(adding to this because i think it would be fun) and that’s why he feels the most connected with balloon boy. it was just supposed to be one prank call, a silly dare from his friends. they called the pizza place with the strangest name that none of them had ever heard before. shayne dialed the number on his red phone with the long, spiraled cord, and waited as it began to ring. balloon boy answered the phone with a simple and friendly, “Hello?” and shayne answered, “Hi, Freddy Fazbear's Pizza? You’re my favorite pizza place!” but before he could hang up, balloon boy felt so happy and appreciated that he wanted other pizza place workers to experience the same feelings that he just did. so without any hesitation, he attached himself to shayne. from that day on, whenever he went to use that red phone, balloon boy would take over and make the same phone call to other pizza places. shayne was able to take his body back over after a few minutes, but with no explanation for why he’d done the same prank call from that night. he never did learn why, or why it suddenly stopped happening. he thought about it from time to time, but only when he looked at that red phone for a moment too long. the same phone that now belonged to his daughter… (i might’ve gotten a bit too invested with that but i’m a writer and had an idea so i went with it lol)
@@knockoffalexaaa that was something we all voted on in the Smosh Games community tab, and RE7 won for which horror game Amanda would play next! (I voted it since I was actually wanting RE8 bc of Lady D bc I wanted her to cosplay her, but that was before the new sketch lol)
My favourite theory will always be how all the kids died in a specific way that correlates to how the animatronic do things. Foxy died running so he runs to you, chica died screaming so her mouths always open, Freddy died hiding so you barely see him except his eyes and Bonnie died fighting William afton
I’m pretty sure this is semi cannon since William was afraid of Bonnie and that was because Bonnie was the only child that had the guts to fight him back
She's already gonna be confused enough. What they're telling her is basically just a clusterf*ck of some right and a whole lot of wrong, even with confirmed stuff. Like, they just said William dressed as Freddy... uh, nooooo.... William was Springtrap. Which seems to have completely gone over their heads when talking about FNAF 3.
i love each of their roles. Spencer tries to explain everything from the start slowly, Courtney tries to fill in for missed details, and Shayne tries to keep everything on track.
Agree lol. I love smosh and they sent me down the rabbit hole to begin with. Although much of the lore is up for debate, this is giving 3 people tell you the same story from 3 different perspectives from 8 years ago, from memory at the same time.
@@Radioshack65 same! Smosh is what sent me digging through lore and even getting into fnaf at all but the way they are explaining it makes it really clear why the lore is so frustrating - there is simply so much conflicting info that unless you're only hearing it from one person at a time you're just going to get a story that has many holes in it, leaves out major parts of one game or another, doesn't make sense, or is baseline inconsistent... or all of the above. regardless it's extremely low stakes in this environment and it's mostly just fun to see them all try to figure it out together 😂
@@play-fool That’s awesome to hear someone had the same experience! Even Shayne admits its just a game of telephone. Which I thought was a funny way of putting it. I also really wish they played pizza simulator but all will be cleared when they watch the matpat videos and I had fun watching as you did too
41:00-41:50 love how it took Amanda 50 sec to say what Spencer, Courtney, and Shayne took roughly 30 min to explain. that's how you know she's a true crime girlie
3 people explaining something to someone is always very funny because there’s so many moments of, “Nononono, that’s not true.” which just further confuses the person having things explained to them.
The cast the entire video Spencer: this person did this Courtney: up for debate Shayne: this is this theory but only the basics *explains lore perfectly* Amanda: *recites lore perfectly*
They haven't even played FNAF Simulator yet, which is probably the one that has arguably the most content and lore. Petition for Shayne and Amanda play it, please.
You have to go through a lot and do a lot of difficult stuff to get to the juicy lore, and since they’re only doing one vid per game, them playing that one probably would amount to nothing
Quick Chica fun fact for Amanda! The girl possesing Chica was called Susie and she had a dog ( who i think was called cupcake )who tried to save her from Afton, but he killed it before killing Susie and the dogs spirit is in the cupcake :)
@@TheGreenBean18 No. Mangle is either possessed by the soul of one of the murdered DCI kids, or is haunted by the spiritual agony their murders left behind.
Honestly, love Courtney for pointing out MatPat's contribution and Scott's response to his theories bc (for better or for worse) that's truly the reason FNaF became what it is now
Such an interesting situation. I can see where the frustration from Scott would come from with fans just straight up telling him "no we like Mattpats version better than yours" when Mattpat was probably reading way too far into it in the first place.
@@Jack_Sswhich is why I feel like when Courtney brings up Mat’s side of the lore it ends up getting confusing, because there have been several times where Mat backtracks or throws several theories for one specific thing. Least from the video essays I’ve seen they all generally just follow a narrative whereas Mat usually follows the road until he drives through a forest or a lake and gets back on the road.
Many people don't realize that the idea that there's a sort of rivalry between MatPat and Scott is just a joke. Scott's clearly not changing up the lore just to mess with MatPat. The reason why things got so crazy with the lore is pretty clear when ya watch the interview with Scott on Dawko's channel. He only made the 4th game because of the negative reception for the 3rd one due to it not being scary. FNaF5 and 6 retcons what FNaF4 was originally about, which nobody really figured out at the time. Dream Theory was the accepted answer then, and people didn't like it as it felt lazy. Hence, the reason why the lore got crazier.
@@absolutechadd8895And just to be clear, Dream Theory was just flat out wrong even at the time. Scott immediately discounted it with FNAF World. But nobody liked World, so that wasn’t a very effective way to do it. lol Enter Sister Location, which takes great pains to distance itself from the idea. Even changing the nightmare room to an experiment room. Still a baffling choice.
Honestly, as someone who's job is FNAF lore, y'all did a really good job with this! Especially emphasizing how little we ACTUALLY know for sure in this franchise. But overall, really good work y'all!!
You are like the only reason i was able to ACTUALLY understand most of the FNAF lore, thank you for that lol because i would not have understood if i ended up trying to teach/understand it by myself!
As a teen librarian, the fnaf books do not stay on the shelf and there is always a hold list. My teens love this game and I know nothing about it. And this is actually helping me with my job lol
It's a long video series but I'd really recommend watching Game Theories most current time line for the games. They do a slightly better researched version than this 😂
There is a really good introduction video to fnaf by footofafarrot in cooperation with Matpat! Its not the most updated or complex thing, but its enough for a basic understanding!
