I used to be a fanboy of Yasir Qadhi. I used to listen to him a lot. Wallahi this Yajuj wa Majuj lecture of bothered me a lot when I first was listening during his series of Signs of Judgement Day. I had to listen to it twice to understand what he was taking about. I still didn't get and couldn't believe what he was saying. Then Alhamdulillah refutations came across from Sajid and others. At first I found myself defending Yasir because I loved listening to him then after listening to refutations against Yasir I had to accept the truth. I had to choose Islam over blind love of a "scholar" who keeps making huge mistakes. Never follow anyone blindly. There are a lot of real and trustworthy scholars around the world. Listen to them but never follow anyone blindly.
The fact that you got confused after his ya'juj ma'juj lecture showed that you already followed something blindly, why did that lecture bother u? because u already followed a commonly accepted narrative, and hearing something different is strange to you, but hey, thats fine, everyone does that, but its what you do with that feeling is whats important innit? but it seems like you didnt do the right thing with that feeling and instead u went on slandering an esteemed scholar on the internet, so keep on telling yourself to never follow anyone blindly, but just know that you yourself need that advice the most, take a look in the mirror m8
@@daftyute it’s ok for him to make a joke. However this is a scholar saying a zinadeeqa theory is viable and possible and even “makes more sense”. This outrageous for him and even his “clear up video” was a pretty backhanded apology. But yea jokes are one thing. A scholar saying yajuj and majuj being zombies “makes sense” and is possible is another.
If you notice, Yasir Qadhi has a habit of invoking the "unimpeachable witness" -- (my friend said, an imam you all know agreed with me, one of my teachers whose name I can't say, etc ).
I feel sorry for the people who are into this 'follow' culture. Once they start following someone they don't bother to do their own research and become zombies themselves. While it is the responsibility of the educated to pass on the right knowledge, we as laymen need to realize that scholars or speakers or students of knowledge even, are not infallible. And in today's times with the ease in access to information, we need to go back to our sources and confirm everything to the best of our ability.
For example I'm a layman muslim I want understanding of Islam that is the closest to the truth What can i do? Find someone who is knowledgeable, wise and has credentials I know that YQ has credentials and I personally found his lectures to be nuanced, wise and beneficial So there are 2 possible ways i, a layman muslim, would dismiss YQ's position on anything 1. Some 'alim with good credentials who i find wiser and more knowledgeable comes along and refutes YQ's position. Then i would prefer this new 'alim's opinion over the opinion of YQ But I don't see that 'alim. With admiration to every caller to Islam, I don't find Farid and Daniel and Sajeed etc to be nuanced and wiser etc in their content, so I won't prefer their opinion over YQ's 2. YQ says something that goes directly against clear aspect of Islam You talk about doing "one's own research" and "right knowledge", but what if Quran and Sunnah don't establish clearly that these tribes are alive today (that hadeeth was found problematic by Ibn Kaseer, for example). So is YQ's position "wrong knowledge" because he adopts a minority position while having precedent? And am i wrong for following him so that you should feel sorry for me, my muslim brother?
@@mark_severin There is nothing wrong in "following" I fact it is a good thing to follow and now invent things in the religion, however you follow the scholars of ahld sunnah wa aljama'a who take their views from their salaf and now make up stuff from their brains, you said yasir has credentials and is wise, well get what ? Everyone has credentials today and as for wisdom, you can't know truly who's wise or dumb in the deen if you yourself is a layman, and yasir qadi is not ( a mujtahid) or someone who reached the level of ijtihaad mutlaq which makes him worthy of being follow on his views as a reliable scholar, and I can tell you that a mujtahid would not fall into the issues as yasir did, so Don't be building conclusions based on a false premise, so if you wanna follow, then follow those who are not upon innovation rather they teach the religion as it was taught from those before them, and this is exactly what the Messenger pbuh said "the saved group is those who are upon what I am upon and my companions" meaning that islam is clear and you should stick to what knows scholars of deen say not even joe and shmoe, if we follow random dudes just bcz they got a degree every now and then, and follow their weird absurdities that clearly go against Islam, then in just a 50 year period, you'd end up with a new religion totally different from Islam, so may Allah make us from those who follow the path of the Messenger and those after him and not of the innovators .
@@hamzamohiuddin973 You are not in a position to advice your own self even YQ retracted and said he was not being serious and was "joking" (joking on a faith issue), more so I don't need to watch a Gay loving liberal Imam's lecture for anything actually.
I’ve watched many of his lectures and I came across this Gog and Magog video recently. It’s just strange to me how inconsistent he is with the topic of Ya’juuj and Ma’juuj. When it comes to other mysteries, he says: “Allah knows best about the mechanisms and realities but we accept it.” Yet when it comes to Ya’juuj and Ma’juuj, he’s like, “How do you explain a tribe living behind a barrier for thousands of years?“ and he’s coming up with all these crazy theories.
We should answer simple the way we believe Isha(AWS) is alive thousands of years. we don't know his whereabout either but we believe it too. especially if something in Quran and authentic Sunnah we believe it.
Sh.Yasir is arguing that the current existence of yajuj and majuj is not explicit anywhere in the Quran and Sunnah and therefore it is not necessary to accept it as it is, the same you would for other miracles - the Resurrection etc. It is NOT confirmed in the Quran and sunnah that yajuj and majuj are currently alive so why should he have to accept it as he would other confirmed miracles? Fear Allah, you dont even understand the subject and are critical of a scholar who has studied the deen more than you ever will. Have some humility.
@@angrypat4023 I know what he’s arguing and that’s not even what I’m trying to say. I watched the entire series lol. Some of the commenters don’t understand the difference between a miracle and an opinion but I’m not one of those. I just don’t get what’s the big deal about Ya’juuj and Ma’juuj. What’s so hard or bizzare to understand about a tribe behind a barrier somewhere for thousands of years?
@@Kimeikus The point is that there is no reason to believe it. If there was then there would be no difficulty in believing it. Since the world mostly mapped and understood, it is hard to accept that billions of people are alive somewhere behind a wall, you would have to believe that it be a miracle. By definition, some miracles are those that cannot be explained by natural causes - hard to believe without Allah swt. Thats what he means by it being difficult to accept in that regard. The idea that someone is thrown into fire for an extended period of time and survives is hard to believe, however none of us doubt for a second that this happened to Ibrahim AS, because Allah makes all conceivable things possible and it is easy for him. But sheikh yasir is only arguing that it is difficult in that regard, not that it is hard to believe that Allah swt can make it happen should he so will.
I have never been a fan of Yasir Qadhi or any of the so-called "celebrity Imams or Sheikhs". I converted to Islam in the early 90s, so this was before the internet transformed so many of Ummat into "Mashaayikh". A couple years after my conversion, I was blessed with the opportunity (الحمد لله على نعمه التي لا تحصى) to study under some traditional scholars. Even after over 20 years, I still remember one of my teachers telling me to beware of "celebrity Imams". It's one thing for someone to become famous because of their knowledge, piety, and adab. If this wasn't the case, we wouldn't still be talking about such giants as Imams Abu Hanifa, Shafi, ibn Hanbal, Malik, their students and the Imams of hadith and so on رحمهم الله جميعا. Traditionally, it was understood that a seeker of Islamic knowledge knew his or her place so to speak, and conducted themselves with a sense of التواضع humility. Unfortunately, nowadays, someone with a B.A., an M.A. or even a PHD or perhaps not even any of the above, readily give Fataawa without hesitation, or their own "personal ijtihaad". These same people would not even have been allowed to speak in the Majaalis of true scholars let alone give their opinions. The sad thing is that so many are being mislead by them. أسأل الله تعالى أن يهدينا ويحفظنا جميعا
The evolution of yasir qadhi is astonishing I remember attending his munaaqasha in madinah and from how he was then until now is crazy how he has changed 😳 Allah guides whom he wills
@@qasmb1546 { ...يُضِلُّ بِهِۦ كَثِيرٗا وَيَهۡدِي بِهِۦ كَثِيرٗاۚ وَمَا يُضِلُّ بِهِۦٓ إِلَّا ٱلۡفَٰسِقِينَ } _...Through this ˹test˺, He leaves many to stray, and guides many. And He leaves none to stray except the rebellious-_ 2:26
@Bearded Guy How can you have free will and no compulsion when Allah is literally guiding who he feels like guiding? and misguiding who he feels like? Can any puny human stop Allah's choice? No. So what you mean no compulsion? This is clear divine compulsion, which eliminates free will. So again how can life be a test then.
@Bearded Guy Lmao you mean the scholar bamboozles with you rhetoric? The text is so clear, is a scholar going to change whats written in hadith and quran? Sorry should i submit to my scholars or my creator? because you people seem to submit to whatever the scholar says. NO MATTER WHAT THE TEXT SAYS. No matter if the scholar is contradicting the text.
So he projected this view onto his friend and presented it as a joke, but he hoped that people would start contemplating this bizarre view and give it validity. 2:40 I'm surprised the original video isn't called "how to give waswasah 101"
@@nadeematif1993 ?? this is exactly what YQ said at 2:40.. it doesn't matter if this view was thought up by his friend or not. That's not the issue here.. The problem is YQ is the one propagating it publicly and misleading people.
@@nadeematif1993 the original commenter didn’t imply that U just want to argue for argument sake and r looking for shallow responses Sarcasm doesn’t fit you btw
@@nadeematif1993 I’m talking about the original commenter You r being sarcastic to him and arguing a point the commenter didn’t make If you want to refute him, stick to his points and don’t bring annoying sarcastic responses. Did you even understand what he said? I didn’t water down anything. It’s clear u r being sarcastic. Or r u serious that he knows what’s in his heart???!
I was stunned that 3 years later he actually lied that he was ‘joking’! He clearly was not joking , and he also mentioned that I am just saying ‘what my friend said’ and was at least part serious.
