Plasma Cutting AR500 Plate vs. Water Jet or Laser Facts may surprise you

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 16 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 82

  • @sethhughes2163
    @sethhughes2163 11 месяцев назад +1

    Solid info my friend! KUDO'S for you sharing info with the masses! Respectfully, Seth

  • @M3rVsT4H
    @M3rVsT4H 7 лет назад +1

    My mind was blown for a moment that you even can plasma cut in water. But it makes perfect sense . Nice setup you have there.

    • @DesertFabworks
      @DesertFabworks  7 лет назад

      thank you

    • @M3rVsT4H
      @M3rVsT4H 3 года назад

      @Kairo Quinn wOw, and you both joined RUclips within the last 30 days. What an amazing coincidence and not at all scammy.

  • @nglanister
    @nglanister 8 лет назад +6

    I used to program and run water jets and that is actually a lower temperature then what a water jet would run at. Cutting parts with friction using water and sand makes a LOT of heat. After cutting a sheet of parts the pool would be around 130 degrees or more and the part would be even hotter then that. After they got a large water cooler to cool the water in the pool it dropped the temperature of the pool down to 60 degrees but still it makes more heat then people think it does, especially with thicker harder objects.

    • @DesertFabworks
      @DesertFabworks  8 лет назад +1

      Thanks for the feedback good to know info!

    • @rolandocrisostomo2003
      @rolandocrisostomo2003 5 лет назад

      I used to run an FLOW water jet and it's hot towards the end of the day. Usually 110-135 degrees. The water jet is better if you are cutting thick material or if you are cutting different kinds of materials.

  • @waynegarner1202
    @waynegarner1202 7 лет назад +2

    yes and no. the plasma arc is over 25,000 degrees and does in fact heat the kerf as it cuts just because you quench it quickly doesn't mean that you don't have a heat effected zone. try running a drill bit through a mild steel hole that has been plasma cut and tell me that it wasn't hardened. you just not heating the whole plate but the edges of the plate is most definitely harder and thus more brittle than if you water jet cut them. temperature tests mean nothing do a Rockwell hardness test on your edges if you want to know the truth about how you effect the steel.

  • @turbochevelle5641
    @turbochevelle5641 8 лет назад +8

    Plasma has its place, just like the others. One note though, plasma limits you usage to one media where waterjet for instance lets you cut anything you want with the exception of tempered glass.

    • @greggreen9414
      @greggreen9414 6 лет назад

      is it Media or medium? god i hope i aint been saying medium this whole time wrong.

    • @MisterRorschach90
      @MisterRorschach90 6 лет назад

      pretty sure it is medium.

    • @MisterRorschach90
      @MisterRorschach90 6 лет назад +2

      and its completely obvious that these people work exclusively with metals. if they were cutting other materials they would use different tools and machines.

  • @atomicbill
    @atomicbill 9 месяцев назад

    I have repaired over 20,000 welding machines and plasma cutters!
    Also operated 5 nuclear reactors.

  • @garybrown9719
    @garybrown9719 Год назад +1

    On thick plate not submerged in water you would think less heat with the plasma
    Not so more worepage with plasma

  • @MisterRorschach90
    @MisterRorschach90 6 лет назад +1

    i am very glad i watched this video. i have been wondering how i was going to shape the ar500 plates i have in the garage without a waterjet or some crazy diamond or cbn saw. i always wondered if precise plasma or laser cutting of ar500 would actually work without destryoing the steel. i still would like to see controlled ballistic tests however.

    • @DesertFabworks
      @DesertFabworks  6 лет назад

      jordan secrist - I never had a chance to do any scientific testing but my targets are in use at 3 commercial ranges two police academies and hundreds a personal sales as well as my own range and never had any problems or complaints so there were no need to do any scientific testing. I have seen edge damage on plasma, water jet and laser with a bullet strike so in my non scientific opinion it really does not matter

  • @scottburrous2375
    @scottburrous2375 7 лет назад +2

    The HAZ (Heat Affected Zone) can be measured in thousandths to large fractions of an inch depending on cut process, metal thickness, rate of travel and time. There's no way to get around it, it can only be minimized. Using a hacksaw wouldn't give you an HAZ but it's boring. The major component you are (almost) eliminating is warping of the material being cut. I'm sure you can measure it in microns but I doubt you're looking for that degree of flatness.
    I've flame cut AR500 then conventionally milled milled it to make it look professional and it did BAD things to my bits while making the blank round or square but once thru the HAZ it milled just fine.
    Oh, by the way, I got my metallurgy thru a multi year welding apprenticeship program where I welded on nuclear, pressure vessels and structural. My tests were X-rayed as well as destructively tested and improperly tempered welds (bead placement, HAZ) would fail the destructive test by either breaking or the metal would form lesions in or around the HAZ welded portion of the test coupon.

