Classical Musicians React: DAY6 'Congratulations' vs 'You Were Beautiful'
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 22 авг 2024
- For the 72nd video of this series, classical music majors react to DAY6’s ‘Congratulations’ MV vs ‘You Were Beautiful’ MV!
We plan on reacting to DAY6’s How Can I Say & Dance Dance, I Smile, Say Wow and Hunt.
~Channel instagram: @reacttothek_official
~Support us on patreon and get extra access to videos you’ll never see on YT: / reacttothek
~Full Reaction Schedule:
docs.google.co...
~THE FULL LIST OF MVs TO-BE REACTED TO: • Playlist
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Video editing by Umu
Thumbnail credit goes to Nozomi Murayama (insta: @nonchanyuzuru)
Subs will be done by Ash
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(PD) Umu:
Instagram and twitter: @_emcha_
RUclips (Kpop covers): EMCHA
Tumblrs: / kpop-instrumental-covers
/ omg-horns
/ bangtan-fanart
/ funny-vixx
(kpop, mamamoo, bts, vixx) Amino app: Umu @ ReacttotheK
(channel manager & assistant editor) Eric:
Twitter: @ricekangaroo
(Assist. filmer) Ash:
Instagram: @ashhfong
Snapchat: @ashleyfong457
Henry:
instagram: @zappa_yes_floyd_genesis
Twitter: @henry_carpender
Yunyi:
Tumblrs: / classic-jenny
/ beijingboi
Facebook: / classicjennycomics
Peyton:
Instagram and Twitter: @pjohnzzz
Jarod:
Instagram: @JVLPhotographic
and @Jarod_lau
Melissa
Instagram: melissa.447
Kevin:
Twitter: @nerdymusicks
RUclips: nerdymusicks
Gwen:
Instagram and Twitter: @gwenpakerr
RUclips: Gwen Paker
Hugo:
Instagram: @hugohumbility
Shimon:
Instagram: @shimonohi
Ben:
Instagram: @ben.j.l.kronk
Naoki:
Instagram: @naokitoyomura
Lindsey:
Instagram and twitter: @lamusicstudio
tumblrs: / punk-popsicle
/ double-horn
Fiona:
twitter: @fiona_stout
Insta: @fionaastout
Emiel:
Fb: Emiel De Jaegher
Insta: @trumpetoats
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
*DISCLAIMER: I do not own any of the songs or videos being reacted to in this video. All credits to the companies that own them.
Also, none of us are PROFESSIONAL musicians. So if you come here for a strict breakdown/analysis of the music, you won’t be getting that.This is strictly my conservatory musician friends taking time in their schedule to watch kpop for fun, and throw in any musical comments that come into their mind! Also please do not complain about any "boring" reactions...some of the musicians have blank faces since they are concentrating so deeply on analyzing the music.
"kinda sounded like boy-band-pop"
somewhere in the world, Jae is super triggered
Abby Thornton 😂😂😂
Abby Thornton let's tweet it and wait for his reaction muahahaha😎
do it lmao
very true
Abby Thornton LMAOO
"I'm assuming they broke up"
"Who gets the puppy?"
Melissa out here asking the real questions
"I don't mind if music doesn't go anywhere, 'cause I feel like sometimes life doesn't go anywhere, and you just have to enjoy the moment" Melissa the Wise strikes again, she's on a roll
Yeah that puppy is important😂😂
She has priorities, good priorities.
XD
the girl with the nose ring and the asian guy in the green shirt have the best comments and analysis of the music. you can tell they really appreciate the composition.
They are literally professional musicians and music analysts. I am loving it.
YEAHH I THINK SO I LOVE THEM
I stan Kevin
I know this is late but they were the most senior I believe in the group :)
Which is why we don’t see them anymore since they graduated :( although Kevin stayed back to do more reactions but Yunyi :(
Plus Kevin’s basically a piano god lmao
Yeah agree
How we react :
HOLY GOD VISUAL, THE MV IS SO TOUCHING TOO
How they react :
That drum, his voice, mhm that tune
makes mo sense lol we listen to the music too though?? sounds like it's just your personal preference.. visuals over music
LOVING YOUR PROFILE
I react both ways
yeah and so many terms that i basically don't know but it's o k
@@sasham6960 this comment is cringe man hahaha
One of the reactors: boyband
Jae: ExCusE yOu IT SAYS ON THE JYP WEBSITE THE WE ARE FIRST BAND FOR JYP
We are not a boyband nor idols.
