Why the WOW Signal Is Astronomy's Most Puzzling 72 Seconds
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 апр 2023
- Get Surfshark VPN at Surfshark.deals/thoughty2 and enter promo code THOUGHTY2 to get 83% off and 3 extra months for free!
Thoughty2 Audiobook: geni.us/t2audio
Thoughty2 Book: geni.us/t2book
Support Me & Get Early Access: bit.ly/t2club
Thoughty2 Merchandise: bit.ly/t2merch
Follow Thoughty2
Facebook: / thoughty2
Instagram: / thoughty2
Website: thoughty2.com
About Thoughty2
Thoughty2 (Arran) is a British RUclipsr and gatekeeper of useless facts. Thoughty2 creates mind-blowing factual videos about science, tech, history, opinion and just about everything else.
#Thoughty2
Writing: Steven Rix
Editing: Sandeep Rai
The sad part of this is, that could have been the last and or only signal a civilization sent out before it was destroyed. Which means we will never get that signal ever again, if that be the case.
I thought this too. Totally blows my mind.
Why is that the sad part? What if the sound we heard was not a distress signal, but another civilisation wiping out the very civilisation you say sent the distress call, but, it was not a distress call, but a signal back to their home world to let them know they destroyed their neighbour and the planet no longer exists? 😅 that’s strangely less traumatic to think about although worse in nature, and if true, means we might get to hear it again when they visit us 😅
but that would mean there is still an intelligent civilication out there ...if live still exist its a win
@@christianmarx3249 if there’s definitive proof of just one more; I’m almost certain that would instantly mean there’s millions or billions yet to be discovered. Same principle applies for AI theory apparently, the moment we create a simulation as real as life itself, that would instantly mean we ourselves live in a simulation.
Maybe it was a cannibalistic, barbaric, destroyer species who seen a giant asteroid coming to their planet and there was actually a message sent. Maybe it was there way of saying "oh shi-t", or telling their species that were out flying in ships to not come home, cause there wouldn't be one.
One of the things about extra-terrestrial signals that I find intriguing or maybe even a bit unnerving is the concept of a necro signal, where you receive a signal from a now dead civilization. In a way, Voyager 1 with the gold plaque, if found 100 million years from now, would be a necro signal. That thing will outlive us all.
If it doesn't smash into debris between star systems and break apart first
@@kevincloud574never thought of that. Holy cow. As unrealistic as it seems we could have literally done it all for nothing
@@yewstew8312I mean not to be too negative, but most likely we did do it for nothing, and we knew that when we sent it. If there is life in the universe it's very unlikely that something sent out in a random direction will come in contact with it.
I still thinks chers hair is ancient Egypt DNA.
Almost inevitably any contact will be with a long dead civilisation. I suspect that there is too great a distance for there to be any meaningful contact, unless wormholes in space actually exist.
Important to note is that we might not have heard the full signal, and we also didn't listen for a repeat continuously, only every now and then at seemingly arbitrary times. If it did repeat we might have missed it. Maybe the signal we picked up was the last of the repeats. Maybe they only sent one, which btw is what we humans do. We sent 1 signal into space that famous time. Not 2, not 3, but 1. Point is, there are too many questions and possibilities for us to say with certainty "this signal was it". Very frustrating.
#1 misconception about the "WOW! signal".... is that it was a signal. The scant bits we know about it suggest it was either using a modulation that cycled too subtly for it to be picked up by the admittedly crude instrument that detected it, or it was using NO modulation at all. If this is true, then it's almost certainly NOT artificial.
Thoughty talked up the idea that natural cosmic sources of signals are very stable... but he's WRONG. Novas make signal bursts and so do many other cosmic events. This is why most people DON'T see it as a sign aliens are calling us. It's the equivalent of hearing a loud BANG! noise a mile away. We don't know exactly what MADE the noise, but it's not a form of communication.... unless it's the equivalent of morse code via dynamite blasts.
Why would we send a signal one time then hear a signal come in then randomly wait and expect to hear more back? Usually if you want a conversation to take place you have to say more than One ☝️word! 🤷🏼♀️🤦🏼♀️😂
Exactly!!
Or maybe they operate on vastly different time scales compared to a human lifespan. There are species that live for hundreds of years and there are species that only live for a few days. Ming the clam lived for 507 years!!! There are sharks documented to be several centuries old!
being an introvert I'm just wondering if the alien is like me on a phone, made the call, got no answer, and thought "phew, no one's answering, maybe I'll try again later" and just never does. Back when we had land lines there was no way of knowing who called if they didn't leave a message so maybe we'll never know.
