WWII, Deportation Kamp Westerbork in early 1943 in color! [AI enhanced & colorized]
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 13 окт 2024
- Deze film toont trieste beelden van het werkkamp Westerbork tijdens de Tweede Wereldoorlog. Feitelijk was het een doorgangskamp voor Joodse tewerkgestelden naar de concentratiekampen in Duitsland en Polen. De film werd gemaakt in opdracht van kampcommandant Alfred Konrad Gemmeker en gefilmd door de Joodse fotograaf Rudolf Breslauer die helaas de concentratiekampen niet overleefde. Tot de dag van vandaag is de omvang van de rol van Gemmeker controversieel aangezien hij tot zijn dood in 1982 bleef volhouden nooit van de misdaden in de concentratiekampen te hebben geweten. Om die reden kreeg hij in 1945 dan ook een relatief milde straf van 10 jaar gevangenis. De beelden tonen de Joodse tewerkgestelden aan het werk in het kamp en op de momenten waarop zij in goederen wagons op transport worden gezet naar hun laatste bestemming.
Dit is slechts een korte samenvatting van al het beschikbare filmmateriaal waarvan in totaal nog ruim 70 minuten is teruggevonden. De laatste scene van de Duitse soldaat op wacht is pas onlangs boven water gekomen.
De complete, bijna 2 uur durende, door mij gerestaureerde en ingekleurde film is nu beschikbaar!: • De volledige Westerbor... Deze film staat volledig los van de gerestaureerde Z/W film die Beeld En Geluid op 19 mei 2021 naar verluidt gaat uitbrengen.
Noot: Beeld en Geluid en/of een van haar partners is niet betrokken geweest bij de creatie van deze ingekleurde versie. De afgelopen jaren heeft Beeld en Geluid, in samenwerking met Herinneringscentrum Kamp Westerbork, het NIOD en het Joods Cultureel Kwartier en vele experts, gewerkt aan een duurzame restauratie van deze belangrijke film, waarbij het originele materiaal en kleurgebruik wordt gerespecteerd. Deze officiële gerestaureerde film is sinds 19 mei 2021 beschikbaar.
Westerbork was the infamous labour camp in The Netherlands during World War II which in fact was an in between station for Jews to be transported to the concentration camps in Germany and Poland. This film was made at the initiative of camp commander Alfred Konrad Gemmeker by the Jewish photographer Rudolf Breslauer. The latter did not survive the concentration camps.
It shows moving scenes of Jewish labourers at work in the camp and boarding the trains that would take most of them to their destination of death.
To this day the role of commander Gemmeker is controversial in view of the fact that until his death in 1982 he claimed to have had no knowledge of what happened in the concentration camps. Taking this into account, he received a prison sentence of only 10 years.
The most poignent moment in this film is the footage of Settela Steinbach, a Roma girl who was part of a gypsy group, about to be deported. This scene of her face between the almost closed doors of a goods wagon is famous the world-over, but now can be seen for the first time in color. Historians only recently discovered her identity.
This is just a summary of the total of 70 minutes of footage that was found after the war.
The last scene of the German soldier standing guard was only recently discovered.
The original fragments have been motion-stabilized, speed-corrected, enhanced and artificially colorized by means of modern A.I. software.
Note the "double vision" blur that starts around 00:15 was caused by the initial use of a poor quality camera. Later on Gemmeker arranged a better camera.
The full, much longer, nearly 2 hours long film about Westerbork that has been restored and colorized by me, has now been released! • De volledige Westerbor...
FYI: The Dutch Beeld En Geluid archive, who is the guardian of the public domain (Unesco) film, has released their own restored B&W version on the 19th of May 2021.
Music: Philip Ayers - "Together We Rise".
Source: Beeld en Geluid.
![Amazing China in 1917 in color [AI enhanced and colorized]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/_GWa4b7g9qs/mqdefault.jpg)
![(1939) WWII begins: Siege of Warsaw.[4k, 50fps,colorized]](/img/1.gif)
*Attentie: Op 19 mei heeft Beeld en Geluid zelf een prachtige gerestaureerde film over Westerbork uitgebracht. Die film staat los van de door mij gerestaureerde versie die hier wordt getoond* . Op 10 april is door mij ook de gerestaureerde en ingekleurde versie van de volledige, bijna 2 uur durende Westerbork film uitgebracht: ruclips.net/video/ekeBr8-yjXU/видео.html Ook die versie heeft geen verband met voornoemde film van Beeld en Geluid. My full, much longer, nearly 2 hours lasting, restored and colorized film about Westerbork has now been released on the 10th of April! : ruclips.net/video/ekeBr8-yjXU/видео.html
Ah- all the reels are being "enhanced" ... amazing!!!
