Ghost in the Shell - Tachikoma Self-Sacrifice HD Subtitled
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 23 сен 2024
- The only other copy on RUclips is fairly low res / low quality.
This is one of the saddest moments in the show and I felt it deserved to be in a much higher quality... I'm sure if you got crazy you could make it in even higher quality then this with a more perfect copy but this is good enough for youtube.
This is not my work ect ect I don't claim rights to this... and seriously if the people with the copy rights to this want me to take it down I have no issues with taking it down as I make zero money from this.
If you haven't seen Ghost in the Shell Stand Alone Complex you should (And the second season 2nd Gig) + Solid state society OVA ;).
I love how Arimaki puts it at the end. "Some members of my team sacrificed themselves." Even he considered them to be more than just materiel at this point.
As the phrase goes: Human after all.
Hope he made a backup
@@reverendbluejeans1748 He didn't have to, at :53 seconds you can see the tachikoma's uploading All of their memories.
@@davidturtlebert1635 People after all. Human is the species... I know many humans that I wouldn't quite consider people. Even Dune has the test they put paul through, be a human and pull your hand out of the pain and die or be a people and deal with it because you can control yourself. My point is clear, don't make this about semantics.
It’s a callback to the first episode when he referred to them as their property and kept telling kusensgi that she would be given one like it was a rifle or something. Later on he starts calling to them on the radio as if they were humans and assigning them individual tasks to be performed in the mission as if they were team members. They showed how valuable they were just by the work they put in and they were the heroes in the end. However I dislike this scene as a follower of Jesus Christ because the whole self sacrifice concept is taking power away from Christ’s sacrifice also the cross symbology that Bato was holding is very much offensive to me because it steals from the story of Christ
And then Aramaki says, "It appears that some members of my team sacrificed themselves...." He understood, at that moment, that the Tachikomas were no longer equipment, but had become sentient beings. And, as sentient beings, they had performed perhaps the ultimate act that such a being could do: conscious self-sacrifice.
A brilliant, brilliant episode, in a brilliant series. I wonder if the entire second season was concocted just to set up that scene.
It is possible. It such a good scene in an awesome series.
I think the better term would be sapient. Sentient means something can feel and learn. Which all A.I's can do. Sapience means that they are capable of empathic and philosophical understanding.
And they did it all without fear as well. Godspeed, Tachikomas.
+Neon Pegasus They showed they are capable o feeling fear before, so I would say they did it all with fear, and that's what make their sacrifice even greater
This scene ties everything! They sacrificed themselves for LIFE, contrary to the suicide bombers who died and killed in the name of "individuality". The tachikomas, by sacrificing their data gained ghosts, souls. Best anime writers ever.
yup..I don't know why I felt more sympathy over them than those who died at Dejima or even Kuze...this really touched my heart and I can't help getting teary when they sang the song while intercepting the nuclear. They gained individuality but at the same time working collectively to attain the goal of saving the people and they proved it when they ignored Major's order and unanimously agreed to use their satellite to stop the nuclear. This should be a life-lesson to those suicide bombers. If i remember, it's even pointed out in the series that those who died were forgotten. Even Kuze didn't become the hero as what Ghoda had said. I believe that the tachikomas are the real heroes of that incident.
Mango Pie Totally!
***** Exactly, right on the money: sacrifice. While the tachikomas "sacrificed" the part of them which is dead (the system, the robot), the suicide bombers sacrificed themselves because of a system, a belief, a future not a present. The tachikomas followed their ghosts, their souls, even if that destroyed their bodies or defied the orders of their bosses, while the suicide bombers destoyed their bodies and stoped following their ghosts to follow a system, the difference os that tachikomas were in the present moment while the suicide bombers were thinking about a promise of what the future could be. The tachikomas are so zen.
cant die if you're not alive. their death made them alive
They stored their copies into the net, that's what that one Tachikoma was doing. They come back in Solid State Society... which made me scream in absolute happiness.
+Akane Kurashiki It was kind of obvious when you see the 7-8 lines synching with the massive data storage they had just created. But yeah, spoiled me too, of which I'm kind of glad.
Derp Festor it's just data without their ghosts...
Well. Considering that the original versions developed ghosts on their own. Its not ruled out that the copies can do the same.
