Cement Tiles Almost Disappeared. Now They’re More Expensive Than Ever | So Expensive

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 22 май 2024
  • Cement-tile artisans use colorful pigments to form hundreds of designs. The tiles have been popular for nearly 200 years as a beautiful and affordable building material, but today, they can cost over 10 times as much as some ceramic subway tiles. And despite the premium, many workshops have struggled to stay in business. Now, the price for their main ingredient has skyrocketed, aggravated by supply chain issues and shortages. So, what's made cement tiles more expensive? And can new trends sustain this traditional craft?
    MORE SO EXPENSIVE VIDEOS:
    Why Japanese Kanzuri Chile Paste Is So Expensive | So Expensive | Business Insider
    • Why Japanese Kanzuri C...
    Why Calligraphy Inkstones Are So Expensive | So Expensive | Business Insider
    • Why Calligraphy Inksto...
    Why Puppies Bred And Trained To Be Seeing Eye Dogs Are So Expensive | So Expensive
    • Why Puppies Bred And T...
    00:00 - Intro
    00:55 - Inside A Cement Tile Workshop
    01:30 - Colorful Pigments
    02:36 - Tile Making Process
    04:02 - Maintaining Quality
    05:11 - Hydraulic Press
    06:42 - Price Of Cement Tiles
    07:32 - Cement Shortages
    09:02 - Raising Popularity Of Handmade Tiles
    11:22 - Installing Cement Tiles
    13:07 - Keeping The Craft Alive
    14:17 - The Future Of The Workshop
    15:29 - Credits
    ------------------------------------------------------
    #art #tile #businessinsider
    Business Insider tells you all you need to know about business, finance, tech, retail, and more.
    Visit our homepage for the top stories of the day: www.businessinsider.com
    Business Insider on Facebook: / businessinsider Business Insider on Instagram: / insiderbusiness Business Insider on Twitter: / businessinsider
    Business Insider on Snapchat: / 5319643143
    Business Insider on TikTok: / businessinsider
    Cement Tiles Are More Expensive Than Ever. Why Can’t Some Artisans Stay In Business? | So Expensive

Комментарии • 163

  • @virtualfilmer
    @virtualfilmer 11 дней назад +234

    The corporations that produce the raw products are making record profits - it’s not a “supply chain” problem, it’s greed.

    • @markb.8460
      @markb.8460 10 дней назад +9

      sounds like monopoly, no competition?

    • @yahyobekazimov5811
      @yahyobekazimov5811 10 дней назад

      Q is​

    • @ShawnAR25
      @ShawnAR25 9 дней назад

      Cry me a river

    • @stickyfox
      @stickyfox 5 дней назад +2

      @@ShawnAR25 we're all drowning in the same river.

    • @duke605
      @duke605 День назад

      No no. Don't look at the man behind the curtain. Don't question the economic model. Just consume

  • @nicholas5623
    @nicholas5623 11 дней назад +57

    anyone that has the passions he does for his craft, is something id like because you know he put his heart and soul into it.

    • @zusiarosenthal4674
      @zusiarosenthal4674 11 дней назад +2

      and thats the differnece between a career and a job

  • @psyche141
    @psyche141 11 дней назад +43

    The designer tiles look atrocious; the Moroccan ones are just plain beautiful.

    • @MouuStaa
      @MouuStaa 11 дней назад +13

      and guess who sells them for a much higher price and has better publicity and reach lol unfair

    • @WorldCitizenW
      @WorldCitizenW 10 дней назад +5

      Those colors+ motif are just ugly.

    • @free_internet_bird
      @free_internet_bird 6 дней назад +5

      I was sad when I saw the big company selling their tiles and knew that somewhere somebody was trying sell their hard work but this giant was having much higher succes thanks to their aggressive marketing.

    • @free_internet_bird
      @free_internet_bird 6 дней назад +4

      In theory, you can approach these artisans if you have the resources and start a business that caters to affluent customers and take your own piece of the pie. The only thing that would have to be done is aggressive marketing and creating an image. It should be possible.
      After all, one of the core values of the luxury market is limited availability, craftsmanship, challenging production that creates prestige and individuality, and history.

  • @nadineeeee
    @nadineeeee 11 дней назад +19

    If the middle eastern tile makers had better marketing in place aimed at western buyers, they would be millionaires tbh.