What we see here is beyond anyone's understanding and experience despite its seeming unconspicuousness.
It is also good to keep in mind that the film maker who shot these scenes was also deported to a death camp shortly after and killed. Most of the people seen here were sent to a death camp and killed as well.
It would be great if the soundtrack could be eye witnesses from Westerbork who would contrast these propaganda scenes with actual experience.
@@omgsolikevalleygirl Thank you very much. The full film will probably be released tomorrow. Currently we are colorizing the last of 10 film fragments (and having to blackout some scenes that a couple of nasty companies have wrongfully claimed as being copyrighted, despite the fact that the film is now Unesco heritage). I am sorry, but I am just a one-man-band so the film will only be accompanied by sad music. I have no possibility to try to find some of the last remaining Westerbork survivors. Most of them are dead by now.
@@Rick88888888 fantastic! Being able to look at this footage is very important - we can't imagine what happened at these camps, and if we can not imagine it, we can not keep it in mind - so someone may say at some point "do you really think it was that bad.. makes no sense" - that is why the eyewitness accounts are so important.
The Shoah Foundation or the Yad Vashem archive have a lot of recorded eye witness accounts.
But just having the footage with "decreased distance" by you enhancement process is really fantastic! Thank you so much!!!
@@omgsolikevalleygirl The full film has been uploaded now: ruclips.net/video/ekeBr8-yjXU/видео.html
Merci
Thank you. We must never forget.
So what were the building plans?
We already forgot in 1948 as the zion..zi started the same excersize in palestine
Palestine
In kleur zijn de beelden nog meer confronterend. Vooral die sterren raakten me. Omdat het woord Jood zo goed te lezen is door de verscherping van het beeld. Dank voor deze bewerking Rick.
according to Franz Suchomel, one of the deporation trains such as the ones seen departing from Westerbork here could carry up to 2000 people to an extermination camp. That is more than died during the sinking of the Titanic. Innocent people, families, children... people just like you and me.
This has shocked me more than anything I have seen on this subject. Thank you.
you obviously haven't seen "Come and See"
This may not be the type of content you do, but it is the type of content you/we NEED TO DO. We can't let anyone forget these moments, and may god bless you for doing this and for god giving you the time and talent to essentially recreate parts of our history that we need to remember and pass down for generations to come. Maybe not pretty or the most exciting, these are the stories that MUST BE TOLD no matter what, if not, they will fade and be forgotten. Again, your channel is beyond, and I thank you so much for this, I look forward to more.
Thank you very much. I was hesitant to upload this video here. An alternative would have been this new "World War II Colorized" channel: ruclips.net/channel/UCkOR3skX3wLCDOruw5a7wzg
To see the expressions on the faces of people who don't know what is about to happen. To know it has not happened yet, but is going to happen.
Thank you for putting on this colorized segment from the Westerbork film. The full version can also be seen on RUclips, in black and white. I think the full version should be colorized as well. This is among the most important surviving Holocaust footage that survived the war, as evidence of the crimes of the Nazis.
*This is not the kind of material that I usually place on this channel* . In view of the fact that it is of huge historic importance I decided to make an exception. *Kindly refrain from potentially inflamable comments* and just reflect on the sad fate of these victims of WWII.
*Graag geen potentieel ontvlambare discussies ontketenen* en laat slechts het trieste lot van deze oorlogsslachtoffers op je inwerken.
Veel meer boeiende informatie over deze film lees je hier: www.beeldengeluid.nl/verhalen/de-westerborkfilm-een-beeld-om-nooit-te-vergeten
*Please read as much as you can before blindly commenting on this film! So far there are far too many ignorent and poorly informed comments* .
Thank you very much for posting this one. It really brought it home that most of the people you see in this movie would be murdered within a few years.
Goed gezegd!
@@tderoo71 Probably immediately after the footage was shot.