William Afton didn’t stay alive after he stepped into the springlock suit after the springlock failure. His soul just possessed the suit with his corpse still inside. The diner was in disrepair and the ceiling was leaking, so when he jumped into the suit to get away from the childrens souls the water of the leakage caused the spring locks to fail and crushed him instantly in a painful death. This was a happy “the end” for the kids but as we know, he always comes back. He possesses the animatronic and becomes springtrap, and his corpse rots inside the suit over time
@@happykidkai8624because of the different way we see the kids possessing the suits. Williams entire rotting corpse fills every springlock and bc the springs are.. well… locked.. he doesnt move as well,, while the children are more souls possessing a suit,, its scattered considering he hid bodies in the suits originally,, however its safe to assume that as time went on either the same souls were guided to the newer suits or the old children were forgotten about as newer children were forced to possess these suits which ultimately led to the robots wanting to become sentient
@@happykidkai8624don’t know if it’s true, but I’ve heard theories that the spring trap (and fredbear) suits were slightly different models because they were worn as suits much more often, perhaps that also contributes to why he moves differently
@@waufl there's also the factor that a child's body is just physically smaller than an adult's, and so wouldn't restrict an animatronic's movement as much
She gets so in to it! I hope they play more cinematic and story based games with her because I think she would love it. Not sure if she can focus on story and gaming at the same times though because both in FNAF and D&D she seems to be very focused on moving forward, but it's worth a try
Absolutely hats of to Amanda - This WHOLE journey was such a step outside of her norm and she was down for it. She played the games - she screamed, she laughed, she cried, she theorised. It's the exact reaction you are chasing when you introduce a friend to your fave show/game/movie that they normally wouldn't be into but it's your fave thing in the world! Truly an amazing ride!
10 seconds in I'm all: "OMG. Art department killed it with that conspiracy-style storyboard." 30 seconds in: "... so Courtney put together this board...". Damn. Homie went for it. Respect.
The absolute chaos that ensues when 3 supernerds try to explain their super niche passion to someone who genuinely tries to understand is such a validating experience for me xD
people would also say that chica died screaming, Bonnie died fighting, Freddy died hiding, and foxy died running..which is why each one is doing those things.
Evan was crushed by the Fredbear suit in 1983, the regular cast don't get made for a while after, and honestly, the main cast of the first game are actually the ones with the least details regarding their deaths. The only confirmations are names and that william did it *at some point*
For me it was the opposite, I couldn't even watch people play it before I knew why they wanted to kill me. I stayed away from FNAF content before Wendigoon's lore video, and that was recent 😂😂😂
this series is crazy. amanda learning about fnaf is the most inefficient ways possible. talking over phone guy, coming up with the fungus, and having three people who can't even agree on where to start explaining the lore. that said, would love to see them play pizza simulator (fnaf 6).
Its crazy cool to see Amanda actually getting the kid's trauma with the animatronics RIGHT!!! from the kid seeing the man suiting up in the backroom, then getting shut down by spencer and courtney was WILD WHEN SHE WAS COOKING
i appreciate that whenever someone who isnt in the loop explains the lore from their perceptive, it always sounds more logical than whatever the actual lore is.
The scene where the puppet finally gets out and is looking for Emily, finds her dead in the alley way, and just lies next to her in the rain as the rain slowly kills the animatronic - saddest scene in the series.
@@Andy-roid When you buy the security puppet in the last store catalog you can play a minigame from them, I think if you do it enough times you see Emily outside looking inside, the puppet then leaves the box and you can go outside to go to her.
you mean Charlotte. Emily is her middle/last name (unconfirmed bc in the character encyclopedia she's Charlotte Emily, but Henry doesn't have a listed last name)
@@WishGender Ahh, no clue about the details but I vaguely know the other part. All the stuff about different names and timelines and stuffs confuses me.
the fnaf lore is so insane cause quite literally, it’s different to every person. LMAO there’s no one timeline of what is the lore and that’s why i love it and i’ve loved ever since the first game dropped.
Shayne has such an understanding soul. Whenever it felt like so much info was being thrown at Amanda, Shayne always diled it back to Amanda's theory so it was easier for her to understand in her own terms. Its so nice to see :)
Oof, just a small correction to what they were saying. Afton made Golden Bonnie, that was *his* baby, and that's what he wore to kill the kids, not Golden Freddy.
Or what's funny is she only fully nerds out on shows cause it's a good place to get stuff out lol. But I could totally see her just bringing it up randomly during an after dinner movie.
Honestly, for as absolutely wild as fnaf lore is, you guys did a really good job of explaining the story from scratch in a way that didn't confuse Amanda so much that she didn't understand at all, so great job guys. I also agree with Amanda that the games are scarier when you actually know the lore behind it. I watched lets plays of fnaf as they came out years ago and wasn't scared at all, but now rewatching as Amanda and Shayne play them, knowing all the lore, it's just deeply unsettling and gets to me like it never did before
Only when you're trying to explain the lore of this franchise to a newbie do you appreciate how well FNAF RUclipsrs are able to package the story/theories in a concise and digestible manner.
1:01:23 Nope. This is referring to Matt’s first theory, which I’m pretty sure was proven false. Scott didn’t actually base the games off of that event, it was just a coincidence that he didn’t intend to be the inspiration. The real inspiration was one of Scott’s older games, Chipper and friends, having negative reviews saying that the characters looked like creepy animatronic robots instead of cartoony creatures.
Idk could honestly be both. The animatronic use in a horror genre is definitely due to the criticism of his past game but could draw some parallels and inspiration from that case. There are too many details surrounding the case to call coincidence even if Scott doesn't want to admit it. But ultimately the only one who truly knows is Scott regardless of how long either of us could debate this.
I’d like to point out that Evan is *not* a canon name, it was a name the fandom decided on because they got “Eva” on the Foxy grid in the survival log book, tacked on an N that there’s no way to find, and decided that that was the crying child’s name
@@AlphaSteam2 Never said it was. But Spencer made NO effort here to get ANYTHING, even confirmed stuff, right. It's like he's saying stuff he THINKS he remembers from a video he watched five years ago, but did absolutely NO memory refreshing to prepare for this episode. Because he's the gamer guy and already knows it all... /s. 🙄 Courtney, on the other hand, put in some actual work, made a conspiracy board and kept herself up to speed... maybe just on Matpats theories, yeah, and she brought up some obscure things that could have been left alone. But at least she made a better effort. Despite being constantly talked over by the menfolk.