Yasir Qadhi is a Neo-orientalist and continuing the work of Syed Ahmad Khan, he was supposedly an Islamic scholar, however he worked with the British during the occupation of India, introducing himself as a reformist. He was a big asset in the colonization of India and subduing Muslims there; the British still promotes him as a role model and a great man.
he plays around with words so much, you can actually see it clearly once you put all the clips together. harder to notice if you only watched the videos when they came out
8 major benefits of Astaghfar in the Quran. 1. It opens the doors of mercy. The Quran says, “Ask forgiveness of your Lord. Indeed, He is ever a Perpetual Forgiver.”[Quran 71:10] 2. It will give you wealth and children. The Quran says, “And give you increase in wealth and children.” [Quran, 71:12] 3. A Believer’s Dua gets accepted. There’s nothing better for a believer that all the duas that he or she makes in hopes that they will one day get accepted by their lord, actually get fulfilled. Astagfirullah has the power to make a Muslim’s duas get accepted. 4. Astagfar provides sustenance. The Quran says, “Seek forgiveness of your Lord and repent to Him, [and] He will let you enjoy a good provision for a specified term and give every doer of favour his favour” [Quran, 11:3] 5. A Muslim is not punished while they seek forgiveness. The Quran says, “And Allah would not punish them while they seek forgiveness ” [Quran, 8:33] 6. Allah will send the rain of mercy. The Quran says, “He will send [rain from] the sky upon you in [continuing] showers.” [Quran, 71:11] 7. Adding strength in our lives. The Quran says, “. . . ask forgiveness of your Lord and then repent to Him. He will send [rain from] the sky upon you in showers and increase you in strength [added] to your strength.” [Quran 11:52] 8. Allah will provide you with gardens and rivers. The Quran says, “. . . and provide for you gardens and provide for you rivers.” [Quran, 71:12]
*Yasir Qadhi:* “How can the disbelievers find it strange that Allah will resurrect them when He was the One who created them in the first place?” *Also Yasir Qadhi:* “How do you explain a tribe living behind a barrier for thousands of years???????” Wallahi, the inconsistency is amazing 😂😂
@@tiktokasylum5186 Exactly *Edit:* Just a clarification for those who didn’t get my point-Yasir Qadhi’s rejection of this interpretation is based on the logical possibility of the event happening, not because of textual ambiguity. He literally said: “How will they survive? Where will they get provision? etc.” That’s the whole reason why he’s looking for alternative explanations in the first place. I just want to understand why this miracle is so troubling for him when he already accepts the other miracles face value.
nothing in our pillars of faith forces us to believe there is yajuuj and maajuj alive somewhere behind a barrier today. If you claim otherwise please show proof or fear Allah and correct your comment.
I'm not defending YQ but it's true to the average person, God resurrecting people obviously makes sense because God has the ability to, but human beings don't live for thousands of years. Not a defence of YQ but a view I understand where people can side with him.
If you question them, they will certainly say, “We were only talking idly and joking around.” Say, “Was it Allah, His revelations, and His Messenger that you ridiculed? Make no excuses! You have disbelieved after your belief. If We pardon a group of you, We will punish others for their wickedness." Surāh taubah (9:65-66).
@@Ahadun.Ahad56 Please don’t engage with this person, they’re fishing for attention. It’s clear that nothing will change their minds with these bad faith arguments.
@Brother asked a very good question I wouldn't have quoted it if I didn't know! Whoever says the apostate punishment doesn't exist has definitely lied about Islām.
I found his indirect support for Ilhan Omar more disturbing - I think his approach to the whole thing has been terrible with vague statements. His comments on Quran preservation were also very confusing and deeply troubling. That said ... I've recently been going through YQs Seerah series which I am finding very beneficial alhamdulilah.
@Brother asked a very good question lol islam is rent free in your head hence the name and commenting on our channels Apuss not doing it for you anymore
you find it beneficial for inorder to gain trust he needs to back to the teaching of the salaf (sererah series ) and in doing that he can add his opinions and for those whos aqeeda is not grounded they will fall for it. if you need to benefit there are alot of brother who teach without watering down Islam. Madaratul ummariyyah ,Medina college ,khalid green among many
When one prefer the INTELLECT over REVELATION/WAHY, then Shaitan will have the way to render one to go astray through the instillment of PRIDE followed by ARROGANCE.
@@Nima-ec4tr May Allah bless your brother and guide him to the straight path and you too🤲🏻 This is why the salaf said if we were to trust our deen with someone, we should trust it with the dead coz the living is not free from fitna
We are also very clear Mr YQ that you are tailoring Deen Al Islam to please your worldly God! May Allah Subhanawatala saves us from these kinds of Modernists scholars i.e: Omar Sulaiman, Nouman Ali Khan, Imran Hossain
05:47 "However, in this particular issue there is nothing to clarify" - he says this statement in the context where he is trying his best to clarify the same issue. Edit: YQ is contradicting himself.
Bro, first he said he didnt believe in yajuj and majuj, after we called him out, he says ( Now) in the video, he believes in it, thats first a contradiction, why would he make up theories to believe if he doesn't even believe in it??, secondly he also said there are holes in the Quran then says there arent after they called him out,
By "nothing to clarify" that is presumably referring to the content of the lecture itself. What he was speaking may he seen as a "clarification" of the whole matter but he didn't go into specifics to clarify on the topic of discussion (by expanding in his "point" and whatnot). Hope that makes sense.
either YQ really has so much confusion in his brain that he doesn't remember what he said and how he said it or he is really a deceiver and an arrogant liar.
@Brother asked a very good question As an atheist you should find another hobby besides spending all your time talking about a God you supposedly don't believe in it is clear that religious people live rent free in your life. You derive no joy or fulfilment from your empty life I feel sorry for you.
@Brother asked a very good question You're confusing with Yahweh the deceiver that love to fool his servants by sending lying spirits. Quit the projection!
He has nothing to say or defend. Even if you tell a 2 year old child this story. He will laugh at you. It's a fairy tale and not revelation, let alone come from God.
As an atheist, I find the stories in the Qur'an to be even more fantastical than tales of zombies. I can't help but to see this as YQ admitting he doesn't fully understand the stories of Yajuj and Majuj. Too often, I see believers expressing excessive confidence about what God truly meant. Admitting you do not know is not a weakness.
I find this amusing …. Yasir Qadhi is a scholar. Whether big or small. He makes an ijtihad. His principles are Quran and Sunnah with usool of our tradition. Whether ijtihad right or wrong. How can so many keyboard scholars Most of whom has not studied basics make him a deviant. His ijtihad being wrong doesn’t make him deviant
Last time I looked up, he's a Dayee and not a Scholar. He has knowledge but that doesn't give him rights to give fatwa on religious matters. He always says that's his "own" opinion.
I think there's some Islamic channel that also have a similar problem, but it's with their thumbnails. They write things like " *YAJUJ AND MAJUJ* ... !* " on it with a picture of some monsters/goblins/zombies from some movies. I also saw some thumbnails of videos about the angels using images of horses with wings. We don't know what angels look like, they should not even try to represent them. I understand that they don't want people to scroll across youtube without looking at their videos but it isn’t permissible to use something haram to give da'wah. Lying, and teaching things that have no foundation in Islam will not help in this life and the other. On top of that, as you said, people might think this is serious and they will start believing in ridiculous things that are not part of Islam at all. May Allah guide all of us and forgive us for the mistakes that we make.
@@Kitty99900 i watched apostate prophet, david , hatun many more . U didn't need to tell me. U think everything apostate prophet told is true and changable. Thats ur delusion. Sometimes it seems what people say arw true but reality is different
3 signs of a hypocrite: when he speaks he lies, makes an oath breaks it and when he is insulted he behaves in an evil and insulting way. -Prophet Muhammad pbuh
Do not ignore the enormous flaws of him. Do not listen to him. They are much too big to simply “ignore” . Stick to the reliable shuyookh and remain safe.
@@hasnain9654 Imagine thinking YQ is a “deviant”, lol couldn’t be me. Typical madkhali’s going so hard at other muslims while being kind to enemies of Islam.
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته Laymen have really taken this "joke" seriously! A few months ago I'd criticised YQ on my twitter, and one of my mutuals dmed me to defend him! And when I shared a picture in which there were many points listed regarding YQ's misguidance, this mutual of mine actually said "his zombie theory might be true"! Look at how she fell for this! May Allāh ta'ala protect us from misguidance. May Allāh ta'ala bless those who refute misguiding claims and those who share and spread them!
I thought Yasir Qadhi already made it clear in the past that he doesn’t believe their is a tribe of people hidden away from people. Daniel already called him out on this.
@@Sufia_Rafidah_Buster he only shared with you three hadīth, you really thought that was too long? have you ever read the entire Qurān or any hadith book from front to back? Just saying bro you can read those hadith in 60 seconds
Wait, Yajuj and Majuj are not ridiculous? When did that happen? Zombies certainly sound as reasonable as the tall tale of Y & M. Yasir Qadhi was spot on.
Your reasoning is wrong. To believe in something in the future is different then to believe in something that is occurring in the present. For example, if I tell someone I will help them move houses next week, and the person I’m helping has knowledge that I’ve done this before and knows that I’m also currently helping others , then it isn’t impossible for them to believe that I will do it for them as well. But if someone was to say, I have a Bugatti and big mansion at this location, yet no one can find it, then this belief is blind and merely trusting someone without any evidence. Yasir Qadhi argued that Yajuj have died out, therefore no one can find them. But they will come out from the graves when Allah orders this. His conclusion might be funny to you, but it’s either he believes this or become a ex Muslim and abandon Islam. Because to believe that there exist today a nation bigger then the current population of humanity, behind a wall. And not a single person have found these people is hilarious. And any average person will see that your faith isn’t built upon truth but cope.
Joking about Islam and Islamic teachings is a sin so serious that I cannot possibly express it's seriousness using words. This is something we all should keep in mind and avoid this sin and we should always be careful when it comes to Islamic teachings. Assalamu alaikum
Dear Farid, I respect you and that is the reason I feel I must make this comment: A Muslim should not criticize another Muslim behind his back or in public. If you have issues with him, and it seems you have some valid issues, you should talk to him directly in private, and then perhaps you two can make a joint public statement after agreeing on what that statement should be. This ummah cannot and should not behave in any other way. Try to be as humble as you can be and make an effort to show your humbleness to others because Allah loves for Muslims to have better etiquette, and may He bestow on you better etiquette and on me as well :)
So a muslim can criticize a non muslim behind his back and publicly , coming from a scholar like you i guess that's the islamic way of doing things, would it be ok if non muslims take that stance?
Hi Farid Al-Bahraini, just wanted to tell u that I have just recently completed your book "Martyrdom of Hussayn RA", it was a wonderful piece of work✨ by you....Your research on authentic tranditions of Martyrdom of Hussayn RA was absolutely brilliant loved it! Can't believe it's written by you, it was awesome 👏
All those authentic traditions or stories were written by Sunnis. When you become a judge, before passing any judgement, you have to investigate from both sides. If you hear from one side then you’re surely following a wrong path.
