2:52 First comments/questions by participating HongKongers. 6:03 New comments/questions 9:20 New comments/questions 12:55 New comments/questions [As I find most of these comments/questions by HongKongers are so wise and insightful, I'll try to add more timecodes if I can find time. Unfortunately, after a few minutes of listening, I lost interest in Ms. Lam's broken record style of answers so I won't waste time tracking them.] 1:56:20 New comments/questions 2:00:27 New comments/questions (Six former 中6生) 2:04:17 New comments/questions 1:50:30 (Fact check needed!) Is she a POLICE OFFICIER (??) as 吳文遠 Avery Ng seem to try to point out in his post (with photo) facebook.com/Ng.ManYuen/photos/a.700176220011257/3187156574646530/?type=3&theater Police officier is HongKonger too and is entitled to her/his views. BUT IF (fact checking needed) this lady is indeed pretending to be a regular citizen and saying she is NOT "afraid of police" when she herself is a police officier, then this gives the impression of dishonesty and misrepresentation as she would OF COURSE NOT AFRAID OF POLICE as a member of the force. For her sake and HK sake, I hope there is some mixup here. HK has enough trouble already!
expectation to every town hall = 1st day of protest : those has no accountability for incompetence , will not to serve moral obligation towards those who serve
At 51:32... This man raised various practical issues, about jobs economy etc., saying previous speakers were focused too much on HK politic situation....but, do you not know, that politics affects every thing we do....we could have the best jobs, good housing, good future, but all can be destroyed, overnight, by a simple change in the CCP policy, which they have dictatorship power, to change , anytime they seevfit. We can have lots of Jack Ma in Hong Kong, and then just like the real Jack Ma, have to give up his control of Alibaba, his dream, very likely, all because of CCP wanting to take over all your hard work to benefit the CCP party leaders. So, without a legal system to protect me, why would I work so hard, to eventually risk losing all my effort, when the CCP wants to ?
I watch this from the USA, HongKongers STRONG. Lam is insulting our intelligences, she is not qualify to lead Hong Kong. She must step down. This Q & A is a joke. Quality questions, poorly answers from Lam is all I hear. Step down is only way one.
The lady at 37:38....totally wrong in many aspects...the government money all come from the people, therefore, any salary paid by the government is really paid by the people. Yes, teach the children about the history of China, both the good and the bad, about the millions of people died from culture revolution, about Tinanamen Square, in addition to whatever "good" achievement the country has achieve. Even a young child would ask...why do I have no choice and why my parents do not have the right, to influence my education, to educate me about moral values, about justice and human rights issues that we I'll affect my future very seriously . You think the children nowadays are as dumb as you are, even now, as an adult ?
林太，好多謝你，令香港咁多人團結一齊，有同一個目標為香港既未來，林太你己經任務完成，請你功成身退 唔該
是的，团结一致的毁了香港
林鄭對話前在《紐時》撰文 重申對撤銷控罪訴求不能妥協
www.rfa.org/cantonese/news/htm/HK-Carrie-09262019084504.html
大陆的朋友，我在我的youtube主页做了这个视频的普通话字幕。有兴趣可以进我主页，点击右下方CC字幕选择"Chinese simplified"
所有香港市民都必須全力支持警察逮捕暴力示威者, 支持盡快立蒙面法, 很多罪犯都犯這罪, 讓香港回到和平生活的城市.
Iris lol 香港快此將管治權交給中華人民共和國，共管商界，所有市民，所有香港政府機構，我們的市民財產，我想信这個城市就會好安全，好平靜，好和平了
2:52 First comments/questions by participating HongKongers.
6:03 New comments/questions
9:20 New comments/questions
12:55 New comments/questions
[As I find most of these comments/questions by HongKongers are so wise and insightful, I'll try to add more timecodes if I can find time. Unfortunately, after a few minutes of listening, I lost interest in Ms. Lam's broken record style of answers so I won't waste time tracking them.]
1:56:20 New comments/questions
2:00:27 New comments/questions (Six former 中6生)
2:04:17 New comments/questions
1:50:30 (Fact check needed!) Is she a POLICE OFFICIER (??) as 吳文遠 Avery Ng seem to try to point out in his post (with photo) facebook.com/Ng.ManYuen/photos/a.700176220011257/3187156574646530/?type=3&theater
Police officier is HongKonger too and is entitled to her/his views. BUT IF (fact checking needed) this lady is indeed pretending to be a regular citizen and saying she is NOT "afraid of police" when she herself is a police officier, then this gives the impression of dishonesty and misrepresentation as she would OF COURSE NOT AFRAID OF POLICE as a member of the force. For her sake and HK sake, I hope there is some mixup here. HK has enough trouble already!
