Forest City has been gazetted as a Special Economic Zone (SEZ) with Singapore, and there is a high chance High Speed Rail project between Kuala Lumpur and Singapore will be revived, with one of its key stops in none other than the Forest City linking this city directly to Singapore. This is not a failed project, please read up before making assumptions like many others before you!
You're just another idiot coming over and making false statements. Don't be jealous when you don't effort it, don't tell me Pakistan is better than Malaysia.
It might look like a ghost city but it has population living in it. My brother and his wife lives there with their children. As an introvert it really is a heaven for me. Forest city is actually a holiday destination for Malaysians especially to play golf and water activities. Maybe you are there during weekdays when most people are working. that’s why it is quiet. You also interviewed the staffs who are mostly local Malay young men. I guess this development does provide job opportunities for the local people.
I find it very annoying that these small time UK European or US RUclipsrs descend on Forest city and make a "ghost city" video about it, just cuz some famous RUclipsr or two did it before them. I'm glad you gave more Justice to the subject.. you interviewed the residents, workers, etc. At least you tried.
He didn't. He basically asked him a few shallow questions and then walked away saying they were lying when they gave answers that don't fit his ghost city story.
Singapore is so expensive, they should allow for a certain percentage of Singaporean workers to live here. The rest should really be Malaysians. They should figure out an ideal price for the condos, that is affordable by local middle class Malaysians.
'Nasty coffee '😂....btw I think you should notice by now the color of the water bottle indicates the source of water ie underground/natural/processed tap water etc
@@Arnold_X3the apartments are all sold out. They are already sold to the Chinese. The issue is the apartments have no resale value now that the area is a ghost town so they can't be sold as investment properties. And the prices of the apartments are way more expensive than is reasonable for the locals if they are buying for their own use.
Nice place, I like the view of development and its building and greenery and sea view and its best . If I had money I like to stay there. If this place was fully developed as planned on the proposed model it would be the best attraction in Malaysia.
It has an occupancy rate of less than 3% following recent stats. Skyscrapers are designed to accommodate dense populations. Might change if they work on the restrictions but for now when you factor an occupancy rate of 6000 in city that was designed to hold close to 1 million people, shops boarded up, many unfinished places/ places already breaking down after 8 years. And especially when you consider the resale price of the properties have dropped in average by 40%, It's pretty safe to call this a failure ;)
Forest City ghost beach ⛱️ same as my beach at North Queensland Australia every day only myself swimming at Alva Beach Burdekin north Queensland lots of people live here but they are not beach lovers sometimes I see couple of people fishing others walking dogs but no one swimming or sunbaking I'm thinking of visiting Ghost Forest City, by the way it's very informative video thanks
I would love it there…. It’s a young family’s paradise quiet beaches to ourselves…. I think you have a pessimist view of the place…. Glass is always half full 🥛
@@audreygiamlayhoon Not really as more Singaporeans are moving over, as home prices in SG are way too expensive now. Retirees and mobile workers are moving over.
@neonboy99 Retirees , perhaps, though they are actually rich . But with a capacity of 700,000 , Forest City cannot depend on Singaporean retirees to stop it from being a Ghost City.
Forest City" in Malaysia is considered a failure due to its status as a largely deserted "ghost town," with very few residents despite ambitious plans for a large, new city, primarily attributed to overreliance on Chinese buyers, strict travel restrictions during the COVID-19 pandemic, and concerns about obtaining visas to live there, leaving the development largely empty and struggling financially; the developer, Country Garden, is now facing significant debt issues related to the project. Key points about Forest City's failure: Low Occupancy: Despite being built on reclaimed land with a vision for a large population, the city has very few residents, leading to deserted streets and empty buildings. Chinese Buyer Dependence: The project heavily marketed itself towards Chinese investors, but restrictions on capital outflow from China significantly hampered sales. COVID-19 Impact: Travel restrictions imposed during the pandemic further reduced buyer interest and hampered development progress. Visa Concerns: Uncertainty regarding visa policies for foreign residents in Forest City discouraged potential inhabitants. Developer Debt: The struggling Chinese developer, Country Garden, is facing significant financial pressure due to the lack of sales at Forest City.