@@DesignbyBK i have heard Shite side and it has no logic to it... The Shite version involves the slandering of companions of Prophet SAW, which I can never ever endorse... Because Allah is pleased with all companions of Prophet SAW, whether he is Muawiya RA, or else
@@hasnain9654 First thing I want to clear, nobody clearly knows what exactly happened in Karbala… I’m neither in favor of accusing Mawiyah RA neither any other sahabis. My Question to you is simple If Allah is pleased with all the Companions of Prophet Muhammad SWW. Then who were Munkireen e Zakath? Weren’t the companions who accepted Islam during Prophet Muhammad SWW life and after they rejected to give zakah tou govt?
Let's be honest here, Yasir Qadhi mentioned the zombie theory as a far out out interpretation of Yajuj and Majuj. He himself does not believe in it, but seems to think it is a far out possibility. That is why you can even see him and his audience giggling in the original video. Unfortunately, certain Najdi Salafis, who hate Yasir Qadhi, made this into a big issue and made it seem like he was putting this forward as his main theory. You have to remember, that the Najdi Salafis are out to get Yasir Qadhi because he left their sect and criticised their founder. But I thank brother Farid for making this video in a respectful manner.
Salaam alaikum. What exactly did he say against the Quran and Sunnah? He mentioned the zombie theory as a far out possibility, not that he himself believes in it. I actually think Yasir Qadhi is hurting himself when he says it was a joke, because it is quite clear to me that he considers it a possibility, however unlikely and humorous that possibility is.
He literally said “ how can you believe people are under a rock for thousands of years without sunlight” whilst reading a surah about a group of people under a rock for 300 years.. so he went on to come up with better more plausible theories like the zombie theory lol 😂… this man isn’t fit to be called a shakh. He has Eurocentric inferiority complex
@@gajiburrahman7378 his indirectly against surah al Kaff and the boys who sleep under a rock for 300 years because it’s not plausible for them to survive that long without sunlight… he said that about gog and Magog but he indirectly exposed that he also has doubts about surah al khaf..
@@gajiburrahman7378 What about what the Qur'an and Sunnah actually say? That they are a large tribe of creatures hidden behind a barrier and that they are digging each day trying to break free and whenever they get close to breaking free, they pause the work to continue it the next day, only to find that the barrier reverted to its original state by Allah and He will allow them to move when He sees fit. What about their story with Dhu Al Qarnayn which happened in the past. Did Zombies exist in the past? The zombie theory clearly rejects all this (unless if you wish to brainstorm and expand on it to include these points as well). In addition, Yassir Qadhi said that this theory makes more sense than what is in the Qur'an and Sunnah. He may not totally believe in it, but just the idea that he sees it as a possibility says something about him, given how this theory deviates in a large degree from what is in the Qur'an and Sunnah. In my opinion, I think people hide behind this zombie idea and defend it just because it uses scientific terminology (virus, vaccine...)
@Aziz Rahman That's exactly the point brother YQ is trying to make. Go watch YQs latest video on this topic. In summary, he said that the narrative that yajuj and majuj digging behind a trapped wall has a weak chain. Therefore, it isn't required for Muslims to accept and defend it like we defend other authentically reported miracles or signs. Therefore, it can't be called mocking as claimed by many.
Farid im not against you ....and not against Yasir Qadhi , but why are you making a mountain out of an ant heap. You are showing shaitaan that we have become divided based on a subject that contains elements against mankind. Shaitaan and Yajooj and Majooj. They will trouble mankind and this argument ON THE ACTUAL SUBJECT ON THEM is making them celebrate. Brothers UNITE !!!
@Idoloclast4 Im not against Yasir Qadhi. Is there something you know that i dont. I have learned a lot from his lectures, and i know he has many supporters who love him. He is sincere. .....but where is he wrong?
So many scholars not able to penetrate this subject, that's where I say that sheikh Imran Hossain explanation is correct. There are others who also say gog and magog are released but still there analysis of this subject is weak. Only one who has been able to see the bigger picture of this subject is sheikh Imran
YQ has become so bizarre that the US government has him on the list of people they can use to manipulate the Muslim community in America. We have all seen this with all of his non-sense. Now that he is openly known for this, his reputation has been destroyed.
I don't know this guy but Yasir Qadhi is one of the greatest scholars alive in our world today may Allah blessed him. Just the library chats in his youtube channel is enough for a proof. I think you got disease in your heart if you can't see the sincerity, knowledge and goodness of Yasir Qadhi.
Tawbah 65-66 “If you ask them (about this), they declare: ‘We were only talking idly and joking.’ Say: ‘Was it at Allah, and His Ayaat (proofs, evidences, verses, lessons, signs, revelations, etc.) and His Messenger (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) that you were mocking? Make no excuse; you have disbelieved after you had believed. If We pardon some of you, We will punish others amongst you because they were Mujrimoon (disbelievers, polytheists, sinners, criminals, etc.)” Yasir Qadhi might not be Muslim anymore, Allah knows best.
Even when he's trying to pass it off as a joke.. he has the silver youtube sign in the back infront of the books of hadith... that says it all putting youtube and fame infront of the deen may Allah guide us and him aameen
Funny how he rejects the concept of yajuj and majuj but accepts the Hollywood idea of zombies and tries to refute what is in hadith and Quran with western fiction
06:32 with respect and love to my fellow muslim, why don`t you make a poll which takes into account what percentage actually watched the whole video of YQ, not clips cut by you and others and put online so that people who already don`t like YQ read in and make the worst assumptions? no one who knows YQ`s methodology and actually watches his videos with all his disclaimers and remarks and caviats will say that he was "making mockery of the deen" like you said. we all make mistakes, but the way Farid, Daniel H. and others blow things out of propotion and cut and paste when it comes to YQ who is sincere and has studied Islam extensively and is respected by some senior ulama and has put forward so many videos millions of muslims benefit from. tell me, how much of his thousands of videos is wrong? 1-5 percent? is it so important that you ignore everything else he has done and that you spread misunderstanding and hate and fitna among people with this massive bias and your cut and paste? do you really think this is beneficial? if there`s one thing that makes people i know stay away from their deen it`s how much polemics and accusations and fitna there`s on the level of people of `ilm
Thank you for speaking up. Yasir Qadhi has done immeasurable good. It's not the end of the world if he has unique views on certain issues. He's neither the first nor last to do so. These refutation videos only create animosity and ill will.
Subhanallah, I couldn't have said it better. Again I also hope the best for brother farid, but do we seriously think that a twitter poll has any meaningful value when considering this topic? Right away there are flaws in using this data as (1) the people who vote tend to be people who follow you and are aware of your previous content on YQ and (2) there is no way to determine whether the people viewed the *entire* lecture or just the clip (or didn't even bother watching smh). Let us not waste our time in such fruitless endeavours. And let us use our ability to genuinely think with an open mind which our actions truly benefit the ummah. May Allah guide us all.
Wow, so much energy and effort put into making a video to divide muslims even further over a misunderstanding. YQ was making a side point about the possibilities of future events that none but Allah know.; this isn't haram as far as i know, scholars will have opinions and theories but they are human and allowed to interpret things based on their scholarship. We have to give the shayukh and teachers some space to teach without criticising their every word; this is extreme behaviour unfortunately and a lot of us are missing the manners and fiqh around iqthilaaf. How many events described in the Quraan and prophetic Sunnah are described in terms that didnt happen literally or we couldnt fully understand until after the event. YQ even said 'allahuallam' in the video; its clear it was a point that he was making without it being his primary message. If he wanted to undermine the religion or make light of the sunnah dont you think there would be stronger examples; are we just going to forget the mountains of hours of good he has contributed that blows that theory away? Allah help us.
The prophet (s.a.w) Abubakr ,Umar. Uthman ,Ali (r.a) the tabieen did make not that possibility .what gave him that rights . its haram when you bring a teaching in which the prophet(s.a.w) did not bring . If so everyone can interpret according to his/hers unserstanding but we say ALLAH said ..... His prophet said.... we those shuyukh and scholars teach something that is against the teaching of the prophet (s.a.w) we refute. . YQ has an intention to reform Islam when he says there is holes in the QURAN, qomut lut should be given their rights, mocking our scholars the list goes on . By the way people refute the mistakes he is doing . This is not personal but keeping the deen as it was brought by AL MUSTAFA (s.a.w )and passed down by the sahaba and tabieen until now.
@@everygoodisinwhatthesalafb7613 There were scholars who held worser views of Yajuj and Majuj in the past. Ibn Taymiyyah had a strange belief about hellfire for a longtime until he retracted his position on it. At that time would you would have thrown Ibn Taymiyyah under the buss?
Absolute fools, so quick to jump on their brothers for perceived "errors/mistakes". I wish y'all had the same energy when it comes to your brothers and sisters dying by the thousands all around the globe. Or towards your hypocritical regimes that are complicit, even supporting, the deaths of the thousands. Y'all take a stand on the most trivial of stupidities, yet refrain when it's actually needed. May the ummah be cleansed of hypocrisy and those trying to promulgate division.
Bismillah Salaamu alaikum ikhwan. Do we want unity as an Ummah? Do we want to be unified upon Islam and what is the arkan? Or do we want to be divided on these types of lesser issues? We have to stop supporting those who don’t want the best for our Ummah and who are willing to divide us for a few views. Is this type of content making us better? Wallahi think about it! I’m done with this time waiting and slander! أَطِيعُوا اللَّهَ وَرَسُولَهُ وَلَا تَنَازَعُوا فَتَفْشَلُوا وَتَذْهَبَ رِيحُكُمْۖ وَاصْبِرُواۚ إِنَّ اللَّهَ مَعَ الصَّابِرِينَ And obey Allah and His Messenger, and do not quarrel with one another lest you should lose courage and your power depart. Be steadfast, surely Allah is with those who remain steadfast. (8:46)
I'm not fan of him, but if I remember correctly what YQ said in his lecture that it's actually someone's "bizarre" theory from his circle, not him iniciated by the way. And it's not ushul aqidah to believe where are yajuj majuj now, are they hiding or not, if I'm not mistaken, so I hope the comment section not ended up becoming a slandering arena.
@ilamos ___ I'm not defending him, but I watched that lecture from start to end, and not expecting it to become such a controversy (I start to think that why everything YQ said it easily become huge problem for some people). And be careful brother, you just doing سُوْۤءُ الظَّـنَّ. Your adab manifesting your iman, said Al Ghazali
It may not be but I think alot of people hide behind "it's not aqeedah" to avoid things from the ghayb. It's a path that only leads to heresy and eventually apostasy. It's a modernist liberal view that's distaste for miracles is obvious.