Yeah the reactors know the details of Day6 being a band, but their music is leaning towards pop more than any other rock group so sometimes it's easy to call them a "boygroup"
No worries! I was just making the joke because Jae likes to point it out.
Hahah! Jae the Sassy Twitter God
ReacttotheK They're still not a boygroup and are a rock band
They're clearly a pop rock band at best though, any person who listens to rock music can tell you that
If only DAY6 can also release MVs for their non-title tracks. Gosh, these guys just don't know how to release a bad song.
I'm shitting myself he legit played it after hearing it only once...Wgejsidhejsbegkws damn I have no talent
He's been practicing for almost a dozen hours a day for his whole life. It's just hard work and passion more than talent really
is it weird that the first song makes me want to watch a kdrama XD
skyah31 SAME
AWWWWE YEH
IM NOT ALONE XD
I know this is an old comment but when I show this one song to my bestfriend she told me exactly the same XD
Choi woo shik aka the guy in the train is actually in train to busan
Tiffany Yangiee and Parasite lol.
Can we have Kevin play the entire You Were Beautiful on piano it's so beautiful omg im crying ;-;
laxorarity I support that
It's so beautiful
laxorarity YES I WANT THAT!!
I'M ABOUT TO COMMENT THE SAME THING 😭😂 AND YASSS
Yeess! Please make it happen Umu~
"AAAAWWWW!!! THE PUPPYYYYY!!!!"
Me: "I did not expect that from him... but I like it."
such high note lol
thats me every time i see a puppy xD
You should see his reaction to Stigma then
Shivangee Chauhan Oh I have, don't worry, caught that too LOL.
Luscious Angel I literally said in that moment : "SOMEBODY PLEASE GIF THAT!" Hahah
Comic GOLD! SO RELATABLE ~
Actually, what makes a good song? Some reactors were disappointed that there wasn't a lot of musically interesting stuff in these songs (though I beg to differ) and that similar stuff had been done before. Not trying to refute them because we all have different preferences and experiences when it comes to music.
But listen carefully to their melody. Day6 songs have amazing melodies. More importantly, they always gel with the lyrics. That is what pulls me into their music, all the time. Melody + lyrics + music arrangement + delivery of the songs. They do it so well! For example, their newest release 'Hi Hello' has simple chords and progression and nothing groundbreaking musically. But that is when the ingenuity of their melody writing stands out. And I LOVEEEE it. I listen to music to enjoy them and maybe feel some emotions, not to analyze them. Again, I know the purpose of this reaction series. So I understand why you guys won't react to 'Hi Hello'.
Can I also say I am always amazed by how Day6 songs throw me off guard. How a sad song can be super major or have lots of percussion. You were beautiful is not a very slow song for a very sad one. And if you only listen to it without the singing, you might even think it's a happy song! But with the melody and delivery, it sounds super sad. And oh, I love their subject matter. So refreshing. When it comes to that though, my favorite is How Can I Say. Cannot wait to watch the reaction to that one! Thanks guys for the hard work!
omg you said it so beautifully...same, I feel the same way mate!
Yes, can't wait for "What can I do" too
You just simply speak out all of the thing inside my brain OMG. Actually, I'm not really into Day6 at the start. I don't know i just feel like something is missing. But somehow i read the lyric, understand the meaning of the song and now i become their fan. You're so right they totally stick to the lyric. After reading the lyric, everything is make sense, i can see now how the melody like that, totally fit to the lyric. I also like how they pay attention into detail. Ex: I Smile is a sad song about meeting your ex when you still not move on but you still have to smile to him/her, and you can see they kinda force it when sing the "i smile" part. Also at Letting Go, Jae's part at first at the "hana mana" somehow his voice sounds like holding tears.
Kei Yoo bc they have studied music a lot songs may sound boring which is sad. But to people who have untrained ears the music just sounds nice, personality I think “simple”and “repetitive” songs are good at times
Kei Yoo THIS. THIS. THIS.
