Some years ago Lataji herself was literally in tears by the 'memorization' of this song , sung live by Bidushi Kaushiki Chakraborty,, and here some pandits are criticizing this performance,,
I am a great admirer of Kaushiki but I do not dispute the right of "some pandits" to express their opinions. Why are we Indians unable to appreciate beauty without turning it into a competition.
This is the actual way of singing darda ,if I am wrong please correct me but this is the actual flavoir of singing Dadra, chaiti, kajri in one word semi- classical stream as a classical student i know that and Didi is awesome her techniques ❤❤❤❤ just love them
I happened to travel on adjacent business class seat from Kolkata to Mumbai on 7th Dec 23 and attended her concert for the first time on 17th Dec 23 at Sawai Gandharva Bhimsen Joshi Mahotsav Pune from a VVIP seat. Its was all a divine intervention.
Kaushiki beti, you are spendid. Masha Allah, your voice is a gift from Almighty, may Allah shower His blessings on you and your family. Love from Pakistan.
Jo koi bhi is ka mazak ura raha hain wo first knowledge gain karke aye about classical music.... Aise notes laga kar dikhau uske bad bolo jyada baat .....waise bhi empty vessel makes much noise ..... Kaushiki chakraborty is the gem of our indian classical music 🎵🎶
Only a student of music can appreciate such intricate renditions. Sobha ji is a legend. Her version is untouchable. But this is amazing in it's own stead. I have heard her sing this live multiple Times. Every time it sounded diff. She is a genius.
Itna aasani se ye aesi jgh le rhi hai jese koi bhi le skta hai but we know that jo ye kr skti hai wo koi nhi .(inki performance jese mithi sharbat ko pina aur kbhi dil na bhre )❤❤❤❤
💙💙 She is one of my most favourite singer. I was present at that event. What a wonderful memory. Thank you Sumna Haque for your invitation. ☘️🇧🇩🍀🇧🇩☘️🇧🇩🍀🇧🇩☘️🇧🇩🍀🇧🇩☘️🇧🇩🍀
For me, art has never been stoic and it is this dynamic nature of Indian Classical Music that has fascinated me time and again. The constant breaking and creating, making and unmaking, keeps art going, for art is founded on personal interpretations and it is intended first and foremost for the happiness of the artist, then the audience. It takes a scholarly approach and great elan to be able to interpret and execute Classical Music differently each time. It is in this process that the ears of the audience gets trained too (to not be backward as the audience is, after all, our duty). Loved this interpretation/rendition, as much as I know I will love the next interpretation of this song that I'll come across.
Absolutely agreed but unfortunately not all listeners has this perspective or the capacity to understand and perceive in this manner. Kaushiki ji is an artist who is though popular and respected is not understood that well. Her musical sense and aesthetics is way beyond her age and i believe not all can truly fathom that intellectually. I am in awe of her mastery n musical philosophy. Ek umar beet jayegi par 1% v nahi ho payungi inke age. Such a well put comment ❤
I am someone who isn’t a very big fan of a lot improvisations to an original song like for example what navdeep wadali does in Indian idol cos that very often ruins the song. But now I realise that actually if done well it can sound very nice. Kaushiki chakroborty in my opinion did such a great job improvising on this song and making it her own. It’s really very very nice to listen to. In this case I like both renditions of Kaushiki’s and Shobha gurtu’s
She herself is in a gulabi saree, with a large red bindi on her forehead-what an epitome of elegance and delicacy. All the ladies here seem to be direct incarnations of Devi Saraswati.
Suggestion: please make intensity of tanpura sound lower and seem like accompanying the vocalists or musicians. Let sound engineers know this while they are mixing the sound. It hurt my ears when using headphones. If anybody else didn't feel the same with headphones, please let me know.
@varunjiii8398 wrong. I have pretty good headphones and tanpura was too sharp. Interfered with vocals. It may be tough to differentiate Ina live setup but impacted a fine performance.
90% of the time I have seen dumb sound controllers. they know technalities but dont know anything about music to make a balanced mixing. Also same things with videographers, due to zero passion for music they dont know how to change camera angles and zooms for various artists, again this is simple because they make good shoots but dont understand music nuances to capture them on camera
@@HumbleSubmissionBengal 🇮🇳 means West Bengal from where the National song & national anthem came from 👉🏻 Jana Gana Mana & Vande Mataram,, Vo n Tell ur FATHER too okk beta
It is unfair to compare Shoba Gurtu with Kaushiki Chakraborty. They belong to different schools and styles of singing. I am a fan of both, and I enjoy both renditions.
