The Rings of Power but it's actually Lord of the Rings
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 13 фев 2022
- After the new trailer of Amazon's "The Rings of Power", I decided to make my own one with actual footage of "The Lord of the Rings" from Peter Jackson!
Развлечения
![Moneybagg Yo - WHISKEY WHISKEY [feat. Morgan Wallen] (Official Audio)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kJamyq0WplE/mqdefault.jpg)
My opinion about the new trailer for Amazon's "The Rings of Power".
First of all, I did not experience that excitement feeling I had back then when I watched the trailer for "The Hobbit" in 2012. That's clearly a sign that something is missing. I did for sure enjoy some parts, since it actually looked like from a movie made by Peter Jackson. But on the other hand, it felt like Narnia or some other fantasy movie. The visuals are beautiful, actors are probably going to do a great job, despite some of their characters not fitting in some contexts.
Worst problem will be how they treat the plot and the story. I have heard that Galadriel will be a warrior, something she never was, or their attempt to tell different stories from different periods at the same time and in the same timeline, or something like that, which will be confusing.
Therefore, my advice is to just stop comparing it with lord of the rings or the world Tolkien created, and maybe then we will be able to enjoy this show, despite how difficult it could be to us to get use to it without constantly making conections with the movies or the books. At the same time I wouldn't like to despise the great job from part of the visual team, the actors or whoever.
(I ask people that comment to be respectful. You can give your opinion and give your discontent with the series, but always with respect, even towards the actors).
While I appreciate your request for our comments to be respectful, I feel like asking "why should we show respect?" Before it's release we're getting suggestions to stop comparing it to Lord of The Rings, or the world Tolkien created........what does THAT tell you about what this is going to be, if we have to ignore the actual work it's adapted from or purports to be? The only obvious inference is that it will bear little or no resemblance to the actual works of J R R Tolkien..........they've just bought the rights to the title in order to hoodwink the audience into thinking its going to be something it clearly isnt......The makers and writers of this impending garbage fest are not being respectful to either the original source material OR the genuine fans and lovers of the works of J R R Tolkien who have taken umbrage at the bastardisation of the greatest work of fiction ever written............Yes, I am sure it will look beautiful, as well it should, given the budget for it........but it's not Tolkien, is it? it's now just the plaything of a very rich man, who has more money than respect for Professor Tolkien, and it has been written by a couple of non-achieving hacks who in 13 years of collaboration have produced nothing of any consequence but who have the arrogance to consider they've written "the novel Tolkien never wrote".........damn right it's something Tolkien never wrote, he wouldnt have lent his name to this at the point of a gun..........
Yeah ... Peter Jackson work is way better. Even for the hobbit who was not as good as LOTR. In this trailer, you showed how much it was better.
The prime trailer looks cheap, costume looks like crap, actor looks like crap, cgi looks like crap, director's choice looks like crap, the story looks like crap. It is not working.
@@MichaelHill-we7vt I understand your point. I was mostly referring to the actors and other people that are working hard on this project but have no fault for the outcome.
@@MichaelHill-we7vt I just love people are assuming this show is going to be trash before its even out. Calling it a garbage fest is a bit over the top, since you havent seen an single episode of it yet. Trailers have been known to be misleading, but who knows. It might be trash. It might be not. But until the show is out, I refuse to judge it. I refuse to label it as either good or bad before ive seen an single episode of it for myself, and I encourage you to do the same.
Or, the Galadriel with her icepicks is a part of the prologue wich tells about the abonded Noldor surviving the Helcaraxë?
Although, I hope it is.
Crazy how the Lord Of The Rings films were made over 20 years ago, with a smaller budget than Amazon's offering, and yet still look better...
And it will be for another 20 years cause of remastered edition..
It is not crazy. When talented people work together with passion they can achieve great things. With a little bit of money they can achieve the extraordinary as well. When the first priority is to grow your numbers in the bank best you can achieve is a TV show with great CGI. I agree the bar was set high long ago but how Amazon is dealing with this is just ridiculous.
There are movies from the 1980s and 1940s that look a hundred times better. It's mostly about talent and passion, not so much about budget and technology.
