This episode contains fictional stories with depictions of animal cruelty, violence, suicide, and death which may be triggering or upsetting to some audiences. 0:00 Intro 3:55 General trigger warning 4:21 “Distorted Warning Signals” (TW: death) 9:45 “Ickbarr Bigelsteine” (TW: animal cruelty, violence) 21:01 Sponsor! 22:17 “Smile Dog” // (TW: suicide) Click at your own risk! knowyourmeme.com/photos/270734-smilejpg 37:38 “Dead Bart” (TW: death) 44:32 Sponsor! 45:46 “The Rake” (TW: suicide) 55:46 Scary story debriefing
Distorted Warning Signs could make for a fun horror short. You end up with the ghost of the girl and the phone on her hands, trying to warn herself and end with a full circle moment
@A.2.123 not sure if it's the same but there's the dyatlav pass film where 2 of the main cast end up being the monsters that where chasing them throughout the film.
Wasn’t there one called like Ben is dead or Ben drowned or something like that that had to do with a haunted Zelda game where they did “updates” in the story?! That one was so good!
@@coccrocc Nah, you judging someone for being scared of something is what's silly and disappointing. Weird ass thing to call disappointing lmao, weirdo
The scariest part about the imaginary friend story is that its extremely probable the main character is actually just a paranoid schizophrenic. They talk a lot about feeling constantly watched, and the pack of wild dogs chasing them is very similar to many common paranoid schizophrenic delusions of being stalked/gang stalked. To me that is far more scary than actual monsters, because it means that they're just killing and shoving random peoples teeth in a doll while believing that doing it is saving them.
Exactly how i feel too! I find it way creepier thinking of it more as a realistic story with a mentally unwell person falling deeper and deeper into their own mind rather than a supernatural story. Always one of the saddest but hardest hitting tropes in my opinion.
You’re right unfortunately my dads cousin was schizophrenic and he thought the man was our prime minister here in australia was following him around and tracking him through the radio
I have schizophrenia, luckily I finally got on an injection medication that worked for me. And now I’m going to college for art. It was scary during my time at the hospital. It felt like I’d be there forever. I just gotta focus on school and hope for the best.
@@A1D3NA1D3N I hope it helps you! It's really difficult having such a highly stigmatized condition, I know. We have DID so we're in a kinda similar boat as far as stigma goes (though I think it's a less scary disorder to actually experience). I'm proud of you for coming so far ♥
Shane. Bro. For the last 8 years of my life I've listened to creepy pastas, true horror stories, murder mysterys, and scary redit stories and they've never made me feel as unsettled as the first one you read. I didn't expect you to have a story like THAT!
What I find really funny about that aspect of Amanda is that the only reason she's not chronically online is because she didn't have much contact with the parts of the internet that clearly fascinates her early in her youth, so experiencing them now, she's immediately obsessed with them.
I thought the Smile dog was a goofy little goober, but apparently my phone did not. I looked at the picture and immediately after, my phone, which was at almost fifty percent, died. Edit: I’m still alive guys, nothing happened after that lmao
@@adriannajane Aw that was so wholesome thank you LOL maybe one day. I totally would but I worry I'd get fired from my stable 9-5 if they found some goofy azz video I made or something like that
35:26 the creepypasta craze of the 2010s produced so much weird fan art and head canons that I forgot some of these stories (especially smile dog) are actually really well done. clicked on that link for a little blast from the past
@@The0neand0nlyEvy lmao no, the image they used is a photo of Halloween decor covered in snow. It's 100% fake, there's plenty of real messed up experiments from that era though
@@The0neand0nlyEvy the picture is of a halloween decoration lol also i dont think they'll ever read it on here just because half of it is describing gore
Have you heard of CreepCast with Wendigoon & MeatCanyon? They read aloud creepypastas and discuss them, make fun of them, poop their pants in fear, etc. They have a few supersized episodes that are 3-5 hours or 2 parters.
I love how serious Amanda is during all of these stories. Like they could be or are fake but she listens with such sincerity and passion, it’s like she’s listening to someone tell their life story.
the smile dog link not working makes it so much more scary lmao (edit, the original link was changed within an hour of posting, i get that it works now omg😭😭)
@@Kriplingpowri think had they been a little quieter it would’ve worked for me, like i saw their vision and sometimes it added to the story but other times it was more of a jumpscare 😭
@@yurilover13 yea probably. I don’t think it was so much of a jump scare but more of an annoyance that just brought me out of the zone of the story. It was mainly the dogs and animal noises that messed me up the distance screams and ambient noises could have worked if they were in the background not the foreground.
Drop Dead Fred is an early 90s misunderstood masterpiece. I adore it and it’s incredibly sweet behind all of the crazy over the top comedy. A true 90s oddity gem. Rik Mayall is a comedic genius.
I want them to read Doors just because the way everyone has a different reaction to the twist is super interesting to me. It made me cry when I read it as an 11 year old and then I showed it to a friend and they burst out laughing I don’t know how Shane and Amanda would react and it’s bothering me lol
5:07 I'm not joking when I say my phone started ringing right as Shayne read this. Not from "Unknown", thank god, or I would've really lost it, but still not a number saved in my phone. It was a spam call for voting, but it still freaked me out enough that I had to step away from my desk.
@@Emisnyan ive seen it twice in this comment section, one for "2 sentence horror stories" and one for "russian sleep experiment, youtube highlights that part of the text and shows it in blue with a magnifying glass icon on the right..???!? as if youtube isnt already working overtime to recommend vids i dont want or need? also building traffic to other things through a creators comment section is pretty absurd. i hope this feature never reaches u 🩷
I never thought I would hear the story about the rake again... It used to give me nightmares as a kid. I can’t watch horror movies because of how that thing traumatized me😭😭 smosh cast are the only people I would listen to scary stories for/with.
Okay, this NEEDS to become a reoccurring thing. reading creepy stories in the dark like this made for such a good video please keep this up in some way.
The Simpsons one is probably implying that Matt Groening knows when the end of the world is as the Simpson always predicts the future and Matt has been accused of being a time traveler. hence creating Futurama and Homer “jokingly” but accurately writing the equation for the God Particle in an episode. The equation was written down in the episode before the Higgs Boson and particle accelerator experiments.
@@humphreybiggins8295 Yes, it's true. A decade before it was discovered. However, a few caveats. For one, Homer's formula predicted the mass of the Higgs boson, but was off by a factor of about 6. That seems like a lot, but apparently that was still impressively close. Also, the Simpsons writer that wrote this formula is a mathematician, who contacted an astronomer friend to work on the formula together. Lastly, the Higgs Boson was first proposed in the sixties, so they had been working on discovering it for a while before that episode of the Simpsons came out. Just google "simpsons higgs boson", plenty of articles about it. It's really cool, and quite a bit of coincidence that they got as close to the correct answer as they did. But no future predicting powers or time travel would need to be involved.
