Ning Ning and Giselle are not popular in the group and are not visible, so people make little comments and get buried by other members.. poor member😭😭 The 4th gen top is Karina
Ning Ning and Giselle are not popular in the group and are not visible, so people make little comments and get buried by other members.. poor member😭 The 4th gen top is Karina
@@aneu22hofoWhy you said NINGNING and GISELLE are not popular and not visible????? Clearly most of the comments are talking about NINGNING and GISELLE..
just everglowup aka choujimi ningverse winterosy thewoo hooned peachxtaehyung psdoyoo etc trying to look nice after being xpsd with her alts nasrun and hypeboy with which she always wants all groups to d13.
3 comments in just a few seconds is you confirming that you copy paste everything and how riled up you are because over 100 people xpsd you in karinas solo vid where you showed that you dont even know who writes their songs.
180 liikes in one jump each which can be seen in many nice siites about these things confirming that you still use scripts for it and that there is still not a single person on your side or seeing you as a my.
even after a year of sppming using scripts and alts to support urself while you know that youre alone and still couldnt get a single person on your side is just you being the most mental h aater ever to still go on doing what you always do with all your alts.
even after a year of sppming using scripts and alts to support urself while you know that youre alone and still couldnt get a single person on your side is just you being the most mental h aater ever to still go on doing what you always do with all your alts.
running away and even now not being able to answer to anything i said is you admitting to everything same with everyone else who xpsd you here on a daily basis.
300 liikes in one jump a few hours ago after seeing that you didnt get any generic ones conffirms once more that no everyone here knows that youre a h aater.
We need more Ningning in the thumbnail because she’s one of the most beautiful female celebrities I’ve ever seen in my life. Her glorious face needs to be on thumbnails, magazines and billboards everywhere🙌
Ningning with Ponytail as always she's the ace member of Aespa!! other members are slaying too !! and the starting position with Audiz and Mingmingz were so cute!!!
making fun of their language even now when alone this week over 100 knetz xpsd you for it so you just admitted once more that you dont care one bit about them.
even after a year of sppming using scripts and alts to support urself while you know that youre alone and still couldnt get a single person on your side is just you being the most mental h aater ever to still go on doing what you always do with all your alts.
using your script for 180 liikes in one jump for a comment where you make fun of their language is also you saying youre the most mental h aater without telling us.
Ning Ning and Giselle are not popular in the group and are not visible, so people make little comments and get buried by other members.. poor member😭😭😭
@@aneu22hofo Nah, in Twitter this two have a massive fandom and most Winrina stans have hots for these two. It’s only Korea but they do feel the love. They were really happy with their solo concert songs numbers
The most versatile of the foreigner-line 4th gen idols 😊😊😊😊. One should constantly tell SM to have her own solo works in Mandarin Chinese and Korean, even Japanese. Perhaps the Western producers behind the group’s newly released “Whiplash” can be tapped for dance-pop and EDM solos for the ice princess of Harbin (a northeastern city in China off Heilongjiang province where she came from)
Ning Ning and Giselle are not popular in the group and are not visible, so people make little comments and get buried by other members... poor member😭😭😭 The 4th gen top is Karina
@they are very much visible so lets not act stupid don’t stan the group if you dislike them aespa will always have 4 members‼️ karina giselle winter and ningning
Winter's red bob with her strong facial expression and Giselle's stage presence are the highlights for Wishplash era no doubt! These two owning the era the most!
![[#2024MAMA] aespa-Bored!+Spark+Dopamine+UP+Supernova(MAMA ver.)+Whiplash(MAMA ver.)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/_LyRdiHwyFA/mqdefault.jpg)
![[#2024MAMA] aespa-Bored!+Spark+Dopamine+UP+Supernova(MAMA ver.)+Whiplash(MAMA ver.)](/img/tr.png)
![aespa - Whiplash [더 시즌즈-이영지의 레인보우] | KBS 241101 방송](/img/1.gif)
썸넬 닝닝 미모 뭐야;;; 놀라서 심장 붙잡고 뛰어옴
요새 닝닝 자꾸 썸네일에 뜸.. 근데 무조건 눌러보게 됨 그래서 뜨나
외모달란트역대급임ㅎㄷㄷ
뭔가 눈썹이 바뀐거 같은데 그래서 그런가 더 존예 ….내가 미쳐
매혹적인 고양이 같아…
레드벨벳 조이 선배님 닮았네 좀 더 통통한 조이 버전
GISELLLE YOU'RE SERVING THIS ERA SO HARD!!!