@@tommoncrieff1154 Maybe with the odd exception, there were no killings at Westerbork which served as a kind of a "halfway station". The killings happened after these forced labourers were deported to Germany and Poland.
Although every single one of your restored movies are priceless, this kind of material is of extreme importance. I sure hope you can and will post more of the discovered material from Rudolf Breslauer. Thank you again for your great work.
We must never be allowed to forget this time in history. The shame of those who perpetrated these crimes will last for ever more
It is happening again, now. It has begun. Klaus Shwab will ensure that the unvaxxed meet a similar fate
Yep and they last every day in palestine and are committed by the zion..zi
Incredible...it looks like it's just yesterday.
Thats what makes it so terrifying & heartbreaking
Rick , door deze herstelde films komt alles tot LEVEN , en spreekt het beeld voor zich ... onvoorstelbaar wat er is gebeurd in WW2 ....
En ? NOG !!!!!.
All happening again. Camps in Germany and other countries for antivaccers
I was there 3 days ago. We must never ever forget.
Hier hoef je geen woorden meer aan vuil te maken. Deze beelden vertellen het verhaal zelf.
Respect voor je werk. Elke keer weer fantastisch. Soms dramatisch, soms vrolijk, maar elke keer prachtig.
Dank je wel!
My late father's Canadian Regiment liberated the Westerbork Camp. The South Saskatchewan Regiment. He was the Regiment's Anti-Tank Artillery company Captain, and was wounded by a sniper after crossing the Schipbeek Canal 5 days before the liberation. His comrade Captain Cecil Law of the mortar company wrote a book about the liberation.
I still own a uniform from the South Saskatchewan Regiment (I live in the Netherlands)
@@usmcn Do you mind sharing how you got it ? Is there any story attached to it ? Thank you for posting.
I bought it on a garage sale. Since i have relatives in sask I thought it be Nice to own. The seller couldn't tell me anything about it sadly.
So many didn't have any idea what a horrifying fate awaited them. We must never forget what evil deeds so-called civilized people are willing to inflict on others.
Never ever again. Nie wieder!! We are still here....
Being in colour makes this remarkable film even more important as a reminder to what cruelty man kind can force on others. Thank you for the work you did to restore this film .
The film is so sad and difficult to watch.
Thank you for sharing this with us!
Remamber !.
German language always give me goosebumps and stress.
My father was prisoner of war and survived 2.7 years in concentration camp.🙏
sounds like you should go to a therapeut
Elena, I am german and I understand you very well. 🌹
@@franz6448 Are you aware that there were a lot Jews who themselves spoke nothing else but german, or for whom german was their mother tongue? You make a weird distinction in which german is the Nazi language. In reverse it would mean that german is therefore something "artfremd" to Jews today, just exactly the Nazis claimed once.
The reasons why german gives her goose bumps is obviously because she encountered the language only in a holocaust context and by Hitler speeches from documentaries, which is a sad development.
It must have been a very bad concentration camp then.
Colour brings to life what happened in detail
Het meisje met de hoofdoek die door de halfopenstaande treindeur kijkt heet Settela en was een roma of Sinti meisje. Iemand uit Nederland schreef een boek over haar verhaal
Aangrijpend
Fascinating footage. I've studied WW2 formally and informally since I was a kid and I still don't think that events have totally sunk in.
I'm 62. I saw The World At War when I was a teenager and I'm still a ww2 buff. I'm still learning new things. Lately, I'm learning about spies.
Heartbreaking to see.
Best heftig, met de kennis van nu. Bedankt Rick!
Visited kamp Westerbork today. So sad to be there and realize what happened. Even more sad the world didn't learn from this.
Heartbreaking.
Not really
Bravely done Rick. And necessary.
bijna te relaxed in kleur ,maar t voelt zoveel dichterbij nu..maar een oorlog kan soms dichterbij zijn dan je zelf vermoed..zie alle conflicten om ons heen..teveel uitdagingen die op ons afkomen!!bless the days in peace!!
Impressive.... even more then we already knew..... lessons to be learned.... days to be remembered
there is nothing learned,still happends(like in China)
True ?.
At 2:41 I was surprised how easy it was for the man to pick up the barrel. Clearly it is empty. And I do recall from survivors that they had one small container as a toilet per packed railroad cattle car for the multi-day journey to the camps. Men and women together. They were stripped of dignity before they were stripped of life. Just so sad.