Meh, they didn't really do anything more interesting with it in SSS, so kind of a waste. Sometimes a spade is just a spade, and that's the most impactful way to deal with it. Considering the state that GITS is in these days, all stories have to end, and perhaps it was better for it to end then.
Suppose that's true for many things.
For a nano second I thought you were referring to the tachikomas as Onion Ninjas. Fair enough.
i... cried... for robots... childish robots... childish arachno tank...war machines with a child's soul... who are singing... i cried for singing automatic tanks, throwing themselves from a satellite to stop a nuke...and i cried :'(
You're not the only one homie you're not the only one
You are not the only one
We all did...
I didn't cry. Phwt! Crying is for Women.
Real men weep. I wept like a spoiled little girl. MOTOKO!... I mean... TACHIKO!
@@kinenai *M O T O K O ! ! !* 😭 😭
"Some member of my team"
That is the highest compliment to give those wonderful Tachikoma
This scene really made me cry. The innocent curiosity of the Tachikoma's is what made them unique. I remember when Ishikawa said that the Tachikoma's doesn't understand the concept of labor. Since their AI is childlike in simple terms. Instead what other people think as labor is just an childish adventure of curiosity for the Tachikoma's. When they said their goodbyes to Batou, made me tear up. But the fact that they were able to save their ai memories in the net made me happy in the end.
Same.
they lived as children and died as heroes may their sparks join the matrix of the all spark
The greatest of Cybertron.
Think back to the comment they said earlier in the show.
" _The mark of an immature man is that he wants to die for a noble cause, while the mark of a mature man is that he wants to live humbly for one._ "
Dinobot would be proud.
Children or not they never wavered.
*ghost
I came back and watched this scene to realize that Proto was talking about the Tachikomas when he said that everyone one of them had ghosts. That shit blew my mind.
Mr. Stebb thank you.
Probably the deepest and most important gift that GITS has given to the scifi genre and story telling in general.
I really need to tattoo this sentence on my arm
That’s one of the things that makes this scene so heartbreaking :*(
Wait wait wait you serous? Ghosts? But how?
Love the symbolism. When Batou holds the beam that is shaped like a cross.
Seriously one of the most beautiful moments in cinema.
It's TV
Obviously referring to the broader world of motion pictures, dude.
Quiet Giant shit your bitchass up
My eyes might have started to get a little wet a couple of times, but for me, tears actually fell at two points in watching the S.A.C. series. Once when the Tachikoma sacrifice themselves to save Batou, and again when this happened.
Gentlemen, I salute you ;-;
Kurouga - the saving of *Batou* in the first series is especially heart wrenching when they’re talking about how weak they are and the Major’s voice comes to them... jebus, just thinking of that gets me.
The thing that really cuts me is how Aramaki refers to them as members of the team after, he talks about them as he would refer to the Major or Bato, and when the President refers to them as such he doesn't correct her.
At this point it became clear that they were more than just machines
"Were all alive, every last one of us"
tachikomas are examle of a great character development. In first episodes, I fucking hated these little squiky robots. In the end of season 1 I started to like them. In the finally of season 2 I cried for their death.
Trully amazing.
I love how japanese can reverse trend :D in metal gear solid or ghost in the shell it presents that advanced AI does not have to be evil it can become friend with human,
Its the nature of our (American media) to fear the other. Its really a sad trend. I think AI or Synthetics might be the best thing to happen to us. If we dont bind them down with our bad old ways of thinking.
Jacek K When in Metal gear was an A.I. good?
Blade Wolf from Metal Gear Rising
Ah. Sorry, you said Metal gear solid, so it threw me off.
They definitely get that machines we create can inherit our best and most important values and feelings if we steer them towards it?
People say that this scene is cheapened by the fact that the Tachikomas come back in Solid State Society and have a continued presence in SAC_2045, but I really don't think that's the case. That satellite had their CPU's on it, which is essentially their ghosts, and while the Major was able to recreate them between the end of 2nd Gig and Solid State Society due to their design specs being released onto the net and was seemingly able to restore their memories from a backup, she still would have had to have created all new CPU's from scratch meaning that the distinctive personalities of the originals are gone forever.
