Having a Ram under-dubbed would be excellent! I wished Paul used this for the archived set.I hope this sells well, and he decides to release more under-dubbed material.
RAM is Paul’s absolute masterpiece, his “ópera prima”, so to speak. One of its many marvelous characteristics is that it was recorded without overdubbs, hence there could be no underdubb version ! I do wish Paul performed it live with his band in a sort of farewell tour.
First of all, i’m happy that you’re fine now! Great video, great record. I listened it this weekend, since i finally received the double set. But i’m happy that you’re fine, more important than anything else! Ciao
I really enjoy the under dubbed mixes and gives this old chestnut a fresh listening experience. Band on the Run was the first McCartney album I bought on CD back in the 80s so I have been long familiar with it and it still ranks near the top for me alongside Tug Of War and Ram. Thanks for sharing your thoughts on this Andrew!
@@absurdyellowdog9700 you have an undeniable good music taste! I feel the exact same way. RAM is like the post Beatle bible. Had it been The Beatles who recorded that album, it would be praised as one of the finest pieces of music of all time.
Thank you for mentioning that the new CD has the same mastering as the 2010 set, which I already have. I'll probably get the anniversary edition anyway for the underdubbed mixes and the inclusion of "Helen Wheels." I do have a turntable, but it isn't great, and I've been primarily a CD guy for over 30 years.
Thanks for this really insightful video review Andrew. I really enjoy my 2 LP set which I got last week. I love the underdubbed album, I just love hearing early versions of songs like this, lends some context to how an album finally sounds, and how these songs evolved to the versions we all came to know and love. I have a bit of a weakness for the more acoustic material of McCartney's career right from Blackbird on the white album to the current day. (If only he'd record a wholly acoustic solo album, but I can but dream.) So Bluebird, and Mamunia are among my current faves on this release. I do have a soft spot also for Let Me Roll It, or as I call it, his Plastic Ono Band On The Run track. I also invested in the CD set which I play through my surround sound system, and I have to say it sounds fab, I'd go as so far to say that it's on par with my Revolver deluxe set when I play that through this system of mine. The half speed master is now my go to choice of this album to play, having Helen Wheels on here is a bonus which I enjoy, and I wonder why it wasn't on the UK pressing as lyrically it does fit in with the rest of the album. So thanks for this Macca, now I'm looking forward to a Venus and Mars half speed with it's very own version of underdubbed....
I also didn't really see the point in getting this album but in the end I did get the same as you on vinyl an I'm glad I did it sounds amazing, I love your videos they are the highlight of my weekend
I enjoyed your video as usual. The underdubbed is fantastic and Jet was outstanding. I bought the SHM Japan cd version. Big fan of Helen Wheels. Love your idea to do the same thing with Ram!
Andrew, I completely share your assessment of this release. I purchased both the CD and the double Vinyl, and I’m blown away by how wonderful the vinyl sounds. The Underdubbed is a really fun listen, and it has already had several spins. Thanks for the great feedback.
Thanks heaps for your post which I'm really pleased to have watched and listened. Having purchased the double CD here in Australia for $45, I was incredibly disappointed, on first listen, to learn that the original album was in fact the 2010 remix which I don't rate that highly and not the new 50th anniversary mix. If I hadn't watched your post I would have filed this double CD 50th anniversary edition away as a bad purchase. Your comments regarding the under dubbed mix had me intrigued although I was feeling somewhat sceptical but gave it go. Wow!!! it really is awesome and sounds amazing. After listening to the CD I gave it (under dubbed mix) a listen through my Air Pod Max - dolby atmos and geez it really does sound amazing! So many highlights; Band on the Run vocals, Jet drums, Bluebird bass and percussion, etc etc. Thanks again!
I ordered the new half speed master on the weekend it was released, but my record shop already sold all of their copies. Due to high demand, the same happened in many other record stores in The Netherlands. I was informed that the half speed master is being re-printed and a new batch is expected to be available at the end of this month or the beginning of march. On the Steve Hoffman forum, some people say the sales did disappoint, but the information I got says the opposite: they did not release enough copies in the first place to fulfill the demand, so many of us did not have the chance yet to buy one. Like me. ~Marjet p.s. This is a stunning video and I enjoyed every second. Thanks!
Excellent video again Andrew!! I've listened to the underdubbed mixes & was very impressed. My fave track on this album is - & has always been - the Australian single "Mrs. Vandebilt".
Great video as usual Andrew, just like to mention that my 2 disc 25th anniversary edition of the LP does have the lyrics to Helen Wheels on the inner sleeve.
Greetings from Sydney, Australia and a big, BIG thank you for this and all the other Beatles-related videos that you have made. I enjoy them very much.
Thanks for an interesting take on the under dubbed concept. With all the unreleased archive material Paul has in the vault it would be interesting if MPL teamed up with Deagostini to produce a fortnightly magazine containing his unreleased material on high grade vinyl with a CD version and commentary.
Well done! I’ve always loved this album. I was thrilled with the idea of the underdubbed idea since the Doors “Perception” release. I love the underdubbed version of BOTR. It’s what I listen to the most now. I do hope they do this to Venus and Mars. I’ve never been a fan of the original mix of that release anyway, so a rework would be nice…plus an underdubbed companion. Ram also would benefit…Abbey Road…Sgt. Pepper’s…uh oh,I’ll stop there. By the way, I cannot hear BOTR without Helen Wheels. That brain thing…! Great episode! Thanks Andrew
Yes the brainthing. I bought the European version of BOTR while released in 1973. So I never got used to Helen Wheels. Actually: I really HATE It. Thats why I paid €700,- for the Nimbus edition of BOTR
Thanks for the content Andrew! I bought all 3 of the available releases, both on vinyl and disc. I do have to say something though, the first LP I ever purchased with my own money was BotR. I bought my copy at a discount store called Meijer, for what I believe was $3.99. In 1979, I bought a copy of BotR from the UK, from LordSitar Records out of Long Island, NY. To be frank, after ALL these years, I never noticed that the photos on the back cover were in a different order, what an odd little detail! I will also add that I am disappointed that MPL just shipped the Archive version of BotR, they could have done something, like maybe give us the ATMOS version or the NIMBUS version, if they have it! Then maybe it would have increased sales even more! Now on an unrelated note, what in the hell is Apple thinking with these 3" one-sided singles they are releasing for Record Store Day?Why couldn't they have just done an EP of the four tracks and if they wanted to maximize the money haul, they could have just released 3 seperate EPs, one in red vinyl, one in white and one in blue! I really don't want or need another format to have to try to play. Cheers Andrew!
You remember when there’s been rumors for over over 40 or more years that Paul McCartney was going to release all his best unreleased material and calling it “hot hits and cold cuts.” where the hell is it? He’s been promising the damn thing since the days of wings. Still waiting for it and it would be a great seller because it’s all new music that has not been released.