These people had no idea what awaited them at the end of that train ride.
This is devastating to watch.
The color makes it look more real. As if it was taken yesterday. Black and white tends to make footage look ancient and so far into the past when in reality this was only 77 years ago. Its not ancient history. A tregedy like this can definitely happen again if humanity doesn't remember.
Exactly. It’s very recent history. We tend to view events that took place before we were born as so distant and far in the past.
Immediately brought to mind Trains of No Return by Ofra Haza
What's so shocking is that these beautifully attired people look like there going on holiday,which is what the feeling the Nazis wanted so to make deportation easier..the camp had, hairdressers,restraunts and more to make those sent there comfortable with the process, absolutely disgusting..... Anne Frank was sent to this internment camp,but another woman who was famous at the time sent there was (Dora gerson)her first husband who she divorced in 1924 after 2years filmed a anti Semitic film in 1940 on the orders of Goebbels..the other thing is that she did 2 films with a certain Hungarian actor ( Bela Lugosi)called on the brink of paradise+ caravan of death..and the sad thing is that she died on the 14th February 1943 (st valentine's Day)a celebration of your love for somebody)also this resonated with me because my mother was born on Saint valentine's Day 1942 in Liverpool, Britain,just a year before...also really sad to think just over the English channel or North sea probably less than 50 miles from the interment camp would of been freedom in Britain... nearly 97,000 innocent people,women old young and children were sent to there deaths in autswich and sobibor..🙏...never forgotten...
The things you can do with the latest up-to-date tech to put more 'life' from the original footage really is impressive. I did wonder if you was going to project your work to Wartime footage at some point. Its sad to see but can be used to educate the todays and the future generation to come with past historic importance. Thank you for sharing and a very interesting read up.
I am very careful with WWII footage. A lot is still copyrighted. At present my channel is free from any copyrighted material (apart from New York in 1937). There is a new channel that will deal with colorized WWII material: ruclips.net/channel/UCkOR3skX3wLCDOruw5a7wzg
Here is Pearl Harbor in color: ruclips.net/video/qZUpXZ7aDaY/видео.html
@@Rick88888888 Thank you for the reply, I had thought much footage was still under copyright. I have now subscribed to your latest channel. I forgot to say the music in your videos really brings the hairs of my neck to stand. Keep up the great work.
It's so sad to see all these people who don't know what will happen to them.
this is the beginning of the deportation, when they still didn't know they were going to be in these wagons for days without food, only made to take this trip to be killed in a gas chamber or worked to death.
Some of them are carrying an innocent smile on their faces not knowing what they are expecting there :(
Страшно смотреть, как люди это пережили. А другие люди считали,что делают все правильно. Это ужасно!
Почитайте Евгению Гинзбург Крутой маршрут ,там тоже самое делалось и люди на все это смотрели равнодушно
Сейчас хотят также создать концлагерь,только страшнее, планетарный
@@skandinavkakz5246 *вы этот бред больше никому не рассказывайте.*
@Я Soul *и к чему это было?*
@Я Soul *не,неинтересно.*
This is evil in color!
How could any human being, treat another in this manner!
NEVER AGAIN!
It's about to happen again... Most just don't see it and go for their shower in the form of a "vaccin"
Ongelofelijk dat dit zich ooit heeft voorgedaan. Prachtig document en weer mooi gepresenteerd.
@Franco. Een jaar geleden zou ik dit inderdaad ongelofelijk hebben genoemd. Nu kan ik het me prima voorstellen. Als ik ‘s avonds nog even een rondje loop, wat ik al een paar jaar doe, kom ik niemand meer tegen. 🤔
@@nicokremers7150 ga je schamen Nico, huilebalk. Ben jij nou een vent? Wat zou je moeder hiervan zeggen?
0:27 This girl looked so afraid and probably knew that she would be murdered like million others who have been murdered as part of the Final solution. Her name was:
*Settela Steinbach* Born on 23-12-1934 Bocht, Holland. Died on 31-07-1944 KZ Aushwitz, Poland.
On May 16th 1944 she was arrested in Eindhoven with other Jewish family’s during a razzia and got deported to durchgangslager Westerbork. On May 19th she was deported again to Auschwitz-Birkenau as destination. Before the doors were closed, she was looking to a dog passing by before a SS camp guard closed the cargo car door.