Again brother These snippets don’t help u or the people that follow you His last lecture hi clarified his position It doesn’t matter what he said three years ago what’s important is what he said The last part he said he is sorry, he said it was a mistake and clarified his position
Agreed. I'm sick of polemics. Farid is an intelligent and knowledgeable person; I would be more interested in videos that are educational than refutational. Polemics serve to harden the heart. We need not take every 'fringe' position someone espouses as an existential threat to Islam. Otherwise, we raise Muslims that cannot tolerate living in the real world.
This is deen we r talking about bro!!! How can u b so lenient with Allah’s religion to an extent that a person can change colors anytime and u r like “oh he said sorry”?
He didn’t apologize. He said he usually apologizes for mistakes but he said he doesn’t need to in this case. He accuses the people of not knowing English or having a disease in their hearts
@@FaridResponds I just thought that he was different than most ex Muslims with the type of arguments he brought up and I haven’t seen much responses to him from Muslims
@@greaterparrot3 Why are you going around spreading filth like that persons name? Please don't go diving in filth then ask people to pull you out from it.
Salam, what I wonder is why does he not just take accountability and say he was wrong? Take the L and be humble geez.. Instead of making excuse X, Y, and Z… subhanallah.
YQ has a very odd framework but I believe he was actually joking in the first clip. He is clearly laughing. Rather give him benefit of the doubt here unlike other stuff
@@tiktokasylum5186 In his latest video, he said that it is not explicit in the quran and sunnah that yajuj and majuj are currently alive behind a wall digging it. He says that if it was the case, we accept the narration as it is, but since the narration has chain issues, there is no reason why a Muslim should accept it and defend it. This is a valid point. And then he light heartedly mentioned the zombie theory which he also clarified in the last video. So he is not mocking Islam as others are claiming here.
@@tiktokasylum5186 so? I’m talking about laughing. Like the other brother said the one Hadith that is considered Sahih also has chain issues when further examining it
I didn't think he was serious. As a muslim we do not use our contemplation into realities. I do agree with you that it is haram to make a joke out it and he should always be mindful of overzealous.
Yasir Qadhi is fighting a losing battle against the orientalist system as a single man. One person can only do so much. He should accept that God alone has complete knowledg of how these things will manifest when they do and we believe in the knowledge that has reached us in the Qur'an and the scholarship.
And if you ask them, they will surely say, "We were only conversing and playing." Say, "Is it Allah and His verses and His Messenger that you were mocking?" Make no excuse; you have disbelieved after your belief. If We pardon one faction of you - We will punish another faction because they were criminals. Qur'an 9:65-66 And leave those who take their religion as amusement and diversion and whom the worldly life has deluded. But remind with the Qur'an, lest a soul be given up to destruction for what it earned; it will have other than Allah no protector and no intercessor. And if it should offer every compensation, it would not be taken from it. Those are the ones who are given to destruction for what they have earned. For them will be a drink of scalding water and a painful punishment because they used to disbelieve. Qur'an 6:70
Akhi Farid, I am speechless,shout out to you!!!! for your bravery and strength to crush down yasir ''s false theory Allhamdulilah for putting the warriors of Islam among us May Allah protect you all
Firstly, a poll within your own followers isn’t scientific at all since we know who is more likely to follow you. Secondly, your point about some people believing that YQ was serious when he wasn’t is valid. However, his recent clarification about it being a joke would’ve solved that problem, no? Did it require this video to be made?
@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 One only needs common sense to know that majority of one’s followers will agree with the channel they subscribe to. Otherwise they wouldn’t be followers. Especially since Farid has a history of refuting YQ. That’s judging to you? In the same sentence you talk about a fellow person of knowledge in our deen and accuse him of lying and working with those who lie. Wallahi it’s mind boggling the mindset of y’all’s firqa.
{Until when [the dam of] Gog and Magog has been opened and they, from every elevation, descend. And [when] the true promise has approached; then suddenly the eyes of those who disbelieved will be staring [in horror, while they say], “O woe to us; we had been unmindful of this; rather, we were wrongdoers.”} [Quran 21: 96-97]
Bismillah Salaamu alaikum ikhwan. This video and the lack of Akhlaq that allows someone to make this kind of content is really disgusting. This type of mentality really captures why we are so lost as an Ummah - these are our fruits. Our status in the world, our lack of unity in our Masaajid, our coldness when we greet each other, our willingness to rip each other off, abuse our spouses, our silence when fellow Muslims are oppressed and I can go on, but no one really cares because we are occupied making videos trying to discredit others with out any benefit of the doubt being applied. It’s a sickness that is ruining us. Allah is our protector!
Lack of akhlaq? If you saw how the salaf dealt with deviants, maybe u would call them “lack of akhlaq” We will boycott mubtadis and b cold to them until they stop playing with the deen of Allah
@@mzmi1422 Bismillah Salaamu alaikum dear brother. What happened to your salaams and your kind speech? Is it of our religion to expose the faults of our brother or to cover? Is of our religion to assume the worst or the best of our brother? Allahu alim. Allah Mubarak.
People need to lighten up and get rid of dirt in their hearts he was trying to break the ice and make a joke during the lecture people need to stop putting other Muslims down I love yq
I would defend this particular issue of YQ as he seems to be critiquing the Hadith chain to justify his opinions. I think you should critique the Hadith instead of his character. This approach would be much more beneficial for the audience who would have a better understanding directly from the source
I used to be a fanboy of Yasir Qadhi. I used to listen to him a lot. Wallahi this Yajuj wa Majuj lecture of bothered me a lot when I first was listening during his series of Signs of Judgement Day. I had to listen to it twice to understand what he was taking about. I still didn't get and couldn't believe what he was saying. Then Alhamdulillah refutations came across from Sajid and others. At first I found myself defending Yasir because I loved listening to him then after listening to refutations against Yasir I had to accept the truth. I had to choose Islam over blind love of a "scholar" who keeps making huge mistakes. Never follow anyone blindly. There are a lot of real and trustworthy scholars around the world. Listen to them but never follow anyone blindly.
The fact that you got confused after his ya'juj ma'juj lecture showed that you already followed something blindly, why did that lecture bother u? because u already followed a commonly accepted narrative, and hearing something different is strange to you, but hey, thats fine, everyone does that, but its what you do with that feeling is whats important innit? but it seems like you didnt do the right thing with that feeling and instead u went on slandering an esteemed scholar on the internet, so keep on telling yourself to never follow anyone blindly, but just know that you yourself need that advice the most, take a look in the mirror m8
Wallahi it’s outrageous
@@beanman5458 can prove that yajuj and majuj exist?
@@daftyute it’s ok for him to make a joke. However this is a scholar saying a zinadeeqa theory is viable and possible and even “makes more sense”. This outrageous for him and even his “clear up video” was a pretty backhanded apology. But yea jokes are one thing. A scholar saying yajuj and majuj being zombies “makes sense” and is possible is another.
@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 I am not Muslim my friend so how can you prove to me that yajuj and majuj exist
If you notice, Yasir Qadhi has a habit of invoking the "unimpeachable witness" -- (my friend said, an imam you all know agreed with me, one of my teachers whose name I can't say, etc ).
Maybe shayateeens
Nouman Ali Khan would do the same lol
This is a very good observation, and it is not acceptable in the realm of scholarship.
Imran Hossein
I feel sorry for the people who are into this 'follow' culture. Once they start following someone they don't bother to do their own research and become zombies themselves. While it is the responsibility of the educated to pass on the right knowledge, we as laymen need to realize that scholars or speakers or students of knowledge even, are not infallible. And in today's times with the ease in access to information, we need to go back to our sources and confirm everything to the best of our ability.
@Brother asked a very good question even if he didn’t, his advice is true.
I would advise people to first watch the whole lecture of YQ on this topic before passing labels on him
For example I'm a layman muslim
I want understanding of Islam that is the closest to the truth
What can i do? Find someone who is knowledgeable, wise and has credentials
I know that YQ has credentials and I personally found his lectures to be nuanced, wise and beneficial
So there are 2 possible ways i, a layman muslim, would dismiss YQ's position on anything
1. Some 'alim with good credentials who i find wiser and more knowledgeable comes along and refutes YQ's position. Then i would prefer this new 'alim's opinion over the opinion of YQ
But I don't see that 'alim. With admiration to every caller to Islam, I don't find Farid and Daniel and Sajeed etc to be nuanced and wiser etc in their content, so I won't prefer their opinion over YQ's
2. YQ says something that goes directly against clear aspect of Islam
You talk about doing "one's own research" and "right knowledge", but what if Quran and Sunnah don't establish clearly that these tribes are alive today (that hadeeth was found problematic by Ibn Kaseer, for example). So is YQ's position "wrong knowledge" because he adopts a minority position while having precedent?
And am i wrong for following him so that you should feel sorry for me, my muslim brother?
@@mark_severin
There is nothing wrong in "following" I fact it is a good thing to follow and now invent things in the religion, however you follow the scholars of ahld sunnah wa aljama'a who take their views from their salaf and now make up stuff from their brains, you said yasir has credentials and is wise, well get what ? Everyone has credentials today and as for wisdom, you can't know truly who's wise or dumb in the deen if you yourself is a layman, and yasir qadi is not ( a mujtahid) or someone who reached the level of ijtihaad mutlaq which makes him worthy of being follow on his views as a reliable scholar, and I can tell you that a mujtahid would not fall into the issues as yasir did, so Don't be building conclusions based on a false premise, so if you wanna follow, then follow those who are not upon innovation rather they teach the religion as it was taught from those before them, and this is exactly what the Messenger pbuh said "the saved group is those who are upon what I am upon and my companions" meaning that islam is clear and you should stick to what knows scholars of deen say not even joe and shmoe, if we follow random dudes just bcz they got a degree every now and then, and follow their weird absurdities that clearly go against Islam, then in just a 50 year period, you'd end up with a new religion totally different from Islam, so may Allah make us from those who follow the path of the Messenger and those after him and not of the innovators .
@@hamzamohiuddin973 You are not in a position to advice your own self even YQ retracted and said he was not being serious and was "joking" (joking on a faith issue), more so I don't need to watch a Gay loving liberal Imam's lecture for anything actually.
I’ve watched many of his lectures and I came across this Gog and Magog video recently. It’s just strange to me how inconsistent he is with the topic of Ya’juuj and Ma’juuj.
When it comes to other mysteries, he says: “Allah knows best about the mechanisms and realities but we accept it.”
