Late to the party on this, I realize. It's 2023, and I'm just discovering this exquisite series for the first time. I agree with you all here, that the relationship between John/Caliban/The Creature and Vanessa Ives was the true heart of the story for me. The series, in it's entirety, is absolutely remarkable, with some stellar performances and the best writing I've ever encountered on television... but every time these two characters met on screen it became something absolutely transcendent, soul shuddering, beautiful. Thank you, laurakenji, for putting this lovely tribute together for us.
I'm crying 😢 I agree with everything you wrote and these two were my favourites and their relationship was so deep and beautiful, thank you for this video ❤
MASTERPIECE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! forever lonely after the end of this amazing show... these 2 characters... only god knows how much I'm gonna miss them,,,
God I love these two. I never really "shipped" them either but what they had was so beautiful. Like you said, impossible to label. It was so wonderfully written, so heart wrenching and well-developed in only a few episodes. I truly truly believe that Rory and Eva are two of the greatest talents of our time, and they said more with their eyes in 3x04 than what other actors can say to one another with words over a series of episodes. Seriously. I miss them and Penny Dreadful so much.
This is perfection. My absolute fav song with the most brilliant tv series in my lifetime. Thank you to the creator of this. I will have it at ny funeral. Ty
I watch this at least one time a day, it makes me feel better and also keep alive in my mind this beautiful show that unfortunately is ended. Those two are by far my favourite characters of my favourite show. Thank you Laurakenji for your amazing montage, you perfectly caught the intense connection and friendship between the two. Keep doing this stuff!!
They're the actual best couple. I know Ethan and Vanessa were a doomed kind of canon couple, but John and Vanessa have this deep and long-running cord between them that has nothing to do with prophecy or indeed the supernatural. It is a bond that is utterly _natural_ - and that's what's so beautiful. Without ever witnessing the other's capability for viciousness, they still recognize the likeness in each other without it being foundational to their relationship. They have such capacity for tenderness when it comes to the other, that if they were more involved in each other's lives, to guard and be there for each other, they might've lived happier lives. And of course, kudos to Rory Kinnear and Eva Green, who can wring every ounce of emotion out of a viewer by putting their very souls in their eyes.
Wow ... I really love this! And a dedication to me!!! So not worthy. They do have some sort of on screen magic together. I've said in the past that Vanessa's relationship with Caliban/John Clare was the healthiest one she had ... and indeed the healthiest one between any of the characters on the entire series.
This is INCREDIBLY beautiful and touching. Now, I do ship these two romantically but I adore their friendship and bond for what it is. Love exists in multiple forms, after all ;)
This was beautiful, you did a fantastic job, l miss this show so much , TV shows come and go and you move on , but l'm finding it hard to move on as are so many fans , Rory is just so special, l'm so glad people around the world got to see what a handsome, beautiful actor he truly is.
I love you, this video.. is what I was waiting for too long Those characters are my favorite and their relationship is the most beautiful thing on Earth God bless you
I got a twist imagine if John became embroiled with jealousy towards Dr Sweet and he went to threaten/kill him only to draw out his true nature revealing who he is to Vanessa. Then he along with the gang work together to defend Ms Ives from Dracula(Amun Ra) and his minions.
it is the most beautiful thing i have ever saw as i and my husband love the show and them , i am ill and this is the way i can say all i feel and say good bye thank you for this it is all that i feel i could never say it and well thank you
........ho il magone a mille, dopo questo video! Sono contenta di avere aspettato di avere un momento di calma per vederlo per bene e poter soffrire da sola in pace, perché ne è valsa la pena
Ma tu sei pazza a dire certe cose, non scherziamo ;w; Non posso negare che leggere certe cose mi riempie di gioia/soddisfazione/orgoglio, ma d'altra parte sono anche ben conscia di non essere affatto la migliore editor xD Mi sento troppo lusingata ed onorata, soprattutto detto da te!!! Btw, recentemente sto usando molto gli Sleeping at Last nei video, questo è il secondo video consecutivo in cui utilizzo una loro canzone e, nonostante non siano proprio il mio genere preferito, devo dire che sono davvero bravi, molto poetici e delicati come hai detto tu e credo che le loro canzoni siano perfette per farci video :D E dato che era da una vita che volevo fare un video su loro due, trovare questa canzone è stata una manna dal cielo! Sono contenta che il video ti piaccia, è stato difficile anche per me facendolo rivivere certe scene ;___; Non so più come dirti grazie, davvero, i tuoi commenti sono sempre too precious (e anche troppo gentili xD)
I am not great at this , please helps ad i need a copy of this desperatluy for mu fueral. Is just a maltter af time for me and this song and video version is the only way to say goodbye. I have been tryinng but hes not hearing it. But this song is my only way. I need permision from the vieo amd recording of theis verson help thank yu so much if you cant tell me how yto do it. Love and peacevon the new year blessing and great health to all
I don't know who you are, Laurakenji, but I hate you, I hate so fucking much. It's been a while since I finished Penny Dreadful and I still know how much I cried at the end. Whenever I cry with movies or tv shows, I just go on with it until it ends while my tears run down my face, but when I saw the end of Penny Dreadful, I had to stop EVERYTHING so I could cry during 20 minutes and then go on until the credits. I just opened you video to watch something cute and it was needed just 10 seconds to start crying as much as I did that day when Penny Dreadful ended. I do hate you, Laura, I do hate you. But thank you for uploauding this.