That moment was captured by the Jewish-German photographer: Rudolf Breslauer.
(*died on February 28th 1945 in Auschwitz, only his daughter Ursula Breslauer survived the war.*)
On May 21th 1944 she arrived at KZ Auschwitz-Birkenau with her family and were registered and sended to a section for Roma’s. In summer 1944 when a train arrived from Hungary with more than half a million Jews, a arose broke out in the Roma barrack section which resulted in an uprising, this was quashed by the SS camp guards and Roma’s who were considered fit during health inspections by SS doctors, were deported to Germany for forced labour in the German weapon industry.
In the period of August 3, 1944, the remaining 3,000 Jews of the Roma section were gassed. Settela, her mother, two brothers, two sisters, two nephews, a niece and her aunt belonged to this group, so her date of death when she was gassed is still unknown to this day. of the entire Steinbach family, only the father survived.
Due to the great loss, he died of Grief in 1946, two years after his entire family was gassed and murdered in Auschwitz-Birkenau, Poland.
- One like is one pray for every single murdered victim of the Holocaust -
We must stop Holocaust-deniers and neo-Nazi’s!
it is so great to know the name and circumstances of these victims - how was this found out, do you know? I wish the story of each of the millions of victims could be told.
very nice work with the restoration, it really look so good and refreshed, thanks :)
Thank you very much!
It´s so sad to view this!! so sad!
There's nothing wrong by showing this. This is the truth and needs to be shown to the young population of the world of the horrors of WW2 and the Nazi's. God Bless from the USA!.
You are absolutely right, the footage should be shown.
I’m grateful for this footage.
My grandmother was detained at Westerbork until its liberation. The rest of her family (née Swaap) was deported then executed at Auschwitz. We are unclear how or why she was separated from her parents and siblings, we only know she’s the lone survivor of her immediate family.
In all probability, I would never have been born had my grandmother been deported to Auschwitz, too.
Thank you for sharing this footage.
My deepest condolences and prayers to all of those affected by the Holocaust, especially the victims and the families of the victims.
Sent shivers down my spine seeing the german officers in their uniforms what did those poor people go through is beyond my imagination
Un verdadero campo de trabajo. La verdad ante nosotros. Excelente video !!
Nu ik deze beelden zoveel scherper en op de juiste snelheid zie, maken ze nog meer indruk dan ze al deden in mindere kwaliteit. Het toevoegen van kleur hoeft van mij persoonlijk niet. Dank voor het delen.
Adding color only makes this footage all the more gruesome and difficult to watch.
It makes it real of which sadly it was!!.
Humans pffft.
Destroy everything x
This is the camp that Anne Frank and her family and friends were sent to in August 1944 and from where they were sent to Auschwitz on the last transport to leave Holland on Sunday 3rd. September. To see this place as she saw it, is very poignant.
Merci Richard pour cette précision.
Bergen belsen not Auschwitz
@@pastro9277 Anne Frank and her family were sent to Auschwitz from Westerbork in September 1944. In October she and her sister along with Mrs. Van Pels were sent from Auschwitz to Bergen Belsen where the two sisters died in the early spring of 1945 during the typhus epidemic that had spread through the camp.
I feel like these images could be footage produced for Nazi propaganda - the seeming innocuousness and relaxed atmosphere at the trains and in the factories seems so unreal given what we know happened to these people later on: most of them, also the women and children seen here, were killed or died from the abuse.
It would be good to cross-check with eyewitness reports of people who were to Westerbork at this time. It may have been a lot more abusive than it appears here. Or it could be that these people were indeed still clueless about what was about to happen to them.
@@richardhumphreys8662 why thete famíly not stay in Auschwitz?
De acht onderduikers uit het Achterhuis waren ook hier in augustus 1944. 💔
Thank you very much Rick.
I was born after the WOII but watching this video makes me sad.
Visiting Auschwitz and Birkenau a couple a years ago I realized what happened in those days and
many innocent people were murdered in those camps and you felt the atmosphere of the past.
Thank you for showing this too Rick and also remembering the song of Bob Dylan "With God on our side"
Rick bedankt en dit mogen we natuurlijk nooit vergeten
I think this is so sad seeing this poor people
Als ik naar mijn ouders ga in Drenthe dan rij ik vaak het spoor over en dan gaan mijn gedachten vaak terug naar hoeveel mensen over het spoor zijn gedeporteerd.