Caller ID existed and would tell you who was calling and *69 would return calls to whoever called you last. So yea, back when landlines were around you could know who called and even call them back automatically with a land line.
@@Vincent_Beers Uh…WHAT? 😂 Caller ID did not exist in 1977. Nor did *69. They were not a thing until the early 90s in all of North America. We had serious issues with hang up and silent callers from 1975 until 1980 and again from about 1986 until 1989. Even having a tracer put on our phone was a big process that could only be done by the phone company, and they couldn’t always tell what the number was that was calling if it was out of province. That required even more special tech that involved law enforcement.
If aliens took a single glance to humanity and saw TikTok trends they would never contact us again
To be fair they'd probably think it's a mating ritual or something😂
Tik Tok inside China is enriching and educational.
That's fair
Hate to break it to you, but TikTok of the least of humanity's problems rn. Aliens would ghost is for far worse things that we do over stupid things like skin color, imaginary lines drawn in soil, and non-existent sky daddy.
@@dataexpunged6969 that whole ass statement says more about you than humanity
Has anyone ever thought to reply to the signal?
sender: "hi"
earth: listens for 50 years
@@Cicada-3301 Well if we're gonna get something back, they should send 2x the amount 😆😆
We've sent plenty of replies. There's no one answering
@@debbieanne7962 It's possible that it was a signal meant for somebody else. The Earth just happened to be in the right place at the right time to pick it up. Sort of like catching a wave that was meant for a person behind you.
Imagine interstellar alien civilizations communicating across the cosmos. They're probably a lot more advanced than us, both scientifically and technologically. We happen to intercept one of their signals and we try to signal back. The aliens are like "Gee, this is embarrassing. We need to be more cautious when transmitting in that direction."
@@debbieanne7962 LOL - when was it sent? and how long did it take for us to receive it in 1977?
Sending replies to an unknown sauce (*source whoops silly me) is generally a tactical mistake. Thats like poking a bear to see if its friendly. i hear a buzzing. why dont i stick my head inside this hive? they might be friendly.
Just putting this out there. If we haven’t heard anything like it in the past 50 years, surely it could have been an accident, or a distress call from an alien spacecraft. Or even just a spacecraft flying over the right point in space.
My conclusion after pondering it for years... is that it was actually a cosmic event. the one thing Thoughty gets VERY wrong, is that cosmic events don't make bangs. It is true that most cosmic events don't do... that, but it is known that many cosmic events can be heard on radio telescopes.
In that case, we've never detected another 'cosmic event' like that. Nor is there even a theory what kind of cosmic event it could be.
Or it's so far away it takes hundreds of years to reach us. Maybe we'll find the second signal in 2430? Hope not though, I wanna be alive when this happens😂
@@dirremoire well, there's a lot we don't know about the universe. I've seen a few theories, but I don't remember enough details to explain them.
Imagine if the "aliens" had been broadcasting for hundreds of years and shut it down due to no replies. And we literally just caught the signal as it was shut down.
Hah, yeah the irony 😄 but in reality we're probably talking hundreds of years at the very least before any signal eventually reaches us, so they'll have already long been out of business by the time we find out
lol The signal was not meant for humans to understand. It was sent to the Archangel Base -- probably in Antarctica.
500,000 years ago, they came to teach Neanderthal Man herding and husbandry. And all went well for about 300,000 years (cro magnon man) until Lucifer -- sovereign of over 600 evolutionary worlds -- declared Liberty from Rule by a non-existent grand-father god, and ordered the Planetary Princes, like the one who still remains on Earth, to do as they WILLED.
Fast forward: Lucifer and Satan were detained in 30 AD, just after Pentecost, and were judged by the Ancients of Days, far from Earth, in 1985. The devil and dragon remain on Earth. Their judgement is set for 10/12/26. They intend to prove Mankind unfit for God's Kingdom with a worldwide war, and thereby to absolve themselves of blame.
"After all," the devil argues, "Jesus, Himself, tried to teach these beasts to love one another, 1,994 years ago -- almost two full days in heaven. Surely, the Ancient of Days will judge Man at fault. Or Jesus. Not Me."
The devil is delusional -- Daniel 7: 9-14. Revelation 12: 12-13.
The Big Ear was built for radio astronomers to make a sky map, so it had swept across that area before, perhaps several times, and no signal had been detected. Of course, it is unlikely that aliens would broadcast continuously, in all directions around their planet. Likely they would only sometimes be pointing their signal at Earth. Probably pointing in other directions most of the time. Maybe we will get lucky, and every 50 years they turn on the transmitter and broadcast all around the sky for a year, and then listen for a response.