    • @free_internet_bird
      @free_internet_bird 6 дней назад +2

      Yes, the marketing make or break business sometimes.

  • @Unhomiee
    @Unhomiee 11 дней назад +29

    I can understand the value of cement tiles and the artistry behind it, but I swear that lady is probably what Google Images spits out when you search for pretentious...

    • @WorldCitizenW
      @WorldCitizenW 10 дней назад +4

      Those terecata color abstract motif are ugly

  • @BrownyBird
    @BrownyBird 8 дней назад +21

    My childhood home had these tiles. I got the best memories laying down on them in the hot summer days!

  • @gicardee6756
    @gicardee6756 11 дней назад +19

    this episode was so beautiful to watch

  • @SaphireTech
    @SaphireTech 7 дней назад +8

    I just watching these skilled artisans at work, these tiles look amazing.

  • @soniatriana9091
    @soniatriana9091 8 дней назад +3

    Thank you for profiling these genuinely talented gentlemen! You hear the love in their voices, see their passion in the eyes & body language, & watch their delicate mannerisms as they work! They are very proud of their skill set & their cultural history! This was a fantastic documentary video!! Thank you so much for creating & sharing this wonderful history!!

  • @user-xo7hb6ts7j
    @user-xo7hb6ts7j 11 дней назад +21

    It seems to make sense that these would be more expensive, they are hand maid. (Though I am positive that you can make the same thing using machinery).
    I just hope the guys who actually make it get the profit rather than some fancy design studio or a supplier claiming all the profits.

    • @paulg3012
      @paulg3012 11 дней назад +8

      You know Kate make the lion's share.

  • @oxvendivil442
    @oxvendivil442 4 дня назад +2

    We call these Baldoza in our country the Philippines, some call these Machuca tiles, very few makes these these days, an almost lost art, hope more people use these timeless materials, my grandpa also used to make these for his home and to sell in his hardware store.

  • @TikiHi77
    @TikiHi77 11 дней назад +4

    I would be honored to have these in my home.

  • @miskee11
    @miskee11 11 дней назад +45

    nice I'm gonna go there and buy all of their rejected and broken tiles and use them for mosaic works. easy money

  • @thehangmansdaughter1120
    @thehangmansdaughter1120 11 дней назад +7

    They're beautiful!

  • @mikkosha
    @mikkosha 10 дней назад +4

    I think with more modern mold making techniques one could reduce the amount of reject tiles and make it significantly easier to produce them…

  • @JayCWhiteCloud
    @JayCWhiteCloud 11 дней назад +26

    Personally, as a design-builder in the world of natural and traditional vernacular architecture, I think it is both disingenuous and inaccurate to call these "cement tiles" as much is being confused in the translation. These, when traditionally made, are not OPC industrial materials but the ancient "roman cement" type mixes which of course takes more understanding and craft. This is a sustainable product and not the massively polluting material the modern OPC cements are that fall apart around us all...These traditional tiles are wonderful...!!!

    • @leolow2057
      @leolow2057 11 дней назад +7

      Most people spend their decades of saving and money just to buy a house.
      And now you are telling them to use tiles that are maybe 10x more expensive to renovate their house because it is more environmentally friendly or because of artisan value.
      Nah.

    • @josenavarro3816
      @josenavarro3816 11 дней назад

      Most people had to save for decades due to a shit economy, not the other way dude, as is we have a shitty president that screwed the economy along with dumbass people that saw fit to let this slide too.

    • @JayCWhiteCloud
      @JayCWhiteCloud 11 дней назад +7

      @@leolow2057 First, I'm not telling anyone to do anything...Each person has to make their ethical decisions about how they live. These tiles would not typically be used in architecture, and projects I consult on, …or…they would be made locally by members of the project or related craftspeople. I love “hand made” materials, and do not find them the “most expensive” at all so disagree with what this video is projecting on that aspect as well. I generally think, based on experience and knowledge, there are a number of flaws in this video…but that does not negate that hand made tiles of natural cement or clay are not wonderful…

    • @Panda_Gibs
      @Panda_Gibs 11 дней назад

      Roman cement is not more advanced or environmentally friendly. The Romans left an indelible layer of ash and lead across the world with their economic activity. And any surviving roman cement is just selection bias at its finest.