@@humphreybiggins8295 as far as I know (internet 🤔) yes. They asked some of the writers who are mathematicians and super nerds about it. that video is on RUclips. They were off by like one number on the Simpson episode years before it was proven.
To this day Candle Cove is still one of my absolute favorite creepypastas all time. I loved the way it was written as if it was multiple people talking on a forum and the pay off at the end haunted me when I was a teenager.
What I find so cool about the distorted warnings one is that I keep wondering who the unknown caller is. Like is it the woman herself from other dimensions trying to communicate to herself? Maybe the catastrophes wouldn’t happen if the woman didn’t answer the phone. So maybe she is safe in her apartment after all. Or she would be if she didn’t listen to the message. What if somehow the woman is causing the catastrophes by not participating in them. I have so many questions. It’s such a cool concept
My hunch leans on the fact that the narrator describes the caller's voice in that last message as a woman's voice sounding "as if her throat had been sliced to ribbons." She didn't note this quality in the other calls, even though those voices were garbled as well. It's my interpretation that every call is from a version of the narrator from an alternate sequence of events where she did die in these incidents, sent to warn her by some cosmic force or quirk of fate.
@silverfiore01 The specific wording is what I'm talking about. "Sliced to ribbons," has a specific implication when used the way the narrator does. "Shredded," as in destroyed by a wild, chaotic force, like the airplane crash. "Sliced to ribbons," is more subdued, intentional. It's likely that there was a home invader that killed the narrator shortly after the story ended by slicing her throat.
My take is that homegirl was so unlucky she needed her dead alternate selves to warn her because damn was she good at ending up in bad situations, until her 'luck' ran out, that is
fr! there's something about the way shayne reads these stories that makes them hit harder. he's not playing it up or getting into the theater of it, which makes the story shine even more. it's like a neutral presentation of facts that makes even stories I've heard before feel refreshing 😁
If you're interested in the reason why they're called creepypasta: Early in internet culture of the 00's, it became common to find particularly silly or unhinged strings of text (usually originating as comments in forums) and to take these silly things and just copy + paste them in response to random things or as reactions to posts. Kind of like an early version of a text-based meme, but always copy + pasted verbatim. They were called "copypastas" after the phrase to "copy + paste." Then, when people started writing these scary stories and posting them around, they were dubbed "creepypastas," as a portmanteau of "copypasta" and "creepy."
@@kybifox13 jojos bizarre adventure reference!! a stand is like a spirit attached to one person and it has a unique, special ability. but it's not just some random spirit, it's kind of an extension of the person who the stand belongs to. dio is the villain of the series with a very very powerful stand which he uses to harm other stand users and innocent, normal people. it's a very bizarre manga and anime, as you can probably tell by the name.
AMANDA you have saved me for years of being confused as to why beetlejuice doesnt have a scene on a big party boat or a crazy guy in a full green suit. I thought i was going mad and made a whole movie up!!!!
Can we talk about how absolutely doing the actual smile dog photo is? It's genuinely a product of its time and I can't help but laugh when I see it. Amanda being afraid of it makes it so much funnier
i've watched 8hrs of creepypasta iceberg, read and listened to hundreds of creepypastas, and still shayne found a story i haven't an idea about. bravo shayne. bravo creepypastas
@@AnneZomerdijk-nv9ye I’m curious abt that as well. My guess is maybe the phone one bc that one likely isn’t as popular as the others. I haven’t been as involved with creepy pastas but I’ve at least vaguely heard abt a good bit of these. I don’t think I’ve heard of the phone call warning one.
Spread the word spread the word spread the wros spreadthe word spread the work kspread the word. Spread the word spread the word spread the word spread the word spread the word PREAD THE WORD SPRE THE WORD SPREAD THE WORD SPREWAD THE WORD SPREAD THE WORD SPREAD THE WORD SPREAD THE WORD SPRED THE WORD SPREAD THE WORD. :)
Here Are Some Creepy Pasta Recommendations For Amanda And Shayne: - The Disappearance of Ashley, Kansas (i HIGHLY recommend this one) - Pen Pal - Psychosis - The Left Right Game - Tales From the Gas Station (This one is funny yet slightly horrifying at the same time, I also highly recommend it)
The left right game is so good! I found the podcast of it a few years ago, and switched to the original version written on reddit a few chapters in. I've been thinking about rereading it, or listening to the podcast for a while now.
Goddamn, it's been a long time since I've seen people talking about Psychosis. That one shook me to the core because of the uncertainty of the senses of the protag while reading it. It was so good. I hope they check it out
The Unwanted House Guest (AKA: Never Alone or Shadowlurker) is the creepy pasta that frightens me the most. I find its face to be the most scary of all of them, and it's the kind of thing my frightened brain expects to find in my dark house in the middle of the night.
How have I not even thought about that?? But you're so right. What would Amanda be an avatar of? No matter what it is it's 100% her just being swept into it (probably by shayne) and ending up as an avatar. Michael Shelley style. Wait does that imply that shayne is Gertrude
@@rebeccapach6420 I see Shayne more as a Jonathan Sims type. Mostly because I find it funny to imagine Jon saying "Okay, Update..." Whenever the research team follows up on a statement. I think Amanda could be a servant of The Lonely, because of how scared she got while playing FNAF 2 when Shayne "left her hanging." Or because of her TNTL character who gets left alone at parties and concerts.
Shane has the right vibe for horror stories, the creepy ones that give a chill up your entire spine is like a drug I crave. Some of these nailed it, thank yoU!
The complete 180 from the expectation of potentially seeing an extremely creepy smiling dog to what I saw after clicking on the link to the picture gave me a whiplash. One of the funniest things I've seen.
It's so funny seeing the different reactions to the image. Some people are like "its super creepy and scary" and others just think its funny; when I saw it I actually laughed lol.
Amanda saying Drop Dead Fred is SCARY made me cackle, it's genuinely one of the funniest feel good movies! Rik Mayall was a gem that we truly didn't deserve
Shayne has the energy of one of those kids that always read out of the textbooks really good and everybody always made that kid read for the class because they did it so well whenever I hear him read reddit stories and these creepypastas
The part of this that creeped me out the most was Shayne's "For me? For free?" because that gave me such fae bargain vibes. Don't let him have it. He wants it for bad reasons.
