@Dark Matter this is what you have to stay away from, she is meek with her knowledge or the prowess to use her mind, so what devdutt did should be seen as dharma and not as win or smashing.
She only knows two things... 1. Ask stupid questions 2. then not listen to the answer fully and interrupt the speaker when the discussion does not go as per her philosophy. Very low level of crude knowledge.
When you invite someone like Devdutt for a productive discussion you should also have an intelligent enough moderator who can ask pertinent questions without interjecting his/ her opinions.
Devdutt hit the nail on the head when he said you are not curious instead judgemental. Therefore, if Shoma conducts an interview even the day after, she will still have the same questions. The whole point of a debate is to change our views if the other person can convince us. This is lacking in all our discussions. Both the parties have their views and are hell bent not to be convinced. Further, Devdutt makes a clear distinction between ill-informed interpretation and informed interpretations
I am not sure on what basis the interviewer is saying different classes of society did not have access to bodies of knowledge. Basaveshwara spread vedic knowledge to masses. In Karnataka people from all castes have written highly philosophical works. Ramanuja and Madhwacharya initiated lower caste people as brahmins. Kanakadasa was a Shepard, Sarvajna was from lower caste. A beggar on the street defeated Adi Shankara in philosophical argument. Vidyaranya, a brahmin helped hakka and bukka establish Vijayanagar empire but they were Shepherds.... every village will have one such story to tell.. But you won't know it by swallowing some communist garbage and puking it in public...
adarsha rao she doesn’t need basis apparently, the entire interview process seems to suggest, she has just browsed through some criticisms of Hinduism and didn’t make an effort to do any research, because she agreed with that side of the argument... seeking validation for one’s prejudices is what media has been reduced to today...
and not everyone depends on knowledge. There are different dharmic yoga paths which lead to the same truth. There is dhyana yoga, karma yoga, sanyasa yoga and bakthi yoga in addition to jnana yoga (wisdom/knowledge yoga)
She got caught red-handed, she cover-up by stating his work at end... These people are the real hidden breaking forces, who stay within and destroy country from within. If she is truthful at are last words, she will definitely follow dharma else karma will follow her...
Sadhguru says a beautiful thing about questioning (since i don't remember the exact words, i am trying to portray the meaning), it should not be to put down the other or having already decided on something but should come out of curiosity. When you see Shoma Chaudhary questioning, you understand where she is coming from.
Joseph Raj. A masterly exposition of Indian Thought. Dharma, Karma, Equality, Diversity etc explained with utmost clarity. The difference between Indian Thought and Judeo-Christian Perspective was well enunciated. That Justice, Right & Wrong etc are not Indian concepts at all - was made amply clear. The inclusive nature of Indian religions was also shown. All in all, a feast of a presentation. Great education to all learners.
Listening to & reading the strong opinions of Rajiv Malhotra (& his fanboys) about Devdutt Pattnaik, I avoided listening to Devdutt. But boy he was impressive here. So glad I listened to this.
Devdutt has a lot to contribute through his interpretations of, and sharing of Indian cultural ethos and stories. Having said that, some of the criticisms of rajiv malhotra about devdutt are valid, but I don't see that as a problem; in fact every intellectual has blind spots, including Mr. Malhotra..
Most disturbing was Devdutt striving to open bottle and drink water but that poor lady did not show basic courtesy to open cork for him as he could not put mike down to answer question whereas she had all the time to help. True face of arrogance of Shoma. She does not deserve to be anchor. Great answers by Devdutt and as always she wanted to show off her gyan.
Devdutt has shown, in this conversation, how balanced he could be in his arguements no matter how equivocal they may seem.The guy just explained himself in one of the examples that he quoted during this session where he talks about the difference between somebody who has read one book and somebody else who has read the whole library.
Wow this is the first time I listened to this guy.... i am mind boggled ... we shd put these guys on center stage to educate indians of what indians/hindus mean...
The way Devdutji has articulated his version of understanding of the concept of Dharma is pure bliss. I am now opened to a whole new paradigm of comprehending the Sanatan concept of Dharma. Seriously feel this is more deep an insight than any of the present day Babas/Gurus we have. Will be eagerly flowing Devdutji in the future.