Imagine if you didn’t drop out of statistics class.
The disappointing part is that the wrong telescope picked it up.
Its a static telescope on a rotating earth. The reason they waited until the next day to listen again was because they had to wait for the earth, so the telescope would be pointing at the same point in space.
Conversely, if it were a telescope that tracked a point in space, it most likely never would have even heard the wow signal, there is a lot of directions it could be facing and the wow signal was just one.
Perhaps the signal was just a cue signal for the incoming information and we missed it by a few hours.
And now we could only imagine the mindblowing alien cat memes we missed. Truly a great loss for humankind as a whole.
Yeah but if it was from an intelligent civilization trying to make contact, they would repeat it, and the proceeding information, over and over again. It’s only logical.
well they would certainly try to send more signals again right?
the aliens know that sht so no prob. the disappointing part is no modulation = bird poop not aliens
@@TaleDreamer Alien cats aren't as cool or cute as ours. so nothing much missed.
It would be super creepy if we sent a message out and got a response "quiet. They'll hear you"
That concept is literally a creepypasta
@@TheAnazrieth they know
Just read this in an old, and I mean OLD, reddit post this morning.
You like Dark Forest Theory I see.
What is actually scary is that fact that means the british have imperialized different planets and we are now just founding out.
Imagine that was a warning or help signal sent through the universe but abruptly cut off because it's source got destroyed.
What if it's just a prank from aliens? Something like an alien guy got bored with his job observing human civilization on earth then decided to do something fun by sending a specific radio signal to prank the lesser civilization but then his superior found out and fired him and that's why we have never heard something similar ever again.
Lol it's like shining a flashlight or something at a closed/protected habitat and made all the animals go wild and confused 🤣
😂 for some reason I get a mental picture of a loony toons reel playing out in my head.
This is the most likely scenario
"Dude, let's land our ship on that planet and blow their caveman minds!"
Bro fell asleep on the job
If it was an alien signal, chances are it wasn't intended for us at all. We probably just happened to be in the right spot when Kirk decided to unlock the enterprise with his key fob. 😂
LoL
🤣🤣🤣
That was my thought, also. Sort of like catching a wave that was meant for the person behind you.
Someone hailing the Federation on a subspace frequency?
==================================================================
Thought something similar... there's noting indicating this signal, if really produced by alien life, was directed at us.
Not diving into conspiracy theories as to why we haven’t heard anything in 50 years another big reason is that we just can’t go through all the data fast enough. We’ve been compiling data for many many years, but can’t keep up with looking at it. Another big problem is that sometimes when we’re looking at data we’re looking for very specific things so sometimes other big discoveries go unnoticed just because we weren’t looking for them at that time.
🤔
i agree, there might of been something very similar to this discovery but because it wasn’t that exact frequency we just didn’t pay attention.
Yeah, I wonder about similar things too…specifically this, when it comes to alien communication: How are we so sure that the electromagnetic spectrum is how aliens would choose to communicate? It’s *preposterously* slow and easily compromised…to get a message to our nearest star takes years, nevermind the return trip. I have this (completely uneducated) “theory” that, at some point, we’ll discover some form of quantum communication and after some refinement, etc, the quantum airwaves will be filled with messages from all over the universe.
yea they could of missed something in all of that data, people do get tired looking at this information all the time, it should put online for others to look over if that has not already been done.
but... you would only have to scan the section of sky the original signal originated, which they have, and no subsequent signal detected unfortunately. was probably random (or caused by frequency clash). But ofc it's always worth double, triple checking etc.. in the whole scheme of things.
Radio signals emitted by alien technology are not necessarily messages meant for us or even messages of any kind at all. Perhaps it didn't repeat because the aliens are completely unaware that one of their radio waves was detected by us. It's fun to speculate!
I really like listening/reading the "humans are weird" posts. It's essentially stories about sci-fi humans being explained from alien points of view.
Where do I find those?
that reminds me of the book „Fables for Robots“ by Stanisław Lem. Some of them mention humans and it‘s very funny how they are described
HFY is the far superior format... for Agro... for Humanity... for the Algorithm...
They are made of meat!
😂😂😂
You never fail to make night shift a little bit easier 😂
😂.. yep... night shifts are always nice... i am watching yt until next case comes...
But it's like 1pm.
@@BLOXKAFELLARECORDS time zones exist, remember?