Shayne, Amanda, I'm sorry but we NEED more of this format. It can't be just a Halloween special 😭 I'd watch an entire series of y'all talking about creepy stuff ngl.
How about introducing Amanda (and possibly Shayne?) to SCPs next? Similar origin to creepypastas and I can see the redacted descriptions of weird shit and how they're contained tickling Amanda's love of horror 💁♀ I feel like these would be up Spencer or Alex T's sleeve
clicked the link before watching the video... knew i was in for a freaky picture of some kind, thought to myself, "oh thats creepy, but a cool creepy. i wonder why it says click at your own risk..." and proceeded to listen to Shayne explain how the rest of my days will be filled with unimaginable horrors of this lil pupper with a silly lil smile, and i wont be sleeping tonight :DDD
omg the no sleep subreddit was everything to me in highschool … you should read the cordyceps one if you ever do an episode (i think the tagline goes like “Do your eyes hurt when you go to sleep”) anyways!! love these videos they’re so calming listening to the reading !! or you should come up with your own and have amanda figure out which one is real or not lol
The reason I'm not going to click the smile dog link is because I know I'm going to convince myself that it's real and give myself the nightmares from the story 💀💀
The russian sleep experiment image f'd with me when I first saw it when I was younger. Crazy how much a random image with no connection to you can mess with you
Amanda being afraid of drop dead fred and saying its a horror has me dead. I adore that movie man him helping her reconect with her childish/fun self and standing up for herself in life that movie is everything
It's so interesting seeing whether people prefer the more paranormal/supernatural type horror versus the true crime/real life style horror because I cannot watch paranormal/supernatural horror stuff very often because it freaks me out, but have no issue listening to stories about serial killers and unsolved crimes.
i like paranormal stuff if it's well done & not cheesy bc real life stories upset me usually. old gods of appalachia, the silt verses, etc etc stuff like that. it's my fav kind of horror media to consume.
I can handle true crime bc I know it can't impact me because its a human often from a long time ago or in another country. but paranormal/supernatural things are more unknown and I feel like if I think about it too much I might conjure them into my reality or nightmares 😂😅
@jodi4558 I think that's part of it for me too! Obviously true crime is more likely to happen than ghosts or demons or something, but also that means true crime is at least the result of humans. I'd probably still lose fighting a human, but at least I know where to aim or theoretically what to do. How do I avoid or protect myself from some ghost, demon, or idk, Mothman???
this is so crazy. i’m taking an urban legends class at my college rn, and *today* was our lecture on creepypastas. we talked about candle cove, ben drowned, polybius, slenderman, and a bunch of other stories of the like. this is giving *me* deja vu … our professor recommended a show called “channel zero”. they created an episode of candle cove, and the first season surrounds that creepypasta.
Channel zero is a masterpiece of a show. Every season is a banger (although the final one less so). My favorite is the one based off of the story Amanda and Shayne read last video about the creepypasta of the search and rescue guy who finds staircases in the woods. Also the house one is incredible.
I absolutely thought smile dog was real when i first read it years ago, along with a specific scp. I cant remember the name but its the one that chases you down and kills you if you look at a picture of it, and there is an entire story about the scp foundation trying and failing to capture it before it gets one of its victims. I saw a picture of it on accident and was so convinced i was gonna die soon that i refused to eat for 3 days because i didn't want to "waste food" 😅
@@beanbread9422 SCP-096. Chases you rapidly if you see it in any way, either directly or by photo/video. One of the scary versions is it being a tiny little speck in a picture of some snowy mountains, because you don't even perceive it, but it still gets pissed. A very silly version, on the other hand, is them doing an experiment where someone looks at a picture while in space. Let's just say the way it gets to space was pretty dumb.
When the second story said they had dentures I LAUGHED OUT LOUD that totally took me out of it. Just the casual, I now have dentures is fcking HILARIOUS. No torture story behind it just "I have dentures" at 22yrs old. I just imagined that Harry Styles meme "Who da ya fink gave u da teef luv?"
That candle cove story or whatever it was with the static TV still sticks out in my mind, I love these videos I hope we get another one sooner than next year
One of my favorite creepypastas to this day is Penpal. I listen to it at least once every six months or so. It’s so good. And it’s scary in a very real world kind of way. I honestly think it would be a great one for the Smosh cast to read.
@@meggsntoast great minds think alike because that’s specifically who I was thinking of when I wrote the comment. I think it would destroy Amanda in the best way lol
This episode contains fictional stories with depictions of animal cruelty, violence, suicide, and death which may be triggering or upsetting to some audiences.
0:00 Intro
3:55 General trigger warning
4:21 “Distorted Warning Signals” (TW: death)
9:45 “Ickbarr Bigelsteine” (TW: animal cruelty, violence)
21:01 Sponsor!
22:17 “Smile Dog” // (TW: suicide) Click at your own risk! knowyourmeme.com/photos/270734-smilejpg
37:38 “Dead Bart” (TW: death)
44:32 Sponsor!
45:46 “The Rake” (TW: suicide)
55:46 Scary story debriefing
Ok
Yesssss you guys did post smile.jpg 😂 I love it
The link didn't work
i saw the rake and got chills, super excited.
@@taeaortkc9885yes it did
the most unrealistic part of the imaginary friend story is a 22 year old having a well-paying job and their own place lol
Real.
And being able to afford dentures.
Literally what I was thinking 😭
Perhaps Mr. Ick did more than keep evil away. Unless it was the source of it in which case it just unleashed it to their every business competitor .
omg, literally
I love how we’re so used to Reddit stories that Amanda just immediately says “UPDATE!”
For reall lmaooo 😂😂😂
it felt so natural I didn't even think about it
Yeah it was kinda adorable lol
It's like pavlovian.
"No, no update!" 😂
Shayne has the perfect vibe for Creepy Pasta, legit got chills just in the way he read some of the stories.
He really is so good at reading stories
Bro I was not expecting “don’t come home after dinner tonight”
Yeah. Forget Reddit stories- I WANT THIS ALL THE TIME!
My hand covered my mouth as my jaw dropped! 😮
That person avoided their fate until it could no longer be avoided 😮
I had gasped. It was such a good twist ending 🫣
A chill ran thru my spine
Shayne : a little bit of unknown, that's what really gets me
Like seeing a plate of BBQ ribs in a nondescript corner of the Smosh office
that's just Real Life, man!