@@mariasol1545 plastic surgery or not she has always served cvnt!
@@mariasol1545you're faster than fans lol very dedicated
also theyve been spamming the same thing under giselle comments dont reply to them
@@mariasol1545jealousy eh
@@mariasol1545 and here is aedark showing her real side.
닝닝은 이런 생머리 느낌일때가 항상 리즈인듯 이번 스타일로 진짜 천상계 미모찍었네
머리 볶거나 두건 같은거 쓰면 안됨 촌스러워짐
@@jfrhcahrto 목이 원래 짧은데 더 짧아보이는게 문제.. 그냥 시원하게 머리 묶는게 나음
드라마때 긴머리 레이어드에 풍성하게 살짝 웨이브 들어간것도 이쁨
닝닝잉이렇게 이뻤냐;; 놀람
빅토리아느낌남 중국계 애들이 포니테일 잘어울리는듯
ningning looks SO good with this hair and makeup style 😭 i hope we see more of it
NingNing is unique❤
ㄱ글 에서 벳프리 보느라 눈밑에까지 다크써클 들어옴 ... 진짜 근데이뻐서 눈을못떼겟다...
ㄱ글 에서 벳프리 보고 나면 다낵질 보충제 한사발 빨아야 한다는데 사실인가요?
ㄱ글 에서 벳프리 보고 나면 다낵질 보충제 한사발 빨아야 한다는데 사실인가요?
ㄱ글 에서 벳프리 보고 나면 다낵질 보충제 한사발 빨아야 한다는데 사실인가요?
카메라감독님 쩐다....인기가요 카메라가 제일 레전드인듯
원테이크 한 번 봐보세요 진짜 미쳤습니다 sbs
인기가요 감독님은 진짜 믿고 본다구 ㄹㅇ
이렇게 좋은 말씀 해주시니 본인이 보신다면 얼마나 흐뭇할까요
감독님 최고에요!!뮤뱅 레알마드리드 버린 눈 여기에서 치유받아요
저도 이 생각했는데
Ningning thumbnail i thought it was AI so pretty 😍
the stylist is finally giving giselle good outfits this era i love it
0:13 닝닝 얼빡 진짜 미침....개인적으로 제일 예쁘다 생각함...ㅠ
몸매 카리나 얼굴 닝닝
내가더얘쁨ㅋ
나도... 최애는 카리나지만 내 취향 얼굴임ㅠㅠㅠ 넘 예뻐
@@이하연-x3c 거울봐라
카리나 하관이 점점 못나지는느낌
nothing just tearing up reading comments abt ningning ;')
아니 닝닝 진짜 비주얼 레전드..
Ning Ning and Giselle are not popular in the group and are not visible, so people make little comments and get buried by other members.. poor member😭😭 The 4th gen top is Karina
@@aneu22hofo?
@@aneu22hofo악플러 검거
@@aneu22hofo아가리 좀~
@@aneu22hofo 당장 여기서 좋아요 가장 많이 받은 댓글이 닝닝 얘기인데 뭔소리임?
Ningning in the hairstyle is killing me and theyre finally doing justice for mother giselle in this era😭❤
justice was absolutely served
ㄹㅇ ㄱ글 에서 벳프리 보면 다른거 눈에도 안들어옴 그냥 다시보면 되니까 개이득임 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ ?
ㄱ글 에서 벳프리 보느라 눈밑에까지 다크써클 들어옴 ... 진짜 근데이뻐서 눈을못떼겟다...
그놈의 ㄱ글 에서 벳프리 댓글 ㅈ 나많네 그렇게죠 좋은가보지 보러갈까?
그놈의 ㄱ글 에서 벳프리 댓글 ㅈ 나많네 그렇게죠 좋은가보지 보러갈까?
ningning's eye makeup is sooooo pretty shes beautiful 😭🩷
NINGIEE SO PRETTTYYYYY!! i really like her style in this stage
닝이..진짜...눈이 화려한게 너무이뻐...ㅠㅠ 윈터는 ;; 리얼 무슨 초미래 완전 인간형ai 로봇같고 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 독보적이긴 하네
Thumbnail Ningning Finnalyyy😍 Ningning look like AI😍
Giselle’s stage presence and dance has improved A LOT
looking back from even savage era, they’ve all improved SOOO much 🥹
She appears to be so much more confident too. Love to see it 💖
Agreed! She's been my bias since debut, and I'm forever proud of her and the other æspa girls for coming this far❤
SO TRUE I CAN'T EVEN RECOGNIZE HER ANYMORE SHE'S GOT THIS NEW AURA IN HER!