I am wondering how were/are they going to survive there for all those shops, hotel and outlets there. I guess they were given with low rental to setup shops/store/outlets there
Not sure what did u expect the staffs to tell you about the crowd and occupancy rate in here. Especially the hotel staff, if he told you the truth, you would cause him to be fired. As for retailer, your video taking would cause him to be fired too. Doing your video blog is OK but ruining others is a BIG no.
Capitalists all over the world chasing after profitable projects of all sorts. This is fine when the economy is doing well and the buying demand also high, because the cash（ in all manners) keep coming in to fund the project. When the economy turn south, incoming cash flow in short and the project becoming unsustainable.
@jon8697 he is a Pakistani born in America and therefore am American citizen. Just like Malaysian born come to Singapore and become Singapore citizen..aiyoh
The surrounding area is quiet, pleasant and made attractive with a beach nearby, but the buildings are hideous. Massive, ugly, tall buildings filling up space for miles with the repetitive identical, boring architecture. Except for the greenary and beach, there is a zero sense of aesthetics in this sad place.
You don't really find many beautiful quite city like this with all the things you need.....so this is good for people who want to live in quite beautiful modern city,, that's unique
Malay is Malaysian, Malay people say we are only real Malaysian and other people not Malaysian, they say, Malay is Native people of Malaysia, but actually I don't know reality, who is real native Malaysian,
Foreigners only can buy residential units above RM 1mil; which means the majority of buyers are Malaysian. Now at the JB city the condominiums are selling more than RM1k per sqft, but still selling fast. Most of the buyers is still local people. JB newly built factory and commercial unit mostly above 1mil to 10mil, also bought by the local.
I like seeing RUclipsrs blabbering and assuming the things they are see without understanding the real reason why things are they are especially Americans , coming a first world economic country.they don’t know’ commonly comes out of their comfort zone and always think American is correct like getting involved in other people war, they have won any tu big since ww2……..so assume?btw Pakistani is a more humble people actullay and have strong faith in Islan. This one??? I don’t know ..for the sake of content he does anything
@romyhamid1888 just shush! Facts don't lie. This is why Malaysians are still living in the past of your mindset. Grow up and enjoy your political people who eat your money; stop blabbering here, moron.
Facts don't lie. This is why Malaysians are still living in the past of your mindset. Grow up and enjoy your political people who eat your money; stop blabbering here, moron.
It's like something out of George Orwell's 1984 when the workers there say "it is so busy" when the reality is the complete opposite 😂😂 Maybe, though it does get busier at week-ends when Singaporeans cross the strait to visit, but really there is nothing to see or do there ! 😂😂
Mr. Myer:Congratulations to you for arriving safety in this amazing Ghost city, Malaysia this weekend in great joy & peace to tours some great places this weekend in joy 2024❤❤❤
Myer, read/watch the whole documentary of the forest city before you continue further. Come back when the project jumps start again. This project will not be abandoned.
Some corrupted google staff ( bias with muslim) use shadow ban tracking my words comment. Vs against free speech vs truth !!!!?????😮🦧👿😱🪭 Now deleted please👿
' Ghost City ' of america | A Century of Poverty ⛺• Ep 42 | Los Angeles, California [4K] | | California’s New Law in Effect? ⛺ • Ep 39 | Los Angeles, California [4K] | - youtube
The King of Malaysia, Sultan Ibrahim Ismail of Johor wants a High-Speed Rail (HSR) station in Forest City for the KL-Singapore route. He thinks it would make the area more attractive and easier to get to.
drove here after SIN_MALAYSIA after covid 19 border re_ opening.Had a coffee break at the hotel lounge.Oppo is Singapore northern Senoko power station and Woodlands.The revelant China developer Country Garden is having financial issues now
There is no such thing as fail for China bro. These lands are probably owned by them now and this place I can see that will be so populated in the near future
many you tubers and media have done videos about this.... from what i have read and analysed, china property developers and government often overly exaggerates their projects to mislead, hoodwink people plus generate extra interests and media reportings.... e.g. their will boast the plan / scale and money involved for phase 5 or 7 but actually only have money and real plan to build up to phase 1 to 3 ... the extra phase or expansion plans are merely for propaganda and hype and to trick buyers about the scale and connectivity .... never trust the Commie CHina chinese and companies.
The project collapsed because of government policy. Suddenly they want to curb Chinese people buying and end up, no one else can absorb such mega development, hence her collapse. The Malaysian government simply liked to flip flop on their policies and that's why even though the properties are not expensive, not many swarmed in.