  • @chrisscottwatson
    @chrisscottwatson 7 лет назад +1

    You are going to hear heat effected zone, which is the zone effected by the heat... haha nice.

    • @DesertFabworks
      @DesertFabworks  7 лет назад

      Strange how that works, Still get a lot of questions on that. Even though its really basic.

  • @richardfoulkes8436
    @richardfoulkes8436 6 лет назад +3

    What was that measuring metal out in the sun supposed to prove? That made no sense. The middle of the plate isn't going to have a HAZ, its right at the cut. To know how thick your HAZ is you need to polish the surface, etch it and look at the crystal structure under a microscope. I agree that Plasma's probably the way to go for this application. a temp gun isn't going to tell you how thick it is.

    • @anthonymoschella859
      @anthonymoschella859 4 года назад

      He was just saying your plate will not "go bad" sittin in the sun where it reaches higher temps than his cutting method

    • @dakotareid1566
      @dakotareid1566 2 года назад

      @@anthonymoschella859the plate doesn’t heat up during cutting only the edges do that’s why it made no sense

  • @ajax8m
    @ajax8m 8 лет назад +2

    Just use plan water with nickle blocks in the water bath it's cheap and it works

  • @AaronCook83
    @AaronCook83 8 лет назад

    I wonder how hot these plates get set up in the sun and absorbing bullet impacts.

  • @ankushsachdeva3791
    @ankushsachdeva3791 4 года назад

    Can i cut 33mm deep hchcr d3 steel annealed with plasma,laser or water jet cutter?
    Which can do the job ????? Please guide me.

  • @billmeyers9584
    @billmeyers9584 3 года назад +1

    Hey there, thanks for the video. I run Mach 3 on my CNC plasma table and I'm thinking about cutting out some of my own plates for Target practice. What amps are you using? I see you are using 65 amps at 45 in per minute. Also did you have any angled cuts with your machine? What plasmacutterr we're using?

  • @AztecWarrior69_69
    @AztecWarrior69_69 6 лет назад +1

    Showing that the heat of the sun is more than cutting with your setup doesn't prove that the metal isn't changed. That's idiotic. All that proves is that the temp is lower. All it can really show is that at the metal would be more brittle at the point where it gets cut. Why? Because in the sun the metal will get heated from the outter surface inward and cooled at about the same rate. Keeping its integrity better than a super heated very localized area.

  • @nickanderkay7148
    @nickanderkay7148 5 лет назад +1

    I doubt the heat of the whole plate is what people are talking about. Its the 1000+degrees that the edge is taking as its being cut. Cutting under water would make it even worse on hard materials your essentially quenching the edge as it cuts. Do that with 4140 or something hardenable and is guess you could make a nice knife out of the edge lol. I wouldnt worry about the plate for shooting tho just thought this was a pretty dumb video as far as breaking any myths goes. Cool plasma tho i stumbled on this looking for a home use plasma table

    • @christophegroulx8187
      @christophegroulx8187 4 года назад +1

      Ur dumb, cutting with water is the least stressful for the material

    • @dakotareid1566
      @dakotareid1566 2 года назад

      @@christophegroulx8187re read the comment and watch the video, he’s referring to plasma cutting under water

  • @aj7utu
    @aj7utu 7 лет назад +1

    Water has very low thermal conductivity and has little effect on the heat affected zone, which is determined by the plasma settings necessary for an acceptable cut, and to some degree, by the thermal diffusivity of the metal itself, which is much higher than the water. The water merely protects the operator, shield the UV to some extent, and acts as a reservoir to cool the plate, perhaps slightly faster than if it were sitting in air. The water also differs from air in its chemical reaction properties with the plasma cut plate.