Dis guy is smne who gt my respct.. salute to u.. N dis anchor is in a gud position to seek and REALIZE the knowledge.. knwledge need realization. Movies and tv series shd be made wid true realized knowledge of Mahabharata and Ramayana. It will help the society.
Brilliant! I love this man. He speaks on the untold side of religion and many awakened ones can hear him clearly what he speaks of. High praise for his wisdom and intelligence!
That's how you debate when someone is trying to bring you down to their own level, based on their own personal biases.. We will not just sit and take your word for it. Thank you Sir Devdutt.
Awesome Devdutt sir !! This lady does not deserve to interview you !! You really nailed her when u said ' you r not curious u r judging' ...she is a classic example of urban naxal !!
Subbu Swamy ??? The man who said, he would have taken up the Raffale issue if congress had not taken it up. ..... and now if he takes up, congress will get credit. *WHAT A SHAME* . in matters of national importance, corruption.... there is no egoism......fight for truth.
So when he is mocking the left he is suddenly your hero! Otherwise you berate him because someone has told you to. Be more flexible in the way you judge people. Sri Pattanaik is a learned man and he needs to be respected for that.
Please don't pitch Devdutt and Rajiv Malhotra against each other. They both are trying to do some good and restore the ethos and self respect in the country. So pls stop pitching them against each other. They both are equally good. We understand better and learn more as we grow, so don't cherry pick some of their past mistakes to defame them.
I totally Agree on ethis, Yes may be once he supported some lady abroad, I don't get her name who was anti Hinduism, But I've seen him always talk straight & jagg all these so called ass *#@$ leftists
rajiv malhotra do not claim himself guru he says he respects all gurus he is only bringing out how vested interests are damaging hinduism like islam slaughtered 80 million hindus still many people consider it is good religion and british changed our--- out look with vested interests by modifying cognitive sciences on the other hand mr.DDP considers himself as expert on hinduism represents as mythology he does not know the meaning of sanatana ( eternal) if hinduism is sanatan then how it is mythology he does not know hindu traditions or pramparas . University graduates in hinduism are just fools you have to have guru to experience the hinduism he is good entertainer he should admit he is not swami / he does not follow vedic traditions his mentors are western hindu scholars
@@vinsin328 @29:10..... wow !! What a Slap... A tight slap ..... !!!! Thanks Devdutt ! is this inspired by British and christian interpretation ??? do not get poisoned by rajiv malhotra ...... do ur own research. Thanks also to Malhotra for his works though.
"Dharma is not about being right or wrong"🔥🔥"Don't put Dharma/Adharma in the mould of Haram/Halaal or Good/Sin." Literally Devdutt's erudition on mythology is awesome.
Bravo Bravo Mr Pattnaik. I sense some mild dignified rage in your talk here. I am so happy that you putting shoma in place. I dunno why Rajiv Malhotra picked up a spat with you because you two should definitely reconcile and you are not a plagirist as Mr Malhotra alleges. . Can you two talk and make up please ? Your articulation in above talk completely absolves you of any citicism and i was struggling with how to articulate this and your talk hit the spot right on. Mr Rajiv malhotra should hear this and I am a fan of his to except when he becomes pugilistic unnecessary and would be great for you to meet in a civil setting and pool your ideas adn thoughts. For the sake of India it will be truly epic and benefit India.
Dp is primary ryhme type while RM is a University unto himself.. How can they even be in the same bracket.. DP is sold out, brown sepoy of like of w doniger.. RM is a scholar.. Into deep research with dedication, not doing for career but dharma..How can we compare the two.
@@sinara2 Those are all too subjective and honestly getting too personal in criticism. DP maybe self-taught and one needs to respect all types of scholars. If RM and DP cannot talk civily then both don't deserve to be called scholars. Its a sign of hubris and ahankar if criticism become visceral like this. They are not the same and honestly as a fan of both I refuse to be dragged into political camps..I am not a psychophant but I am so impressed with both when they talk. Both have spent years reading and studying. They could be in completely different planes but that is the beauty of the indian system. They have rights to intrepret and present and deserve to be respected. I hate mud-slinging and crass personalization or labelling. RM and another guy criticizes DP as anti-brahmin but in this talk he talks about brahminism wonderfully. As a audience lets be objective and not get carried away in the poison of the venom. Lets keep it civil and not get personal.