I am on a limited income and I don't even have a working turntable. I already have 2 copies on CD, 1 being the 25th anniversary. I always enjoy your reviews and your updates , thank you very much.
Thank you for the tip on the Meze headphones. My old pair of headphones was worn out and falling apart. After watching your video last Sunday I ordered a pair using the 20% discount. They arrived today! Talk about fast service. I've just given them a test ride listening to Sgt. Pepper's, my favorite record and the one with which I am most familiar. The Mese headphones performed brilliantly. The clarity was wonderful. As you noted the bass and mid-range were quite nice. They are extremely comfortable and the fit--a problem with past headphones--was perfect. My last test will be how my ears feel after 3 or 4 hours straight of listening. My equipment is set up in the same room with our TV. I don't want to be in a room separate from my wife, who mostly watches TV. So, 90% of my music listening is done with headphones. Terry
Because I have a seventies vinyl US pressing and a second hand archive collection set on CD with the original album missing, I opted for the two CD set. The underdubbed disc is worth the occasional listen and both discs sound great. I would have liked some liner notes, but there’s plenty of that in my archive collection.
Thanks Andrew for your videos, the rough mix is just wonderful with a great place for Paul’s vocals. What a voice and such a thrill to heard BOTR on a différent way. Maybe a clue for the next remaster. I hope
I just picked up a Nimbus Super Cut of this album. It's so nice I haven't even cleaned it yet let alone played it. I commented about another rare set I just picked up. Would love to hear your thoughts on it. It is a Special Limited Numbered Edition of all 3 Anthology albums that comes with a T-shirt and paper weight. Mine is missing those items but all albums are sealed and the plastic bix is also pristine. I'm loving your channel. Thank you for your work and time.
Thanks Andrew. Though I’m disappointed to realise that the CD edition is the same as the 2010 version, I appreciated your comments on the underdubbed one (that must necessarily be new also for the CD.) Ciao 😊
Although the concept of stripped down mixes is nothing new (only the "under dubbed" buzzword is new), what really needs to come out are the individual recording tracks IMHO. With technology so many people are essentially providing stems and whatnot as it is, the next best way to engage with a fan is let them create their own personal mixes. David Bowie did this ages ago on a CD ROM. Sometimes the original mix is near perfect except for an instrument being too loud or quiet. Officially releasing the multitracks would be the ultimate "thank you" and engagement with fans. Just my thoughts on it. Peace all!
Andrew, that was a nice review of the new “Band On The Run” 50th. I bought the CD Version only because of the Underdubbed Mixes. I wasn’t expecting anything earth shattering sound wise from the 2010 mix or 1/2 speed master mix. My ears are too old to hear the difference, but I still can tell when a recording is brickwalled. Thankfully none was detected. Like yourself I was floored and pleasantly surprised how much I enjoyed the “Underdubbed Mixes, this will be getting many spins on my CD player. Whereas, “Let It Be Naked” and “Double Fantasy Stripped Down” not so much. Glad to see you looking good and feeling better Andrew, Cheers!
Hi Andrew. I liked the video, as usual. I only feel you missed talking about the Steve Hoffman mixes from the 90s and the DTS mix. They released BOTR and Venus and Mars at the time, and they're interesting. Have you actually mentioned anything about the 93 cd releases? There was also a 25th aniversary edition of BOTR.
Not sure how it compares to the Atmos mix, but I have a copy of the 2001 DTS Super Jewel Box CD which is quite impressive. Picked up the single LP for the Obi strip, and the CD for the “underdubbed” album (changing the playback order in iTunes, and inclusion of ‘Helen Wheels”.
Another excellent mini documentary and commentary, Andrew. Your material really is outstanding. From research to editorial, photography and production. I particularly appreciate the detail in the "photochemical" idents, complete with that pink crossfade bias and occasional cue mark!
I have a first press U.K. version and the new 2 vinyl with slipcase. Both sound great. A wonderful record still sounding great in 2024. The underdubs sound great, and also show what a great arranger McCartney is, his overdub and orchestral choices are superb. Another fab video, Andrew. Thank you 🙏
Hi Andrew. I love the underdubbed versions as, stripping back the orchestration and some of the other overdubs, it really gives the tracks the chance to breath ! I had the same feeling when they put of the stripped back Double Fantasy. The clarity of the tracks is amazing and McCartney's drum and bass playing is excellent ! And the combination of Paul's and Denny's acoustic guitars is wonderful. Yes, whilst I was listening to the underdubbed version, my brain was constantly filling in the rest ! I thought Mamunia, Mrs Vandebilt and and Let Me Roll It were the stand out cuts. Cheers Tim
Glad you’re feeling better, Andrew. I had been planning on buying the CDs of the 50th but I won’t be now! I’ll wait until the LPs are on a good sale. That said, I’m now looking foreword to listening to the ATMOS mix. All the details should abound!
Great video and rundown of the material in this set. I own the Columbia half speed master and both, the new and old sound superb. The Columbia version has noisier vinyl, in that you hear more record noise in between tracks. The Columbia is also slightly brighter. The new version is hotter in level and has a slight low end bump. Other than that, they are both great. The under-dubbed is a cool listening experience, but at the end of the day, the released version rules. My favorite from under-dubbed is Jet. That track always sounded dark, possibly because of the tape shedding issue they had while recording the song, or the dubbing of additional instrument, or both. Sometimes less is more. Thank you for posting this wonderful video.
Another great video Andrew. I only own the original US release on vinyl that I purchased in 1974. It is surely Paul's best album and I would guess that in some way Paul knew this album had to shine after the success of John's Imagine and George's "All things must pass." I did listened to the Dolby Atmos version of the "Under Dubs" on streaming and they are a delight to the ears. In some ways better in my opinion, since , although I loved the album, I always thought the original album sounded "overdubbed" .
Recently I've found the 7 inch single «Jet»/«Let Me Roll It» in a One-Euro-Box outside of a record store in Lindau (the bavarian island in Lake Constance). No cover, no audiophile quality. But now it's mine. Cleaned and with a black sleeve in my singles collection. Thanks for the video, Andrew. See you soon --- Martin
I'm glad they released the underdubbed mixes because it's good for historical/preservational means. Not to mention, it's a great alternate listening experience.
Fabulous upload, I thought the underdubbed versions would be less than the originals but I agree they are outstanding. I can here the heart and soul of the songs and Paul's vocals have never been better than here. I also agree that the download version is the way to go if you want the music the CD version is simply not worth it for the lacklustre packaging and lack of "extras". Thanks Andrew
I am only interested in these reissues if there are bonus tracks and unreleased songs. Paul McCartney literally has hundreds of unreleased finished songs in his catalog. I have books on his unreleased music that could fill several albums and CDs. Why the hell does he keep releasing the same music over and over again. Just release the finished songs, just the best of the best
I could add a question to Paul and his 'people' - "Why wait? ALL McCartney tracks will generate attention and questions. Why not release them now so we might get The Horse's Mouth to answer our questions?" He's been wonderfully talkative during this 2022-2023 NOW AND THEN period. I'd love to hear his descriptions of unreleased tracks.