This seemingly carries over into SAC_2045 where, although their personalities may seem the same at first, the distinctive personalities that we saw in the first two series are entirely absent. The Tachikoma who loves reading books, for example, is nowhere to be found, something which is even more noticeable in the English dub with the absence of Lara Jill Miller, who played that particular Tachikoma in the English. This is particularly notable considering that fact that not only has Lara Jill Miller recently gotten back into voice acting, she also plays a major character in another Netflix anime, Beastars, so she was would have certainly be available had they needed her. But perhaps the most glaring absence is that of the Tachikoma that clung to Batou and served as a sort of de facto leader to the other Tachikomas. Not only does Batou not seem to show preference to any one Tachikoma over the others in SAC_2045, he doesn't really seem to have the fondness that he had for the Tachikomas in the earlier series.
So in the end, the Tachikomas really did sacrifice their lives by crashing that satellite which held their CPU's into that nuke, and although their replacements are still very much every bit as alive and sapient as their predecessors and have their memories, they were never able to develop the same distinct personalities that made each of the original Tachikomas so unique in their own individual ways.
Everytime I boot this up, I'm like "yeah, not gonna cry this time, I know what happens", then by the second line of the song I've teared up.
God damn, onion ninjas. Every single time I see this scene, they come and rub onions over my eyes.
I know, they are even using Themo-Optics because I can't find them anywhere u-u
Damn ninjas!!! They found me too!
I don't know how I found this place, or what I have just seen.
SAME
Yup... you’re (not) alone...
1:24 that fade to silence, a widely observed quiet and respectful acknowledgment of passion and self sacrifice, disrupted by the piercing wails of my sobbing like a newborn child.
It satisfies me that Aramaki refers to them as "members of my team."
I too get tears eyes when I watch this scene, but it is actually a happy scene. The Tachkoma are content and know the value of their existence and of their sacrifice. It is really a party, that they are having in the cyber space. High-fives and singing about being alive, knowing that in the end, their lives had a meaning and were able to serve and save those they cared about.
It is almost a sci-fi cliche, robots and artificial intelligences and other kinds of non-human entities being more human than the vast majority of mankind, displaying what we collectively as a species claim to be and should be but are still millennia away from achieving....
Kilravok AI is rarely depicted positively in Scifi.
But if it's anything like Human intelligence, it's how they're treated that matters.
This clip is always hard for me to watch, because of the Tachikomas. They will always be my heroes for what they did.
James Caufield agree
First time I watched this it did not dawn on me that song was from the Tachikomas and that they were moving their satellite until it intercepted the nuke and the singing stopped. Then it hit me like a ton of bricks. I love how Aramaki evenly says that the nuke crisis was adverted like it was another normal day. Then just as evenly states it seems members of his team sacrificed themselves... acknowledging them and their importantance.
0:54 hope. Tachikoma is making a backup of all your memory on the server Kuze ;)
That's the tachikomas memory's
They are back in the new Ghost in the Shell series and they kept their cheerful selves when they see Batou or Togusa.
Came to see which episode this was from, ended up with a severe case of allergies. That's my explanation for these tears and runny nose and I'm sticking to it.
Seriously though, years later and just thinking of this scene still makes my eyes sting and my throat tighten.
Stop using natural oil. :)
scifihero2 - you’re (not) alone :*(
Man, Going into this anime all those years ago, I had no idea how much i'd cry at the end of both S1 and S2 for these Tachikoma's
togusa's reaction is so sweet especially in regards to how he beaves towards the tachikomas in earlier episodes but aramaki is still as stonecold as usual.
To be fair he referred to him as his team.
stoic, not cold… aramaki considered them a part of the team.
Scene is so powerful it makes my skin numb yet so abrupt I cant bring myself to tears after its over. The Tachikoma attained sentience but instead of seeing humans as beings that abuse their free will, they used their free will and existence to protect humans and cyborgs from their own inhumane decisions. More advanced than the cyborgs or governing humans because of the wealth of data in understanding humans the Tachikoma amassed led to them discovering what humanity is. Their compassion for humans made them more human than humans themselves and they conquered their technology, politics, ideals, philosophies and a freaking nuclear missile in a single moment of genuine act of sacrifice. Scene is epic, beautiful, sad, haunting and mentally stimulating all at once, leaves me in awe every time. Power of love can still create miracles even in an advanced society that's losing its humanity. A lost expression in Science Fiction nowadays!
