000/= .kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/90652/
Here from mkurugenzii
Oh, Lord Jesus Christ! This is so sad and such a waste of justice, taxpayers' money, and great skills.
He is not guilty at all. The dead man and his family has no justice yet. The Dr. would have been of so much help in our health system.
How do they conduct their investigations?
Jameni, so sad.
The man is lying 100%. First, he is not a doctor
Virginia Mutheu Nzomo, [PW 2], was at her house at Kibera sometimes in October, 2009 when Clement Munyao Katiku [A 4], a neighbour asked her for a loan of 1,000/=. As security Clement gave her a Nokia mobile model 1208 admitted in evidence as exhibit No. 1. Clement, however, did not commit when he would re-pay the loan. Two weeks later, her child fell sick. She [PW 2] approached Clement Munyao for the repayment of the loan in vain. As a stop gap measure she got a loan from Justus Mutinda Ndeko. [PW3] As security, she pledged the Nokia phone which Clement Munyao [A4] had pledged as security for a loan of shs. 1000/= .kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/90652/
wooiye Ngai..you could have been saving lives instead of Jera
Saudi Arabia 🇸🇦 watching
Kibe, please do some background check before airing a program. We need some more information about the guy. There some inconsistencies.
Like which one
You didn't follow the story well, he is very consistent
@@annahmutahi6163 Not really. there are many things that do not really add up. I picked some that I will list here:
1. No neurosurgeon is naive/gullible enough to buy a second-hand phone. These are bright enough people to know the dangers involved
2. He did masters in pathology, how did he end up as a neurosurgeon????
3. His diction is too basic for a neurosurgeon.
These simple observations made me do a simple google search on his case only to find out that the dude is an imposter who owns a pub in Kibera and lives there. The wife of the victim was his co-accused and she got the death sentence. KNH the hospital he supposedly works for stated that he has never worked for them and he is an imposter.
read his own affidavit that was submitted in court for his defense. the link is kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/90652/
Well said steve
@@annahmutahi6163 you are clueless🤭.Steve is very right.
I wish I have all it takes to set you free. Our God is working on your freedom
He is not what he says he is. I mean, he is not a neurosurgeon/doctor. He was actually behind the murder and he is a serial liar.
What a shame! It seems the jails in Kenya are for the innocent guilty are out there!! God give this man strength , hope when he comes out hell continue with his work
I was once accused with rape case but in two weeks time it had changed and I was freshly accused of having been in affairs with a student.for who doubting this man's innocent is because they don't know Kenya well.
Lord have mercy
Wooooi so painful 😭😭
Wuui Mwathani Jesu Kristu Ngai aroteithia Dr munyao ma it's so sad
Were is that last person who had the phone,so called sergeant.!!!! justice for the Dr! Kenya's we can do this demonstration for this case!
# RELEASE the DOCTOR!
The man is lying 100%. First, he is not a doctor .kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/90652/
@@nelsonmaingi1297 Kenyatta hospital😳
@@nelsonmaingi1297 mm ata sikujua you can get someone's case online lmfaooo. Amesanitize crime yake kabisa
hata akindanya hajishaindii. Media houses should do research before posting misinformation
Waaah Kenya Aki..am sorry our dad.
Lord have mercy on him🙏🙏 I know u can do anything jehova fight for him dear God🙏
Pole sana my brother for what opening
Ngai Mwathani nii ndingigura thimu ya second hande,sasa huyu Daktari ameshikwa kwa makosa sio yake pole sana Dr
God knows why. Take heart sir.
So sad.
Take heart daddy. God will make a way.
Woooiii,that's why siwezi nunua simu mzee
Kenya pesa huongea but wanjue ni kwa muda,,kufunga MTU hana makosa na unabaki ukifurahia ngojea malipo ni hapa hapa
God bless kituo cha sheria,this guy ni dr then kituo imemfunza sheria(paralegal)
inooro tv good job,pia hawa watu ni wetu
God have mercy to this man
Nafeel analie
Oh my God🙆🙆I can relate to this,I feel for this man though😢...I found myself in search a scenario nikiwa high school but God fought for me....watu wajihathari sana na simu za second hand
Kindly pray for him that God who brought you out
Does the same for him.
He is not a doctor let him say the truth. His English and course taken in medicine do not add up. Listen to him mixing up courses taken in medicine. Good command in English is a requirement in undertaking a degree in medicine
Pole Sana mungu akuepushie
Once he's out, he need a good lawyer nd he will be paid all those wasted years
Just read the link from nelson maingi
Paid by who
Hata ukilipwa, most victims still do not get the money in Kenya.
@@minazufa4636
Let him read and understand. Criminals are very deceitful.