Or an unattended bowl of chili where no one should be eating
LMAO this is so good 😂
his reaction destroyed me lmao
AHAHAHAHA
Distorted Warning Signs could make for a fun horror short. You end up with the ghost of the girl and the phone on her hands, trying to warn herself and end with a full circle moment
There's a movie kinda similar to that, can't remember what it's called tho
@A.2.123 not sure if it's the same but there's the dyatlav pass film where 2 of the main cast end up being the monsters that where chasing them throughout the film.
brilliant idea
@@A.2.123is it a Korean movie? There’s a Korean movie with this plot
@@thanos9979 is that The Call?? i don’t remember if it’s the same plot but i remember liking that one
Amanda asking for an UPDATE on a Creepypasta is hilarious and actually brilliant. Imagine someone just updating their creepypasta.
Wasn’t there one called like Ben is dead or Ben drowned or something like that that had to do with a haunted Zelda game where they did “updates” in the story?! That one was so good!
There are a few like that actually!!! With chapters and everything
There are actually a few they are usually just called parts or chapters
Or anyone adding to it so it grows as more people contribute
there are some ARG type ones with the writer is supposedly updating over some time!
Smile dog very much feels like a relic of the older internet because that image now looks so goofy lmao
i thought it was that stupid bulldog smiling dog meme (normal teeth)
@@fluerry_14 there are two. that one was the original, and IMO the better and scarier one
I literally covered my screen, and then when I moved my hand, I said “Oh… okay.” 😂
@@yansw look at the OG, much better image IMO.
@@potatoman7594 I think I’ll pull an Amanda and say “no thank you” 😂
Amanda's bored face during Smile.jpg is SO REAL
I agree. The best part is the image itself not the story. But her being actually scared of what’s essentially a fake story is silly and disappointing
@@coccrocc she's not scared. she's just semi-superstitious, i think, and would just prefer to be on the safe side
@@coccrocc Nah, you judging someone for being scared of something is what's silly and disappointing. Weird ass thing to call disappointing lmao, weirdo
Fr, in reading comments while listening to it because it's so boring.
@@coccroccchronically online take to find it “disappointing”
"SHE'S HOME....AFTER DINNER TONIGHT." 😂😂😂 Love Amanda so much.
Honestly, she has always been one of my favorite Smosh people ever
"UPDATE" killed me
Amanda's reactions are always a killer
@@harrypeener That Shayne effect where whenever he reads something, I assume it's from reddit 😂
P
The scariest part about the imaginary friend story is that its extremely probable the main character is actually just a paranoid schizophrenic. They talk a lot about feeling constantly watched, and the pack of wild dogs chasing them is very similar to many common paranoid schizophrenic delusions of being stalked/gang stalked. To me that is far more scary than actual monsters, because it means that they're just killing and shoving random peoples teeth in a doll while believing that doing it is saving them.
Exactly how i feel too! I find it way creepier thinking of it more as a realistic story with a mentally unwell person falling deeper and deeper into their own mind rather than a supernatural story. Always one of the saddest but hardest hitting tropes in my opinion.
You’re right unfortunately my dads cousin was schizophrenic and he thought the man was our prime minister here in australia was following him around and tracking him through the radio
My exact thought
I have schizophrenia, luckily I finally got on an injection medication that worked for me. And now I’m going to college for art. It was scary during my time at the hospital. It felt like I’d be there forever. I just gotta focus on school and hope for the best.
@@A1D3NA1D3N I hope it helps you! It's really difficult having such a highly stigmatized condition, I know. We have DID so we're in a kinda similar boat as far as stigma goes (though I think it's a less scary disorder to actually experience). I'm proud of you for coming so far ♥
Shane. Bro. For the last 8 years of my life I've listened to creepy pastas, true horror stories, murder mysterys, and scary redit stories and they've never made me feel as unsettled as the first one you read. I didn't expect you to have a story like THAT!
RIGHTTTT THAT ONE SCARED ME SO BAD AND I HAD NO IDEA WHY
i gasped at that twist!
Shayne should introduce Amanda to SCP’s. I’d kill to see an episode of them going over the weirdest ones.
This is a completely underrated suggestion, it would be a good to see Amanda's reaction to SCPs.
How many people know about that? I have the special edition.
What is SCP?
I JUST SUGGESTED THIS OMG
@@Flare-sv3kj What is SCP?
Our chronically offline queen becoming chronically online with shayne, spencer and trevor showing her everything! Loving the content
What I find really funny about that aspect of Amanda is that the only reason she's not chronically online is because she didn't have much contact with the parts of the internet that clearly fascinates her early in her youth, so experiencing them now, she's immediately obsessed with them.
don't forget Damien!!
and court
Not my queen 😎
@@chugalu-h2d can't forget him! Or court
I thought the Smile dog was a goofy little goober, but apparently my phone did not. I looked at the picture and immediately after, my phone, which was at almost fifty percent, died.
Edit: I’m still alive guys, nothing happened after that lmao
Update?
😭
@@safaebergor3959i think they’re dead
UPDATE!?
So did you lose your mind or send the photo to someone else
Shayne has carved out a niche for himself reading internet stories for a living and I'm kinda jealous
Could always try it for yourself! You never know. I've seen unknown people make a career out of less. ❤
@@adriannajane Aw that was so wholesome thank you LOL maybe one day. I totally would but I worry I'd get fired from my stable 9-5 if they found some goofy azz video I made or something like that
@@andrikohDon't let fear keep you from taking chances!! 💜 I'm a public speaker in the making.
@@Nothannahbruhk That's awesome, best of luck with your public speaking journey
Reading for a living. He won life ❤🎉
Whoever is responsible for the lighting should get a raise. It looks incredible
About 30 seconds in and came here to say this. Gorgeous lighting!
ETA: And the sound effects 😍
Amanda looks so cute in this light
It's a dim light...
@@CoolExecutioner It's at minimum 3 lights, you can tell just by the different colours (Orange, white and blue)
@cuckoobrain7999 yes. But it's nothing ground breaking lol
35:26 the creepypasta craze of the 2010s produced so much weird fan art and head canons that I forgot some of these stories (especially smile dog) are actually really well done. clicked on that link for a little blast from the past
The Russian Sleep Experiment was the first creepypasta I ever read, and it's still the one that comes to mind any time the topic comes up
THATS NOT REAL???
I love that one. It creeps me out to this day.
@@The0neand0nlyEvy lmao no, the image they used is a photo of Halloween decor covered in snow. It's 100% fake, there's plenty of real messed up experiments from that era though
@@The0neand0nlyEvy the picture is of a halloween decoration lol
also i dont think they'll ever read it on here just because half of it is describing gore
The best one for me was Expressionless
why does shayne without his ipad feel like an angel without their wings
The segway from the puppet having human teeth to "Anyways heres our sponsor mint mobile!" Is so funny
Dude this is my dream video, I hope we get 6 hours minimum next time
manifesting next year they read the creepypasta called 1999! it would terrify them 😂
Have you heard of CreepCast with Wendigoon & MeatCanyon? They read aloud creepypastas and discuss them, make fun of them, poop their pants in fear, etc. They have a few supersized episodes that are 3-5 hours or 2 parters.