@@BLOXKAFELLARECORDS This just in: local RUclips commenter is about to discover time zones
@@BLOXKAFELLARECORDS it’s only 10 am in my time zone lol
Imagine it was a cadet on a alien starship who forgot to clear the background before opening the communication channel to their home planet, then turned it off quickly. No information sent, but a blip on the radar. Thanks cadet
Ya know, with between 100 & 400 BILLION stars in the Milky Way and at least that number of planets... You'd really expect space to be filled with noise, not just random black holes and quasars, but intelligent type of stuff... And then you remember just how freaking big space is & how spread out all of those stars really are, and really... Finding anything at all is amazing to me.
I think the aliens accidentally CC’d us in to an intergalactic group chat
😂😂😂
I’m actually addicted to this channel. Binge watched all weekend
I envy you... I have already watched everything like 3 times, wish I could delete my memory and re-watch it :D
The subtle humor in the editing is always what gets me. The wink at the end is what keeps me coming back. Just kidding. That and your content is always interesting. Love you man ❤
You have really outdone yourself this time. The amount of work you put into this to explain it in a way that anyone could understand is nothing short of astounding.
The more I look into this I’m wondering if it was some sort distress signal or something like that they might have gotten picked up by someone or they got destroyed in the process way the ship wouldn’t be transmitting afterwards and that’s why we can’t find it anymore
I heard somewhere a long time ago that “what if it were a warning? What if some hyper advanced civilization came into contact with or created something themselves that was so unstoppably destructive that all they could think to do was warn the rest of the universe in hopes that they would have enough time to prepare.” Something like that
Maybe it was an inter dimensional unicorn and this was the result of it farting but it’s stomach has settled now so we’ll never see the signal again. So sad to think about if true.
Why would they send a signal with no information?
@@gerhardsmith7892 maybe they did and we can’t decode it yet with our current level of technology
@@gerhardsmith7892 Maybe I don’t understand, do you know something about the signal we don’t? Are you in possession of evidence as to what the signal means or represents? Or is there something I’m just not grasping the idea of?
The signal could also have been transmitted by a space ship, that can explain why, when we look at the same spot again, we cant find the signal annymore.
If there was a compelling human based explanation, certainly it would've occurred more than once. It would have to be communication technology related. And with extraordinary advancements since the 1970's, wouldn't it manifest again? One other thing--we often think in time frames of our own existence. Perhaps that first signal received in 1970 might take until 2070 for the next iteration is detected.
Or perhaps it was sent only once for the reason we only did it once. Cost and practicality. If it indeed was an alien race and one of a similar technological level to ours, that seems quite reasonable. To them, we're just another point in space, possibly overlooked.
Yes they are likely firing one signal in one direction at a time, but firing at an insane number of directions so the next time they get around to us in a loop could be 100 years or more. If we detect the same signal the same amount of time apart, that's interesting. Also they may expect us to be able to know which direction it's coming from to fire signals back. Effectively letting each other know we exist and to work towards that direction to meet up.
I’ve been watching thoughty2 for years now…. Just recently caught my 11 year old son watching a video of his a couple weeks ago…. My boy told me he has been watching him for awhile now too!
For the past 2 weeks anytime we enter a room together we drop a “FORTY two here!”
Looking at the state of humanity right now, I don't think we are ready to have aliens come to Earth
I don't think the aliens are ready to witness this shit.
I think aliens is what will set us back on track. When we find out there is other intelligence that set many things in motion.
@@ChaosHero17 people used to say a global crisis like a pandemic would "bring us together". Obviously that didn't happen. Chances are the knowledge of aliens would just polarize humanity more, because everyone would be so sure they know what the aliens want, and what we should do.
Hello hamster!
🤗
“Two possibilities exist: either we are alone in the Universe or we are not. Both are equally terrifying.” - Arthur C. Clarke
The wow signal could have took thousands of years to reach us. My hypothesis is that whomever sent it their planet no longer exists. This is the reason a second one was never sent.
Or maybe it'll take another thousand years
Almost forgot about this channel from years ago! Finally stumbled upon this video and all my memories came back! Great to see you again!
Honestly if aliens came to Earth, they would probably lose brain cells if they witnessed the state of the world
trying hard to be next "the guys without a moustache" arent you?
Probably not. Unless they are unbelievably smug assholes.
It's like if humans time traveled back to the stone ages and sneered at all the cavemen not cleaning their wounds or not cooking their food properly.