@@vinsin328 Tooo much of an ego issue. Calls narayan murty, a "robber barron"... has issues with ram madhav .... devdutt patnaik... gangs up with other Subbu swamy to defame modi .....
shes upset hes insulting her ..... but these people keep on and on insulting misrepresenting a large community for 100 odd years and expect then not to be upset about it..
I appreciate how he is generalising all his answers to all her targeted particular questions! Everything she questions Hinduism, he draws all other cultures and then asks her to see(darshan) and you decide!
DP is probably the first guest of SC who shone light on her shallow knowledge about her own roots who always puts Hindu society in bad light. He said each and every society has good and bad, but in SC’s closed mind Hindus were bad, still bad until Moguls and Christian conquered them. It is amazing there are people like her have a big mice who still are not decolonized, yearning for a foreign ruler and concepts. Social media is the answer for a person to figure out.
First of all I like to asks sorry to you sir because first time I understood you worngly you are really a great person and your speech is really inspiring thank you sir I am proud of you and Hindu thanks again
The word india is recent but,the word Bharata to describe India is 2000yr old,from the vishnupuran,and the Constitution of India also has accepted 2 names for the country,India and ""Bharata""
She is doing her job, don't be hard on her because of Tarun Tejpal- that man did wrong got his dues. She is asking queries so as Hindu we get a chance to express ourselves - who we are and let the world know. Its a process of discovery for me as well as a Hindu as I resonate with DEVDUTT's idea and proud to be a Hindu. To that extent she did a good job and to Devdutt many thanks for making me identify with myself as a Hindu and take pride in myself
Okay, so the host is asking historic questions to a mythologist. The caste system was brought in during colonization. That's why he compares the hierarchy with the access to BiBle. Until then we were provinces and tribes who had their own hierarchy. Following on Mahabharat or Ramayana was before all these colonies and mediaeval hierarchy system.
I m over whelmed by this session of Devdutt sahab. I hope we could find more figures in India who are of same knowledge stature. May u live long Devdutt sahab.
He has wonderfully understood and articulated hinduism finally. Glad he is slapping the half boiled egg left and right. but i like her as it is these people who gets right answers from great people.
Devdutt pattanaik is arrogant, but he has got real good insights into mythology! Round of applause to the moderator to such Grace and dignity in the face of so many insults!
Interestingly this time our beloved Shoma prepared with few questions that have been debated by our communists, evangelists and rationalists to negate our history. She is always trying to target all the people who working to bring back our true past (even targeting an individual by calling NRI) such a vindictive manner. Not sure what all these people want our India to be or our culture to be. Devdutt ji really open up their falsified beliefs by answering and challenging every of wrong perception of them. Wonderful job sir...all respects to you. As you know, our approach is to unfold wisdom by debate, discussions (eg: Shankara, Ramanuja, Madhwacharya etc) and improving ones interpretations, so there is nothing wrong in disagreements from other scholars. At the end of the day, we wanted to reach truth.
Every knowledge system has levels. For example only a person with PHD can become a professor, or a person with a medical degree can become a Doctor. Hinduism also followed a similar system the level of knowledge a person receives is based on his character (guna), his actions (karma) and his other qualifications. This was never to be controlled based on a persons birth. As long as spiritual level was high this was a no brainer. Once ego started taking greater importance than the soul then the inappropriate restrictions crept in.
If you want to know more about the caste system and why there was no revolution by dalits in your country (never questioned by your countrymen) try this article bit.ly/1ScKYol
If I was in her place I would have gone on a tirade and indicated to him to hand over the mic momentarily so the man can have a sip of water. This is uncomfortable and she should have helped him out. That is Dharma.
![I.N "HALLUCINATION" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/n5B5q1Hwt_U/mqdefault.jpg)
Ohh man!! those subtle punches he throws occasionally with a slight change of tone ! Eloquently articulated.
Devdutt is Smashing here.!! Well done
And good thing is that Soma knows,she is being smashed.