Yet when it comes to Ya’juuj and Ma’juuj, he’s like, “How do you explain a tribe living behind a barrier for thousands of years?“ and he’s coming up with all these crazy theories.
We should answer simple the way we believe Isha(AWS) is alive thousands of years. we don't know his whereabout either but we believe it too. especially if something in Quran and authentic Sunnah we believe it.
Sh.Yasir is arguing that the current existence of yajuj and majuj is not explicit anywhere in the Quran and Sunnah and therefore it is not necessary to accept it as it is, the same you would for other miracles - the Resurrection etc.
It is NOT confirmed in the Quran and sunnah that yajuj and majuj are currently alive so why should he have to accept it as he would other confirmed miracles?
Fear Allah, you dont even understand the subject and are critical of a scholar who has studied the deen more than you ever will. Have some humility.
@@angrypat4023
I know what he’s arguing and that’s not even what I’m trying to say. I watched the entire series lol. Some of the commenters don’t understand the difference between a miracle and an opinion but I’m not one of those.
I just don’t get what’s the big deal about Ya’juuj and Ma’juuj. What’s so hard or bizzare to understand about a tribe behind a barrier somewhere for thousands of years?
He game a talk years ago about if Allah wants to keep people separate from us it's easy for him but now Google maps can't see yajooj and majooj
@@Kimeikus The point is that there is no reason to believe it. If there was then there would be no difficulty in believing it. Since the world mostly mapped and understood, it is hard to accept that billions of people are alive somewhere behind a wall, you would have to believe that it be a miracle. By definition, some miracles are those that cannot be explained by natural causes - hard to believe without Allah swt. Thats what he means by it being difficult to accept in that regard.
The idea that someone is thrown into fire for an extended period of time and survives is hard to believe, however none of us doubt for a second that this happened to Ibrahim AS, because Allah makes all conceivable things possible and it is easy for him. But sheikh yasir is only arguing that it is difficult in that regard, not that it is hard to believe that Allah swt can make it happen should he so will.
What amazes me is the fact that he can justify what he said by saying it was a joke !!! How can anyone take you seriously
It would've been so much better had he just owned up to it and admitted his error. Recanted and repented
That applies to everyone out there really
@@ebaybasuki well OBVIOUSLY but "everyone out there" is not the topic
That's my thoughts too ... why beating around the bush
He never owns up to his mistakes he's always deflecting and blaming others I can't stand his arrogance.
if he said am wrong in some of his things like this u will go and fellow him ?
I have never been a fan of Yasir Qadhi or any of the so-called "celebrity Imams or Sheikhs". I converted to Islam in the early 90s, so this was before the internet transformed so many of Ummat into "Mashaayikh". A couple years after my conversion, I was blessed with the opportunity (الحمد لله على نعمه التي لا تحصى) to study under some traditional scholars.
Even after over 20 years, I still remember one of my teachers telling me to beware of "celebrity Imams". It's one thing for someone to become famous because of their knowledge, piety, and adab. If this wasn't the case, we wouldn't still be talking about such giants as Imams Abu Hanifa, Shafi, ibn Hanbal, Malik, their students and the Imams of hadith and so on رحمهم الله جميعا. Traditionally, it was understood that a seeker of Islamic knowledge knew his or her place so to speak, and conducted themselves with a sense of التواضع humility. Unfortunately, nowadays, someone with a B.A., an M.A. or even a PHD or perhaps not even any of the above, readily give Fataawa without hesitation, or their own "personal ijtihaad". These same people would not even have been allowed to speak in the Majaalis of true scholars let alone give their opinions. The sad thing is that so many are being mislead by them. أسأل الله تعالى أن يهدينا ويحفظنا جميعا
The evolution of yasir qadhi is astonishing I remember attending his munaaqasha in madinah and from how he was then until now is crazy how he has changed 😳 Allah guides whom he wills
Lmao so Allah guides whom he wills?
Lmao how is life a test then?!
@@qasmb1546 { ...يُضِلُّ بِهِۦ كَثِيرٗا وَيَهۡدِي بِهِۦ كَثِيرٗاۚ وَمَا يُضِلُّ بِهِۦٓ إِلَّا ٱلۡفَٰسِقِينَ }
_...Through this ˹test˺, He leaves many to stray, and guides many. And He leaves none to stray except the rebellious-_
2:26
@Bearded Guy How can you have free will and no compulsion when Allah is literally guiding who he feels like guiding? and misguiding who he feels like?
Can any puny human stop Allah's choice? No.
So what you mean no compulsion?
This is clear divine compulsion, which eliminates free will.
So again how can life be a test then.
@@Suleiman212 There is no point posting verses which talk about free will, when the problem is the other verses which contradict free will.
@Bearded Guy Lmao you mean the scholar bamboozles with you rhetoric?
The text is so clear, is a scholar going to change whats written in hadith and quran?
Sorry should i submit to my scholars or my creator? because you people seem to submit to whatever the scholar says.
NO MATTER WHAT THE TEXT SAYS.
No matter if the scholar is contradicting the text.
So he projected this view onto his friend and presented it as a joke, but he hoped that people would start contemplating this bizarre view and give it validity. 2:40 I'm surprised the original video isn't called "how to give waswasah 101"
Yes. Clever theme of what he said. It's exactly what it feels like was wasa
@@nadeematif1993 ?? this is exactly what YQ said at 2:40.. it doesn't matter if this view was thought up by his friend or not. That's not the issue here.. The problem is YQ is the one propagating it publicly and misleading people.
@@nadeematif1993 the original commenter didn’t imply that
U just want to argue for argument sake and r looking for shallow responses
Sarcasm doesn’t fit you btw
@@nadeematif1993 I’m talking about the original commenter
You r being sarcastic to him and arguing a point the commenter didn’t make
If you want to refute him, stick to his points and don’t bring annoying sarcastic responses.
Did you even understand what he said?
I didn’t water down anything. It’s clear u r being sarcastic. Or r u serious that he knows what’s in his heart???!
@@mzmi1422 You're right on point, brother.
I was stunned that 3 years later he actually lied that he was ‘joking’! He clearly was not joking , and he also mentioned that I am just saying ‘what my friend said’ and was at least part serious.
TODAYS LESSON: When Farid calls you 'Doktor' you know you're in trouble
Doktoor*
@@khoyrulislam Duktoor^***
ya Doktor*
*Ya Duktooر
@@khoyrulislam 😂😂😂😂
It’s now I understood the comment Subhanallah
“My laughter turned to contemplation” that does not sound like a punchline of a joke.
That is the joke.. 🤣
Yasir Qadhi is a Neo-orientalist and continuing the work of Syed Ahmad Khan, he was supposedly an Islamic scholar, however he worked with the British during the occupation of India, introducing himself as a reformist. He was a big asset in the colonization of India and subduing Muslims there; the British still promotes him as a role model and a great man.
he plays around with words so much, you can actually see it clearly once you put all the clips together. harder to notice if you only watched the videos when they came out
He should be a politician he's clearly in the wrong vocation.
@@lail111 in the way he speaks he does remind me of Boris Johnson
@@baabmansour 😆🤣
8 major benefits of Astaghfar in the Quran.
1. It opens the doors of mercy.
The Quran says, “Ask forgiveness of your Lord. Indeed, He is ever a Perpetual Forgiver.”[Quran 71:10]
2. It will give you wealth and children.
The Quran says, “And give you increase in wealth and children.” [Quran, 71:12]
3. A Believer’s Dua gets accepted.
There’s nothing better for a believer that all the duas that he or she makes in hopes that they will one day get accepted by their lord, actually get fulfilled. Astagfirullah has the power to make a Muslim’s duas get accepted.
4. Astagfar provides sustenance.
The Quran says, “Seek forgiveness of your Lord and repent to Him, [and] He will let you enjoy a good provision for a specified term and give every doer of favour his favour” [Quran, 11:3]
5. A Muslim is not punished while they seek forgiveness.
The Quran says, “And Allah would not punish them while they seek forgiveness ” [Quran, 8:33]
6. Allah will send the rain of mercy.
The Quran says, “He will send [rain from] the sky upon you in [continuing] showers.” [Quran, 71:11]
7. Adding strength in our lives.
The Quran says, “. . . ask forgiveness of your Lord and then repent to Him. He will send [rain from] the sky upon you in showers and increase you in strength [added] to your strength.” [Quran 11:52]
8. Allah will provide you with gardens and rivers.
The Quran says, “. . . and provide for you gardens and provide for you rivers.” [Quran, 71:12]
What's bad is how people blindly follow the guy. Like you criticize anything he says or point out he's wrong and you're somehow some "extremist"
*Yasir Qadhi:*
“How can the disbelievers find it strange that Allah will resurrect them when He was the One who created them in the first place?”
*Also Yasir Qadhi:*
“How do you explain a tribe living behind a barrier for thousands of years???????”
Wallahi, the inconsistency is amazing 😂😂
Whilst reading a surah about a group of guys and there dog going to sleep for 300 years. literally gog and magog are in the same surah..
@@tiktokasylum5186
Exactly
*Edit:* Just a clarification for those who didn’t get my point-Yasir Qadhi’s rejection of this interpretation is based on the logical possibility of the event happening, not because of textual ambiguity.
He literally said: “How will they survive? Where will they get provision? etc.”
That’s the whole reason why he’s looking for alternative explanations in the first place. I just want to understand why this miracle is so troubling for him when he already accepts the other miracles face value.
nothing in our pillars of faith forces us to believe there is yajuuj and maajuj alive somewhere behind a barrier today. If you claim otherwise please show proof or fear Allah and correct your comment.
I'm not defending YQ but it's true to the average person, God resurrecting people obviously makes sense because God has the ability to, but human beings don't live for thousands of years. Not a defence of YQ but a view I understand where people can side with him.
@@Figleaf-Bicarbonate because allah can make them live for 1000 years!!!!
It's Easy
I actually thought he was serious.
He was.
@@lail111 so when he claims that he wasn’t serious, are you therefore calling him a liar?
Say what you want, hisab is between you two
@@Deibinator Yes I'm calling him a liar a manipulative liar who can't keep his stories straight.
@@lail111 you wanna call him a kaffir too while you’re at it?
@@Deibinator we consider him even worse than a liar lol 😆
If you question them, they will certainly say, “We were only talking idly and joking around.” Say, “Was it Allah, His revelations, and His Messenger that you ridiculed?
Make no excuses! You have disbelieved after your belief. If We pardon a group of you, We will punish others for their wickedness."
Surāh taubah (9:65-66).
