Reaction To Could China Invade Australia?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 1 июл 2024
- Reaction To Could China Invade Australia?
This is my reaction to Could China Invade Australia
In this video I react to a short documentary that looks at the possibility of China invading Australia and whether it is possible or not looking at the Australian military and Australian geography.
Original Video - • Could China Invade Aus...
One thing he hasn't taken into account is that the Singaporean air force trains for about 6 months a year in central QLD.
My Grandfather was from Glasgow and he joined the SAS and was stationed at the top of Australia as a Lookout and Radio Operator During the War ❤and he lived there with the Aboriginal community in a hut for years. As a Redhead I suppose he stayed in the shade as much as possible 😅
Cheers Carolyne Mitchener/McFaul .
I don’t know why but I found this video hilarious 😂
Good stuff keep it up bro
Being a Tasmanian I am safe, no one knows where we are. Shhh! :P
Xi paid a visit to Tasmania so he knows where you are just the rest of the world does not know.
😂 I do
@@bettymarshall2702 It's all a myth that people need to stop keeping it alive
@@davidareeves What is a myth?
@@bettymarshall2702 Tasmania :P
G'day. 80 000 against 2 000 000.Sounds like a target rich environment.
I nearly ended up with a delivery job today.A client needs a component for a mining machine. My boss was calculating how to deliver that part (about 250kg) and asked if I would be willing to drive the work ute from North West Queensland to Perth. It's over 3300 km eaach way.
As a Queenslander, I can confirm that invading Cairns is not possible because there are few things worse than living with Queenslanders. Of course those few worse things are the New South Welsh, Victorians, Capital Territorians, and Clive Palmer. Tasmanians don't quite make the cut because there are only two or three of them, and as the Tasmanian in this comment section, @tameelah3839 points out, nobody knows where they are. South Australians are too drunk to make the list, and as for Westralians, they already have enough problems, with Gina up their rear ends trying to extract any iron ore that might be hiding up there.
Absolutely right!
As a bloke from Perth, there's no point invading here there's not enough housing as it is.
That's because the Chinese buy all our realestate numbnuts.
With the amount of property they've been allowed to buy id say it's already happened just in a more covert way.
This is where being part of a 56 country commonwealth should come into play.
You no concept of what the 'Commonwealth of Nations' actually is!
Sorry…don’t think that is going to help…😂
@@kallekas8551 - Don't expect much from Commonwealth countries like Canada. Look to non-Commonwealth USA.
@@user-kq5ke5yb6k That is exactly 100%…anyone who thinks the Commonwealth is anything more than the Games every 4 years is delusional … and that’s down the tubes as well.🤣
Yeah, worked well during the second world war.
Around 1990, retired Chief of Air Force Air Marshal David Evans wrote a paper talking about potential threats to Australian sovereignty. In the paper, talking about a potential threat from Indonesia, he suggested any invasion scenario would not involve storming the beaches in Sydney. He suggested a force could establish a beach head in the north west and would just say, you don’t want us here? Come and remove us then. At that point the Australian forces have the task of deploying with 3-4000 km supply lines, troop and equipment movements and so on. If ‘an enemy’ lands at multiple locations across northern Australia it is unlikely our armed forces are large enough, in both personnel and equipment, to cope with that. A reliance on the U.S. is also problematic. ANZUS gives each signatory an ‘out’ to not get involved if it is not in their interests to do so. To win what they want, they don’t need to raise their flag in Canberra.
You're right. I've always said this.
Good show. This is a good analysis indeed. I wish you’d do one about the possibility of a war between India and Australia. Thanks
India's military is focused on Pakistan and China in Kashmir. Their military is large, but, like China, they don't have the sort of assets required for intercontinental invasion.
@@artistjoh Thank you for your insight. I hadn’t thought of it like that. 🇦🇺
I don’t think that would happen. China has too much to lose. They enjoy their economy at the moment. This sounds like a joke😂😂😂
You obviously don't think strategically or geopolitically .
@@concernedaussie1330 no just guessing.
@@bunnican333 look at it this way we are the worlds quarry.
If Chinese businesses men didn’t have to pay for the resources, or could set up shop over here . Imagine the profits. Cutting out all of the taxes & shipping & then using slave labour from Asia. Basically free coal , gas & uranium. Australia is the prize & personally India has the most to gain IMO .
China would suffer hugely in a war with the US & it’s allies , but quite India could swoop in on a open ticket & take the lot.
They have a huge population of their own & slaves in the way of Bangladesh and Sri Lanka .
No Australians are Not worried about China at all! just fear mongering but a funny clip though.
Exactly China's philosophy is war is bad for business just like 99% of the world funny enough
The great US Admiral Nimitz , who thought up the Island Hopping Strategy said that it was not possible to land troops on Taiwan because of the steep ground around its coast line .