Ik woon vlakbij het rangeer station Muiderpoort, deze was toen speciaal gebouwd...verderop zitten kogelgaten in de oude muur.
I gave a like. For showing this again to the world. I hope humanity will face the fact that humans can be monsters and that we have to deal with that fact and not just judge people that were on the wrong place at the wrong time.
Indrukwekkende en tegelijk verschrikkelijke beelden. Bizarre tijden.
Dit is voor mij te pijnlijk om naar te kijken.
Blijf sterk !.
@@egongefferie9194 denk dat Cornelis bedoeld dat hij er verdrietig van wordt, terecht.
Meteen dat vingertje.. jammer.
Op minuut 2.09 worden de laatste afscheidsbrieven uit de trein gegooid.
Nooit opgevallen ! Thx !
2:09
De eerste beelden die ik van dit kamp in werking heb kunnen vinden. Zeker van historische waarde.
Way different in colour❤️
Ik heb de funderingen van de oude barakken ooit gezien aldaar. De tranen springen in je ogen. Als je nu er doorheen loopt, blijf dan eens stil staan, doe je ogen dicht en luister. Je begint spontaan te huilen. Heb het zelf ervaren. Gr
This video is heartbreaking to watch. Unlike a scene from a film that was set during the Holocaust but made in modern times, you know that the people in it weren't actors who got to go to their comfortable homes at the end of the day, but real people whose fates hung in the balance. Many of the prisoners seen in this video very likely died in the concentration camps that they eventually wound up in. Anne Frank and the seven other people in hiding with her spent two months at this camp before being put on the last train to Auschwitz; only her father would survive the war. Westerbork, which mainly functioned as a holding area for Jews being transported elsewhere, was almost a resort compared to the other horrific camps that these unfortunate prisoners would be sent to. The facilities were primitive, but at least the prisoners got to wear their normal clothes and have hair, get medical care if they needed it, have social activities to some degree, and live a relatively normal life within prison walls. Sadly, most of the prisoners spent maybe two or three months here at the most, before experiencing a living nightmare at camps like Auschwitz, or gassed upon arrival at places like Sobibor and Treblinka. This is all so tragic beyond imagination!
What about Sachsenhausen.
@@pereiraplaza222
ALL the Nazi camps were terrible places. Some were less brutal than others, but none of them were pleasant places, by any means!
@@JoMarieM I visited Sachsenhausen in 2016.
Very strange and sureal how civilised things appeared, and to think today history repeats.
Sadly it's happening here.
Orange Goblin Bosnia 1995, Rwanda 1998, China present day.
Mooie beelden Rick... opdat wij nooit vergeten!!!
het werk wat je doet met inkleuring van zwart wit films is fantastisch, wat we vandaag zien is de bittere waarheid wat toen is gebeurt, hebben we er wat uit geleerd is de vraag die mening mens zichzelf stelt als je deze echte beelden ziet, dit zou nooit meer mogen gebeuren, helaas komt onderdrukking van diverse bevolkingsgroepen nog steeds voor overal in deze wereld
@@NobbyStilestheToothlessTiger gast leer eerst schrijven voor je commentaar geeft
Het komt veel dichterbij wanneer je het zo in kleur ziet. Bizar om te zien dat veel mensen nog gewoon aan het lachen waren, en zelfs lachend de trein in stapten. Niet wetende wat er met hun ging gebeuren… Vreselijk
The terrible thing is that we are taking the first steps along the same road again. Different perpetrators different victims.
I can’t tell who the targets are though ...
lol
Although it breaks my heart to see this video, I feel that younger generations should know what really happened during the second world war so that it is never repeated. Thanks again for your work on these videos.
So what about the 30 million murdered in the 1920s & 1930s in the USSR ? What about the 60-100 million victims of Communism in China (and the 1 million in re-education camps today)? How about N. Korea ? Pol Pot's Cambodia? Why do you think that the "younger generations" should know about just WW2 when similar horrors are continuing today under Communist regimes and in Islamic nations ?
Instead of watching RUclips videos about WW2 crimes, perhaps you should be screaming about the labor & re-education camps in China & N. Korea.
@@Baskerville22 I feel the same way about all of those situations. I was just making a point concerning this specific video.