    • @lullabyandtales904
      @lullabyandtales904 6 дней назад +1

      I'm using this tiles and my grandparents has this tiles in their home more than 50 years. When it get dull, they will polish it and it's like new tiles again. The bolder the color, it's more expensive. I paid about $26.5 per square meter. Custom color.

  • @moonshinebling
    @moonshinebling 10 дней назад +1

    Thankyou for this epi,it ws good to know the design process

  • @donaldharlan3981
    @donaldharlan3981 11 дней назад +7

    Excellent craft!😀

  • @fansizhe9997
    @fansizhe9997 11 дней назад +4

    Wow amazing art work!!!👍👏🏻😍💖💖💖 So beautiful 🤩🥰😍

  • @christopherfriedberg6597
    @christopherfriedberg6597 3 дня назад

    So Pretty and Absolutely Fascinating ! This Art must continue for all Eternity !

  • @dondobbs9302
    @dondobbs9302 2 дня назад

    I was lucky enough to go to a shop that made these in Merida, Mexico. Absolutely amazing!

  • @vinzanity68
    @vinzanity68 11 дней назад +5

    Its beautiful. I didnt know there are tiles other than ceramic.❤

  • @kt38138
    @kt38138 2 дня назад +1

    The pattern on good quality cement tiles last much longer than on ceramic tiles. Although the later can have very sophisticated design, once the enamel layer wear off, so does the thin pained-on pattern just right beneath. It will take much, much longer for cement tile to expose its cement backing.

  • @TechnoMasterBoy
    @TechnoMasterBoy 10 дней назад +2

    Why was this reposted? This was already in one of the marathon episodes several months back.

  • @NAKDTV
    @NAKDTV 11 дней назад +1

    This is a really neat video 🥹

  • @ChristopherFoote69
    @ChristopherFoote69 11 дней назад +1

    Thank You ❤

  • @wadood8700
    @wadood8700 11 дней назад +4

    Beautiful

  • @ANWFineArt
    @ANWFineArt 5 дней назад

    Wow those are beautiful.

  • @nikdo0816
    @nikdo0816 9 дней назад +2

    The tiles with design imperfections get destroyed? Why not sell them in mixed sets (every tile different is also an aesthetic some people go for) for reduced price? As I understand it, the most time consuming part (on the worker's side) already went into it at the very beginning, so just letting them dry and selling them, even for lower price, would mean that the work put into it is at least somewhat profitable.

    • @lullabyandtales904
      @lullabyandtales904 5 дней назад

      The company I ordered my tiles sell those reject tiles. The price is lower and really, when put together like mix pattern, no body gonna know its reject.

  • @beverlylumley4150
    @beverlylumley4150 11 дней назад +1

    Thank you, very interesting, Canada

  • @Katrene.
    @Katrene. 8 дней назад

    These tiles are lovely! :D

  • @gracemay8775
    @gracemay8775 4 дня назад

    I would love to have these in my home one day!

  • @RnldsWrap
    @RnldsWrap 10 дней назад

    Wow! I wish I could learn from them.

  • @nerd26373
    @nerd26373 11 дней назад +9

    Cement tiles are expertly crafted. They can never be replicated. But who am I to add more information. I know nothing else about the whole manufacturing process behind all this.

    • @NamelessONEMail
      @NamelessONEMail 11 дней назад

      No... they can make cars mostly automatically and you think simple tiles can't be made? The reason these are not mass factory produced is likely that western demand is too low (if it even exists at all) combined with them likely not being as profitable to make.

  • @renataheiberg7534
    @renataheiberg7534 День назад

    I love this art.

  • @knightshade6232
    @knightshade6232 8 дней назад

    Working their sooo theraputic 🌿

  • @hoverbeaver
    @hoverbeaver 8 дней назад +2

    me, an electrician, watching that tile installer bury an electrical box

    • @Grumblertron
      @Grumblertron 7 дней назад +1

      No mud ring, blank cover already sealed shut with mud on every edge. Horrific.

  • @mfmr200
    @mfmr200 День назад

    the weirdest thing is, all of used to be affordable product are becoming trendy and when rich people like it, the price increase.

  • @Martin_Priesthood
    @Martin_Priesthood 10 дней назад +1

    👍 beautiful 💯🙏

  • @blessedbeauty2293
    @blessedbeauty2293 7 дней назад +2

    - I hope the Moroccan tiles can continue to be made for *very* long. I'd love to get them if anyone has any idea how to.