I wonder how Amanda did the lady dimetrescu character without knowing about 8… but I think if they were gonna do some more horror, it might be really cool if they did 7, it’s the scariest imo. I think it’s a bit too long tho. The classics would be a way better idea🤭🤭
Amanda very quickly became one of my favorite members and this episode where she shows such genuine interest and a huge want to listen to all of the information and take it in makes me love her more. I love having people exist around me that just want to absorb information, even if it's something that someone they love is interested in rather than themselves.
Balloon boy is a partial soul. Part of Shayne’s soul went into Balloon Boy when Shayne drowned, but when he was revived, the possession stopped so it’s a partial soul
Markiplier is a very good podcast guest, but I wouldn't say he'd be relevant to the LORE. He can be a good bouncing board where MatPat and Mark do a back and forth while Amanda and Shayne just speak their mind and ask questions. I feel it'll be fine.
The pure poetic irony of "we're gunna explain the story of Five Nights at Freddys to Amanda" to the video being such a fuster Cluck in about 4 minutes and being so much information that even an experienced FNAFologist like myself is lost and slightly unsure if they are saying the right thing is perfection
so sad that they didn't play pizzaria simulator, the ending to that game is like one of the best moments in all the games, with henry's speech, like he has a very small role in the games, he's kinda like a retcon in a weird way but his speech literally cemented his place in the series because it's just such an iconic moment, i mean reaching that point is pretty tough since there's multiple endings to pizzaria simulator, but it is just so worth it
love the way amanda handled getting all of that information, so amazing! just want to add that in sister location Baby is not the one talking to you, it is Enard(he is the one who goes inside of scooped Michael Afton). Baby talks about learning how to pretend, its because she is. Enard is pretending to be Baby to trick you to get you to the scooping room to take over Michaels body. Baby is scooped when you walk into the scooping room and yet you still hear her voice, that's because it is Enard. He is a combination of all of the scooped animatronics. You can see him in the window right before you are scooped. I think Baby is innocent in a lot of ways because she is just innocent Elizabeth a victim of her father, just wanted to clear that up, love you guys!!!
I remember when I sat my mother down and explained the entire lore last year because she said if I did she would buy me Help Wanted 1 and 2. She loved it so much that she played the games.
Spencer calmly trying to explain the lore in the only way Amanda has been able to comprehend this entire time constantly getting interrupted by Courtney who admittedly knows less about the lore than Spence is so funny
Not doing nuch good though. She's getting the most right, but Spencer and Shayne are mussing it up again. They should've just let Courtney do it alone. Too many cooks salting the soup.
Maybe, then we wouldn't have experienced this mess of showing their different approaches. Shayne going the empirical approach, Spencer going ham with most of the in-universe stuff but fumbles some off the details in the process and Courtney explaining most of the behind-the-scenes shenanigans and picking up on certain details that Spencer brings up, which hints that she knows more than him.
they shouldve watched the video by Dual Process Theory and then had spencer and courtney explain this. i think theyd be able to piece it together more thoroughly even if they disagree with their conclusions, this was the only video I've ever watched that made me able to concisely explain the plot of FNAF since like, when FNAF world came out
I like how within the board there is no mention of pizzeria simulator when that’s the one of the games that gives you the most lore, idk why they skipped it and went to security breach😂😂
This video feels like 3 students, who didn't rehearse their presentation, trying to explain a video game to their teacher. 10/10
Honestly this is the best and most accurate description
It feels like my middle schoolers trying to explain anything to me.
Best comment ⤴️
Explains the writing of these games.
YES! xD At least Amanda was able to keep up thanks to all her crime junkie expertise. Fun episode tho!
Talking about fnaf lore and then being interrupted by “there’s no greater threat to your hot girl summer than swamp ass” was crazy.
she killed me w that but she's so right
@@play-fool oh she’s so real for it I just was NOT expecting it 😭😭
it was SOOO funny i love smosh mouth so much
that had to be set up on purpose. editors must’ve been chuckling it up during playback
SAME
Plot twist: Shayne calling multiple locations saying, “You’re my favorite pizza place” is actually an animatronic possessing his human body.
(adding to this because i think it would be fun) and that’s why he feels the most connected with balloon boy. it was just supposed to be one prank call, a silly dare from his friends. they called the pizza place with the strangest name that none of them had ever heard before. shayne dialed the number on his red phone with the long, spiraled cord, and waited as it began to ring. balloon boy answered the phone with a simple and friendly, “Hello?” and shayne answered, “Hi, Freddy Fazbear's Pizza? You’re my favorite pizza place!” but before he could hang up, balloon boy felt so happy and appreciated that he wanted other pizza place workers to experience the same feelings that he just did. so without any hesitation, he attached himself to shayne. from that day on, whenever he went to use that red phone, balloon boy would take over and make the same phone call to other pizza places. shayne was able to take his body back over after a few minutes, but with no explanation for why he’d done the same prank call from that night. he never did learn why, or why it suddenly stopped happening. he thought about it from time to time, but only when he looked at that red phone for a moment too long. the same phone that now belonged to his daughter… (i might’ve gotten a bit too invested with that but i’m a writer and had an idea so i went with it lol)
This is now canon
Love this
Comparing Scott to William Afton and Mattpatt to Henry Emily might actually be the greatest FNAF revelation ever lol
As soon as she said that I was like: Why does that make so much sense, though 😅😅😅
yeah, i even got goosebumps when she said that cause I've never thought of it
Literally life imitating art. Genuinely crazy
MatPat really is samurai Freddy in FNAF. 😂😂😂
Amanda just randomly cooking up the plot of Resident Evil 7 💀💀
I KNOW, It was so funny hahaha
followed up by Spencer’s reveal that she’ll be playing it
she's so offline that she went full circle and became a game dev
Capcom needs to hire her as a writer NOW (we need to teach her Japanese next)
@@knockoffalexaaa that was something we all voted on in the Smosh Games community tab, and RE7 won for which horror game Amanda would play next! (I voted it since I was actually wanting RE8 bc of Lady D bc I wanted her to cosplay her, but that was before the new sketch lol)
My favourite theory will always be how all the kids died in a specific way that correlates to how the animatronic do things. Foxy died running so he runs to you, chica died screaming so her mouths always open, Freddy died hiding so you barely see him except his eyes and Bonnie died fighting William afton
i love this theory
The other one I’ve heard is that the Withered represent how they were killed (or at least representative of what their bodies looked like).