@@Baskerville22 Sorry if you thought I was screaming.
@Jake Johansson "Numbers are not decisive" ??
The murder of 30 million by Lenin/Stalin not so bad as the murder of 6 million by Hitler ?
The killing - by man-made famine (the Great Leap Forward) and the murder of 60 million + in Mao's China during The Cultural Revolution....not so bad as Hitler killing 6 million ??? Perhaps you put those millions in your "times of struggle" category ?
Your bizarre and monstrous calculus marks you as every bit as cold-blooded as those who perpetrate these genocides.
@Jake Johansson So you think that Stalin and his NKVD murdering 7 - 10 million Ukrainians in order to enforce 'collectivisation' in the 1930s was a "good reason" ? Try Googling "Holodomor".
And in Communist China, no "cold-blooded" genocide there ?
Toevallig brachten mijn vriendin en ik op 24 februari een bezoek aan dit kamp. Extra indrukwekkend om nu de (ingekleurde) beelden te zien.
Emotionele beelden in deze film.
It would be interesting to check if these officers were punished after the war. I think most likely not...
Mooi werk met kleur! Wordt er stil van! 😪
Страшное время, но посмотрите какое небо, нежно голубое и ни облачка
heartbreaking but needs to be seen
Een zwarte bladzijde in de geschiedenis. Dit alstublieft nooit en nooit meer. Maar de praktijk is weerbarstig. Nog steeds veel onrecht in deze wereld......
@@egongefferie9194 idd.
Eerst zwart-wit, nu in kleur en zodadelijk weer in functie.
We leren NIETS !!
Hannah Arendt schreef er al over.
@ wat een walgelijke vergelijking trek je hier. Mag jij zonder begeleiding de straat op?
This is such a sad and terrible period in history. I hope these poor victims are at peace.
😭😭😭😭😭💐From Greece🇬🇷
Heart breaking 😑😣
The discription is in English also just keep scrolling down. Andy England 🇬🇧
Memory eternal.
Let's never forget!
0:43 kinda eerie to think those men on the train likely went to their deaths in the gas chambers of birkenau
well a lot of people going east bound those days never came back the eastern front was the real hell
all horrific terror rape and mayhem you can think of also stealth death and death by starvation kannibalism
triple genocide
shocking.... all have been lied to be “relocated” to the East
and how many of them survived ?
no one ?
3 % ?
😭😭😭
3% of the world???? wow...I did not know that
Thank you
"Most of the approximately 100,000 Jews sent to Westerbork perished. Between July 1942 and September 1944 almost every Tuesday a train left for Auschwitz-Birkenau and Sobibor extermination camps, or Bergen-Belsen and Theresienstadt, in a total of 94 outgoing trains."
FURCHTBAR! DANKE FÜRS EINSTELLEN !
Very interesting historical video. Thanks for sharing. I must say though, I've never seen a comment section with so many people talking out of their rear ends. The virtue signalling...dear Lord. So many "historians", and never before seen "facts". This seems to be one subject where just saying something in a dramatic way makes it so. Platitudes abound!
It says a lot about the quality of the history lessons that todays youth get. I often shield my eyes when reading the comments section. You haven't even seen the worst of them, including Holocaust-deniers who I don't give a platform on my channel.
@@Rick88888888 I get exextremely upset about the holocaust deniers and white supremacist nazi's. My grandparents home in Norway was occupied by German officers during the occupation. My mother slapped my face in a store when I was 7 years old for saying what a jew,about the price of the item she was buying. Of course I didn't know what I was saying, had heard others say it. We must never allow these people who claim to be nazi's a platform to spew their hatred.
Harald Lief Christiansen 🇧🇻🇺🇸
Hello back rick...thx for your message...fascinating history notes description ...if this film was not intended for nazi propaganda reasons , do you perhaps know what it was intended for? So many details and further questions surface in this short film.i wonder how they identified the girl in train ...we can finally see who she is in color..rest their souls
Thanks again
You might want to visit the Dutch weblink in the description and translate that page with Google.
Camp commander Gemmeker maybe made this film to try and clear his name after the war by showing that there were no attrocities in his camp. We will never know his exact motives. After the war he denied having had any knowlegde of what happened to the people after they were transported on to Germany.