  • @fatwamindai
    @fatwamindai 7 дней назад

    I would really love to collect those tiles🤤

  • @abhishekanil3596
    @abhishekanil3596 5 дней назад

    In South India it is called "Athangudi tiles". It is cottage industry in Chettinadu in Tamil Nadu. Chettinadu Mansions got its long lasting beauty from these tiles

  • @OcarinaSapphr-
    @OcarinaSapphr- 10 дней назад +1

    What do they do with the rejected tiles? Are they used as infill, or can they be recycled into new tiles?

  • @oppositeofh8
    @oppositeofh8 11 дней назад

    fierceness.
    😻😻😻😻😻 5/5

  • @blessedbeauty2293
    @blessedbeauty2293 7 дней назад +1

    - How can we buy his tiles? They're really creative.

  • @karenneill9109
    @karenneill9109 9 дней назад

    It should be relatively easy to automate portions of this process- a machine with nozzles can fill exact amounts, sprinkle cement, press it, etc. There’s no reason they couldn’t be even cheaper than ceramic- especially as they don’t have to be fired. (And yes, I realize that would reduce the handmade aspect of it, but if you wanted to, production could be upped).

  • @siggyincr7447
    @siggyincr7447 11 дней назад

    Thing is, if a sizable market develops for these you can be assured that someone will automate the process in a location closer to the market. Cement tiles are heavy and shipping costs are a sizable portion of the cost to the end user.

  • @thebetyazedsaleem
    @thebetyazedsaleem 10 дней назад +1

    المغاربا مبدعين.

  • @Comm0ut
    @Comm0ut 8 дней назад

    The vast majority of the production is in manual labor. What is the actual percentage cost of the raw materials and what are their margins in which specific markets?
    The amount of cement used per tile is quite small, yet large construction projects continue using thousands of tons. More useful detail is required to understand the actual market reality.

  • @ellen4956
    @ellen4956 2 дня назад

    The art of making these tiles takes amazing skill, and if the tiles cost 10 times more than "some subway tiles", it's probably because anything of lasting quality and beauty costs more. These men are skilled craftsmen, as shown in the video, and if you want this kind of quality you have to pay for it. They have to pay more now for the products to make the tiles. Why not do a focus piece on the rising cost of cement? The tiles are still cheap at even $3.00 a tile. Average cost of glazed tile is $3 - $15, porcelain $3 - $40 per square foot (*thisoldhouse) so these are actually still a bargain, and will last far longer.

  • @adrianaalara6724
    @adrianaalara6724 11 дней назад +6

    The man in Egypt made me so sad. You can see everything in his eyes.

  • @nikmills
    @nikmills 11 дней назад +15

    The designer tiles are so lame compared to the real thing. I grew up in the Mediterranean where these tiles were everywhere. They're bold, not minimalist and pretentious.

  • @hasnaamahry7458
    @hasnaamahry7458 11 дней назад +2

    morocco is wonderfull

  • @GodzHarleyGirlStudio
    @GodzHarleyGirlStudio 11 дней назад +2

    Second part is an old video, already seen.

  • @user-np2lp5yg3o
    @user-np2lp5yg3o 7 дней назад

    What is the shop called?

  • @zusiarosenthal4674
    @zusiarosenthal4674 11 дней назад

    more and more people are strating to realize that quality that costs money is cheaper in the long run with heavy use ie. walking on it all day

  • @nicolasartheau822
    @nicolasartheau822 23 часа назад

    Sécher au soleil n’est pas une bonne solution. Une cure humide de trois semaines à un mois serait préférable. La prise du mortier mortier de ciment lui donne sa résistance qui s’accroît avec le temps de prise même si cette montée en résistance est plus important en début de prise. Mais cette prise s’arrête dès que le mortier est sec, d’où l’importance du temps de cure . La cure peut prendre deux formes essentielles : Humide, par arrosage régulier suffisant ou sèche, en protégeant le mortier avec une paroi étanche . On peut également utiliser des additifs plastifiants qui amélioreront l’étanchéité des mortiers qui permettent aussi de raccourcir la cure par conservation plus longue de l’humidité à l’intérieur du mortier.
    Sinon, excellente et très intéressante vidéo sur le sujet ! Très complète ( petit manque sur la fabrication des moules et des modèles métalliques de moulage)

  • @xshotx2745
    @xshotx2745 11 дней назад +2

    Haven't watched the video but let me guess, it's handmade

  • @KP-nx8lo
    @KP-nx8lo 5 дней назад

    It’s because its touched by human hands that makes it worth the cost

  • @kzm-cb5mr
    @kzm-cb5mr 11 дней назад +1

    Similar to machuca tiles in the Philippines

  • @evolancer211
    @evolancer211 11 дней назад

    A half new, half old video. I guess that's better than an old video uploaded as new

  • @edtag
    @edtag 6 дней назад

    Que suerte que aun se fabrquen.