@@tibb75omg no way!! i had no idea wendigoon and meat canyon ever did anything together- i totally have to check it out
god me too
I would actually pay for them to read The Left Right Game
Should give Amanda and Shayne a couple of weeks to come up with their own creepypastas and then read them on the show like the Don't Laugh episodes.
PLEASE I do this, then do it again on gor smosh theater!
YES PLEASE
OMG YESS
Damien! Thoughts?
I love how serious Amanda is during all of these stories. Like they could be or are fake but she listens with such sincerity and passion, it’s like she’s listening to someone tell their life story.
the smile dog link not working makes it so much more scary lmao (edit, the original link was changed within an hour of posting, i get that it works now omg😭😭)
just gotta refresh the page and then it works. just spreading the word
It works if you open it in safari instead of RUclips’s browser
right?
@@TrioArtsOfficial “just spreading the word” … eeeuughhh
Won't work on mobile it seems even after a refresh
The way I JUMPED when I heard the dogs barking sound effect 😭😭
Honestly thought all the sound effects broke the tension and were corny. Listening to Shayne was fun tho
@@Kriplingpowri think had they been a little quieter it would’ve worked for me, like i saw their vision and sometimes it added to the story but other times it was more of a jumpscare 😭
@@yurilover13 yea probably. I don’t think it was so much of a jump scare but more of an annoyance that just brought me out of the zone of the story. It was mainly the dogs and animal noises that messed me up the distance screams and ambient noises could have worked if they were in the background not the foreground.
😂😂
@@Kriplingpowryeah they weren’t scary at all, idk what people are on sometimes
Drop Dead Fred is an early 90s misunderstood masterpiece. I adore it and it’s incredibly sweet behind all of the crazy over the top comedy. A true 90s oddity gem. Rik Mayall is a comedic genius.
"That's it? UPDATE??!"
I thought the same thing. I love Amanda.
amanda’s cardigan and the theme of this episode is the perfect contrast.
?
@@coroner2141 the theme of the video is dark and creepy.
Her cardigan is colorful
See?
@@tartatovsky huh
The cardigan is giving final girl
it’s giving fall carnival..kinda spooky ! 🍂🍎
Amanda refusing to look at smile dog and trying to convince others not to look is so mom coded and i love her for it lol
shayne needs to read bad scary stories, jeff the killer and 'man door hand hook car door' are my favorites, amanda would love them
Or the creepypasta fanfics about slenderman's mansion
@@Vitasaurus That gave me so many flashbacks, i fr cosplayed sally as a child not even KNOWING what her story was
How dare you call Jeff a “bad scary story”? Don’t disrespect my first anime emo cute boy crush like that
Creepcast did an absolutely hilarious podcast on Jeff the Killer
I want them to read Doors just because the way everyone has a different reaction to the twist is super interesting to me. It made me cry when I read it as an 11 year old and then I showed it to a friend and they burst out laughing
I don’t know how Shane and Amanda would react and it’s bothering me lol
5:07 I'm not joking when I say my phone started ringing right as Shayne read this. Not from "Unknown", thank god, or I would've really lost it, but still not a number saved in my phone. It was a spam call for voting, but it still freaked me out enough that I had to step away from my desk.
I would shit myself
Freaky af either way
I totally respect Shayne not wanting to read these too often but boy do I love the creepypasta episodes, need more!!
i got chills when shayne said he was looking at the image - it seemed like he embodied the writer
Okay now I NEED another bad 2 sentence horror stories episode. That is by far my favorite you’ve ever done and it makes me cackle every single time
how did this become a link to the search bar what did you do
You want more two sentence horror stories.
Unfortunately so does the sand worm.
A blue search thingie on RUclips? I thought this was an only tiktok thing 🔍
@@Emisnyan ive seen it twice in this comment section, one for "2 sentence horror stories" and one for "russian sleep experiment, youtube highlights that part of the text and shows it in blue with a magnifying glass icon on the right..???!? as if youtube isnt already working overtime to recommend vids i dont want or need? also building traffic to other things through a creators comment section is pretty absurd. i hope this feature never reaches u 🩷
@@listerjne 👁️👄👁️ huh
I never thought I would hear the story about the rake again... It used to give me nightmares as a kid. I can’t watch horror movies because of how that thing traumatized me😭😭 smosh cast are the only people I would listen to scary stories for/with.
Okay, this NEEDS to become a reoccurring thing. reading creepy stories in the dark like this made for such a good video please keep this up in some way.
is this not them doing it as a recurring thing? This is the 2nd time they did this, with the 1st being around a year ago
You should check out creepcast they have a podcast reading creepypastas
@@Penquinn14i think OP means more than an annual thing
The Simpsons one is probably implying that Matt Groening knows when the end of the world is as the Simpson always predicts the future and Matt has been accused of being a time traveler. hence creating Futurama and Homer “jokingly” but accurately writing the equation for the God Particle in an episode. The equation was written down in the episode before the Higgs Boson and particle accelerator experiments.
Ohhhh this makes so much sense. Thank you!
@@sharkbait398 🫡🫡🫡
wait what? the god particle equation? is this real???? it was in a simpsons episode before if was actually created?? 😂
@@humphreybiggins8295 Yes, it's true. A decade before it was discovered. However, a few caveats. For one, Homer's formula predicted the mass of the Higgs boson, but was off by a factor of about 6. That seems like a lot, but apparently that was still impressively close. Also, the Simpsons writer that wrote this formula is a mathematician, who contacted an astronomer friend to work on the formula together. Lastly, the Higgs Boson was first proposed in the sixties, so they had been working on discovering it for a while before that episode of the Simpsons came out. Just google "simpsons higgs boson", plenty of articles about it.
It's really cool, and quite a bit of coincidence that they got as close to the correct answer as they did. But no future predicting powers or time travel would need to be involved.
@@humphreybiggins8295 as far as I know (internet 🤔) yes. They asked some of the writers who are mathematicians and super nerds about it. that video is on RUclips. They were off by like one number on the Simpson episode years before it was proven.