The psuedo kansens acting like tansens in youtube comment sections of some artists who are awayyyyy above their reach when it comes to their artform makes me enraged but also its lowkey funny. Over compensating basically. Coming to the song While the original version has its own beauty and is unmatched .but this particular version by k ji is Marvellous. The alaap established essence of pahadi is beautifully. Those who think its too much. Stop listening to artists who like to experiment, knows their art and have the ability to create their thing inspired by a structure.
This fills the void amd renews my collection after what I got from my father's collection. I am over the moon that it is still alive.. And continues (despite a worrisome gap)
@@neelumsethi9072 Agreed! However, the much I know Lt. Smt. Lata Mangeshkar ji is known as Nightingale of India. Well, music has no barrier I believe, Bengal or India, its the same thing. ☺☺
We are obsessed with the alap, laykari etc of Shoba Gurtu and so a little deviation from the familiar style may create a momentary disappointment. But at the end one has that elusive satisfying feeling.
@rajaedi7048 no true music lover can react in such a bad way to some comment.. Shobha Gurtu has been one of the ultimate Thumari masters and the way she used to flourish thumari by her expressions faithful just to the mood and context in the "thumari" way without trying to impress in various ways has been her trademark. Her solid voice with faithfulness to the thumri has been the soul of her presentations. Comparing this performance with Shobha Jee's version is not at all practical. Kaushiki has been the present of classical singing and has presented this thumari with lots of variations which might impress some audience but a true thumari lover always can argue that Shobha Jee's version sounds better. There should be freedom of expression without harming others feelings ❤
Shobha Gurtus version is often on repeat mode in my home. So I was looking forward to hearing another version of this beautiful composition. While there's no doubt she is an accomplished singer, I did not enjoy her take on this song.I can't say I will listen to Vid. Kaushikis version again.
😍😍😍 explanation eita plan kare pehenichni 😊 very sweet of u maam i am younger generation but still have soft corner for classical and visiting to your door just justify my visit , awesome 👌 👏 love from odisha jay jagannath 🙏🙏🙏
Kaushikmi chakroborty is my spiritual wife of Krishna Kant ojha,as I I always cried for supreme while listening her all sons and I don't know why start crying in her king kingdom of music vibration Krishna Kant ojha,ballia,up
Rangi saari gulaabi chunariya re Mohe maare najariya sanwariya re Mohe maare najariya sanwariya Hm.. Rangi saari gulaabi chunariya re Rangi saari gulaabi chunariya re Mohe maare najariya sanwariya re Mohe maare najariya sanwariya re Rangi saari gulaabi Gulaabi chunariya haan.. Jao ji jao karo na batiyaan Jao ji jao karo naahi batiyaan Jao ji jao karo na batiyaan Ae ji baali, ae ji baali hai mori umariya re Mohe maare najariya sanwariya re Mohe maare najariya sanwariya re Rangi saari gulaabi chunariya re Rangi saari gulaabi chunariya re Mohe maare najariya sanwariya re Mohe maare najariya sanwariya Rangi saari aa.. Pehan saari gulaabi chunariya re Mohe maare najariya sanwariya re Mohe maare najariya sanwariya re..
![[#2024MAMA] ROSÉ (로제), Bruno Mars - APT. | Mnet 241122 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/dgGqD28J6aQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Some years ago Lataji herself was literally in tears by the 'memorization' of this song , sung live by Bidushi Kaushiki Chakraborty,, and here some pandits are criticizing this performance,,
That performance was still close to the original structure, only the tempo was fast. Here is her completely revamped version.
@@prajwaldabbu i disagree. that had way from frills and ornamentation than that one . This way more similar to original .
I am a great admirer of Kaushiki but I do not dispute the right of "some pandits" to express their opinions. Why are we Indians unable to appreciate beauty without turning it into a competition.
Too much expert opinion from people who dont even the knowledge or background@@rohitparikh8132
This is the actual way of singing darda ,if I am wrong please correct me but this is the actual flavoir of singing Dadra, chaiti, kajri in one word semi- classical stream as a classical student i know that and Didi is awesome her techniques ❤❤❤❤ just love them
I happened to travel on adjacent business class seat from Kolkata to Mumbai on 7th Dec 23 and attended her concert for the first time on 17th Dec 23 at Sawai Gandharva Bhimsen Joshi Mahotsav Pune from a VVIP seat. Its was all a divine intervention.