I'm so happy that people are now recognizing how great Day 6 - Congratulations is and the song's getting more and more attention 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 day 6 artistry is lit! I can't say much though for the guy in the middle who said this is below impressive but hey, different strokes for different folks
can't wait to see them react to "hi hello" and have them freak out over them throwing their instruments
Jomster lmao I'm not even a musician and I cringed so hard when they were throwing the instruments into the truck
Jomster ummu already reacted to it solo. Kevin and her love the song but they decided not to have video reaction with other reactor. The reason is there isn't much musically going on.
Where can I see it?
See the reaction or the music video? The reaction is on this channel as well :)
ughhh when jae threw his guitar i wanted to cry
Melissa: who gets the puppy?
Now we're asking the real questions LOL
Love you guys and your reactions ❤️
afternoon tiy i hv a couple friend who stayed together because of their dog lmao 😂
"you out your feet on my guitar girl? you better hope i love you"
same peyton, same.
*sad noises*
"I need a kpop support group"
"Stop dancing, we're sad"
"I just really like Day6, okay."
Omg I relate to emo, angsty Gwen so much 😂😂
The best thing that has happened to me in 2017 is Day6 releasing two new songs every month I can't even put into words how much I love their music
Same, after the drought of 2016 (I swear once I didn't see any of them for like two months) this is everything I've ever wanted!
exactly
"hi i'm- oh fuc-" melissa i like u already👌😂
edit: AND I SEE U WITH A LEGEND O ZELDA SHIRT KEVIN
Hey, can we take a moment and talk about the fact that Kevin just listened the song once and played her on the piano like it was nothing? I'm thrilled. Kevin is amazingly talented. Gosh.
Does he have perfect pitch? If so it isn't that hard
nah, i think it's common in music institute (they've been taught music theory), and the chord pretty simple imo, if you get used to analyse chord proggression in songs, i think you can do that too...
Hugo: "I'm gonna go listen to this and cry"
Me: same
I know this is not important but can someone tweet this video to Jae? I want him to see that there are people analyzing them musically and actually love it. I just want Day6 to feel loved and inspired to make more beautiful music uhuhu idk man im just so emotional rn send help
laxorarity I'm gonna totally spam him with this. He NEEDS to see this!
laxorarity Im not sure, jae would probably roast all of them lmao
Inspiring my Infires knowing Jae he probably will roast whoever conplimented Wonpil 😂
Inspiring my Infires lmao the shade to be thrown 😂
Already done, xD.
"THEY WERE ON A BREAK"
that reference from friends tho
honey menu Fencing man
How the hell did I JUST NOW NOTICE that “Congratulations” was the guys POV of their relationship and “You were beautiful” was the girls POV!?
Comparing this to their latest day6 reactions, I can't believe how their reactions against Dowoon's drums changed. At this point, they were underwhelmed by the drums, but at the new reaction, they are amazed. Thank you for pointing out Dowoon's improvement.
WHO ELSE WAS CONSTANTLY REFRESHING WAITING FOR THIS UPLOAD
I just went on their channel to see the reaction schedule and then saw "..uploaded 26 sec ago". And then 3 minutes later came the notification :D
meeeeeeeeeeeeee !!!!
Life of Jodie MEEEEEEEEEEE TOOOOOOO!
MEEEE!!
Life of Jodie Hell me.. sure me...hell yeah
How can Kevin do such a thing? Immediately runs to the piano and just banging out those chords? my gosh. I SALUTE.👊👌👍
markiepooh tuan I thought I was the only one who was legit fucking shook even tho he does it regularly it amazes me everytime I need him to teach me his ways
The girl with blue shirt: *being sad*
The boy on the side: the foot thing again..
14:50 did he just casually walk to the piano and played the song? from memory??
Kevin has perfect pitch (and a pretty good memory, obviously), so he can reproduce the chords with fair amount of ease.