Very likely those aliens themselves had very similar issues back in their past. When it comes to being warlike/aggressive, natural selection tends to favor territorial and expansive species, so there probably aren't that many ultra pacifistic aliens either who would gasp at human capability for violence.
Real
They got close enough to watch TikTok, made a U-turn and got the hell out of our solar system as fast as possible.
@@saucerar7615 lol Fr tho why would anyone? It’s a thankless Payless and even makes certain people disdain a person they might actually like had they not seen them blurting out popular meme phrases that kids like without thinking about, to be top comment on everything popular.
I’m actually on a porcelain throne right now, when I started watching this video and pondering on this topic.
well im sure the shock helped speed up your royal duties
The signal at least made more people take more notice of space bourne signals and widen the search parameters. The universe is huge looking at the right spot at the right time is pure chance too much "sky" to monitor constantly, so it's always going to be a game of chance.
To quote Truman in Armageddon, "...begging your pardon, sir, but it's a big-ass sky."
I heard this story so many times, but never explained so well. Good work.❤
I’m a simple man, I see a new Thoughty 2 video… I watch the new Thoughty 2 video!
Even if there was another signal, they wouldn't tell us, would they?😮
There are several other signals that are strong candidates but SETI is claiming that they still need more time study
Oooh a conspiracy! I love conspiracies.
Now tell me, why wouldn't they? What do they gain?
@@50-50_Grind conspiracy theory. There is no proof that our governments keep alien life a secret. There’s no reason they would hide it from us.
@@50-50_Grindidk, maybe to avoid public panic or something
"Who" wouldn't tell you? A university detected it.... not some CIA, DOD, or some other black ops site.. "seti" and even Nasa don't have many direct employees, what they do is to fund different universities to work on the research, and universities are full of Scientists.. Science heavily involves peer review, which means as soon as that signal got detected, it was sent across the world to other scientists to verify what he is seeing. You just can't keep stuff like this quiet
I suppose one explanation for why there was no information in the Wow Signal could be similar to a situation in the first Mass Effect game. Wherein the Council tells you they have a team on Virmire investigating Saren. The Salarian councilor says that "the signal we received was little more than static. But, the transmission was sent on a channel reserved for mission critical information. Whatever they were trying to tell us, we know it was important". This is assuming alot, especially considering I'm using a sci-fi game as reference, but given the lack of hard evidence beyond the initial Wow Signal, it might be worth considering. Which I guess falls into the Dark Forest theory if whatever civilization sent the signal couldn't send anything of substance
Ah, yes. "Reapers" we have concluded its a myth created by Saren to get the geth to follow him.
I absolutely love his interjected humor within all the info. Got to be my favorite channel:)
We will never know, and possibly for good reason. We can’t even handle relationships among ourselves on this small planet. Artificial borders and pointless conflicts over merely accidental differences 🤦🏾♂️
What does our behavior with eachother have to do with identifying this signal?
@@JAB-bc9uv sorry, that was a response to a question he asked in the earlier part of the video on whether or not we will ever know if we're alone in the universe.
Given the almost unimaginably massive size of the universe the idea we are the only intelligent life is pretty absurd, not to mention incredibly narcissistic.
That's hilarious considering the probability of actually developing intelligent life on even a small scale like ours is extremely unprobable but whatever fuck me and Google and statistics as a whole.
@@aidanwatson910 Then whats the point of a huge never ending Universe full of billions and billions of galaxies with each galaxy full of billions of billions of stars, with each star more likely than not having planets orbiting around them, if this is the only planet in the entire universe and or "multiverse| capable of not only one type of life form, but thousands of species of plant life, mammals, insects, fish, birds, reptiles not to mention all the life that has existed thoroughout the history of this planet and has since gone extinct?
@@edstar83 you're asking me "what's what's point of a huge huge ending universe". Unless you are religious, there's actually no point of human existence much less the existence of matter in any given spot in any solar system. That's what humans have been trying to figure out, what's the point of existence.
@@aidanwatson910 Does there HAVE to be a point though? That's just human existentialist narcissism!
@@2760ade the other guy literally asked me what's the point and I I realistically and mathematically there isn't unless an all knowing powerful being created everything and everything was not actually the product of perfect variables coming together at the exact perfect time. The probability of our existence is less than the probability that there's other life out there and you don't even understand how small of a probability that actually is.
Dude been watching you since the beginning. Your content is always "Wow"....😉🤣 it's awesome to watch you grow.