"Halloween's coming up now"
Me, watching this on Christmas Eve: indeed it is, good sir
To this day Candle Cove is still one of my absolute favorite creepypastas all time. I loved the way it was written as if it was multiple people talking on a forum and the pay off at the end haunted me when I was a teenager.
they read it in the previous episode! it was my favourite among the ones as well
You should watch season 1 of Channel Zero. It's Candle Cove and they do it so well.
A creepy pasta podcast with our boy Damian would be great
Totally!! He was actually supposed to be in the one last year but was sick, I'm a little bummed he wasnt in this one instead
Missed opportunity!
Yeah, I was really hoping he was going to be here.
RIGHT!!?? We need some Damien hosting for the spoopies
and Angela reacting
the way shayne’s voice is PERFECT for reading these! same with the reddit stories, i love listening to him read
What I find so cool about the distorted warnings one is that I keep wondering who the unknown caller is. Like is it the woman herself from other dimensions trying to communicate to herself? Maybe the catastrophes wouldn’t happen if the woman didn’t answer the phone. So maybe she is safe in her apartment after all. Or she would be if she didn’t listen to the message. What if somehow the woman is causing the catastrophes by not participating in them. I have so many questions. It’s such a cool concept
My hunch leans on the fact that the narrator describes the caller's voice in that last message as a woman's voice sounding "as if her throat had been sliced to ribbons." She didn't note this quality in the other calls, even though those voices were garbled as well. It's my interpretation that every call is from a version of the narrator from an alternate sequence of events where she did die in these incidents, sent to warn her by some cosmic force or quirk of fate.
My take was that she could no longer avoid her inevitable fate. Yours is a really interesting take too!
@@Dex-ik4js Well the first call says the voice sounds strange as if her vocal cords had been shredded
@silverfiore01 The specific wording is what I'm talking about. "Sliced to ribbons," has a specific implication when used the way the narrator does. "Shredded," as in destroyed by a wild, chaotic force, like the airplane crash. "Sliced to ribbons," is more subdued, intentional. It's likely that there was a home invader that killed the narrator shortly after the story ended by slicing her throat.
My take is that homegirl was so unlucky she needed her dead alternate selves to warn her because damn was she good at ending up in bad situations, until her 'luck' ran out, that is
Usually Shayne's voice is calming and charming, but his narration of these stories is fantastically spooky! What a great episode, thanks guys!
I was about to comment this! I'd listen to a legit audiobook with him reading
fr! there's something about the way shayne reads these stories that makes them hit harder. he's not playing it up or getting into the theater of it, which makes the story shine even more. it's like a neutral presentation of facts that makes even stories I've heard before feel refreshing 😁
@daa5865 new side job unlocked!
MintMobile is the scariest among these creepy pasta, my favorite
too minty, too spicie
ryan reynolds 😱😱😭
Ryter Reynleds 😢 /ref
Ah, a classic, I remember reading it on Creepypasta Wiki back in the day
idk what a creepypasta is but I love smoshmouth and I love pasta! so very excited for this
ok that was not what I was expecting a creepypasta to be but im still excited haha
@@GPower542love the reply to yourself after you figured out what it was 😂
this is an amanda style comment
If you're interested in the reason why they're called creepypasta:
Early in internet culture of the 00's, it became common to find particularly silly or unhinged strings of text (usually originating as comments in forums) and to take these silly things and just copy + paste them in response to random things or as reactions to posts. Kind of like an early version of a text-based meme, but always copy + pasted verbatim. They were called "copypastas" after the phrase to "copy + paste."
Then, when people started writing these scary stories and posting them around, they were dubbed "creepypastas," as a portmanteau of "copypasta" and "creepy."
@@GPower542 well you know this is the second in the series, they did this last Halloween
The smile dog creeps me tf out. I legit thought you were gonna show its picture. Thank you for not doing that 😭❤️
That first story has a simple answer, OP had a STAND that warns her of imminent danger and it was DIO at home waiting for her after dinner.
I must know more! What does this mean? STAND? DIO?
@@kybifox13 same it went over my head
@@kybifox13 jojo's bizarre adventure -- watch it!
@@kybifox13 jojos bizarre adventure reference!! a stand is like a spirit attached to one person and it has a unique, special ability. but it's not just some random spirit, it's kind of an extension of the person who the stand belongs to. dio is the villain of the series with a very very powerful stand which he uses to harm other stand users and innocent, normal people. it's a very bizarre manga and anime, as you can probably tell by the name.
@@Liktafrog this is the first time I learned anything about what goes on in that series. that's wild lmao
“Sometimes I wonder; where have I been?” Real Amanda. Real.
Felt that one in my soul. 😅
AMANDA you have saved me for years of being confused as to why beetlejuice doesnt have a scene on a big party boat or a crazy guy in a full green suit. I thought i was going mad and made a whole movie up!!!!
Can we talk about how absolutely doing the actual smile dog photo is? It's genuinely a product of its time and I can't help but laugh when I see it. Amanda being afraid of it makes it so much funnier
I built myself up to look at that smile dog pic so much then opened it and was like oh...hey doggy!!
I've seen it so much over the years. It's literally the background of a few creepypasta videos. I think it's been on my fb a few times even.
its literally the goofiest picture i've ever seen lol. the hand was the only thing that looked remotely non goofy
DO NOT COME HOME AFTER DINNER TONIGHT FREAKING KILLED ME OMG I GOT FULL BODY CHILLS AND TEARED UP
you guys NEED to read that one creepypasta story thing about police finding staircases in the woods.
They have I'm pretty sure! It would be in the first creepypasta video they did
it was in last years vid -- the last story the talk about!
They did that last year
@@Ace_and_Asa oh ohkay
i've watched 8hrs of creepypasta iceberg, read and listened to hundreds of creepypastas, and still shayne found a story i haven't an idea about. bravo shayne. bravo creepypastas
Which story or stories hadn't you heard of yet?
Which one?
Answer dammit
@@KKO_FLUMfr
@@AnneZomerdijk-nv9ye
I’m curious abt that as well. My guess is maybe the phone one bc that one likely isn’t as popular as the others. I haven’t been as involved with creepy pastas but I’ve at least vaguely heard abt a good bit of these. I don’t think I’ve heard of the phone call warning one.
smile dog is so silly because it’s been years since i’ve seen it but i really can’t look at it for a long time or i will scare myself lol
35:24 y'all are wild for this
I looked at it… it’s pretty hilarious 😂 I can’t take the story seriously after seeing that lmao
@@Ddalgiichigoit is kinda goofy looking. Still creepy in that eerie “I can’t fully tell what’s going on and that worries me” way
I didn’t realize I had seen it before lol
The way I immediately went to look at it. I have no self preservation instincts
Spread the word spread the word spread the wros spreadthe word spread the work kspread the word. Spread the word spread the word spread the word spread the word spread the word PREAD THE WORD SPRE THE WORD SPREAD THE WORD SPREWAD THE WORD SPREAD THE WORD SPREAD THE WORD SPREAD THE WORD SPRED THE WORD SPREAD THE WORD. :)
Here Are Some Creepy Pasta Recommendations For Amanda And Shayne:
- The Disappearance of Ashley, Kansas (i HIGHLY recommend this one)
- Pen Pal
- Psychosis
- The Left Right Game
- Tales From the Gas Station (This one is funny yet slightly horrifying at the same time, I also highly recommend it)
Even if they don’t check these out, I’m going to!!