दादरा और ठुमरी मे कौशिकी आप का और गझल मे प्रतिभा का कोई जवाब नाही,हिंदुस्थानी संगीत को एक उरुज पे पोहचाया हे आपने
She is blessed by Goddess Saraswati 🙏🏻
And this is called pure music ❤️
Ĝ55 1:06
Agreed 101%❤
Kaushiki beti, you are spendid. Masha Allah, your voice is a gift from Almighty, may Allah shower His blessings on you and your family. Love from Pakistan.
Sir Where are you from in Pakistan?
Welcome to *Hinduism🕉️🕉️* because sangeet(song) is the part of *samved*
SIR ..YOUR COMMENT TOUCHED MY HEART.LOVE FROM INDIA.
Thankyou sir for admiring indian music ❤
Like father like child ❤God gifted
I'm feeling blessed that I'm living in this generation just because of mam and our traditional classical music ❤lots of love to our dear mam
Ma Saraswati of Bengal ❤
Correction Ma Saraswati of Bharat ❤
Correct ❤❤❤❤@@anjanachatterjee7727
Jo koi bhi is ka mazak ura raha hain wo first knowledge gain karke aye about classical music.... Aise notes laga kar dikhau uske bad bolo jyada baat .....waise bhi empty vessel makes much noise ..... Kaushiki chakraborty is the gem of our indian classical music 🎵🎶
Only a student of music can appreciate such intricate renditions. Sobha ji is a legend. Her version is untouchable. But this is amazing in it's own stead. I have heard her sing this live multiple Times. Every time it sounded diff. She is a genius.
Guys How lucky we Indians r ❤
Right
Itna aasani se ye aesi jgh le rhi hai jese koi bhi le skta hai but we know that jo ye kr skti hai wo koi nhi .(inki performance jese mithi sharbat ko pina aur kbhi dil na bhre )❤❤❤❤
💙💙
She is one of my most favourite singer.
I was present at that event.
What a wonderful memory.
Thank you Sumna Haque for your invitation.
☘️🇧🇩🍀🇧🇩☘️🇧🇩🍀🇧🇩☘️🇧🇩🍀🇧🇩☘️🇧🇩🍀
For me, art has never been stoic and it is this dynamic nature of Indian Classical Music that has fascinated me time and again. The constant breaking and creating, making and unmaking, keeps art going, for art is founded on personal interpretations and it is intended first and foremost for the happiness of the artist, then the audience. It takes a scholarly approach and great elan to be able to interpret and execute Classical Music differently each time. It is in this process that the ears of the audience gets trained too (to not be backward as the audience is, after all, our duty).
Loved this interpretation/rendition, as much as I know I will love the next interpretation of this song that I'll come across.
Well put!
Absolutely agreed but unfortunately not all listeners has this perspective or the capacity to understand and perceive in this manner. Kaushiki ji is an artist who is though popular and respected is not understood that well. Her musical sense and aesthetics is way beyond her age and i believe not all can truly fathom that intellectually. I am in awe of her mastery n musical philosophy. Ek umar beet jayegi par 1% v nahi ho payungi inke age. Such a well put comment ❤
Wah g kia batt hay hindustani music ki. Beautifll composition Hatts off for singer from Pakistan. Love Indian traditions.
Putul Di best version of this song!
I am someone who isn’t a very big fan of a lot improvisations to an original song like for example what navdeep wadali does in Indian idol cos that very often ruins the song. But now I realise that actually if done well it can sound very nice. Kaushiki chakroborty in my opinion did such a great job improvising on this song and making it her own. It’s really very very nice to listen to. In this case I like both renditions of Kaushiki’s and Shobha gurtu’s
bollywood destroying these beautiful songs..
True 🥺💯
She herself is in a gulabi saree, with a large red bindi on her forehead-what an epitome of elegance and delicacy. All the ladies here seem to be direct incarnations of Devi Saraswati.
Suggestion: please make intensity of tanpura sound lower and seem like accompanying the vocalists or musicians. Let sound engineers know this while they are mixing the sound. It hurt my ears when using headphones. If anybody else didn't feel the same with headphones, please let me know.