You talk about this part 2:55 she said : I can feel myself
ningning thumbnail is wow so pretty and winter sporting new hair everyday amazing
아니 초미녀 그룹 미쳤다 진짜....넷 다 어케 이렇게 빠지는 게 없냐 한명 한명 자기 파트 찰떡같이 받아가네;;
@@이하연-x3c아... 그러시구나아....☠️
지젤은 아닌데 개소리하노 ㅋㅋ
와 윈터 ㄹㅇ ai 아니냐며 0:10
칼단발 할 때마다 레전드 찍는듯..ㄹㅇ
에스파는 작년에 10억 정산 받았음
본인 인생이나 챙겨 200은 버니?
ㅇㅈ 귀엽ㅋㅋ
Ningning thumbnail is what i live for 🎉❤
I hope it won't get change this time 🙏🙏
OMG NINGNING SO GORGEOUS❤
닝닝은 검정빨강이 진짜 잘 어울리는 듯.. 드라마때도 그렇고
이번 위플래쉬는 지젤 헌정곡이다 2:54 볼때마다 쾌감 미친다
인정😊
진짜 이노래는 지젤이 미쳐날뛰네요..
이번 무대의상 지젤 최고..
1:17 여기서가진짜 ㅁㅊ음
카메라 시선따라가는거 존나 섹시함 ㅠㅠ
NINGNING SO GORGEOUS!!!!!!
여기댓글 왜이럼 ㄷㄷ ㄱ글 에서 벳프리 도대체 머길래--
wahh ningning thumbnail, thanks inkigayo
NINGNING PONYTAILLL IS SO GORGEOUS!!
Yes
I´m not even a my, but seriously, Ningning and Giselle ate so hard this choreo!
Ningning is so gorgeous like an AI ❤❤ !!
3:17 지젤 개이쁨 찢었다
윈터 이번 헤메코 아만다사이프리드 인타임 느낌나네 이쁘당..
원조는 제5원소 밀라요보비치
그거 노린거 맞아요 윈터가 해당 캐릭터를 레퍼삼고 자켓에서부터 헤메코한거라
닝닝 헤메코 레전드....❤❤❤❤
Ning Ning and Giselle are not popular in the group and are not visible, so people make little comments and get buried by other members.. poor member😭 The 4th gen top is Karina
@@aneu22hofoWhy you said NINGNING and GISELLE are not popular and not visible????? Clearly most of the comments are talking about NINGNING and GISELLE..
@@boboyaaa8641똥들은 그냥 더럽다 생각하고 무시하면 돼요 ㅋ
This is GISELLE's comeback! Amazing. Also, Ningning looks really pretty with black hair.
NINGNING AHHH you gorgeous talented being
THE ENDING FAIRY IS SO FUNNY! Winter and Ningning being gorgeous, Giselle going sweet but Karina is like EEEE? HAHAHAHA
just everglowup aka choujimi ningverse winterosy thewoo hooned peachxtaehyung psdoyoo etc trying to look nice after being xpsd with her alts nasrun and hypeboy with which she always wants all groups to d13.
3 comments in just a few seconds is you confirming that you copy paste everything and how riled up you are because over 100 people xpsd you in karinas solo vid where you showed that you dont even know who writes their songs.
180 liikes in one jump each which can be seen in many nice siites about these things confirming that you still use scripts for it and that there is still not a single person on your side or seeing you as a my.
even after a year of sppming using scripts and alts to support urself while you know that youre alone and still couldnt get a single person on your side is just you being the most mental h aater ever to still go on doing what you always do with all your alts.
even now using your karinaverse seconds after u and sppm more with it to make yours look better thats you saying youre the most men tal h aater ever.
NINGNING LOOKS SO GORGEOUS
2:58 ahhh Giselle the body rolll🥵🥵🥵🥵🥵🥵🥵🥵🥵🥵
TOO HOT TO HANDLE 🔥🔥
WINTER TOO GOSHH!!!