@@minazufa4636 He had an employer and the Gov't
I feel soo bad. Pole mzee. Justice we have in this country jameni.😢. 2nd hand phones =trouble!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
so painful God interven in the mighty name of Jesus amen
Very sad for Dr munyau but one day things will wake for but it's a lesson to those who but or steal or harder steal en property
@@mercynduati6381 The man is lying 100%. First, he is not a doctor
Virginia Mutheu Nzomo, [PW 2], was at her house at Kibera sometimes in October, 2009 when Clement Munyao Katiku [A 4], a neighbour asked her for a loan of 1,000/=. As security Clement gave her a Nokia mobile model 1208 admitted in evidence as exhibit No. 1. Clement, however, did not commit when he would re-pay the loan. Two weeks later, her child fell sick. She [PW 2] approached Clement Munyao for the repayment of the loan in vain. As a stop gap measure she got a loan from Justus Mutinda Ndeko. [PW3] As security, she pledged the Nokia phone which Clement Munyao [A4] had pledged as security for a loan of shs. 1000/= .kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/90652/
Regardless of his origin ,the man is truly innocent.
My question? If I am wrong correct me.
So, his CV says he was born in 1957.
Began school in 1962 when he was 5 years old and completed CPE 1968 when he was 11 years old.
He further says he is a surgeon then a pathologist.
He was a surgeon, without a lawyer? 🤔
His story is extremely complicated I guess he's a criminal.
From mkuru..
President should review this
This is just a smart con, that English is wanting of a neurosurgeon plus I have gone through into his story (in details) and they didn't add up when he was convicted
Thanks to having someone who can see through BS when they see one. Some of the things I picked while reading this story:
1. No neurosurgeon is naive/gullible enough to buy a second-hand phone. These are bright enough people to know the dangers involved
2. He did masters in pathology, how did he end up as a neurosurgeon????
This made me do a simple google search on his case only to find out that the dude is an imposter who owns a pub in Kibera and lives there. The wife of the victim was his co-accused and she got the death sentense
Very true. He is just a con!
@@SuperVostie exactly my thoughts, he says he did pathology, actually forensic pathology, the 2 are completely different. I can't imagine a full neurosurgeon earning more than 200k at that time for one operation dealing with such petty issues.
It's very nice that you can see through his lies. And Kenyans are here wondering why this psychopath should be in jail instead of saving lives out here.
At least someone saw that and how do you study pathology plus sijui forensic medicine and become a neurosurgeon
ii Dio Ile mizigo mizito God alisema atatuvebea😢
This is so inhumane, and the guilty people are out there 😢
woooi Ngai wa tha
My the Almighty Lord fight for your battle
Ati mwea kwetu😳 woiye daktari
This is such a sad case that I have ever watched 😭😭😭😭😭. Absolutely so sad 😭😭😭😭
he should be rotting in jail. First, he is not a doctor
Virginia Mutheu Nzomo, [PW 2], was at her house at Kibera sometimes in October, 2009 when Clement Munyao Katiku [A 4], a neighbour asked her for a loan of 1,000/=. As security Clement gave her a Nokia mobile model 1208 admitted in evidence as exhibit No. 1. Clement, however, did not commit when he would re-pay the loan. Two weeks later, her child fell sick. She [PW 2] approached Clement Munyao for the repayment of the loan in vain. As a stop gap measure she got a loan from Justus Mutinda Ndeko. [PW3] As security, she pledged the Nokia phone which Clement Munyao [A4] had pledged as security for a loan of shs. 1000/= .kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/90652/
Mungu atusaidie na hii mambo ya simu second hand.
May God have mercy 🙏
Hiyo Masomo yote inapotea bure 🤔🤔🤔🤔 he needs to be released for sure
why? he should be rotting in jail. First, he is not a doctor
Virginia Mutheu Nzomo, [PW 2], was at her house at Kibera sometimes in October, 2009 when Clement Munyao Katiku [A 4], a neighbour asked her for a loan of 1,000/=. As security Clement gave her a Nokia mobile model 1208 admitted in evidence as exhibit No. 1. Clement, however, did not commit when he would re-pay the loan. Two weeks later, her child fell sick. She [PW 2] approached Clement Munyao for the repayment of the loan in vain. As a stop gap measure she got a loan from Justus Mutinda Ndeko. [PW3] As security, she pledged the Nokia phone which Clement Munyao [A4] had pledged as security for a loan of shs. 1000/= .kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/90652/
Nelson, are you a cop? Nakuona everywhere. Or is the deceased family?