I wonder why
You saw 60 seconds.
why did i get more goose bumps while watching this than the actual trailer lol
Because it has heart, soul and respect for the World that Tolkien created.
Because you know the characters and story. Since the show is brand new, you don't get emotional with an trailer.
@@guilhermemeyer5110 wrong, i have some emotions when i see a nice new Trailer, like the Hobbit Trailer back in 2012
SAME
@@RaveTonic Bilbo, Gandalf and others appear on that trailer...
HOLY SHIT.... 20 years later and I got GOOSEBUMPS with that footage
This looks way better! Thanks a lot for taking away 12 hours of my life because now I have no choice but to go watch all 3 extended edition movies again!
Me too!
Yess!!🔥🔥🔥🔥
just did the same
You know what would be great...if someone hosted an event for the movies the day the show is premiered
If that ain’t the truth 😂😂
When 20 year old footage looks 100000 times better than a 1 billion dollar project. Insanity.
Why does everything have to be some sort of "adaptation". I don't understand why they didn't use the same looks and feels as Peter Jackson did. Like the Elves being angelic and long hair.
True. The characters do not look as mysterious or otherworldly as in the trilogy. This is the same costume design flaw many TV shows make, they make them appear too modern. It doesn't have that fantastical feeling of the trilogy.
@@somekindofflower2024 That's the whole point with Tolkien's Elves. They're *meant* to look otherwordly and ethereal. Not just because its fantasy, but because that's more akin to how Tolkien envisioned them. Amazon seem to think they're just humans with pointy ears.
@@englishlady9797 I just don't know where they find the audacity to change anything because they don't like it or think they can do it better? Sure, I also had those thoughts that I can change some things in a book for the better that some writers, but it's not my work, it's not my vision and it's not my right. What makes them think they are allowed do it? There are parts were they can work and do it better, but there are always parts that just cannot be touched.
It's all about political correctness.. it's more important to have a black Elf or a black dwarf
Looking at CGI in cinema, I've got a feeling that LOTR was created at EXACTLY the right time. Early enough to create massive battlefields and realistic monsters, but not within the era of over-used CGI like we saw in the Hobbit.
2000's were a magical time, like the 80's with animatronics or the 60's with stop motion. When the technology began, it was used in innovative ways, now its easy to achieve but they are lazy with it.
@@ShadowDragon-cw7wb Exactly.
Exactly! They still used actual actors with costume and make up for the orcs and their cockney accent making it far more realistic. The hobbit was just CGI but I know for a fact it’s better than the Amazon series.
My expectations for the new show are rock bottom.
and you'll still be disappointed 🙂
True lol. #NotMyLOTR
@@Gryffster #NotMyLOTR
Now this is Middle-earth !
Tolkien needs NO extra characters or stories.
Middle Earth already has plenty to explore.
It's from your America that there are tendencies to ensure that there are necessarily gays and African Americans;) so thanks to your idiots))) we, in Russia, have even more or less adequate people left 😅
@@user-qj3mv6ih5b
You live on a failed state ruins of Soviet...
Stop bragging about something that you don't have, Russia is barely comparable to Texas lol.
@@user-qj3mv6ih5b I try to differentiate Russia's crazy politicians from the populace, until I see it like this. Impossible not to think they are the same strain. I hope I'm wrong.
@@ROGIO53 one more... girl (are you a girl?), it's not our bad policy, it's the West that is forcing us to take tough retaliatory measures. when you invaded Iraq or Afghanistan, which, for example, is extremely far from the United States, on another continent, we were silent. And when we clean up the Nazis in our historical territory since the 17th century, the same Nazis that were in the Third Reich, you immediately shout and show us something.Stop the policy of double standards, understand that in addition to your interests, there are interests of other countries or alliances, and then, perhaps, we will become great friends.
@@user-qj3mv6ih5b There is that too, but it is the very way in which the government deals with its own population.
Got goosebumps watching this. Felt only ambivalence and mild annoyance to the Rings of Power trailer.
The Rings of Power trailer was so boring I couldn’t even muster up enough emotion to feel annoyed by it.