From Pakistan Vanessa should have chosen Caliban, He can even kill Dracula. The things he have done for her when he was alive and she was is her worse state, always in control even seek her body rather her soul, and even when she was in er perfect state and he was in worse ( a monster ) yet she rejected him. You take your loves one with you even in pain , if they are ready to come, this is God biggest gift. She rejected it and paid the price. Think if she had Caliban on her side 24/7 dracula would be pissing himself. All women make such mistakes and lives in misery, they reject the one who help and care for them and seek others. From east to west its all same.
![[Penny Dreadful] Caliban » Why Did You Allow Me To Feel?](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/lUK3UQ3Iif4/mqdefault.jpg)
Late to the party on this, I realize. It's 2023, and I'm just discovering this exquisite series for the first time. I agree with you all here, that the relationship between John/Caliban/The Creature and Vanessa Ives was the true heart of the story for me. The series, in it's entirety, is absolutely remarkable, with some stellar performances and the best writing I've ever encountered on television... but every time these two characters met on screen it became something absolutely transcendent, soul shuddering, beautiful. Thank you, laurakenji, for putting this lovely tribute together for us.
I cried. I won't lie. This video is beautiful and it pays homage to the most beautiful relationship on the show. Instant fav!
Us to it sume up my soul in this clip. I'm glad to know that I am not the only one.
This is simply perfection. I am terminal ill and want this video to be played at my funeral. Thank you who ever made it thank you ❤
The greatest moments of joy in this show were between these two, and the most tear jerking. I rewatch this series because of them
You are right this is the purest of love I have ever seen in tv or cinema.
I'm crying 😢 I agree with everything you wrote and these two were my favourites and their relationship was so deep and beautiful, thank you for this video ❤
Thank you very much!
MASTERPIECE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! forever lonely after the end of this amazing show... these 2 characters... only god knows how much I'm gonna miss them,,,
Thank youu! ♥
Their friendship was so beautiful. I loved this show dearly and that ending broke my heart💔
God I love these two. I never really "shipped" them either but what they had was so beautiful. Like you said, impossible to label. It was so wonderfully written, so heart wrenching and well-developed in only a few episodes. I truly truly believe that Rory and Eva are two of the greatest talents of our time, and they said more with their eyes in 3x04 than what other actors can say to one another with words over a series of episodes. Seriously. I miss them and Penny Dreadful so much.
Such a pure and almost divine love on my opinion.
In my opinion
Well said my darling
Rewatching the series seven years later, and I’m back here, because they are still my favorites ❤️
This is perfection. My absolute fav song with the most brilliant tv series in my lifetime. Thank you to the creator of this. I will have it at ny funeral. Ty
I watch this at least one time a day, it makes me feel better and also keep alive in my mind this beautiful show that unfortunately is ended. Those two are by far my favourite characters of my favourite show. Thank you Laurakenji for your amazing montage, you perfectly caught the intense connection and friendship between the two. Keep doing this stuff!!
They're the actual best couple. I know Ethan and Vanessa were a doomed kind of canon couple, but John and Vanessa have this deep and long-running cord between them that has nothing to do with prophecy or indeed the supernatural. It is a bond that is utterly _natural_ - and that's what's so beautiful. Without ever witnessing the other's capability for viciousness, they still recognize the likeness in each other without it being foundational to their relationship. They have such capacity for tenderness when it comes to the other, that if they were more involved in each other's lives, to guard and be there for each other, they might've lived happier lives.
And of course, kudos to Rory Kinnear and Eva Green, who can wring every ounce of emotion out of a viewer by putting their very souls in their eyes.
I cannot agree more with each word you wrote. Thanks
This is gorgeous
Thank you!
Wow ... I really love this! And a dedication to me!!! So not worthy. They do have some sort of on screen magic together. I've said in the past that Vanessa's relationship with Caliban/John Clare was the healthiest one she had ... and indeed the healthiest one between any of the characters on the entire series.
Totally agree with you! :)
Thank you so much, btw, I'm really glad you liked the video!
This is INCREDIBLY beautiful and touching. Now, I do ship these two romantically but I adore their friendship and bond for what it is. Love exists in multiple forms, after all ;)
Thank you so much!
i'VE SEEN THIS VIDEO THREE TIMES, AND i'VE CRIED THREE TIMES, OMG.
Oh this is so beautiful, I am weeping with joy for what they had, sadness for what they lost (what we all lost)
Thank you!
This video brought me to tears.
literally the healthiest relationship on the show. if they'd gotten together they'd be alive on a farm somewhere
This was beautiful, you did a fantastic job, l miss this show so much , TV shows come and go and you move on , but l'm finding it hard to move on as are so many fans , Rory is just so special, l'm so glad people around the world got to see what a handsome, beautiful actor he truly is.