W Tales From the Gas Station reference. One of the funniest things I’ve read in recent memory
The left right game is so good! I found the podcast of it a few years ago, and switched to the original version written on reddit a few chapters in. I've been thinking about rereading it, or listening to the podcast for a while now.
Thank you for recommending! I just finished reading the left/right game and it was awesome
Goddamn, it's been a long time since I've seen people talking about Psychosis. That one shook me to the core because of the uncertainty of the senses of the protag while reading it. It was so good. I hope they check it out
The Unwanted House Guest (AKA: Never Alone or Shadowlurker) is the creepy pasta that frightens me the most. I find its face to be the most scary of all of them, and it's the kind of thing my frightened brain expects to find in my dark house in the middle of the night.
I love how Shayne is really embracing the whole Magnus Archives thing. I can't wait for him to be an avatar of The Eye
How have I not even thought about that?? But you're so right. What would Amanda be an avatar of? No matter what it is it's 100% her just being swept into it (probably by shayne) and ending up as an avatar. Michael Shelley style. Wait does that imply that shayne is Gertrude
@@rebeccapach6420 I see Shayne more as a Jonathan Sims type. Mostly because I find it funny to imagine Jon saying "Okay, Update..." Whenever the research team follows up on a statement.
I think Amanda could be a servant of The Lonely, because of how scared she got while playing FNAF 2 when Shayne "left her hanging." Or because of her TNTL character who gets left alone at parties and concerts.
oh you’re so right. gosh i hope someone draws this
I'VE BEEN SAYING THIISS!! I really can't wait for Amanda to get into the magnus archives
@@loucaniom8984 OMG SHE WOULD LOVE IT
I love that the subtites still say Welcome to Smash Mouth in the beginning
some BODY
SOME
@@IsaacMayerCreativeWorks ONCE TOLD ME
They pay extra for that.
The subtitles seem to always say Smash instead of Smosh!
Shane has the right vibe for horror stories, the creepy ones that give a chill up your entire spine is like a drug I crave. Some of these nailed it, thank yoU!
The complete 180 from the expectation of potentially seeing an extremely creepy smiling dog to what I saw after clicking on the link to the picture gave me a whiplash. One of the funniest things I've seen.
It's so funny seeing the different reactions to the image. Some people are like "its super creepy and scary" and others just think its funny; when I saw it I actually laughed lol.
i cried laughing at an image below the original, genuine tears
I see y'all spreading the word heh
@@k8tieisjustjusthereOng I was gonne look it up until I saw your comment and went “yeah never mind”
Amanda saying Drop Dead Fred is SCARY made me cackle, it's genuinely one of the funniest feel good movies! Rik Mayall was a gem that we truly didn't deserve
That film used to terrify me lol 😅
IS THERE A TIMESTAMP 😭
I was thinking the same thing 😂 I haven’t watched in a while but my recollection is that it’s a comedy. Highly recommend it though! Absolute classic.
@@Sevensodas10:51 !
Love this movie! Cobwebs! She's got Cobwebs!! lmao
We NEED another one of these episodes. I can’t wait another year 😭😭😭
ngl i feel like these guys would freaking love the magnus archives. ESPECIALLY amanda
The magnus archives mentioned !!!
Its not happening but i would die for a listen through with commentary of it , and see amanda and shane theorizing
is that the one with the sex bug lady
@@garbomode29 i like to think of it as the one with the homophobic vase
Literally scrolled the comment section 'till I found someone that mentions/suggesting TMA to them
@@jersenshadowz XD IT'S SO GOOD THO!
Shayne has the energy of one of those kids that always read out of the textbooks really good and everybody always made that kid read for the class because they did it so well whenever I hear him read reddit stories and these creepypastas
great idea watching this just before sleep.. no but for real this was great, i love me some spooky time with Shayne and Amanda, wish there was more
You've been living life Amanda! Traveling the world, embracing experiences, tasting it's food! Food like, Mexican salsa? Yes!!!
The part of this that creeped me out the most was Shayne's "For me? For free?" because that gave me such fae bargain vibes. Don't let him have it. He wants it for bad reasons.
I love how I JUST finished this episode and, for the life of me, cannot recall him saying this 💀
@@ImNotElijah uh oh. You got a fae curse on you...
I thought it was just a Bedtime Stories reference lol
@@ImNotElijah it's at the end of The Rake. He's talking about sleeping with a leg outside the covers.
@@ImNotElijah54:30 found it!!!
Shayne, Amanda, I'm sorry but we NEED more of this format. It can't be just a Halloween special 😭 I'd watch an entire series of y'all talking about creepy stuff ngl.
1:23 SHAYNE AND AMANDA PLAY SLENDERMAN
YES COLLECT MY PAGES
YESSSSS
Watching the original videos would be better than that unscary game
PLEASEEEEE
YESSS
How about introducing Amanda (and possibly Shayne?) to SCPs next? Similar origin to creepypastas and I can see the redacted descriptions of weird shit and how they're contained tickling Amanda's love of horror 💁♀
I feel like these would be up Spencer or Alex T's sleeve
SCPs are so interesting, I was thinking the same. An episode reading some SCPs would be cool
Yaassss
clicked the link before watching the video... knew i was in for a freaky picture of some kind, thought to myself, "oh thats creepy, but a cool creepy. i wonder why it says click at your own risk..." and proceeded to listen to Shayne explain how the rest of my days will be filled with unimaginable horrors of this lil pupper with a silly lil smile, and i wont be sleeping tonight :DDD
Shane is giving Milo from Atlantis
How generous! What’s he giving him?
Rake still gets me and i remember having actual recreation of Rake in my nightmares as a teen.