  • @mikelemon5109
    @mikelemon5109 7 лет назад +2

    How much would a relatively simple part with about 5 holes of 55x100mm 14mm thick part cost approximately at yours?

    • @DesertFabworks
      @DesertFabworks  7 лет назад

      Michael email us at sales@desertfabworks.com with the specs your looking for and we will get you a quote. Thank you

    • @mikelemon5109
      @mikelemon5109 7 лет назад

      I was asking for an approximation... do you atleast have some example part price quote?

    • @DesertFabworks
      @DesertFabworks  7 лет назад

      Sounds like you are in Europe closest to 14 mm here in the US is .5 inches. It would be about $3.60 US

    • @mikelemon5109
      @mikelemon5109 7 лет назад

      Huh great what about shipping and do you also do welding and bending?

    • @DesertFabworks
      @DesertFabworks  7 лет назад +1

      Please refer to our website www.desertfabworks.com for what we can do as far as services and we can not talk about shipping until we know what we are shipping and to where. Please use the contact form on the website Thank you,

  • @brizzell2101
    @brizzell2101 7 лет назад +1

    Interesting facts here. Who makes this stuff and Id love to here their video response of this video. Would you do a SIDE hit video on a plate such as this? Im looking for some how to vids on welding this stuff to if you know of any

    • @DesertFabworks
      @DesertFabworks  7 лет назад

      Hello BriZZell, When you say who makes this stuff do you mean the targets? Or who makes the steel? We make the targets from steel that is sourced from US foundries. AR500 steel is a common grade of steel and is available from steel suppliers across the US. As far as a side hit video Its tough to hit the edge accurately at distance. I can try going out to the ranges that use our targets and take pictures of plates that have been in use or months and years for comparison. As far as welding AR500 plate its possible but not recommended. The heat from welding will definitely affect the hardness and in targets its best to avoid welds because of the impacts you will useally see cracks or failures along the welds or in the HAZ of the weld. We try to design all of our target systems without any welds on the AR500 plate.

    • @brizzell2101
      @brizzell2101 7 лет назад +1

      Who makes AR500?.. is what I meant.
      I'm looking to make a structure that is bullet proof - but saying that is so not good nuff. What we think of when someone sez bullet proof is not the reality. First off the structure is not disposable and will be needed after gunfire not replaced. bullet proof in this case means handling one or two clips from a few AK47's. non absorption of the rounds is a good thing which is unheard of elsewhere.
      I SAID CLIPS! BITE ME! lol

    • @DesertFabworks
      @DesertFabworks  7 лет назад

      You can get AR500 from nearly any metal supplier. I use 3/8 AR500 for my targets it stops and shows no damage from nearly every pistol round and also .223 5.56, .308, 7.62 x 39. The plate usually only shows damage if people are shooting the plate very close with those rifle calibers. Normally if the bullet is traveling less than 3000 fps at impact there will be little to know damage. 5.56 and .223 up close will slightly dent the surface when shot very close 15 to 20 yards but it stops it with no problem. Armor piercing rounds and larger calibers like 338 lapua and 50 cal can pierce the 3/8 plate but they do make thicker plate. Bullet Proof is dependent on the bullet. Pick what you want to stop and then design from there. 1/4 AR500 plate would work for all your common pistol rounds.

    • @brizzell2101
      @brizzell2101 7 лет назад

      15 feet away, concentrated fire (3 foot spread), three 30 round mags. .Perps using a 223 5.56 or 7.62x39. 8x17x8 foot box. don't even have a clue how to budget for this.

    • @DesertFabworks
      @DesertFabworks  7 лет назад

      AR500 in 3/8 thickness would provide the protection you needed. Standard sheet is 4x8 feet check local steel suppliers for price.

  • @garetitz
    @garetitz 8 лет назад +2

    i don't think your measurement is that accurate going through water, what emissivity exponent is the device set to? those temperatures are way too low to do anything to the steel's microstructure. if you do have some heat effected zones it is probably so close to the edge it doesn't matter for overall target strength. generally to get brittle steel you must heat it up to transition then quench it quickly. not sure if that process happens here. other than that, heat it up and letting it cool slowly results in more of an annealing, opposite from brittleness.

    • @DesertFabworks
      @DesertFabworks  8 лет назад +1

      I agree it was not the most scientific of experiments but it gives a lot of people the general idea of what it taking place and what measures we take to minimize the heat affected zones on the plate.