The way she said "move" ughhhhh mother 🥵🥵🥵
Right!!!!! Ive rewind that part like 10 times ❤❤❤
@@jessicaperalta3680 only 10?! lol
I knew it from the beginning, ningning is the most beautiful in aespa with complete package as idol, i love her
와 닝닝 미쳤다… 이번 메이크업 역대급으로 잘어울리는듯
이번 곡 진짜 닝닝지젤이다
ㄹㅇㄹㅇ 매력이 잘보임
느그지젤이 왜끼노 ㅋㅋㅋ
Their Stage presence improved so much over the years! NingNing's 2nd verse is so charismatic
닝닝레전드
에스파는 지금 어나더 레벨인듯
컨셉소화력이 그냥 미쳤다
와 닝닝 존나 이뻐 ㅁㅊ
the thumbnail omg ningning’s beauty is unreal
Giselle’s boy roll in her center part dayummmmn
Giselle you're soooo freaking pretty with pink hair
닝닝 너무 예뻐서 홀린 듯이 들어옴... 헤메코 레전드다
닝닝 진짜 미쳤다고밖에는...(positive)
I’m always waiting for Giselle’s part cause it’s so goooddd she literally own this era 💗🔥
FR
닝닝 너무 예쁘다
ningning is so AI beauty and thank you for thumbnail
심지어 닝닝은 보컬 톤조차 아름답고 우아함~
SES 바다 같음 목소리가
여신
0:14 진짜 이쁘다...
에스파 무대영상중 최고같음 ㅋㅋ
개개인도 이쁜데 팀적으로 조화롭고 카메라워크?도 레전드
ㅇㅈㅇㅈ
0:46 전환되는 부분을 너무 찰지게 살리심
카메라 무빙이라고 해용!
요즘 들어서 카메라 무빙하는 거 신경 많이 써주시는 것 같아서 조음 ㅎㅎ
개인적으로 이 부분... 2:53 쾌감 미침
cant take my eyes off NINGNING!!!
Karina - Gorgeous Outlaw Look
Giselle - Pinkie Barbie Look
Winter - Redhead Queen Look
Ningie - All black Diva Look
Nobody touching aespa's visual, styling and dance game!
even after a year of sppming using scripts and alts to support urself while you know that youre alone and still couldnt get a single person on your side is just you being the most mental h aater ever to still go on doing what you always do with all your alts.
so much sppm and once more not a single generic like seen on any copy paste comments shows that no one is on your side.
running away and even now not being able to answer to anything i said is you admitting to everything same with everyone else who xpsd you here on a daily basis.
as everyone can see multiple alts appeared in the last shorts to defend you seconds after your sppm here.
300 liikes in one jump a few hours ago after seeing that you didnt get any generic ones conffirms once more that no everyone here knows that youre a h aater.
Love ningning hair so suitable for her
썸넬 닝닝 와 너무이뻐.. 에스파는 무대 진짜 잘한다 네명 다 실력도 좋고 지금도 잘됐지만 더 더 잘되길
닝닝이가 진짜 요즘 리즈다….
what’s about liz means?
@@night_guard전성기
@ it means prime
@@zxaop991 🙏🏻
Ningning is the best performer ever
Ningning omg she's so pretty ‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️
Ningning is so beautiful
나 에스파 음악방송 영상처음보는데
썸네일 보고들어왔다 닝닝이라는애 왜케이쁘냐
닝닝 뭐야..갈 수록 예뻐져..왜그래 정말 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ아니 그나저나 이팀은 ㅋㅋㅋ죄다 비쥬얼 맴버인건가? 미쳤네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
0:20 인기가요가 진짜 좋은게 카감님이 에스파무대 항상 시작할때 스봉을 너무 이쁘게 잡아주시고 에스파도 너무 멋지게담아주심👍👍 썸넬뿐만아니라 에스파 미모 다 너무 이쁘고, 특히 이무대 카메라 무빙 너무 멋있어서 에스파가 입체적으로 추는 느낌임❤
We need more Ningning in the thumbnail because she’s one of the most beautiful female celebrities I’ve ever seen in my life. Her glorious face needs to be on thumbnails, magazines and billboards everywhere🙌
Ningning is eye-catching
Ningning kenapa cantik banget woy 😮😮
Bangettttttt
인트로부터 닝닝 줌한거에 감탄하고 감상
그냥 와~! 가 나오네
Ningning thumbnail so pretty. Aespa on fire
everyone is so beautiful, NINGNING I love you
Ningning with Ponytail as always she's the ace member of Aespa!! other members are slaying too !! and the starting position with Audiz and Mingmingz were so cute!!!