I’ve never heard this one, love it tho
I'm pretty sure that's almost kinda canon at this point.
I’m pretty sure this is semi cannon since William was afraid of Bonnie and that was because Bonnie was the only child that had the guts to fight him back
Getting Mattpatt on here would’ve been legendary, but the video would’ve been 157 hours long, so this will have to do
nah they need the KING of FNAF instead
I’m ready for the 2 hour lore speedrun when he does get here tho. Amanda’s mind will be blown 😂
Why not both
She's already gonna be confused enough. What they're telling her is basically just a clusterf*ck of some right and a whole lot of wrong, even with confirmed stuff. Like, they just said William dressed as Freddy... uh, nooooo.... William was Springtrap. Which seems to have completely gone over their heads when talking about FNAF 3.
@@HerSandinessI agree that they are going nowhere but they said it in the beginning, they will probably get many of the lore wrong.
I'd like a show called "Info Dump" that is just a Smosh member explaining something that they enjoy to other Smosh members.
I love that idea!!
and we will get frustrated watching it, perfect
There’s literally nothing I love more than just listening to people talk about what they’re passionate about. So I’d be so down for this!!
Smosh Dump
I lovvveee this idea
i love each of their roles. Spencer tries to explain everything from the start slowly, Courtney tries to fill in for missed details, and Shayne tries to keep everything on track.
real balloon boy lore: not many people know this but when shayne drowned as a baby part of his soul possessed balloon boy
That’s why he’s so short
Thats what i was hoping they'd say💀💀💀
bruh 💀💀💀
Part of him went back up, part went down. That is why the balloons, it wants to go up again, but can't.
“Now you’ll float too…” - Balloon Topp
I love the approach of not using a matpat video, but 3 different people all trying to recite the lore from memory
Agree lol. I love smosh and they sent me down the rabbit hole to begin with. Although much of the lore is up for debate, this is giving 3 people tell you the same story from 3 different perspectives from 8 years ago, from memory at the same time.
This is the Smosh Magic only they can do, I would not want it any other way.
@@Radioshack65 same! Smosh is what sent me digging through lore and even getting into fnaf at all but the way they are explaining it makes it really clear why the lore is so frustrating - there is simply so much conflicting info that unless you're only hearing it from one person at a time you're just going to get a story that has many holes in it, leaves out major parts of one game or another, doesn't make sense, or is baseline inconsistent... or all of the above. regardless it's extremely low stakes in this environment and it's mostly just fun to see them all try to figure it out together 😂
@@play-fool That’s awesome to hear someone had the same experience! Even Shayne admits its just a game of telephone. Which I thought was a funny way of putting it. I also really wish they played pizza simulator but all will be cleared when they watch the matpat videos and I had fun watching as you did too
It's what makes this fun content, not just reactions to someone else's video. Very smosh pit. :)
It's frustrating to hear these three try to explain it to Amanda but it's so satisfying to hear Amanda makes a solid conclusion about the story.
To be fair...its hard to explain 😭
Now we need a video that’s just Courtney and Amanda watching and reacting to the FNAF movie
@@RetroIsaac real!!! It literally took me an hour and a half to explain it all to my stepdad 😭
41:00-41:50 love how it took Amanda 50 sec to say what Spencer, Courtney, and Shayne took roughly 30 min to explain. that's how you know she's a true crime girlie
hahaha this was my favorite part
Thanks for this! I was so lost haha
Amanda is truly iconic for this, the first 15 minutes were such a mess that I'm surprised anything stuck lol
I mean if we want to simplify the stories its just revolves around the afton family.
Our crime icon
3 people explaining something to someone is always very funny because there’s so many moments of, “Nononono, that’s not true.” which just further confuses the person having things explained to them.
it drives my brain crazy i love them all sm but omg i can only imagine what amanda is thinking listening to spencer and courtney 💀💀💀
They 100% should’ve had a quick meeting to establish what they’d talk about and in what order they’d talk about that stuff
@@frkn_weebNah this is better, it's so funny.
@@P0rk_Sinigang Exactly I'm here for the entertainment, I don't actually care about FNAF lore.
@@frkn_weebThis is why all the theorists write a SCRIPT. 😂😂😂
The cast the entire video
Spencer: this person did this
Courtney: up for debate
Shayne: this is this theory but only the basics *explains lore perfectly*
Amanda: *recites lore perfectly*
They haven't even played FNAF Simulator yet, which is probably the one that has arguably the most content and lore. Petition for Shayne and Amanda play it, please.
PLEASE. this comment needs to be boosted. The end monologue is such a perfect full circle moment.
I think Shayne would enjoy the 8-bit restaurant building aspect too!
agreed
You have to go through a lot and do a lot of difficult stuff to get to the juicy lore, and since they’re only doing one vid per game, them playing that one probably would amount to nothing
Maybe they saved it for after this podcast, because they talked about having already played fnaf vr so who knows
Shaynes poor fingers the cut of ‘24 😭
LMAOOOOO
Which is way better than the bite of 24(apr 1)
this got me laughing unexpectedly hard 😭
'24* 24' is 24ft 😋
The peel of 24
Quick Chica fun fact for Amanda! The girl possesing Chica was called Susie and she had a dog ( who i think was called cupcake )who tried to save her from Afton, but he killed it before killing Susie and the dogs spirit is in the cupcake :)
None of that is a fact. lol
It’s in the pizzaria simulator dinglehopper
There is nothing fun about this fact
Wait I thought Mangle was the dog??
@@TheGreenBean18 No. Mangle is either possessed by the soul of one of the murdered DCI kids, or is haunted by the spiritual agony their murders left behind.