@Dark Matter this is what you have to stay away from, she is meek with her knowledge or the prowess to use her mind, so what devdutt did should be seen as dharma and not as win or smashing.
Devdutt's savage level= infinity
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
when he calls her out - whoa! i want to be like that.. LOL
Does shoma chaudhury actually know anything other than words like ethos and resonance ?
😂😂
rashida sitabkhan hahaha..good observation 👍🏼😜
😆😅
She only knows two things... 1. Ask stupid questions 2. then not listen to the answer fully and interrupt the speaker when the discussion does not go as per her philosophy. Very low level of crude knowledge.
lol
he totally killed her... shes sounding so idiotic .. and she gets angry when shown the mirror!!!
She is behavin lile my stupid sister.
@@vijubabu3685 na.she is only superior idiot :) :)
Wow !!! The depth of his knowledge and wisdom
“What colour dress does the celibate men wear??” WTF is wrong with the anchor🤷🏻♀️ Good that Mr Pattnaik did not fall for her ideological mousetraps.
exactly that was like WTF moment
@@suwarnaca9595 the answer is white. All nuns and priests wear it. But she wouldn't have digested that answer ;)
@@saketrashmi 😂😂
That's the question where her true colour came to surface.
She's Shitty Tharoor's hoor 😶🙄
When you invite someone like Devdutt for a productive discussion you should also have an intelligent enough moderator who can ask pertinent questions without interjecting his/ her opinions.
Couldnt have put any more appropriately.. 👍
Seriously it's hard to find someone who can face Devdutt and his facts....
She can not be more intelligent than this... You are expecting too much out of no body..
Ummm well yeah but, I think he's full of shit. I suggest reading and watching Nityanad Mishra instead. Namaskar.
This is honestly the best interview of Devdutt Pattanaik.
The lady talks too much without any study ...
becoz she is head long
True. This lady just talks without any substance altogether.
Everywhere the problem is same . Extremely crude and illiterate people made as anchor/ moderator and they ask silly questions.
@@hiralm530 she is doing good by asking and debating things becoming more clear
She has a point. She's doing exactly what a hindu and a citizen of India does that is to question
Devdutt hit the nail on the head when he said you are not curious instead judgemental. Therefore, if Shoma conducts an interview even the day after, she will still have the same questions. The whole point of a debate is to change our views if the other person can convince us. This is lacking in all our discussions. Both the parties have their views and are hell bent not to be convinced. Further, Devdutt makes a clear distinction between ill-informed interpretation and informed interpretations
Brilliant. My only request when i get into a debate is, "if your points are solid, I will change my position, will you do the same?"
I am not sure on what basis the interviewer is saying different classes of society did not have access to bodies of knowledge. Basaveshwara spread vedic knowledge to masses. In Karnataka people from all castes have written highly philosophical works. Ramanuja and Madhwacharya initiated lower caste people as brahmins. Kanakadasa was a Shepard, Sarvajna was from lower caste. A beggar on the street defeated Adi Shankara in philosophical argument. Vidyaranya, a brahmin helped hakka and bukka establish Vijayanagar empire but they were Shepherds.... every village will have one such story to tell.. But you won't know it by swallowing some communist garbage and puking it in public...
adarsha rao she doesn’t need basis apparently, the entire interview process seems to suggest, she has just browsed through some criticisms of Hinduism and didn’t make an effort to do any research, because she agreed with that side of the argument... seeking validation for one’s prejudices is what media has been reduced to today...
and not everyone depends on knowledge. There are different dharmic yoga paths which lead to the same truth. There is dhyana yoga, karma yoga, sanyasa yoga and bakthi yoga in addition to jnana yoga (wisdom/knowledge yoga)
Can you tell me who defeated Adi Shankaracharya in debate ? Curious
@@shivvyas8835 A chandala once asked a tough question to Shankaracharya, which actually turned his life.
Very well written bro... ☺️
She got caught red-handed, she cover-up by stating his work at end... These people are the real hidden breaking forces, who stay within and destroy country from within.
If she is truthful at are last words, she will definitely follow dharma else karma will follow her...
haha.. one of the best comments
Right
@30:57 Devdut finally manages to open that bottle and have a sip 😅
but thats only after the Tightest Slap he gives her @29:10..... wow !! What a Slap...