💯
You're using very low quality headphones ! Change it
@varunjiii8398 wrong. I have pretty good headphones and tanpura was too sharp. Interfered with vocals. It may be tough to differentiate Ina live setup but impacted a fine performance.
90% of the time I have seen dumb sound controllers. they know technalities but dont know anything about music to make a balanced mixing.
Also same things with videographers, due to zero passion for music they dont know how to change camera angles and zooms for various artists, again this is simple because they make good shoots but dont understand music nuances to capture them on camera
💯
I was a lucky person because of being a member of the Bengal Foundation.
Surprised to see the Hindustani Classical Music programme in Bangladesh....I didn't know there's any such culture there
@@HumbleSubmissionBengal 🇮🇳 means West Bengal from where the National song & national anthem came from 👉🏻 Jana Gana Mana & Vande Mataram,, Vo n Tell ur FATHER too okk beta
@@DjLeo10101rude 😅
No offence
লেখার কোনো শব্দ খুজে পেলাম না ❤
❤❤❤❤❤❤
It is unfair to compare Shoba Gurtu with Kaushiki Chakraborty. They belong to different schools and styles of singing. I am a fan of both, and I enjoy both renditions.
Music wins the living creatures/ Nature is a great musician / he is our great god who is every where
lovely renditiion and super harmonium and tabla accompaniment
Ami Koushiki madamer voice e ai ganti anek bar sunechi.Proteck bar uni notun kore ganti poribeshon koren.Katota classical depth na thakle eta hoy❤.
आदरणीय कौशिकीजी, "मन मोहना बडे झुठे" यह गीत को लताजी के बाद सिर्फ और सिर्फ आप ही न्याय दे सकती हो! बस अब आप के बारे में क्या कहना!
She is nightingale of India
What a beautiful singer
My God… God’s own musician ❤❤
Concert,s a big STAR ,Sri sri saraswati srimoti kaushiki chakraborty devi,focuses lights sarowinding the whole world,nomo mohadevi nomo..
.
Ap jaisa koi nahi kaushiki ji 😊😊😊😊🙏
The psuedo kansens acting like tansens in youtube comment sections of some artists who are awayyyyy above their reach when it comes to their artform makes me enraged but also its lowkey funny. Over compensating basically. Coming to the song While the original version has its own beauty and is unmatched .but this particular version by k ji is Marvellous. The alaap established essence of pahadi is beautifully. Those who think its too much. Stop listening to artists who like to experiment, knows their art and have the ability to create their thing inspired by a structure.
This fills the void amd renews my collection after what I got from my father's collection. I am over the moon that it is still alive.. And continues (despite a worrisome gap)
মন ভরে গেল। ধন্যবাদ
Wahhhh...ki sundor!!!😍😍
Zameen ko sarhadon mein bandha ja sakta hai, Sangeet ko nahin. 🙏🏻
I found no reason not to call her "The Nightingale of Bengal"!! 🙏🙏🙏
Why not India? How long will this divisive game will continue in the name of art?
@@neelumsethi9072 Agreed! However, the much I know Lt. Smt. Lata Mangeshkar ji is known as Nightingale of India. Well, music has no barrier I believe, Bengal or India, its the same thing. ☺☺
I am sure she will never be anything more than mediocre Ajoy’s daughter. This is India, nepotism always trumps talent.
@@shekharpatel Like to listen you once. If you may.. 🤥
@@shekharpatelwho's Ajoy...? 🤔🤔🤔
In a word, It's a masterpiece....I am just an enthusiastic classical music listener, not a critic, and to me it's really Amazing.
অসম্ভব অসাধারণ,, অসাধারণ
অপূর্ব গায়কি
The combination of raaga lolit and this dadra is incredible❤
I can listen to her all day!
We are obsessed with the alap, laykari etc of Shoba Gurtu and so a little deviation from the familiar style may create a momentary disappointment. But at the end one has that elusive satisfying feeling.
Downloaded offline so that i can hear it all day even without internet.
Love and respect from Bangladesh
I'm just speech less ❤️❤️❤️kaushiki mam u r the best 👍❤️
She is above comparison. I heard it first as Pahadi thumri from her. It was 22 minutes of pure nectar.
14 min ki video hai
In English: Kaushikiji is beyond comparison. Her voice is pure nectar @@dr.strange5091
Filled my heart with joy, as usual
Woww ❤
Mesmerizing performance. Just heavenly experience.