His innocence is his guilt
I find this incredibly heartbreaking, knowing what happened to so many of these people. You can see on their faces they had no idea what was in store for them. The Nazis were fkn cowards.
prachtig geremasterde beelden, met kleur spreekt het veel meer aan dan zwart wit. bizzar eigenlijk.
This is some nice AI work, on some very sad images.
The adult waving at the kid got to me...so many trains went from Westerbork to sobibor..straight to death. It hurts to watch but we must..
Indeed, that is a very tragic scene.
Wenn ich diese Kreaturen {ich kann sie nicht Menschen nennen} in ihren Uniformen sehe, wird mir schlecht. Diese Überheblichkeit, Gefühlskälte ihren wehrlosen Opfern gegenüber, kann ich nicht begreifen. Man schämt sich das es so etwas gab. Unbegreiflich.
Totgeschlagen, totgeschwiegen! Den allen Opfern des Nationalsozialismus.
Weing van geleerd helaas
This could have been the UK had it not been for 'The Few' in 1940. What is owed to the RAF fighter pilots - of many nationalities not just British - is immeasurable.
God bless Britain.
wake up, im-be-cile
Settella Steinbach à 0'25...Je songe toujours aux " Lettres de Westerbork" de ma chère Etty Hillesum en visionnant ces terribles images, ainsi qu'au frère de mon grand-père, Georges (1906-1968), débarqué sur la rampe de Birkenau le 30 avril 1944, deux semaines avant Settela...Convoi parti de Compiègne -Royallieu le 27 avril précédent... Curieusement l' ambiance générale de ce film est très différente des films tournés en Pologne où les Juifs tirés des ghettos apparaissent épuisés, humiliés, terrorisés : l'ambiance de violence (davantage masquée ici) y est vraiment palpable... image terrible à 2.30 cependant...
In Ukraine, in its capital, a march was held in honor of the SS division, and everyone is silent.
silence is because western countries need these nazis to fight Russians.....history repeating :(
I didn't know about this but I do now. Im going to search and see if I can find more about this.
Kan niet vaak genoeg getoond worden. Inmiddels zijn er mensen die dit soort praktijken alweer een goed idee lijkt in opmars. Geschiedenisonderwijs moet meer en beter!
daar sluit ik me bij aan hoe kunnen we nu van onze jeugd verwachten dat ze dit nooit weer laten gebeuren als we hun niks leren van het verleden
Helemaal mee eens! Zie bijvoorbeeld de ondoordachte opmerking van Ackerley Trade
hierboven. En zo zijn er meer. De ergste heb ik weggehaald. Jongelui hebben vaak geen idee van wat zich tijdens WOII allemaal heeft afgespeeld.
Mensen die nog steeds zo denken hebben nog niet genoeg van deze beelden gezien. Niks ervan geleerd. Mooi dat deze beelden ingekleurd en verbeterd zijn, waarvoor dank. Het geeft een veel realistischer kijk op wat er toen gebeurde. De broer van mijn grootmoeder heeft 5 kampen overleefd. Hij heeft veel geluk gehad. De echtgenoot van mijn grootmoeder heeft nooit in een kamp gezeten maar werd in ons dorp geëxecuteerd samen met 2 anderen omdat waarschijnlijk verzetsleden of sympathisanten "iets" geprobeerd hadden tegen terugtrekkende Nazi's.
@@Rick88888888 Wat me ook stuit is dat mensen onze huidige situatie met deze beelden vergelijken, dus betreft de avondklok ( voor onze gezondheidszorg) Dat is ook weerzinwekkend!🤔
@@LindaEll89 Beste Linda, kun je echt niet zien dat we belazerd worden? Die hele pandemie is een grote corrupte zooi. Kun je echt niet zien dat het gewoon een poppenkast is, een "spel"? Denk je echt dat gezonde mensen een killer virus over kunnen dragen, zonder zelf iets te merken? Denk je echt dat de overheid zoveel om ons geeft dat ze miljarden uitgeven voor onze gezondheid en bereid zijn om de samenleving en de economie te slopen? Nee, het is een plan 'The Great Reset' van het wef, of Agenda 2030 van de UN (komt op hetzelfde neer).
Omg, these people don't even know what's going 2 happen. There body language. Netflix "5 came back" shocked me I will never be the same.
I guess once saw those wagons overcramming many began to perceive a much worse destiny was dwelling upon them.