I felt nothing watching that
Amazon has nothing on your skills, my Lord!
The trilogy had a timeless imagery. Absolutely beautiful.
Excellent work Max! 10/10 would watch it again.
Thanks buddy! 😀
Lets give this more views than the original trailer until amazon files a complaint for copyright.
“Before the king” and “before the ring” don’t really make sense anymore, but other than that I love this. Man LOTR has such good cinematography…
It feels like they are setting up the hobbit, because what else came before king & fellowship?. Other than the silmarillian of course...
"Before the king" never made sense, there were loads of kings in the second age.
it ddidnt make sense in the original trailer either... at least the one with the king (spoiler alert: aragorn is not the only king in the history of middle earth)
In the original trailer I was expecting the "before the two towers" 🙄.. at least they didn't put it
Man, I really wanna go watch LOTR now.
go ahead
Dew it.
The fact that this man probably went through 9 hours of footage finding the right things for the right places, and making this actually look real, is awesome! Love the dedication!
The rings of power looks too HD, they should of gone for the saturation/gradient effects that was used in Lord of the Rings to give the same feel, instead we're looking at Galadriel like she's straight up from the Polar Express. Good work with the video, I'm now watching the entire trilogy again. :)
god this gave me chills! one thing for sure, the music is on point
This has me more hyped for Tolkiens work than the amazon series. Well done!
Oh just uploaded my version of it ^^
This is great ! Love the ending when Frodo garbs Sam arm.. Fits perfectly ! Wish I could have thought of that when I was editing mine x)
I'd literally watched this movie over 20 times and this trailer still had me excited.
Du machst jetzt einfach die neue Herr der Ringe Serie🤩😁👍
Geniale Idee!
Argh, this was so great I have to spend the rest of the day re-watching Lotr, thanks guy.
Something about the whole construction of the Rings of power trailer was just, off... It felt more like Star Wars or Marvel than LOTR. Or like generic fantasy, but maybe they forgot that a lot of us don't just like generic fantasy: We love Tolkien, and Middle Earth, because everything, the history, the language, the culture the geography the wars and legends, are all so full and well crafted. This Amazon show just has me worried.
Something about the black elf just is soo off, in his picture if he was holding a light saber instead of a bow i think it would make way more sense
@@punkrocker6431 The black Elf doesn't even bother me that much, as long as he makes sense, like if he comes from a southern region or something, but the trailer just had so much cringe. The narration sounded straight out of Disney, Galadriel being a wild warrior does not fit her character as written in the least, and the thought that they will be rewriting all my favorite Elves (Celebrimbor, Elrond, Gilgalad, Glorfindel) along with their condensing the timeline, has just made me lose all faith in these writers. I wish there was some studio with the necessary resources committed to a faithful adaptation of Middle Earth.
I did chuckle when some Amazon exec, thought they were being clever by giving the different races different accents and slightly different patterns of speech.
You're referring to the works of the man who invented two langauges just for Elves, my good man.That's not couning the Dwarven langauges, and the human languages. Its already been done. Better.
@@mastinbarry8749 I dread what they're going to do to my boys Celebrimbor and Glorfindel. I get protective of Celebrimbor. Leave him alone you salicious, avaricious blighters. Go and pillage some other fantasy universe. They have messed with the wrong fandom, I fear.
THIS is what I call an EPIC trailer
I know next to nothing about LoTR as I haven't seen any of the movies or read the books, but how the hell does the movie that came out decades ago look significantly better than the tv show coming out this year?! This looks so beautiful and it gave me chills but the trailer for the show just made me cringe. How could Amazon, with the shitload of money/resources they have, make their version look so cheap? How are they not embarrassed?
And now go watch the movies. Or better yet- read the books :-) happy reading!
Dude, treat yourself with the extended edition. You won't regret it.