  • @aaronanthonymoat
    @aaronanthonymoat 3 года назад

    I want it all in my man Cave. I'd never come out. Lol

  • @Bigwingrider1800
    @Bigwingrider1800 8 лет назад +1

    The edges are different then water. But plasma is faster and the shit i think

  • @actorzone856
    @actorzone856 5 лет назад

    can anyone demonstrate why the worry about the so called weakness at the edge of steel that is cut due to heat? when an item is fully fabricated and on the machine steel will break at the weakest point, if the job is engineered properly heating the metal at the edges is of not worth the worry over nothing.

  • @blowmeracing
    @blowmeracing 7 лет назад +1

    I also built my table with candcnc...and also am using a H65 cutter...where did you get the cone on your torch to limit the water spray? something you made or found as a dual purpose?

    • @DesertFabworks
      @DesertFabworks  7 лет назад +3

      The splash guard is actually a rubber drain stopper from Ace Hardware. I have put a link at the end of this comment. I just cut out the center with a razor blade so it is snug on the torch. I works to keep the splash off the components above and it also works as a soft bumper for pieces that flip up. www.acehardware.com/product/index.jsp?productId=1273002

    • @blowmeracing
      @blowmeracing 7 лет назад +1

      I wondered that..kept thinking, what around the house looks like that because it seemed familiar..funny..good idea. I designed a laser center pointer for the machine torch that I had wanted to integrate a deflector.. I'll look into it..thanks

  • @kenrobbins1927
    @kenrobbins1927 5 лет назад

    I've done this many times....... We cut out 1" AR plate for bench rest silhouettes on a vented system (no water at all). Over time; these things get shot thousands of times and you can tell no difference between the center of the silhouette and the heat affected zone, from projectile impact. The myth is just that; a myth .................

  • @bobburnitt5389
    @bobburnitt5389 6 лет назад

    Good video, BB

  • @focalratio456
    @focalratio456 9 лет назад

    I want plates cut during winter months!!! ;) haha

    • @DesertFabworks
      @DesertFabworks  9 лет назад

      +casey dierkhising ??

    • @focalratio456
      @focalratio456 9 лет назад

      +Desert Fabworks LLC Welding - Plasma Cutting the temp difference between a plate of steel laying out in the sun versus the temp of the steel being cut by a plasma torch was minimal. I'm just being silly. I work at Rotochopper Inc. and we use AR500 on certain parts of our machines and we use CNC plasmas also.

    • @DesertFabworks
      @DesertFabworks  9 лет назад

      Gotch you probably do no not have days where its 125 in the shade in MN.

    • @focalratio456
      @focalratio456 9 лет назад +1

      +Desert Fabworks LLC Welding - Plasma Cutting
      Never! but you'd be interested in seeing why we use AR500 steel, youtube search Rotochopper and see what we do, from one metal fabber to another, I think you'd find it interesting. we have a bunch of industry firsts

  • @hamidbahrami6620
    @hamidbahrami6620 5 лет назад

    supposed to be Plasma cut Vs the Laser. All i hear is about Plasma Cut.

  • @hanssolo4ever
    @hanssolo4ever 8 лет назад +1

    How much is a system like that?

    • @DesertFabworks
      @DesertFabworks  8 лет назад +3

      Tough to put an exact price on it. I have done a lot of upgrades and changes over the years but rough guess 15 to 20 thousand to get a turn key system less if your willing to do a lot of the construction and set up yourself.

  • @tensixtythreevideo
    @tensixtythreevideo 6 лет назад

    Nice work

  • @blowmeracing
    @blowmeracing 7 лет назад +1

    I too cut targets as well many other things with my home built plasma table and it makes me laugh how these laser guys are putting us plasma guys down....it take way more heat to change any molecular stability than plasma cutting in water...but they paid so much for there lasers that they need to bash other methods so they can steel our business to make there laser payment for the next 50 years...lol