Like the high speed rail project with Singapore. They just pulled out of the project after the Singaporean government made significant investments into the project. The Singaporean government had already bought out a country club to develop it into a train depot. The Malaysian government had to compensate a huge amount to the Singaporean government. There were disagreements to the tender process of the hsr construction in the Malaysian part. Singapore wanted both parties to be privy to the tender and appointment of the contractors while Malaysia wanted autonomy in appointing contractors. That’s what happens if you have a corrupted government.
@@TheManabopohaha significant investment? Singapore was going to build less than 4.5% of the alignment plus don't they need the land for something far more important
Mr. Myer:Welcome to the Ghost City, Malaysia to shows those amazing places in Southeast Asia this weekend in October of 2024❤❤❤❤Thanks you so much for this great video 2024❤❤❤
180 guests in the whole place. People will be pretty spread out too. But if it is just people looking to get away from it all that will go there,, it's going to be a lot of depressed people gathering in the place.
Mr. Myer:Welcome to this amazing beautiful Ghost city, Malaysia this weekend in great joy after spending weeks in Singapore city, Singapore before heading to this amazing Ghost City, Malaysia in peace 2024❤❤❤
Hi bro most malaysian work in singapore definitely they can afford 200k condominium or landed property goven singapore currency to msian ringgit is times 3. Every 100 sgd = 300RM. So they cn afford a bike car n housing in johor bahru. In singapore u have to work hard for housing n car. Car is abt 200k cos theres certificate of entitlment u could use ur car only for 10 yrs & need to renew it costs 100k ++.msians get to keep their bike n cars for many yrs though.
Just give incentives to locals and the rest will follow. Lose some n win big🎉🎉 I really loved the environment especially the beach alongside golf course. Love to visit someday n much much cheaper than hk.
From what I've seen and heard, the Forest City will be alright, many people already booked the houses recently especially foreigners from China, Singapore etc and some locals.. I believe that one day after fully constructions redeveloping and etc done by the Malaysian government especially the Johor Royal government who owns partially of the projects/the Forest City and also the said Korean investors that are keen to join to continue in the development of the Forest City, somehow there will be a demand for housing area there as it is nearby to new link bridge to and from SG and MY; and many Singaporeans are looking for new places out of the SG island to move to nearby relocations..
This project will be the next big thing soon. It failed before but Johore gov will revive it with a lot of tax incentives to draw the rich to park their $$$ there.
Chinese and Singaporeans are not prohibited from buying overseas properties. In fact, Chinese have been buying many properties in Singapore. And Singaporeans have been buying properties in the UK, Australia, New Zealand. There is no reason to buy into Forest City. Why? It is because it is just not a global real estate investment prospect. And after a decade of being a non starter, Forest City has the burden of being a good investment story. That's just my point of view.
Thank you for your continued support, Don't forget to hit the SUBSCRIBE and THUMBS UP!!
Forest City has been gazetted as a Special Economic Zone (SEZ) with Singapore, and there is a high chance High Speed Rail project between Kuala Lumpur and Singapore will be revived, with one of its key stops in none other than the Forest City linking this city directly to Singapore. This is not a failed project, please read up before making assumptions like many others before you!
You're just another idiot coming over and making false statements. Don't be jealous when you don't effort it, don't tell me Pakistan is better than Malaysia.
can you visit and vlog yakutsk Russia in the sakha republic?
It's beautiful and peaceful. I prefer places like this. 😊♥️
I think you went there with a pre-built image about that place that you couldn't change no matter what you saw or heard
Having seen and heard, he has reflected the reality
Back in early 80s, Subang Jaya was considered as a failed project.
True things can always change
It might look like a ghost city but it has population living in it. My brother and his wife lives there with their children. As an introvert it really is a heaven for me. Forest city is actually a holiday destination for Malaysians especially to play golf and water activities. Maybe you are there during weekdays when most people are working. that’s why it is quiet. You also interviewed the staffs who are mostly local Malay young men. I guess this development does provide job opportunities for the local people.
7000 people live in a Ghost Town. This Ghostly place has a capacity for 700,000 people
@@audreygiamlayhoon maybe in a few years, it will reach 700,000 people
I find it very annoying that these small time UK European or US RUclipsrs descend on Forest city and make a "ghost city" video about it, just cuz some famous RUclipsr or two did it before them. I'm glad you gave more Justice to the subject.. you interviewed the residents, workers, etc. At least you tried.