Gutiri undu ingiuga, Ngai gutiri gitumi atoii
Kenya ni gutee gutheri
The man is lying 100%. First, he is not a doctor
Virginia Mutheu Nzomo, [PW 2], was at her house at Kibera sometimes in October, 2009 when Clement Munyao Katiku [A 4], a neighbour asked her for a loan of 1,000/=. As security Clement gave her a Nokia mobile model 1208 admitted in evidence as exhibit No. 1. Clement, however, did not commit when he would re-pay the loan. Two weeks later, her child fell sick. She [PW 2] approached Clement Munyao for the repayment of the loan in vain. As a stop gap measure she got a loan from Justus Mutinda Ndeko. [PW3] As security, she pledged the Nokia phone which Clement Munyao [A4] had pledged as security for a loan of shs. 1000/= .kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/90652/
Kenya needs to review it's law.please
This story depicts how pathetic our investigating arms are, to them closing a case is more important than getting justice. The sergeant major At Iteere's is the person supposed to be behind bars he was the first contact with the phone, but juu ni mwenzao waka amua ku sacrifice daktari, Lord have mercy on the doctor
Yesu muonekanie
You don't become a neurosurgeon by studying forensic surgery.
A reason for me to believe he's a quack
But who knows...
Exactly. This is a fake Doctor. From his fake CV it shows that he did his bachelor of medicine and surgery for just 5years! That's not possible.
@@JohnJohn-bq4yv it has been 5years at UON until recently
He's a crook. Google his case vs State
He is clinical officer
This is a lier! He's not a Doctor or a medic at any level.
Pole sana doctor 😢nmekuelewa kabisa hapa Kenya hamna haki kabisa na police ni mikatili sana
I pray he gets justice. May God intervene.
L
This is my real brother ours first born ,,, pray GOD that one day he shall out of jail ,, after we tried All our best to rescue him,, but money was problem but I know GOD will rescue him
This is my real brother imjn others people are now out of jail but my brother still there in jail because of money,,but one day GOD will rescue him
What kind of investigation was taken,if the CID got to know he was on duty that night,despite even taking them where he got the phone ad chain of other guys,he ended up jailed innocently🙄😳 he lost his wife very sad.😥Government should stop throwing guys in prison like that.nkt😔
DW5, Clement Munyao Katiku, [A4], in his sworn statement, testified that he owns a bar christined Munyao Pub, at 42 Kibera Estate, and is also an employee of Keyatta National Hospital, in the capacity of a casual labourer. His personal number is 314316. That his bar-maid and some customers were arrested on 27th September, 2009. To bail them out the police required a sum of sh. 5000/-. He did not have enough money so he approached, inter-alia, Virginia [PW2] who loaned him a sum of sh. 1000/=. As consideration of the said loan he pledged his Nokia model 1200 to Virginia. On 30th October, 2009 he went to Kileleshwa to see his cousin, Christopher Munyao. He met Mark Makau Mathaa [DW8]. He asked Mark if he could take up a job at a canteen belonging to his boss at Kenyatta National Hospital. Mark declined and in turn called Andrew Muua Kimomo who accepted the offer. However, in order to be employed, at the canteen, Andrew Muua Kimomo [A5] had to get a health certificate at a cost of sh. 2400/=. Andrew had only sh. 1700/=. He loaned Andrew sh. 700/= to make a grand total of sh. 2400/=. In consideration of a loan of sh. 700/= Andrew pledged to him Nokia model 1200. However, when he came to court he was charged with the offence of theft of Nokia 6300. He denied the charge. DW6, Florence Nduki Mutiso, an employee of Kenyatta National Hospital since 1981 is the head of Human Resources. She maintains records of all employees. She categorically testified that the code for Kenyatta National Hospital starts with 52 or 53. She confirmed that the said hospital does not have personal number 314316. She denied that Clement Munyao Katiku [A4] was an employee of Kenyatta National Hospital at any given time. That personal number 314316 is fake. She further testified that casual workers were not given personal numbers hence Clement Munyao Katitu was an imposter. She totally disowned Clement Munyao Katiku [A4] and branded him a liar.
Influence. The slain man was a brother to the then commissioner of police ,Mathew Iteere
@@bettymuriu 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
God have mercy on wenye wamefungwa mbila kutenda.
This is so sad may God see you through
Very heart breaking,I know God will make away for you
CJ ought to Review Such cases and serve Justice. Our PRESIDENT ought to do the needful to help this Gentleman.
Woiyee aki
The guy who was killed was Janet Karamana's husband (featured on case files). She was also sentenced alongside Clement and five others. This case is very complicated indeed.
Watu wengi wako ndani wako so innocent,, pole doctor na utatoka
God c wamwachilie sasa
Am here from mkurugenzi
So sad 😭 😭 😭 God see you through
I have checked the graduation list UON 1980 but it's not available.