@@daveduffy2823 I think he just doesn’t own the Beatles songs because of the 1970 or 69 Northern songs takeover that led to Michael Jackson eventually etc. After that, all of his solo songs are his own and with wings
Great review as always! I listened to the Atmos mix through my home theatre system. And I must say that this McCartney album really has the best Atmos mix so far! They really put a lot of work into this one. When the orchestra hit me from behind on the title track it almost knocked me off the couch 😅 Atmos on headphones is fun but not nearly comparable to the listening experience a Atmos Home Theatre System gives you! 😃
Great review Andrew like always. But now that I know that the CD release is the same as the one of 2010, I will pass on buying this one. I'm still listening to CD's because they are less costly then the vinyl release. Cheers from Quebec Canada !
I’m a sucker for physical releases, and bought the 2-CD version, but disc 1 is admittedly redundant with the 2010 archive edition. I ended up only ripping disc 2 onto my MacBook and syncing with my iPhone, but the Underdubbed Mixes are available to purchase alone digitally on the iTunes Store for only $9.99 and is arguably the best deal for what we got out of this release.
Thanks for the video, Andrew! I just added the albums to my Apple Music library--- I listened to the first couple minutes of "Mamunia" and "No Words," and they sound excellent through my AirPods Pro. I have the 1999 and 2010 reissues on CD and this version sounds much more alive. Curiously, the Apple Music Atmos version does not contain "Helen Wheels." I haven't gone through "Underdubbed" yet but looking forward to it. And thanks for your headphone review!
Glad to see you're feeling better Handsome. Love your review on the new BOTR reissue. Haven't had a chance to listen to mine, but it sounds like i'm in for a treat.
Honestly glad I watched your take on this set. I planned on just skipping over it and just enjoying my 2010 archive cd set as it has the bonus material. But, I just gave the underdubbed (which I agree the alternate tracklist along with the underdubbedness provides a refreshing listen and). And the atmos version of the main album is very nice as well. My favorite atmos album tho to date is actually not Beatles related, but Stephen Sanchez’s “Angel Face”. Worth a listen if you’ve never heard. Real nice 50s/60s r&b and rock n roll sound. Anyway thanks Andrew, cheers
I totally agree with you Andrew, I really enjoyed the underdubbed tracks a lot. I thought it was great. Too bad its not a standalone vinyl lp. Im tired of having to buy lps i already have. Sometimes more than one. Id love to have Ram like this too. See you next time.
Since you mentioned it, I have a sealed copy of the CBS Mastersound half-speed mastered LP. It still has the price sticker on the plastic cover: $13.59 (that's USD). According to an online inflation calculator, that would be $46.11 in 2024. For comparison, back in '79 or '80 when I bought the MFSL Abbey Road, it was about $17 (probably $16.99) as best I can recall. And when I started buying the UK imports in the late 70s, they were generally a penny or two under $9 or $10.
Great video!! I had preordered the 2CD… the underdubs sound good!! It was a fun listen. I was baffled at how much I enjoyed Jet… almost prefer it to the original!! Also, I agree, I’d really love if MPL/Paul (whoever) would finally put London Town and BTTE in the archive collection, and finish Wings’ discography!!
The underdubbed has been my main jam for the past week. It’s a fun listen. I just wish they had offered the underdubbed alone. Most don’t need another band on the run.
I was excited for the underdubbed mixes because I so enjoyed the rough mixes and re-workings the Ramones did for the 40th anniversaries of their ‘70s albums. (1980’s End of the Century received the same treatment in 2020, but that’s sat on the shelf since then for frustratingly unspecified reasons.) Suffice to say that underdubbed did not disappoint, and Let Me Roll It is indeed the most compelling track in this form.
Your waveform visualizations definitely confirm what I'm hearing. This is a great pressing of a great album and a worthy new release in Paul's half-speed remaster series. The underdubbed LP is fun too, with Bluebird and Let Me Roll It being particular favorites. (What IS that sound during the intro of Let Me Roll It? A chicken?) As for the still missing version of BOTR, we'll never hear it, because the stolen tape story looms large in the McCartney legend. He's not about to ruin one of his favorite oft-told interview answers by suddenly saying "Oh we had another copy all along."
Glad you are all recovered Andrew. Personally, I love to hear rough mix or "underdubbed" versions of albums. It gives a feel of how they were before all the polish arrives and gives the raw sound that I love. That is not to say that it works on all albums as sometimes they can actually just sound worse. However, with this album that contains some of my favourite Macca (and Wings) songs, I look forward to listening to it very soon (am awaiting a suitably opportune moment when I will not be disturbed!). Talking of which, I do feel it is a bit naughty that they are now labelling it as a Paul McCartney album. Bit unfair on Linda and Denny especially. Shame on the record company for changing it. I wonder why that is and what the upshot of it is royalty wise? Hmmmmmmm, just a thought. Any thoughts on this at your end Andrew? Anyway, great video as always. Thanks
Would love to see you undertake a McCartney album ranking or perhaps a shorter ranking such as a top 10 or 5 albums. Keep up the great work, I love the channel!
Thank you! This was a very entertaining review, and frankly one of the first that hold the under dubbed to a positive level. I purchased the half speed stand alone, and felt it really shined in audio quality. I'm kind of regretting not picking up the under dubbed now. Maybe I'll get it too. Thank you for the quality work you do and for your enthusiasm you put into your reviews and research. Also enjoyed your Meze review, by the way where can you apply the Parlogram20 code?
Well done as usual Andrew. So glad you are enjoying this new issue....but for me this just isn't enough. The underdubbed concept is ok but doesn't grab me the way original demos and outtakes would have. Sorry Paul...not this time. Cheers Andrew till next week!
I’ve had a listen to some of the ‘underdubbed’ mixes - and while they are interesting, and really show what a great unit Denny, Linda and Paul were as a band, I don’t find they add anything more to Band On The Run. I’m still happy with my old vinyl copy, and will continue to play that. What I would like to hear are some of the demos - notably for Nineteen Hundred and Eighty Five, Bluebird and Jet.
I've been on the fence about the BOTR reissue *and* the headphones. Your video (and Meze discount code) helped seal the deal. 😀 Thanks! (And continued thanks for your great content.)