He didn't. He basically asked him a few shallow questions and then walked away saying they were lying when they gave answers that don't fit his ghost city story.
He is a pakistani where there is too overcrowding
@@nomorenews He's been living in America forever lol did you notice any heavy accent? Jeez these basement generalists
@@Arnold_X3 dude he visits Pakistan all the time and family is in Pakistan.usa accent anyone can acquire without even stepping in usa.Get some edu
Singapore is so expensive, they should allow for a certain percentage of Singaporean workers to live here. The rest should really be Malaysians. They should figure out an ideal price for the condos, that is affordable by local middle class Malaysians.
Cuz what is the point of maintaining thousands of apartments, if they don't sell?
Public housing in Singapore look better and are more well maintained than this. Not to mention, also cheaper.
Who is "they"?
'Nasty coffee '😂....btw I think you should notice by now the color of the water bottle indicates the source of water ie underground/natural/processed tap water etc
@@Arnold_X3the apartments are all sold out. They are already sold to the Chinese. The issue is the apartments have no resale value now that the area is a ghost town so they can't be sold as investment properties. And the prices of the apartments are way more expensive than is reasonable for the locals if they are buying for their own use.
It's a damn shame. All of that living space would be hugely welcomed in unaffordable cities like NYC, London or Toronto.
It’s not a ghost city. Even ghosts aren’t relocating themselves there 😂
It's not a ghost city, it's a expensive ghost town. Ghosts are hiding behind the greenery.😂
Nice place, I like the view of development and its building and greenery and sea view and its best . If I had money I like to stay there.
If this place was fully developed as planned on the proposed model it would be the best attraction in Malaysia.
It did not fail. Only less populated
It has an occupancy rate of less than 3% following recent stats. Skyscrapers are designed to accommodate dense populations.
Might change if they work on the restrictions but for now when you factor an occupancy rate of 6000 in city that was designed to hold close to 1 million people, shops boarded up, many unfinished places/ places already breaking down after 8 years. And especially when you consider the resale price of the properties have dropped in average by 40%, It's pretty safe to call this a failure ;)
man you people are in extreme denial lol
@@JesseHMRhow much these condos cost?
Forest City ghost beach ⛱️ same as my beach at North Queensland Australia every day only myself swimming at Alva Beach Burdekin north Queensland lots of people live here but they are not beach lovers sometimes I see couple of people fishing others walking dogs but no one swimming or sunbaking I'm thinking of visiting Ghost Forest City, by the way it's very informative video thanks
Nice perspective. Thank you
My pleasure!
@@myertravels It was a pleasure for me too.
I would love it there…. It’s a young family’s paradise quiet beaches to ourselves…. I think you have a pessimist view of the place…. Glass is always half full 🥛
You are right!
Nice quiet city, next year we will live there 🎉
The Forest City was built hastily on reclaimed land. Part of the road just collapsed recently. ☠️
Careful, You might get Canceled… 😊
Nice Well maintained.
GHOST CITY?
This Ghost City may come to life soon, as it may become a Special Economic Zone.
Ghost SEZ
@@audreygiamlayhoon Not really as more Singaporeans are moving over, as home prices in SG are way too expensive now. Retirees and mobile workers are moving over.
@neonboy99
Retirees , perhaps, though they are actually rich . But with a capacity of 700,000 , Forest City cannot depend on Singaporean retirees to stop it from being a Ghost City.
I saw a lot of people in your video, all those people are ghosts?
i dont know. Video was filmed during the seventh month.
No they were actual humans. Ghost city or ghost town is a hyperbole used to describe empty and isolated places.
Their English is so poor that they can’t understand what 'ghost city' means. Hahaha! please learn how to speak english malaysian
Like u say, its beautiful and looks very clean too but just too empty.
Fewer ppl can mean peaceful and relax place too. But! This is just over quiet.
It's gonna be crowd after this because of financial special zone
Forest City" in Malaysia is considered a failure due to its status as a largely deserted "ghost town," with very few residents despite ambitious plans for a large, new city, primarily attributed to overreliance on Chinese buyers, strict travel restrictions during the COVID-19 pandemic, and concerns about obtaining visas to live there, leaving the development largely empty and struggling financially; the developer, Country Garden, is now facing significant debt issues related to the project.