Thanks Devdutt !
@@kushaltm6325 😂👏👏👏
Abhisar She is no match for Devedutt's intellect.
haha bro i was also waiting for that... give the man some water lol
Amazing sir...I think everyone should learn that this is the real Hinduism
Devdatt after studying lot .now he is on right track. First time I watched full video
Sadhguru says a beautiful thing about questioning (since i don't remember the exact words, i am trying to portray the meaning), it should not be to put down the other or having already decided on something but should come out of curiosity. When you see Shoma Chaudhary questioning, you understand where she is coming from.
One of best line of SADHGURU that ( INDIA IS A LAND OF SEEKER NOT THE LAND OF BELIEVER)
I am lucky to be a Hindu. We have the right to ask for explanations. There are religions where you can't even question
My my 😂 this one just got thoroughly schooled by Mr Pattnaik.
Savage✌👏👏👏👏well-done devdutt sir
The booze n beef lady would never understand the hindu religion in spite of born on the land
Don't call it a religion.
Nobody understand hindu Relgion. Not even you.
If we dig deep Beef was very much a part of hindu culture ,I t was brahamism which enforced strict vegetarian diet .
Bahadur Tuber To be better than our baser animal self. Dev also talks about in the start.
Joseph Raj. A masterly exposition of Indian Thought. Dharma, Karma, Equality, Diversity etc explained with utmost clarity. The difference between Indian Thought and Judeo-Christian Perspective was well enunciated. That Justice, Right & Wrong etc are not Indian concepts at all - was made amply clear. The inclusive nature of Indian religions was also shown. All in all, a feast of a presentation. Great education to all learners.
Listening to & reading the strong opinions of Rajiv Malhotra (& his fanboys) about Devdutt Pattnaik, I avoided listening to Devdutt. But boy he was impressive here. So glad I listened to this.
Devdutt has a lot to contribute through his interpretations of, and sharing of Indian cultural ethos and stories. Having said that, some of the criticisms of rajiv malhotra about devdutt are valid, but I don't see that as a problem; in fact every intellectual has blind spots, including Mr. Malhotra..
@Nathulal Dubey exactly,im a fan of Rajiv Ji.But we still need both to fend off foreign propagandists.
Most disturbing was Devdutt striving to open bottle and drink water but that poor lady did not show basic courtesy to open cork for him as he could not put mike down to answer question whereas she had all the time to help. True face of arrogance of Shoma. She does not deserve to be anchor. Great answers by Devdutt and as always she wanted to show off her gyan.
Devdutt has shown, in this conversation, how balanced he could be in his arguements no matter how equivocal they may seem.The guy just explained himself in one of the examples that he quoted during this session where he talks about the difference between somebody who has read one book and somebody else who has read the whole library.
He is a good author. I learn a lot. The concept of LSD is great.
Wow this is the first time I listened to this guy.... i am mind boggled ... we shd put these guys on center stage to educate indians of what indians/hindus mean...
The way Devdutji has articulated his version of understanding of the concept of Dharma is pure bliss. I am now opened to a whole new paradigm of comprehending the Sanatan concept of Dharma. Seriously feel this is more deep an insight than any of the present day Babas/Gurus we have. Will be eagerly flowing Devdutji in the future.
very very invigorating thought process by Devdutt
Dis guy is smne who gt my respct.. salute to u..
N dis anchor is in a gud position to seek and REALIZE the knowledge.. knwledge need realization.
Movies and tv series shd be made wid true realized knowledge of Mahabharata and Ramayana. It will help the society.
I've seen all of Algebras events on RUclips. Please keep bringing back devdutt pattanaik every year...
let's include abrahmic and islamic and christian "Mythology" and debate on their MYTHS
No liberal/secular can dare to do that.
They will simply play minority card or ran away. Abrahmic philosophy are shallow and have no depth. Exclusivit
Brilliant! I love this man. He speaks on the untold side of religion and many awakened ones can hear him clearly what he speaks of. High praise for his wisdom and intelligence!
Every Action has Consequence.. Hinduism proves the nature of law..
That's how you debate when someone is trying to bring you down to their own level, based on their own personal biases.. We will not just sit and take your word for it. Thank you Sir Devdutt.