One other thing to note for Atmos, I had a pleasure this last week to hear, silly love songs on a pair of klipsch horn speakers. I understand what the mastering engineer of mobile Fidelity sound lab meant when he says good stereo will just outclass surroundsound and you won’t even need multiple channels. mind you this also, I think a lot of it being both the speakers, and the fact that was Macintosh amplifiers
I enjoyed listening to the underdubbed version of Band on the Run over at Apple Music. And I agree with what you said, it was interesting enough for me to listen to more than once Great video, and thanks for sharing.
Let Me Roll It is one of my favorites and the new underdubbed version is now my favorite. Paul’s voice and the harmonies are more open and sound amazing, and I prefer how the lyrics are presented here compared to the released version. The rest of the tracks are very interesting but I still prefer most of the release versions except for Let Me Roll It. Although this set is tempting, I am probably going to stick with finding a UK original when I go on my trip to London.
Who would have said ten or 15 years ago that the LP records would return on the market, with more prestige than before? Who would have bet? Well, here they are. I have been brooding a lot of times about how the MP3 and the podcast are no good for real music, the music you really like. For the ones like me who spent their teen-years holding in their hands the records they loved, placing them on the furniture (standing and leaning against the wall) to look at them more often, well, you understand what I mean. They had pushed the MP3 too far, this is the right reaction. With MP3 you don’t own anything, you haven’t got anything in your hands, and you can lose it all if the flash memory goes nuts or if a virus cancels your hard disk. Let’s get back to the old good LPs!
With the news that Sam Mendes has been given complete access to Apples' archive to produce four biopics, can we expect an instalment on this exciting, upcoming event?
Thanks for the always great video. Am listening to the Underdubbed Mix now, and the first thing that stands out is on BOTR, Paul's vocal is a different take - not as "polished" as the regular version.
Hello Andrew Great video as always!!!! I have not purchased this album I still have my original cd US version I am very disappointed that the cd is the 2010 virsion and that it wasn’t remixed it should have been I have heard a lot of negative comments about the underdubbed mixes I haven’t purchased any of the albums with the US obby strip Yes they look Great and I would like to own them but with out the guarantee that all the albums will come out this way, I don’t wanna start investing look what’s happened to the colored vinyl look what’s happened to the archive series? Everything is stopped why I don’t know but I don’t want to start purchasing just to be let down. If Abby Road and Nems consider the archive edition to be the best then why didn’t they continue with that series and as for the record why didn’t they just put out the 2010 version for the cd and vinyl again. Maybe I don’t know to much and am over speculating but the action of last doesn’t help me make a good decision to buy buy buy. I am hopeful for a NEW ALBUM THAT WILL MAKE ME HAPPY! Thanks for the video take care.
I'm loving the new half speed master! I got the single LP with the obi strip and the CD set. I'm hoping we get a re-release of Memory Almost Full soon. Also where's the Dolbly Atmos mix of the White Album? They released a few of the songs in Atmos for the new blue album so they should do the rest.
Thanks to your review Andrew I went ahead and ordered the 2 record vinyl set. As with most here I have several copies. I did not however get the 2010 archive edition (have all the others on vinyl)..I skipping it because it was released not too long after the 25th anniversary vinyl edition (1998)..I'm a huge collector but in this case was not interested in buying another copy just 12 years later. Again I was on the fence on this but your review pushed me off!
I picked this Lp up at our good Will Store here in iowa Mine is the original press from 1973. I would have to check But I think the copy I have is the US pressing. wow, 12 years ago.. I am not sure on the date ... but, some how, the LP is near mint looking! and plays good!
For the life of me, I don't get why some people are so dismissive of No Words. It's my second favorite song on the album, after Nineteen Hundred and Eighty Five. Paul even included No Words in Wings' live set, during their last tour in 1979. On the other hand, I am not a big fan of Helen Wheels. I think it disrupts the flow of the album.
It's because everyone likes different things, that's why. There's no universal truths here. You like blue, they like red. You like wooden kitchen cupboards, they like painted. You like Words, they don't. Way it is. Music would be way too boring and uninteresting if we all liked the SAME things. Ugh.
Nice review, Andrew. In my opinion the Underdubbed are definitely worth it... and that's it. The quality of the packaging is not up to scratch, I find the design for the underdubbed LP underwhelming and the sound of the remaster a bit flat (I haven't had the luck of listening to a 1st ed yet).
Enjoyed the review Andrew. Have you heard the CD, what does it sound like, is it brickwalled? I do have mixed feelings about ATMOS for headphones, it's different for sure but really doesn't knock me out. Cheers!
Just a question you may know ... On how many tracks does McCartney mention Sailor Sam? Band On The Run / Helen Wheels ..... any more? I can only think of two but it seems that there are many more. Sailor Sam is a character from Rupert so I can see where Paul is coming from.
![Hunxho - Ball Forever [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/nki9ZTF9Uls/mqdefault.jpg)
Having a Ram under-dubbed would be excellent! I wished Paul used this for the archived set.I hope this sells well, and he decides to release more under-dubbed material.
RAM is Paul’s absolute masterpiece, his “ópera prima”, so to speak. One of its many marvelous characteristics is that it was recorded without overdubbs, hence there could be no underdubb version ! I do wish Paul performed it live with his band in a sort of farewell tour.
I think the new 2CD set is great. Sounds wonderful. I love the underdubbed stuff, with some songs given an extended ending and chatter, etc.
First of all, i’m happy that you’re fine now! Great video, great record. I listened it this weekend, since i finally received the double set. But i’m happy that you’re fine, more important than anything else! Ciao
Although not mentioned in the video, what I love about the under dubbed on cd is the clarity of Paul's melodic bass lines. They really add to songs.
Hi Andrew, great video! I'm looking forward to listening to the new remastered album and the under dubbed mixes 😊
I agree 100% the underdubbed is a great way to listen to songs we've heard so many times. I love this box set.
Thanks Andrew, happy to see you are healthy and back in Beatles history mode. Fantastic information as always.
I really enjoy the under dubbed mixes and gives this old chestnut a fresh listening experience. Band on the Run was the first McCartney album I bought on CD back in the 80s so I have been long familiar with it and it still ranks near the top for me alongside Tug Of War and Ram. Thanks for sharing your thoughts on this Andrew!
RAM, what a revolutionary album! I’ve never understood why BOTR is more highly regarded. Never!
@@JoseAntonioDuclaud totally agree. RAM is my favorite McCartney anything.
@@absurdyellowdog9700 you have an undeniable good music taste! I feel the exact same way. RAM is like the post Beatle bible. Had it been The Beatles who recorded that album, it would be praised as one of the finest pieces of music of all time.
The Paul McCartney remastered campaign is the most weird, where is London Town, Back To The Egg etc. Seems like the Archive Collection is over
No Words is my favorite song on Band on the Run! I love those harmonies
Thank you for mentioning that the new CD has the same mastering as the 2010 set, which I already have. I'll probably get the anniversary edition anyway for the underdubbed mixes and the inclusion of "Helen Wheels." I do have a turntable, but it isn't great, and I've been primarily a CD guy for over 30 years.