Honestly, love Courtney for pointing out MatPat's contribution and Scott's response to his theories bc (for better or for worse) that's truly the reason FNaF became what it is now
Facts
Such an interesting situation. I can see where the frustration from Scott would come from with fans just straight up telling him "no we like Mattpats version better than yours" when Mattpat was probably reading way too far into it in the first place.
@@Jack_Sswhich is why I feel like when Courtney brings up Mat’s side of the lore it ends up getting confusing, because there have been several times where Mat backtracks or throws several theories for one specific thing.
Least from the video essays I’ve seen they all generally just follow a narrative whereas Mat usually follows the road until he drives through a forest or a lake and gets back on the road.
Many people don't realize that the idea that there's a sort of rivalry between MatPat and Scott is just a joke. Scott's clearly not changing up the lore just to mess with MatPat. The reason why things got so crazy with the lore is pretty clear when ya watch the interview with Scott on Dawko's channel.
He only made the 4th game because of the negative reception for the 3rd one due to it not being scary. FNaF5 and 6 retcons what FNaF4 was originally about, which nobody really figured out at the time. Dream Theory was the accepted answer then, and people didn't like it as it felt lazy. Hence, the reason why the lore got crazier.
@@absolutechadd8895And just to be clear, Dream Theory was just flat out wrong even at the time. Scott immediately discounted it with FNAF World. But nobody liked World, so that wasn’t a very effective way to do it. lol Enter Sister Location, which takes great pains to distance itself from the idea. Even changing the nightmare room to an experiment room. Still a baffling choice.
"bisexual?" under bonnie is sending me
LMAO YEAH
when i noticed that i laughed so loud 😭😭
literally
I mean… they aren’t wrong
Yeah. You and me, together
Gay bunnies and bears lmao
grateful for Amanda’s summary at 41:00 because as someone who was hearing this lore for the first time i was still insanely confused haha
Same here 😅
Frrr and then after that I could follow a little better lol😂
Matching denim jackets? Mexican Salsa, Yes 💖💅✨
✨🇲🇽 💃 👍 ✨ -Amanda Lehan-Canto
Spencer letting the side down
Spencer being the odd one out.
Bring matpat back on !!!
And fisherman Spencer!
Spencer looks like the guy who owns the summer camp and Courtney, Shayne, and Amanda are the teen came counselors there for the summer.
omg why is this so accurate 💀
Holy shit it’s just like The Quarry but not at all but kinda
came counselor
smosh summer games foreshadowing
without the glasses, Spencer looks like the gamer nerd kid that has a weird vibe in the camp
amanda manages to describe every other game except the one they’re actually talking about when clarifying what game they’re on
That was taking me out 😂😂 loved this ep
Honestly, as someone who's job is FNAF lore, y'all did a really good job with this! Especially emphasizing how little we ACTUALLY know for sure in this franchise. But overall, really good work y'all!!
Hello popular FNAF RUclipsr and Theorist Ryetoast. Owner of neat cats and streamer of games.
Omg Rye :0
You are like the only reason i was able to ACTUALLY understand most of the FNAF lore, thank you for that lol because i would not have understood if i ended up trying to teach/understand it by myself!
They did ok they didn’t do that great
@@Neo_Blade001do you unironically believe that the crying child’s name is evan
As a teen librarian, the fnaf books do not stay on the shelf and there is always a hold list. My teens love this game and I know nothing about it. And this is actually helping me with my job lol
Just say "But that's just a theory" and wait for their faces
that is actually so cute
duuude you need do what FanTalks1 said to do to ur kids lol. like imagine you bring up fnaf and say "but thats just a theory" omg 😭😭
It's a long video series but I'd really recommend watching Game Theories most current time line for the games. They do a slightly better researched version than this 😂
There is a really good introduction video to fnaf by footofafarrot in cooperation with Matpat! Its not the most updated or complex thing, but its enough for a basic understanding!
William Afton didn’t stay alive after he stepped into the springlock suit after the springlock failure. His soul just possessed the suit with his corpse still inside.
The diner was in disrepair and the ceiling was leaking, so when he jumped into the suit to get away from the childrens souls the water of the leakage caused the spring locks to fail and crushed him instantly in a painful death. This was a happy “the end” for the kids but as we know, he always comes back. He possesses the animatronic and becomes springtrap, and his corpse rots inside the suit over time
question, so how come he moves the way he does? like, he doesn't move the same way the animatronics do
@@happykidkai8624because of the different way we see the kids possessing the suits. Williams entire rotting corpse fills every springlock and bc the springs are.. well… locked.. he doesnt move as well,, while the children are more souls possessing a suit,, its scattered considering he hid bodies in the suits originally,, however its safe to assume that as time went on either the same souls were guided to the newer suits or the old children were forgotten about as newer children were forced to possess these suits which ultimately led to the robots wanting to become sentient
@@happykidkai8624don’t know if it’s true, but I’ve heard theories that the spring trap (and fredbear) suits were slightly different models because they were worn as suits much more often, perhaps that also contributes to why he moves differently
he has a heartbeat in ffps
@@waufl there's also the factor that a child's body is just physically smaller than an adult's, and so wouldn't restrict an animatronic's movement as much
"local couple brings their nerd friend to help spread the FNAF brainrot to a innocent millennial"
NERD FRIEND WITH A VEST*
Funniest part is that they're all millennials
💀 this is so funny
The slow zoom in on Shayne’s hand 😂
I was just about to comment on that lol that is brutal
“There are no accidents”
- Master Oogway
So now he can’t flip Amanda off 😃
@@Idk_My_Name i went ‘BRUTAL’ in Shayne’s voice
@@turdinatheprincess i mean he still can it just when he flips amanda in front of a green screen it just be half of his middle finger lol
@@charlizepierce i want the "brutal" merchs so bad lol
Courtney and Spencer come from the polar opposite schools of thought in the FNAF fanbase and it’s hilarious trying to watch them find common ground
28:01 “Chica is HUGE in VR”
FNAF VR VID DROPPING SOON?
*YESSS*
I WAS SEARCHING FOR THIS COMMENTT
WE CHEERED
I was looking for something like this… I didn’t process that comment but when Shayne said something about VR again. I was like did I miss something???
They had it as a goal for ticket sales and met it. Nice to hear they have it filmed!!