@Brother asked a very good question your point?
@@Ahadun.Ahad56
Please don’t engage with this person, they’re fishing for attention.
It’s clear that nothing will change their minds with these bad faith arguments.
@UCbfark_y0O8FqmOBwdRDmPA you're right. JazakalLāhu khāiran
@Brother asked a very good question I wouldn't have quoted it if I didn't know! Whoever says the apostate punishment doesn't exist has definitely lied about Islām.
I stopped going to the masjid he's employed at even though it happens to be the closest masjid for me.
In america?
Where is it?
Barakallahu feekum
@@branchprediction9923 EPIC masjid. Look it up.
الله يكتب لك الأجر
I found his indirect support for Ilhan Omar more disturbing - I think his approach to the whole thing has been terrible with vague statements. His comments on Quran preservation were also very confusing and deeply troubling.
That said ... I've recently been going through YQs Seerah series which I am finding very beneficial alhamdulilah.
Direct support what are you on about indirect
@Brother asked a very good question lol islam is rent free in your head hence the name and commenting on our channels
Apuss not doing it for you anymore
Stay away from his seerah series please
May Allah protect you
you find it beneficial for inorder to gain trust he needs to back to the teaching of the salaf (sererah series ) and in doing that he can add his opinions and for those whos aqeeda is not grounded they will fall for it. if you need to benefit there are alot of brother who teach without watering down Islam. Madaratul ummariyyah ,Medina college ,khalid green among many
what comments on quran preservation? he has no doubt the quran is preserved
When one prefer the INTELLECT over REVELATION/WAHY, then Shaitan will have the way to render one to go astray through the instillment of PRIDE followed by ARROGANCE.
The Prophet A.S forbade lying even when joking. This is one of the many reasons why.
I’m not on Twitter so I couldn’t vote, but even I thought he was serious and I didn’t think he was joking
🙂
as a former fanboy i even now think he was not joking
and sadly at first i started to tell people his nonsense but thanks to Allah my brother refuted me and my eyes got more open.
@@Nima-ec4tr May Allah bless your brother and guide him to the straight path and you too🤲🏻
This is why the salaf said if we were to trust our deen with someone, we should trust it with the dead coz the living is not free from fitna
He wasn't joking tbh, never appeared to me
Much love from Somalia 🇸🇴 brother
We are also very clear Mr YQ that you are tailoring Deen Al Islam to please your worldly God! May Allah Subhanawatala saves us from these kinds of Modernists scholars i.e: Omar Sulaiman, Nouman Ali Khan, Imran Hossain
What is wrong with Nouman Ali Khan? Btw I don't think they're scholars .
@@NULLOASIS oh ok thanks for letting me know I had no idea, the last I watched his content was about 12 years ago
05:47 "However, in this particular issue there is nothing to clarify" - he says this statement in the context where he is trying his best to clarify the same issue.
Edit: YQ is contradicting himself.
Bro, first he said he didnt believe in yajuj and majuj, after we called him out, he says ( Now) in the video, he believes in it, thats first a contradiction, why would he make up theories to believe if he doesn't even believe in it??, secondly he also said there are holes in the Quran then says there arent after they called him out,
@@alishomali7626 Check the edit part of my original comment now.
@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 Read my comment again.
By "nothing to clarify" that is presumably referring to the content of the lecture itself. What he was speaking may he seen as a "clarification" of the whole matter but he didn't go into specifics to clarify on the topic of discussion (by expanding in his "point" and whatnot). Hope that makes sense.
Jazakallah khaira for this video.
either YQ really has so much confusion in his brain that he doesn't remember what he said and how he said it or he is really a deceiver and an arrogant liar.
@Brother asked a very good question Maybe the Allah you believe in. Allah of the Muslims is the greatest
@Brother asked a very good question your own god in the bible is a great deceiver, paolo
@Brother asked a very good question goodjob getting brainwashed by the media to become an atheist🐷 and i don't believe you you are a xtian🤡
@Brother asked a very good question As an atheist you should find another hobby besides spending all your time talking about a God you supposedly don't believe in it is clear that religious people live rent free in your life. You derive no joy or fulfilment from your empty life I feel sorry for you.
@Brother asked a very good question You're confusing with Yahweh the deceiver that love to fool his servants by sending lying spirits. Quit the projection!
I think culturally we have a higher tolerance for sarcasm. So, Farid is colossally wasting his time here.
Farid, you didn't mention your own view on Yajuj & Majuj.
Because his view is likely what the prophet ﷺ told us, because the Prophet ﷺ is a truthful person ﷺ
@@mohammeduddin1528 Every Muslim accepts that, even Yasir Qadhi.
He has nothing to say or defend. Even if you tell a 2 year old child this story. He will laugh at you. It's a fairy tale and not revelation, let alone come from God.
As an atheist, I find the stories in the Qur'an to be even more fantastical than tales of zombies. I can't help but to see this as YQ admitting he doesn't fully understand the stories of Yajuj and Majuj. Too often, I see believers expressing excessive confidence about what God truly meant. Admitting you do not know is not a weakness.
It's a non-issue. Try to move on. There is nothing to it.
@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 he did not lie
Pretty sure Qadhi is fans of Resident Evil.
FIRE INTROOWWW
I find this amusing …. Yasir Qadhi is a scholar. Whether big or small. He makes an ijtihad. His principles are Quran and Sunnah with usool of our tradition. Whether ijtihad right or wrong. How can so many keyboard scholars Most of whom has not studied basics make him a deviant. His ijtihad being wrong doesn’t make him deviant
Last time I looked up, he's a Dayee and not a Scholar. He has knowledge but that doesn't give him rights to give fatwa on religious matters. He always says that's his "own" opinion.
Salaam Brother Farid, keep up the great work I'm glad we have people like yourself to defend our Islam. Thank you brother
Farid is reviving, a forgotten non issue. I am sure you have better things to do than focus on Zombies
8:44 Vaya, qué cojones! What happens to them when it comes to Mojob and his garbage!? Go for him, Habibi!
I think there's some Islamic channel that also have a similar problem, but it's with their thumbnails. They write things like " *YAJUJ AND MAJUJ* ... !* " on it with a picture of some monsters/goblins/zombies from some movies. I also saw some thumbnails of videos about the angels using images of horses with wings. We don't know what angels look like, they should not even try to represent them.
I understand that they don't want people to scroll across youtube without looking at their videos but it isn’t permissible to use something haram to give da'wah. Lying, and teaching things that have no foundation in Islam will not help in this life and the other.
On top of that, as you said, people might think this is serious and they will start believing in ridiculous things that are not part of Islam at all.
May Allah guide all of us and forgive us for the mistakes that we make.
Farid really kept me believing Islam . Gonna meet u some day and thank u for ur wisdom and knowledge. Need more like Farid to defend Islam.
Watch the apostate prophet. It made me loose belief. If you still believe in islam afterwards, i’d be suprised.
@@Kitty99900 i watched apostate prophet, david , hatun many more . U didn't need to tell me. U think everything apostate prophet told is true and changable. Thats ur delusion. Sometimes it seems what people say arw true but reality is different
@@Kitty99900Prostate Prophet have been severely debunked in this channel 😂😂
3 signs of a hypocrite: when he speaks he lies, makes an oath breaks it and when he is insulted he behaves in an evil and insulting way. -Prophet Muhammad pbuh
One of the many versions of the hadith
@@ebaybasuki there's no conflict or uncertainty in this.
People should ignore some of his flaws , I mean the guys done really well with his seerah and history of Islam videos.
Do not ignore the enormous flaws of him. Do not listen to him. They are much too big to simply “ignore” . Stick to the reliable shuyookh and remain safe.
@@gogreen_0 how about no, madkhali
@@eliteflite8395 ur wish,, if u want to follow a deviant so go ahead
@@hasnain9654 Imagine thinking YQ is a “deviant”, lol couldn’t be me. Typical madkhali’s going so hard at other muslims while being kind to enemies of Islam.
@@eliteflite8395 Lol 😂😂😂 okay go ahead if u really think that we are jealous of Yasir Qadhi 👌 Allah will show you his true colours by yourself!!
Think he took The Walking Dead fanboyism too far
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
Laymen have really taken this "joke" seriously! A few months ago I'd criticised YQ on my twitter, and one of my mutuals dmed me to defend him! And when I shared a picture in which there were many points listed regarding YQ's misguidance, this mutual of mine actually said "his zombie theory might be true"! Look at how she fell for this!
May Allāh ta'ala protect us from misguidance. May Allāh ta'ala bless those who refute misguiding claims and those who share and spread them!
جزاك الله خيرا اخي فريد
I thought Yasir Qadhi already made it clear in the past that he doesn’t believe their is a tribe of people hidden away from people. Daniel already called him out on this.
Scholars especially should be mindful of what they utter with their tongues because there are people who look up to them
@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 some people see him as a scholar though and thanks for the long comment but there's no way I'm reading all that
@@Sufia_Rafidah_Buster he only shared with you three hadīth, you really thought that was too long? have you ever read the entire Qurān or any hadith book from front to back? Just saying bro you can read those hadith in 60 seconds
@@tuwaylubul_3ilm I'm not reading all that either
@@Sufia_Rafidah_Buster aww seems like you suffer from NPD
Wait, Yajuj and Majuj are not ridiculous? When did that happen? Zombies certainly sound as reasonable as the tall tale of Y & M. Yasir Qadhi was spot on.
I guess, for YQ, making excuses is easier than admitting his fault.
His number of excuses literally linear to the number of mistakes he made
Your reasoning is wrong.
To believe in something in the future is different then to believe in something that is occurring in the present.
For example, if I tell someone I will help them move houses next week, and the person I’m helping has knowledge that I’ve done this before and knows that I’m also currently helping others , then it isn’t impossible for them to believe that I will do it for them as well.
But if someone was to say, I have a Bugatti and big mansion at this location, yet no one can find it, then this belief is blind and merely trusting someone without any evidence. Yasir Qadhi argued that Yajuj have died out, therefore no one can find them. But they will come out from the graves when Allah orders this. His conclusion might be funny to you, but it’s either he believes this or become a ex Muslim and abandon Islam. Because to believe that there exist today a nation bigger then the current population of humanity, behind a wall. And not a single person have found these people is hilarious. And any average person will see that your faith isn’t built upon truth but cope.