Thanks for this really insightful video review Andrew. I really enjoy my 2 LP set which I got last week. I love the underdubbed album, I just love hearing early versions of songs like this, lends some context to how an album finally sounds, and how these songs evolved to the versions we all came to know and love. I have a bit of a weakness for the more acoustic material of McCartney's career right from Blackbird on the white album to the current day. (If only he'd record a wholly acoustic solo album, but I can but dream.) So Bluebird, and Mamunia are among my current faves on this release. I do have a soft spot also for Let Me Roll It, or as I call it, his Plastic Ono Band On The Run track. I also invested in the CD set which I play through my surround sound system, and I have to say it sounds fab, I'd go as so far to say that it's on par with my Revolver deluxe set when I play that through this system of mine. The half speed master is now my go to choice of this album to play, having Helen Wheels on here is a bonus which I enjoy, and I wonder why it wasn't on the UK pressing as lyrically it does fit in with the rest of the album. So thanks for this Macca, now I'm looking forward to a Venus and Mars half speed with it's very own version of underdubbed....
Can you make a video about Paul’s missing Bass that recently got found after 51 years.
Indeed. I just read about that last night. Must be a great story …
I absolutely love the underdubbed version. It’s like discovering these songs for the first time, hearing new sounds and the clarity is superb.
I also didn't really see the point in getting this album but in the end I did get the same as you on vinyl an I'm glad I did it sounds amazing, I love your videos they are the highlight of my weekend
Remember, each time you play it, it's wearing out.
I enjoyed your video as usual. The underdubbed is fantastic and Jet was outstanding. I bought the SHM Japan cd version. Big fan of Helen Wheels. Love your idea to do the same thing with Ram!
Helen Wheels does not fit in the magic of the album
Andrew, I completely share your assessment of this release. I purchased both the CD and the double Vinyl, and I’m blown away by how wonderful the vinyl sounds. The Underdubbed is a really fun listen, and it has already had several spins. Thanks for the great feedback.
Thanks heaps for your post which I'm really pleased to have watched and listened.
Having purchased the double CD here in Australia for $45, I was incredibly disappointed, on first listen, to learn that the original album was in fact the 2010 remix which I don't rate that highly and not the new 50th anniversary mix. If I hadn't watched your post I would have filed this double CD 50th anniversary edition away as a bad purchase.
Your comments regarding the under dubbed mix had me intrigued although I was feeling somewhat sceptical but gave it go. Wow!!! it really is awesome and sounds amazing. After listening to the CD I gave it (under dubbed mix) a listen through my Air Pod Max - dolby atmos and geez it really does sound amazing! So many highlights; Band on the Run vocals, Jet drums, Bluebird bass and percussion, etc etc.
Thanks again!
I ordered the new half speed master on the weekend it was released, but my record shop already sold all of their copies. Due to high demand, the same happened in many other record stores in The Netherlands. I was informed that the half speed master is being re-printed and a new batch is expected to be available at the end of this month or the beginning of march. On the Steve Hoffman forum, some people say the sales did disappoint, but the information I got says the opposite: they did not release enough copies in the first place to fulfill the demand, so many of us did not have the chance yet to buy one. Like me. ~Marjet p.s. This is a stunning video and I enjoyed every second. Thanks!
Excellent video again Andrew!! I've listened to the underdubbed mixes & was very impressed. My fave track on this album is - & has always been - the Australian single "Mrs. Vandebilt".
Great video as usual Andrew, just like to mention that my 2 disc 25th anniversary edition of the LP does have the lyrics to Helen Wheels on the inner sleeve.
Greetings from Sydney, Australia and a big, BIG thank you for this and all the other Beatles-related videos that you have made. I enjoy them very much.
Many thanks! Glad you like them!
Thanks for an interesting take on the under dubbed concept. With all the unreleased archive material Paul has in the vault it would be interesting if MPL teamed up with Deagostini to produce a fortnightly magazine containing his unreleased material on high grade vinyl with a CD version and commentary.
Well done! I’ve always loved this album. I was thrilled with the idea of the underdubbed idea since the Doors “Perception” release. I love the underdubbed version of BOTR. It’s what I listen to the most now.
I do hope they do this to Venus and Mars. I’ve never been a fan of the original mix of that release anyway, so a rework would be nice…plus an underdubbed companion. Ram also would benefit…Abbey Road…Sgt. Pepper’s…uh oh,I’ll stop there.
By the way, I cannot hear BOTR without Helen Wheels. That brain thing…!
Great episode! Thanks Andrew
Cheers Brian!
Yes the brainthing. I bought the European version of BOTR while released in 1973. So I never got used to Helen Wheels. Actually: I really HATE It. Thats why I paid €700,- for the Nimbus edition of BOTR
Thanks for the content Andrew! I bought all 3 of the available releases, both on vinyl and disc. I do have to say something though, the first LP I ever purchased with my own money was BotR. I bought my copy at a discount store called Meijer, for what I believe was $3.99. In 1979, I bought a copy of BotR from the UK, from LordSitar Records out of Long Island, NY. To be frank, after ALL these years, I never noticed that the photos on the back cover were in a different order, what an odd little detail! I will also add that I am disappointed that MPL just shipped the Archive version of BotR, they could have done something, like maybe give us the ATMOS version or the NIMBUS version, if they have it! Then maybe it would have increased sales even more! Now on an unrelated note, what in the hell is Apple thinking with these 3" one-sided singles they are releasing for Record Store Day?Why couldn't they have just done an EP of the four tracks and if they wanted to maximize the money haul, they could have just released 3 seperate EPs, one in red vinyl, one in white and one in blue! I really don't want or need another format to have to try to play. Cheers Andrew!
That means that there’s a Wings package - with a dedicated 3 inch player - in the works.
The way it’s worded, it sounds like they’re issuing the actual Ed Sullivan show performances on the 3” discs.
Thank you Andrew! I love the CD set and also the hi res downloads. The Underdubbed CD is a real treat.
You remember when there’s been rumors for over over 40 or more years that Paul McCartney was going to release all his best unreleased material and calling it “hot hits and cold cuts.” where the hell is it? He’s been promising the damn thing since the days of wings. Still waiting for it and it would be a great seller because it’s all new music that has not been released.
A lot of what would have been on Cold Cutz is out there on You Tube - there’s some little gems!
I am on a limited income and I don't even have a working turntable. I already have 2 copies on CD, 1 being the 25th anniversary.
I always enjoy your reviews and your updates , thank you very much.