Right?! I searched and found my people!! Awaiting VR FOOTAGE!!!
it’s gotta be tomorrow 😭 i NEED
Amanda’s fungus theory is genuinely more coherent than the actual lore
Which is wild because it's essentially re7 and that series' lore is pretty wild as well
They tried to compete with Kingdom Hearts for the most confusing lore possible
I just don’t get where the fungus came from
@@Mattriarc still not even close lol
@@Mattriarc if you include all the handheld and mobile games, which are canon, kingdom hearts takes the cake. I'd say fnaf is close to tekken though.
1:00:57 The irony that I’m literally listening to this while restoring my Chuck E Cheese animatronics
I'm sorry, _what?_
@@cobwebinthecorner uh yeah, whuut
shayne is such a balloon boy. he's so real for that
Shayne as Ballon Boy in the next Try Not To Laugh?
Hey~
Hi!
@@RedSpade37 Balloon boy just standing there holding a piss balloon
explaining lore to amanda should be its own podcast
She gets so in to it! I hope they play more cinematic and story based games with her because I think she would love it. Not sure if she can focus on story and gaming at the same times though because both in FNAF and D&D she seems to be very focused on moving forward, but it's worth a try
She's super wholesome and and a good active listener, (maybe not a good listener but yea).
She's awesome and always uplifting.
Angela and Amanda are the best people to explain something to because they just have the best reactions possible 😂❤
Lorecast
Absolutely hats of to Amanda - This WHOLE journey was such a step outside of her norm and she was down for it. She played the games - she screamed, she laughed, she cried, she theorised. It's the exact reaction you are chasing when you introduce a friend to your fave show/game/movie that they normally wouldn't be into but it's your fave thing in the world! Truly an amazing ride!
The constant interjections of the three lore keepers telling the story is giving horror movie teens arguing about their small town urban legends 🤣🤣
10 seconds in I'm all: "OMG. Art department killed it with that conspiracy-style storyboard." 30 seconds in: "... so Courtney put together this board...". Damn. Homie went for it. Respect.
Shayne suggesting they play Res Evil 7 when in reality he just wants to get to Village and see Lady Demitrescu again
He never got over the want to get pegged by a 7ft tall lady vampire
I do not blame him
The absolute chaos that ensues when 3 supernerds try to explain their super niche passion to someone who genuinely tries to understand is such a validating experience for me xD
people would also say that chica died screaming, Bonnie died fighting, Freddy died hiding, and foxy died running..which is why each one is doing those things.
Freddy hiding? Isn't Freddy the son that got his head bit? Damn, I must have gotten things confused.
@@raymax_1071 It sounds like the son went into the Fredbear suit, which is different than the main Freddy suit?
@@raymax_1071 evan got his head crushed by golden freddy, normal freddy is possessed by another kid called gabriel>>
@@raymax_1071the son did used to hide in his room from his fear, so
Evan was crushed by the Fredbear suit in 1983, the regular cast don't get made for a while after, and honestly, the main cast of the first game are actually the ones with the least details regarding their deaths. The only confirmations are names and that william did it *at some point*
me and my cousins at thanksgiving explaining pop culture to our moms/grandmas
i COMPLETELY agree with amanda on how it gets scarier when you know the lore, it made it feel too real, made it so scary to me 😭😭
For me it was the opposite, I couldn't even watch people play it before I knew why they wanted to kill me. I stayed away from FNAF content before Wendigoon's lore video, and that was recent 😂😂😂
People who all know the lore, all arguing about the lore, shows how insane this lore has gotten
this series is crazy. amanda learning about fnaf is the most inefficient ways possible. talking over phone guy, coming up with the fungus, and having three people who can't even agree on where to start explaining the lore. that said, would love to see them play pizza simulator (fnaf 6).
Its crazy cool to see Amanda actually getting the kid's trauma with the animatronics RIGHT!!! from the kid seeing the man suiting up in the backroom, then getting shut down by spencer and courtney was WILD WHEN SHE WAS COOKING
Time?
@@alexamurphy6610 in retrospect It was actually just spencer XD the time is 25:55
Nobody shut her down, wdym
@@jkuli5314it was spencer...he absolutely did lmao
Amanda's reaction @33:50 killed me. The deer in the headlights, glance at camera, "I have no idea what he's talking about."
shes so cute haha
i appreciate that whenever someone who isnt in the loop explains the lore from their perceptive, it always sounds more logical than whatever the actual lore is.
The scene where the puppet finally gets out and is looking for Emily, finds her dead in the alley way, and just lies next to her in the rain as the rain slowly kills the animatronic - saddest scene in the series.
Which one is this from?
@@Andy-roid fnaf 6
@@Andy-roid When you buy the security puppet in the last store catalog you can play a minigame from them, I think if you do it enough times you see Emily outside looking inside, the puppet then leaves the box and you can go outside to go to her.
you mean Charlotte. Emily is her middle/last name (unconfirmed bc in the character encyclopedia she's Charlotte Emily, but Henry doesn't have a listed last name)
@@WishGender Ahh, no clue about the details but I vaguely know the other part. All the stuff about different names and timelines and stuffs confuses me.
shayne: It’s SHREK
everyone else: *total silence*
Consequence of millennialism
"oof I wish I didn't say that"
Thank fuck Amanda said "...Anyways-"
It was hilarious 😂 justice for Shayne! 🎉
it's literally the first thing i thought of when i saw his finger lol
while we're dealing with weird horror lore, can we get Angela to explain the lore of Starkid's Hatchetfield universe?
Would love to see Nick or Matt Lang as a guest star if that happened; they're probably the best candidates since they wrote them, after all! 😄
I second that, that would be really fun to watch
YES
Man, you can really see that Shayne, Spencer and Courtney didn't REALLY plan this out too much. And that makes it awesome
Seems like Courtney did the most planning but they did no coordination with each other lol
the fnaf lore is so insane cause quite literally, it’s different to every person. LMAO there’s no one timeline of what is the lore and that’s why i love it and i’ve loved ever since the first game dropped.
Dude the moment Spencer said the word Evan, I knew the comments section would be a war zone
I'm sure someone has said this before, but I NEED a FNAF reunion video where each of them are the animatronics! It would EAT!!!!