Joking about Islam and Islamic teachings is a sin so serious that I cannot possibly express it's seriousness using words. This is something we all should keep in mind and avoid this sin and we should always be careful when it comes to Islamic teachings. Assalamu alaikum
Dear Farid, I respect you and that is the reason I feel I must make this comment: A Muslim should not criticize another Muslim behind his back or in public. If you have issues with him, and it seems you have some valid issues, you should talk to him directly in private, and then perhaps you two can make a joint public statement after agreeing on what that statement should be. This ummah cannot and should not behave in any other way. Try to be as humble as you can be and make an effort to show your humbleness to others because Allah loves for Muslims to have better etiquette, and may He bestow on you better etiquette and on me as well :)
So a muslim can criticize a non muslim behind his back and publicly , coming from a scholar like you i guess that's the islamic way of doing things, would it be ok if non muslims take that stance?
@@dontegardner4735 Non-Muslims don't do it? Don't make me laugh, man. You people have been doing exactly that for centuries.
Jazakamullah khair brother Farid
Hi Farid Al-Bahraini, just wanted to tell u that I have just recently completed your book "Martyrdom of Hussayn RA", it was a wonderful piece of work✨ by you....Your research on authentic tranditions of Martyrdom of Hussayn RA was absolutely brilliant loved it! Can't believe it's written by you, it was awesome 👏
Can I have the link to the book pls
All those authentic traditions or stories were written by Sunnis. When you become a judge, before passing any judgement, you have to investigate from both sides. If you hear from one side then you’re surely following a wrong path.
@@DesignbyBK i have heard Shite side and it has no logic to it... The Shite version involves the slandering of companions of Prophet SAW, which I can never ever endorse... Because Allah is pleased with all companions of Prophet SAW, whether he is Muawiya RA, or else
@@stingehte Let me find bro i will send inshaallah
@@hasnain9654 First thing I want to clear, nobody clearly knows what exactly happened in Karbala… I’m neither in favor of accusing Mawiyah RA neither any other sahabis.
My Question to you is simple If Allah is pleased with all the Companions of Prophet Muhammad SWW. Then who were Munkireen e Zakath? Weren’t the companions who accepted Islam during Prophet Muhammad SWW life and after they rejected to give zakah tou govt?
bro farids really angry this time !
Let's be honest here, Yasir Qadhi mentioned the zombie theory as a far out out interpretation of Yajuj and Majuj. He himself does not believe in it, but seems to think it is a far out possibility. That is why you can even see him and his audience giggling in the original video. Unfortunately, certain Najdi Salafis, who hate Yasir Qadhi, made this into a big issue and made it seem like he was putting this forward as his main theory. You have to remember, that the Najdi Salafis are out to get Yasir Qadhi because he left their sect and criticised their founder.
But I thank brother Farid for making this video in a respectful manner.
Salaam alaikum.
What exactly did he say against the Quran and Sunnah? He mentioned the zombie theory as a far out possibility, not that he himself believes in it.
I actually think Yasir Qadhi is hurting himself when he says it was a joke, because it is quite clear to me that he considers it a possibility, however unlikely and humorous that possibility is.
He literally said “ how can you believe people are under a rock for thousands of years without sunlight” whilst reading a surah about a group of people under a rock for 300 years.. so he went on to come up with better more plausible theories like the zombie theory lol 😂… this man isn’t fit to be called a shakh. He has Eurocentric inferiority complex
@@gajiburrahman7378 his indirectly against surah al Kaff and the boys who sleep under a rock for 300 years because it’s not plausible for them to survive that long without sunlight… he said that about gog and Magog but he indirectly exposed that he also has doubts about surah al khaf..
@@gajiburrahman7378 What about what the Qur'an and Sunnah actually say? That they are a large tribe of creatures hidden behind a barrier and that they are digging each day trying to break free and whenever they get close to breaking free, they pause the work to continue it the next day, only to find that the barrier reverted to its original state by Allah and He will allow them to move when He sees fit. What about their story with Dhu Al Qarnayn which happened in the past. Did Zombies exist in the past? The zombie theory clearly rejects all this (unless if you wish to brainstorm and expand on it to include these points as well). In addition, Yassir Qadhi said that this theory makes more sense than what is in the Qur'an and Sunnah. He may not totally believe in it, but just the idea that he sees it as a possibility says something about him, given how this theory deviates in a large degree from what is in the Qur'an and Sunnah. In my opinion, I think people hide behind this zombie idea and defend it just because it uses scientific terminology (virus, vaccine...)
@Aziz Rahman That's exactly the point brother YQ is trying to make. Go watch YQs latest video on this topic.
In summary, he said that the narrative that yajuj and majuj digging behind a trapped wall has a weak chain. Therefore, it isn't required for Muslims to accept and defend it like we defend other authentically reported miracles or signs. Therefore, it can't be called mocking as claimed by many.
i find your points valid and your approach childish, i pray that someday i find you have grown out of it.
بارك الله في مجهودكم
Farid im not against you ....and not against Yasir Qadhi , but why are you making a mountain out of an ant heap. You are showing shaitaan that we have become divided based on a subject that contains elements against mankind. Shaitaan and Yajooj and Majooj. They will trouble mankind and this argument ON THE ACTUAL SUBJECT ON THEM is making them celebrate. Brothers UNITE !!!
@Idoloclast4
Im not against Yasir Qadhi. Is there something you know that i dont. I have learned a lot from his lectures, and i know he has many supporters who love him. He is sincere. .....but where is he wrong?
I been thought "yessir" was moving funny a long time ago not to mention he's in or was in my community
Yasir Qadhi should not be allowed to speak publicly about these matters anymore lol.
So many scholars not able to penetrate this subject, that's where I say that sheikh Imran Hossain explanation is correct. There are others who also say gog and magog are released but still there analysis of this subject is weak. Only one who has been able to see the bigger picture of this subject is sheikh Imran
YQ has become so bizarre that the US government has him on the list of people they can use to manipulate the Muslim community in America. We have all seen this with all of his non-sense. Now that he is openly known for this, his reputation has been destroyed.
2:18 your friend? Imran hossein? Lol
I don't know this guy but Yasir Qadhi is one of the greatest scholars alive in our world today may Allah blessed him. Just the library chats in his youtube channel is enough for a proof. I think you got disease in your heart if you can't see the sincerity, knowledge and goodness of Yasir Qadhi.
Stop embarrassing yourself and stop defending this deviant. YQ is a shaytan and it is YOU who has the disease in your heart
Wow
“One of the greatest scholars alive” is a great joke that I couldn’t even laugh
Salam Mohamed, you know Yasir Qadhi himself says he’s not a scholar right
Tawbah 65-66
“If you ask them (about this), they declare: ‘We were only talking idly and joking.’ Say: ‘Was it at Allah, and His Ayaat (proofs, evidences, verses, lessons, signs, revelations, etc.) and His Messenger (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) that you were mocking?
Make no excuse; you have disbelieved after you had believed. If We pardon some of you, We will punish others amongst you because they were Mujrimoon (disbelievers, polytheists, sinners, criminals, etc.)”
Yasir Qadhi might not be Muslim anymore, Allah knows best.
Even when he's trying to pass it off as a joke.. he has the silver youtube sign in the back infront of the books of hadith... that says it all putting youtube and fame infront of the deen may Allah guide us and him aameen
Funny how he rejects the concept of yajuj and majuj but accepts the Hollywood idea of zombies and tries to refute what is in hadith and Quran with western fiction
06:32
with respect and love to my fellow muslim, why don`t you make a poll which takes into account what percentage actually watched the whole video of YQ, not clips cut by you and others and put online so that people who already don`t like YQ read in and make the worst assumptions? no one who knows YQ`s methodology and actually watches his videos with all his disclaimers and remarks and caviats will say that he was "making mockery of the deen" like you said.
we all make mistakes, but the way Farid, Daniel H. and others blow things out of propotion and cut and paste when it comes to YQ who is sincere and has studied Islam extensively and is respected by some senior ulama and has put forward so many videos millions of muslims benefit from. tell me, how much of his thousands of videos is wrong? 1-5 percent? is it so important that you ignore everything else he has done and that you spread misunderstanding and hate and fitna among people with this massive bias and your cut and paste?
do you really think this is beneficial? if there`s one thing that makes people i know stay away from their deen it`s how much polemics and accusations and fitna there`s on the level of people of `ilm
Thank you for speaking up. Yasir Qadhi has done immeasurable good. It's not the end of the world if he has unique views on certain issues. He's neither the first nor last to do so. These refutation videos only create animosity and ill will.
Akhi it's cuz you got a clean heart. Diseased hearts don't look at situations like this the way you do.
Subhanallah, I couldn't have said it better. Again I also hope the best for brother farid, but do we seriously think that a twitter poll has any meaningful value when considering this topic? Right away there are flaws in using this data as (1) the people who vote tend to be people who follow you and are aware of your previous content on YQ and (2) there is no way to determine whether the people viewed the *entire* lecture or just the clip (or didn't even bother watching smh).
Let us not waste our time in such fruitless endeavours. And let us use our ability to genuinely think with an open mind which our actions truly benefit the ummah. May Allah guide us all.
Stop embarrassing yourself
@@arabianknight0000 i wish they would listen to this advice😭
Things brings into question at this point everything he has historically taught and said.
Was he not embarassed to out his theory?
Wallahi when I heard this speech I nearly crashed my car lol😂 some people go so far into things and then loose themselves
Wow, so much energy and effort put into making a video to divide muslims even further over a misunderstanding. YQ was making a side point about the possibilities of future events that none but Allah know.; this isn't haram as far as i know, scholars will have opinions and theories but they are human and allowed to interpret things based on their scholarship. We have to give the shayukh and teachers some space to teach without criticising their every word; this is extreme behaviour unfortunately and a lot of us are missing the manners and fiqh around iqthilaaf. How many events described in the Quraan and prophetic Sunnah are described in terms that didnt happen literally or we couldnt fully understand until after the event. YQ even said 'allahuallam' in the video; its clear it was a point that he was making without it being his primary message. If he wanted to undermine the religion or make light of the sunnah dont you think there would be stronger examples; are we just going to forget the mountains of hours of good he has contributed that blows that theory away? Allah help us.
The prophet (s.a.w) Abubakr ,Umar. Uthman ,Ali (r.a) the tabieen did make not that possibility .what gave him that rights . its haram when you bring a teaching in which the prophet(s.a.w) did not bring . If so everyone can interpret according to his/hers unserstanding but we say ALLAH said ..... His prophet said.... we those shuyukh and scholars teach something that is against the teaching of the prophet (s.a.w) we refute. . YQ has an intention to reform Islam when he says there is holes in the QURAN, qomut lut should be given their rights, mocking our scholars the list goes on . By the way people refute the mistakes he is doing . This is not personal but keeping the deen as it was brought by AL MUSTAFA (s.a.w )and passed down by the sahaba and tabieen until now.