Love your channel and EVERY SINGLE VIDEO that you put out. If I could do a video request on what I'd like to see would be a video of how vast space actually is and like how far the closest star is to us and how long it would take to get there. Then do a lot of comparisons with common things for some good ol fashion mind blowing/brain melting perspectives oh yeah🤓🤩😁 again love your content. 2 thumbs way up 👍👍
I wouldn’t be surprised if it was some distant hydrogen heavy star exploding in a way we haven’t witnessed yet and it had sent a very limited radio wave length and that’s why we only saw it once and never again.
Narrow band signals are generated by tech, pay attention to tge video
@@24framedavinci13 what part of "in a way we haven’t witnessed yet" do you not understand?
do you truly think science has already discovered everything in the universe, that there is nothing left to find?
Nah
Maybe, but like he said, stars generate wide band signals so it seems unlikely an exploding star wouldn’t.
@@24framedavinci13 So do pulsars. Pay attention in school
2:44 to skip ad
Here after watching 3 body problem on Netflix. Thought it was really cool how they incorporated this into the show!
Had to come back to this and see if there were any developments since I last first heard about it 10+ years ago.
The Wow! Signal could be the equivalent of a text that got shot off to the wrong address. Perhaps that signal wasn't meant for us humans.
The WOW signal decoded: “Daddy’s just going out to get some milk, I’ll be right back.”
"We may already have received a message...Surfshark keeps you safe!"
My kind of humour 😅
It’s free real estate
Ever since I switch to RUclips revanced, I haven't seen any sponsored segment.
Too bad some sponsored segments are pretty cool.
Sadly two years ago they discovered that it was most likely a comic ray hitting a transistor opening the wrong gate in the processing board which kicked out an error.
Yes. It's so improbable that it could be another lifeform that also uses radio signals. There's completely zero evidence of any other carbon based life anywhere near our corner of an immense universe
That's disappointing
An error that just so happened to be at 1420 hz and lasted 72 seconds which is how long the telescope would be able to detect it if it were a continuous signal from space?
Yeah, okay…
@@Promatheos Some people just wanted to find an explanation that is mundane, even if it may not be accurate.
“as though someone sneezed on them while eating alphabet soup”. Brilliant. I’ll find a way to use that. Fascinating content, as usual.
just yesterday i watched the old video about scary sounds from Thoughty2 and Wow signal was there! what a timing!
Great video! I would love to see you cover the Bloop sound from the ocean as well. ❤️ much love from Belgium🇧🇪
Iceberg. Or rather an ice shelf breaking off or grounding on the sea floor. I can't remember exactly.
You and your team are the very best! Thank you for taking the time to make my day.
Arran, I thought of a good historical figure I would like you to cover: John Muir. I am quite passionate about the man. "I asked the boulders I met, whence they came and whither they were going." From his strict upbringing, to walking across the country, to the National Parks and his influence on politicians much has been documented. I would like to see how you could fill in some of the lesser-known years for us. If humanity has any chance of seeing this through, we will owe a lot to Mr. Muir. Thank you for everything you do.
Love your work Aron! Keep it up🥸
The Wowe signal repeats every 10,000 years. Let’s just be a little patient 😂
wowee
Or maybe every million years? Quite possible for all we know
Interesting claim
You're wrong, it's every 372 years.
finally watched all videos..took a couple of weeks but done and done
The introduction is crazy, the phrase "whilst perched on porcelain thrones" is a figurative expression that refers to someone sitting on a toilet seat or using the bathroom. It is a poetic or humorous way of describing the act of being in the bathroom or engaging in toilet-related activities.
The phrase is composed of several elements:
"Whilst" means "while" or "during the time that." It is a slightly more formal or archaic term for "while."
"Perched" suggests a posture of sitting or balancing on something, often with a sense of being elevated or in a precarious position.
"Porcelain thrones" is a metaphorical term for toilet seats or toilets. "Porcelain" refers to the material commonly used in the construction of toilets, and "thrones" humorously elevates the toilet seat to a royal or regal status.
Putting it all together, the phrase describes the act of using the bathroom or sitting on a toilet in a whimsical or fanciful way, adding a touch of poetic imagery to a mundane reality, I love this.
John Michael Godier also has some great content on the Wow Signal (and many other topics).
Do you think Oumuamua was their second attempt at contact, seeing if we're still in existence, considering it takes a long GD time to get anywhere in space??
I like your theory!
@@drifter3166 It came back in time to visit the whales named George and Gracie? It must have been disappointing for the probe that George and Gracie went time traveling into the future with the USS Enterprise.