Key points about Forest City's failure:
Low Occupancy:
Despite being built on reclaimed land with a vision for a large population, the city has very few residents, leading to deserted streets and empty buildings.
Chinese Buyer Dependence:
The project heavily marketed itself towards Chinese investors, but restrictions on capital outflow from China significantly hampered sales.
COVID-19 Impact:
Travel restrictions imposed during the pandemic further reduced buyer interest and hampered development progress.
Visa Concerns:
Uncertainty regarding visa policies for foreign residents in Forest City discouraged potential inhabitants.
Developer Debt:
The struggling Chinese developer, Country Garden, is facing significant financial pressure due to the lack of sales at Forest City.
Thanks for the detailed explanation!
I am wondering how were/are they going to survive there for all those shops, hotel and outlets there. I guess they were given with low rental to setup shops/store/outlets there
yes, stairs way to heaven,go check &johore Temple then u know. . How can he got a coffee on the house????
salam bro, oiishii corner singapore........off the record bro......"Welcome To Twillight Zone"........Land Of the Unknown
I'm 2nd 🎉🎉🎉🎉
Thanks for watching!
Idk. When I look at that place, it still does hold some potential. It just needs a little something to entice everyone in.
good video.
Not sure what did u expect the staffs to tell you about the crowd and occupancy rate in here. Especially the hotel staff, if he told you the truth, you would cause him to be fired. As for retailer, your video taking would cause him to be fired too. Doing your video blog is OK but ruining others is a BIG no.
I think, however, the workers that he interviewed did try their best to "follow the script" and say "how busy the place is." ! 😂
Capitalists all over the world chasing after profitable projects of all sorts. This is fine when the economy is doing well and the buying demand also high, because the cash（ in all manners) keep coming in to fund the project.
When the economy turn south, incoming cash flow in short and the project becoming unsustainable.
How about do homeless video in the US. Heard a lot of story about them. Is it true?
People often think speak English = from US? in the same video he mentioned he was from Pakistan
He's an American ex-real estate real estate agent haven't you seen his past videos. Educate yourself before commenting!
Mamak American 😂 Mcm pandai... This smarty pants should vlog about his country millions where homeless.
@jon8697 he is a Pakistani born in America and therefore am American citizen. Just like Malaysian born come to Singapore and become Singapore citizen..aiyoh
@@TheStudio-divhe Is born n America and therefore is a citizen. His ethnicity is Pakistani
In Asia you are to ask people for their consent before filming them! are they comfortable to be featured?
It's seem likes a slow profit project despite a FAILED project
I like Forest City lol of privacy and free of criminals ❤
Similar to PIK and BSD in Jakarta but this has less population!
The surrounding area is quiet, pleasant and made attractive with a beach nearby, but the buildings are hideous. Massive, ugly, tall buildings filling up space for miles with the repetitive identical, boring architecture. Except for the greenary and beach, there is a zero sense of aesthetics in this sad place.
You don't really find many beautiful quite city like this with all the things you need.....so this is good for people who want to live in quite beautiful modern city,, that's unique
Yes it’s great for an introvert
unsustainable
Why Malaysians (Malays, Chinese, Indians) do not buy in those buildings? Im looking for an answer from a Malaysian
Far from town or airport, far from work, hella expensive
Malay is Malaysian, Malay people say we are only real Malaysian and other people not Malaysian, they say, Malay is Native people of Malaysia, but actually I don't know reality, who is real native Malaysian,
Foreigners only can buy residential units above RM 1mil; which means the majority of buyers are Malaysian. Now at the JB city the condominiums are selling more than RM1k per sqft, but still selling fast. Most of the buyers is still local people. JB newly built factory and commercial unit mostly above 1mil to 10mil, also bought by the local.
@@henrybutcher9436 not really, Foreigner can buy RM500k for high rise (special term and condition) in Johor.
Drop the price..big chance local buy it
the housing is too expensive for locals so
I like seeing RUclipsrs blabbering and assuming the things they are see without understanding the real reason why things are they are especially Americans , coming a first world economic country.they don’t know’ commonly comes out of their comfort zone and always think American is correct like getting involved in other people war, they have won any tu big since ww2……..so assume?btw Pakistani is a more humble people actullay and have strong faith in Islan. This one??? I don’t know ..for the sake of content he does anything
Glad you enjoy it!