This ‼️😭
this would be SO FUNNY😭😭😭😭
CHICA BIB LET'S EAT!!!!! LET'S FUCKING EAT!!!
Bumping this
Shayne has such an understanding soul. Whenever it felt like so much info was being thrown at Amanda, Shayne always diled it back to Amanda's theory so it was easier for her to understand in her own terms. Its so nice to see :)
Oof, just a small correction to what they were saying. Afton made Golden Bonnie, that was *his* baby, and that's what he wore to kill the kids, not Golden Freddy.
that was bothering me the whole video 😭 but I understand where they were coming from
I love how Shayne is completely over fnaf by this point. Meanwhile court is at full brain rot.
Probably adds to why he's so over it. Because it's been 24/7 thing for him. FNAF everywhere he goes!
I’m wondering how much Courtney talks about it at home lol
@@rhettmitchell Did you see the tntl theatre livestream they did on pit a while ago? My guess is, A LOT
Or what's funny is she only fully nerds out on shows cause it's a good place to get stuff out lol.
But I could totally see her just bringing it up randomly during an after dinner movie.
You'd think Court would be more up to date on the canon lore with how obsessed she supposedly is
I'm so impressed with amanda's ability to remember all this stuff so fast lol, LOVE this ep, i think she is primed for actual matpat now lol
Honestly, for as absolutely wild as fnaf lore is, you guys did a really good job of explaining the story from scratch in a way that didn't confuse Amanda so much that she didn't understand at all, so great job guys. I also agree with Amanda that the games are scarier when you actually know the lore behind it. I watched lets plays of fnaf as they came out years ago and wasn't scared at all, but now rewatching as Amanda and Shayne play them, knowing all the lore, it's just deeply unsettling and gets to me like it never did before
Spencer not wearing his jean jacket is an epic move
Smosh is in its Jean Era
Literally just thought the same thing😭😭
jeara
Only when you're trying to explain the lore of this franchise to a newbie do you appreciate how well FNAF RUclipsrs are able to package the story/theories in a concise and digestible manner.
Damn skipping fnaf 6 pizza simulator that is one of the most lore heavy games is a crime
Amanda coming out the gate strong with the plotline of RE7 is craaazyy. Now I really wanna see her play it😭
How does one cut enough of their finger off with a vegetable peeler to require it to be sewn back on?! That's a special skill all on its own.
Impressive 😎
i cut off my index fingerpad by accidentally picking up glass instead of a rock. it was glued back on. it happens!
He is fully committed to peeling those veg
He works out too much, he's too powerful
he explained how it happened on the members only livestream but i don't remember the details fully
1:01:23 Nope. This is referring to Matt’s first theory, which I’m pretty sure was proven false. Scott didn’t actually base the games off of that event, it was just a coincidence that he didn’t intend to be the inspiration. The real inspiration was one of Scott’s older games, Chipper and friends, having negative reviews saying that the characters looked like creepy animatronic robots instead of cartoony creatures.
Idk could honestly be both. The animatronic use in a horror genre is definitely due to the criticism of his past game but could draw some parallels and inspiration from that case. There are too many details surrounding the case to call coincidence even if Scott doesn't want to admit it. But ultimately the only one who truly knows is Scott regardless of how long either of us could debate this.
Amanda saying she’s attracted to spencer has got to be the best joke ever or the most 1000 iq play of hiding in plain sight Ive ever seen lol
He’s so fine
when did dhe say it?
@@travioliraviolicanoliThe last 10 seconds of the video 😅
Clip Shayne saying "No its Shrek" for everything now.
and the complete silence after that lmao
@@geckopecko And add in Angela’s “oof, I wish I didn’t do that” after
@@rhettmitchell yessss😂
I’d like to point out that Evan is *not* a canon name, it was a name the fandom decided on because they got “Eva” on the Foxy grid in the survival log book, tacked on an N that there’s no way to find, and decided that that was the crying child’s name
seriously!!! the Cassidy solution makes so much more sense
@WishGender yeah dual process theory convertited me to a die hard ccasidy afton believer and hearing then call Evan "canon" me want to scream
The closest name we have is Garrett from the movie. That’s more reliable than a random puzzle that’s never been solved
I know absolutely nothing about FNAF but hearing courtney say "are you sure about that?" is healing me
Rest assured: every time she said it, Spencer ABSOLUTELY got something very wrong.
Spencer was the Analytical explanations and Courtney would jump in with the passionate explanations
@@HerSandiness actually not rlly 😭 there were some parts that spencer got right that courtney negated & vice versa
@@HerSandiness Reminder that not everything MatPat says is right
@@AlphaSteam2 Never said it was. But Spencer made NO effort here to get ANYTHING, even confirmed stuff, right. It's like he's saying stuff he THINKS he remembers from a video he watched five years ago, but did absolutely NO memory refreshing to prepare for this episode. Because he's the gamer guy and already knows it all... /s. 🙄
Courtney, on the other hand, put in some actual work, made a conspiracy board and kept herself up to speed... maybe just on Matpats theories, yeah, and she brought up some obscure things that could have been left alone. But at least she made a better effort. Despite being constantly talked over by the menfolk.
The recent SmoshMouth videos have been absolute bangers
I really love that of the 3 that claim to know the lore, not one of them knows it 100% but they all speak with such confidence. bless
I really want to see Shayne and Amanda play more horror games outside of FNAF. Stuff like Amnesia, Resident Evil 7/8, Slender Man, the classics!
I would love to see Amanda play Slender Man loool
I wonder how Amanda did the lady dimetrescu character without knowing about 8… but I think if they were gonna do some more horror, it might be really cool if they did 7, it’s the scariest imo. I think it’s a bit too long tho. The classics would be a way better idea🤭🤭
@@ghostea6479 Very fair, slender man might be a great bet since it's nice and short.
Lmao slenderman
“William Afton wears the Freddy suit” NO NO NO OTHER WAY AROUND 😂
... I said, screaming at the screen!!! 🤣
BONNIE WAS HIS OG
Amanda very quickly became one of my favorite members and this episode where she shows such genuine interest and a huge want to listen to all of the information and take it in makes me love her more. I love having people exist around me that just want to absorb information, even if it's something that someone they love is interested in rather than themselves.