Thank you for the tip on the Meze headphones. My old pair of headphones was worn out and falling apart. After watching your video last Sunday I ordered a pair using the 20% discount. They arrived today! Talk about fast service. I've just given them a test ride listening to Sgt. Pepper's, my favorite record and the one with which I am most familiar. The Mese headphones performed brilliantly. The clarity was wonderful. As you noted the bass and mid-range were quite nice. They are extremely comfortable and the fit--a problem with past headphones--was perfect. My last test will be how my ears feel after 3 or 4 hours straight of listening. My equipment is set up in the same room with our TV. I don't want to be in a room separate from my wife, who mostly watches TV. So, 90% of my music listening is done with headphones.
Terry
Because I have a seventies vinyl US pressing and a second hand archive collection set on CD with the original album missing, I opted for the two CD set.
The underdubbed disc is worth the occasional listen and both discs sound great. I would have liked some liner notes, but there’s plenty of that in my archive collection.
Thanks Andrew for your videos, the rough mix is just wonderful with a great place for Paul’s vocals. What a voice and such a thrill to heard BOTR on a différent way. Maybe a clue for the next remaster. I hope
I just picked up a Nimbus Super Cut of this album. It's so nice I haven't even cleaned it yet let alone played it. I commented about another rare set I just picked up. Would love to hear your thoughts on it. It is a Special Limited Numbered Edition of all 3 Anthology albums that comes with a T-shirt and paper weight. Mine is missing those items but all albums are sealed and the plastic bix is also pristine. I'm loving your channel. Thank you for your work and time.
Thanks Andrew.
Though I’m disappointed to realise that the CD edition is the same as the 2010 version, I appreciated your comments on the underdubbed one (that must necessarily be new also for the CD.) Ciao 😊
Although the concept of stripped down mixes is nothing new (only the "under dubbed" buzzword is new), what really needs to come out are the individual recording tracks IMHO. With technology so many people are essentially providing stems and whatnot as it is, the next best way to engage with a fan is let them create their own personal mixes. David Bowie did this ages ago on a CD ROM. Sometimes the original mix is near perfect except for an instrument being too loud or quiet. Officially releasing the multitracks would be the ultimate "thank you" and engagement with fans. Just my thoughts on it. Peace all!
I went for listening to the underdubbed versions on RUclips . Love the mixes, love the price.
Thank you for a well thought out and honest review of this set, Andrew. I always value your opinions on all matters Beatles and solo Beatles!
Andrew, that was a nice review of the new “Band On The Run” 50th. I bought the CD Version only because of the Underdubbed Mixes. I wasn’t expecting anything earth shattering sound wise from the 2010 mix or 1/2 speed master mix. My ears are too old to hear the difference, but I still can tell when a recording is brickwalled. Thankfully none was detected. Like yourself I was floored and pleasantly surprised how much I enjoyed the “Underdubbed Mixes, this will be getting many spins on my CD player. Whereas, “Let It Be Naked” and “Double Fantasy Stripped Down” not so much. Glad to see you looking good and feeling better Andrew, Cheers!
PS: how do I become a Patreon member?
Here you go: www.patreon.com/parlogram
Hi Andrew. I liked the video, as usual. I only feel you missed talking about the Steve Hoffman mixes from the 90s and the DTS mix. They released BOTR and Venus and Mars at the time, and they're interesting. Have you actually mentioned anything about the 93 cd releases? There was also a 25th aniversary edition of BOTR.
Not sure how it compares to the Atmos mix, but I have a copy of the 2001 DTS Super Jewel Box CD which is quite impressive. Picked up the single LP for the Obi strip, and the CD for the “underdubbed” album (changing the playback order in iTunes, and inclusion of ‘Helen Wheels”.
Another excellent mini documentary and commentary, Andrew. Your material really is outstanding. From research to editorial, photography and production. I particularly appreciate the detail in the "photochemical" idents, complete with that pink crossfade bias and occasional cue mark!
Thank you, Samuel. Glad you enjoyed it!
I have a first press U.K. version and the new 2 vinyl with slipcase. Both sound great. A wonderful record still sounding great in 2024. The underdubs sound great, and also show what a great arranger McCartney is, his overdub and orchestral choices are superb. Another fab video, Andrew. Thank you 🙏
Hi Andrew. I love the underdubbed versions as, stripping back the orchestration and some of the other overdubs, it really gives the tracks the chance to breath ! I had the same feeling when they put of the stripped back Double Fantasy. The clarity of the tracks is amazing and McCartney's drum and bass playing is excellent ! And the combination of Paul's and Denny's acoustic guitars is wonderful. Yes, whilst I was listening to the underdubbed version, my brain was constantly filling in the rest ! I thought Mamunia, Mrs Vandebilt and and Let Me Roll It were the stand out cuts. Cheers Tim
Glad you’re feeling better, Andrew. I had been planning on buying the CDs of the 50th but I won’t be now! I’ll wait until the LPs are on a good sale.
That said, I’m now looking foreword to listening to the ATMOS mix. All the details should abound!
Great video and rundown of the material in this set. I own the Columbia half speed master and both, the new and old sound superb. The Columbia version has noisier vinyl, in that you hear more record noise in between tracks. The Columbia is also slightly brighter. The new version is hotter in level and has a slight low end bump. Other than that, they are both great. The under-dubbed is a cool listening experience, but at the end of the day, the released version rules. My favorite from under-dubbed is Jet. That track always sounded dark, possibly because of the tape shedding issue they had while recording the song, or the dubbing of additional instrument, or both. Sometimes less is more. Thank you for posting this wonderful video.
Another great video Andrew. I only own the original US release on vinyl that I purchased in 1974. It is surely Paul's best album and I would guess that in some way Paul knew this album had to shine after the success of John's Imagine and George's "All things must pass." I did
listened to the Dolby Atmos version of the "Under Dubs" on streaming and they are a delight to the ears. In some ways better in my opinion, since , although I loved the album, I always thought the original album sounded "overdubbed" .
Recently I've found the 7 inch single «Jet»/«Let Me Roll It» in a One-Euro-Box outside of a record store in Lindau (the bavarian island in Lake Constance). No cover, no audiophile quality. But now it's mine. Cleaned and with a black sleeve in my singles collection. Thanks for the video, Andrew. See you soon --- Martin
I never noticed that Helen Wheels didn’t have its lyrics on the inner sleeve, and I have an original 1973 Apple pressing!
I'm glad they released the underdubbed mixes because it's good for historical/preservational means. Not to mention, it's a great alternate listening experience.
Fabulous upload, I thought the underdubbed versions would be less than the originals but I agree they are outstanding. I can here the heart and soul of the songs and Paul's vocals have never been better than here. I also agree that the download version is the way to go if you want the music the CD version is simply not worth it for the lacklustre packaging and lack of "extras". Thanks Andrew
Many thanks, Tim. Glad you enjoyed it!