建議林鄭喺下次的「社區對話」開始之前請愛國愛港的肥媽獻上經典名曲「嘥氣」嚟營造氣氛。
做夠show未？
Violence is never encouraged. No matter police or mobster.(Sorry I do not agree they are ordinary citizens. They destroyed all my life.)
這對話會特首林鄭月娥只答應聆聽，沒有答應過其他訴求會立刻回應或者答應。
林鄭不是在听民眾议见，不是想解決问题，而是在'对问题进行绞辯。
天雷給她 一巴掌
表示香港 的立場
人民立誓 再歸來
清算五年 的舊賬
毛澤東說：
「世界上沒有無緣無故的愛，
也沒有緣無故的恨。」
expectation to every town hall = 1st day of protest : those has no accountability for incompetence , will not to serve moral obligation towards those who serve
將來如果可以將林鄭月娥定罪的話,不要判她監禁,罰她當眾裸跑作為應有的懲罰!惡女人最怕這種懲罰!個人意見!
港人素质真高，每一个发言者素质都是如此的高，要在大陆不知会出多少丑
@林鄭onL99 这条狗也好友素质呢，会自己上厕所的呢，真乖
其實這種對話會是浪費公帑，是沒有结果的對話!
1:47 C37 red shit woman is a retired law enforcement officer 🤕
對話會？我以為係911反恐會😂😂D保安嚴到🤣
momo So The rioters could not be ignored. Security shall be well set up. It makes no sense to doubt it.
@@vinck.6847 The riot is caused by the government and the police.
Thx for RFA coverage. 我要真普選！
咁叫對話？對咩話？佢只係造場Show 再過多一兩場 咪好似4點阿黑蛇Show咁
點解 唔問獨立委員會除咗黑警驚 係查到何妖後邊嘅人點查 查到邊個位截？所以係唔係唔可以成立獨立委員會原因？
多谢RFA帮大家指出左特首甘令人发指既目的！不过等等，你又唔系特首你点知特首有咩目的？哦，我明白了，你系推测的。作为媒体以一己之见为了影响睇视频既各位很方便地为了大家定义了这个对话的目的。见识了，香港媒体！
從家春秋的年代學生已經參與政治!
林很优秀
林郑浪费紧特首的宝贵时间 根本冇必要对话 因为尼班人的目标系解散警队 推翻现有政府 抢夺管治权 你答应区地个五大诉求 继续会有六大,七大,八大, 九大,百大诉求 特区政府根本冇可能做到! 现时政府要做呱系止暴制乱 比足够支持警队 让警队继续强硬执法 有任何困难应向中共政请求忇助 如果继续拖拖拉拉 受苦的还是香港普罗大众 特区政府应舍小保多 才是生存之道
能不能加个字幕 大陆同胞表示听不懂
大陆的朋友，我在我的youtube主页做了这个视频的普通话字幕。有兴趣可以进我主页，点击右下方CC字幕选择"Chinese simplified"
完全聽不懂 嗚嗚 粵語I can’t!
這麼多自己友在這𥚃問問題和回答問題。
41分的卷髮姐姐講得幾好。
其實我覺得他們真的就是想要你真誠的道歉，你之前太高高在上太自信太自以為是啊。可惜，現在真的有點晚了，就在200萬人的時候你能像現在這樣真的稍微有點態度的聽大家說，就不會搞成今天這樣了。香港確實真的不是內地啊，不能那樣高高在上，很討人厭啊。但，真的，太暴力了現在。
大家真係對ccp好恐懼，有一種來自傳說中的，再在自我想象中渲染下咁的升級恐懼感咁樣~🤦🏿♀️
Carie lam is merciful Hongkongers really ....????Or love chinazi fascist..... Or love Money 💰💰💰💵💵....Or position.... She is in POWER
林鄭onL99
越搞越大鑊、已經沒公信、存要用黑警份民市對話、無辱市民的智慧、如𠺢政府是面對緊一班未來主人翁、佢哋審查能力非常高
没有中文听不懂
香港大部份市民…… 諗多左
香港人要既民主，已經好早好早就經已失去了
我剛再看這問答大會。
香港最大的問題是人口太多，有人便有問題的了，不過這幾年因為又出現移民潮及出生率下降，人口數字也減低了。
沒有一個國家有完全的民主自由的，北美的國家也沒有完全的民主自由! 香港是屬於中國的，中國是共產國家，更加不可能有完全的民主自由! 我也感到很可惜及可悲!