Anchor lady just know English, but to talk with Devadat anchor should have knowledge too...
Awesome Devdutt sir !! This lady does not deserve to interview you !! You really nailed her when u said ' you r not curious u r judging' ...she is a classic example of urban naxal !!
Isn't this the same anchor who gets own by Dr Swamy every year on this panel ?
hahaha yeah
Subbu Swamy ??? The man who said, he would have taken up the Raffale issue if congress had not taken it up. ..... and now if he takes up, congress will get credit.
*WHAT A SHAME* . in matters of national importance, corruption.... there is no egoism......fight for truth.
Yes she is😁
@@kushaltm6325
That doesn't change the fact that she get ripped apart by swamy everytime.
@@kushaltm6325 another whinner spotted..devdutt sir pls domesticize this one too..
Devdutt is finally reading properly after getting some smack from Malhotra and Nityanand Misra
Yes bro I just watched them debunking him.
Yes.
He is directly attacking the Sadhu samaj. How has he improved ?
So when he is mocking the left he is suddenly your hero!
Otherwise you berate him because someone has told you to.
Be more flexible in the way you judge people.
Sri Pattanaik is a learned man and he needs to be respected for that.
@UCGRtB42FB4Sh0L2I_iUw2QA yes he is a doniger bhakt. What more can be expected of him.
Even on my worst day I can sleep while hearing this session ❤❤🔥
Love you Devdutt
You’re saving our ideas and nobility
Thank you
A beautiful excerpt, and I again fell in love with who I am, proud to be an Indian, proud to be Hindu.
You showed that india is having gr8 brains....
yup , but he is not one of them ... He is just a fiction writer dont take him very seriously ...
@@believeroflight9888 yup I think every algebra viewer already knew that .. that's why they named it ALGEBRA 😃
People may criticize the anchor but because of her questions we are understanding best of our history and culture either you like it or not.
Finally he was able to grab some water at 31:00 🧐🤣
Thnx Algerba for presenting before us the intellectual conversation.
Please don't pitch Devdutt and Rajiv Malhotra against each other. They both are trying to do some good and restore the ethos and self respect in the country. So pls stop pitching them against each other. They both are equally good. We understand better and learn more as we grow, so don't cherry pick some of their past mistakes to defame them.
I totally Agree on ethis, Yes may be once he supported some lady abroad, I don't get her name who was anti Hinduism, But I've seen him always talk straight & jagg all these so called ass *#@$ leftists
It is Rajiv Malhotra who likes to fight with others. His interpretation is influenced by British and Christians Interpretation, nothing more.
rajiv malhotra do not claim himself guru he says he respects all gurus he is only bringing out how vested interests are damaging hinduism like islam slaughtered 80 million hindus still many people consider it is good religion and british changed our--- out look with vested interests by modifying cognitive sciences on the other hand mr.DDP considers himself as expert on hinduism represents as mythology he does not know the meaning of sanatana ( eternal) if hinduism is sanatan then how it is mythology he does not know hindu traditions or pramparas . University graduates in hinduism are just fools you have to have guru to experience the hinduism he is good entertainer he should admit he is not swami / he does not follow vedic traditions his mentors are western hindu scholars
@@vinsin328 @29:10..... wow !! What a Slap... A tight slap ..... !!!!
Thanks Devdutt !
is this inspired by British and christian interpretation ???
do not get poisoned by rajiv malhotra ...... do ur own research.
Thanks also to Malhotra for his works though.
Totally very proud of Devdutt!
Am not happy to say this ... but she had a me too moment here
This tug-of-war or "Manthan" of words has clarified some of the most inarticulated ideas of "Indism". Thanks to Algebra for organising this "samvaad".
It is good that in this kind of discussion an uneducated girl gets the opportunity of being guided and enlightened. It is a good initiative.
@devdutta you are pure beauty.. At his best!! There's always more than What meets to the eyes about Him..
marvelous, brain storming speech by Devdutt Sir.Each and every sentence carries a deep knowledge of Indian Culture. Overwhelmed by his speech..
"Dharma is not about being right or wrong"🔥🔥"Don't put Dharma/Adharma in the mould of Haram/Halaal or Good/Sin." Literally Devdutt's erudition on mythology is awesome.