@@everygoodisinwhatthesalafb7613 There were scholars who held worser views of Yajuj and Majuj in the past. Ibn Taymiyyah had a strange belief about hellfire for a longtime until he retracted his position on it. At that time would you would have thrown Ibn Taymiyyah under the buss?
Huh, Farid really pulled out the 'how dare you' catchphrase....imran, ibraheem & co would be jumping chanting umpa lumpa kumbaya!!!
Absolute fools, so quick to jump on their brothers for perceived "errors/mistakes". I wish y'all had the same energy when it comes to your brothers and sisters dying by the thousands all around the globe. Or towards your hypocritical regimes that are complicit, even supporting, the deaths of the thousands. Y'all take a stand on the most trivial of stupidities, yet refrain when it's actually needed. May the ummah be cleansed of hypocrisy and those trying to promulgate division.
May the ummah be cleansed of deviants like YQ and the secularists
Assalamualeykum Warahmetullah i was a fan aboht Dr Yasir Qhadi but no more but JazakAllah hayr for what he has done before!!!
Bismillah
Salaamu alaikum ikhwan. Do we want unity as an Ummah? Do we want to be unified upon Islam and what is the arkan? Or do we want to be divided on these types of lesser issues? We have to stop supporting those who don’t want the best for our Ummah and who are willing to divide us for a few views. Is this type of content making us better? Wallahi think about it! I’m done with this time waiting and slander!
أَطِيعُوا اللَّهَ وَرَسُولَهُ وَلَا تَنَازَعُوا فَتَفْشَلُوا وَتَذْهَبَ رِيحُكُمْۖ وَاصْبِرُواۚ إِنَّ اللَّهَ مَعَ الصَّابِرِينَ
And obey Allah and His Messenger, and do not quarrel with one another lest you should lose courage and your power depart. Be steadfast, surely Allah is with those who remain steadfast. (8:46)
Wallahi you've hit the nail in the head, بارك الله فيك
@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 at this point, we should start ignoring his blind followers
@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 are you a scholar? Have you studied the quran?
وَلَئِن سَأَلْتَهُمْ لَيَقُولُنَّ إِنَّمَا كُنَّا نَخُوضُ وَنَلْعَبُ ۚ قُلْ أَبِٱللَّهِ وَءَايَـٰتِهِۦ وَرَسُولِهِۦ كُنتُمْ تَسْتَهْزِءُونَ ٦٥
I'm not fan of him, but if I remember correctly what YQ said in his lecture that it's actually someone's "bizarre" theory from his circle, not him iniciated by the way. And it's not ushul aqidah to believe where are yajuj majuj now, are they hiding or not, if I'm not mistaken, so I hope the comment section not ended up becoming a slandering arena.
@ilamos ___ I'm not defending him, but I watched that lecture from start to end, and not expecting it to become such a controversy (I start to think that why everything YQ said it easily become huge problem for some people). And be careful brother, you just doing سُوْۤءُ الظَّـنَّ. Your adab manifesting your iman, said Al Ghazali
It may not be but I think alot of people hide behind "it's not aqeedah" to avoid things from the ghayb. It's a path that only leads to heresy and eventually apostasy. It's a modernist liberal view that's distaste for miracles is obvious.
This problem is widespread... 'scholars' who talk so fast that their brains can't keep up with their gobs.
Again brother
These snippets don’t help u or the people that follow you
His last lecture hi clarified his position
It doesn’t matter what he said three years ago what’s important is what he said
The last part he said he is sorry, he said it was a mistake and clarified his position
Agreed. I'm sick of polemics. Farid is an intelligent and knowledgeable person; I would be more interested in videos that are educational than refutational. Polemics serve to harden the heart. We need not take every 'fringe' position someone espouses as an existential threat to Islam. Otherwise, we raise Muslims that cannot tolerate living in the real world.
@@Anonymous-sc6sf بارك الله فيك
This is deen we r talking about bro!!!
How can u b so lenient with Allah’s religion to an extent that a person can change colors anytime and u r like “oh he said sorry”?
What do you mean it doesn’t matter what he said three years ago ???
He didn’t apologize. He said he usually apologizes for mistakes but he said he doesn’t need to in this case. He accuses the people of not knowing English or having a disease in their hearts
His friend is Abu Layth.
You should respond to Hassan Radwan
Respond to him regarding what? He doesn't have anything that hasn't been dealt with elsewhere.
@@FaridResponds I just thought that he was different than most ex Muslims with the type of arguments he brought up and I haven’t seen much responses to him from Muslims
@@greaterparrot3 That is because his channel is relatively small and he's barely posted anything in two years.
@@greaterparrot3
Why are you going around spreading filth like that persons name?
Please don't go diving in filth then ask people to pull you out from it.
Salam, what I wonder is why does he not just take accountability and say he was wrong? Take the L and be humble geez.. Instead of making excuse X, Y, and Z… subhanallah.
YQ has a very odd framework but I believe he was actually joking in the first clip. He is clearly laughing. Rather give him benefit of the doubt here unlike other stuff
He literally said it makes more sense than people leaving for a thousand years under a rock? Did you even watch the video
@@tiktokasylum5186 In his latest video, he said that it is not explicit in the quran and sunnah that yajuj and majuj are currently alive behind a wall digging it.
He says that if it was the case, we accept the narration as it is, but since the narration has chain issues, there is no reason why a Muslim should accept it and defend it. This is a valid point.
And then he light heartedly mentioned the zombie theory which he also clarified in the last video. So he is not mocking Islam as others are claiming here.
Joking? He has to decide if he is a “scholar” or a comedian.
@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 if if I was a jahmi you still give benefit of the doubt until you know otherwise
@@tiktokasylum5186 so? I’m talking about laughing. Like the other brother said the one Hadith that is considered Sahih also has chain issues when further examining it
I didn't think he was serious. As a muslim we do not use our contemplation into realities. I do agree with you that it is haram to make a joke out it and he should always be mindful of overzealous.
Yasir Qadhi is fighting a losing battle against the orientalist system as a single man. One person can only do so much. He should accept that God alone has complete knowledg of how these things will manifest when they do and we believe in the knowledge that has reached us in the Qur'an and the scholarship.
And if you ask them, they will surely say, "We were only conversing and playing." Say, "Is it Allah and His verses and His Messenger that you were mocking?"
Make no excuse; you have disbelieved after your belief. If We pardon one faction of you - We will punish another faction because they were criminals.
Qur'an 9:65-66
And leave those who take their religion as amusement and diversion and whom the worldly life has deluded. But remind with the Qur'an, lest a soul be given up to destruction for what it earned; it will have other than Allah no protector and no intercessor. And if it should offer every compensation, it would not be taken from it. Those are the ones who are given to destruction for what they have earned. For them will be a drink of scalding water and a painful punishment because they used to disbelieve.
Qur'an 6:70
Shaykh uthaymeen and his teacher also had the same view as Yasir Qadir
Al-Sa'di never implied anything about zombies.
@@FaridResponds may be not but they both did not believe yajooj majooj are alive right now behind the wall….
@@naz2you Irrelevant to my video brother.
Akhi Farid, I am speechless,shout out to you!!!! for your bravery and strength to crush down yasir ''s false theory
Allhamdulilah for putting the warriors of Islam among us
May Allah protect you all
Firstly, a poll within your own followers isn’t scientific at all since we know who is more likely to follow you. Secondly, your point about some people believing that YQ was serious when he wasn’t is valid. However, his recent clarification about it being a joke would’ve solved that problem, no? Did it require this video to be made?
@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543
One only needs common sense to know that majority of one’s followers will agree with the channel they subscribe to. Otherwise they wouldn’t be followers. Especially since Farid has a history of refuting YQ. That’s judging to you? In the same sentence you talk about a fellow person of knowledge in our deen and accuse him of lying and working with those who lie. Wallahi it’s mind boggling the mindset of y’all’s firqa.
Can you address that he says that yajuuj and majuj are not trapped behind a wall and are already out?
{Until when [the dam of] Gog and Magog has been opened and they, from every elevation, descend. And [when] the true promise has approached; then suddenly the eyes of those who disbelieved will be staring [in horror, while they say], “O woe to us; we had been unmindful of this; rather, we were wrongdoers.”} [Quran 21: 96-97]
Bismillah
Salaamu alaikum ikhwan. This video and the lack of Akhlaq that allows someone to make this kind of content is really disgusting. This type of mentality really captures why we are so lost as an Ummah - these are our fruits. Our status in the world, our lack of unity in our Masaajid, our coldness when we greet each other, our willingness to rip each other off, abuse our spouses, our silence when fellow Muslims are oppressed and I can go on, but no one really cares because we are occupied making videos trying to discredit others with out any benefit of the doubt being applied. It’s a sickness that is ruining us. Allah is our protector!
The 'my favourite teacher is better than your favourite teacher' mentality. Back to the stone age aye
Lack of akhlaq?
If you saw how the salaf dealt with deviants, maybe u would call them “lack of akhlaq”
We will boycott mubtadis and b cold to them until they stop playing with the deen of Allah
@@mzmi1422
Bismillah
Salaamu alaikum dear brother. What happened to your salaams and your kind speech?
Is it of our religion to expose the faults of our brother or to cover? Is of our religion to assume the worst or the best of our brother? Allahu alim. Allah Mubarak.
People need to lighten up and get rid of dirt in their hearts he was trying to break the ice and make a joke during the lecture people need to stop putting other Muslims down I love yq
I would defend this particular issue of YQ as he seems to be critiquing the Hadith chain to justify his opinions.
I think you should critique the Hadith instead of his character.
This approach would be much more beneficial for the audience who would have a better understanding directly from the source
5:10 so this hadith about yajud and majood is weak??? And a high possibility of it being a fake?
Wish YQ watches this
A fair and respectful advice from brother Farid
May Allah guide him through this
Yasir Qadhi is fighting a losing battle
First💪💪💪💪
Akh farid I have never seen angry at end of video like you did "this is deen" walai it is sad
Brother FARID we already have APUS And many APUSES to fight . Why are we fighting our own Muslim Brother......!!!!!
An enemy who pretends to be your friend is far more dangerous than someone who is you open enemy .
Appropriate wording is cleansing impurity from within.
Yasir qadhi should be sincere in his preaching about the deen of Islam. He seem to lack consistency