아니, 닝닝 미모 무슨 일임 대박 와 진짜 말이 안 나옴…
카메라 무빙이 미쳤는데요…?
우리나라 감독들 쩔어요
쩔어 특히 인가 에스비에스 인가 음방 감독 ㅎ
Im obsessed with Giselle this comeback! Girlie popped off and she owns it!
NINGNING THUMBNAIL OMGGG
3:31 ningning so beautiful ❤️🦋
Ningning, I will haunt you like a ghost.😻
아 닝닝 너무 예뻐서 홀린듯 클릭해버림 진짜 너무예쁘다
NINGNING SO PRETTY
오늘 에스파 정말 멋져보였어요...! 카리나의 반다나 룩은 미쳤고, 지젤의 핑크 바비 룩은 아이코닉하고, 민정의 레드 단발은 입이 떡 벌어졌고, 닝닝의 디바 비주얼은 전부입니다. 에스파의 또 다른 놀라운 퍼포먼스...!
as everyone can see multiple alts appeared in the last shorts to defend you seconds after your sppm here.
making fun of their language even now when alone this week over 100 knetz xpsd you for it so you just admitted once more that you dont care one bit about them.
even after a year of sppming using scripts and alts to support urself while you know that youre alone and still couldnt get a single person on your side is just you being the most mental h aater ever to still go on doing what you always do with all your alts.
using your script for 180 liikes in one jump for a comment where you make fun of their language is also you saying youre the most mental h aater without telling us.
Gisselle no es una Barbie porque no tiene cintura delgada como las demás
Giselle really deserved the Hot Girl title
NOOOOO NINGNING SO PRETTYYYY 😭😭😭😭😭
Ningning cantik bgt jir
NINGNING SO BEAUTIFUL 🤩
aero Chan ❤
Ning Ning and Giselle are not popular in the group and are not visible, so people make little comments and get buried by other members.. poor member😭😭😭
@@aneu22hofo Nah, in Twitter this two have a massive fandom and most Winrina stans have hots for these two. It’s only Korea but they do feel the love. They were really happy with their solo concert songs numbers
Ning Ning is beautiful！！！！
ningning is really the best performer of this generation
The most versatile of the foreigner-line 4th gen idols 😊😊😊😊.
One should constantly tell SM to have her own solo works in Mandarin Chinese and Korean, even Japanese.
Perhaps the Western producers behind the group’s newly released “Whiplash” can be tapped for dance-pop and EDM solos for the ice princess of Harbin (a northeastern city in China off Heilongjiang province where she came from)
👍👍100% agreed
Ning Ning and Giselle are not popular in the group and are not visible, so people make little comments and get buried by other members... poor member😭😭😭 The 4th gen top is Karina
@@aneu22hofo NONO NINGNINGGG ERA
@they are very much visible so lets not act stupid don’t stan the group if you dislike them aespa will always have 4 members‼️ karina giselle winter and ningning
어쩜..다들 미모가 날로.. 천상계로 가는중! 특히 닝닝이.. ㅠㅠ 너무 이쁘당!!
Everyday ningning doesn't disappoint me. She looks stunning ❤
Ningning is totally amazing! ❤❤
Aespa did it amazingly stunning! 🎉🎉
Everyone will watch this video because its cover. Ningning's face card is activated. ❤🔥
Winter and Giselle look so pretty cool with their colorful hair. I love their amazing performance with their hit new song 💯🫶🖤✨
닝닝은
진짜
역대급
와....
제일 예뻐진 멤버 ㄷ ㄷ
Benar benar era ningning, masyaallah cantiknya gaada obat😌
Ningning looking like a kitty in the thumbnail ❤❤
Winter's red bob with her strong facial expression and Giselle's stage presence are the highlights for Wishplash era no doubt! These two owning the era the most!
Ningning and Giselle*
닝닝 미모 무엇?..
Ningning looks so AI-coded in the thumbnail. So gorgeous!
ningning with a high ponytail is so GORG! she ate!
NINGNING ATEEEE
닝닝❤
오늘 닝닝 왜케 예쁜가요……. (원래 예쁘지만..😍)