Bravo Bravo Mr Pattnaik. I sense some mild dignified rage in your talk here. I am so happy that you putting shoma in place. I dunno why Rajiv Malhotra picked up a spat with you because you two should definitely reconcile and you are not a plagirist as Mr Malhotra alleges. .
Can you two talk and make up please ? Your articulation in above talk completely absolves you of any citicism and i was struggling with how to articulate this and your talk hit the spot right on. Mr Rajiv malhotra should hear this and I am a fan of his to except when he becomes pugilistic unnecessary and would be great for you to meet in a civil setting and pool your ideas adn thoughts. For the sake of India it will be truly epic and benefit India.
Dp is primary ryhme type while RM is a University unto himself.. How can they even be in the same bracket.. DP is sold out, brown sepoy of like of w doniger.. RM is a scholar.. Into deep research with dedication, not doing for career but dharma..How can we compare the two.
@@sinara2 Those are all too subjective and honestly getting too personal in criticism. DP maybe self-taught and one needs to respect all types of scholars. If RM and DP cannot talk civily then both don't deserve to be called scholars. Its a sign of hubris and ahankar if criticism become visceral like this. They are not the same and honestly as a fan of both I refuse to be dragged into political camps..I am not a psychophant but I am so impressed with both when they talk. Both have spent years reading and studying.
They could be in completely different planes but that is the beauty of the indian system. They have rights to intrepret and present and deserve to be respected. I hate mud-slinging and crass personalization or labelling. RM and another guy criticizes DP as anti-brahmin but in this talk he talks about brahminism wonderfully. As a audience lets be objective and not get carried away in the poison of the venom. Lets keep it civil and not get personal.
Rajiv Malhotra has an ego issue.
@@vinsin328 Tooo much of an ego issue.
Calls narayan murty, a "robber barron"... has issues with ram madhav .... devdutt patnaik... gangs up with other Subbu swamy to defame modi .....
@@kushaltm6325
Whats wrong with narayan murthy being called a spade?
EQUALITY OR DIVERSITY - BRAHMANICAL AVARICE WOW - YOU R ON FIRE
Because of her questions , I feel proud to be part of this great culture
I heard the lady saying ethos and resonance so many times...
Its the abrahimic method... *Spell check.. its her narrative..
shes upset hes insulting her ..... but these people keep on and on insulting misrepresenting a large community for 100 odd years and expect then not to be upset about it..
Suwarna Alur it’s more like he is educating her, but for a “know it all” it seems like an insult... she is the definition of pseudo intellectual
@@nupurkhare7941 yea... I'm just thinking about how upset the Hindu community needs to be on the basis of how she gets offended
Wow. Proud of being a Hindu. Persons like Devdutt ji are modern Swami Vivekananda who are rising every Hindu head high.
At last Devdutt opened the water bottle...Hat off Devdutt.....truely worthwhile
Finally the verdict has been given by Devdatt ji after 41.20, listen 👏
This is masterpiece!!!
Salute to Devdutt Patnaik. 😊
Beautiful articulation of principles of Hinduism.
Devdutt - is a master piece in Hindu mythology...
I appreciate how he is generalising all his answers to all her targeted particular questions!
Everything she questions Hinduism, he draws all other cultures and then asks her to see(darshan) and you decide!
Devdutt Pattanaik is Absolute Genius
Every action has conseq
uence- Beautiful description.Newton's Law is lifted out of Hinduism.
Very insightful talk. Thanks for uploading.
DP is probably the first guest of SC who shone light on her shallow knowledge about her own roots who always puts Hindu society in bad light.
He said each and every society has good and bad, but in SC’s closed mind Hindus were bad, still bad until Moguls and Christian conquered them. It is amazing there are people like her have a big mice who still are not decolonized, yearning for a foreign ruler and concepts. Social media is the answer for a person to figure out.
devdutt s interpretetion is superb.i always thought mahabharata was somewhat flawed but ge changed my view
Very nice articulation. Nicely translated and transcended. Kudos to Mr. Patnaik. Host too was quite graceful.