  • @richardchubey4826
    @richardchubey4826 7 лет назад +5

    I have ran all three machines for decades.
    I dont know what you are trying to prove here?
    I have cut AR plate on all three machines. About 400 holes in each plate 60 by 50 inches. On the laser the plate warped by about 1 and a half feet. On the plasma cutter about a foot. On the waterjet machine no warpage. Your high tech thermo tech gun making two cuts on steel! Wow!
    Make 400 hundred cuts. Then give me some readings!
    I can send you a client you can cut product for. You could probably cut twice as fast as me. You promise no warpage? We did too, and we got that with waterjet machines.
    Our laser cutter and plasma cutter made a mess out of this.
    You are welcome to try. Lets make a bet! If you can cut the product at decent speed for the machines in question and you get no warpage I pay you in full for your services. If you fail though, you pay me the cost of material times two, and the cost of cut time times 4.
    I need a plate cut with no warpage. 1/4 inch is a fail. 1/8 of an inch is a fail. Shop tolerance is 1/16. If you can cut 400 holes in a 3/8 plate of AR with no warpage at all I want to know about the machine you are running.
    25 years experience tells me you are full of shit!
    I run a plasma table, laser table, and waterjet table!
    Prove me wrong and I want to buy the machine you have.

    • @biaggiwins
      @biaggiwins 6 лет назад +1

      Richard Chubey i think someone needs a nap...

  • @dacountryone
    @dacountryone 6 лет назад +1

    He says plasma is hotter than the sun...does ANYONE on the planet know exactly how hot the sun is...can anyone answer that question for me?

  • @terralilymusic
    @terralilymusic 8 лет назад

    A grain of sand at the temperature of the sun will kill anything within 100 miles of it

    • @DesertFabworks
      @DesertFabworks  8 лет назад +3

      +The Amazing Cookies Temperature of the sun = 5,778 Kelvin, Plasma Arc 28,003 Kelvin I stand next to the plasma torch and I nor anyone within 100 miles have died as a result so I'm having a hard time believing you.

    • @terralilymusic
      @terralilymusic 8 лет назад

      +Desert Fabworks LLC Welding - Plasma Cutting I think the reason that you all did not burn is because plasma is an energy. It transmits the heat through it and keeps it until it contacts something to expose this heat, so yeah.

    • @lorenzolorenzo6484
      @lorenzolorenzo6484 8 лет назад +1

      The sun's atmosphere is about 500,000 kelvins, 900,000 degrees Fahrenheit which is way hotter than any Plasma machine lol.
      The sun's surface temperature, which is its "coolest" layer is 5,778 kelvin (10,000 F)
      The sun's core is 27,000,000 F, which is15,000,000 kelvins!

    • @douglasalan7786
      @douglasalan7786 8 лет назад

      Who measured it and how did they get there ? I mean. David Icky said it's a computer generated image. AHHHHHHHHH Call Alex Jonez !

  • @TMS5100
    @TMS5100 7 лет назад

    now shoot those cut edges. water cut doesn't nick. laser cut does. I bet these do too.

    • @DesertFabworks
      @DesertFabworks  7 лет назад

      We have found that every cut process will "nick" on the cut edges water, plasma, laser. Water jet is most expensive process followed by laser then plasma. In all the testing we found that the HAZ really did not matter and what really matters is price for the customer. So plasma wins for overall cost per piece.

    • @veselipastir
      @veselipastir 6 лет назад +1

      it is stupid to compare plasma and laser for the HAZ , temperatures are high on both on the cut zone (and around it (few mm- as heat transfers trough metal materials travels faster) but that heat transfer is exponentially lost that is why you don't melt 1cm in diameter but 1mm.
      laser is far more precise but for thick (more then 0,5mm) metals it doesn't do shit of difference, as it needs power to melt trough it and the same power is used as with plasma and the same transfer of heat is done just a tiny bit faster. HAZ you may get on the edges (in a 1-2 mm at worst) and that is true for both of the methods. rest of the plate is more then safe ... so all in all , that HAZ thing about cutting is bullshit.
      If any of you went to proper technical school you would learn about "materials" and their properties ,and the curves for changing crystal structure of metals ...
      en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steel - learn about heat treatment section

  • @TheAntipedy
    @TheAntipedy 6 лет назад +1

    Accent and speaking to fast made it hard to understand.

    • @holle1279
      @holle1279 4 года назад

      I'm from Europe, and I understand him perfectly fine.

  • @mamoonnaseer1886
    @mamoonnaseer1886 5 лет назад

    Talking talking and more talking