Apparently, the song the tachikomas are singing, "Tenohira wo tai you ni", was written by a former Japanese soldier who fought in WWII named Yanase Takashi.
I cried ...........like a little bitch I loved those guys
"We're all alive.
It's because we're all alive that we're sad.
When we raise our hands and let the sunlight filter through,
we can see our blood coursing through them a vivid red.
Even earthworms, mole crickets and water striders
are all, all alive and all our friends.
We're all alive
It's because we're all alive that we laugh.
We're all alive
It's because we're all alive that we're glad.
When we raise our hands and let the sunlight filter through,
we can see our blood coursing through them a vivid red.
Even dragonflies, frogs and honey bees
are all, all alive and all our friends."
Thank you
“There no greater love than laying down ones life for a friend.” I strange to think this may be the future some day and we do need to ask if a Robot can can love and have a soul. A soul made of silicon.
I've buried friends, too many.
and foes; yet not enough.
and still...
this fiction... about AI children...
about sacrifice.
made my ' old man' ass weep like a child.
Aramaki... very precise word choice, honor band respect given. quietly.
Tachikoma are very interesting. some people think that AI will see human as a threat but the tachikoma do the opposite. they learn what humanity actually is and find value in it those make them ready to sacrifice themselves
This is .. extremely sad and fascinating... but you'll find the very best thing at 0:53
ya that's how the major brought them back later
Notice how it refers to itself and not all?
@@Trek001: The Tachikomas synchronize their memories so thoroughly that they can't remember which of them did what. It's during synchronization that they can switch to agent mode and run around in cyberspace, so, in this scene, there is effectively only one Tachikoma memory to save.
This scene and Blade Runner "Tears in the Rain"...two of the best
I was just watching the Star Trek TNG episode where they have a tribunal to decide if Data is alive and self aware. It reminded me of this scene and I came here, only to find for the first time the translation to the song they sing as they sacrifice themselves. It’s awkward, because I’m standing in a grocery store trying not to cry
I loved the tachikoma. Tripped over this clip tonight- still makes me cry like a little bitch. They were good kids. And good troops. And in the end, they got to find out if they really did have souls.
Lucky them.
I love this song. Never knew the lyrics, made me cry 😭. Thank you 💕💐
'Don't concern yourself ma'am' What the hell chief, this is quite a bit more concerning than just a nuclear attack. A group of A.I. not only achieved individuality and decided to sacrifice themselves AGAIN, but they did so unanimously. This act changes the whole world!! Not just having ghosts on par with humans, they might be more noble than us.
Freeze 0:54 seconds and read what Tachikoma typed in.
haha sly tachikoma storing their AI/Ghost memory in somewhere in the net.
this is what GITS is about. questioning what is reality and what is a soul. not that shit hollywood created.
Tachikomas became much more than humans, they are far superior in my opinion. What we should be like, maybe.
They are the children of man. And all wise parents wish that their children should be better than they were...
"more human than human"
This shit legit made me cry. An absolutely beautiful moment
What a banger of a show. Even after all the time of its release, its amazing writing. 10/10 I am def foward of rewatching it sometime in the future. Loved those little robots too. :,)
That and the first time the Tachicoma's sacrificed themselves for Batou were the saddest moments in Ghost in the Shell! That anime is the best there ever was , nothing will ever come close to it (Monster's a pretty good second place though! )
I'd still say Togusa about to pull the trigger to save his daughter in Solid State Society is more heartbreaking, but damn if this scene doesn't hit just as hard, but in a different way
They are truly more alive than any of us meatbags
So true !!
Yeah... I still get tears in my eyes rewatching this... years and years later.
I just finished this anime and didn't realize until the end why the Major called the new green ones. Because the originals sacrificed themselves.
I still cried inside more from the 1st season when one says “Goodbye Mr. Batou”. Before 2 of them blew themselves up right in front of him.
I'm 28 years old, and that made me cry. 💯💯
im 33 and i watched GOTS for the first time these last 2 weeks. I cried both times. And it really got me when i got on youtube and found this video with the english lyrics AND finding out this is a popular children's song in japan that kids sing in elementary school.