5:11 I read somewhere that the phrase “extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence” was actually coined by Marcello Truzzi and not Carl Sagan
you use a lot more alliteration than i remembered, and i appreciate that a lot
I know pretty much nothing here but- could it have still been an instrument error? In an age where we have computers in most homes, we know they have a habit of doing random glitches that we can't reproduce, or that never happen again. It could very easily have just been a random glitch
Exactly!!
Pretty sure that's literally the first thing they consider it was when they received that signal.
@@DaviRed_ Oh I'm sure they would, the guys behind the tech obviously know so much more then me the random guy watching a youtube video, but it just throws me that something like this can be considered aliens or whatever. Like, for it to be aliens it's got to be repeatable right?
I just love yr channel, u and The Why Files make my day xx
Aye! Another fellow Why Files fan.
Yes! Why files is so great channel, another great is mrballen😊
Top 3 channels:
1. Answers with Joe
2. Thoughty2
3. The why files
@@myscreen2urs HeckleFish for President!
This the best coverage of this I have seen to date.
It's nice when you find a new channel you like and you have all the videos to watch. : )
Has anyone considered "Oh crap, they've seen us! Turn it off!" as an answer?
Imagine it was a meme sent by trolling aliens. That would be impressive.
I do have a question: with Earth slowly rotating on its axis, wobbling slowly, and revolving around the sun - I imagine the "alien world would be making these movements - and our solar system, like all the other star systems, are moving through the Milky Way, could Earth have been in the target line of the signal for that brief amount of time? With EVERYTHING moving around in many ways all the time, perhaps the signal is still out there (assuming it was sent like a laser beam), but we are just not at the right place in the Milky Way to hear it again?
Me: “I’m looking for alien signals.”
Computer: “ALIEN SIGNAL DETECTED”
Alien: “6EQUJ5”
Really well and clearly explained, thankyou. If alien beings transmitted the signal, perhaps they don't follow the same laws of time. Many years might have passed for us, but only a few seconds for them. While we wonder why the signal was never repeated, they're just about to, in their time frame. Who knows?
The WOW signal was from aliens and finally was translated. It said, 'The extended warranty on your vehicle is about to expire'.
Imagine driving down the road at say 70 miles an hour when you see a light reflection out of the side of your eye for one second. You drive down the road till you find a place to turn around and go back finding another place to turn around .Then try to catch that same glint out of your eye . About the same ,only larger to find that signal again.
Aliens listening for radio waves is like us listening for banging two rocks together. Radio waves are probably stone age for an alien civilization.
I thought you meant something entirely different for a second when you said "trained gaze" 👀🤣
Yeah it all went a bit weird there.
Trained gays 😂😂😂
The fact you’ve been doing this for a decade is absolutely insane. Keep up the great work man
I bet you a dollar that Contact was made long before We even started recording Human History...🤑
@@Cicada-3301 We'll see lil mud buggy.
Thank you for this wonderful explanation.
The WOW signal was decoded (translated) years ago. Four words sent back to earth. "Send More Chuck
Berry"
The Wow Signal's code seems like a fairly interesting topic to discuss. We can its complexity unraveling each minute.
What if It turns out to be Us from the Future?
What the telescope heard was a short burst of static. One thing that it might have been was similar to a phonic ping, like that used on submarines. If an alien race was looking for something specific that could and would respond to the same signal, but not be recognized by others is the same thing that we do on earth with our own military and civilian devices.
If there was enough intelligent life in the universe for that ping to be reliable despite being so short, we'd see the signals from those other intelligent species more than the ping. The ping also couldn't simply have stopped upon receiving a ping back from us, because of how incredibly long it takes light to traverse space, our very first radio waves haven't even reached that far beyond our neighboring stars, let alone out into the galaxy and into other galaxies(with it taking millions of years to reach Andromeda).
Human race v.2 that’s developed far beyond us waiting for us to figure out to respond with the same key code message in the same frequency yup. Universal echo location. They probably don’t even need a response there just waiting for their signal to get back to them to give them our exact location. Or we just happen to notice like we notice a breeze in the wind but there’s nothing to respond to and it’s some fundamental static in the universes’ solar wind created by interaction of solar winds from celestial bodies which we just don’t even think to test for but happen to catch a sample of in another code for another system similar to the system that would be used to measure the static of the universes’ solar wind
Wonderful video! Totally enjoyed it. ❤️
i have an electronic experimental old track inspired by the wow signal on my channel. I Always believed it to be one of the most awesome things happened in modern science. This video is a very nice reporting on the event! kudos
I have my own possible theory. Maybe it could have been a sort of distress signal from a ship or space station, or planet. I think it is likely that a more advanced civilization with the ability to travel through space would probably also be able to locate the source of a radio signal pretty easily, so that could be why there was no information encoded in the signal. And we recognize the probable universal significance of 1420 MHz, much like the universal understanding of SOS here on Earth (• • • - - - • • •).