First of all I like to asks sorry to you sir because first time I understood you worngly you are really a great person and your speech is really inspiring thank you sir I am proud of you and Hindu thanks again
The word india is recent but,the word Bharata to describe India is 2000yr old,from the vishnupuran,and the Constitution of India also has accepted 2 names for the country,India and ""Bharata""
One of the mobile University of India with supra explaining power!!!
Somebody need to make this man Devdutt Indias education minister. Maybe the Odisha govt.can think on those lines.
She is doing her job, don't be hard on her because of Tarun Tejpal- that man did wrong got his dues. She is asking queries so as Hindu we get a chance to express ourselves - who we are and let the world know. Its a process of discovery for me as well as a Hindu as I resonate with DEVDUTT's idea and proud to be a Hindu. To that extent she did a good job and to Devdutt many thanks for making me identify with myself as a Hindu and take pride in myself
Only if Devdutt stopped using the word "myth" for everything. Some are meant to be, some are not. :)
After a long time I see a real Dev dutt Patnaik
wow Devdutt...
Okay, so the host is asking historic questions to a mythologist. The caste system was brought in during colonization. That's why he compares the hierarchy with the access to BiBle. Until then we were provinces and tribes who had their own hierarchy. Following on Mahabharat or Ramayana was before all these colonies and mediaeval hierarchy system.
I m over whelmed by this session of Devdutt sahab. I hope we could find more figures in India who are of same knowledge stature. May u live long Devdutt sahab.
Informed and ill-informed interpretation,! Brilliant Sir. We see lot the latter these days in India (self-styled 'secular' "intellectuals").
Only today, I understood the clear meaning of Dharma.
I got bould... 👌 he speaks n makes everyone Undersrand so well it is of some great level
The interviewer is extremely rude; she is more interested in pushing her own interpretations instead of....
Agree In the beginning only she interrupted by commenting about some color of clothes. So that shows her mindset
He has wonderfully understood and articulated hinduism finally. Glad he is slapping the half boiled egg left and right. but i like her as it is these people who gets right answers from great people.
Friends she is just asking questions not debating. Please understand that.... She is good interviewer.
Respected Devdutt is so precise in his every single point..
Wow!! God! He could strip with his words!
Devdutt pattanaik is arrogant, but he has got real good insights into mythology!
Round of applause to the moderator to such Grace and dignity in the face of so many insults!
he is not arrogant , but this is only to her, she is a Pseudo liberal, just to break her and her kind of people he did this.....
Interestingly this time our beloved Shoma prepared with few questions that have been debated by our communists, evangelists and rationalists to negate our history. She is always trying to target all the people who working to bring back our true past (even targeting an individual by calling NRI) such a vindictive manner. Not sure what all these people want our India to be or our culture to be.
Devdutt ji really open up their falsified beliefs by answering and challenging every of wrong perception of them. Wonderful job sir...all respects to you.
As you know, our approach is to unfold wisdom by debate, discussions (eg: Shankara, Ramanuja, Madhwacharya etc) and improving ones interpretations, so there is nothing wrong in disagreements from other scholars. At the end of the day, we wanted to reach truth.
Every knowledge system has levels. For example only a person with PHD can become a professor, or a person with a medical degree can become a Doctor. Hinduism also followed a similar system the level of knowledge a person receives is based on his character (guna), his actions (karma) and his other qualifications. This was never to be controlled based on a persons birth. As long as spiritual level was high this was a no brainer. Once ego started taking greater importance than the soul then the inappropriate restrictions crept in.
If you want to know more about the caste system and why there was no revolution by dalits in your country (never questioned by your countrymen) try this article bit.ly/1ScKYol
First watch the segment from 41:22 to 42:15 and then start from the beginning.. Everything will make sense to u..
So profound ideas! I am amazed..
If I was in her place I would have gone on a tirade and indicated to him to hand over the mic momentarily so the man can have a sip of water. This is uncomfortable and she should have helped him out. That is Dharma.
Wow Devdutt Sir ...... really made her stutter.
in absolute love with Devdutt from 29:14 to 32:48 :D
patnaik owned this conversation.....
There are no Hindu myths or Hindu Mythology
There were facts n for real
42.00 just excellent 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Devdutt sir rocked