Yeah...nah. They could seriously hurt us ofc & we will support Taiwan, so there's that.
Our unique northern OTH radar chain is unknown to most people. It rocks.
This is all just for fun, not a serious analysis. Cheers from Canberra.
OTH still only detecting coast watch planes maybe ,plenty of boats getting through
Not likely it’s too far away very hard to keep up the support for the military
Australia has binding defence agreements under ANZUS and AUKUS involving Australia, USA, UK, and NZ. It carries out military training and exercises with Indonesia and Singapore.
The USA uses Australian ports for its navy which provides strategic access to both the Indian and Pacific Oceans. And let's not talk about Pine Gap.
As the video points out, the sheer logistics involved would be immense, including the loss of essential imports from Australia such as iron ore. Plus Australia's military is geared to just such scenarios.
In WW2 Australia was prepared to used its size and hostile environment by establishing the Brisbane Line.
Good thing old mate didn't mention how the locals operate away from the coast.
I'm from Queensland and I can only guess who ever made the video must be a salty guy from NSW after loosing state of origin
Hi. You should check out the the Australian-developed Slinger. This cutting-edge technology is set to revolutionise drone warfare by combating low-tech, lethal drones.
That’s a false sense of security !
No major undertaking like this would happen alone ( China ) .
China would most likely gather up a Asian coalition .
I don’t think it would be hard to negotiate deals based around r 13:44 esources for developing nations with cheap wages .
Indonesia is only a stones throw away from the torres straits islands & it wouldn’t take much persuasion for Papua New Guinea to allow forces to be based there.
So if Indonesia & potentially PNG maybe even Malaysia allow Chinese forces to operate out of their Territories , now range isn’t that much of a concern!
Australia has or still exploit’s most of it’s neighbours.
I don’t think any Asian country would stand in China’s way IMO.
Australia has imported large numbers of immigrants of questionable loyalty.
Let alone the questionable quality of a large portions of its own people.
Then there’s a very large portion of the country that wouldn’t fight on behalf of this totally corrupt government that has sold Australia out from under its own citizens nose’s.
Where are the weapons, boots , fuel & other hardware coming from ?????
We manufacture basically nothing !
Imo this country is open for the taking & I believe India has the most to gain IMO .
Sorry I didn’t mean to post my comments on the back of your post .
@@concernedaussie1330 All good. I also believe Australia is not the place it used to be. I just saw the slinger on RUclips yesterday and thought it would be great for a reaction video.
Oh wow! Another game changer.
@@AUsTISTIC_RENegade Australia is so far behind in anti air weaponry, it's a crime .
I watched the slinger video last night.
Shotguns truely are about as good as it gets right now for off the shelf fpd drone defense.
I did a deep dive on the subject a month ago.
Shotguns can be effective out to 100ish meters if tuned with the right ammo / choke combination. & the humble over under double barrel works just fine.
Dual , triple or quad machine mounts on light vehicles or on static mounts could also be advantageous.
We aren't even aloud cellars or basements . ( for emergency shelters )
I challenged tenterfield shire council over it & they replied with a list of red tape.
IMO we need a volunteer citizen defense force trained for homeland defense, using cheap locally manufactured analogue equipment.
Good video lol
There would be no element of surprise from any invading force. Just look up what Pine Gap is capable of and for how far and it's easy to see that a surprise invasion of Australia just couldn't happen. It took me all of a second of the video to mention Pine Gap and the rest of the breakdown wasn't necessary. It was rather interesting and a bit of an ego boost. I've grown up always knowing that an invasion of Australia was impossible. Both Darwin and Broome were attacked by the Japanese during WWII, but things are very different now in many ways.🇦🇺💖👩🏼🎨
He forgot to mention that we also have JORN.
Never.
Distance is still a HUGE concern. If China had the ability to move a significant amount of people that significant distance they'd arrive at Darwin which couldn't sustain them
China is our biggest training partner
China doesn't have the resources to send a huge force here.
They could perhaps attack Darwin and occupy it, and then what?
remember that crack about crocs well they won't be a problem as china will eat them all as well as the magpie geese then they can grow 3 crops of rice a year food isn't a problem when you are willing to eat anything .In the north there more protein then most chinese have ever seen
Cyber?
100% accurate regarding queenslanders. 🤣
China has not the navy logistics to invade Australia, Tawain will be a huge challenge.
We have US airbases here and military infrastructure which the US uses. If China attacked Australia, they're also attacking the USA and the UK.
Both nuclear superpowers. What's more, China has how many aircraft carriers? Three!? Australia alone has an airforce and navy capable of sinking Chinese ships. But like I mentioned, we're not alone.
I wouldnt hold my breath waiting for US to show up..
@@nolasyeila6261 The US Navy has already shown up to the Philippines, to make their presence felt.
do know that our treaty with the US doesn't include anything about them defending us??