Been looking forward to seeing you cover this topic! Thanks for being my primary source of education Thoughty2! ❤
0:15 That dude just slammed a door that closes counter-inversely from the outside. Respect.
I've known about the wow signal for years and this is the first time it's ever actually made sense to me
What if they sent out that signal before something tereible happened. Like destruction/ extinction. One last ditch to reach out and say help.
Also if you send out a signal, is there anyway to tell if someone or something has received it?
likely whenever, if that is the case, receives a reply.
awesome video i love watching the ones you do about unexplained phenomena
love your videos
The way you speak is marvelous
Let's assume it is of alien origin. It might be from a civilization that is not significantly superior to us technologically. I can imagine that it is nothing more than a "we are/were here" signal. They could have built a radio emitter on one of their moons that beam a very narrow beam with little spread so that the signal can go very far, but the beam is slowly scanned over their entire night sky over a long period. They could have designed it very robustly and automated so that it could function for centuries without intervention. It could in a sense be like a monument for them with the aim that whoever out there (us!) are lucky enough to pick up the signal can know they're not alone. It might not be designed to say anything more than that. Inherent to its design, anyone who picks up the signal will only do so briefly, so there's no need to encode anything on it. An interstellar "the Zorgs were here" signal. They're not expecting anything back. They might be trapped in their solar system due to the same constraints we face. It's like cosmic writing on a cell wall. This is of course all very speculative.
The signal was never repeated.
@@anonp2958 Correct, but by its design to cover their entire sky thoroughly with a very narrow beam it is likely to take ages before it gets around to us again.
@@stoutgat7 Surely not 50 years.
Professor Antonio Paris, of St Petersburg College, has now discovered the explanation: A pair of comets. The work was published in the Journal of the Washington Academy of Sciences.
These comets, known as 266P/Christensen and 335P/Gibbs, have clouds of hydrogen gas millions of kilometers in diameter surrounding them. The Wow! Signal was detected at 1420MHz, which is the radio frequency hydrogen naturally emits. Notably, the team has verified that the comets were within the vicinity at the time, and they report that the radio signals from 266/P Christensen matched those from the Wow! signal.
Wait I thought “there is no compelling explanation other than aliens”?
He specifically mentions this in the video as having been widely discredited by the scientific community (a quick look at Wikipedia and its sources will confirm this)
Since there is a link between radio signals and gravitational fields, this signal could still be emitting but due to distortion of the field we cannot lock onto it for now
Thoughty 2 is answering all the questions that I never asked
It's exciting to think that we may one day receive definitive proof of life beyond Earth, and events like this give us hope that such a discovery may be just around the corner.
I couldn't agree more! The search for extraterrestrial life is an exciting and ongoing quest, and events like the Wow Signal remind us that we're not alone in the universe. Who knows what other discoveries await us as we continue to explore and learn more about the cosmos.
The Wow Signal is a fascinating mystery that reminds us of the vastness and potential for discovery in the universe.
If and when it happens, it’s going to be disappointing. Highly likely for it to be very primitive or just plain extinct. Still exciting discoveries in their own way, but it’s not the advanced sentient life we think of or that Captain Kirk would inevitably try to shag.
They put a microwave in the facility that detects microwaves.
A worker was warming up his coffee, and left a door open,
That's where wow signal came from.
It's well documented ! !
I thought that was from another incedent
Astronomer Antonio Paris and his team have new evidence suggesting that the well-known Wow! signal from 1977 - long thought by some to be a sign of extraterrestrial life - is in fact a natural phenomenon and was generated by a comet.
@@Cicada-3301
The story is more interesting then the truth,
People just trying to get more views.
Mein that was not WOW-signal🤦♂️🤦♂️
"The mystery behind radio signals that have baffled scientists at Australia’s most famous radio telescope for 17 years has finally been solved.
The signals’ source? A microwave oven in the kitchen at the Parkes observatory used by staff members to heat up their lunch."
@@kanukki84
I'm sorry you are ill informed.
Thoughts 2’s animation is iconic now
It was probably a rerun of "I Love Lucy" bouncing off of a passing meteor, or someone walking around in their socks touching a doorknob in the listening lab. Go back to sleep everybody. Nothing to see here.