Gwen and Hugo are always so emo :'D
YES IKR?! Melted and One Shot were epic emo time of Hugo and Gwen tho 😂
I relate to them so much tho xD Same, Gwen & Hugo, same. ;-;
awk ward I was so disappointed because Gwen didn't react to melted
I loved the girl and boy that were so saddened by the videos. They're true homies. The others that were really into made me proud haha. My Day here! ♡
예뻤어는 데이식스 멤버 원필군이 작곡한 곡입니다! 지인분의 예뻤어라는 말을 듣고 영감을 받아서 급하게 아이폰의 악기앱으로 대충 따놓은 것만 들어도 발매된 예뻤어와 거의 동일하답니다 천재죠,,ㅠ 무조건 다들 좋다고는 하진않지만 그래도 긍정적인 반응이 많아서 좋네요 데이식스는 케이팝 아이돌이 아니라 밴드그룹이라 많이 느낌이 다를거예요! 많이 들어주셨으면 좋겠어요
I love how they appreciate youngk's rapping and how he's one of the better rappers they have heard and I just totally agree. For me, he's a really good rapper (the best even lol cuz im kinda biased you see) and a vocal at the same timeㅡ a perfect combination!
Last time I noticed that Naoki and Shimon were not actually into Day6, but now they like ittttttt #imaproudMyDay
Yeah, I was actually expecting them to dislike these ones but their reactions were a pleasant surprise.
Ikr, I always thought they were gonna like I wait and Letting go better but well, life is full of surprises :D
Tramiere SAME I'M SO RELIEVED 😭💞
Tramiere Me too! Especially since Shimon & Naoki are my favorites (well let's not forget about Hugo & Gwen) it makes me really happy to see them liking Day6 much more now;;; and Shimon saying Day6 were like, really up there put of the many groups and songs they've listened to just made me super happy as someone who was a MyDay since debut.
It's really refreshing to hear all the reactors have so many different opinions. Also, it kind of comforts me as a 'layman' listener, because it proves me that my tastes are valid as long as I can defend them with good arguments, which are provided profusely on this youtube channel. I've always loved music but I can really feel how my ear has changed now that I pay more attention to all the things the reactors often point out. So thank you, to you and eveyone ❤️ (sorry if I made mistakes, English is not my mother tongue)
Elb: What I find really refreshing is that someone, YOU; wrote a simple but meaningful comment about the value and impact that ReacttotheK has on your enjoyment, understanding and appreciation of music. Plus you wrote it in a humble and thankful way. And, no apology is necessary for any self-perceived inadequacies in communicating in English because they don't exist!
You sir, are very kind and made my day better. So much love in this comment section hahaha 😄
Elb: Looks like Umu is showing you some love too. She promised on her twitter account, Umu @_emcha_ ,to share the following tweet thread with all the reactors! twitter.com/fda1115/status/885682481445220352
You explained it well more than what i feel.. Thanks for this because we have a same feel dude 😍😍
hey really late reply but your tastes are valid no matter what! if you like it, you like it - you don't need to explain yourself to anyone else
i’ve listened to Day6 for a while now and i’ve been trying to figure out why Day6 is so different than most kpop groups. When i first heard them was from Congratulations and it gave off a very american vibe to me and i’m wondering is it just because they used band instruments? (i don’t know much about the analytical part of music so i don’t know how to describe it) I love their music because it is unique to most kpop groups but also very typical pop rock in american music to me. Please help me describe this better anybody who knows music.
I think they get most inspiration from British rock? Correct if I'm wrong but I'm pretty sure I heard that somewhere
For the fact that one of them is raised in LA... I guess you can say that?
Em Rose probably bc they’re not a kpop group
You guys make me want to be a classical musician even if I have no musical talent whatsoever
I HAVE BIOLOGY, CHEMISTRY AND 2 OTHER EXAMS TOMORROW BUT THIS POPS UP IN MY NOTIF SO HELL YEAH! WHERE ARE MYDAY'S AT??
Who Are you??? SAME
Who Are you??? I thought ur pfp was a hair on my screen 😑😑😂
Your DP lmfao I thought there was a strand of hair on my laptop screen. XD
·The chain Rapmon broke while filming reflection· SAME 😂😂
Who Are you??? / bc of your pf pic i thought there was a hair on my screen so i blew on my screen for no reason-
#MyDay here !! 🔥🔥 anyone else ?? 😉✌
A.C.E iarmy-l stans HERE
HERE!!
Right here!
eyyy~ hello there~ !