@@myertravels I love hearing your American assumptions coming from a 1st world country 😁
lol you sound like a little B that likes to complain alot over trivial things. what a self entitled small little man.
@romyhamid1888 just shush! Facts don't lie. This is why Malaysians are still living in the past of your mindset. Grow up and enjoy your political people who eat your money; stop blabbering here, moron.
Facts don't lie. This is why Malaysians are still living in the past of your mindset. Grow up and enjoy your political people who eat your money; stop blabbering here, moron.
It's like something out of George Orwell's 1984 when the workers there say "it is so busy" when the reality is the complete opposite 😂😂 Maybe, though it does get busier at week-ends when Singaporeans cross the strait to visit, but really there is nothing to see or do there ! 😂😂
The beautiful ghost city. Beautiful hotel and beach with stairway to nothing 😀. i super like it. I’m a fan of a quiet place like that.
I'm glad you found it interesting! 😊
Ya , away from blabbering assuming bloggers ….but no ……there’s one there
Malaysia is still undeveloped why need man made land.
i hear the Malaysia government worry that people might misjudge China Chinese take over Malaysia land that why they build an artificial land instead.
They needed to spite Singapore and it backfired. Karma's a b**tch
I'd say Malaysia is pretty developed, with good highway systems, transportation, infrastructure etc
Mr. Myer:Congratulations to you for arriving safety in this amazing Ghost city, Malaysia this weekend in great joy & peace to tours some great places this weekend in joy 2024❤❤❤
Ghost City meant less populated.
Yup not literally ghosts haha
Nice video 😊
Appreciate you saying that!
Myer, read/watch the whole documentary of the forest city before you continue further. Come back when the project jumps start again. This project will not be abandoned.
truth video 👍
Its NOT a ghost city. Please stop saying that.
It certainly looks like one though ! 😂😂
So what is it?..a silent city or a city with a less people?
4444👿 city vs 4848 🦧✅️😱🪭
Then all my words will be deleted @shadow ban by corrupted google zionist brain👿😱🪭
🇲🇾🇸🇬
Some corrupted google staff ( bias with muslim) use shadow ban tracking my words comment. Vs against free speech vs truth !!!!?????😮🦧👿😱🪭
Now deleted please👿
go and correct your stupid country that run live22 and mega888 so shameful no wonder becoming chinese country
You pissed off the Chinese trolls 😂
Nah they don't have Google.
pull or push, it is a question...
an introverts dream hotel 😁
Haha yup
Insane project 😂
' Ghost City ' of america
| A Century of Poverty ⛺• Ep 42 | Los Angeles, California [4K] |
| California’s New Law in Effect? ⛺ • Ep 39 | Los Angeles, California [4K] | - youtube
A failed project! So sad. If it was due to covid I understand, but now covid has more or less diminished & yet not much buyers or investors!
Hopefully it grows
$100 billion? The GDP of Kuala Lumpur isn’t even less than $80 billion 🤣
The King of Malaysia, Sultan Ibrahim Ismail of Johor wants a High-Speed Rail (HSR) station in Forest City for the KL-Singapore route. He thinks it would make the area more attractive and easier to get to.
That is a wonderful idea. Hope it comes to fruition
My wife can drive a car here😂😂
drove here after SIN_MALAYSIA after covid 19 border re_ opening.Had a coffee break at the hotel lounge.Oppo is Singapore northern Senoko power station and Woodlands.The revelant China developer Country Garden is having financial issues now
There is no such thing as fail for China bro. These lands are probably owned by them now and this place I can see that will be so populated in the near future
Really? There’s 3500 ghost cities in China and Malacca gateway isn’t exactly a success
many you tubers and media have done videos about this.... from what i have read and analysed, china property developers and government often overly exaggerates their projects to mislead, hoodwink people plus generate extra interests and media reportings.... e.g. their will boast the plan / scale and money involved for phase 5 or 7 but actually only have money and real plan to build up to phase 1 to 3 ... the extra phase or expansion plans are merely for propaganda and hype and to trick buyers about the scale and connectivity .... never trust the Commie CHina chinese and companies.
China waste alot of $.😅
The project collapsed because of government policy. Suddenly they want to curb Chinese people buying and end up, no one else can absorb such mega development, hence her collapse. The Malaysian government simply liked to flip flop on their policies and that's why even though the properties are not expensive, not many swarmed in.