I’m so scared rn
You just need an imaginary friend to fend it off.
omg the no sleep subreddit was everything to me in highschool … you should read the cordyceps one if you ever do an episode (i think the tagline goes like “Do your eyes hurt when you go to sleep”)
anyways!! love these videos they’re so calming listening to the reading !!
or you should come up with your own and have amanda figure out which one is real or not lol
8:42 LMAOOO AMANDAA "update??!? 😟"
Its so funny but thats just how lots of old creepypastas were! Theyd end really quickly and your brain just has to work with it, let it stick
The reason I'm not going to click the smile dog link is because I know I'm going to convince myself that it's real and give myself the nightmares from the story 💀💀
MEEEE
the link is broken anyway 😭
@@disc0queen worked for me on Android
It’s working now I guess. It’s just bad photoshop lol.
Yeah exactly I'm just not gonna go there to keep my mind at ease when I'm out in the dark.
I would listen to an entire podcast of Shayne just reading scary stories, omg. I absolutely loved this
Please do creepypastas and creepy stories as often as you guys can handle it! Its super fun and i love hearing you both discuss them after
the audio for this episode is AMAZING! the screams? the foot steps? *chef’s kiss*
Omg i looooved Drop Dead Fred as a kid! Never hear anyone else reference it. Brought me back, thanks Amanda!
Sound design ate again!!!! I didn’t expect the editors to give sfx to this episode because it’s so long but there is!! what a treat, thank you ❤☺️☺️☺️
I've seen the smile dog image because i thought "it aint gonna scare me, it's just an image"... it scared me for good. This story creeps me out
The russian sleep experiment image f'd with me when I first saw it when I was younger. Crazy how much a random image with no connection to you can mess with you
@@t-o-m-msame I thought “oh it’s just like other creepy pastas”it scared the Fvck outta me
Smile Dog is still the only creepy pasta that freaks me out, due to how young I was when I first read it, lmfao
Amanda being afraid of drop dead fred and saying its a horror has me dead. I adore that movie man him helping her reconect with her childish/fun self and standing up for herself in life that movie is everything
I hope the dog picture redirects to the picture Courtney drew of Shayne
Unfortunately no, it’s very creepy
If you’re on mobile, it’ll open on RUclips’s browser and won’t work. BUT if you tap whatever will open it on your main browser, then it works.
i clicked it and im mildly terrified. im gonna sleep soon so i guess i’ll give you an update tomorrow, remind me.
@@Vaelykra make sure you share the image around
@@michael_bullard update: i forgot about the image and slept very peacefully
It's so interesting seeing whether people prefer the more paranormal/supernatural type horror versus the true crime/real life style horror because I cannot watch paranormal/supernatural horror stuff very often because it freaks me out, but have no issue listening to stories about serial killers and unsolved crimes.
i like paranormal stuff if it's well done & not cheesy bc real life stories upset me usually. old gods of appalachia, the silt verses, etc etc stuff like that. it's my fav kind of horror media to consume.
I can handle true crime bc I know it can't impact me because its a human often from a long time ago or in another country. but paranormal/supernatural things are more unknown and I feel like if I think about it too much I might conjure them into my reality or nightmares 😂😅
@jodi4558 I think that's part of it for me too! Obviously true crime is more likely to happen than ghosts or demons or something, but also that means true crime is at least the result of humans. I'd probably still lose fighting a human, but at least I know where to aim or theoretically what to do. How do I avoid or protect myself from some ghost, demon, or idk, Mothman???
Shayne being such a good internet sherpa for Amanda is so much fun. :)
this is so crazy. i’m taking an urban legends class at my college rn, and *today* was our lecture on creepypastas. we talked about candle cove, ben drowned, polybius, slenderman, and a bunch of other stories of the like. this is giving *me* deja vu … our professor recommended a show called “channel zero”. they created an episode of candle cove, and the first season surrounds that creepypasta.
Channel zero is a masterpiece of a show. Every season is a banger (although the final one less so). My favorite is the one based off of the story Amanda and Shayne read last video about the creepypasta of the search and rescue guy who finds staircases in the woods. Also the house one is incredible.
10:50 THE VINDICATION I FEEL AFTER HEARING AMANDA SAY THIS. My mom has been making fun of me for almost 20 years about being scared of this movie!!!!
I loved that movie
watching this while already knowing all of the creepypastas is so fun, i love amandas reaction. smile dog is so silly btw i love him
im loving this creepy vibe for halloween, r/nosleep next PLEASE theyre so eerie cause the whole subreddit has to be part of it and act like it’s real!
Amanda not wanting to look at the picture of smile dog reminded me of my younger self reading that creepypasta and believing it was real lmao
Ur just trying to get me to the image, aren't you?
I absolutely thought smile dog was real when i first read it years ago, along with a specific scp. I cant remember the name but its the one that chases you down and kills you if you look at a picture of it, and there is an entire story about the scp foundation trying and failing to capture it before it gets one of its victims. I saw a picture of it on accident and was so convinced i was gonna die soon that i refused to eat for 3 days because i didn't want to "waste food" 😅
@@beanbread9422 SCP-096. Chases you rapidly if you see it in any way, either directly or by photo/video. One of the scary versions is it being a tiny little speck in a picture of some snowy mountains, because you don't even perceive it, but it still gets pissed. A very silly version, on the other hand, is them doing an experiment where someone looks at a picture while in space. Let's just say the way it gets to space was pretty dumb.
I had never heard of Dead Bart, but my favorite lost media is the Max and Ruby one
When the second story said they had dentures I LAUGHED OUT LOUD that totally took me out of it. Just the casual, I now have dentures is fcking HILARIOUS. No torture story behind it just "I have dentures" at 22yrs old. I just imagined that Harry Styles meme "Who da ya fink gave u da teef luv?"
I thought they meant they just bought them to give out- not that they actually gave away their teeth and now wear them themselves 🤦🏻♀️
That candle cove story or whatever it was with the static TV still sticks out in my mind, I love these videos I hope we get another one sooner than next year
the second shayne said chain letter, I got both excited and reminded of nightmares I used to have reading my favorite creepypasta.
One of my favorite creepypastas to this day is Penpal. I listen to it at least once every six months or so. It’s so good. And it’s scary in a very real world kind of way. I honestly think it would be a great one for the Smosh cast to read.
I WAS GONNA SAY PENPAL!! I feel like Amanda would love it.
@@meggsntoast great minds think alike because that’s specifically who I was thinking of when I wrote the comment. I think it would destroy Amanda in the best way lol
totally! i only found out recently that the author actually turned penpal into a book!
DUDE I HAVE THE BOOK! It legit is my favourite story period.
Have you read Borrasca, those 2 stories go hand in hand
@@with_seth1901 I listened to Creepcasts episodes with Penpal and Borrasca, really great back to back episodes.