It's so funny that this is a very serious conversation about FNAF lore. The FNAF war room
Balloon boy is a partial soul. Part of Shayne’s soul went into Balloon Boy when Shayne drowned, but when he was revived, the possession stopped so it’s a partial soul
The crying child’s name is not “Evan”, that name was gotten from a convoluted way of solving the Foxy Grid Puzzle in the Logbook
Markiplier and MattPatt NEED to be on a FULL CONVO
Markiplier has admitted he has no clue about the story… he wouldn’t be helpful. He just plays the games and dumps them from his brain
Mark doesn’t follow the lore, he’s just been good at guessing while playing in the past. MatPat, FuhNaff, and other theorists would be better
Yeah, no
*Mattpatt and Wendigoon
Markiplier is a very good podcast guest, but I wouldn't say he'd be relevant to the LORE. He can be a good bouncing board where MatPat and Mark do a back and forth while Amanda and Shayne just speak their mind and ask questions. I feel it'll be fine.
The pure poetic irony of "we're gunna explain the story of Five Nights at Freddys to Amanda" to the video being such a fuster Cluck in about 4 minutes and being so much information that even an experienced FNAFologist like myself is lost and slightly unsure if they are saying the right thing is perfection
so sad that they didn't play pizzaria simulator, the ending to that game is like one of the best moments in all the games, with henry's speech, like he has a very small role in the games, he's kinda like a retcon in a weird way but his speech literally cemented his place in the series because it's just such an iconic moment, i mean reaching that point is pretty tough since there's multiple endings to pizzaria simulator, but it is just so worth it
When Amanda so ‘that’s just a theory’ I shed a single tear, she’s come so far
I’m so into the diorama in the background.. omg Courtney made it?! I totally thought it was the art department. I’m so impressed!
love the way amanda handled getting all of that information, so amazing! just want to add that in sister location Baby is not the one talking to you, it is Enard(he is the one who goes inside of scooped Michael Afton). Baby talks about learning how to pretend, its because she is. Enard is pretending to be Baby to trick you to get you to the scooping room to take over Michaels body. Baby is scooped when you walk into the scooping room and yet you still hear her voice, that's because it is Enard. He is a combination of all of the scooped animatronics. You can see him in the window right before you are scooped. I think Baby is innocent in a lot of ways because she is just innocent Elizabeth a victim of her father, just wanted to clear that up, love you guys!!!
I remember when I sat my mother down and explained the entire lore last year because she said if I did she would buy me Help Wanted 1 and 2. She loved it so much that she played the games.
You’ve got a precious mom. How sweet!
@@alexshaw8167
It was really fun and she is in fact very sweet.
Aww, that's amazing! Perfect bonding moment as well!
The one day Spencer doesn’t wear his jean jacket is when everyone else does 😂
He has to be different 💅
they tried to cosplay as him and he threw them a curveball. he's so powerful
Spencer calmly trying to explain the lore in the only way Amanda has been able to comprehend this entire time constantly getting interrupted by Courtney who admittedly knows less about the lore than Spence is so funny
YESS, we have Courtney for the FNAF episode!!
it seems correct
Not doing nuch good though. She's getting the most right, but Spencer and Shayne are mussing it up again. They should've just let Courtney do it alone. Too many cooks salting the soup.
@@HerSandiness Spencer at least is telling the lore (even if messing it up) in a very straight forward fashion.
If only Spencer would stop mansplaining over top of her just cause he’s the “gamer” of the bunch
@@SecondAftermath Courtney's sentences are WAY more understandable here. 🤣
Shayne, Courtney and Spencer really should’ve had a pre-meeting where they worked out how they would explain this all to Amanda 😂
Yeah... but I enjoyed the chaos.
The point was to yap about FNAF, not to do a full comprehensive summary on FNAF lore
Maybe, then we wouldn't have experienced this mess of showing their different approaches. Shayne going the empirical approach, Spencer going ham with most of the in-universe stuff but fumbles some off the details in the process and Courtney explaining most of the behind-the-scenes shenanigans and picking up on certain details that Spencer brings up, which hints that she knows more than him.
No this was better
nah it was fun to watch the raw chaos unfold 😂 the best way may I argue
amanda truly is a true crime girly. when she perfectly recounted all of the lore she was just told back to them i was the proudest ive ever been
I cannot believe the way Pizzeria Simulator is being ignored 😭
I KNOW!! like henry's monologue is easily the best part of the fnaf lore!!
I know
“We played all the games”
No ;-; y’all missed the ending of the original series
the most satisfying ending 2 that whole arc :[
Maybe they want Amanda to know the lore around it before they play so that the monologue would actually have a big impact
@@spooks9204 i really hope 😭
Courtney and Spencer out nerding each other is so funny lol
they shouldve watched the video by Dual Process Theory and then had spencer and courtney explain this. i think theyd be able to piece it together more thoroughly even if they disagree with their conclusions, this was the only video I've ever watched that made me able to concisely explain the plot of FNAF since like, when FNAF world came out
I like how within the board there is no mention of pizzeria simulator when that’s the one of the games that gives you the most lore, idk why they skipped it and went to security breach😂😂
I'm fully confused by that too, it gives the resolution to alot of the plotlines they mention. I really hope they eventually do get to it
We need a 3 hour Mike’s Mic style video explaining this to Amanda lol
Okay but the visuals for a Mike’s Mic style video of FNAF would go crazy. I need this to exist now haha
@@pattykcake I feel like the color coding would come in handy lol
MIKES MIC MENTIONED
@@clara.galley it’s only right after all the content he’s graced us with
I don't know why but this is giving explaining fnaf to grandma vibes like every time Amanda goes "Ohhhhhhhh"
"I think his name is Evan" Oh Spencer thats a quick way to get the ire of the community lol
I just refer to him as "Evan/Norman".
Right. Love him so much but that instantly had me like "Oh, nevermind, Spencer is not going to be the credible source here" LMAO
@@kngbee07 is his name not Evan ;-;
i call him c.c..
i just call him crying child, so no one gets mad
All of them trying to explain fnaf and stepping over each other reminds me of explaining my hyperfixations to my friends lol
Exact same feelings lol
this is THE BEST breakdown of FNAF i've had the pleasure of watching. BRAVO TEAM:)
I really love the fact that the first half of this video is just “let’s circle back” “let’s put a pin in that”