I am only interested in these reissues if there are bonus tracks and unreleased songs. Paul McCartney literally has hundreds of unreleased finished songs in his catalog. I have books on his unreleased music that could fill several albums and CDs. Why the hell does he keep releasing the same music over and over again. Just release the finished songs, just the best of the best
I could add a question to Paul and his 'people' - "Why wait? ALL McCartney tracks will generate attention and questions. Why not release them now so we might get The Horse's Mouth to answer our questions?" He's been wonderfully talkative during this 2022-2023 NOW AND THEN period. I'd love to hear his descriptions of unreleased tracks.
He may not be releasing it. If he doesn’t own the songs then it’s just the label reselling the same thing over again, lp to cd to lp again.
@@daveduffy2823 I think he just doesn’t own the Beatles songs because of the 1970 or 69 Northern songs takeover that led to Michael Jackson eventually etc. After that, all of his solo songs are his own and with wings
Great review as always!
I listened to the Atmos mix through my home theatre system. And I must say that this McCartney album really has the best Atmos mix so far! They really put a lot of work into this one. When the orchestra hit me from behind on the title track it almost knocked me off the couch 😅 Atmos on headphones is fun but not nearly comparable to the listening experience a Atmos Home Theatre System gives you! 😃
Great review Andrew like always. But now that I know that the CD release is the same as the one of 2010, I will pass on buying this one. I'm still listening to CD's because they are less costly then the vinyl release. Cheers from Quebec Canada !
I’m a sucker for physical releases, and bought the 2-CD version, but disc 1 is admittedly redundant with the 2010 archive edition. I ended up only ripping disc 2 onto my MacBook and syncing with my iPhone, but the Underdubbed Mixes are available to purchase alone digitally on the iTunes Store for only $9.99 and is arguably the best deal for what we got out of this release.
A wonderful video, Andrew. I truly enjoyed your song by song analysis. Thank you for your honesty.
Glad you enjoyed it, Antonio!
Thanks for the video, Andrew! I just added the albums to my Apple Music library--- I listened to the first couple minutes of "Mamunia" and "No Words," and they sound excellent through my AirPods Pro. I have the 1999 and 2010 reissues on CD and this version sounds much more alive. Curiously, the Apple Music Atmos version does not contain "Helen Wheels." I haven't gone through "Underdubbed" yet but looking forward to it. And thanks for your headphone review!
Glad it was helpful!
Glad to see you're feeling better Handsome. Love your review on the new BOTR reissue. Haven't had a chance to listen to mine, but it sounds like i'm in for a treat.
I enjoy any new way to listen to albums I have listened to over a hundred times. Loved both.
The Under Dubs are interesting but not sure how often I would re visit them.
When im in the mood l listen to Paul,thisb is the album I go to This is His Masterpiece ❤
Can't seem to find this anywhere! Great video. found it. Ordered off Paul's site! Can't wait!
Honestly glad I watched your take on this set. I planned on just skipping over it and just enjoying my 2010 archive cd set as it has the bonus material. But, I just gave the underdubbed (which I agree the alternate tracklist along with the underdubbedness provides a refreshing listen and). And the atmos version of the main album is very nice as well. My favorite atmos album tho to date is actually not Beatles related, but Stephen Sanchez’s “Angel Face”. Worth a listen if you’ve never heard. Real nice 50s/60s r&b and rock n roll sound. Anyway thanks Andrew, cheers
I totally agree with you Andrew, I really enjoyed the underdubbed tracks a lot. I thought it was great. Too bad its not a standalone vinyl lp. Im tired of having to buy lps i already have. Sometimes more than one.
Id love to have Ram like this too.
See you next time.
Since you mentioned it, I have a sealed copy of the CBS Mastersound half-speed mastered LP. It still has the price sticker on the plastic cover: $13.59 (that's USD). According to an online inflation calculator, that would be $46.11 in 2024. For comparison, back in '79 or '80 when I bought the MFSL Abbey Road, it was about $17 (probably $16.99) as best I can recall. And when I started buying the UK imports in the late 70s, they were generally a penny or two under $9 or $10.
Great video!! I had preordered the 2CD… the underdubs sound good!! It was a fun listen. I was baffled at how much I enjoyed Jet… almost prefer it to the original!! Also, I agree, I’d really love if MPL/Paul (whoever) would finally put London Town and BTTE in the archive collection, and finish Wings’ discography!!
The underdubbed has been my main jam for the past week. It’s a fun listen.
I just wish they had offered the underdubbed alone. Most don’t need another band on the run.
I was excited for the underdubbed mixes because I so enjoyed the rough mixes and re-workings the Ramones did for the 40th anniversaries of their ‘70s albums. (1980’s End of the Century received the same treatment in 2020, but that’s sat on the shelf since then for frustratingly unspecified reasons.) Suffice to say that underdubbed did not disappoint, and Let Me Roll It is indeed the most compelling track in this form.
Your waveform visualizations definitely confirm what I'm hearing. This is a great pressing of a great album and a worthy new release in Paul's half-speed remaster series. The underdubbed LP is fun too, with Bluebird and Let Me Roll It being particular favorites. (What IS that sound during the intro of Let Me Roll It? A chicken?)
As for the still missing version of BOTR, we'll never hear it, because the stolen tape story looms large in the McCartney legend. He's not about to ruin one of his favorite oft-told interview answers by suddenly saying "Oh we had another copy all along."
Much like the beatles remixes it gives me a new way to listen to some of my favorite songs, i love how crisp some elements are in the rough mixes
Glad you are all recovered Andrew. Personally, I love to hear rough mix or "underdubbed" versions of albums. It gives a feel of how they were before all the polish arrives and gives the raw sound that I love. That is not to say that it works on all albums as sometimes they can actually just sound worse. However, with this album that contains some of my favourite Macca (and Wings) songs, I look forward to listening to it very soon (am awaiting a suitably opportune moment when I will not be disturbed!). Talking of which, I do feel it is a bit naughty that they are now labelling it as a Paul McCartney album. Bit unfair on Linda and Denny especially. Shame on the record company for changing it. I wonder why that is and what the upshot of it is royalty wise? Hmmmmmmm, just a thought. Any thoughts on this at your end Andrew? Anyway, great video as always. Thanks
I forgot to mention my favourite underdubbed mixes: Band on The run and Jet. See you next week
I just got the single 50th Anniversary, and am always unsure of "underdubbed" versions. Now I'm interested in hearing it.
Would love to see you undertake a McCartney album ranking or perhaps a shorter ranking such as a top 10 or 5 albums. Keep up the great work, I love the channel!
Excellent job as usual!!
Thank you! This was a very entertaining review, and frankly one of the first that hold the under dubbed to a positive level. I purchased the half speed stand alone, and felt it really shined in audio quality. I'm kind of regretting not picking up the under dubbed now. Maybe I'll get it too. Thank you for the quality work you do and for your enthusiasm you put into your reviews and research. Also enjoyed your Meze review, by the way where can you apply the Parlogram20 code?