The poms have 2 carriers which they have not been able to get out of The English Channel with them not breaking down and have to be towed back to port .The Houthis will keep the
US Carriers in the dry docks . The US built their pre 2017 nuke subs out of the wrong steel . So we should not feel to cocky , especially if they give them a coat of paint and
hock them off to the our navy at a discount for say 300 billion cash up front.
@@gordonstorch8561 The primary defence against a carrier, is not another opposing carrier. Carriers are offensive and used to project the will of a nation, which is why I raised the topic of Chinese carriers against Australia.
Our best defence against carriers are strategic subs and unlike the Houthis, those subs won't be sending those carriers back to dry dock, they be sending them to the bottom of the ocean.
Cherry picking small points does not refute the effectiveness of the whole and China does not want a taste of any of the SLBMs that are on our side.
The same way we don't want a taste of theirs.
They already Have and all is well
they take over Indonesia, then - there they are, right in Australian waters. leave out the surprise element, they are going to go with the Might is right scenario, already in Solomon Is, and Samoa I believe. China has deliberately engaged in South Pacific relations lately. it will be no surprise when it unfolds.
If the Chinese touch our cigarettes and booze shops then you will upset the locals, that's tantamount to declaring war. lol
Irrelevant even the usa force's don't have enough landing craft and other resources. The Chinese don't have enough landing craft either or planes etc. Our geographical location is pretty well suited to defence.
but people are thinking like it's just going to be China invading. They have NK and Russia as very friendly communist allies. ppl have to think outside the box when discussing this. it isn't going to be normal wartime activities. expect war, if not from china then when Russia goes to war with Israel.
China could do a lot of things but doesn't mean they would that and Australia is working with USA, New Zealand, England among a few others they wouldn't be stupid enough to try that and someone would take that opportunity to attack china as most there a list of other country's that dislike them.
Please don’t speculate about this. It potentially puts people in danger.
That is why the Chinese flogg is trying to get into The Solomons.
🤣
Clive Palmer, Australia's version of Donald Trump. His scare mongering doesn't really work here. I'm from Queensland and I found this absolutely hilarious.🤣
Yeah Clive and his big mouth would be ideal as a human shield, lol.
Yeah, Clive Palmer isn't a well liked person here in WA and the Chinese aren't too keen on him either. I, for one, was happy when he was refused entry during COVID, I wonder if he is still trying to build the Titanic II? There's one person I'd be happy to never see again.
@@utha2665 He must of paid Tucker Carlson a lot of moolah to come here that distance to listen to his crap . Maybe the recession is knocking Tucker about too .
Australia is technically being invaded by china already hahah
There’s 2 main military problems that have blown up that aren’t covered in this video, which could draw Australia into a long term war with China indirectly in the SE Asian region, rather than China going straight for Australia. Firstly, Trump has signalled heavily he’s not interested in honouring the USA treaty with NATO, plus he has tied his personal interests with China and Russia, while physically snubbing his relationship with Australia in the person of the Australian Prime Minister. A second Trump presidency realistically could have the US military ordered by Trump to stand by if China starts a war of aggression with the South East Asian region or Russia invades Europe, which we would of course participate in.
Secondly, which hasn’t been covered enough in the West, China is headed into a slo mo economic and population catastrophe (all those men without female counterparts) that has an easy fix for a psychopathic leadership willing to have others to die for it: war. WW2 was the economic fix for the Great Depression of the 1930s. After multiple decades of extreme economic growth in China the wildly unbalanced Chinese economy is being taken out by collapsing real estate giants. If China doesn’t come up with a fix soon, it’s not an exaggeration to say a hundred million Chinese people will lose their jobs before the economy turns itself back around from the real estate collapse. The Chinese government doesn’t have the revenue to pay for that many people being out of work.
Killing off a significant population of Chinese men is the easiest fix for the dictatorship, as long as they have patriotic fervor on their side. And there seems to be a widespread ignorance that Chinese leadership have been pushing a narrative that it’s the Chinese turn for Empire building and world domination. Their leadership pushes a Han ethnic supperiority message, the way the old colonial powers used to push a White Superiority/Supremacy message to justify world occupation. I don’t see China going for Australia as a primary target. But if China goes for SE Asia? Things could get *really* messy for Australia if China is physically occupying parts of SEA. Especially as China is on an Aircraft Carrier building kick. Only 2 operating, one being commissioned, and one being built now. But it’s a worrying trend that could absorb a lot of jobless men.
You watch Peter zion ( different spelling , but stands for the same )
I agree with you .
If Australia knows this & does nothing to combat it we deserve everything that's coming our way.
China isn't our enemy !
Our government is, Australia has been made this way since at leased 1973 .
Everyone who blindlessly voted labor , liberal nationals or greens .
Are all equally to blame for the demise of Australia.