Denia Diaz ❤❤
COn-GRA-du-LA-tions
I will never get over the low and high in this one word
“I think I need to go listen to this and cry” *mood*
dear classical musicians,
*AKMU/ AKDONG MUSICIAN IS HAVING A COMEBACK* YOUR REACTIONS TO THEM IS A MUST HAHAHA I'M ALREADY WAITING.
IM REALLY HYPED, BUT LIKE ALL OFHER GROUPS WE STAN WHO HAVE COMEBACKS WE STAN, WE WONT REACT UNLESS THE SONG IS MUSICALLY COMPLEX
Can classical or vocalists react to Sohyang on king of masked singer pls!
ReacttotheK React to Blackpink's As if it's your last. I want to hear your opinions musically.
BLINK MEME Umu says they won't be reacting to BP's comeback
yes but remember this is akdong musicians so it's already given that their music is lit haha
I do understand why some reactors did not prefer this kind of music but anyway they do have many various genres in their music...
if you haven't tried, do try to listen
''Blood" - kind of dance vibe but the beginning part sounds colorful to me
"Color" - vocally, this is quite strong...
I LOVE IT WHEN KEVIN GOES TO PLAY THE SONG ON THE PIANO, OMG MY HEART. AND THE FACT THAT HE CAN JUST EAR ALL OF IT I--?? PLEASE MAKE KEVIN GO TO THE PIANO MORE OFTEN GEHIDJNLK
2:46 "Who gets the puppy?" I already stan
“i just really like day6 okay" same
aww gwen and hugo are so cuute
Farah Yusrania Theyre both such sweet people. im glad that they react together, they complement each other well
Farah Yusrania they really are cute together. i like how their reactions especially when the voices are so good
Umu: "so, yeah, was anything particularly musically interesting-"
Kevin: *WHAT IS MIXTURE*
"I'm not crying, you're crying"
They know now why we call them SAD6.
Counting down the days until 4minute.
Jessica I'm sorry but how did you know it?? Is there a schedule list?😢
In the description box for every video there is a link to google docs. It has a list of all the songs that will be released with their dates. Also at the end of each video, a few second preview of the next song is played.
하하하 there's a link in the description box of the complete schedule! :)
Jessica Thank you so much!!♡
Effie M Thank you!! So kind♡
Finally I love Day6 soooo much their songs never disappoint (neither do their tweets lmao)
5:38 dear God, Kevin helped me finally realize why Day6's music feels so familiar. It sounds so close to early 2000s American pop/rock.
that new girl is cute af
awww gwen and hugo were so cute and squishy in this 😁
STAN DAY6!!!!!
also
"I'm not crying you're crying" i relate
Melissa: I guess their relationship wasn't good at the start..."
it showed flashbacks of their relationship and how good it was going in the MV
big bruh moment
Because the flashback moments contains all of their relationship...a relationship can look happy on the outside from other people'e eyes. and still be unhappy. Big bruh moment because Sayrose doesn't seem to understand this.
My point was how melissa stated it tho, "at the start", at the start it was going well, at the end it wasnt cause the girl was fed up, that's what i'm saying about the flashbacks. Bruh moment for you my guy for not reading properly🤦♂️
Guy: *sees jae*
Guy: uh god I love him
Okay me.
I flailed like a damn fish when I saw this notification
Update: Gwen and Hugo are fucking adorable. My biases
2nd update: New girl is creepin on my bias list. She so pretty and I love that "life doesn't really go anywhere sometimes" remark, drawing parallel from the music
I think the guy in the green shirt, blonde hair needs to see Royal Pirates and FTIsland! Or even some indie bands!
RP :((((
I love Day6 sooooooooooo much! thank you for this reaction
jae tweets absolutely anything:
us: congratulations (ALL VERSIONS)
"Who gets the puppy?" lol serious question
Quality as always but 'Who gets the puppy?' is the type of question that needs to be asked more! More Melissa pls hahaha ^^
Day6 will have a comeback this month. So excited to see a reaction from the OG reactor of Day6
just happened to come across y'all's channel while practicing fanchants for the day6 concert, and omg i honestly love it sm!! everyone makes me giggle so much!
Someone send this to Jae
Hikari Elf Already done, xD.