I'm glad too! (about Rory)
The most intimate and beautiful relationship in the series, friends and souls that were so meant to meet 💛✌️🔥
Thankyou for making this ♥️♥️♥️
I love you, this video.. is what I was waiting for too long
Those characters are my favorite and their relationship is the most beautiful thing on Earth
God bless you
I got a twist imagine if John became embroiled with jealousy towards Dr Sweet and he went to threaten/kill him only to draw out his true nature revealing who he is to Vanessa. Then he along with the gang work together to defend Ms Ives from Dracula(Amun Ra) and his minions.
“All sad people like poetry.” Lol make me chuckle. Truth. Hahaa
Can't say in words how much I love this video. Thank you so much for this.
Only just discovered this show 3 days ago
Finished all the seasons now
These two were absolutely outstanding
I loved 'Calinessa' so much 😍
i still cry years later.. and i still am madly in love with john clare..
oh how i love these two, they have such a beautiful friendship. Stunning video, amazing job
Thank you so much!
no words needed. its perfect....
it is the most beautiful thing i have ever saw as i and my husband love the show and them , i am ill and this is the way i can say all i feel and say good bye thank you for this it is all that i feel i could never say it and well thank you
i had to stop for a moment i could not stop crying . this is all i wand to say perfect thanks for putting it on
I cried so hard!
burst into tears. I admit it :'(
I cried, I love this so much
every single thing you said!! so beautiful .. they became so real to me in the series. and im an old woman..
I've seen this five times and I've cried five times.
this is so beautiful thank you...
He was the best character of the whole series and kept me watching even when season 2 wasn't great, Rory Kinear owned that role.
This. Is. Epic.
Perfection thank you
My heart💔😥
........ho il magone a mille, dopo questo video! Sono contenta di avere aspettato di avere un momento di calma per vederlo per bene e poter soffrire da sola in pace, perché ne è valsa la pena
Ma tu sei pazza a dire certe cose, non scherziamo ;w; Non posso negare che leggere certe cose mi riempie di gioia/soddisfazione/orgoglio, ma d'altra parte sono anche ben conscia di non essere affatto la migliore editor xD Mi sento troppo lusingata ed onorata, soprattutto detto da te!!! Btw, recentemente sto usando molto gli Sleeping at Last nei video, questo è il secondo video consecutivo in cui utilizzo una loro canzone e, nonostante non siano proprio il mio genere preferito, devo dire che sono davvero bravi, molto poetici e delicati come hai detto tu e credo che le loro canzoni siano perfette per farci video :D E dato che era da una vita che volevo fare un video su loro due, trovare questa canzone è stata una manna dal cielo! Sono contenta che il video ti piaccia, è stato difficile anche per me facendolo rivivere certe scene ;___; Non so più come dirti grazie, davvero, i tuoi commenti sono sempre too precious (e anche troppo gentili xD)
I don't know what anyone says, John Clare is so beautiful. ❤️
So beautiful!
Thank you!
Same to me these 2 should have been together and had a nice happy ending i just wish i can write a complaint about the ending
What does he say to her about God. Saying if you believe in him. He isn’t far away? Driving me nuts. Just finished the series.
I am not great at this , please helps ad i need a copy of this desperatluy for mu fueral. Is just a maltter af time for me and this song and video version is the only way to say goodbye. I have been tryinng but hes not hearing it. But this song is my only way. I need permision from the vieo amd recording of theis verson help thank yu so much if you cant tell me how yto do it. Love and peacevon the new year blessing and great health to all
I don't know who you are, Laurakenji, but I hate you, I hate so fucking much. It's been a while since I finished Penny Dreadful and I still know how much I cried at the end. Whenever I cry with movies or tv shows, I just go on with it until it ends while my tears run down my face, but when I saw the end of Penny Dreadful, I had to stop EVERYTHING so I could cry during 20 minutes and then go on until the credits.
I just opened you video to watch something cute and it was needed just 10 seconds to start crying as much as I did that day when Penny Dreadful ended.
I do hate you, Laura, I do hate you.
But thank you for uploauding this.
Imagine when the boy men freak out when we point out how attractive he is. 😂😢
POR QUE ME HACEN ESTO
Please o please do a video of Caliban with Meatloaf's I'd do anything for love??
Pleeeeeeease??? 😍😍😍😍🙏
From Pakistan Vanessa should have chosen Caliban, He can even kill Dracula. The things he have done for her when he was alive and she was is her worse state, always in control even seek her body rather her soul, and even when she was in er perfect state and he was in worse ( a monster ) yet she rejected him.
You take your loves one with you even in pain , if they are ready to come, this is God biggest gift.
She rejected it and paid the price.
Think if she had Caliban on her side 24/7 dracula would be pissing himself.
All women make such mistakes and lives in misery, they reject the one who help and care for them and seek others.
From east to west its all same.