You are my favourite singer ❤❤❤
True Masterclass 🎵
Melody and style of the raga imbued lively
সত্যি কন্ঠ যেন স্বাখাত মা স্বরসতী
একদম ঠিক লিখেছেন।
Madam really you are Goddess Saraswati of Kali yug. Anant pranams to you. 🙏🙏🙏🙏🌹🌹🌹🌹🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Lovely song ❤
Woow what a rendition... Mind-blowing
Always soothing....lucky to listen
@rajaedi7048 no true music lover can react in such a bad way to some comment..
Shobha Gurtu has been one of the ultimate Thumari masters and the way she used to flourish thumari by her expressions faithful just to the mood and context in the "thumari" way without trying to impress in various ways has been her trademark. Her solid voice with faithfulness to the thumri has been the soul of her presentations.
Comparing this performance with Shobha Jee's version is not at all practical.
Kaushiki has been the present of classical singing and has presented this thumari with lots of variations which might impress some audience but a true thumari lover always can argue that Shobha Jee's version sounds better. There should be freedom of expression without harming others feelings ❤
Shobha Gurtus version is often on repeat mode in my home. So I was looking forward to hearing another version of this beautiful composition. While there's no doubt she is an accomplished singer, I did not enjoy her take on this song.I can't say I will listen to Vid. Kaushikis version again.
No hard feelings. You are the loser.
Beautiful song, singing and her style of presentation of the song in very sweet voice
Soul soothing singing 💚❤️💚
Is this really a voice? This is something which should have contained with some heavenly stuffs.
😍😍😍 explanation eita plan kare pehenichni 😊 very sweet of u maam i am younger generation but still have soft corner for classical and visiting to your door just justify my visit , awesome 👌 👏 love from odisha jay jagannath 🙏🙏🙏
Kaushikmi chakroborty is my spiritual wife of Krishna Kant ojha,as I I always cried for supreme while listening her all sons and I don't know why start crying in her king kingdom of music vibration Krishna Kant ojha,ballia,up
Mind blowing ❤
Excellent ❤❤
Beauty with talent.❤❤
Most favourite song ❤❤❤
Felt like she is singing in heaven ❤
Amazing rendition!😍
अति सुन्दर ❤
Madam you have won / wishing you to win the nature than anything else
Wow ❤
No words ❤
Rangi saari gulaabi chunariya re
Mohe maare najariya sanwariya re
Mohe maare najariya sanwariya
Hm.. Rangi saari gulaabi chunariya re
Rangi saari gulaabi chunariya re
Mohe maare najariya sanwariya re
Mohe maare najariya sanwariya re
Rangi saari gulaabi
Gulaabi chunariya haan..
Jao ji jao karo na batiyaan
Jao ji jao karo naahi batiyaan
Jao ji jao karo na batiyaan
Ae ji baali, ae ji baali hai mori umariya re
Mohe maare najariya sanwariya re
Mohe maare najariya sanwariya re
Rangi saari gulaabi chunariya re
Rangi saari gulaabi chunariya re
Mohe maare najariya sanwariya re
Mohe maare najariya sanwariya
Rangi saari aa..
Pehan saari gulaabi chunariya re
Mohe maare najariya sanwariya re
Mohe maare najariya sanwariya re..
भगवान का शुक्र है .... ये महँगा संगीत का ट्रेंड चल रहा है
Nice nice accurate right singing thanks singings praisings nice one
Nightingale of India ❤❤
Koushik Chakrabarti ji ko koti koti pranam 🙏🙏
Love from Nepal
Who else are from shruti sambeg
Too........... Good
My favorite song .ossam
Beautiful 🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤❤
मा सरस्वती का आशिर्वाद है
Incredible
Who is here after Laapata Ladies ???
Nice performance 👍
❤❤❤❤
I wish I could sing like this...
Stunningly beautiful presentation .
Kaushiki, you are spendid.
What comments to add? Can you comment on Heaven?
वाह❤❤
Is there any plan to organise the event this year? We miss the event.
Agreed with last coment!
Wah ki bhalo
ধন্যবাদ,কৌশিকী।
❤Once again Kaushikiji's Tum ho DebiShwarashyati,Mai hu ek shangeet vikhari
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Unfinished Rose of Spring
Nice Mishra Pahari
Speechless!
Real Ear pleasure..... ❤️❤️❤️