Thank you every one for watching, remember to be kind, every artist has their own unique style whether you like it or not, be appreciative of talent! much love - Team CHQ
This ghazal was written in 1971 by Naseer Turabi, you can see the emotions and despondency put by him in this ghazal to express his love for East Pakistan now Bangladesh. Love from Bangladesh 🇧🇩❤️ 08-11-2024
Let's not compare. QB is the og singer for this one and no doubt she's set a benchmark so high it's kind of unparalleled. But Shae Gill has done it beautifully. Let's give her the due credit that she has been able to maintain the right feel. The woman deserves praises equally.
She's definitely playing it safe. Not reaching any high notes at all. Not sure if its done deliberately. But it didn't work in this particular setup. Could be because its live and even QB won't sound the same if its done live
Nobody realized that the filler guitar solo was from Mekaal Hassan's Sampooran. The best and greatest composer and guitar player that Pakistan produced.
Thank you every one for watching, remember to be kind, every artist has their own unique style whether you like it or not, be appreciative of talent! much love - Team CHQ
She's sung it so beautifully, for me her performance stands out on its own, no need for comparisons
I just love when someone say something like this ( positive vibes 😊
@@miiz2415 ❣️
This ghazal was written in 1971 by Naseer Turabi, you can see the emotions and despondency put by him in this ghazal to express his love for East Pakistan now Bangladesh. Love from Bangladesh 🇧🇩❤️
08-11-2024
No one in the entire universe can compete with qb. She's ❤
Agreed
1000% agreed ❤️
QB means?
@@asliabhinav Quratulain Balouch, the original singer of this OST. listen it, u will understand..
Yess 100%
Instead of comparing two artists you should rather enjoy their performance:)
Let's not compare. QB is the og singer for this one and no doubt she's set a benchmark so high it's kind of unparalleled.
But Shae Gill has done it beautifully. Let's give her the due credit that she has been able to maintain the right feel. The woman deserves praises equally.
Shae Gill far better
QB Has Feel + TASTE that never get's OLD
The song was written in memory of the separation of east pakistan in 1971..
really... but it can be
@@asadnaeem123 yes it is.
Not song ghazal
What a masterpiece..!! All the versions of this song are amazing..❤❤ original is still unbeatable....!
after qb she did justice to this song💗
Shae has made a wonderful attempt. We also listened to Aima's failed version of kahani suno.
Shae gill is one of my favorite pakistani singer but QB sung this better than anyone in thw entire universe
better than any indian singer
No shae Gill no.. Although u're so much talented but QB's singing is something else... She mesmerised everyone while singing this gem... ❤❤
After QB shae gill nailed this song ❤
Qb is brand. No one will goes on her level of singing 🎶
this is live that was recorded in a studio
Please come to India anytime. Such a sweet voice.😍
no need .. tatti-india
spitt on gandu desh india
Very Empty song without QB Voice. QB's Melodious Voice brings feeling in this song.
She's a gem
Wow... QB & Shae ❤
she looks so beautiful
she looks very elegente.
Queen QB slayed this song
QB The queen Of The singers in THE whole world 💙
This song has my heart.
However; broken.
QB 👑
Fav shae Gill❤️❤️👌👌👌 amazing wowww
Don't forget this is live...
Sound raw ❤ Wonderful
Without QB, this song is nothing
QB ny jo gaya woh masterpiece tha
She's definitely playing it safe. Not reaching any high notes at all. Not sure if its done deliberately. But it didn't work in this particular setup. Could be because its live and even QB won't sound the same if its done live
Agree
True
Q voice so much high Lauder thats y she is better in original but shae also favourite..
everyone talk about qb but no one talk about abida parveen she sing humsafer. she deserve lots but this world cant afford
بہترین... بہت زبردست گایا ہے۔
Sung beautifully 💯
That's not qb's song it's ghazal of the living legend maestro in her self medam abida Parveen sahiba! 🙌🏻❤️
u cant compare this live version with QB's studio version, but QB's voice has more maturity than Shae's voice.
Love shae 💖
This is not a QB but Abida Perveen's ghazal
I want this kinda confidence 😀😀🙌🙌 gaa k pher upload b kerny ka .
Bahut allaaa😊
Excellent 👌
Beautiful voice.
Decent effort but the issue is that QB voice is extremely unique
It is diffucult to do covers of her songs..
Wow😮❤❤❤
QB did it in studio and this is LIVE lot difficult ❤
You can watch her live performances..🙃🤌🏻
QB is best❤
Tumse na ho pay ga. Qb is ❤
is there any studio version of this? she sang very well but there is some audio output issues in middle of her performance.
Gutlu ,you never fail to bless ears.
Shae, u are the besttt
Nobody realized that the filler guitar solo was from Mekaal Hassan's Sampooran. The best and greatest composer and guitar player that Pakistan produced.
You are forgetting the late Amir Zaki
QB jesa koi bhi is song ko perform nahe kr skta
Good effort, 👍
Where she says she sing better than qb people are comparing her for no reason she Have Nice voice
I honestly wish the drummer hadn't overplayed. Such a great performance.
Beautiful ❤❤❤
only QB is best, even on live concert! ❤❤❤
QB❤❤
good live performance
Very Nice
Qb❤
1971 Fall of Dhakka, Naseer Turabi :(
Can anyone tell me who is that guy playing midi keyboard ?
WOW!!
Qb is unmatchable it's considered karaoke practice
QB is best
Better than original ❤
jatti, ya sung goo and well tried jatti.
Shae Gill and Shae in GOT look alike
Why tease such an iconic song of the iconic singer???? Why???
Eyes
It's good but only QB can pull it off the best!
She's wearing Ross's top from F.R.I.E.N.D.S 😅
😂😂
You made me notice this
❤❤❤
❤🎉🎉
guitarist just copy pasted one of Mekaal Hassan riff as a solo at @2:38 :D couldnt blend it with the song though :P
and also the outro :D
ruclips.net/video/Pn8kst0zQXI/видео.html here is the original ...Riff is at 2.17
QB is QB
in mid audio is switched , and also she couldn't keep up the beat. she is good singer. but atleast should try to keep the rhythm of actual song.
Pakistani Dua lipa ❤
she's giving gracie abram vibes
now thats something :D
Acha h new taste h but QB to phir 👑 h
QB
Vocals (Y)
Na na not even close
Gaane ko bekar kar diya aapne Shae.. m big fan of urs Shae.. please don’t do this 🙏
Rush music never compete with qurat ul ain baloch😊
Naa Surr Na tall 🥲🥲😂😂😂
Satyanash
❤✨️🫶🏻
She need Ustad, she is missing notes, i know live performance is difficult where you cannot retake or fix part by part
Pakistani dua lipa
But but dua lipa? No?
She is looking like Dua Lipa
QB is on a different level …
She almost looks like Aybüke Pusat
She could’ve tried to sing Woh Humsafar in her own way, rather than copying QB.
I prefer Shae then qb
Dua Lipa Lite 😂😂😂
Dua Lipa mini
Not better then qurat al ain
both have very different style...no need for comparison
Auto tune vs live stage performance! There is no comparison at all. Having said that, I do like Qurat’s version.
@@yuvrajsingh121 CORRECT!!!
Can't compare with QB