Thank you, Bill. Glad you enjoyed it. You apply the code at checkout.
@@Parlogram I tried it at Amazon but it wouldn't take. The Maze site has them at backorder.
wish I could buy the double vinyl ! Paul's site won't ship to Australia. Not available elsewhere over here
Any thoughts on doing something in regards to the now past 50th anniversary of Ringo! ?
Well done as usual Andrew. So glad you are enjoying this new issue....but for me this just isn't enough. The underdubbed concept is ok but doesn't grab me the way original demos and outtakes would have. Sorry Paul...not this time. Cheers Andrew till next week!
Very informative, Andrew! - Roger
I’ve had a listen to some of the ‘underdubbed’ mixes - and while they are interesting, and really show what a great unit Denny, Linda and Paul were as a band, I don’t find they add anything more to Band On The Run. I’m still happy with my old vinyl copy, and will continue to play that. What I would like to hear are some of the demos - notably for Nineteen Hundred and Eighty Five, Bluebird and Jet.
I've been on the fence about the BOTR reissue *and* the headphones. Your video (and Meze discount code) helped seal the deal. 😀 Thanks! (And continued thanks for your great content.)
One other thing to note for Atmos, I had a pleasure this last week to hear, silly love songs on a pair of klipsch horn speakers. I understand what the mastering engineer of mobile Fidelity sound lab meant when he says good stereo will just outclass surroundsound and you won’t even need multiple channels. mind you this also, I think a lot of it being both the speakers, and the fact that was Macintosh amplifiers
I enjoyed listening to the underdubbed version of Band on the Run over at Apple Music. And I agree with what you said, it was interesting enough for me to listen to more than once Great video, and thanks for sharing.
Thanks Ronald. Glad you enjoyed it!
Let Me Roll It is one of my favorites and the new underdubbed version is now my favorite. Paul’s voice and the harmonies are more open and sound amazing, and I prefer how the lyrics are presented here compared to the released version. The rest of the tracks are very interesting but I still prefer most of the release versions except for Let Me Roll It. Although this set is tempting, I am probably going to stick with finding a UK original when I go on my trip to London.
Who would have said ten or 15 years ago that the LP records would return on the market, with more prestige than before? Who would have bet? Well, here they are. I have been brooding a lot of times about how the MP3 and the podcast are no good for real music, the music you really like. For the ones like me who spent their teen-years holding in their hands the records they loved, placing them on the furniture (standing and leaning against the wall) to look at them more often, well, you understand what I mean. They had pushed the MP3 too far, this is the right reaction. With MP3 you don’t own anything, you haven’t got anything in your hands, and you can lose it all if the flash memory goes nuts or if a virus cancels your hard disk. Let’s get back to the old good LPs!
With the news that Sam Mendes has been given complete access to Apples' archive to produce four biopics, can we expect an instalment on this exciting, upcoming event?
Great headphones got my discount...❤
I went for the two CD pack. I know it's the same master as the archive edition, but as I wasn't buying CDs in that era, this was my best option!
Thank You Andrew !!!! You rock !
Thanks for the always great video. Am listening to the Underdubbed Mix now, and the first thing that stands out is on BOTR, Paul's vocal is a different take - not as "polished" as the regular version.
Hello Andrew Great video as always!!!! I have not purchased this album I still have my original cd US version I am very disappointed that the cd is the 2010 virsion and that it wasn’t remixed it should have been I have heard a lot of negative comments about the underdubbed mixes I haven’t purchased any of the albums with the US obby strip Yes they look Great and I would like to own them but with out the guarantee that all the albums will come out this way, I don’t wanna start investing look what’s happened to the colored vinyl look what’s happened to the archive series? Everything is stopped why I don’t know but I don’t want to start purchasing just to be let down. If Abby Road and Nems consider the archive edition to be the best then why didn’t they continue with that series and as for the record why didn’t they just put out the 2010 version for the cd and vinyl again. Maybe I don’t know to much and am over speculating but the action of last doesn’t help me make a good decision to buy buy buy. I am hopeful for a NEW ALBUM THAT WILL MAKE ME HAPPY! Thanks for the video take care.
Hi Andrew, thank you for your new very informative video. It's my favourite McCartney solo album. Cheers Fred.
I'm loving the new half speed master! I got the single LP with the obi strip and the CD set. I'm hoping we get a re-release of Memory Almost Full soon. Also where's the Dolbly Atmos mix of the White Album? They released a few of the songs in Atmos for the new blue album so they should do the rest.
Thanks to your review Andrew I went ahead and ordered the 2 record vinyl set. As with most here I have several copies. I did not however get the 2010 archive edition (have all the others on vinyl)..I skipping it because it was released not too long after the 25th anniversary vinyl edition (1998)..I'm a huge collector but in this case was not interested in buying another copy just 12 years later. Again I was on the fence on this but your review pushed me off!
Great video im really curious about the other half speed masters if you have any info on how they sound as ive heard mixed things
Correct me if I’m wrong, but I found some of the underdubbed songs had different lead vocals, not just minus the orchestrations.
I picked this Lp up at our good Will Store here in iowa Mine is the original press from 1973. I would have to check But I think the copy I have is the US pressing. wow, 12 years ago.. I am not sure on the date ... but, some how, the LP is near mint looking! and plays good!
more stones! also, when you discuss different tracklists from different countries you should say which you prefer!
For the life of me, I don't get why some people are so dismissive of No Words. It's my second favorite song on the album, after Nineteen Hundred and Eighty Five. Paul even included No Words in Wings' live set, during their last tour in 1979. On the other hand, I am not a big fan of Helen Wheels. I think it disrupts the flow of the album.
It's because everyone likes different things, that's why. There's no universal truths here. You like blue, they like red. You like wooden kitchen cupboards, they like painted. You like Words, they don't. Way it is. Music would be way too boring and uninteresting if we all liked the SAME things. Ugh.
Nice review, Andrew. In my opinion the Underdubbed are definitely worth it... and that's it. The quality of the packaging is not up to scratch, I find the design for the underdubbed LP underwhelming and the sound of the remaster a bit flat (I haven't had the luck of listening to a 1st ed yet).
Enjoyed the review Andrew. Have you heard the CD, what does it sound like, is it brickwalled? I do have mixed feelings about ATMOS for headphones, it's different for sure but really doesn't knock me out. Cheers!
I love the updated remaster more than the 1999 remaster.
I’m a big fan of the -5/-6 Harry Moss cutting.
Just a question you may know ... On how many tracks does McCartney mention Sailor Sam?
Band On The Run / Helen Wheels ..... any more?
I can only think of two but it seems that there are many more.
Sailor Sam is a character from Rupert so I can see where Paul is coming from.