Watch the old movies (extended versions preferably) and if you're interested in HOW they were created watch the appendices on YT - you ll be blown away (no cgi compares)
They hired people with passion and master craftsmanship. Many of the locations are real miniatures crafted to tiny details with camera tricks and minor supplemental CGI to achieve photorealism. They weren't obsessed with virtue signalling and political sensibilities and instead wanted to make a good movie(s) that was honest to Tolkien's vision. It is a timeless story about defeating the evil. Rings of Power is taking Tolkien's world and perverting it with modern politics. It is no longer his work, it's just a brand owned by Amazon. They even fired Tolkien expert and then did an IGN piece with another guy to lie about the authenticity of Rings of Power.
this actually restored my faith in humanity after watching the rings of power trailer
You have my sword.
and My Bow
and my axe
Now this is a trailer!!!!!! Beautiful work maxe!!!! 💯😍❤️
Thank you very much!
THIS IS INCREDIBLE DAMN IT ❤️👏😭
Loved this edit of it. Saw the original Amazon version and was bored; it felt like “Generic fantasy story #3012”, not Middle Earth/Arda.
Just because LOTR made fantasy popular doesn't mean it isn't also generic lol
@@nordbard5027
LOTR is not generic. Generic fantasy has action at the centre of it, whereas LOTR is deliberately opposed to solving problems with the use of violence. That’s the whole point of the Battle of The Black Gate and the story of Turin.
@@killgriffinnow Please stop deluding yourself I love LOTR but saying it's not generic is just plain wrong. Just because it came before a lot of material doesn't mean it's not generic.
@The Outlaw And why is it a soulless husk?
DUDE, what an amazing trailer is this?!!! you did a masterpiece
SEE AMAZON, that's WHAT WE WANTED!
This teaser that you made made me feel good. I didn't feel anything when I watched the Amazon's teaser. I wished felt the same feeling when I watched the Amazon's teaser. Good job btw.
And now I will be on a LoTRs marathon again, great work Max Justh!
When a work from 20 years ago still give you goosebumps. :D
Wow, just wow. The contrast is STARTLING. I hope this video and others like this are viewed by every fan and casual alike.
"There is still some good in this world, Mr. Frodo, and it's worth fighting for." - Samwise Gamgee
You have a microscopic fraction of the budget Amazon sunk on to That 5 season disaster and yet you manage to make me hyped for a, edit which won't have any further elaboration and I love it
I mean, this was good but making a trailer out of already-beloved award-winning films is always going to be easier than making a trailer out of brand new footage while being very restricted in what you can and can't show.
Instant goosebumps! wel done. Didnt feel anything with the original ROP trailer
Give this Man a Medal
THERE'S WONDERS IN THIS WORLD, MR FRODO
Chills all over again,, even after 20 Years.. no movie can do this.
That’s how you make a teaser trailer. Music is just spot on. Feeling, showing environment, editing etc. You’ve literally showed how to tell a story my friend and you did that with same teaser music which Amazon used in theirs. Big applause… 🙌🏽
That helm's deep part is just perfect 10/10
AHHHHH this is beautiful! With the hand grasp at the end and everything.
Getting goosebumps from a trilogy ive watched like 100 times.
man... this was a great trailer. I would LOVE to watch those movies. Thankfully I own them on bluray to watch whenever I want :D I doubt anyone is going to want to buy Rings of Power on physical disk let alone pay to watch it.
Like others have said, I got chills watching this. All the excitement and joy and nostalgia came back and oh man I loved it!
That really looks like something to expect greatness from. It's been a long time I've felt this way. Cinema/TV bussiness can't even create a great teaser anymore.
Now that’s a trailer!
so many memories in that 1 minute
"What orders from Mordor my lord?
What does the eye command?"
"We have *woke* to do."
Bro why did I get chills? I’ve seen this movie a million times!😂🤣
Now I'm excited to watch a film I've watched dozens of times now
Amazing edits! I felt nostalgia and excitement watching this. Time to watch LOTR movies again! :D
Glad to see that there are ppl out there who understand what TLOR is about.
Imo the Cast of the Series dont fit... I dont want to sound racist but why would you cast a black actor as an Elf... in Lore Elves are Blond/Brown haired with Pale Skin and and Hairs (Exept for Elrond which IS blond in the series for some reason and looks more like young Legolas, but thats whats makes him special as an half elf half human) so imo its kind of disrespectfull against Tolkien and what he created its more of quatioa think to include that.