@@justinkerr8063 I think that makes this scene all the more sad and touching. 💯
It's possible they decided to sacrifice themselves merely because of programming, but their decision to sing about how amazing life is undoubtedly was the result of a ghost.
Damn! I cry every time watching it. Yet, I always seek out this video.
This destroyed my heart with emotions
40 years old and I cry every time
Instant waterworks even after all these years.
*//THE FALLEN SHALL BE FOREVER REMEMBERED AS THE EMPEROR'S FINEST.//*
I had tears when i saw this. Even in the first series when they sacrificed their bodies without knowing that their ghosts were somewhere else.
This is both so sad, heartwarming and awesome. Like... they rammed a nuclear missile with the satellite containing their souls. How badass is that?
Well, i really shed a tear when it comes to fiction. But Tachikomas managed to make me do it.
This song always makes me sad but as a lover of artificial intelligence makes me happy that tachikoma show that they are able to give his life for his friends!!
All the tears in the world.
Those little guys, I'd be so upset with them but also so very happy. Ahh
I randomly watch this years later. and I'm still crying. been over twenty years balling right now.
I teared watching this again
I cried here... :'( That was amazing...
This is how you make a story to make us questioned souls in machines, as Human we can reflect on it, not making us doing a guilt trip on how despicable humanity is with the story, looking at you Detroit become human.
Ping Pong the Animation
Ghost in the Shell
Man, every anime I've seen that has this song has been an absolute killer.
I think my soul died along with them...
That face when you spend the entire series thinking they're dumb and then you get hit with this scene...
1st law of robotics : a robot shall not harm a human, or by inaction allow a human to come to harm.
Greatest scene in anime history.
still one of the best scenes in any media i have scene.
beats avatar twice over at least, so much more actual meaning in so many different areas makes it a no brainer.
I'll be honest, when I watched this back in the day, I sorta found the Tachikomas a little annoying... until they did this. It was an All The Feels Gut Punch I didn't see coming.
Lost some of my MEN. He recognized them as part of his crew, and as alive.
the scene was so sad being that these guys had pretty much gotten something that for a time would seem impossible for a machine. They all had gain a ghost they were no longer equipment anymore they evolved into thinking sentient being an even then still gave up their lives to protect their friends.
I'm not ashamed to say that I teared up....there I said it.
Larga vida a los Tachikomas, como no llorarlos, ... no lo puedo creer que se sacrificaran
Man I watched this whole season this week and this specific moment had ninja cutting some onions they were pure kind and always eager to know more and more they really have special space.
"members of my team" gets me every time.
I teared up a bit at this.
I saw, no idea why it does that.
When real men cried.
Requiescat in Pace, tachikomas.
I get misty eyed and that knot in my chest everytime I watch this.
"You lost men?"
"No. These things had way bigger nuts and bolts than any men ever had."
so sad yet so cute
"And God shall wipe away all tears from their eyes; and there shall be no
more death, neither sorrow, nor crying, neither shall there be any more
pain: for the former things are passed away."
Revelation 21:4
True sadness is when you dont backup your drive
I just loved how immortal they are (Solid State Society)!
Damn it! Hints all allong and still tears for the Tachikoma. I don't usually even like anime. This is brilliant.
They are always the goodest of bois.
In my friendgroup we only need to mention the existence of this song for tears to start flowing. Actually singing it is a struggle because the ugly crying starts about halfway through.
Tachikomas are too pure for this shit filled world T_T
These robots where the only thing i remembered from this anime. I was young then. R.i.p. robots
right in the feels
This is really amazing beautiful and sad.. cant help but cry for the tachikomas.
I never knew what the lyrics to the song were. This scene has made me cry so many damn times even now. There are so many things about this that are fascinating though. Tachikomas have none of the features that would normally make someone love them (other then personality if you watched the show) This is the one that has always thrown me off the most.
They sacrificed themselves for the greater good, they paid the ultimate price, to save the gosts of millions of others. They were truly lovely beings.
If they uploaded their current conciousness to the net they only left a copy. They still experienced true death in the satellite. Its incredibly sad, but its what i would or anyone decent would do, even if they didnt have the option. "Lives of the many" kind of stuff.
I remember I cried violently the time I saw this..
I'm not crying... YOU'RE crying!
Get Chills everytime I watch this