  • @Immortal0183
    @Immortal0183 11 дней назад +3

    LOVE FROM PUNE INDIA🇮🇳 😉😎😊😍🙂🥰

  • @Cecilioconc
    @Cecilioconc 10 дней назад

    What was the name of that company?

  • @salaarsikandarbakht3416
    @salaarsikandarbakht3416 11 дней назад

    Make a documentary on multani blue pottery

  • @byakuya4267
    @byakuya4267 11 дней назад

    I can't find the country's name in which this factory is filmed 😐 why isn't it mentioned in the description?

    • @WorldCitizenW
      @WorldCitizenW 10 дней назад +2

      In Morocco, artisans either works in Fez or Marrakesh.
      The endless in Cairo, Egypt. Those are Islamic geometric traditional designs. Every Moroccan city gates has these titles design. Designer Yves St Lauren was inspired by their art and he had a home in Morocco, which now a museum in Marrakesh.

  • @toddbellows5282
    @toddbellows5282 10 дней назад

    They use so little cement that the price should not be much of an issue.

  • @lazurusknight2724
    @lazurusknight2724 11 дней назад +2

    omg silicosis, silicosis everywhere. Someone get these people respirators stat

  • @bakerkawesa
    @bakerkawesa 11 дней назад

    Seems like an error-prone process. I'm amazed that they can make so many with few mistakes.

  • @masms8691
    @masms8691 11 дней назад

    morocco🤩

  • @Calum_S
    @Calum_S 11 дней назад

    I'm sure you posted this a couple of years ago

  • @user-cl9ew9jr2g
    @user-cl9ew9jr2g 2 дня назад +1

    директор без зубов показатель

  • @-joe90
    @-joe90 6 дней назад

    Hand made dor your !

  • @brianmckeever5280
    @brianmckeever5280 6 дней назад

    Interesting! I have the Lumix/Leica 8-18. I love it, but should use it more. Funny, I'm pretty sure I can see my condo complex in that wide-angle shot of Vegas looking north @ 04:35. Wonder how often that happens :-)

  • @BurtHagertonscovite
    @BurtHagertonscovite 11 дней назад

    i just wish my back would stop itching.

  • @ExcerionsForte
    @ExcerionsForte 11 дней назад +1

    Israel's war on Palestine has also contributed to expenses increasing given the increases in shipping and insurance in the Mid East region. Do not forget this omission.

    • @ecognitio9605
      @ecognitio9605 11 дней назад +1

      How lol? Gaza doesn't export anything and Israel doesn't make these tiles or cement in masse.

    • @ExcerionsForte
      @ExcerionsForte 11 дней назад +2

      @@ecognitio9605 Young padawan, you must learn to read before engaging. GPT can help you, go copy-paste and ask.

    • @ellenmorse8559
      @ellenmorse8559 6 дней назад

      Oh! Shut up!!! 👹

    • @ExcerionsForte
      @ExcerionsForte 6 дней назад

      @@ellenmorse8559 u first

  • @nd7908
    @nd7908 6 дней назад

    Come to india i can buy a tile under 10$ or lessthan that . !

  • @WorldCitizenW
    @WorldCitizenW 10 дней назад

    Every Moroccan city gates are decorated with these tiles, i love the blue or green color way. That so called interior designer 's terracotta version is ugly.

  • @ceciliascavo3484
    @ceciliascavo3484 11 дней назад

    Who's reaching that microwave???

  • @adrianaalara6724
    @adrianaalara6724 11 дней назад +3

    The designer tiles are just plain ugly.

  • @paulbounleuth8901
    @paulbounleuth8901 11 дней назад

    🎨💭

  • @chintanvankar1249
    @chintanvankar1249 3 дня назад

    👌👌👌👌

  • @puckpuck88
    @puckpuck88 6 дней назад

    Aaannnd the name or business link...? Shame on you BI. really. not that hard.