And now before you say im racist or sexist and anything like that hear me out. You remember the Haradrim leader in TLOR Pt. 3 Return of the King. Lets just imagine Huge Weaving never played Elrond but played him... would that sound funny to you? If it does you already got my point.
A Actor shouldnt be devided in Skincolor or Sex but the (in-Movie) Character defenetly should.
And the fact Durin the 4th and Gil Galad look spot on in the Trailer and the Pictures show that Amazon IS indeed pretty much aware of what the Characters should look like and that they only try to fill the Quotia of black/female actors so that the Series is attractive to the wide audience instead of making the series satisfy the real TLOR fans. I was so hyped when i heard that there is a Series about one of my favourite movie franchise coming, with such a big budget even, but now, im no longer so sure. I just hope the Story is great so that i can oversee the weird cast.
Also please excuse my horrible English lol. Im from Germany haha...
Wokeness destroys everything
And the costumes and makeup are just bad. It's like YA fantasy TV show
@@somekindofflower2024 lets not forget the cgi. The chi in the original movie was way better
Now THIS I can get behind. Sent chills. Also, mostly ALL practical effects
looks so much better!
Now THAT looks like Tolkien’s Lord Of The Rings. Well done!
That made me emotional not going to lie 😂
YES
nice.
This is so good. It proves to me that it isn't the music that's bad it just the generic visuals.
watched this 5 times already. It's awesome man! Way better than amazon's.
Great work dude, great work 👏
What a beautiful, lovely, awesome trilogy!
the fact that this works because the composer is Howard Shore and the footage is Peter Jackson's Middle Earth instead of Amazon's just tells you that even though it doesn't entirely make sense it still evokes 10x more feelings than the other.
This looks and feels so fucking good.
Very Very Very amazing and emotionally. You are great man
This does look so much better.
'Middle Earth has no extra characters. Middle Earth needs no extra characters.'
This is soooo much better than the Amazon's, goosebumps all over.
EYYYY These fan Trailers give me goosebumps! while the actual trailer gives me grief!
This trailer makes me more anticipated to watch the trilogy all over again, then to watch the Amazon series.
My eyes have been cleansed! Thank you!
just 1 second of this made it superior
This is absolutely awesome. I'd have waited for the hand to come alive and grab frodos hand before the cut. You should make trailers for a living top notch.
Yeah I would have liked to put the crab but it was too long and didn't fit the cut (If you know what I mean) but I appreciate to see more people with similar ideas 😀👍🏻
@@MaxJusth hey its no criticism Its absolutely awesome I was just expecting the grab ha. Makes me laugh how a person on RUclips with some talent and a computer can do what 1 billion amazon dollars can't. 👏👏
@@jamst123 I know bro, don't worry, even if it was, any criticism is welcome here 😉
Thank you again!
@@MaxJusth keep on making more 👍 wishing you endless channel growth 🙏
This is so much better in every way !
That's what I'm talking about. Such extraodinary films!
This is incredible!
MASTERPIECE
This shows that the music in the trailer wasn’t bad.
that is a movie i would want to watch
perfection at last
Damn... This made me wanna rewatch Peter Jackson's LOTR
I had chills, literal chills! And I think that says it all.
My reaction when seeing the amazon trailer: 0:34
I got chills omg
Thank you.. Wow this felt so much better 👏👏😯
This is amazing!!!
This is called art man
It’s almost scary how much better this looks than the new trailer. Like holy fuck
"Das Böse ist nicht in der Lage, etwas Neues zu schaffen, es kann nur entstellen und zerstören, was von den Kräften des Guten erfunden oder geschaffen wurde." - J.R.R Tolkien
WOW! It fits perfectly!
Woaaaahh thats amazing!!! Thats Middle Earth feeling! A Trailer like this one would made a lot of Tolkien Fans excited and happy and not so many concerned...
im excited to re watch lord of the rings after watching this
Wow... I would watch this show. Great job!
Goosebumps.