Like the high speed rail project with Singapore. They just pulled out of the project after the Singaporean government made significant investments into the project.
The Singaporean government had already bought out a country club to develop it into a train depot.
The Malaysian government had to compensate a huge amount to the Singaporean government.
There were disagreements to the tender process of the hsr construction in the Malaysian part. Singapore wanted both parties to be privy to the tender and appointment of the contractors while Malaysia wanted autonomy in appointing contractors.
That’s what happens if you have a corrupted government.
@@TheManabopohaha significant investment? Singapore was going to build less than 4.5% of the alignment plus don't they need the land for something far more important
@@noorulhasan4904 it’s the ending station. You need a depot
Not anymore because of financial special zone
Forest city is tax free. Soon Singaporeans will fill it up
Unlikely any time soon
Far better places in jb to buy property than forest city tbh plus it's way cheaper and it doesn't look deserted
Give me 1 BHK in 50,000 $ with PR 😂😂 i will buy in this ghost 👻 town
Malaysia is the country where wearing a rainbow watch is a 3 year prison sentence right?
its cool right?im not Malaysian,but i support them
🤝
It is easy to be discouraging. But things will be alright eventually. It is too big to fail.
There’s no such thing as too big to fail.
The stairway to heaven or the stairway to nothing very funny 7:9
Looks like heaven
Mr. Myer:Welcome to the Ghost City, Malaysia to shows those amazing places in Southeast Asia this weekend in October of 2024❤❤❤❤Thanks you so much for this great video 2024❤❤❤
180 guests in the whole place. People will be pretty spread out too. But if it is just people looking to get away from it all that will go there,, it's going to be a lot of depressed people gathering in the place.
I think this is your most boring video
Y am I feeling like you got big invectives from the rivals of this city? hahah
You are so arrogant..
Mr. Myer:Welcome to this amazing beautiful Ghost city, Malaysia this weekend in great joy after spending weeks in Singapore city, Singapore before heading to this amazing Ghost City, Malaysia in peace 2024❤❤❤
Hi bro most malaysian work in singapore definitely they can afford 200k condominium or landed property goven singapore currency to msian ringgit is times 3. Every 100 sgd = 300RM. So they cn afford a bike car n housing in johor bahru. In singapore u have to work hard for housing n car. Car is abt 200k cos theres certificate of entitlment u could use ur car only for 10 yrs & need to renew it costs 100k ++.msians get to keep their bike n cars for many yrs though.
0:16 and 4:47 it has beautiful beach 😮
nice
Just give incentives to locals and the rest will follow. Lose some n win big🎉🎉 I really loved the environment especially the beach alongside golf course. Love to visit someday n much much cheaper than hk.
very nice
From what I've seen and heard, the Forest City will be alright, many people already booked the houses recently especially foreigners from China, Singapore etc and some locals.. I believe that one day after fully constructions redeveloping and etc done by the Malaysian government especially the Johor Royal government who owns partially of the projects/the Forest City and also the said Korean investors that are keen to join to continue in the development of the Forest City, somehow there will be a demand for housing area there as it is nearby to new link bridge to and from SG and MY; and many Singaporeans are looking for new places out of the SG island to move to nearby relocations..
If you think it will be alright, you can buy them now. A lot of the units are selling for real cheap right now.
I hope it grows!
@@myertravels in shaa Allah
@@Slla-th5vt shut up
This project will be the next big thing soon. It failed before but Johore gov will revive it with a lot of tax incentives to draw the rich to park their $$$ there.
Right as if those people driving prices here weren't already enough
If China & Malaysia lifted their restrictions Forest City will be completely filled within a year time.
Forest City is NOT a fail project.
There are no restrictions.
It is totally a failed project
@@audreygiamlayhoon
What’s the reasons then.
Please clarify.
Chinese
and
Singaporeans are not prohibited from buying overseas properties.
In fact, Chinese have been buying many properties in Singapore.
And Singaporeans have been buying properties in the UK, Australia, New Zealand.
There is no reason to buy into Forest City.
Why? It is because it is just not a global real estate investment prospect. And after a decade of being a non starter, Forest City has the burden of being a good investment story.
That's just my point of view.
@tanchye1720
The reason is that it is a failure and no one wants to buy
It's a 20 years project to be developed as far as I know
I'd like to visit lol
You should it’s very surreal