  • @user-uz6lg9vn9k
    @user-uz6lg9vn9k 10 дней назад

    Will be out of business within the next 2-5 years tops. So sad.

  • @devinekaren7
    @devinekaren7 11 дней назад +2

    4 days in a row of sun?? Is there such a place?

    • @catatonicbug7522
      @catatonicbug7522 11 дней назад +1

      Lots of them. Most of the SW USA.

    • @WorldCitizenW
      @WorldCitizenW 10 дней назад

      Morocco is on the Sahara

    • @devinekaren7
      @devinekaren7 10 дней назад

      @@catatonicbug7522 Ontario doesn't get many days of sunshine. Count ourselves lucky if we get 2 in a row

  • @themanwnoname3454
    @themanwnoname3454 11 дней назад

    2024(Gregorian) “Respect and dignity.” Furthermore:

  • @brycecombs2868
    @brycecombs2868 5 дней назад

    Very nice. If they would just abandon the nightmare totalitarian violent belief of Islum, they might have a real future.😞

  • @Jayshil_Mukhi
    @Jayshil_Mukhi 11 дней назад +1

    We still have cement tiles in our 60+year home.

  • @kirbyak47
    @kirbyak47 11 дней назад

    Sand is stolen like clouds 😂

  • @FernandoTorrera
    @FernandoTorrera 5 дней назад

    Just go to Mexico

  • @trezenx
    @trezenx 11 дней назад +2

    as a Ukrainian, thank you for calling the war for what it is. It's staggering how the whole is struggling in different ways because of one shitty nation

  • @wawaweewa9159
    @wawaweewa9159 9 дней назад

    They should target rich people , if i was a millionaire id buy from them

  • @luckyskivvy6077
    @luckyskivvy6077 11 дней назад

    Cement didn't get more expensive. The dollar got more sh💩ttier. Taking more dollars to buy the same tile.

  • @daniellokoski8204
    @daniellokoski8204 10 дней назад

    what a joke if you think this can be replaced with machine.

  • @auro1986
    @auro1986 11 дней назад

    why? your new 3d printers can print anything

  • @moonshinebling
    @moonshinebling 10 дней назад +1

    Dnt they wear masks?and gloves? M sure breathing in that cement is not good and having cement stuck in ur nails and eating after

  • @naeemgaffar3435
    @naeemgaffar3435 2 дня назад +1

    Free Palestine 🇵🇸

  • @moon3173
    @moon3173 11 дней назад +1

    it's expensive bc they have not automated the production....

    • @MouuStaa
      @MouuStaa 11 дней назад +2

      not everything needs to be automated, just like Japanese traditional pottery and swordsmaking, that's their real value and what makes them special from massively produced cheap industrial ceramics

    • @Centrioless
      @Centrioless 10 дней назад

      This 100%. Nobody really cares abt "handmade" quality when ppl need them in bulk.

    • @MouuStaa
      @MouuStaa 10 дней назад

      @@Centrioless well the massively growing demand and market disagrees buddy

    • @Centrioless
      @Centrioless 10 дней назад

      @@MouuStaa crazy if you think the demand for this is bigger over ceramic tiles that're fully automated and cheaper economically

    • @MouuStaa
      @MouuStaa 10 дней назад

      @Centrioless I never said it's bigger?? And bro why am I even arguing with someone who doesn't value traditional business and wants everything automated for some reason, quality over quantity is something certain people look for, yes industrial ceramics are good but these have their value in other aspects you clearly don't understand

  • @louisvanrijn3964
    @louisvanrijn3964 11 дней назад

    Print the desired design on very durable plastic film (back-printing). Attach it onto a white tile, while also going around the "corners" to avoid peeling. Problem solved.
    same appearance, more photo-versability to print very large pictures with many tiles.
    Forget old methods, the productivity was always low, not of this time.

  • @ecognitio9605
    @ecognitio9605 11 дней назад +1

    The process could easily be automated.

    • @user-bk2ig8bf6o
      @user-bk2ig8bf6o 11 дней назад +5

      And you could be easily educated, but alas

    • @freighter1097
      @freighter1097 10 дней назад

      So why haven't you automated it if its so easy?