So this is Musicians react to Musicians ? 👌🏼👍🏼⚡️😂
The first time I heard congratulations, I cried seriously it got a lot to my heart and I started to investigate more of them, I don't regret anything I love that band
저 친구들이 이 뮤비 남자주인공이 기생충 주연배우인 거 알면 무슨 반응일지 궁금하네요 ㅋㅋ
저도 문득 그 생각이 들었어요 ㅋㅋㅋ
I really like melissa(?) she's very bright, hope she appears in future episodes(maybe)
she's the Official sub for Davis and you'll see her in about 10 more videos before next school year starts
I HAVE BEEN WAITING FOR THISSSSS! YASSSSSS! WHERE U AT #MyDay?!
Its so amazing how Kevin just gets up and can be able to play the whole song in the piano
Just lole that hahsha
예뻤어 작곡 비하인드 스토리 멤버 중 누구더라 한명이 누워있다가 생각난거 녹음했는데 그거 가이드
라인이 원곡이랑 그냥 똑같음
React to Wondet Girls, 'I Feel You' and 'Why So Lonely'.
Already on the schedule
My life is complete we finally have a reaction to Congratulations!!! Woooo
I'm very excited!!
currently on a reacttothek throwback binge and i GASPED when i saw shimon naoki and ben THE ULTIMATE TRIO
Always coming back here whenever I can to revel on how amazing DAY6 is! A VERY PROUD MYDAY HEEEERE 😍😍😍😍
WE NEED KEVIN TO MAKE A PIANO COVER OF "YOU WERE BEAUTIFUL" ASDFGHJKL-- Pretty please~~~~~
you should let them react to some king of masked performances ^^
Tessa G. Sohyang- Home and Mona Lisa. It NEEDS to happen.
Truuue. So sad she had to leave. Also Chen's Stained.
Solji " Maria"😍 I like it a lot
"Baby demon (DK) - Fate" too!! uwu
ekateuno I agree! Solji's version of Maria is so epic. it's a classic for King of Masked Singer fans.
09:27 그리움이 혀 끝에 감돈다는 표현이 참 좋네
Congratulations gives me a massive goosebumps everytime I'm hearing or listening to it. 😭
YAAAAAAAAAASSSSSSSSS!
okay, but can we talk about Henry screaming about the puppy? cause I'm sure my heart melted
"I think I'm gonna listen to this and cry."
*ME ON A DAILY BASIS COZ DAY6*
4:37 oh my gosh he knew 😂 JAE HE GOT THE MESSAGE
YASS DAY6!
I'm so glad I decided to check Day6 out more - they are so lovely and talented, I love them and their music and Congratulations is definitely one of my favourites...nevermind it's too hard to pick any favourites when it comes to Day6! =)
I just came back to watch this video again after Jae said that he watch their reaction too.
He did?
"Stop dancing, we're sad" its literally me 24/7
"I just really like day6" -Gwen, 2017
I feel you girl!!!! 😊
I really love these videos even tho i have no idea what are 'good' chords are.
Good chords are basically any chord that isn't a triad. So any hoed with more than 3 notes. 7th, 9th, 11th....best chords. Usually used in jazz, so when they're used in pop music? 10/10
Chord* not hoed
ReacttotheK Don't worry about your typo. I understand since i had to proofread my comment three times just to fix my typos.
Why did I only discover this reaction video now??? Huhu i love all their reactions even when they're kinda dissin some parts hahahaha but i feel SO DAMN PROUD OF MY BOYS!! 😍👌
Thank you for sharing this video! I personally like day6 and I do respect all those musicians! It was interesting to hear their thoughts about day6's songs :)
"I just really like day6, okay"
thats relatable
I LOVE THE NEW REACTOR GIRL! PLEASE KEEP HER
Everyone was like commenting on the music while henry's crying over the puppy
"This is a good representation of sadness"
YES I CAN RELATE
so happy they're doing Day6 again.
I feel Gwen at the end
whenever i feel depressed, i always go back to season 1 and rewatch my fav reactions. really helps me, i appreciate all of yall so so much thank you TT
OMG YES! Saw the Congratulations MV soon after it was released because of Terry's Twitter, and have been recommending friends watched it ever since. The first time I watched it I initially it was a "congratulations you debuted" sort of thing :P
Also, was definitely not expecting the connection when I watched You were Beautiful, so well done. DAY6 so great :3