根本沒有诚意，这样假对话，简直是多于，不会解决问題的，只有把套在的自己头上的绞绳越拉越紧。
天雷給她 一巴掌
表示香港 的立場
人民立誓 再歸來
清算五年 的舊賬
毛澤東說：
「世界上沒有無緣無故的愛，
也沒有緣無故的恨。」
毛泽东还说过，香港这地方就是庙小妖风大，池浅王八多，吃枣药丸
警察及政府犯法，為什麼不依法去做。
你可以移民去美国了，滚吧，！哪里有自由，你就去当狗好了。
来来。你说说警察和政府犯法的点在哪里，我们用法律来说话
其實佢自己決定唔到下唔下台，中國一定唔俾，如果佢強行下台就全家性命難保，仲要之後無中國俾既福利及職位，調轉係自己也會死頂到任期滿才能下台，佢理得你香港700萬人生死如何，這是自保本能，不能怪佢。而且誰能保證下任特首比林鄭好？不過我估計下任特首，一定是比之前既所有特首更強硬既親中派
呢位琛蓝絲小姐不如叫林鄭收佢做＂靚＂啦！
At 51:32... This man raised various practical issues, about jobs economy etc., saying previous speakers were focused too much on HK politic situation....but, do you not know, that politics affects every thing we do....we could have the best jobs, good housing, good future, but all can be destroyed, overnight, by a simple change in the CCP policy, which they have dictatorship power, to change , anytime they seevfit. We can have lots of Jack Ma in Hong Kong, and then just like the real Jack Ma, have to give up his control of Alibaba, his dream, very likely, all because of CCP wanting to take over all your hard work to benefit the CCP party leaders. So, without a legal system to protect me, why would I work so hard, to eventually risk losing all my effort, when the CCP wants to ?
tennis sport Everything can be destroyed by violence. No excuse.
I watch this from the USA, HongKongers STRONG. Lam is insulting our intelligences, she is not qualify to lead Hong Kong. She must step down. This Q & A is a joke. Quality questions, poorly answers from Lam is all I hear. Step down is only way one.
你無能不立法
To me, political neutral. But no excuse for violence and never forgive.
香港就係共產黨.
林鄭在做戲， 劇本一早寫好了， 一眾演員落力演出。 如果真諮詢市民， 就夠膽叫毛孟靜上台
The lady at 37:38....totally wrong in many aspects...the government money all come from the people, therefore, any salary paid by the government is really paid by the people. Yes, teach the children about the history of China, both the good and the bad, about the millions of people died from culture revolution, about Tinanamen Square, in addition to whatever "good" achievement the country has achieve. Even a young child would ask...why do I have no choice and why my parents do not have the right, to influence my education, to educate me about moral values, about justice and human rights issues that we I'll affect my future very seriously . You think the children nowadays are as dumb as you are, even now, as an adult ?
過主啦！！林鄭快下台啦……一路不好走💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩
傻逼
唔係相傳話佢想quit，上面唔俾佢quit咩？要fix完件事先咩…佢引發的修例
不同形式的對話、由現在開始！
我絕對不認同人人平等
政府及警察依法工作，#取消行政爆力，如警察有号碼及便衣有委任证。 遊行人及警察的暴力要降级，#如果政府及警隊一哥出來向傳媒講警察必須有号碼顯示及便衣必須出示委任証及不打頭，暴力一定減到最低或無。
反对者是否耳朶聽觉有问題呢？警方已经回答过: 因為警隊不足，香港並不是只单方地點有暴動咩？
尼位女仕说從未見过吹淚弹，咁妳出生太遲了，1967年暴徒時我就見过，如果冇暴動又怎会有吹淚弹？
個個銀行女職員。你睇下D暴徒做過D咩先啦，打丫伯，仲可恥啦，讀咁多數，計數計錯左啦！
說一套。。做另外一套。大話精（林郑月娥）