Some of us who have been screaming at the top of our lungs are blatantly shot down & labeled with every ist isim .
My name Concerned Aussie is exactly what it seems & the red ensign was the flag our diggers fought under & every fight under the blue flag has been in the interests of the United States.
The ADF is a false representation of defense force.
Australia needs a citizen defense force for the defense of the homeland that uses home built basic analogue equipment.
Australia is easy to defend, however we need leadership & a total change of government.
Excellent analysis! So, I fully agree with you.
Australia planted the most devastating weapon in it's arsenal on US soil years ago and will use it if Trump dares to not uphold the agreements. We used it on the United Kingdom and it worked perfectly. Does the name Rupert Murdoch ring any bells?😂
well thought out . good on you. I think what people aren't factoring in here is the extremely unstable mindset of the Chinese leaders. they are brutal people, incapable of compassion. they are not the average governmental leader. look how they treat their own. they are going to be brutal in war and Australia being invaded is def on the charts. people need to wake up, glad u have. hold on everyone. and what isn't included in this video is the tension between Aus and China politically that has been going on for years.
Australia doesn't need the numbers. The ANZACs were the first to give both the germans and the japanese their first losses of World War 2.
There is nothing here that interested Japan, and nothing that would do the same for China.
then why did thousand of Japanese soldiers die trying fight their way across PNG to try and get here.they would come for northern australia where some of the largest mines in the world are,your ignorance is huge
@@winstonwilliams4859 I did a thesis on this very subject and Australia was the limit of their expansion, they had such difficulty invading China. Invading Australia is on par with the recently proved fallacy that Japan surrendered because of the atomic bombs.
@@kallekas8551 yeah but u are comparing the 1940s to now.
I am Aussie, and I think China could get a bigger benefit if it invades Taiwan because of Taiwan's semiconductor manufacturing industry. However, I do believe China will attack Australia by air and sea before invading Taiwan in order to disable allied defenses. So, it is better NOT to underestimate China.
China has a 99 year lease on the port of Darwin. They also bought a small airstrip in Western Australia a few years ago. China has been posturing against numerous countries in Australasia for years. It's naive to think China won't ever invade Australia and other Asian countries.
It's not naive. It's understanding geopolitics. It's far cheaper for China to buy their raw materials from us than it would be to try and take them from us.
Were they to try, they would threaten the supply of those raw materials to many more of our customers, including UK, USA, and half of Europe.
Plus they would need to go through Indonesia, Malaysia, Japan and South Korea to do it.
And then they would need to secure their supply lines against all of these angry countries.
Good luck, lol.
good on u. are you Australian? I had a vision of Hobart being invaded by foreign, enemy war ships - they were in the River Derwent. i lived there at the time.i have never forgotten this, it was a prophetic warning dream to be aware of the evil days we are in. anything could happen even with so called allies.
As an Aussie I find America more frightening than china
You are WRONG! China is PURE EVIL. Pretty similar to Imperial Japan during WW2
That statement is the epitome of ignorance.
Back at ya!
Chinas army 2 million strong don't forget the 1 mil that are allready here .but being apart of the Commonwealth,aukus,and the five eyes. ,i think australia is safe
More to fear from the US&A.
If trumps re-elected USA will be allies with Putin and Xi , so you shouldn’t be counting on the yanks
"being apart of the Commonwealth"!! You have no idea what it actually is!
It's our country's name other than that fuck all ,but Australia will always assist other Commonwealth nations when they need it especially in time of war , can't always rely on America to save our ass ,but the Britt's will come regardless and the other Commonwealth nations will aid in whatever area they can ,we weren't talking politics I was referring to the above clip ,sma
@@brendoncrofts6714 The Brits will come to our aid like 1942 .They threw and lost the 8th division into Singapore which they recognise as their worst defeat in history .
When the sixth and seven division were on their way home to defend Australia ,they diverted them to go to Burma .They refused to give the troop ships an escort home .
Never depend on the poms or the yanks .
this "analytical" video is dumb. their assumptions are off. if china invades aus they have to come from china - who says? rubbish. they could be in a number of countries closer to Australia then they are if they remain in China. Indonesia, papa new guinea, some Pacific Is they have made deals with recently - Solomon Is and Samoa I think, so this video needs to rethink their analysis.
china could invade Australia any where they liked and unless the Usa came to our aid there would be no stopping them .our military though well trained is too small and don;t have enough equipment ,although we have some very nice US gear it is in token amounts only enough to train with.Indonesia would just say not our problem and ignore the issue.china is currently pressuring PNG to build a military base in torres strait.the other thing is as far equipment where ever they invade they will immediately build factories in australia making supply less of a problem. our navy fatally under manned and under equipped. the main reason they would come is for resources ie mines oil and gas all in the north so they would probably ignore southern australia until they are well established up there
right on.
Stop talking Bollocks 😵💫